Stable Isotopes and Carbon Cycle Processes in Forests and Grasslands

Abstract: Scaling and partitioning are frequently two difficult challenges facing ecology today. With regard to ecosystem carbon balance studies, ecologists and atmospheric scientists are often interested in asking how fluxes of carbon dioxide scale across the landscape, region and continent. Yet at the same time, physiological ecologists and ecosystem ecologists are interested in dissecting the net ecosystem CO₂ exchange between the biosphere and the atmosphere to achieve a better understanding of the balance between photosynthesis and respiration within a forest. In both of these multiple-scale ecological questions, stable isotope analyses of carbon dioxide can play a central role in influencing our understanding of the extent to which terrestrial ecosystems are carbon sinks. In this synthesis, we review the theory and present field evidence to address isotopic scaling of CO₂ fluxes. We first show that the ¹³C isotopic signal which ecosystems impart to the atmosphere does not remain constant over time at either temporal or spatial scales. The relative balances of different biological activities and plant responses to stress result in dynamic changes in the ¹³C isotopic exchange between the biosphere and atmosphere, with both seasonal and stand-age factors playing major roles influencing the ¹³C biosphere-atmosphere exchange. We then examine how stable isotopes are used to partition net ecosystem exchange fluxes in order to calculate shifts in the balance of photosynthesis and respiration. Lastly, we explore how fundamental differences in the ¹⁸O isotopic gas exchange of forest and grassland ecosystems can be used to further partition terrestrial fluxes.     

Modelling environmental controls on ecosystem photosynthesis and the carbon isotope composition of ecosystem-respired CO2 in a coastal Douglas-fir forest

We developed and applied an ecosystem-scale model that calculated leaf CO₂ assimilation, stomatal conductance, chloroplast CO₂ concentration and the carbon isotope composition of carbohydrate formed during photosynthesis separately for sunlit and shaded leaves within multiple canopy layers. The ecosystem photosynthesis model was validated by comparison to leaf-level gas exchange measurements and estimates of ecosystem-scale photosynthesis from eddy covariance measurements made in a coastal Douglas-fir forest on Vancouver Island. A good agreement was also observed between modelled and measured δ ¹³C values of ecosystem-respired CO₂ ( δ _R). The modelled δ _R values showed strong responses to variation in photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD), air temperature, vapour pressure deficit (VPD) and available soil moisture in a manner consistent with leaf-level studies of photosynthetic ¹³C discrimination. Sensitivity tests were conducted to evaluate the effect of (1) changes in the lag between the time of CO₂ fixation and the conversion of organic matter back to CO₂; (2) shifts in the proportion of autotrophic and heterotrophic respiration; (3) isotope fractionation during respiration; and (4) environmentally induced changes in mesophyll conductance, on modelled δ _R values. Our results indicated that δ _R is a good proxy for canopy-level C _c/ C _a and ¹³C discrimination during photosynthetic gas exchange, and therefore has several applications in ecosystem physiology.     

The underestimated importance of belowground carbon input for forest soil animal food webs

The present study investigated the relative importance of leaf and root carbon input for soil invertebrates. Experimental plots were established at the Swiss Canopy Crane (SCC) site where the forest canopy was enriched with ¹³C depleted CO₂ at a target CO₂ concentration of c . 540 p.p.m. We exchanged litter between labelled and unlabelled areas resulting in four treatments: (i) leaf litter and roots labelled, (ii) only leaf litter labelled, (iii) only roots labelled and (iv) unlabelled controls. In plots with only ¹³C-labelled roots most of the soil invertebrates studied were significantly depleted in ¹³C, e.g. earthworms, chilopods, gastropods, diplurans, collembolans, mites and isopods, indicating that these taxa predominantly obtain their carbon from belowground input. In plots with only ¹³C-labelled leaf litter only three taxa, including, e.g. juvenile Glomeris spp. (Diplopoda), were significantly depleted in ¹³C suggesting that the majority of soil invertebrates obtain its carbon from roots. This is in stark contrast to the view that decomposer food webs are based on litter input from aboveground.     

Diurnal and seasonal variation in the carbon isotope composition of leaf dark-respired CO2 in velvet mesquite (Prosopis velutina)

We evaluated diurnal and seasonal patterns of carbon isotope composition of leaf dark-respired CO₂ ( δ ¹³C_l) in the C₃ perennial shrub velvet mesquite ( Prosopis velutina ) across flood plain and upland savanna ecosystems in the south-western USA. δ ¹³C_l of darkened leaves increased to maximum values late during daytime periods and declined gradually over night-time periods to minimum values at pre-dawn. The magnitude of the diurnal shift in δ ¹³C_l was strongly influenced by seasonal and habitat-related differences in soil water availability and leaf surface vapour pressure deficit. δ ¹³C_l and the cumulative flux-weighted δ ¹³C value of photosynthates were positively correlated, suggesting that progressive ¹³C enrichment of the CO₂ evolved by darkened leaves during the daytime mainly resulted from short-term changes in photosynthetic ¹³C discrimination and associated shifts in the δ ¹³C signature of primary respiratory substrates. The ¹³C enrichment of dark-respired CO₂ relative to photosynthates across habitats and seasons was 4 to 6‰ at the end of the daytime period (1800 h), but progressively declined to 0‰ by pre-dawn (0300 h). The origin of night-time and daytime variations in δ ¹³C_l is discussed in terms of the carbon source(s) feeding respiration and the drought-induced changes in carbon metabolism.     

Different carbon support for respiration and secondary production in unproductive lakes

This study investigates the allocation of allochthonous organic carbon (AlloOC) to pelagic respiration and biomass production in unproductive lakes. Metabolic process rates and stable isotopic composition (δ¹³C) of crustacean zooplankton and respired CO₂ were measured in the epilimnion of 13 forest lakes in northern Sweden. The δ¹³C of zooplankton was low (−31.2 to −38.0‰) compared to that of respired CO₂ (−28.4 to −30.6‰), implying that the relative importance of AlloOC was lower for zooplankton (ca 40%) than for respiration (ca 80%). Combining δ¹³C and carbon flux data revealed that a large amount of metabolized AlloOC was lost in respiration, compared to the amount transferred to zooplankton (<3%). Thus, despite large respiratory losses, AlloOC was still important for zooplankton growth, implying a high supply of AlloOC in comparison to phytoplankton generated organic carbon in the lakes.     

δ 13C of CO2 respired in the dark in relation to δ13C of leaf carbohydrates in Phaseolus vulgaris L. under progressive drought

The variations in δ ¹³C in both leaf carbohydrates (starch and sucrose) and CO₂ respired in the dark from the cotyledonary leaves of Phaseolus vulgaris L. were investigated during a progressive drought. As expected, sucrose and starch became heavier (enriched in ¹³C) with decreasing stomatal conductance and decreasing p _i/ p _a during the first half (15 d) of the dehydration cycle. Thereafter, when stomata remained closed and leaf net photosynthesis was near zero, the tendency was reversed: the carbohydrates became lighter (depleted in ¹³C). This may be explained by increased p _i/ p _a but other possible explanations are also discussed. Interestingly, the variations in δ ¹³C of CO₂ respired in the dark were correlated with those of sucrose for both well-watered and dehydrated plants. A linear relationship was obtained between δ ¹³C of CO₂ respired in the dark and sucrose, respired CO₂ always being enriched in ¹³C compared with sucrose by ≈ 6‰. The whole leaf organic matter was depleted in ¹³C compared with leaf carbohydrates by at least 1‰. These results suggest that: (i) a discrimination by ≈ 6‰ occurs during dark respiration processes releasing ¹³C-enriched CO₂; and that (ii) this leads to ¹³C depletion in the remaining leaf material.     

Population differences in water-use efficiency of Eucalyptus microtheca seedlings under different watering regimes

Gas exchange, water-use efficiency (WUE), carbon isotope composition ( Δ ¹³C) and growth traits were compared among 5 populations of Eucalyptus microtheca F. Muell. Seedlings grown from seed collected across the natural distribution of the species were maintained under water-stressed and well-watered conditions. Gas exchange was measured in terms of net photosynthesis (A) and transpiration (E); WUE was measured in terms of instantaneous water-use efficiency (WUE_i) and transpiration efficiency (WUE_T); growth traits were measured in terms of total biomass (TB), root/shoot ratio (RS), and specific leaf area density (DEN). Significant differences in all traits were detected among the populations. Overall population variation was 1.68–2.50 and 1.48–2.26 μmol CO₂ uptake per mmol H₂O transpired (WUE_i), 1.97–3.04 and 1.64–2.36 g dry matter accumulation per kg water transpired (WUE_T), and Δ ¹³C was −28.81 to −26.75‰ and −30.56 to −30.04‰ under the water-stressed and well-watered conditions, respectively. In addition, WUE_i, WUE_T and Δ ¹³C were significantly correlated with A, E, RS, DEN and TB. The study indicated that measurement of WUE may be a useful trait for selecting genotypes with improved drought adaptation and biomass productivity under different environmental conditions.     

Elevated pyruvate,orthophosphate dikinase (PPDK) activity alters carbon metabolism in C3 transgenic potatoes with a C4 maize PPDK gene

Changes in carbon metabolism and δ¹³C value of transgenic potato plants with a maize pyruvate,orthophosphate dikinase (PPDK; EC 2.7.9.1) gene are reported. PPDK catalyzes the formation of phospho enol pyruvate (PEP), the initial acceptor of CO₂ in the C₄ photosynthetic pathway. PPDK activities in the leases of transgenic potatoes were up to 5.4‐fold higher than those of control potato plants (wild‐type and treated control plants). In the transgenic potato plants, PPDK activity in leaves was negatively correlated with pyruvate content (r²= 0.81), and was positively correlated with malate content (r²= 0.88). A significant increase in the δ¹³C value was observed in the transgenic potato plants, suggesting a certain contribution of PEP carboxylase as the initial acceptor of atmospheric CO₂. These data suggest that elevated PPDK activity may alter carbon metabolism and lead to a partial operation of C₄‐type carbon metabolism. However, since parameters associated with CO₂ gas exchange were not affected, the altered carbon metabolism had only a small effect on the total photosynthetic characteristics of the transgenic plants.     

A new method to measure carbon isotope composition of CO2 respired by trees: stem CO2 equilibration

1.  Applying Keeling plot techniques to derive δ¹³C of respiratory input in a closed non-equilibrated chamber can lead to large errors because steady-state diffusion rules are violated in a non-steady-state environment. To avoid these errors, respiratory δ¹³C can be derived using equilibrated closed chambers.
2.  We introduce a new method to obtain stem respired CO₂δ¹³C (δ_{st - r}) with closed equilibrated stem chambers (E-SC). We present a theoretical model describing the equilibration process, test the model against field data and find excellent agreement. The method is further tested by comparing it with closed non-equilibrated stem chambers (NE-SC); we found no difference between these methods.
3.  Our theoretical model to describe CO₂ diffusion from the respiratory pool into the chamber and the equation to derive the δ¹³C of the efflux are general. They could be applied to other ecosystem components (e.g. soils).
4.  Our method is easy to implement, cost effective, minimizes sources of error and allows for rigorous leak detection. One major limitation is its inability to detect rapid change; the equilibration process requires 15 ± 2 h. A second limitation is that it cannot be used for species that produce abundant pitch at sites of stem wounding (e.g. Pseudotsuga menziesii ).
5.  Investigating δ¹³C of CO₂ respired by different ecosystem components is necessary to interpret δ¹³C of ecosystem respiration. This parameter has major implications with respect to global carbon cycle science.     

How does the C4 grass Eragrostis pilosa respond to elevated carbon dioxide and infection with the parasitic angiosperm Striga hermonthica?

Eragrostis pilosa (Linn.) P Beauv., a C₄ grass native to east Africa, was grown at both ambient (350 μmol mol⁻¹ and elevated (700 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂ in either the presence or absence of the obligate, root hemi-parasite Striga hermonthica (Del.) Benth. Biomass of infected grasses was only 50% that of uninfected grasses at both CO₂ concentrations, with stems and reproductive tissues of infected plants being most severely affected. By contrast, CO₂ concentration had no effect on growth of E. pilosa , although rates of photosynthesis were enhanced by 30–40% at elevated CO₂. Infection with S. hermonthica did not affect either rates of photosynthesis or leaf areas of E. pilosa , but did bring about an increase in root:shoot ratio, leaf nitrogen and phosphorus concentration and a decline in leaf starch concentration at both ambient and elevated CO₂. Striga hermonthica had higher rates of photosynthesis and shoot concentrations of soluble sugars at elevated CO₂, but there was no difference in biomass relative to ambient grown plants. Both infection and growth at elevated CO₂ resulted in an increase in the Δ¹³C value of leaf tissue of E. pilosa , with the CO₂ effect being greater. The proportion of host-derived carbon in parasite tissue, as determined from δ¹³C values, was 27% and 39% in ambient and elevated CO₂ grown plants, respectively. In conclusion, infection with S. hermonthica limited growth of E. pilosa , and this limitation was not removed or alleviated by growing the association at elevated CO₂.     

Weather and climate controls over the seasonal carbon isotope dynamics of sugars from subalpine forest trees

We examined the environmental variables that influence the δ ¹³C value of needle and phloem sugars in trees in a subalpine forest. We collected sugars from Pinus contorta , Picea engelmannii and Abies lasiocarpa from 2006 to 2008. Phloem and needle sugars were enriched in ¹³C during the autumn, winter and early spring, but depleted during the growing season. We hypothesized that the late-winter and early-spring ¹³C enrichment was due to the mobilization of carbon assimilated the previous autumn; however, needle starch concentrations were completely exhausted by autumn, and we observed evidence of new starch production during episodic warm weather events during the winter and early-spring. Instead, we found that ¹³C enrichment was best explained by the occurrence of cold night-time temperatures. We also observed seasonal decoupling in the ¹³C/¹²C ratios of needle and phloem sugars. We hypothesized that this was due to seasonally-changing source-sink patterns, which drove carbon translocation from the needles towards the roots early in the season, before bud break, but from the roots towards the needles later in the season, after bud break. Overall, our results demonstrate that the ¹³C/¹²C ratio of recently-assimilated sugars can provide a sensitive record of the short-term coupling between climate and tree physiology.     

The Eocene Arctic Azolla bloom: environmental conditions, productivity and carbon drawdown

Enormous quantities of the free-floating freshwater fern Azolla grew and reproduced in situ in the Arctic Ocean during the middle Eocene, as was demonstrated by microscopic analysis of microlaminated sediments recovered from the Lomonosov Ridge during Integrated Ocean Drilling Program (IODP) Expedition 302. The timing of the Azolla phase (~48.5 Ma) coincides with the earliest signs of onset of the transition from a greenhouse towards the modern icehouse Earth. The sustained growth of Azolla , currently ranking among the fastest growing plants on Earth, in a major anoxic oceanic basin may have contributed to decreasing atmospheric p CO₂ levels via burial of Azolla -derived organic matter. The consequences of these enormous Azolla blooms for regional and global nutrient and carbon cycles are still largely unknown. Cultivation experiments have been set up to investigate the influence of elevated p CO₂ on Azolla growth, showing a marked increase in Azolla productivity under elevated (760 and 1910 ppm) p CO₂ conditions. The combined results of organic carbon, sulphur, nitrogen content and ¹⁵N and ¹³C measurements of sediments from the Azolla interval illustrate the potential contribution of nitrogen fixation in a euxinic stratified Eocene Arctic. Flux calculations were used to quantitatively reconstruct the potential storage of carbon (0.9–3.5 10¹⁸ gC) in the Arctic during the Azolla interval. It is estimated that storing 0.9 10¹⁸ to 3.5 10¹⁸ g carbon would result in a 55 to 470 ppm drawdown of p CO₂ under Eocene conditions, indicating that the Arctic Azolla blooms may have had a significant effect on global atmospheric p CO₂ levels through enhanced burial of organic matter.     

Air pollution in the past recorded in width and stable carbon isotope composition of annual growth rings of Douglas-fir

Abstract. Tree-ring indices (TRIs) of annual growth rings in stems of Douglas-fir ( Pseudotsuga menziesii ) growing near a copper smelter showed reduced growth during two multi-year time periods in the past. These periods coincided with World Wars I and II, which are known to represent periods of particularly high SO₂ emissions from the smelter. Reduced growth was correlated with less negative stable carbon isotope composition (δ¹³C) in cellulose purified from wood formed in such years. Based on current models for ¹³C/¹²C in plants, these results indicate that exposure to air pollution resulted in reduced concentration of CO₂ in the intercellular air spaces of the needles. This is consistent with the hypothesis that stomatal closure resulted in impaired photosynthesis and reduced growth during past episodes of high air pollution. The pollution-related change in δ¹³C was superimposed on a change with time in δ¹³C, independent of growth, by - 1.4 per mil from 1902 to 1984.     

13C-isotope analyses reveal that chemolithoautotrophic Gamma- and Epsilonproteobacteria feed a microbial food web in a pelagic redoxcline of the central Baltic Sea

Marine pelagic redoxclines are zones of high dark CO₂ fixation rates, which can correspond up to 30% of the surface primary production. However, despite this significant contribution to the pelagic carbon cycle, the identity of most chemolithoautotrophic organisms is still unknown. Therefore, the aim of this study was to directly link the dark CO₂ fixation capacity of a pelagic redoxcline in the central Baltic Sea (Landsort Deep) with the identity of the main chemolithoautotrophs involved. Our approach was based on the analysis of natural carbon isotope signatures in fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs) and on measurements of CO₂ incorporation in ¹³C-bicarbonate pulse experiments. The incorporation of ¹³C into chemolithoautotrophic cells was investigated by rRNA-based stable isotope probing (RNA-SIP) and FAME analysis after incubation for 24 and 72 h under in situ conditions. Our results demonstrated that fatty acids indicative of Proteobacteria were significantly enriched in ¹³C slightly below the chemocline. RNA-SIP analyses revealed that two different Gammaproteobacteria and three closely related Epsilonproteobacteria of the Sulfurimonas cluster were active dark CO₂-fixing microorganisms, with a time-dependent community shift between these groups. Labelling of Archaea was not detectable, but after 72 h of incubation the ¹³C-label had been transferred to a potentially bacterivorous ciliate related to Euplotes sp. Thus, RNA-SIP provided direct evidence for the contribution of chemolithoautotrophic production to the microbial food web in this marine pelagic redoxcline, emphasizing the importance of dark CO₂-fixing Proteobacteria within this habitat.     

Re-evaluation of proposed C4 photosynthetic characteristics in the genus Larix

It has been suggested previously that Japanese larch ( Larix kaempferi ) exhibits characteristics of C₄ photosynthesis. To further evaluate this suggestion, stable carbon isotope ratios were determined for leaf and bark tissue of Larix gmelini, L. kaempferi, L. laricina, L. Iyallii, L. occidentalis , and L. sibirica. All δ¹³C values were more negative than –22‰. Short-term labeling with ¹⁴CO₂ showed that phosphoglyceric acid and other phosphorylated compounds were the first products of photosynthesis in L. sibirica. Both of these results strongly suggest that the initial fixation of atmospheric CO₂ in these six Larix species is accomplished solely via the C₃ photosynthetic pathway.     

Links between methanotroph community composition and CH4 oxidation in a pine forest soil

The main gap in our knowledge about what determines the rate of CH₄ oxidation in forest soils is the biology of the microorganisms involved, the identity of which remains unclear. In this study, we used stable-isotope probing (SIP) following ¹³CH₄ incorporation into phospholipid fatty acids (PLFAs) and DNA/RNA, and sequencing of methane mono-oxygenase ( pmoA ) genes, to identify the influence of variation in community composition on CH₄ oxidation rates. The rates of ¹³C incorporation into PLFAs differed between horizons, with low ¹³C incorporation in the organic soil and relatively high ¹³C incorporation into the two mineral horizons. The microbial community composition of the methanotrophs incorporating the ¹³C label also differed between horizons, and statistical analyses suggested that the methanotroph community composition was a major cause of variation in CH₄ oxidation rates. Both PLFA and pmoA -based data indicated that CH₄ oxidizers in this soil belong to the uncultivated 'upland soil cluster α'. CH₄ oxidation potential exhibited the opposite pattern to ¹³C incorporation, suggesting that CH₄ oxidation potential assays may correlate poorly with in situ oxidation rates. The DNA/RNA-SIP assay was not successful, most likely due to insufficient ¹³C-incorporation into DNA/RNA. The limitations of the technique are briefly discussed.     

Using stable isotopes to determine soil carbon input differences under ambient and elevated atmospheric CO2 conditions

Quantitative estimates of soil C input under ambient (35 Pa) and elevated (60 Pa) CO₂-partial pressure (pCO₂) were determined in a Free-Air Carbon dioxide Enrichment (FACE) experiment. To facilitate ¹³C-tracing, Trifolium repens L. was grown in a soil with an initial δ¹³C distinct by at least 5‰ from the δ¹³C of T. repens grown under ambient or elevated pCO₂. A shift in δ¹³C of the soil organic C was detected after one growing season. Calculated new soil C inputs in soil under ambient and elevated pCO₂ were 2 and 3 t ha^–1, respectively. Our findings suggest that under elevated CO₂ conditions, soil C sequestration may be altered by changes in plant biomass production and quality.     

Effect of elevated CO2 on carbon partitioning and exudate release from Plantago lanceolata seedlings

Plantago lanceolata L. seedlings were grown in sand microcosm units over a 43‐day experimental period under two CO₂ regimes (800 or 400 µmol mol⁻¹) to investigate the effect of elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentration on carbon partitioning and exudate release. Total organic carbon (TOC) content of the collected exudate material was measured throughout the experimental period. After 42 days growth the seedlings were labelled with [¹⁴C]‐CO₂ and the fate of the label within the plant and its release by the roots monitored. Elevated CO₂ significantly (P ≤ 0.001) enhanced shoot, root and total dry matter production although the R:S ratio was unaltered, suggesting no alteration in gross carbon partitioning. The cumulative release of TOC (in mg C) over 0‐42 days was unaltered by CO₂ treatment however, when expressed as a percentage of net assimilated C, ambient‐grown plants released a significantly (P≤ 0.001) higher percentage from their roots compared to elevated CO₂‐grown plants (i.e. 8 vs 3%). The distribution of ¹⁴C‐label was markedly altered by CO₂ treatment with significantly (P≤ 0.001) greater per cent label partitioned to the roots under elevated CO₂. This indicates increased partitioning of recent assimilate below‐ground under elevated CO₂ treatment although there was no significant difference in the percentage of ¹⁴C‐label released by the roots. Comparison of plant C budgets based on ¹⁴C‐pulse‐chase methodology and TOC measurements is discussed.     

Physiological and isotopic (δ13C and δ18O) responses of three tropical tree species to water and nutrient availability

Water-use efficiency and stable isotope composition were studied in three tropical tree species. Seedlings of Tectona grandis , Swietenia macrophylla and Platymiscium pinnatum were grown at either high or low water supply, and with or without added fertilizer. These three species previously exhibited low, intermediate and high whole-plant water-use efficiency ( TE ) when grown at high water supply in unfertilized soil. Responses of TE to water and nutrient availability varied among species. The TE was calculated as experiment-long dry matter production divided by cumulative water use. Species-specific offsets were observed in relationships between TE and whole-plant ¹³C discrimination (Δ¹³C_p). These offsets could be attributed to a breakdown in the relationship between Δ¹³C_p and the ratio of intercellular to ambient CO₂ partial pressures ( c _i/ c _a) in P. pinnatum , and to variation among species in the leaf-to-air vapour pressure difference ( v ). Thus, a plot of v · TE against c _i/ c _a showed a general relationship among species. Relationships between δ ¹⁸O of stem dry matter and stomatal conductance ranged from strongly negative for S. macrophylla to no relationship for T. grandis . Results suggest inter-specific variation among tropical tree species in relationships between stable isotope ratios ( δ ¹³C and δ ¹⁸O) and the gas exchange processes thought to affect them.     

Carbon dioxide fixation in orchid aerial roots

Acidity fluctuation, CO₂ gas exchange, δ¹³C value, PEP carboxylase and RuBP carboxylase activities in aerial roots of selected thick-leaved orchid hybrids ( Arachnis and Aranthera ) were studied. Both aerial roots and leaves showed acidity fluctuation over a 24 h period. Dark acidification in aerial roots was enhanced at low temperature (15°C). Aerial roots had δ¹³C values close to those of leaves which have been previously demonstrated to possess crassulacean acid metabolism. Variation in δ¹³C values along the length of the roots was observed; the root tip having a less negative δ¹³C value (—13.34%‰) than the older portions of the roots (—14.55%‰). There was no net CO₂ fixation by aerial root, although ¹⁴³²CO₂ fixation was observed in light and in darkness. The pattern of fluctuation in activities of PEP carboxylase and RuBP carboxylase in aerial roots was similar to that obtained for the leaves. In both aerial roots and leaves, PEP carboxylase activity was several times higher than that of RuBP carboxylase.