Virulence Analysis and Race Classification of Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae in China

Two hundred and eighty‐five isolates of Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae were randomly collected from 22 rice‐growing provinces in China. Ninety‐one representative isolates were chosen to assess the differential characteristics of 24 near‐isogenic rice lines containing a single resistance gene or two to four genes. Most isolates were avirulent on pyramided lines, except IRBB51, and hence, the pyramided lines cannot be used as differentials for the virulence analysis of X. oryzae pv. oryzae in China. The 13 rice lines with a single gene were used further to establish a system of races classification of X. oryzae pv. oryzae in China. IR24 and IRBB10 were susceptible to the isolates with several exceptions, whereas IRBB5, IRBB7 and IRBB21 were resistant. Based on the interactions between the isolates of X. oryzae pv. oryzae and the 13 near‐isogenic rice lines, six single‐gene rice cultivars (IRBB5, IRBB13, IRBB3, IRBB14, IRBB2 and IR24) were chosen as differentials, and the 285 tested isolates were classified into nine races. The reaction patterns of the nine races in order were: RRRRRR, RRRRRS, RRRRSS, RRRSSS, RRSSSS, RSRRRS, RSSRRS, RSSSSS and SSSSSS. The race frequencies were 10.18%, 10.53%, 4.91%, 10.18%, 24.21%, 5.96%, 11.23%, 22.46% and 0.35% respectively. The virulence of representative strains of eight Philippine races on 13 rice lines with a single gene was determined and compared with the Chinese races. The frequency distributions of X. oryzae pv. oryzae races were primarily described for the different regions in China.     

Field performance of Xa21 transgenic indica rice (Oryza sativa L.), IR72

Based on the characterization of the resistance phenotype and molecular analysis, several homozygous lines carrying Xa21 against the bacterial blight (BB) pathogen were obtained from previously transformed indica rice, IR72. The homozygous line, T103-10, with the best phenotype and seed-setting, was repeatedly tested under normal field conditions to evaluate its levels of resistance to the BB pathogen in Wuhan, China, in 1998 and 1999. The isolates of Xanthomonas oryzae pv oryzae (Xoo) used in this experiments were PXO61, PXO79, PXO99 and PXO112 isolated from the Philippines, T2 isolated from Japan, and Zhe173 isolated from China. The results demonstrated that the transgenic homozygous line expressed the same resistance spectrum, but with a shorter lesion length to each inoculated isolates as the lesion length of the Xa21 donor line IRBB21. The non-transformed control IR72 carrying Xa4 was resistant to PXO61, PXO112, Zhe173 and T2, but susceptible to PXO99 and PXO79. The negative control variety IR24 was susceptible to all isolates under field conditions. The results demonstrated clearly that the Xa21 transgene led to an excellent field performance of the introduced bacterial blight resistance trait on the recipient plants. The yield performance of this transgenic homozygous line, T103-10, is comparable with that of the control under field conditions. Received: 2 August 1999 / Accepted: 3 November 1999     

Analysis of Pathogenic Diversity of the Rice Bacterial Blight Pathogen (Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae) in the Andaman Islands and Identification of Effective Resistance Genes

Bacterial blight (BB) caused by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (Xoo) is a major disease of rice in the tropics for which genetic resistance in the host plants is the only effective solution. This study aimed at identification of resistance gene combinations effective against Xoo isolates and fingerprinting of the Xoo isolates of Andaman Islands (India). Here, we report the reaction of 21 rice BB differentials possessing Xa1 to Xa21 genes individually and in different combinations to various isolates of pathogen collected from Andaman Islands. Pathological screening results of 14 isolates revealed that among individual genes tested across 2 years, Xa4, Xa7 and Xa21 conferred resistance reaction across all isolates, whereas among combinations, IRBB 50 (Xa4 + xa5), IRBB 52 (Xa4 + Xa21) and IRBB 60 (Xa4 + xa5 + xa13 + Xa21) conveyed effective resistance against tested isolates. The nature of genetic diversity among four isolates selected on the basis of geographical isolation in the islands was studied through DNA finger printing. The RAPD primers S111, S119, S1117, S1109, S1103, S109 and S105 were found to be better indicators of molecular diversity among isolates than JEL primers. The diversity analysis grouped 14 isolates into three major clusters based on disease reaction wherein isolate no. 8 was found the most divergent as well as highly virulent. The remaining isolates were classified into two distinct groups. The importance of the study in the context of transfer of resistance gene(s) in the local cultivars specifically for tropical island conditions is presented and discussed.     

MQ2: visualizing multi-trait mapped QTL results

Bacterial blight (BB) of rice (Oryza sativa L.) caused by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (Xoo) is a destructive disease in rice worldwide. Xa3, a gene conferring resistance to BB at the booting stage of the rice plant, has been characterized previously using map-based cloning. We cloned and sequenced the Xa3/xa3 gene in the Korean cultivars Hwayeong, Ilmi, and Goun and conferred resistance or susceptibility to BB. We detected polymorphisms, and polymerase chain reaction-based functional markers were developed based on the single nucleotide polymorphism from the Xa3 and xa3 nucleotide sequence. Susceptible or resistant individuals from an F2 population developed from a cross between Milyang 244 and Ilmi, near-isogenic lines carrying BB resistance genes, were screened with functional markers. The BB3-RF and BB3-RR primers consistently amplified a resistance-specific fragment of 255 bp only in resistant plants, whereas the BB3-SF and BB3-SR primers were specific to susceptible plants. Genotyping results were co-segregated with phenotype by conducting the BB resistance test with the K₃ race. These markers could be effective for marker-assisted selection of the Xa3 gene in rice breeding programs.     

Genotypic and Pathotypic Diversity of Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae Strains in Taiwan

Rice bacterial leaf blight, caused by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae [(Ishiyama) Swings et al. 1990] (Xoo), is a major rice disease of the second crop season in Taiwan. A total of 88 Xoo strains collected from 10 major rice cultivating areas in Taiwan from 1986, 1997, 2000, 2004, and 2011 were characterized by repetitive‐element PCR (REP‐PCR) fingerprinting and virulence analyses. Among the five genetic clusters identified by the pJEL1/pJEL2 (IS1112‐based) and REP1R‐Dt/REP2‐D [repetitive extragenic palindromic (REP)‐based] primer sets, clusters A, C and D contained Xoo strains from geographically distant regions, which suggests a high frequency of Xoo dispersal in Taiwan. The 88 Xoo strains were evaluated by inoculations on IRBB near‐isogenic lines and five Taiwan rice cultivars. A subset of 45 moderately or highly virulent strains were classified into 15 pathotypes by their compatible or incompatible reactions on IR24 and 12 IRBB near‐isogenic lines, each containing a single resistance gene. Analysis of molecular haplotypes and pathotypes revealed a partial relationship. IRBB5, IRBB21 and IRBB4 were incompatible with 96%, 96% and 73% of the strains, so xa5, Xa21 and Xa4 can recognize most of the Xoo strains in Taiwan and elicit resistance. In contrast, IRBB3 (Xa3), IRBB8 (xa8), IRBB10 (Xa10), IRBB11 (Xa11), IRBB13 (xa13) and IRBB14 (Xa14) were susceptible to almost all of the 45 Xoo strains. Inoculation trials revealed significant differences in the susceptibility of five Taiwan cultivars to Xoo (from high to low susceptibility: Taichung Sen 10 >  IR24, Taichung Native 1 >  Taichung 192, Taikeng 9, Tainan 11). This study provides useful information for resistance breeding and the development of disease management strategies against bacterial blight disease of rice.     

Combining bacterial blight resistance and Basmati quality characteristics by phenotypic and molecular marker-assisted selection in rice

Bacterial Blight (BB) caused by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae is a major disease of rice in tropical Asia. Since all the Basmati varieties are highly susceptible and the disease is prevalent in the entire Basmati growing region of India, BB is a severe constraint in Basmati rice production. The present study was undertaken with the objective of combining the important Basmati quality traits with resistance to BB by a combination of phenotypic and molecular marker-assisted selection (MAS). Screening of 13 near-isogenic lines of rice against four isolates of the pathogen from Basmati growing regions identified the Xa4, xa8, xa13 and Xa21 effective against all the isolates tested. Two or more of these genes in combination imparted enhanced resistance as expressed by reduced average lesion length in comparison to individual genes. The two-gene pyramid line IRBB55 carrying xa13 and Xa21 was found equally effective as three/four gene pyramid lines. The two BB resistance genes present in IRBB55 were combined with the Basmati quality traits of Pusa Basmati-1 (PB-1), the most popular high yielding Basmati rice variety used as recurrent parent. Phenotypic selection for disease resistance, agronomic and Basmati quality characteristics and marker-assisted selection for the two resistance genes were carried out in BC₁F₁, BC₁F₂ and BC₁F₃ generations. Background analysis using 252 polymorphic amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers detected 80.4 to 86.7% recurrent parent alleles in BC₁F₃ selections. Recombinants having enhanced resistance to BB, Basmati quality and desirable agronomic traits were identified, which can either be directly developed into commercial varieties or used as immediate donors of BB resistance in Basmati breeding programs.     

Fine Mapping of Xa2, a Bacterial Blight Resistance Gene in Rice

The rice bacterial blight resistance gene, Xa2, confers resistance to T7147 of the bacterial blight pathogen Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae. It is located on the long arm of chromosome 4. Here, we report the fine mapping of Xa2 by genetic recombination analysis with simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers according to the genome sequence. Two F₂ populations are constructed to localize Xa2. In a primary analysis with 136 random F₂ plants of Zhenzhuai/IRBB2, it was found that Xa2 was located in approximately 20 cM region. To accurately determine the locus of Xa2, 120 new SSR markers were developed in this region by screening the sequence. Twelve new SSR markers were successfully used in genetic recombination analysis in IR24/IRBB2 population, while 20 in ZZA/IRBB2 population. We found that the nearest SSR markers to Xa2 are HZR950-5 and HZR970-4, which cover approximately 190-kb region. The sequence analysis of this 190-kb region revealed the presence of a homologous sequence of leucine rich repeat (LRR)-kinase. These results are very useful for transferring or pyramiding Xa2 by molecular marker-assistant selection in rice breeding programs and for cloning Xa2 by map-based cloning in combination with a long-range PCR strategy. Electronic supplementary material Electronic supplementary material is available for this article at and accessible for authorised users.     

Transgenic rice variety ‘IR72’ with Xa21 is resistant to bacterial blight

 An elite indica rice variety, ‘IR72’, was transformed with a cloned gene, Xa21, through particle bombardment. Molecular analysis of transgenic plants revealed the presence of a 3.8-kb EcoRV-digested DNA fragment corresponding to most of the Xa21 coding region and its complete intron sequence, indicating the integration of Xa21 into the genome of ‘IR72’. In the T₁ generation, the transgene was inherited and segregated in a 3:1 ratio. After inoculation with the prevalent races 4 and 6 of Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (Xoo), T₁ plants positive for the transgene were found to be resistant to bacterial blight (BB). We also observed that the level of resistance to race 4 of Xoo was higher due to the pyramiding of Xa21 and Xa4 present in ‘IR72’. Since the inactivation of the transgene Xa21 occurred in the two transgenic T₁ plants, a larger progeny should be obtained for selecting homozygous line with a consistently higher level of resistance to the BB pathogen. Received: 13 October 1997 / Accepted: 21 October 1997     

Pyramiding of bacterial blight resistance genes in rice: marker-assisted selection using RFLP and PCR

 DNA marker-assisted selection was used to pyramid four bacterial blight resistance genes, Xa-4, xa-5, xa-13 and Xa-21. Breeding lines with two, three and four resistance genes were developed and tested for resistance to the bacterial blight pathogen (Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae). The pyramid lines showed a wider spectrum and a higher level of resistance than lines with only a single gene. To speed up the gene pyramiding process and to facilitate future marker-aided selection, we developed PCR markers for the two recessive genes, xa-5 and xa-13, and used these to survey a range of rice germplasm. The results of the germplasm survey will be useful for the selection of parents in breeding programs aimed at transferring these bacterial blight resistance genes from one varietal background to another. Received: 6 December 1996/Accepted: 20 December 1996     

Bacterial leaf blight resistance genes (Xa21, xa13 and xa5) pyramiding through molecular marker assisted selection into rice cultivars

Marker assisted selection was employed to pyramid three bacterial blight resistance genes Xa21, xa13 and xa5 into high yielding susceptible rice cultivars ADT43 and ADT47. With the assistance of PCR markers, homozygous and heterozygous genotypes were identified in F₂ generation of two crosses (ADT43 × IRBB60 and ADT47 × IRBB60) and goodness of fit was tested. Eighty nine plants from F₃ generation of ADT43 × IRBB60 were also screened for resistance genes. The genotypes carrying resistance genes in different combinations were identified. The pyramided lines showed a wider spectrum and higher level of resistance against two Xoo isolates under field conditions.     

High-resolution genetic mapping of rice bacterial blight resistance gene Xa23

Bacterial blight (BB) caused by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (Xoo) is the most devastating bacterial disease of rice (Oryza sativa L.), a staple food crop that feeds half of the world’s population. In management of this disease, the most economical and effective approach is cultivating resistant varieties. Due to rapid change of pathogenicity in the pathogen, it is necessary to identify and characterize more host resistance genes for breeding new resistant varieties. We have previously identified the BB resistance (R) gene Xa23 that confers the broadest resistance to Xoo strains isolated from different rice-growing regions and preliminarily mapped the gene within a 1.7 cm region on the long arm of rice chromosome 11. Here, we report fine genetic mapping and in silico analysis of putative candidate genes of Xa23. Based on F₂ mapping populations derived from crosses between Xa23-containing rice line CBB23 and susceptible varieties JG30 or IR24, six new STS markers Lj36, Lj46, Lj138, Lj74, A83B4, and Lj13 were developed. Linkage analysis revealed that the new markers were co-segregated with or closely linked to the Xa23 locus. Consequently, the Xa23 gene was mapped within a 0.4 cm region between markers Lj138 and A83B4, in which the co-segregating marker Lj74 was identified. The corresponding physical distance between Lj138 and A83B4 on Nipponbare genome is 49.8 kb. Six Xa23 candidate genes have been annotated, including four candidate genes encoding hypothetical proteins and the other two encoding a putative ADP-ribosylation factor protein and a putative PPR protein. These results will facilitate marker-assisted selection of Xa23 in rice breeding and molecular cloning of this valuable R gene.     

Tagging and combining bacterial blight resistance genes in rice using RAPD and RFLP markers

Four genes of rice,Oryza sativa L., conditioning resistance to the bacterial blight pathogenXanthomonas oryzae pv.oryzae (X. o. pv.oryzae), were tagged by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) and random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers. No recombinants were observed betweenxa-5 and RFLP marker lociRZ390, RG556 orRG207 on chromosome 5.Xa-3 andXa-4 were linked to RFLP locusXNpb181 at the top of chromosome 11, at distances of 2.3 cM and 1.7 cM, respectively. The nearest marker toXa-10, also located on chromosome 11, was the RAPD locusO07 ₂₀₀₀ at a distance of 5.3 cM. From this study, the conventional map [19, 28] and two RFLP linkage maps of chromosome 11 [14, 26] were partially integrated. Using the RFLP and RAPD markers linked to the resistance genes, we selected rice lines homozygous for pairs of resistance genes,Xa-4 +xa-5 andXa-4 +Xa-10. Lines carryingXa-4 +xa-5 andXa-4 +Xa-10 were evaluated for reaction to eight strains of the bacterial blight pathogen, representing eight pathotypes and three genetic lineages. As expected, the lines carrying pairs of genes were resistant to more of the isolates than their single-gene parental lines. Lines carryingXa-4 +xa-5 were more resistant to isolates of race 4 than were either of the parental lines (quantitative complementation). No such effects were seen forXa-4 +Xa-10. Thus, combinations of resistance genes provide broader spectra of resistance through both ordinary gene action expected and quantitative complementation.     

High-resolution genetic mapping of bacterial blight resistance gene <Emphasis Type="Italic">Xa10</Emphasis>

Bacterial blight of rice, caused by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (Xoo), is the most devastating disease of rice (Oryza sativa L). Rice lines that carry resistance (R) gene Xa10 confer race-specific resistance to Xoo strains harboring avirulence (Avr) gene avrXa10. Here we report on genetic study, disease evaluation and fine genetic mapping of the Xa10 gene. The inheritance of Xa10-mediated resistance to PXO99^A(pHM1avrXa10) did not follow typical Mendelian inheritance for single dominant gene in F₂ population derived from IR24 × IRBB10. A locus might be present in IRBB10 that caused distorted segregation in F₂ population. To eliminate this locus, an F₃ population (F₃-65) was identified, which showed normal Mendelian segregation ratio of 3:1 for resistance and susceptibility. A new near-isogenic line (F₃-65-1743) of Xa10 in IR24 genetic background was developed and designated as IRBB10A. IRBB10A retained similar resistance specificity as that of IRBB10 and provided complete resistance to PXO99^A(pHM1avrXa10) from seedling to adult stages. Linkage analysis using existing RFLP markers and F₂ mapping population mapped the Xa10 locus to the proximal side of E1981S with genetic distance at 0.93 cM. With five new RFLP markers developed from the genomic sequence of Nipponbare, Xa10 was finely mapped at genetic distance of 0.28 cM between proximal marker M491 and distal marker M419 and co-segregated with markers S723 and M604. The physical distance between M491 and M419 on Nipponbare genome is 74 kb. Seven genes have been annotated from this 74-kb region and six of them are possible Xa10 candidates. The results of this study will be useful in Xa10 cloning and marker-assisted breeding.     

Breeding bacterial blight-resistant hybrid rice with the cloned bacterial blight resistance gene Xa21

The cloned bacterial blight (BB) resistance gene Xa21 was transferred into Minghui63, a widely used restorer line of indica hybrid rice in China, through an Agrobacterium-mediated system. Molecular and resistance analyses revealed that the Xa21 gene was integrated in the genomes of transgenic plants and their progeny inherited resistance stably. For the purpose of hybrid breeding, Xa21 transgenic homozygous restorer lines were selected through `within-lane' dosage comparison of hybridization signal in combination with PCR and resistance analyses. The selected transgenic restorer lines were then crossed with a commonly used sterile line, Zhenshan97A, to produce Xa21 transgenic hybrid rice, Shanyou63-Xa21. The hybrid rice plants with Xa21 displayed high broad-spectrum resistance to Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (Xoo) races and maintained elite agronomic characters of Shanyou63. The propagation of this BB-resistant hybrid variety with Xa21 will benefit rice production.     

Induced suppression of soft rot disease in tobacco by combined application of Bacillus subtilis strain B4 and chemical elicitor BTH

In this study, the utility of the combined application of Benzo-(1,2,3)-thidiazole-7-carbothioic acid S-methyl ester (BTH), a systemic acquired resistance (SAR) inducer, and the plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR), Bacillus subtilis strain B4 (B4), was investigated for the suppression of soft rot disease caused by Pectobacterium carotovorum SCC1 (SCC1) in tobacco seedlings. Soft rot disease was completely suppressed in tobacco with combined application of B4 strain and 0.1 mM BTH when compared to individual application upon pathogen challenge. In addition, the population of bacterial cells of B4 strain was found to be greater when cultured in growth media in the presence of BTH, compared to the growth of B4 strain in the absence of BTH. Spectrophotometer analysis revealed that there was an increased broad range of compounds in the culture filtrate of B4 strain when grown with BTH, compared to the culture filtrate of B4 strain alone. The combined application of B4 strain and 0.1 mM BTH induced the increased expression of PR1a::GUS on tobacco and elicited systemic resistance against SCC1 when compared to individual application. However, there was low expression of PR1a::GUS in the water-treated control. Hence, the integrated use of BTH and B4 strain might be one of the strategies for biological control of soft rot disease through induced systemic resistance (ISR) in tobacco plants.     

Interactions between Sarocladium oryzae and stem attacking fungal pathogens of rice

In laboratory tests Sarocladium oryzae, the sheath rot pathogen of rice was found to inhibit the mycelial growth of other stem-attacking rice pathogens. Among those inhibited, Sclerotium oryzae and Gaeumannomyces graminis var. graminis were most sensitive while Pyricularia oryzae and Rhizoctonia solani were less sensitive. Tissue-based tests made with rice culm segments established that Sarocladium oryzae inhibits mycelial growth and delays sclerotium formation in R. solani. Cerulenin, the toxin produced by Sarocladium oryzae showed a toxicity pattern towards rice pathogens similar to that of Sarocladium oryzae. The stem rot pathogen, Sclerotium oryzae was most sensitive to cerulenin. In two greenhouse experiments, IR58 rice plants inoculated with Sarocladium oryzae alone or together with Sclerotium oryzae, G. graminis var. graminis or R. solani were found to have reduced plant height and increased tiller number. Sheath rot severity increased when Sarocladium oryzae was inoculated as a single pathogen or together with others. Sheath rot inoculation reduced stem rot in rice plants by 76 and 58%, respectively, in Experiment 1 and 2. By its known antagonistic interaction towards stem rot and crown sheath rot pathogens which are sensitive to it and by other unknown interactions, sheath rot emerges as the dominant disease.     

Evaluation of resistance genes in rice against local isolates of Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae in Punjab Province of Pakistan

Absence of resistance/tolerance against bacterial leaf blight (BLB), incited by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae, in famous basmati varieties is one of the main reason for BLB epidemic in Punjab in 2007–2008. For developing resistance against BLB, the response of 26 IRBB lines of IRRI including 10 near isogenic lines (NILs) and 16 gene pyramids carrying two to five resistance genes (Xa series) was evaluated against 61 indigenous Xoo isolates under artificial inoculation field conditions. None of the NILs or gene pyramid provides complete protection against all the isolates. However, Xa21 and xa13 were found resistant against the majority of Xoo isolates, followed by Xa14 and Xa7. Of the 16 gene pyramids used in this study, IRBB-54 (Xa5 + Xa21), IRBB-55 (Xa13 + Xa21) followed by IRBB-58 (Xa4 + Xa13 + Xa21) were found effective against the majority of the Xoo isolates. These resistance genes (individually and in combinations) can be incorporated for the improvement of basmati rice cultivars cultivated in Punjab province of Pakistan. Effectiveness of gene combination supports the strategy of pyramiding appropriate resistance genes. Newly identified resistant genes may also be evaluated for achieving broad spectrum resistance against more Xoo isolates of the area.     

Pyramiding Xa23 and Rxo1 for resistance to two bacterial diseases into an elite indica rice variety using molecular approaches

Rice bacterial leaf blight (BB) caused by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae and bacterial leaf streak (BLS) caused by X. oryzae pv. oryzicola (Xoc) are two important diseases of rice that often outbreak simultaneously and constrain rice production in much of Asia and parts of Africa. Developing resistant cultivars has been the most effective approach to control BB, however, most single resistance genes have limited value in breeding programs because of their narrow-spectrum of resistance to the races of the pathogen. By contrast, there is little progress in breeding varieties resistant to Xoc since BLS resistance in rice was a quantitative trait and so far only a few quantitative resistance loci have been identified. We reported here the development of a high yield elite line, Lu-You-Zhan highly resistant to both BB and BLS by pyramiding Xa23 with a wide-spectrum resistance to BB derived from wild rice and a non-host maize resistance gene, Rxo1, using both marker assisted selection (MAS) and genetic engineering. Our study has provided strong evidence that non-host R genes could be a valuable source of resistance in combating those plant diseases where no single R gene controlling high level of resistance exists and demonstrated that MAS combined with transgenic technologies are an effective strategy to achieve high level of resistance against multiple plant diseases. Y-L Zhou and J-L Xu contributed equally to this work.