Postnatal growth and behavioral development of mice cloned from adult cumulus cells

Since the first successful cloning of mammals from adult somatic cells, there has been no examination of the learning or behavior of cloned offspring. The possibility of adverse effects on animals produced through adult somatic cell cloning is high because many natural biological processes are bypassed and DNA from adult cells, which presumably contain mutations, are used. In this study, we compared cloned mice produced by microinjection transfer of cumulus cell nuclei into enucleated oocytes, to control mice that were specifically generated to eliminate confounding factors that are unique to our cloning procedure. Postnatal weight gain of clones was significantly greater than that of controls. Preweaning development observations revealed that first appearance or performance of 3 out of 10 measures was delayed in cloned mice; however, results of subsequent tests of learning and memory, activity level, and motor skills were comparable for both groups. Together, these data suggest that nuclear transfer of adult somatic cell nuclei to produce cloned mice may delay the appearance of a few developmental milestones but it does not adversely affect the overall postnatal behavior of mice. In addition, this procedure may cause late onset of significantly increased body weight in cloned offspring, the cause or causes of which are being further examined.     

Cloned mice have an obese phenotype not transmitted to their offspring

Mammalian cloning using somatic cells has been accomplished successfully in several species, and its potential basic, clinical and therapeutic applications are being pursued on many fronts. Determining the long-term effects of cloning on offspring is crucial for consideration of future application of the technique. Although full-term development of animals cloned from adult somatic cells has been reported, problems in the resulting progeny indicate that the cloning procedure may not produce animals that are phenotypically identical to their cell donor. We used a mouse model to take advantage of its short generation time and lifespan. Here we report that the increased body weight of cloned B6C3F1 female mice reflects an increase of body fat in addition to a larger body size, and that these mice share many characteristics consistent with obesity. We also show that the obese phenotype is not transmitted to offspring generated by mating male and female cloned mice.     

Dairy cattle exploratory and social behaviors: is there an effect of cloning?

While an increasing number of animals are produced by means of somatic cloning, behavioral studies on cloned animals are still rare. The aim of this study was to investigate whether the somatic cloning procedure has an influence on locomotion, exploratory, vocal and social behaviors of heifers. Ten heifers were used in the present study. Five of them were cloned heifers derived from somatic cells of three different Prim'Holstein cows and five others were same-age control heifers produced by artificial insemination. In addition to observations of social behaviors in the stable group, each animal was placed individually for a short time in an unfamiliar environment. Our results failed to show any statistical differences between clones and their controls both in frequencies of agonistic and non-agonistic behaviors. However, cloned heifers showed significantly more non-agonistic and less agonistic behaviors towards other cloned partners than towards control ones. This result also stood for control heifers. As far as their Hierarchical Index was concerned, three cloned heifers were highest ranking and two others lowest ranking. In this herd, social dominance appeared to be linked to body weight and age rather than to a cloning effect. In an unfamiliar environment, cloned and control subjects exhibited the same level of locomotion and vocalization. However, cloned heifers showed more exploratory behaviors than did control ones. This difference could be due to environmental factors during the postnatal period rather than to cloning.     

Latrunculin a can improve the birth rate of cloned mice and simplify the nuclear transfer protocol by gently inhibiting actin polymerization

Although animal cloning is becoming more practicable, there are many abnormalities in cloned embryos, and the success rate of producing live animals by cloning has been low. Here, we focused on the procedure for preventing pseudo-second polar body extrusion from somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT)-derived oocytes. Typically, reconstructed oocytes are treated with cytochalasin B (CB), but here latrunculin A (LatA) was used instead of CB to prevent pseudo-second polar body extrusion by inhibiting actin polymerization. CB caps F-actin, LatA binds G-actin, and both drugs prevent their polymerization. When the localization of F-actin was examined using phalloidin staining, it was abnormally scattered in the cytoplasm of CB-treated 1-cell embryos, but this was not detected in LatA-treated or in vitro fertilization-derived control embryos. The spindle was larger in CB-treated oocytes than in LatA-treated or untreated control oocytes. LatA treatment also doubled the rate of full-term development after embryo transfer. These results suggest that cloning efficiency in mice can be improved by optimizing each step of the SCNT procedure. Moreover, by using LatA, we could simplify the procedure with a higher birth rate of cloned mice compared with our original method.     

Recent advancements in cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer

Somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) cloning is the sole reproductive engineering technology that endows the somatic cell genome with totipotency. Since the first report on the birth of a cloned sheep from adult somatic cells in 1997, many technical improvements in SCNT have been made by using different epigenetic approaches, including enhancement of the levels of histone acetylation in the chromatin of the reconstructed embryos. Although it will take a considerable time before we fully understand the nature of genomic programming and totipotency, we may expect that somatic cell cloning technology will soon become broadly applicable to practical purposes, including medicine, pharmaceutical manufacturing and agriculture. Here we review recent progress in somatic cell cloning, with a special emphasis on epigenetic studies using the laboratory mouse as a model.     

Phenotypic effects of somatic cell cloning in the mouse

Although a variety of phenotypes and epigenetic alterations have been reported in animals cloned from somatic cells, the exact nature and consequences of cloning remain unclear. We cloned mice using fresh or short-term cultures of donor cells (cumulus cells, immature Sertoli cells, and fetal or adult fibroblast cells) with defined genetic backgrounds, and then compared the phenotypic and epigenetic characteristics of the cloned mice with those of fertilization-derived control mice. Irrespective of the nucleus-donor cell type, about 50% of the reconstructed embryos developed to the morula/blastocyst stage, but about 90% of these clones showed arrested development between days 5 and 8, shortly after implantation. Most of the clones were alive at term, readily recovered respiration, and did not show any malformations or overgrowths. However, their placentas were two- to threefold larger than those of the controls, due to hyperplasia of the basal (or spongiotrophoblast) layer. Although there was significant suppression of a subset of both imprinted and non-imprinted placental genes, fetal gene suppression was minimal. The seven imprinted genes that we examined were all expressed correctly from the parental alleles. These findings were consistent for every cell type from the midgestation through term stages. Therefore, cloning by nuclear transfer does not perturb the parent-specific imprinting memory that is established during gametogenesis, and the phenotypic and epigenetic effects of cloning are restricted to placental development at the midgestation and term stages. Twelve male mice that were born in a normal manner following nuclear transfer with immature Sertoli cells (B6D2F1 genetic background) were subjected to long-term observation. They died earlier than the genotype-matched controls (50% survival point: 550 days vs. 1028 days, respectively), most probably due to severe pneumonia, which indicates that unexpected phenotypes can appear as a result of the long-term effects of somatic cell cloning.     

人-兔异种核移植构建克隆胚的实验研究

“治疗性克隆”是人类最关注的课题之一,而人体细胞核移植是治疗性克隆的基础和前提。异种核移植的方法虽已被引入人体细胞克隆胚的构建,但供体细胞的类型、培养代数及准备方法与其效率之间的关系尚有待探讨。本实验以不同培养代数和不同准备方法的人卵丘细胞、皮肤成纤维细胞和软骨细胞为供体构建了克隆胚,对其发育情况的比较表明,以卵丘细胞为供体时重构胚的体外发育率高于其余二者,差异显著（P〈0．05）;不同培养代数的成纤维细胞克隆胚和不同冷藏天数供体细胞克隆胚体外发育率无明显差异。此外,本实验还尝试用荧光原位杂交法检测所构建的异种克隆胚核遗传物质的来源,结果显示来自人体细胞。本研究表明,人一兔异种核移植构建克隆胚切实可行;体细胞的类型与核移植效率相关;供体细胞的体外培养传代对克隆胚的发育并无影响;而冷藏是一种简便有效的供体细胞准备方法;此外,用FISH方法对重构胚进行核遗传物质的鉴定切实可行。     

The analysis of chromatin remodeling and the staining for DNA methylation and histone acetylation do not provide definitive indicators of the developmental ability of inter-species cloned embryos

The restricted supply of oocytes in the domestic dog limits the development of reproductive biotechnologies in this species. Inter-species somatic cell nuclear transfer could be an alternative for cloning animals whose oocytes are difficult to obtain. In this study, the possibility of cloning dog embryos using pig oocytes was investigated by evaluating nuclear remodeling. Chromatin remodeling, assessed by premature chromosome condensation, pseudo-pronuclei formation, DNA methylation and histone acetylation, along with the developmental ability was compared between intra- and inter-species cloned embryos. The incidence of premature chromosome condensation was significantly higher in intra-species cloned embryos relative to inter-species cloned embryos (87.2% vs. 61.7%; P<0.05), but comparable pseudo-pronuclei formation was observed in both (85.3% vs. 75.8%). None of the inter-species cloned embryos developed beyond the 8-cell stage while 18.3% of intra-species cloned embryos developed to the blastocyst stage. The relative level of both DNA methylation and histone acetylation was similar between intra- and inter-species cloned embryos at all times examined. These results suggest that although partial chromatin remodeling occurs, further investigation is needed to be able to use pig oocytes as recipient oocytes in dog cloning.     

Cloned mice from fetal fibroblast cells arrested at metaphase by a serial nuclear transfer

Cloning using G(0)-arrested somatic cells has led to the suggestion that this stage of the cell cycle is necessary for the success of cloning. In this study we report that cloned mice can be generated from fetal fibroblasts arrested at metaphase of the cell cycle. The procedure involves fusing a metaphase-arrested fetal fibroblast to an enucleated oocyte. After parthenogenetic activation a polar body and single diploid pronucleus were formed. Some of these were allowed to develop to the blastocyst stage, while others were enucleated and the nucleus was transferred to an enucleated fertilized 1-cell embryo. After the single transfer technique, 2 out of 164 developed to late stages of gestation were dead with gross abnormalities. However, after the serial nuclear transfer, 5 out of 272 embryos were recovered live at Day 19.5, and 2 of these went on to develop into apparently normal adults. All of the cloned embryos showed severe placental hypertrophy and defective differentiation of placental tissues. This study illustrates that reprogramming can occur after nuclear transfer at metaphase of the cell cycle.     

Dogs cloned from fetal fibroblasts by nuclear transfer

Fetal fibroblasts have been considered as the prime candidate donor cells for the canine reproductive cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) in regard to the future production of transgenic dogs, mainly due to their higher developmental competence and handling advantage in gene targeting. In this study, the cloning efficiency with canine fetal fibroblasts as donor cells was determined. A total of 50 presumptive cloned embryos were reconstructed, activated and transferred into the oviducts of naturally synchronous recipient bitches. While the fusion rate (76.9%) was similar to those of our earlier studies with adult fibroblasts as donor cells (73.9–77.1%), a high cloning efficiency (4.0%; 2 births/50 embryos transferred) was found compared to the previous success rate with adult fibroblasts (0.2–1.8%). The cloned beagles were healthy and genotypically identical to the donor fibroblast cells. This study shows that a fetal fibroblast cell would be an excellent donor for future production of transgenic dogs via gene targeting in this cell followed cloning using SCNT technology.     

Production of a cloned mouse by nuclear transfer from a fetal fibroblast cell of a mouse closed colony strain.

We have tested a closed colony mouse strain as a source for nuclei donors to determine differences in cloning efficiency. When donor nuclei were isolated from fetal fibroblast cells and injected into recipient oocytes from closed colony mice (ICR), reconstructed oocytes developed to full term and the success rate of cloning was 0.1%. This result indicates that cloning efficiency does not depend on the cell type. The body weight of the cloned mouse was lighter than controls, and the lifetime of the cloned mouse was the average for a mouse. These results contradict commonly-held views on cloning.     

我国体细胞克隆牛的研究进展

近年来,由于体细胞克隆技术在畜牧业生产、疾病治疗、生物学基础理论研究及濒危动物保护等诸多领域所蕴藏的巨大应用价值,克隆效率成为科学界研究的热点问题。本文对克隆技术的相关影响因素进行了综述,研究表明,不同细胞系影响到体细胞克隆牛效率,胎儿细胞和颗粒细胞重构胚的囊胚发育率、犊牛成活率比成年成纤维细胞高。关于卵母细胞和克隆胚胎冷冻保存的研究表明,玻璃化冷冻法可以用于克隆胚胎以及卵母细胞的冷冻保存。在此基础上,讨论了国际上哺乳动物体细胞克隆研究新进展和体细胞克隆的效率,指出体细胞克隆中亟待解决的问题。     

Cloning of endangered mammalian species: any progress?

Attempts through somatic cell nuclear transfer to expand wild populations that have shrunk to critical numbers is a logical extension of the successful cloning of mammals. However, although the first mammal was cloned 10 years ago, nuclear reprogramming remains phenomenological, with abnormal gene expression and epigenetic deregulation being associated with the cloning process. In addition, although cloning of wild animals using host oocytes from different species has been successful, little is known about the implication of partial or total mitochondrial DNA heteroplasmy in cloned embryos, fetuses and offspring. Finally, there is a need for suitable foster mothers for inter-intra specific cloned embryos. Considering these issues, the limited success achieved in cloning endangered animals is not surprising. However, optimism comes from the rapid gain in the understanding of the molecular clues underlying nuclear reprogramming. If it is possible to achieve a controlled reversal of the differentiated state of a cell then it is probable that other issues that impair the cloning of endangered animals, such as the inter-intra species oocyte or womb donor, will be overcome in the medium term.     

Experimental cloning of embryos through human-rabbit inter-species nuclear transfer

Therapeutic cloning,which is based on human somatic cell nuclear transfer,is one of our major research objectives.Though inter-species nuclear transfer has been introduced to construct human somatic cell cloned embryos,the effects of type,passage,and preparation method of donor cells on embryo development remain unclear.In our experiment,cloned embryos were reconstructed with different passage and preparation methods of ossocartilaginous cell,skin fibroblast,and cumulus cells.The cumulus cell embryos showed significantly higher development rates than the other two (P＜0.05).The development rate of embryos reconstructed with skin fibroblasts of different passage number and somatic cells of different chilling durations showed no significant difference.Also,fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH)was conducted to detect nuclear derivation of the embryos.The result showed that the nuclei of the inter-species cloned embryo cells came from human.We conclude that (1)cloned embryos can be constructed through human-rabbit interspecies nuclear transfer;(2)different kinds of somatic cells result in different efficiency of nuclear transfer,while in vitro passage of the donor does not influence embryo development;(3)refrigeration is a convenient and efficient donor cell preparation method.Finally,it is feasible to detect DNA gcnotype through FISH.     

Clinical,hormonal, and hematologic characteristics of bovine calves derived from nuclei from somatic cells

Although healthy animals are born after nuclear transfer with somatic cells nuclei, the success of this procedure is generally poor (2%-10%) with high perinatal losses. Apparently normal surviving animals may have undiagnosed pathologies that could develop later in life. The gross pathology of 16 abnormal bovine fetuses produced by nuclear transfer (NT) and the clinical, endocrinologic (insulin-like growth factors I and II [IGF-I and IGF-II], IGF binding proteins, post-ACTH stimulation cortisol, leptin, glucose, and insulin levels), and biochemical characteristics of a group of 21 apparently normal cloned calves were compared with those of in vitro-produced (IVP) controls and controls resulting from artificial insemination. Oocytes used for NT or IVP were matured in vitro. NT to enucleated oocytes was performed using cultured adult or fetal skin cells. After culture, Day 7, grade 1-2 embryos were transferred (one per recipient). All placentas and fetuses from clones undergoing an abnormal pregnancy showed some degree of edema due to hydrops. Mean placentome number was lower and mean placentome weight was higher in clones than in controls (69.9 +/- 9.2 placentomes with a mean weight of 144.3 +/- 21.4 g in clones vs. 99 and 137 placentomes with a mean individual weight of 34.8 and 32.4 g in two IVP controls). Erythrocyte mean cell volume was higher at birth (P < 0.01), and body temperature and plasma leptin concentrations were higher and T4 levels were lower during the first 50 days and the first week (P < 0.05), respectively, in clones. Plasma IGF-II concentrations were higher at birth and lower at Day 15 in clones (P < 0.05). Therefore, apparently healthy cloned calves cannot be considered as physiologically normal animals until at least 50 days of age.     

Irreversible barrier to the reprogramming of donor cells in cloning with mouse embryos and embryonic stem cells

Somatic cloning does not always result in ontogeny in mammals, and development is often associated with various abnormalities and embryo loss with a high frequency. This is considered to be due to aberrant gene expression resulting from epigenetic reprogramming errors. However, a fundamental question in this context is whether the developmental abnormalities reported to date are specific to somatic cloning. The aim of this study was to determine the stage of nuclear differentiation during development that leads to developmental abnormalities associated with embryo cloning. In order to address this issue, we reconstructed cloned embryos using four- and eight-cell embryos, morula embryos, inner cell mass (ICM) cells, and embryonic stem cells as donor nuclei and determined the occurrence of abnormalities such as developmental arrest and placentomegaly, which are common characteristics of all mouse somatic cell clones. The present analysis revealed that an acute decline in the full-term developmental competence of cloned embryos occurred with the use of four- and eight-cell donor nuclei (22.7% vs. 1.8%) in cases of standard embryo cloning and with morula and ICM donor nuclei (11.4% vs. 6.6%) in serial nuclear transfer. Histological observation showed abnormal differentiation and proliferation of trophoblastic giant cells in the placentae of cloned concepti derived from four-cell to ICM cell donor nuclei. Enlargement of placenta along with excessive proliferation of the spongiotrophoblast layer and glycogen cells was observed in the clones derived from morula embryos and ICM cells. These results revealed that irreversible epigenetic events had already started to occur at the four-cell stage. In addition, the expression of genes involved in placentomegaly is regulated at the blastocyst stage by irreversible epigenetic events, and it could not be reprogrammed by the fusion of nuclei with unfertilized oocytes. Hence, developmental abnormalities such as placentomegaly as well as embryo loss during development may occur even in cloned embryos reconstructed with nuclei from preimplantation-stage embryos, and these abnormalities are not specific to somatic cloning.     

Production of Prnp −/− goats by gene targeting in adult fibroblasts

Homozygous mice devoid of functional Prnp are resistant to scrapie and prion propagation, but heterozygous mice for Prnp disruption still suffer from prion disease and prion deposition. We have previously generated heterozygous cloned goats with one allele of Prnp functional disruption. To obtain goats with both alleles of Prnp be disrupted which would be resistant to scrapie completely, a second-round gene targeting was applied to disrupt the wild type allele of Prnp in the heterozygous goats. By second-round gene targeting, we successfully disrupted the wild type allele of Prnp in primary Prnp (+/-) goat skin fibroblasts and obtained a Prnp (-/-) cell line without Prnp expression. This is the first report on successful targeting modification in primary adult somatic cells of animals. These cells were used as nuclear donors for somatic cell cloning to produce Prnp (-/-) goats. A total of 57 morulae or blastocytes developed from the reconstructed embryos were transferred to 31 recipients, which produced 7 pregnancies at day 35. At 73 days of gestation, we obtained one cloned fetus with Prnp (-/-) genotype. Our research not only indicated that multiple genetic modifications could be accomplished by multi-round gene targeting in primary somatic cells, but also provided strong evidence that gene targeting in adult cells other than fetal cells could be applied to introduce precise genetic modifications in animals without destroying the embryos.