Effects of BCL-2 overexpression on the sensitivity of MCF-7 breast cancer cells to ricin, diphtheria and Pseudomonas toxin and immunotoxins

Immunotoxins are presently being evaluated as novel agents for cancer therapy. The direct mechanism by which immunotoxins kill cancer cells is inhibition of protein synthesis, but cytotoxicity due to induction of apoptosis has also been observed with these agents. Some cancers that express high levels of BCL-2 are relatively resistant to apoptosis inducing agents. It is therefore important to determine to what degree the toxicity of ricin, diphtheria toxin, Pseudomonas exotoxin and Pseudomonas exotoxin derived immunotoxins towards cancer cells can be attributed to inhibition of protein synthesis, and to what degree to subsequent induction of apoptosis. We compared the sensitivity of MCF-7 breast cancer cells that were stably transfected with a BCL-2 expression plasmid and thus protected against apoptosis and of MCF-7 cells transfected with a control plasmid towards ricin, diphtheria and Pseudomonas toxin, a Pseudomonas toxin-derived immunotoxin (LMB-7) and tumour necrosis factor (TNF). We found that BCL-2 mediated inhibition of apoptosis renders the cells almost completely resistant (1000-fold) to tumour necrosis factor, but the same cells were only 3–10 fold more resistant to cytotoxicity induced by immunotoxin LMB-7 as well as Pseudo-monas exotoxin, diphtheria toxin and ricin. We next studied several leukaemia cell lines with variable levels of BCL-2 expression and found them quite sensitive to a Pseudomonas exotoxin containing immunotoxin independent of the level of BCL-2. Our data indicate that although BCL-2 overexpression can have a modest effect on sensitivity to an immunotoxin, cell lines derived from patients are still very sensitive to immunotoxins.     

Enhancement of diphtheria toxin-induced apoptosis in Vero cells by combination treatment with brefeldin A and okadaic acid

In the present study, we compared the abilities of ricin and diphtheria toxin to induce apoptosis in Vero cells. The cytolysis and DNA fragmentation by ricin paralleled its protein synthesis inhibitory activity. However, unlike ricin, diphtheria toxin could induce neither cytolysis nor DNA fragmentation in Vero cells up to very high concentration, in spite of the fact that Vero cells were even more sensitive to protein synthesis inhibition by diphtheria toxin than ricin. Interestingly, coexistence of brefeldin A (BFA) and okadaic acid (OA) significantly enhanced diphtheria toxin-mediated cytolysis and DNA fragmentation without affecting the activity of protein synthesis inhibition. Ammonium chloride almost completely abolished the ability of diphtheria toxin to induce apoptosis in the presence of BFA and OA as well as the protein synthesis inhibitory activity. The mutant CRM 197, which does not catalyze the ADP ribosylation of elongation factor-2 (EF-2), failed to induce apoptosis in Vero cells even in the presence of BFA and OA. Thus, translocation of diphtheria toxin into the cytosol and subsequent enzymatic inactivation of EF-2 may be necessary steps to induce apoptosis. Taken together our results suggest that protein synthesis inhibition by toxins is not sufficient to induce apoptosis, and underlying mechanisms of apoptosis induction may be distinct between ricin and diphtheria toxin. Since a morphological change in the Golgi complex was observed in Vero cells treated with BFA and OA, modulation of the Golgi complex by these reagents may be partly responsible for enhanced apoptosis induction by diphtheria toxin.     

Quantitative analysis of protein synthesis inhibition and recovery in CRM107 immunotoxin-treated HeLa cells

Previously a mathematical model was proposed that quantitatively related protein synthesis inhibition kinetics of antitransferrin receptor-gelonin immunotoxins to the cellular trafficking of the targeting agent. That work is here extended to describe protein synthesis inhibition kinetics of immunotoxins containing the diphtheria toxin mutant CRM107. CRM107 differs from gelonin in both translocation and ribosomal inactivation mechanisms. Targeting agents used were antitransferrin monoclonal antibodies 5E9 and OKT9, OKT9Fab, and transferrin. CRM107 conjugates inhibited protein synthesis at substantially lower concentrations than gelonin conjugates; this effect was attributed to substantially higher translocation rates for CRM107. However, under certain conditions, CRM107 immunotoxin-treated cells were able to recover completely; this behavior was never observed with gelonin immunotoxins. To quantitatively capture this phenomenon, extracellular and cytosolic degradation of the toxin as well as growth-related recovery from toxin-induced damage were incorporated into the mathematical model. Translocation and cytosolic degradation rate constants were determined for each immunotoxin. Unlike the gelonin conjugates, the translocation rate of CRM107 conjugates depended on the targeting molecule. This provided indirect evidence that CRM107 remains disulfide linked to the targeting agent for at least part of the translocation process. Although the CRM107 conjugates all had higher translocation rates and inhibited protein synthesis at lower concentrations than the gelonin conjugates, the cells' ability to recover from protein synthesis inhibition at low immunotoxin concentrations limits the utility of CRM107 conjugates for targeted cell killing.     

Diphtheria toxin entry into cells is facilitated by low pH

At neutral pH, NH4Cl and chloroquine protected cells against diphtheria toxin. A brief exposure of the cells to low pH (4.5-5.5) at 37 degrees completely abolished this protection. When, to cells preincubated with diphtheria toxin and NH4Cl, neutralizing amounts of anti-diphtheria toxin were added before the pH was lowered, the toxic effect was considerably reduced, but it was not completely abolished. A much stronger toxic effect was seen when antibodies were added immediately after incubation at low pH. Upon a short incubation with diphtheria toxin at low pH, the rate of protein synthesis in the cells decreased much faster than when the normal pH was maintained. The data suggest that, at low pH, diphtheria toxin (or its A fragment) penetrates directly through the surface membrane of the cell. The possibility is discussed that, when the medium has a neutral pH, the entry of diphtheria toxin involves adsorptive endocytosis and reduction of the pH in the vesicles possibly by fusion with lysosomes. Low pH did not facilitate the entry of the closely related toxins abrin, ricin, and modeccin.     

Kinetic comparison of ricin immunotoxins: biricin conjugate has potentiated cytotoxicity

The plant toxin ricin was chemically coupled to an anti-Thy-1.1 antibody, and the resultant conjugates were fractionated by gel filtration. The cytotoxicity of the conjugate possessing two ricin molecules per immunoglobulin, yielding a first-order inactivation rate of protein synthesis of -0.4 log/h at 200 ng/mL, was well above that expected just from the increase in ricin per unit mass of conjugate, when compared to a conjugate possessing only one ricin per immunoglobulin. On a conjugate molar scale the biricin immunotoxin was determined to be 8 times more potent than the monoricin conjugate; thus, relative to the number of ricin molecules, the coupling of a second ricin to the immunoglobulin quadrupled the observed potency. The concentration of immunotoxin and the resultant inactivation rates of protein synthesis were found to be related through a power function. Additionally, the inactivation kinetics of these conjugates were found to be similar to those of native ricin.     

白喉毒素类免疫毒素研究进展

白喉毒素类免疫毒素是将缺失天然受体结合活性的白喉毒素片段或突变体与抗体或细胞因子偶联而得到的一类新型导向药物,它可特异性识别并结合靶细胞,通过发挥其ADP核糖基化活性而抑制细胞蛋白合成,引发细胞凋亡。由于白喉毒素类免疫毒素能高效、特异地杀伤特定靶细胞,而使其在肿瘤等疾病的药物开发中暂露头角。综述了基于白喉毒素的免疫毒素的研制现状与应用前景 。     

Dual effects of the ricin A chain on protein synthesis in rabbit reticulocyte lysate. Inhibition of initiation and translocation

Ricin A chain caused inhibition of protein synthesis by reticulocyte lysate with concomitant depurination of 28S rRNA. The partial reaction(s) of protein synthesis inhibited was investigated by following the appearance of [35S]methionine from initiator [35S]Met-tRNA into 40S ribosomal subunits, 80S monosomes and polysomes. Ricin A chain caused an accumulation of [35S]Met in monosomes which did not enter polysomes. In these respects the effects of the ricin A chain resembled those of diphtheria toxin, an inhibitor of elongation-factor-2-catalyzed translocation. This is consistent with the previously proposed site of action of ricin as an inhibitor of elongation. However, the inhibitory effects of the ricin A chain and diphtheria toxin are not equivalent because we observed that the rate of formation of the 80S initiation complex was reduced approximately sixfold with the ricin A chain relative to diphtheria toxin. Analysis of methionine-containing peptides bound to 80S monosomes in ricin-A-chain-inhibited and diphtheria-toxin-inhibited lysates, programmed with globin mRNA, revealed a predominance of Met-Val, suggesting that the elongation cycle is inhibited at the translocation step. Translocation was also implicated as the step blocked in both the ricin-A-chain-inhibited and diphtheria-toxin-inhibited lysates, by the finding that nascent peptide chains were unreactive towards puromycin. It is concluded that ricin-A-chain-modified ribosomes are deficient in two protein synthesis partial reactions: the formation of the 80S initiation complex during initiation and the translocation step of the elongation cycle.     

Comparison of the apoptosis-inducing abilities of various protein synthesis inhibitors in U937 cells

We compared the abilities of ricin, diphtheria toxin, cycloheximide, and anisomycin to induce apoptosis, using human myeloid leukemia U937 cells at the concentration of each toxin at which almost complete protein synthesis inhibition was attained within 3 h. Among these toxins, anisomycin was found to be the most potent apoptosis inducer. After a 6-h exposure to anisomycin (1 microg/ml), nearly 95% of the cells had apoptotic nuclear morphological changes, while 53%, 30%, and 10% of the cells showed apoptotic changes after exposure to ricin (0.1 microg/ml), diphtheria toxin (10 microg/ml), and cycloheximide (10 microg/ml), respectively. Furthermore, a rapid increase in caspase-3-like activity was observed in anisomycin-treated cells. A similar increase in caspase-3-like activity was also observed in ricin-treated cells on a slower time schedule. However, only a slight increase in the protease activity was induced by diphtheria toxin or cycloheximide even after 6 h of incubation. Since both ricin and anisomycin are known to act on 28S ribosomal RNA, our results suggest that this action mechanism may be responsible for their potent apoptosis induction, and protein synthesis inhibition alone is not sufficient to induce apoptosis.     

The Different Behavior of Diphtheria Toxin, Modeccin and Ricin in HeLa Cells Infected with Trypanosoma cruzi

ABSTRACT. We have studied the action of diphtheria toxin, modeccin and ricin on HeLa cells infected by Trypanosoma cruzi . Parasitized HeLa cells were resistant to diphtheria toxin and modeccin, whereas non-parasitized cells from the same cultures and control cultures showed cytopathological alterations. Protein synthesis, assayed by the incorporation of labelled methionine, diminished in toxin-treated control cultures but remained unaltered in the infected ones, compared to synthesis by untreated infected cells. Ricin, on the other hand, is a toxin that enters the cytoplasm by endocytosis. It has greater cytopathological effects in parasitized cells than in non-parasitized ones from the same cultures or uninfected control cells. Protein synthesis was inhibited in infected cultures treated with ricin.     

Entry of lethal doses of abrin, ricin and modeccin into the cytosol of HeLa cells

In attempts to assess how many molecules of the toxic lectins abrin, ricin and modeccin are needed in the cytosol to kill HeLa cells the effect of these toxins on protein synthesis and plating efficiency was studied. The incubation time of the cells after a 1 h exposure to the toxins influenced strongly the extent of inhibition of protein synthesis. The full toxic effect was expressed about 20 h of incubation after the exposure. On further incubation, protein synthesis again increased at a rate comparable to that in the control cells. After exposure to increasing concentrations of toxins the inhibition of cellular protein synthesis measured after 20 h showed excellent agreement with the inhibition of plating efficiency, indicating that the inhibition of protein synthesis can be used as a measure of cell killing. The inhibition of protein synthesis by toxins was found to follow first order kinetics, indicating that the cells are killed by an all- or none-effect. Autoradiographic studies indicated that after exposure to intermediate toxin concentrations protein synthesis was completely abolished in some cells, whereas it appeared to proceed at a normal rate in the remaining cells. The results provide evidence that penetration of one molecule of abrin, ricin or modeccin into cytosol is lethal to HeLa cells and that the efficiency of toxin entry into the cytoplasm is very low compared to the rate of bulk toxin uptake.     

Enhancement of cytotoxicities of ricin and Pseudomonas toxin in Chinese hamster ovary cells by nigericin.

Nigericin and monensin, ionophores for Na+ and K+, have been found to enhance the cytotoxicities of abrin, ricin, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa exotoxin A in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. They do not affect the cytotoxicity of diphtheria toxin in the same cell line. Maximal sensitization of the CHO cells toward ricin and Pseudomonas toxin requires preculture of CHO cells in the presence of nigericin. Inhibition of protein synthesis in CHO cells by ricin or Pseudomonas toxin is also enhanced by preculture of CHO cells in the presence of nigericin. These results suggest a common step in the intoxication process of ricin and Pseudomonas toxin, the rate of which is facilitated by pretreatment with nigericin. This step is, however, not shared by the intoxication of CHO cells with diphtheria toxin.     

Specific killing of lymphocytes that cause experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis by ricin toxin-acetylcholine receptor conjugates

Experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis (EAMG) is an autoimmune disease in which antibodies to acetylcholine receptor (AChR) cause loss of AChR from muscle, thereby impairing neuromuscular transmission. Here we report the use of a hybrid molecule that contains ricin toxin, irreversibly coupled to AChR to specifically suppress the immune response to AChR in vitro. Lymph node cell cultures from rats with EAMG pretreated with ricin toxin-AChR conjugates exhibited suppressed T helper cell proliferation and B cell antibody synthesis in response to the subsequent addition of AChR. Nonspecific toxicity of the conjugates was measured by suppression of the T cell proliferative response to the mitogen concanavalin A and the antigen keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH), and B cell antibody production to KLH. We have evaluated different pretreatment conditions and ricin toxin covalently coupled to AChR in different molar ratios to optimize specific immunosuppression. By varying the number of ricin molecules covalently bound to AChR in the immunotoxin, we were able to minimize the nonspecific toxicity while still maintaining specific killing of AChR-reactive lymphocytes. Furthermore, B cells were more susceptible to specific killing than were the T cells. The specific immunosuppression was potentiated by performing the pretreatment with immunotoxin in the presence of chloroquine. Chloroquine raises lysosomal pH and probably delays the degradation of immunotoxin in the cell. It should be noted that ricin toxin was covalently coupled to AChR by using a novel, non-reducible reaction. These in vitro results suggest that it may be feasible to use immunotoxin molecules to specifically suppress this autoimmune response in vivo.     

Cellular processing of a ricin-antibody conjugate. A kinetic analysis of the rate-limiting step

Upon exposure to holoricin-antibody conjugates, target cells display a period of no measurable intoxication followed by a concentration-dependent exponential decline in protein synthesis. The rate of this decline is increased by conjugate structural variables such as addition of a second ricin to the antibody or introduction of a peptide spacer between the toxin and antibody. Additionally, the rate is enhanced by the addition of ammonia or monensin. The relationship between immunotoxin concentration and the rate of protein synthesis inhibition is shown to obey typical Michaelis-Menten kinetics. By displacing bound immunotoxin with native antibody, it was demonstrated that the rate-limiting saturable process is not due to antibody-surface antigen interaction. Although addition of a second ricin as well as addition of ammonia elevated the measured rate of protein synthesis inhibition, curve-fitting techniques indicated that they did not elevate the maximal rate; however, introduction of a peptide spacer into the conjugate or addition of monensin increased the maximal rate of this saturable process. Additionally, the kinetic examination of the potentiation effects of ammonia and monensin indicates that they operate on different cellular processes involved with the intracellular routing toward intoxication. An equational model is developed which helps interpret the known features of the conjugate intoxication process.     

Receptor-mediated transport of the hybrid protein ricin-diphtheria toxin fragment A with subsequent ADP-ribosylation of intracellular elongation factor II.

A hybrid protein of ricin and the enzymatically active fragment A of diphtheria toxin (toxin A) has been synthesized and purified. The diphtheria toxin A fragment of the hybrid protein is shown to enter the cytosol compartment of HeLa cells, its presence assayed by the fall of intracellular elongation factor II (EF-2) and the rise of ADP-ribosylated EF-2. Hybrid entrance to HeLa cells is blocked by lactose which blocks receptor-mediated entry of ricin but not by NH4Cl which blocks the transport of diphtheria toxin. It is concluded that the diphtheria toxin fragment A moiety of the hybrid enters the cell cytosol via the ricin receptor-mediated transport system. The kinetics of intracellular ADP-ribosylation of EF-2 by diphtheria toxin have also been studied. Ribosylation is preceded by a toxin dose-dependent lag period. The data suggest that the time constant responsible for the lag period is in the transport step. Models consistent with these data are discussed.     

Enzyme treatment of KB cells: the altered effect of diphtheria toxin

Treatment of KB cells with trypsin, phospholipase C and pronase at concentrations which did not affect viability or rate of incorporation of amino acids into protein lowered significantly the inhibition of protein synthesis by diphtheria toxin. Chymotrypsin was effective but only at concentrations toxic to the cells. Lipase and neuraminidase had no effect. It is evident that enzyme-sensitive cell surface components with specificity for diphtheria toxin are present on the KB cell.     

Antibody-mediated routing of diphtheria toxin in murine cells results in a highly efficacious immunotoxin

The chemical coupling of diphtheria toxin to an antimurine Thy1 antibody resulted in the most efficacious immunotoxin to date. At 1 micrograms/ml the immunotoxin inhibited protein synthesis of a Thy+ AKR murine cell at a rate of 1.4 logs/h, within the order of magnitude of the efficacy of native toxins. This is unusual since murine cells are highly resistant to diphtheria toxin. The conjugate is highly specific; Thy- AKR cells display no intoxication at 1 microgram/ml even after 18 h. The effects of ammonia, acid pulsing of external media, and low temperature reveal some similarities and some differences between intoxication of sensitive cells by toxin and of murine cells by the antibody-toxin conjugate. The differences that result in the high efficacy of the antibody-toxin conjugate appear to result from the antibody-mediated routing. These results imply that murine cells possess an acidic compartment which can mediate toxin cytosolic entry. Unlike the Thy antigen, the toxin receptor on murine cells is unable to route the toxin to this cellular site.     

Active target cell processes, possibly involving receptor-mediated endocytosis, are critical for expression of cytotoxicity by natural killer cell-derived cytolytic factor

Inhibitors of energy metabolism, 2-deoxyglucose and cyanide were shown to inhibit NKCF-mediated lysis of L929 target cells at the same molar concentrations that effectively inhibited cellular ATP levels and the toxic effects of pseudomonas toxin A. In addition, inhibitors of receptor-mediated endocytosis, cytochalasin B, a microtubule disrupter, and trifluoperazine, an inhibitor of clathrin-coat formation, inhibited NKCF-mediated lysis and expression of pseudomonas toxin activity, but had little effect upon cellular ATP. Lysomotropic agents chloroquine, ammonium chloride, and dansylcadavarine also inhibited both NKCF-mediated lysis and pseudomonas toxin activity. These results are similar to those involving diphtheria toxin and the plant toxins abrin, modeccin, and ricin, whose mode of action involves inhibition of protein synthesis following receptor-mediated endocytosis. However, it was determined that NKCF did not cause a decrease in the rate of protein synthesis up to the time of cell death. These results suggest that active target cell processes (possibly involving receptor-mediated endocytosis of NKCF) must occur for target cell lysis to be completed.     

重组蓖麻毒素A链与几种天然单链核糖体失活蛋白的活性研究

采用ｐＥｘＳｅｃⅠ载体系统进行了蓖麻毒素Ａ链的原核表达,经ＣＭ－Ｓｅｐｈａｒｏｓｅ一步纯化后,获得了纯度约８０％的重组蓖麻毒素Ａ链．将其与几种天然单链核糖体失活蛋白进行了超螺旋ＤＮＡ裂解研究和无细胞体系中蛋白合成抑制试验,结果表明,重组蓖麻毒素Ａ链具有类似于天然单链核糖体失活蛋白的活性,但两种测活方法之间没有明显的相关性     

Depletion of intracellular NAD(+) and ATP levels during ricin-induced apoptosis through the specific ribosomal inactivation results in the cytolysis of U937 cells

Our previous studies demonstrated that ricin induces the apoptotic death of U937 cells as evidenced by DNA fragmentation, nuclear morphological changes, and increases in caspase-like activities. In this study, we have found that intracellular NAD(+) and ATP levels decrease in ricin-treated U937 cells and that this decrease is followed by the ricin-mediated protein synthesis inhibition. The PARP inhibitor, 3-aminobenzamide (3-ABA), prevents the depletion in NAD(+) and ATP levels and concomitantly protects U937 cells from the lysis that follows ricin treatment. Hence, the protective action of 3-ABA is due to the inhibition of PARP and does not result from its other pharmacological side effects. Moreover, the enzymatic activity of PARP gradually increases and reaches a maximum level after ricin exposure for 3 h, whereas no significant change in activity was observed in untreated cells. However, 3-ABA has no effect on ricin-mediated DNA fragmentation. In addition, immunoblot analysis revealed that significant PARP cleavage occurred more than 12 h after ricin addition, while DNA fragmentation reached a maximum level within 6 h of incubation. Thus, in the case of ricin-induced apoptosis, it appears that PARP cleavage is not an early apoptotic event associated with the onset of apoptosis. Our results suggest that multiple apoptotic signaling pathways may be triggered by ricin-treatment. Probably, the pathway leading to cell lysis via PARP activation and NAD(+) depletion is independent of the pathway leading to DNA fragmentation in which caspases may be profoundly involved. Other protein synthesis inhibitors, including diphtheria toxin and cycloheximide, were less effective in terms of inducing DNA fragmentation and cytolysis, even at concentrations that cause significant inhibition of protein synthesis. Thus, a specific ricin action mechanism through which ribosomes are inactivated may be responsible for the apoptotic events induced by ricin.     

Entry of diphtheria toxin into cells: possible existence of cellular factor(s) for entry of diphtheria toxin into cells was studied in somatic cell hybrids and hybrid toxins

Ehrlich ascites tumor cells were found to be very insensitive to diphtheria toxin. We formed 37 hybrids from Ehrlich tumor cells and diphtheria toxin-sensitive human fibroblasts. The effects of diphtheria toxin on protein synthesis in those hybrids were examined. The hybrids were divided into three groups on the basis of toxin sensitivity. Group A hybrids were as sensitive to diphtheria toxin as human fibroblasts, Group C were as resistant as Ehrlich tumor cells, and Group B had intermediate sensitivity. Group A hybrids had diphtheria toxin-binding sites but Group B and C had no detectable binding sites. Elongation factor-2 of all the hybrids was susceptible to ADP-ribosylation by fragment A of diphtheria toxin. Cells of Group A and B became more sensitive to CRM 45 (cross-reacting material 45 of diphtheria toxin) after they were exposed to low pH (pH = 4.5). The resistance of Group C to CRM 45 was not affected by the same treatment. Group A and B hybrids and human fibroblasts had similar sensitivities to a hybrid toxin composed of wheat germ agglutinin and fragment A of diphtheria toxin, but Group C and Ehrlich tumor cells were resistant to this hybrid toxin. All the hybrids and Ehrlich tumor cells were more sensitive to a hybrid toxin composed of wheat germ agglutinin and subunit A of ricin than were human fibroblasts. On subcloning of Group B hybrids, one Group C hybrid was obtained, but no Group A hybrid. These facts suggest that Ehrlich ascites tumor cells differ from human fibroblasts in the expression of a factor(s) that is involved in entry of fragment A of diphtheria toxin into the cytoplasm after the toxin binds to its surface receptors.