Nitric oxide exacerbates Al-induced inhibition of root elongation in rice bean by affecting cell wall and plasma membrane properties

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is one of the most widespread problems for crop production on acid soils, and nitric oxide (NO) is a key signaling molecule involved in the mediation of various biotic and abiotic stresses in plants. Here we found that exogenous application of the NO donor sodium nitroprusside (SNP) exacerbated the inhibition of Al-induced root growth in rice bean [Vigna umbellata (Thunb.) Ohwi & Ohashi ‘Jiangnan’, Fabaceae]. This was accompanied by an increased accumulation of Al in the root apex. However, Al treatments had no effect on endogenous NO concentrations in root apices. These results indicate that a change in NO concentration is not the cause of Al-induced root growth inhibition and the adverse effect of SNP on Al-induced root growth inhibition should result from increased Al accumulation. Al could significantly induce citrate efflux but SNP had no effects on citrate efflux either in the absence or presence of Al. On the other hand, SNP pretreatment significantly increased Al-induced malondialdehyde accumulation and Evans Blue staining, indicating an intensification of the disruption of plasma membrane integrity. Furthermore, SNP pretreatment also caused greater induction of pectin methylesterase activity by Al, which could be the cause of the increased Al accumulation. Taken together, it is concluded that NO exacerbates Al-induced root growth inhibition by affecting cell wall and plasma membrane properties.     

The amelioration of aluminium toxicity by silicon in higher plants: Solution chemistry or an in planta mechanism?

Aluminium (Al) toxicity is a very important factor limiting the growth of plants on acidic soils. Recently, a number of workers have shown that, under certain conditions, silicon (Si) can ameliorate the toxic effects of A1 in hydroponic culture. The mechanism of the amelioration is unclear, but three suggestions have been put forward: Si‐induced increase in solution pH during the preparation of hydroponic solutions; reduced availability of Al due to the formation of hydroxyaluminosilicate (HAS) species in those solutions during plant growth; or in planta detoxification. It is now known that it is possible to make up Al and Si solutions in an order in which pH is lowered prior to Al addition; in these cases amelioration has still been observed. Amelioration has also been noted in experiments where HAS formation is minimal. These observations would suggest that, at least under some circumstances, there is an in planta component to the amelioration phenomenon. Several microanalytical investigations have noted codeposition of Al and Si in root cell walls. We propose a model in which root cell walls are the main internal sites of aluminosilicate (AS) and/or HAS formation and of Al detoxification. Factors promoting AS/HAS formation in this compartment include: high apoplastic pH; the presence of organic substances (e.g. malate); and the presence of suitable local concentrations of reactive forms of Al and Si, on or within the surfaces of the wall matrix. All these are likely to be important in the amelioration of Al toxicity.     

Aluminum targets elongating cells by reducing cell wall extensibility in wheat roots

Phytotoxicity of aluminum is characterized by a rapid inhibition of root elongation at micromolar concentrations, however, the mechanisms primarily responsible for this response are not well understood. We investigated the effect of Al on the viscosity and elasticity parameters of root cell wall by a creep-extension analysis in two cultivars of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) differing in Al resistance. The root elongation and both viscous and elastic extensibility of cell wall of the root apices were hardly affected by the exposure to 10 microM Al in an Al-resistant cultivar, Atlas 66. However, similar exposure rapidly inhibited root elongation in an Al-sensitive cultivar, Scout 66 and this was associated with a time-dependent accumulation of Al in the root tissues with more than 77% residing in the cell wall. Al caused a significant decrease in both the viscous and elastic extensibility of cell wall of the root apices of Scout 66. The "break load" of the root apex of Scout 66 was also decreased by Al. However, neither the viscosity nor elasticity of the cell wall was affected by in vitro Al treatment. Furthermore, pre-treatment of seedlings with Al in conditions where root elongation was slow (i.e. low temperature) did not affect the subsequent elongation of roots in a 0 Al treatment at room temperature. These results suggest that the Al-dependent changes in the cell wall viscosity and elasticity are involved in the inhibition of root growth. Furthermore, for Al to reduce cell wall extensibility it must interact with the cell walls of actively elongating cells.     

Aluminium tolerance is achieved by exudation of citric acid from roots of soybean (Glycine max)

Fourteen soybean ( Glycine max [L.] Merr.) cultivars were analysed and found to differ considerably in aluminium (Al) resistance. The cultivars Suzunari (Al-resistant) and Shishio (Al-sensitive) were selected for further analysis of physiological mechanisms of Al-resistance. The relative root growth of Shishio was 48% compared to 76% for Suzunari in response to 15 μ M Al (24 h). Aluminium accumulation and Al-induced callose formation in root apices were 50 and 25% of that in Suzunari, respectively. Al inhibited both Suzunari and Shishio during the first 6 h of exposure. However, the root growth inhibition was further increased in Shishio but not in Suzunari, suggesting an Al-induced Al-resistant mechanism operating in Suzunari. Organic acid analysis in root exudates of both cultivars revealed that they specifically exuded citrate in response to Al. However, the citrate exudation rate was significantly higher in Suzunari during the 6 h/24 h Al treatment, which was 52/330 compared to Shishio's 26/118 (nmol [g root fresh weight]⁻¹ [6 h]⁻¹), respectively. This Al-induced citric acid exudation was found to be specific for Al, as several other metals failed to induce citrate exudation in both cultivars. Fourteen days of P deficiency did not elicit citrate excretion in both cultivars, while application of Al to P-deficient plants rapidly induced citrate exudation in both cultivars, confirming the specificity of the response of these soybean cultivars to Al. To our knowledge, this is the first report demonstrating an Al-exclusion mechanism in soybean cultivars, which is conferred by enhanced and specific Al-induced exudation of citrate.     

Aluminium alleviates manganese toxicity to rice by decreasing root symplastic Mn uptake and reducing availability to shoots of Mn stored in roots

Background and Aims Manganese (Mn) and aluminium (Al) phytotoxicities occur mainly in acid soils. In some plant species, Al alleviates Mn toxicity, but the mechanisms underlying this effect are obscure.Methods Rice (Oryza sativa) seedlings (11 d old) were grown in nutrient solution containing different concentrations of Mn²⁺ and Al³⁺ in short-term (24 h) and long-term (3 weeks) treatments. Measurements were taken of root symplastic sap, root Mn plaques, cell membrane electrical surface potential and Mn activity, root morphology and plant growth.Key Results In the 3-week treatment, addition of Al resulted in increased root and shoot dry weight for plants under toxic levels of Mn. This was associated with decreased Mn concentration in the shoots and increased Mn concentration in the roots. In the 24-h treatment, addition of Al resulted in decreased Mn accumulation in the root symplasts and in the shoots. This was attributed to higher cell membrane surface electrical potential and lower Mn²⁺ activity at the cell membrane surface. The increased Mn accumulation in roots from the 3-week treatment was attributed to the formation of Mn plaques, which were probably related to the Al-induced increase in root aerenchyma.Conclusions The results show that Al alleviated Mn toxicity in rice, and this could be attributed to decreased shoot Mn accumulation resulting from an Al-induced decrease in root symplastic Mn uptake. The decrease in root symplastic Mn uptake resulted from an Al-induced change in cell membrane potential. In addition, Al increased Mn plaques in the roots and changed the binding properties of the cell wall, resulting in accumulation of non-available Mn in roots.     

Does aluminium affect root growth of maize through interaction with the cell wall – plasma membrane – cytoskeleton continuum?

The mechanism of aluminium-induced inhibition of root elongation is still not well understood. It is a matter of debate whether the primary lesions of Al toxicity are apoplastic or symplastic. The present paper summarises experimental evidence which offers new avenues in the understanding of Al toxicity and resistance in maize. Application of Al for 1 h to individual 1 mm sections of the root apex only inhibited root elongation if applied to the first 3 apical mm. The most Al-sensitive apical root zone appeared to be the 1–2 mm segment. Aluminium-induced prominent alterations in both the microtubular (disintegration) and the actin cytoskeleton (altered polymerisation patterns) were found especially in the apical 1–2 mm zone using monoclonal antibodies. Since accumulation of Al in the root apoplast is dependent on the properties of the pectic matrix, we investigated whether Al uptake and toxicity could be modulated by changing the pectin content of the cell walls through pre-treatment of intact maize plants with 150 mM NaCl for 5 days. NaCl-adapted plants with higher pectin content accumulated more Al in their root apices and they were more Al-sensitive as indicated by more severe inhibition of root elongation and enhanced callose induction by Al. This special role of the pectic matrix of the cell walls in the modulation of Al toxicity is also indicated by a close positive correlation between pectin, Al, and Al-induced callose contents of 1 mm root segments along the 5 mm root apex. On the basis of the presented data we suggest that the rapid disorganisation of the cytoskeleton leading to root growth inhibition may be mediated by interaction of Al with the apoplastic side of the cell wall – plasma membrane – cytoskeleton continuum. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Differential Al resistance and citrate secretion in barley (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Hordeum vulgare</Emphasis> L.)

While barley ( Hordeum vulgare L.) is the most sensitive species to Al toxicity among small-grain crops, variation in Al resistance between cultivars does exist. We examined the mechanism responsible for differential Al resistance in 21 barley varieties. Citrate was secreted from the roots in response to Al stress. A positive correlation between citrate secretion and Al resistance [(root elongation with Al)/(root elongation without Al)] and a negative correlation between citrate secretion and Al content of root apices, were obtained, suggesting that citrate secretion from the root apices plays an important role in excluding Al and thereby detoxifying Al. The Al-induced secretion of citrate was characterized using an Al-resistant variety (Sigurdkorn) and an Al-sensitive variety (Kearney). In Sigurdkorn, Al-induced secretion of citrate occurred within 20 min, and the secretion did not increase with increasing external Al concentration. The Al-induced citrate secretion ceased at low temperature (6 degrees C) and was inhibited by anion-channel inhibitors. Internal citrate content of root apices was increased by Al exposure in Sigurdkorn, but was not affected in Kearney. The activity of citrate synthase was unaffected by Al in both Al-resistant and Al-sensitive varieties. The secretion rate of organic acid anions from barley was the lowest among wheat, rye and triticale.     

The effect of aluminium on polypeptide pattern of cell wall proteins isolated from the roots of Al-sensitive and Al-resistant barley cultivars

Accumulation of some proteins isolated from the cell wall of roots of the Al-sensitive (Alfor) and the Al-resistant (Bavaria) barley cultivars were followed during treatment with different Al³⁺ concentrations, pH changes of the root medium, and several heavy metals (Cu²⁺, Cd²⁺, Co²⁺). SDS-PAGE analysis revealed an Al-induced accumulation of polypeptides with molecular mass of 14, and 16 kDa and a group of polypeptides around 27 kDa. The accumulation pattern of Al-induced polypeptides was very similar in both cultivars but in the Al-resistant Bavaria it was induced at lower Al concentration and earlier than it was in the Al-sensitive cultivar Alfor. Changes in pH values of root medium (pH 3.5–6.5) did not show any effect on the accumulation of Al-induced cell wall polypeptides either in Al-sensitive or in Al-tolerant barley cultivar. Heavy metals (Cu, Cd, and Co) at concentration of 10 μM resulted in similar accumulation of individual polypeptides as we found after Al treatment. In comparison to Al, quantitative differences in polypeptides accumulation induced by Cu, Cd and Co were less expressed that of Al treatment. More pronounced accumulation and earlier induction of individual cell wall polypeptides in roots of Al-resistant barley cultivar than in Al-sensitive, might indicate some possible role of these polypeptides in plant resistance to Al stress.     

Al-induced efflux of organic acid anions is poorly associated with internal organic acid metabolism in triticale roots

The secretion of organic acid anions from roots has been identified as a mechanism of resistance to Al. However, the process leading to the secretion of organic acid anions is poorly understood. The effect of Al on organic acid metabolism was investigated in two lines of triticale (xTriticosecale Wittmark) differing in Al-induced secretion of malate and citrate and in Al resistance. The site of Al-induced secretion of citrate and malate from a resistant line was localized to the root apices (terminal 5 mm). The levels of citrate (root apices and mature root segments) and malate (mature segments only) in roots increased during exposure to Al, but similar changes were observed in both triticale genotypes. The in vitro activities of four enzymes involved in malate and citrate metabolism (citrate synthase, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase, malate dehydrogenase, and NADP-isocitrate dehydrogenase) were similar for sensitive and resistant lines in both root apices and mature root segments. The response of these enzymes to pH did not differ between tolerant and sensitive lines or in the presence and absence of Al. Moreover, cytoplasmic and vacuolar pH were not affected by exposure to Al in either line. Together, these results indicate that the Al-dependent efflux of organic acid anions from the roots of triticale is not regulated by their internal levels in the roots or by the capacity of the root cells to synthesize malate and citrate.     

Aluminium-induced growth inhibition is associated with impaired efflux and influx of H+ across the plasma membrane in root apices of squash (Cucurbita pepo)

It is generally understood that the inhibition of growth of root apices is the initial effect caused by aluminium (Al) toxicity. The correlation between impaired H+-fluxes across the plasma membrane (PM) and Al-induced growth inhibition, Al accumulation and callose formation in root apices of squash (Cucurbita pepo L. cv. Tetsukabuto) is reported here. The root inhibition was dependent on Al concentration, and the duration of exposure, with the damage occurring preferentially in regions with high Al accumulation and callose formation. Using the fluorescent Al indicator (Morin), Al was localized in the cell walls of the root-tip cells after 3 h and in the whole root-tip cells after 6 h of the Al treatment (50 micro M). The inhibition of H+-pumping rate in the highly purified PM vesicles obtained from the Al-treated apical root portions (1 cm) coincided with the inhibition of root growth under Al stress. Furthermore, H+-ATPase activity of PM vesicles prepared from the control root apices was strongly inhibited by Al in vitro in a dose-dependent manner. Approximately 50% inhibition was observed when PM vesicles were preincubated at Al concentration as low as 10 micro M followed by the enzyme assay in the medium without Al. Using the pH indicator (bromocresol purple), it is shown that surface pH of the control (0 Al) root apices was strongly alkalized from the starting pH of 4.5 in a time-dependent manner. By contrast, the surface pH changed only slightly in the Al-treated root apices. The changes in surface pH mediated by altered dynamics of H+ efflux and influx across the root tip PM play an important role in root growth as affected by Al.     

Aluminum-induced 1-->3-beta-D-glucan inhibits cell-to-cell trafficking of molecules through plasmodesmata. A new mechanism of aluminum toxicity in plants

Symplastic intercellular transport in plants is achieved by plasmodesmata (PD). These cytoplasmic channels are well known to interconnect plant cells to facilitate intercellular movement of water, nutrients, and signaling molecules including hormones. However, it is not known whether Al may affect this cell-to-cell transport process, which is a critical feature for roots as organs of nutrient/water uptake. We have microinjected the dye lucifer yellow carbohydrazide into peripheral root cells of an Al-sensitive wheat (Triticum aestivum cv Scout 66) either before or after Al treatment and followed the cell-to-cell dye-coupling through PD. Here we show that the Al-induced root growth inhibition is closely associated with the Al-induced blockage of cell-to-cell dye coupling. Immunofluorescence combined with immuno-electron microscopic techniques using monoclonal antibodies against 1-->3-beta-D-glucan (callose) revealed circumstantial evidence that Al-induced callose deposition at PD may responsible for this blockage of symplastic transport. Use of 2-deoxy-D-glucose, a callose synthesis inhibitor, allowed us to demonstrate that a reduction in callose particles correlated well with the improved dye-coupling and reduced root growth inhibition. While assessing the tissue specificity of this Al effect, comparable responses were obtained from the dye-coupling pattern in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) mesophyll cells. Analyses of the Al-induced expression of PD-associated proteins, such as calreticulin and unconventional myosin VIII, showed enhanced fluorescence and co-localizations with callose deposits. These results suggest that Al-signal mediated localized alterations to calcium homeostasis may drive callose formation and PD closure. Our data demonstrate that extracellular Al-induced callose deposition at PD could effectively block symplastic transport and communication in higher plants.     

Aluminium triggers malate-independent potassium release via ion channels from the root apex in wheat

The regulatory mechanisms for the aluminium (Al)-induced efflux of K(+) and malate from the root apex of Al-resistant wheat ( Triticum aestivum L. cv. Atlas) were characterized. Treatment with 20 mM tetraethylammonium (TEA) chloride, a K(+)-channel inhibitor, blocked the Al-induced K(+) efflux by 65%, but blocked the Al-induced malate efflux only slightly. Lanthanum (La(3+)) or ytterbium (Yb(3+)) strongly inhibited the K(+) efflux, but slightly increased malate efflux. These lanthanides applied together with Al did not affect the Al-induced malate efflux, but reduced the Al-induced K(+) efflux by 57% for La(3+) and by 35% for Yb(3+). By contrast, pretreatment with 50 microM niflumic acid, an anion-channel inhibitor, strongly suppressed the Al-induced malate efflux, but did not affect the Al-induced K(+) efflux. The efflux of K(+) uncoupled with that of malate resulted in the alkalization of intracellular pH in the root apex, suggesting that the release of K(+) coupled with malate plays an important role in stabilizing intracellular pH. Copper (Cu(2+)) induced the release of K(+) via a TEA-insensitive pathway without the release of malate in both Al-resistant and Al-sensitive (cultivar Scout) wheat. Simultaneous application of Al and Cu(2+) to the root apices resulted in TEA-sensitive K(+) efflux in Atlas but not in Scout, suggesting that Al competes with Cu(2+) for K(+) efflux. Taken together, these results suggest that Al-induced K(+) efflux is mediated by both TEA- and lanthanide-sensitive K(+) channels, although this induction is not a prerequisite for the induction of the release of malate.     

边缘细胞对荞麦根尖铝毒的防护效应和对细胞壁多糖的影响

以2个荞麦(Fygopyrum esculentum Moench)基因型‘江西荞麦’(耐性)和‘内蒙荞麦’(敏感)为材料,采用悬空培养(保持边缘细胞附着于根尖和去除根尖边缘细胞),研究边缘细胞对根尖铝毒的防护效应以及对细胞壁多糖组分的影响。结果表明,铝毒抑制荞麦根系伸长,导致根尖Al积累。去除边缘细胞的根伸长抑制率和根尖Al含量高于保留边缘细胞的根。去除边缘细胞使江西荞麦和内蒙荞麦根尖的酸性磷酸酶(APA)活性显著升高,前者在铝毒下增幅更大。同时,铝毒胁迫下去除边缘细胞的根尖果胶甲酯酶(PME)活性和细胞壁果胶、半纤维素1、半纤维素2含量显著高于保留边缘细胞的酶活性和细胞壁多糖含量。表明边缘细胞对荞麦根尖的防护效应,与其阻止Al的吸收,降低根尖细胞壁多糖含量及提高酸性磷酸酶活性有关,以此缓解Al对根伸长的抑制。     

Intracellular distribution and binding state of aluminum in root apices of two common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) genotypes in relation to Al toxicity

The role of the intracellular distribution and binding state of aluminum (Al) in Al toxicity, using Al exchange and Al fractionation methodologies, were studied in two common bean ( Phaseolus vulgaris L.) genotypes differing in Al resistance. These two genotypes are characterized by a similar initial period (4 h) of Al sensitivity followed by a contrasting recovery period (8–24 h). A higher initial Al accumulation in Quimbaya (Al resistant) in the 5-mm root apex compared with VAX-1 (Al sensitive) could be related to its higher content of unmethylated pectin and thus higher negative charge of the cell walls (CWs). The binding state and cellular distribution of Al in the root apices revealed that the root elongation rate was significantly negatively correlated with the free apoplastic and the stable-bound, not citrate-exchangeable CW Al representing the most important Al fraction in the root apex (80%), but not with the symplastic and the labile-bound, citrate-exchangeable CW Al. It is postulated that the induced and sustained recovery from the initial Al stress in the Al-resistant genotype Quimbaya requires reducing the stable-bound Al in the apoplast thus allowing cell elongation and division to resume.     

Immobilization of aluminum with phosphorus in roots is associated with high aluminum resistance in buckwheat

Oxalic acid secretion from roots is considered to be an important mechanism for aluminum (Al) resistance in buckwheat (Fygopyrum esculentum Moench). Nonetheless, only a single Al-resistant buckwheat cultivar was used to investigate the significance of oxalic acid in detoxifying Al. In this study, we investigated two buckwheat cultivars, Jiangxi (Al resistant) and Shanxi (Al sensitive), which showed significant variation in their resistance to Al stress. In the presence of 0 to 100 microM Al, the inhibition of root elongation was greater in Shanxi than that in Jiangxi, and the Al content of root apices (0-10 mm) was much lower in Jiangxi. However, the dependence of oxalic acid secretion on external Al concentration and the time course for secretion were similar in both cultivars. Furthermore, the variation in Al-induced oxalic acid efflux along the root was similar, showing a 10-fold greater efflux from the apical 0- to 5-mm region than from the 5- to 10-mm region. These results suggest that both Shanxi and Jiangxi possess an equal capacity for Al-dependent oxalic acid secretion. Another two potential Al resistance mechanisms, i.e. Al-induced alkalinization of rhizosphere pH and root inorganic phosphate release, were also not involved in their differential Al resistance. However, after longer treatments in Al (10 d), the concentrations of phosphorus and Al in the roots of the Al-resistant cultivar Jiangxi were significantly higher than those in Shanxi. Furthermore, more Al was localized in the cell walls of the resistant cultivar. All these results suggest that while Al-dependent oxalic acid secretion might contribute to the overall high resistance to Al stress of buckwheat, this response cannot explain the variation in tolerance between these two cultivars. We present evidence suggesting the greater Al resistance in buckwheat is further related to the immobilization and detoxification of Al by phosphorus in the root tissues.     

Target sites of aluminum phytotoxicity

The primary phytotoxic effect of aluminum (Al) is confined to the root apex. It is a matter of debate whether the primary injury of Al toxicity is apoplastic or symplastic. This review paper summarizes our current understanding of the spatial and metabolic sites of Al phytotoxicity. At tissue level, the meristematic, distal transition, and apical elongation zones of the root apex are most sensitive to Al. At cellular and molecular level, many cell components are implicated in Al toxicity including DNA in nucleus, numerous cytoplastic compounds, the plasma membrane, and the cell wall. Although it is difficult to distinguish the primary targets from the secondary effects so far, understanding of the target sites of Al toxicity is helpful for elucidating the mechanisms by which Al exerts its deleterious effects on root growth.This work was partly supported by fund from the Huoyingdong Foundation, Education Ministry of China and Natural Science Foundation of China (Contact No. 30170548).     

Root phosphate exudation and pH shift in the rhizosphere are not responsible for aluminum resistance in rice

A series of hydroponic experiments and an agar culture experiment were carried out to investigate aluminum (Al) accumulation and translocation in two rice (Oryza sativa L.) cultivars (Kasalath and Koshihikari) that differ in Al resistance. Al-resistance mechanisms, including Pi exudation under Al stress and pH shifts in the rhizosphere, were also studied. Al content in rice shoots was 41 mg kg⁻¹ on average and did not differ between the two cultivars, which demonstrated that the rice cultivars were not Al accumulators. The majority of Al (95–97%) accumulated in roots. Al content in roots in the resistant cultivar (Koshihikari) was lower than that in the sensitive cultivar (Kasalath), which indicated that Al-exclusion mechanisms were mainly acting in rice. However, the rate of Pi exudation from the whole root or root tips was very low in both cultivars and was not significantly influenced by Al exposure, and thus seemed not to be the main Al-resistance mechanism. On the other hand, experiments with pH-buffered solution and color changes following culture in agar medium containing bromocresol purple revealed that the Al-induced pH increase could not explain the high Al resistance of rice. In addition, the Al content in shoots of Koshihikari was lower after the formation of iron plaque on the root surface, whereas that of Kasalath was not lower. These results suggested that rice roots cell wall components or root surfaces such as iron plaque, rather than pH changes and/or root exudates including organic acids and phosphate, play important roles in Al resistance in rice.