Aluminium tolerance is achieved by exudation of citric acid from roots of soybean (Glycine max)

Fourteen soybean ( Glycine max [L.] Merr.) cultivars were analysed and found to differ considerably in aluminium (Al) resistance. The cultivars Suzunari (Al-resistant) and Shishio (Al-sensitive) were selected for further analysis of physiological mechanisms of Al-resistance. The relative root growth of Shishio was 48% compared to 76% for Suzunari in response to 15 μ M Al (24 h). Aluminium accumulation and Al-induced callose formation in root apices were 50 and 25% of that in Suzunari, respectively. Al inhibited both Suzunari and Shishio during the first 6 h of exposure. However, the root growth inhibition was further increased in Shishio but not in Suzunari, suggesting an Al-induced Al-resistant mechanism operating in Suzunari. Organic acid analysis in root exudates of both cultivars revealed that they specifically exuded citrate in response to Al. However, the citrate exudation rate was significantly higher in Suzunari during the 6 h/24 h Al treatment, which was 52/330 compared to Shishio's 26/118 (nmol [g root fresh weight]⁻¹ [6 h]⁻¹), respectively. This Al-induced citric acid exudation was found to be specific for Al, as several other metals failed to induce citrate exudation in both cultivars. Fourteen days of P deficiency did not elicit citrate excretion in both cultivars, while application of Al to P-deficient plants rapidly induced citrate exudation in both cultivars, confirming the specificity of the response of these soybean cultivars to Al. To our knowledge, this is the first report demonstrating an Al-exclusion mechanism in soybean cultivars, which is conferred by enhanced and specific Al-induced exudation of citrate.     

Aluminum resistance in maize cannot be solely explained by root organic acid exudation. A comparative physiological study

Root apical aluminum (Al) exclusion via Al-activated root citrate exudation is widely accepted as the main Al-resistance mechanism operating in maize (Zea mays) roots. Nonetheless, the correlation between Al resistance and this Al-exclusion mechanism has not been tested beyond a very small number of Al-resistant and Al-sensitive maize lines. In this study, we conducted a comparative study of the physiology of Al resistance using six different maize genotypes that capture the range of maize Al resistance and differ significantly in their genetic background (three Brazilian and three North American genotypes). In these maize lines, we were able to establish a clear correlation between root tip Al exclusion (based on root Al content) and Al resistance. Both Al-resistant genotypes and three of the four Al-sensitive lines exhibited a significant Al-activated citrate exudation, with no evidence for Al activation of root malate or phosphate release. There was a lack of correlation between differential Al resistance and root citrate exudation for the six maize genotypes; in fact, one of the Al-sensitive lines, Mo17, had the largest Al-activated citrate exudation of all of the maize lines. Our results indicate that although root organic acid release may play a role in maize Al resistance, it is clearly not the only or the main resistance mechanism operating in these maize roots. A number of other potential Al-resistance mechanisms were investigated, including release of other Al-chelating ligands, Al-induced alkalinization of rhizosphere pH, changes in internal levels of Al-chelating compounds in the root, and Al translocation to the shoot. However, we were unsuccessful in identifying additional Al-resistance mechanisms in maize. It is likely that a purely physiological approach may not be sufficient to identify these novel Al-resistance mechanisms in maize and this will require an interdisciplinary approach integrating genetic, molecular, and physiological investigations.     

Organic acid exudation induced by phosphorus deficiency and/or aluminium toxicity in two contrasting soybean genotypes

Experiments in nutrient solution were conducted to investigate the exudation of organic acids (OAs) induced by phosphorus deficiency (–P) and/or aluminium toxicity (+Al) in two contrasting soybean genotypes as related to internal OA concentration and related enzyme activities. Baxi 10 (BX10), a known P‐efficient soybean (Glycine max[L] Merr.) genotype, was shown to be more resistant to +Al than a P‐inefficient genotype Bendi 2 (BD2), indicating the potential of selecting soybean cultivars with dual resistance to –P and +Al. The two contrasting genotypes were further characterized for root exudation and formation of oxalate, malate and citrate and their related enzyme activities in response to –P, +Al or both combined. –P significantly induced malate and oxalate exudation from both soybean genotypes, although the P‐efficient BX10 tended to excrete much more oxalate than the P‐inefficient BD2. The +Al treatment triggered citrate efflux from both genotypes, with BX10 having a much greater efflux rate than BD2. Interestingly, –P did not appear to induce citrate exudation, whereas +Al had no obvious effect on malate or oxalate exudation from the two genotypes. The exudation of OAs was generally diminished under the coupled stress of –P and +Al in comparison with either single stress, implying a possible antagonistic effect of the two stresses on OA exudation. Root malate content was negatively correlated with its exudation in BX10 but positively in BD2. A similar tendency was observed for oxalate content and exudation only with less magnitude. Determination of six related enzymes, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC), phosphoenolpyruvate phosphatase (PEPP), malate enzyme (ME), isocitrate dehydrogenase (ICDH), malate dehydrogenase (MDH), and pyruvate kinase (PK), in the root tips showed that their activities were not significantly altered during the early stage of treatments (2 and 4 days) whereas at 14 days after stress imposition, the activities of PEPC, PEPP, ME and ICDH were generally enhanced for both genotypes. However, the activity of these enzymes did not appear to be correlated with OA exudation or formation. This study clearly demonstrates that OA exudation is differentially induced by –P and +Al in soybean plants, with specific induction of oxalate and malate by –P and citrate by +Al. The lack of a close relationship between OA exudation and internal concentration or enzyme activities may suggest that the regulation of OA formation and exudation by –P and/or +Al could be imposed at different stages.     

Secretion of citrate from roots in response to aluminum and low phosphorus stresses in Stylosanthes

Excess aluminum (Al) ions and phosphorus (P) deficiency are the key factors that limit plant growth in acid soils. Secretion of organic acids (OA) from roots has been proposed as an Al-resistance mechanism. Nonetheless, the correlation between Al resistance and this mechanism has not been tested beyond a very small number of Al-resistant and Al-sensitive genotypes. To elucidate the mechanisms responsible for plant adaptability to acid soils, we studied the secretion of OA from roots of Stylosanthes in response to high-Al and low-P stresses using six different genotypes. Relative root inhibition by 50?µM Al ranged from 25–71% and differed significantly among six Stylosanthes genotypes. Al treatment induced the secretion of citrate from the roots of Stylosanthes seedling in a dose- and time-dependent manner. Moreover, the secretion rate was significantly higher in the Al-resistant genotype. On the other hand, inhibition of Al-induced citrate secretion by phenylisothiocyanate or 9-anthracenecarboxylic acid resulted in an increase in Al content in Stylosanthes root apices. P deficiency also induced citrate secretion from Stylosanthes seedling roots. Furthermore, citrate secretion was much more robust with exposure to both excess-Al and P-deficiency stresses than under either stress alone. Unlike Al-induced citrate secretion, which was rapid, low-P-induced secretion was a slow process, with significant increases in secretion only becoming evident after 6 d of treatment with free phosphate. The lag between treatment with Al and citrate secretion was approximately 4 h. These results suggest that the secretion of citrate is a mechanism for resistance to both excess-Al and low-P stresses in Stylosanthes.     

The role of phosphorus in aluminium-induced citrate and malate exudation from rape (Brassica napus)

Exudation of organic anions is believed to be a common tolerance mechanism for both aluminium toxicity and phosphorus deficiency. Nevertheless, which of these stresses that actually elicit the exudation of organic anions from rape ( Brassica napus L) remains unknown, and the combined effects of Al toxicity and P deficiency on rape have not been reported before. Therefore, in the current study, Brassica napus var. Natane nourin plants grown with or without 0.25 m M P were exposed to 0 or 50 µ M AlCl₃ and several parameters related to the exudation of organic anions from the roots were investigated. Eight days of P deficiency resulted in a significant growth reduction, but P deficiency alone did not induce exudation of organic anions. In contrast, Al strongly induced organic acid exudation, while simultaneously inhibiting root growth. Increased in-vitro activity of citrate synthase (CS, EC 4.1.3.7), malate dehydrogenase (MDH, EC 1.1.1.37) and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC, EC 4.1.1.31), together with reduced root respiration, indicated that the Al-induced accumulation and subsequent exudation of citrate and malate were associated with both increased biosynthesis and reduced metabolism of citric and malic acid. Phosphorus-sufficient plants showed more pronounced aluminium-induced accumulation and exudation of organic anions than P-deficient plants. A divided root chamber experiment showed the necessity of direct contact between Al and roots to elicit exudation of organic anions. Prolonged exposure (10 days) to Al resulted in a decrease in the net exudation of citrate and malate, and the rate of decrease was much more rapid in P-deficient plants than in P-sufficient plants. It is concluded that P nutrition affects the level of Al-induced synthesis and exudation of organic anions. However, the mechanism needs further investigation.     

Aluminum resistance in common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) involves induction and maintenance of citrate exudation from root apices

Two common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) genotypes differing in aluminum (Al) resistance, Quimbaya (Al‐resistant) and VAX‐1 (Al‐sensitive) were grown in hydroponics for up to 25 h with or without Al, and several parameters related to the exudation of organic acids anions from the root apex were investigated. Al treatment enhanced the exudation of citrate from the root tips of both genotypes. However, its dynamic offers the most consistent relationship between Al‐induced inhibition of root elongation and Al accumulation in and exclusion from the root apices. Initially, in both genotypes the short‐term (4 h) Al‐injury period was characterized by the absence of citrate efflux independent of the citrate content of the root apices, and reduction of cytosolic turnover of citrate conferred by a reduced Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate–isocitrate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.42) activity. Transient recovery from initial Al stress (4–12 h) was found to be dependent mainly on the capacity to utilize internal citrate pools (Al‐resistant genotype Quimbaya) or enhanced citrate synthesis [increased activities of NAD‐malate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.37) and ATP‐phosphofructokinase (EC 2.7.1.11) in Al‐sensitive VAX‐1]. Sustained recovery from Al stress through citrate exudation in genotype Quimbaya after 24 h Al treatment relied on restoring the internal citrate pool and the constitutive high activity of citrate synthase (CS) (EC 4.1.3.7) fuelled by high phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (EC 4.1.1.31) activity. In the Al‐sensitive genotype VAX‐1 the citrate exudation and thus Al exclusion and root elongation could not be maintained coinciding with an exhaustion of the internal citrate pool and decreased CS activity.     

Differential Al resistance and citrate secretion in barley (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Hordeum vulgare</Emphasis> L.)

While barley ( Hordeum vulgare L.) is the most sensitive species to Al toxicity among small-grain crops, variation in Al resistance between cultivars does exist. We examined the mechanism responsible for differential Al resistance in 21 barley varieties. Citrate was secreted from the roots in response to Al stress. A positive correlation between citrate secretion and Al resistance [(root elongation with Al)/(root elongation without Al)] and a negative correlation between citrate secretion and Al content of root apices, were obtained, suggesting that citrate secretion from the root apices plays an important role in excluding Al and thereby detoxifying Al. The Al-induced secretion of citrate was characterized using an Al-resistant variety (Sigurdkorn) and an Al-sensitive variety (Kearney). In Sigurdkorn, Al-induced secretion of citrate occurred within 20 min, and the secretion did not increase with increasing external Al concentration. The Al-induced citrate secretion ceased at low temperature (6 degrees C) and was inhibited by anion-channel inhibitors. Internal citrate content of root apices was increased by Al exposure in Sigurdkorn, but was not affected in Kearney. The activity of citrate synthase was unaffected by Al in both Al-resistant and Al-sensitive varieties. The secretion rate of organic acid anions from barley was the lowest among wheat, rye and triticale.     

Phosphorus and aluminum interactions in soybean in relation to aluminum tolerance. Exudation of specific organic acids from different regions of the intact root system

Aluminum (Al) toxicity and phosphorus (P) deficiency often coexist in acid soils that severely limit crop growth and production, including soybean (Glycine max). Understanding the physiological mechanisms relating to plant Al and P interactions should help facilitate the development of more Al-tolerant and/or P-efficient crops. In this study, both homogeneous and heterogeneous nutrient solution experiments were conducted to study the effects of Al and P interactions on soybean root growth and root organic acid exudation. In the homogenous solution experiments with a uniform Al and P distribution in the bulk solution, P addition significantly increased Al tolerance in four soybean genotypes differing in P efficiency. The two P-efficient genotypes appeared to be more Al tolerant than the two P-inefficient genotypes under these high-P conditions. Analysis of root exudates indicated Al toxicity induced citrate exudation, P deficiency triggered oxalate exudation, and malate release was induced by both treatments. To more closely mimic low-P acid soils where P deficiency and Al toxicity are often much greater in the lower soil horizons, a divided root chamber/nutrient solution approach was employed to impose elevated P conditions in the simulated upper soil horizon, and Al toxicity/P deficiency in the lower horizon. Under these conditions, we found that the two P-efficient genotypes were more Al tolerant during the early stages of the experiment than the P-inefficient lines. Although the same three organic acids were exuded by roots in the divided chamber experiments, their exudation patterns were different from those in the homogeneous solution system. The two P-efficient genotypes secreted more malate from the taproot tip, suggesting that improved P nutrition may enhance exudation of organic acids in the root regions dealing with the greatest Al toxicity, thus enhancing Al tolerance. These findings demonstrate that P efficiency may play a role in Al tolerance in soybean. Phosphorus-efficient genotypes may be able to enhance Al tolerance not only through direct Al-P interactions but also through indirect interactions associated with stimulated exudation of different Al-chelating organic acids in specific roots and root regions.     

Dual effects of transgenic Brassica napus overexpressing CS gene on tolerances to aluminum toxicity and phosphorus deficiency

Background and aims

Low phosphorus (P) bioavailability and aluminum (Al) toxicity are two major constraints to plant growth in acid soil. To improve the tolerance of Brassica napus to Al toxicity and P deficiency, we generated transgenic canola (Brassica napus cv Westar) lines overexpressing a Pseudomonas aeruginosa citrate synthase (CS) gene and then investigated the effects of CS gene overexpressing in canola on enhancing tolerance to the two constraints.

Methods

The vector construction and plant transformation, molecular identification, estimation of extracellular and cellular citrate and malate concentrations, enzyme activity and gene expression analyse and Al tolerance and P acquisition assays were conducted using both hydroponics and soil culturing in the study.

Results

Both the root citrate and malate concentrations and their exudations in the two transgenic lines significantly increased compared with wild type (WT) following exposure to Al. These increases may be attributed to higher activities of the CS, malate dehydrogenase (MDH) and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) enzymes in the TCA cycle and the expression of BnALMT and BnMATE in the transgenic plants following Al exposure. The primary root elongation and prolonged Al treatment (10 days) experiments revealed that the transgenic lines displayed enhanced levels of Al tolerance. In addition, they showed enhanced citrate and malate exudation when grown in P-deficient conditions. Moreover, the enzyme activities of the transgenic lines were significantly higher compared with WT in response to P-deficient stress. The soil culture experiment showed that the transgenic lines possessed improved P uptake from the soil and accumulated more P in their shoots and seeds when FePO₄ was used as the sole P source.

Conclusions

These results indicate that the overexpression of the CS gene in B. napus not only leads to increased citrate synthesis and exudation but also changes malate metabolism, which confers improved tolerances to Al toxicity and P deficiency in the transgenic plants. These findings provide further insight into the dual effects of CS gene overexpression on Al toxicity and P deficiency in plants.     

Aluminum Interactions with Voltage-Dependent Calcium Transport in Plasma Membrane Vesicles Isolated from Roots of Aluminum-Sensitive and -Resistant Wheat Cultivars

The role of Al interactions with root-cell plasma membrane (PM) Ca2+ channels in Al toxicity and resistance was studied. The experimental approach involved the imposition of a transmembrane electrical potential (via K+ diffusion) in right-side-out PM vesicles derived from roots of two wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cultivars (Al-sensitive Scout 66 and Al-resistant Atlas 66). We previously used this technique to characterize a voltage-dependent Ca2+ channel in the wheat root PM (J.W. Huang, D.L. Grunes, L.V. Kochian [1994] Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91: 3473-3477). We found that Al3+ effectively blocked this PM Ca2+ channel; however, Al3+ blocked this Ca2+ channel equally well in both the Al-sensitive and -resistant cultivars. It was found that the differential genotypic sensitivity of this Ca2+ transport system to Al in intact roots versus isolated PM vesicles was due to Al-induced malate exudation localized to the root apex in Al-resistant Atlas but not in Al-sensitive Scout. Because malate can effectively chelate Al3+ in the rhizosphere and exclude it from the root apex, the differential sensitivity of Ca2+ influx to Al in intact roots of Al-resistant versus Al-sensitive wheat cultivars is probably due to the maintenance of lower Al3+ activities in the root apical rhizosphere of the resistant cultivar.     

Evaluating the role of root citrate exudation as a mechanism of aluminium resistance in maize genotypes

Organic anion exudation by roots as a mechanism of aluminium (Al) resistance has been intensively studied lately. In the present study, we evaluated qualitative and quantitative aspects of root exudation of organic anions in maize genotypes of distinct sensitivity to Al in response to Al exposure. Maize seedlings were grown axenically in nutrient solution and root exudates were collected along the whole seminal root axis for a short period (4 h) using a divided-root-chamber technique. In root exudates collected from 10-mm long root apices, citrate accounted for 67% of the total organic anions found, followed by malate (29%), trans-aconitate (3%), fumarate (<1%), and cis-aconitate (1%). Rates of citrate exudation from root apices of two genotypes with differential resistance to Al were consistently higher in the Al resistant one, differing by a factor of 1.7 – 3.0 across a range of external Al concentrations. Furthermore, relative Al resistance of eight maize genotypes correlated significantly well with their citrate exudation rate measured at 40 M Al. Higher exudation rates were accompanied by a less inhibited root elongation. The exudation of citrate along the longitudinal axis of fully developed seminal roots showed a particular pattern: citrate was exuded mainly in the regions of root apices, either belonging to the main root or to the lateral roots in the most basal part of the main root. The involvement of citrate in a mechanism of Al resistance is evaluated in terms of protection of the root from the effects of excess Al on root elongation and on nutrient uptake along a root axis showing distinct sites of citrate exudation.     

Multiple Aluminum-Resistance Mechanisms in Wheat (Roles of Root Apical Phosphate and Malate Exudation)

Although it is well known that aluminum (Al) resistance in wheat (Triticum aestivum) is multigenic, physiological evidence for multiple mechanisms of Al resistance has not yet been documented. The role of root apical phosphate and malate exudation in Al resistance was investigated in two wheat cultivars (Al-resistant Atlas and Al-sensitive Scout) and two near-isogenic lines (Al-resistant ET3 and Al-sensitive ES3). In Atlas Al resistance is multigenic, whereas in ET3 resistance is conditioned by the single Alt1 locus. Based on root- growth experiments, Atlas was found to be 3-fold more resistant in 20 [mu]M Al than ET3. Root-exudation experiments were conducted under sterile conditions; a large malate efflux localized to the root apex was observed only in Atlas and in ET3 and only in the presence of Al (5 and 20 [mu]M). Furthermore, the more Al-resistant Atlas exhibited a constitutive phosphate release localized to the root apex. As predicted from the formation constants for the Al-malate and Al-phosphate complexes, the addition of either ligand to the root bathing solution alleviated Al inhibition of root growth in Al-sensitive Scout. These results provide physiological evidence that Al resistance in Atlas is conditioned by at least two genes. In addition to the alt locus that controls Al-induced malate release from the root apex, other genetic loci appear to control constitutive phosphate release from the apex. We suggest that both exudation processes act in concert to enhance Al exclusion and Al resistance in Atlas.     

Differential aluminum tolerance in soybean: An evaluation of the role of organic acids

The role of organic acids in aluminum (Al) tolerance has been the object of intensive research. In the present work, we evaluated the roles of organic acid exudation and concentrations at the root tip on Al tolerance of soybean. Exposing soybean seedlings to Al³⁺ activities up to 4.7 μ M in solution led to different degrees of restriction of primary root elongation. Al tolerance among genotypes was associated with citrate accumulation and excretion into the external media. Citrate and malate efflux increased in all genotypes during the first 6 h of Al exposure, but only citrate efflux in Al-tolerant genotypes was sustained for an extended period. Tolerance to Al was correlated with the concentration of citrate in root tips of 8 genotypes with a range of Al sensitivities (r²=0.75). The fluorescent stain lumogallion indicated that more Al accumulated in root tips of the Al-sensitive genotype Young than the Al-tolerant genotype PI 416937, suggesting that the sustained release of citrate from roots of the tolerant genotype was involved in Al exclusion. The initial stimulation of citrate and malate excretion and accumulation in the tip of all genotypes suggested the involvement of additional tolerance mechanisms. The experiments included an examination of Al effects on lateral root elongation. Extension of lateral roots was more sensitive to Al than that of tap roots, and lateral root tips accumulated more Al and had lower levels of citrate.     

Probing the role of calmodulin in Al toxicity in maize

The role of calmodulin on Al toxicity was studied in two maize (Zea mays L.) inbred lines, Cat 100-6 (Al-tolerant) and S 1587-17 (Al-sensitive). Increasing levels of Al induced the release of malate at similar rate by roots of both genotypes, while the exudation of citrate, a stronger Al-binding compound, was 3.5 times higher in Cat 100-6 seedlings exposed to 16.2x10(-6) Al(3+) activity. The calmodulin inhibitor trifluoperazine significantly reduced the root growth in both genotypes, mimicking the main effect of Al. However, when Cat 100-6 and S 1587-17 seedlings were challenged with Al in conjunction with trifluoperazine, no further reduction in root growth or any other effect of Al toxicity was observed. The rate of Al-induced citrate exudation by both genotypes was not affected by treatment with trifluoperazine or calmidazolium, another calmodulin inhibitor. The Al(3+) interaction with cytoplasmic CaM was estimated using models for the binding of Al(3+) and Mg(2+) with CaM and physiological concentrations of citrate, CaM, InsP(3), ATP, ADP, Al(3+) and Mg(2+). In this simulation, Al(3+) associated with citrate and InsP(3), but not with CaM. We conclude that calmodulin is not relevant to the physiological processes leading to the Al tolerance in maize, nor is it a primary target for Al toxicity.     

A comparative study on the aluminium- and copper-induced organic acid exudation from wheat roots

It is well established that aluminium (Al) and some heavy metals can elicit organic acid exudation from a range of species. In the present research we found that copper (Cu) can also induce organic acid exudation from the roots of wheat, rye, triticale, maize and soybean. Using intact wheat plants, we made a comparative study of Al- and Cu- induced organic acid exudation. In 5-day-old wheat seedlings, severe Cu stress (40 µ M CuCl₂) mainly induced the exudation of malate and citrate, and Al-tolerant genotypes could release significantly greater amounts of malate than Al-sensitive genotypes. The time course of the exudation of malate and citrate from the roots of 5-day-old seedlings of wheat (cv. Atlas) in 200 µ M AlCl₃ was similar to that in 40 µ M CuCl₂. In older wheat plants (15-day-old), moderate Cu stress (12 µ M CuCl₂) induced the exudation of large amounts of citrate and addition of Al or La sharply reduced Cu-induced citrate exudation, while Cu or La did not affect Al-induced malate efflux. When half of the root system of Atlas wheat was immersed in Al- or Cu-containing solution and the remaining half in Al- or Cu-free solution, organic acids were only exuded into the solution containing Al or Cu. This suggests that no long distance signal transport is involved in organic acid exudation induced by Al or Cu, and that direct contact of Al or Cu with plant roots is a prerequisite for the induction of organic acid exudation. The anion-channel inhibitor niflumic acid (NIF) significantly stimulated the exudation of both citrate and malate from 5-day-old wheat seedlings under severe Al or Cu stress. Our results suggest that Cu-induced organic acid efflux may be a common response, which may play a role in alleviating Cu toxicity in plants.     

A promoter-swap strategy between the AtALMT and AtMATE genes increased Arabidopsis aluminum resistance and improved carbon-use efficiency for aluminum resistance

The primary mechanism of Arabidopsis aluminum (Al) resistance is based on root Al exclusion, resulting from Al-activated root exudation of the Al(3+) -chelating organic acids, malate and citrate. Root malate exudation is the major contributor to Arabidopsis Al resistance, and is conferred by expression of AtALMT1, which encodes the root malate transporter. Root citrate exudation plays a smaller but still significant role in Arabidopsis Al resistance, and is conferred by expression of AtMATE, which encodes the root citrate transporter. In this study, we demonstrate that levels of Al-activated root organic acid exudation are closely correlated with expression of the organic acid transporter genes AtALMT1 and AtMATE. We also found that the AtALMT1 promoter confers a significantly higher level of gene expression than the AtMATE promoter. Analysis of AtALMT1 and AtMATE tissue- and cell-specific expression based on stable expression of promoter-reporter gene constructs showed that the two genes are expressed in complementary root regions: AtALMT1 is expressed in the root apices, while AtMATE is expressed in the mature portions of the roots. As citrate is a much more effective chelator of Al(3+) than malate, we used a promoter-swap strategy to test whether root tip-localized expression of the AtMATE coding region driven by the stronger AtALMT1 promoter (AtALMT1(P)::AtMATE) resulted in increased Arabidopsis Al resistance. Our results indicate that expression of AtALMT1(P)::AtMATE not only significantly increased Al resistance of the transgenic plants, but also enhanced carbon-use efficiency for Al resistance.     

Effects of low pH and aluminum stresses on common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) differing in low-phosphorus and photoperiod responses

Using common beans differing greatly in the response to photoperiod and low-phosphorus (P) stress, we investigated their responses to acidity and aluminum (Al)toxicity and the relationship between Al tolerance and organic acid exudation under Al or low P stress. A genotype Ginshi was found to be sensitive to low pH treatment. When exposed to pH 4.5, serious curvature in the root tips of cv. Ginshi was observed; however, it was completely corrected by the application of 5 or 10 μmol/L AlCl3; increasing calcium (Ca) could ameliorate Al toxicity, but it could not correct root curvature at pH 4.5. Common beans showed significant differences in both root growth and Al tolerance, and the varieties from the Andes were more tolerant to Al toxicity than those from the Mesoamerican origin. In the presence of 50 μmol/L AlCl3,all the common bean genotypes exuded citrate, and a significant difference in the amounts of citrate was observed among genotypes. The genotypes originated in the Mesoamerica tended to release more citrate than other origins in the presence of Al. The P-inefficient genotype DOR364 exuded more citrate than the P-efficient genotype G19833 in the presence of 50 μmol/L AlCl3, whereas no organic acids were detected in root exudates under low-P stress. A reduction of citrate exudation in the DOR364, but a slight increase of citrate exudation in the G19833, was observed under Al stress after they were exposed to 6-d P starvation. These results suggest that different low-P or Al tolerance in common beans might not be associated with organic acid exudation.     

Organic acid exudation as an aluminum-tolerance mechanism in maize (Zea mays L.)

In this study, the role of root organic acid synthesis and exudation in the mechanism of aluminum tolerance was examined in Al-tolerant (South American 3) and Al-sensitive (Tuxpeño and South American 5) maize genotypes. In a growth solution containing 6 M Al³⁺, Tuxpeño and South American 5 were found to be two- and threefold more sensitive to Al than South American 3. Root organic acid content and organic acid exudation from the entire root system into the bulk solution were investigated via high-performance liquid chromatographic analysis while exudates collected separately from the root apex or a mature root region (using a dividedroot-chamber technique) were analyzed with a more-sensitive ion chromatography system. In both the Al-tolerant and Al-sensitive lines, Al treatment significantly increased the total root content of organic acids, which was likely the result of Al stress and not the cause of the observed differential Al tolerance. In the absence of Al, small amounts of citrate were exuded into the solution bathing the roots. Aluminum exposure triggered a stimulation of citrate release in the Al-tolerant but not in the Al-sensitive genotypes; this response was localized to the root apex of the Al-tolerant genotype. Additionally, Al exposure triggered the release of phosphate from the root apex of the Al-tolerant genotype. The same solution Al³⁺ activity that elicited the maximum difference in Al sensitivity between Al-tolerant and Al-sensitive genotypes also triggered maximal citrate release from the root apex of the Al-tolerant line. The significance of citrate as a potential detoxifier for aluminum is discussed. It is concluded that organic acid release by the root apex could be an important aspect of Al tolerance in maize.Abbreviations SA3 South American 3, an Al-tolerant maize cultivar - SA5 South American 5, an Al-sensitive maize cultivar The authors would like to express their appreciation to Drs. John Thompson, Ross Welch and Mr. Stephen Schaefer for their training and guidance in the use of the chromatography systems. This work was supported by a Swiss National Science Foundation Fellowship to Didier Pellet, and U.S. Department of Agriculture/National Research Initiative Competitive Grant 93-37100-8874 to Leon Kochian. We would also like to thank Drs. S. Pandey and E. Ceballos from the CIMMYT Regional office at CIAT Cali, Colombia for providing seed for the maize varieties and inbred line.     

Low-P tolerance by maize (Zea mays L.) genotypes: Significance of root growth,and organic acids and acid phosphatase root exudation

We investigated some mechanisms, which allow maize genotypes to adapt to soils which are low in available P. Dry matter production, root/shoot-ratio, root length and root exudation of organic acids and acid phosphatase were investigated in four maize genotypes grown under P-deficient and P-sufficient conditions in sterile hydroponic culture. A low-P tolerant, an acid-tolerant and a low-P susceptible genotype of maize were compared with a Swiss commercial cultivar. The study found increased root development and increased exudation of acid phosphatase under P-deficient conditions in all maize genotypes, except for the Swiss cultivar. Effects on root formation and acid phosphatase were greater for the low-P tolerant than for the low-P susceptible, and the acid soil tolerant genotypes. Organic acid contents in root tissues were increased under P deficiency and related to increased PEPC activity. However, the increase in contents was associated with an increase in exudation for the low-P tolerant genotype only. The low-P susceptible genotype was characterized by high organic acid content in roots and low organic acid exudation. The organic acids content in the phloem exudates of shoots was related to root exudation under different P supply, to the difference between lines in organic acids root content, but not to the low-P tolerance or susceptibility of maize genotypes.