Detection of the apomictic mode of reproduction in maize-Tripsacum hybrids using maize RFLP markers

Polyploid plants in the genus Tripsacum, a wild relative of maize, reproduce through gametophytic apomixis of the diplosporous type, an asexual mode of reproduction through seed. Moving gene(s) responsible for the apomictic trait into crop plants would open new areas in plant breeding and agriculture. Efforts to transfer apomixis from Tripsacum into maize at CIMMYT resulted in numerou intergeneric F₁ hybrids obtained from various Tripsacum species. A bulk-segregant analysis was carried out to identify molecular markers linked to diplospory in T. dactyloides. This was possible because of numerous genome similarities among related species in the Andropogoneae. On the basis of maize RFLP probes, three restriction fragments co-segregating with diplospory were identified in one maize-Tripsacum dactyloides F₁ population that segregated 1∶1 for the mode of reproduction. The markers were also found to be linked in the maize RFLP map, on the distal end of the long arm of chromosome 6. These results support a simple inheritance of diplospory in Tripsacum. Manipulation of the mode of reproduction in maize-Tripsacum backcross generations, and implications for the transfer of apomixis into maize, are discussed.     

SYSTEMATICS OF TRIPSACUM DACTYLOIDES (GRAMINEAE)

Tripsacum dactyloides (L.) L. extends across the range of this genus from about 42°N to 24°S latitude in the New World. It is recognized to include T. dactyloides var. dactyloides (North America), var. meridonale deWet et Timothy (South America), var. hispidum (Hitchc.) deWet et Harlan comb. nov. (Mesoamerica) and var. mexicanum deWet et Harlan var. nov. (Mesoamericana). The genus is divided into sections Tripsacum and Fasciculatum. Mesoamerican members of section Tripsacum are classified into T. bravum Gray, T. dactyloides (L.) L., T. intermedium deWet et Harlan spec, nov., T. latifolium Hitchc., T. manisuroides deWet et Harlan spec. nov. and T. zopilotense Hern,*** et Randolph. A key to the species of section Tripsacum is presented.     

A comparison of apomictic reproduction in eastern gamagrass (Tripsacum dactyloides (L.) L.) and maize-Tripsacum hybrids

The expression of gene(s) governing apomictic reproduction inTripsacum provides the best foundation for comparing the effectiveness of apomictic reproduction in a series of maize-Tripsacum hybrids. Several 38-chromosome, apomictic maize-Tripsacum hybrids are available which possess the gene(s) conferring apomictic reproduction fromTripsacum. Without a base line for comparison, studies directed towards discerning the successful transfer or effectiveness of gene expression in a maize background are hampered. The objectives of this study are to compare the reproductive features found in apomicticTripsacum with those in apomictic maize-Tripsacum hybrids. In addition, this study determined the feasibility of utilizing these maize-Tripsacum hybrid materials to continue an attempt to transfer the genes into a pure maize background. The frequency and occurrence of five unique reproductive features found in apomictic accessions ofTripsacum dactyloides were compared to the reproductive behaviours exhibited in the maize-Tripsacum hybrids. Results indicate the genes controlling apomixis in tetraploidTripsacum are fully functional in maize-Tripsacum hybrids with diploid and triploid maize constitutions. The ability of theTripsacum apomictic genes to retain full expression provides evidence to continue their transfer to a diploid or tetraploid maize background.The use of company names in this publication does not imply endorsement by the USDA-ARS, or the product names or criticism of similar ones not mentioned. All programs and services of the U.S. Department of Agriculture are offered on a nondiscriminatory basis without regard to race, color, national origin, religion, sex, age, marital status, or handicap.     

Composition of Esterase and Peroxidase Isoenzyme Complex, Zein-2 Protein Fraction, and SDS-Protein Complex of Zea Mays L. × Tripsacum Dactyloides L. Hybrids and Parents

The patterns of esterase and peroxidase isoenzymes, subunits of zein-2 fraction and protomers of SDS-protein complex of Zea mays L. × Tripsacum dactyloides L. hybrids and their parents were compared. The study has been made to detect specific to Tripsacum isoesterases and isoperoxidases, zein subunits and SDS-protein protomers which could be used as markers for introgression of gene loci encoding these proteins from Tripsacum into hybrids of Tripsacum with Zea mays. Isoesterases and isoperoxidases as well protomers of SDS-protein complex specific to Tripsacum were detected in all hybrids analyzed. Zein subunits, specific to Tripsacum were detected in some of the analyzed hybrids which i that introgression frequency of the loci encoding proteins studied was different. Chromosome counts taken on the examined hybrids showed the addition of 9 – 13 Tripsacum chromosomes to maize chromosome complement.     

A cross between two maize relatives:Tripsacum dactyloides andZea diploperennis (Poaceae)

Crosses betweenTripsacum dactyloides and teosinte (Zea diploperennis) using standard pollination technique have been successfully attempted and six highly fertile hybrid plants obtained. Previous research had shown other teosintes to be cross-incompatible with Tripsacum and maize to be crossable but highly intersterile withTripsacum. Some investigators believe thatTripsacum played a prominent role in the origin of maize; theTripsacum-diploperennis hybrid provides evidence to support that idea. Ears produced by the hybrid have paired kernel rows, a distinctive characteristic of the oldest archaeological maize that none of the wild relatives have. This unique hybrid is described and discussed in terms of its possible role in the origin and evolution of maize.     

Malate Dehydrogenase, Alcohol Dehydrogenase, and 6-Phosphogluconate Dehydrogenase Isozymes of Zea mays L. × Tripsacum dactyloides L. Hybrids and Parents

Electrophoretic patterns of malate dehydrogenase (Mdh), alcohol dehydrogenase (Adh), and 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase (Pgd) of Zea mays L. × Tripsacum dactyloides L. hybrids and their parents were compared. The components of enzymes specific to T. dactyloides may be used as markers to identify the following T. dactyloides chromosomes in the hybrids: Tr 16 (Mdh 2 and Pdg 1), Tr 7, and/or Tr 13 (Adh 2). The isozymes of Mdh 2 are supposed as a possible biochemical marker to evaluate the introgression of genes, determining an apomictic mode of reproduction from T. dactyloides (localized on Tripsacum 16 chromosome) into Z. mays. The isozymes may be used as markers for the identification of maize chromosomes 1 and 6 in the hybrids as well. Chromosome count taken on the examined hybrids showed the addition of 9 to 13 chromosomes of T. dactyloides to maize chromosome complement.     

Megasporogenesis and megagametogenesis in several Tripsacum species (Poaceae)

The Tripsacum agamic complex (x = 18) will provide valuable characters for maize breeding, provided that apomixis can be manipulated. Apomixis in Tripsacum was first reported 40 years ago, but its prevalence in the genus has not been established. Reproductive development was determined for eight Mexican and two South American Tripsacum species by microscopic analysis of ovaries cleared in a benzyl benzoate-dibutyl phthalate solution using interference contrast optics. The occurrence and distribution of callose deposition during megasporogenesis were determined by fluorescence microscopy of ovaries optically cleared in an aqueous sucrose solution containing aniline blue. Diploid genotypes were sexual. Polyploid forms reproduced apomictically following the Antennaria type (complete meiosis abortion) of diplospory. The Taraxacum type (unreduced megaspore production through meiotic restitution nuclei) of diplospory also occurred but rarely. The walls of diplosporic megasporocytes lacked callose whereas the walls of sexual megasporocytes contained a normal complement of callose. The absence of callose suggests that the diplosporic forms of reproduction result from mutations affecting the normal meiotic process. Apomixis in the Tripsacum genus is facultative, and the production of new polyploid genotypes through genetic exchanges involving both apomictic and sexual genotypes is possible.     

Tripsacum dactyloides (Poaceae): a natural model system to study parthenogenesis

Diplosporous apomeiosis, formation of unreduced embryo sacs primarily of the Antennaria type, followed by parthenogenetic embryo development and pseudogamy (fertilization of the central cell) describe gametophytic apomixis within the Tripsacum agamic complex. Tripsacum dactyloides (Eastern gamagrass) is a close relative of domesticated maize and was chosen as a natural model system to investigate gene expression patterns associated with parthenogenesis. The genome size of diploid sexual and polyploid apomictic T. dactyloides was estimated by flow cytometry to be 7.37 pg (2C), 14.74 pg (4C) and 22.39 pg (6C), respectively. The diploid genome size is thus approximately 1.352 larger than that of maize. The apomeiotic-pseudogamous pathway of seed formation was demonstrated at a rate of 92% by the flow cytometric seed screen (FCSS) with single mature seeds in tetraploid accessions. This number includes twin embryos which were detected in 13% of the seeds analyzed. Fertilization of unreduced egg cells (B_III hybrids) was measured in 10% of apomictic seeds. Autonomous (fertilization-independent) embryo development and fertilization-dependent endosperm formation were confirmed by pollination of tetraploid T. dactyloides with a diploid transgenic maize line carrying an actin::#-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter construct. GUS expression was detected after pollination in the developing endosperm, but not in the embryo. In similar intraspecific crossing experiments with maize, GUS expression was detected in both the embryo and endosperm. A protocol was established for microdissection of embryo sacs and early parthenogenetic embryos of T. dactyloides. Together, these techniques provide new tools for future studies aimed at comparing gene expression patterns between sexual maize and sexual or apomictic T. dactyloides.     

COUNTERFEIT HYBRIDS BETWEEN TRIPSACUM AND ZEA (GRAMINEAE)

Diploid (2n = 36) Tripsacum australe Cutler and Anderson var. hirsutum de Wet and Timothy, T. cundinamarce de Wet and Timothy, T. dactyloides (L.) L. var. dactyloides and var. meridonale de Wet and Timothy, and T. laxum Nash were crossed with Zea mays L. (2n = 20) as the pollen parent. True hybrids combine the cytologically nonreduced genome of Tripsacum (36 chromosomes) with the haploid (10 chromosomes) or more rarely diploid (20 chromosome) genome of Zea. Maternal offspring with 2n = 36 Tripsacum chromosomes commonly result from parthenogenetic development of cytologically nonreduced eggs. Some individuals with 2n = 36 Tripsacum chromosomes, however, resemble true hybrids in phenotype. These counterfeit hybrids incorporated Zea genetic material into their Tripsacum genomes without true fertilization having taken place. Offspring of counterfeit hybrids that were grown to maturity resembled their mothers in phenotype, and must have originated parthenogenetically. It is proposed that counterfeit hybrids are also produced in nature, and that this process contributes to origins of variation in gametophytic apomicts, and perhaps also in sexually reproducing species.     

OBSERVATIONS ON INTROGRESSION OF TRIPSACUM INTO MAIZE

Derivatives of a cross between diploid Zea mays L. and Tripsacum dactyloides (L.) L. (2n = 72) were compared cytologically and morphologically. The objective of this study was to detect introgression from Tripsacum to maize that might have occurred during seven backcross generations with maize. Thirty-three morphological characters were used to analyze variation among aneuploid (20Zm + 2Td), 20-chromosome recovered maize, and the recurrent maize parent plants. Aneuploid and maize checks were extreme types, with 20-chromosome hybrid derivatives being morphologically intermediate. Several recovered maizes clustered with aneuploid plants and these hybrid derivatives have the greatest chance of Tripsacum introgression. Many traits such as endosperm abnormalities, tassel seed, albinos, tunicate glumes, tassel-tipped ears, fasciated and branched ear, and male spikelets between rows of kernels were observed. Although the genetic basis of many traits is unknown, mutations, epistatic effects or expression of Tripsacum chromatin are possible causes. The number of abnormal and tripsacoid traits observed in 20-chromosome recovered maizes indicates genetic transfer from Tripsacum to the maize genome.     

Comparative isozyme polymorphisms of north American eastern gamagrass,Tripsacum dactyloides var.dactyloides and maize,Zea mays L.

Random samples, consisting of at least 100 individual seedlings, were taken from the diploid (2n=2x=36) eastern gamagrass (Tripsacum dactyloides var.dactyloides) and assayed to determine which of 12 enzyme marker loci and isozyme systems would be most informative in providing satisfactory resolution of both maize andTripsacum isozyme systems. For comparison, eight maize inbreds were included in the study to aid evaluation and comparison of the various isozyme systems. In addition, evaluations were conducted to identify if the identified optimum isozyme system could be used to detectTripsacum introgression in maize following a maize ×Tripsacum backcrossing scheme. Using the established isozyme techniques for maize (Zea mays L.), theAdh, Pgd, Cat, Est, B-Glu, Got, Idh, Tpi isozyme systems detected no polymorphism among theTripsacum individuals assayed. TheEst andB-Glu systems forTripsacum were unscorable due to poor staining and resolution. TheAcp, Mdh, Pgm, andPhi isozyme systems were found to be satisfactory markers for differentiating between eastern gamagrass individuals as well as detectingTripsacum introgression in maize. The availability of useful isozyme systems which can simultaneously provide significant isozyme resolution of maize,Tripsacum and maize-Tripsacum backcross hybrids, on a single gel system, will be useful for the detection of marker assistedTripsacum introgression into maize. In addition, the identification of a set of variable biochemical markers should also assist breeding, selection and genetic manipulations in eastern gamagrass.The use of company names in this publication does not imply endorsement by the USDA-ARS, or the product names of criticism of similar ones not mentioned. All programs and services of the U.S. Department of Agriculture are offered on a nondiscriminatory basis without regard to race, color, national origin, religion, sex, age, marital status, or handicap.     

Heterochronic expression of sexual reproductive programs during apomictic development in Tripsacum

Some angiosperms reproduce by apomixis, a natural way of cloning through seeds. Apomictic plants bypass both meiosis and egg cell fertilization, producing progeny that are genetic replicas of the mother plant. In this report, we analyze reproductive development in Tripsacum dactyloides, an apomictic relative of maize, and in experimental apomictic hybrids between maize and Tripsacum. We show that apomictic reproduction is characterized by an alteration of developmental timing of both sporogenesis and early embryo development. The absence of female meiosis in apomictic Tripsacum results from an early termination of female meiosis. Similarly, parthenogenetic development of a maternal embryo in apomicts results from precocious induction of early embryogenesis events. We also show that male meiosis in apomicts is characterized by comparable asynchronous expression of developmental stages. Apomixis thus results in an array of possible phenotypes, including wild-type sexual development. Overall, our observations suggest that apomixis in Tripsacum is a heterochronic phenotype; i.e., it relies on a deregulation of the timing of reproductive events, rather than on the alteration of a specific component of the reproductive pathway.     

Rapid amplification and fixation of new restriction sites in the ribosomal dna repeats in the derivatives of a cross between maize and Tripsacum dactyloides

Some of the derivatives of a cross of maize (Zea mays L.) × Tripsacum dactyloides (L) L (2n = 72) have abnormal development leading to strange and striking morphologies. The Tripsacum chromosomes in these “tripsacoid” maize plants (with Tripsacum-like characteristics) were eliminated and the maize chromosomes were recovered through repeated backcrossing to maize. As an initial attempt to analyze the DNA alterations in tripsacoid maize, we have detected a few restriction site changes in the ribosomal DNA repeat of these plants (Hpa II, Bal I, Sst I, Mbo II, and Sph I) and a new Sph I site was mapped to the spacer region between the 26S and 17S genes. Several possible mechanisms for the generation of a new restriction site are discussed, and we propose that the transient presence of Tripsacum genome during the backcrossing in some way induced a rapid amplification and fixation of new restriction sites in a relatively short period of time.     

Dosage effects in the endosperm of diplosporous apomictic Tripsacum (Poaceae)

 Imprinting in the endosperm of angiosperms, a phenomena by which expression of alleles differs depending on whether they originate from the male or female parent, has been shown to explain most failure of interploidy or interspecific crosses in plants. Because of imprinting, seeds develop normally only if a specific dosage is represented in the endosperm, with the relative contributions of genomes in the ratio of two maternal doses to one paternal dose (2m:1p). In Tripsacum, a wild relative of maize, all polyploids reproduce through the diplosporous type of apomixis. Diplospory results from meiotic failure in megasporocytes that develop into eight-nucleate unreduced female gametophytes. The male gametophytes remain unaffected. Flow cytometry was used to determine ploidy levels in the endosperm of both apomictic and sexual Tripsacum accessions. In both cases, fertilization appeared to involve only one sperm nucleus. Therefore, endosperm of apomictic Tripsacum develops normally even though the ratio of genomic contributions deviates from the normal 2m:1p ratio. Ratios of 2:1, 4:1, 4:2, 8:1 and 8:2 were observed, depending on both the ploidy level of the parents and the mode of reproduction. Thus, specific dosage effects are seemingly not required for endosperm development in Tripsacum. These findings suggest that evolution of diplosporous apomixis might have been restricted to species with few or no imprinting requirements, and the findings have strong implications regarding the transfer of apomixis to sexually reproducing crops. Received: 17 February 1997 / Revision accepted: 7 July 1997     

SYSTEMATICS OF SOUTH AMERICAN TRIPSACUM (GRAMINEAE)

The genus Tripsacum is widely distributed between 42°N and 24°S latitude. In South America, the genus extends around the Amazon and Orinoco basin, and from the Caribbean coast south to Brazil and Paraguay. The most common South American taxon is T. dactyloides (L.) L. var. meridonale de Wet and Timothy (2n = 36), which differs from North American representatives of the species in having subdigitate recemes usually appressed with the apical male sections typically curved. Closely related to T. dactyloides, but usually occupying more seasonally moist and dry habitats, is T. australe Cutler and Anderson. This species is typically robust with the basal leaf sheaths tomentose, and the much elongated culms becoming decumbent in older plants. Smaller plants, with essentially erect culms and leaf sheaths on the culms hirsute rather than tomentose, are recognized as T. australe var. hirsutum de Wet and Timothy. The two varieties of T. australe are both diploid (2n = 36) and they cross to produce fertile hybrids. They also cross with T. dactyloides var. meridonale (2n = 36), but these hybrids are partially sterile. Tripsacum cundinamarce de Wet and Timothy (2n = 36) is a robust species with glaucus leaves. It resembles robust specimens of T. dactyloides in having glabrous leaf sheaths, but can always be recognized by inflorescences that are composed of racemes arranged along a several-noded primary axis. This species is confined to moist habitats, while T. dactyloides occupies a range of habitats in South America. Tripsacum peruvianum de Wet and Timothy is a gametophytic apomict with 2n = 72, 90 or 108 chromosomes. It is characterized by an erect growth habit and strongly hirsute leaf sheaths. The cultivated Guatemala grass, T. andersonii Gray, occurs spontaneously in the mountains of Venezuela, Colombia, and Peru. This sexually sterile species is characterized by 2n = 64, and may combine 54 Tripsacum and 10 Zea chromosomes in its genome. Electrophoretic patterns of seed storage proteins confirm the validity of recognizing T. cundinamarce as distinct from T. dactyloides, and T. peruvianum as distinct from T. australe.     

ORIGIN OF TRIPSACUM ANDERSONII (GRAMINEAE)

Tripsacum andersonii Gray (Gramineae) is a species with 2n = 64 chromosomes. Chromosome behaviour during meiosis of microsporogenesis suggests that the species combines three homologous haploid Tripsacum genomes of x = 18 (54 chromosomes), and an alien haploid genome of x = 10 chromosomes. Cytogenetic studies indicate that T. andersonii originated as a hybrid between a species of Tripsacum (2n = 36) and a species of Zea (2n = 20). Comparative morphology and flavonoid chemistry fail to identify the Zea species involved in this intergeneric hybrid. Chromosome morphology suggests that it was either Z. mays L. subsp. mays (domesticated maize) or subspecies mexicana (Schrad.) Iltis (annual teosinte). The Tripsacum parent probably was T. latifolium Hitchc. of Central America. It resembles T. andersonii in vegetative morphology. Tripsacum maizar Hernandez et Randolph and T. laxum Nash, which resemble T. andersonii in flavonoid chemistry, are eliminated as possible parents on the basis of growth habit and the morphology of their hybrids with maize.     

Molecular analysis of crosses between Tripsacum dactyloides and Zea diploperennis (Poaceae)

 DNA fingerprinting verified hybrid plants obtained by crossing Eastern gamagrass, Tripsacum dactyloides L., and perennial teosinte, Zea diploperennis Iltis, Doebley & R. Guzmán. Pistillate inflorescences on these hybrids exhibit characteristics intermediate to the key morphological traits that differentiate domesticated maize from its wild relatives: (1) a pair of female spikelets in each cupule; (2) exposed kernels not completely covered by the cupule and outer glumes; (3) a rigid, non-shattering rachis; (4) a polystichous ear. RFLP analysis was employed to investigate the possibility that traits of domesticated maize were derived from hybridization between perennial teosinte and Tripsacum. Southern blots of restriction digested genomic DNA of parent plants, F₁, and F₂ progeny from two different crosses were probed with RFLP markers specifically associated with changes in pistillate inflorescence architecture that signal maize domestication. Pairwise analysis of restriction patterns showed traits considered missing links in the origin of maize correlate with alleles derived from Tripsacum, and the same alleles are stably inherited in second generation progeny from crosses between Tripsacum and perennial teosinte. Received: 11 October 1996/Accepted:8 November 1996     

Chromosome control of apomixis in maize-gamagrass hybrids

The results of long-term studies on the transmission of the mode of asexual reproduction through seeds to maize from gamagrass, a closely related wild plant, performed in the Laboratory of Plant Cytology and Apomixis are summarized. The first apomictic hybrids between Zea mays and Tripsacum dactyloides were obtained in this laboratory more than 40 years ago and have been maintained until the present time. Cytogenetic studies on the hybrids have shown that at least nine chromosomes of the wild parent are necessary for the expression of asexual reproduction through seeds. In addition, the genes controlling two elements of apomixis (apomeiosis and parthenogenesis) have been found to be inherited independently from each other.     

Evaluating Tripsacum‐introgressed maize germplasm after infestation with western corn rootworms (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae)

Maize (Zea mays L.) is a valuable commodity throughout the world, but corn rootworms (Chrysomelidae: Diabrotica spp.) often cause economic damage and increase production costs. Current rootworm management strategies have limitations, and in order to create viable management alternatives, researchers have been developing novel maize lines using Eastern gamagrass (Tripsacum dactyloides L.) germplasm, a wild relative of maize that is resistant to rootworms. Ten maize Tripsacum‐introgressed inbred lines derived from recurrent selection of crosses with gamagrass and teosinte (Zea diploperennis Iltis) recombinants and two public inbred lines were assessed for susceptibility to western corn rootworm (Diabrotica virgifera virgifera LeConte) and yield in a two‐year field study. Two experimental maize inbred lines, SDG11 and SDG20, had mean root damage ratings that were significantly lower than the susceptible public line B73. Two other experimental maize inbred lines, SDG12 and SDG6, appeared tolerant to rootworm damage because they exhibited yield increases after rootworm infestation in both years. In the majority of cases, mean yield per plant of experimental maize lines used in yield analyses was equal to or exceeded that of the public inbred lines B73 and W64A. Our study indicates that there is potential to use Tripsacum‐introgressed maize germplasm in breeding programs to enhance plant resistance and/or tolerance to corn rootworms, although further research on insect resistance and agronomic potential of this germplasm needs to be conducted in F₁ hybrids.