Co-ordination of TGF-beta and FGF signaling pathways in bone organ cultures

Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) is known to regulate chondrocyte proliferation and hypertrophic differentiation in embryonic bone cultures by a perichondrium dependent mechanism. To begin to determine which factors in the perichondrium mediate the effects of TGF-beta, we studied the effect of Insulin-like Growth Factor-1 (IGF-I) and Fibroblast Growth Factors-2 and -18 (FGF2, FGF18) on metatarsal organ cultures. An increase in chondrocyte proliferation and hypertrophic differentiation was observed after treatment with IGF-I. A similar effect was seen after the perichondrium was stripped from the metatarsals suggesting IGF-I acts directly on the chondrocytes. Treatment with FGF-2 or FGF-18 resulted in a decrease in bone elongation as well as hypertrophic differentiation. Treatment also resulted in a decrease in BrdU incorporation into chondrocytes and an increase in BrdU incorporation in perichondrial cells, similar to what is seen after treatment with TGF-beta1. A similar effect was seen with FGF2 after the perichondrium was stripped suggesting that, unlike TGF-beta, FGF2 acts directly on chondrocytes to regulate proliferation and hypertrophic differentiation. To test the hypothesis that TGF-beta regulates IGF or FGF signaling, activation of the receptors was characterized after treatment with TGF-beta. Activation was measured as the level of tyrosine phosphorylation on the receptor. Treatment with TGF-beta for 24h did not alter the level of IGFR-I tyrosine phosphorylation. In contrast, treatment with TGF-beta resulted in and increase in tyrosine phosphorylation on FGFR3 without alterations in total FGFR3 levels. TGF-beta also stimulated expression of FGF18 mRNA in the cultures and the effects of TGF-beta on metatarsal development were blocked or partially blocked by pretreatment with FGF signaling inhibitors. The results suggest a model in which FGF through FGFR3 mediates some of the effects of TGF-beta on embryonic bone formation.     

Downregulation of Akt activity contributes to the growth arrest induced by FGF in chondrocytes

Unregulated FGF signaling produced by activating FGFR3 mutations causes several forms of dwarfism-associated chondrodysplasias in humans and mice. FGF signaling inhibits chondrocyte proliferation by activating multiple signal transduction pathways that all contribute to chondrocyte growth arrest and induction of some aspects of differentiation. Previous studies had identified the Stat1 pathway, dephosphorylation of the Rb family proteins p107 and p130, induction of p21 expression and sustained activation of MAP kinases as playing a role in the FGF response of chondrocytes. We have examined the role of Akt (PKB) in the response of chondrocytes to FGF signaling. Differently from what is observed in many other cell types, FGF does not activate Akt in chondrocytes, and Akt phosphorylation is actually downregulated after FGF treatment. By expressing a constitutively activated, myristylated form of Akt (myr-Akt) in the RCS chondrosarcoma cell line, we show that Akt activation partially counteracts the inhibitory effect of FGF signaling. The response of myr-Akt expressing cells to FGF is identical to parental RCS in the first few hours after treatment, but then diverges as myr-Akt cells show decreased p130 phosphorylation, increased cyclin E/cdk2 activity and continue to proliferate at a slow rate. Constitutive Akt activation does not affect p21 expression but appears to influence directly cdk/cyclin activity. On the other hand, the induction of differentiation-related genes is unchanged in myr-Akt cells. These results identify Akt downregulation as an important aspect of the response of chondrocytes to FGF that, however, only affects chondrocyte proliferation and not the ability of FGF to induce differentiation genes.     

Fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF21) inhibits chondrocyte function and growth hormone action directly at the growth plate

Fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF21) modulates glucose and lipid metabolism during fasting. In addition, previous evidence indicates that increased expression of FGF21 during chronic food restriction is associated with reduced bone growth and growth hormone (GH) insensitivity. In light of the inhibitory effects on growth plate chondrogenesis mediated by other FGFs, we hypothesized that FGF21 causes growth inhibition by acting directly at the long bones' growth plate. We first demonstrated the expression of FGF21, FGFR1 and FGFR3 (two receptors known to be activated by FGF21) and β-klotho (a co-receptor required for the FGF21-mediated receptor binding and activation) in fetal and 3-week-old mouse growth plate chondrocytes. We then cultured mouse growth plate chondrocytes in the presence of graded concentrations of rhFGF21 (0.01-10 μg/ml). Higher concentrations of FGF21 (5 and 10 μg/ml) inhibited chondrocyte thymidine incorporation and collagen X mRNA expression. 10 ng/ml GH stimulated chondrocyte thymidine incorporation and collagen X mRNA expression, with both effects prevented by the addition in the culture medium of FGF21 in a concentration-dependent manner. In addition, FGF21 reduced GH binding in cultured chondrocytes. In cells transfected with FGFR1 siRNA or ERK 1 siRNA, the antagonistic effects of FGF21 on GH action were all prevented, supporting a specific effect of this growth factor in chondrocytes. Our findings suggest that increased expression of FGF21 during food restriction causes growth attenuation by antagonizing the GH stimulatory effects on chondrogenesis directly at the growth plate. In addition, high concentrations of FGF21 may directly suppress growth plate chondrocyte proliferation and differentiation.     

Glycogen synthase kinase 3 controls endochondral bone development: contribution of fibroblast growth factor 18

Glycogen synthase kinase 3 (GSK3) inhibits signaling pathways that are essential for bone development. To study the requirement for GSK activity during endochondral bone development, we inhibited GSK3 in cultured metatarsal bones with pharmacological antagonists. Interestingly, we find that inhibition of GSK3 strongly repressed chondrocyte and perichondrial osteoblast differentiation. Moreover, chondrocyte proliferation was inhibited, whereas perichondrial cell proliferation was stimulated. These results mirror the effects of fibroblast growth factor signaling (FGF), suggesting the FGF expression is induced. Indeed, we showed that (1) FGF18 expression is stimulated following inhibition of GSK3 and (2) GSK3 regulates FGF18 expression through the control of beta-catenin levels. Stimulation of cultured metatarsal with FGF18 had similar effects on the differentiation and proliferation of chondrocytes and perichondrial cells as GSK3 repression. This suggests that the regulation of FGF18 expression is a major function of GSK3 during endochondral bone development. Consistent with this, we showed that the effect of GSK3 inhibition on chondrocyte proliferation is repressed in tissues lacking a receptor for FGF18, FGF receptor 3.     

BMPs regulate multiple aspects of growth-plate chondrogenesis through opposing actions on FGF pathways

Bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling pathways are essential regulators of chondrogenesis. However, the roles of these pathways in vivo are not well understood. Limb-culture studies have provided a number of essential insights, including the demonstration that BMP pathways are required for chondrocyte proliferation and differentiation. However, limb-culture studies have yielded contradictory results; some studies indicate that BMPs exert stimulatory effects on differentiation, whereas others support inhibitory effects. Therefore, we characterized the skeletal phenotypes of mice lacking Bmpr1a in chondrocytes (Bmpr1a(CKO)) and Bmpr1a(CKO);Bmpr1b+/- (Bmpr1a(CKO);1b+/-) in order to test the roles of BMP pathways in the growth plate in vivo. These mice reveal requirements for BMP signaling in multiple aspects of chondrogenesis. They also demonstrate that the balance between signaling outputs from BMP and fibroblast growth factor (FGF) pathways plays a crucial role in the growth plate. These studies indicate that BMP signaling is required to promote Ihh expression, and to inhibit activation of STAT and ERK1/2 MAPK, key effectors of FGF signaling. BMP pathways inhibit FGF signaling, at least in part, by inhibiting the expression of FGFR1. These results provide a genetic in vivo demonstration that the progression of chondrocytes through the growth plate is controlled by antagonistic BMP and FGF signaling pathways.     

Phosphate regulates embryonic endochondral bone development

Phosphate is required for terminal differentiation of hypertrophic chondrocytes during postnatal growth plate maturation. In vitro models of chondrocyte differentiation demonstrate that 7 mM phosphate, a concentration analogous to that of the late gestational fetus, activates the mitochondrial apoptotic pathway in hypertrophic chondrocytes. This raises the question as to whether extracellular phosphate modulates chondrocyte differentiation and apoptosis during embryonic endochondral bone formation. To address this question, we performed investigations in the mouse metatarsal culture model that recapitulates in vivo bone development. Metatarsals were cultured for 4, 8, and 12 days with 1.25 and 7 mM phosphate. Metatarsals cultured with 7 mM phosphate showed a decrease in proliferation compared to those cultured in 1.25 mM phosphate. This decrease in proliferation was accompanied by an early enhancement in hypertrophic chondrocyte differentiation, associated with an increase in FGF18 expression. By 8 days in culture, an increase caspase‐9 activation and apoptosis of hypertrophic chondrocytes was observed in the metatarsals cultured in 7 mM phosphate. Immunohistochemical analyses of embryonic bones demonstrated activation of caspase‐9 in hypertrophic chondrocytes, associated with vascular invasion. Thus, these investigations demonstrate that phosphate promotes chondrocyte differentiation during embryonic development and implicate a physiological role for phosphate activation of the mitochondrial apoptotic pathway during embryonic endochondral bone formation. J. Cell. Biochem. 108: 668–674, 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Specific heparan sulfate structures modulate FGF10-mediated submandibular gland epithelial morphogenesis and differentiation

FGF10, a heparan sulfate (HS)-binding growth factor, is required for branching morphogenesis of mouse submandibular glands (SMGs). HS increases the affinity of FGF10 for FGFR2b, which forms an FGF10.FGFR2b.HS ternary signaling complex, and results in diverse biological outcomes, including proliferation and epithelial morphogenesis. Defining the HS structures involved in specific FGF10-mediated events is critical to understand how HS modulates growth factor signaling in specific developmental contexts. We used HS-deficient BaF3/FGFR2b cells, which require exogenous HS to proliferate, to investigate the HS requirements for FGF10-mediated proliferation and primary SMG epithelia to investigate the structural requirements of HS for FGF10-mediated epithelial morphogenesis. In BaF3/FGFR2b cells, heparin with at least 10 saccharides and 6-O-, 2-O-, and N-sulfates were required for maximal proliferation. During FGF10-mediated SMG epithelial morphogenesis, HS increased proliferation and end bud expansion. Defined heparin decasaccharide libraries showed that 2-O-sulfation with either an N-or 6-O-sulfate induced end bud expansion, whereas decasaccharides with 6-O-sulfation alone induced duct elongation. End bud expansion resulted from increased FGFR1b signaling, with increased FGFR1b, Fgf1, and Spry1 as well as increased Aqp5 expression, a marker of end bud differentiation. Duct elongation was associated with expression of Cp2L1, a marker of developing ducts. Collectively, these findings show that the size and sulfate patterns of HS modulate specific FGF10-mediated events, such as proliferation, duct elongation, end bud expansion, and differentiation, and provide mechanistic insight as to how the developmental localization of specific HS structures in tissues influences FGF10-mediated morphogenesis and differentiation.     

Wnt/beta-catenin signaling interacts differentially with Ihh signaling in controlling endochondral bone and synovial joint formation

Both the Wnt/beta-catenin and Ihh signaling pathways play essential roles in crucial aspects of endochondral ossification: osteoblast differentiation, chondrocyte proliferation and hypertrophy. To understand the genetic interaction between these two signaling pathways, we have inactivated the beta-catenin gene and upregulated Ihh signaling simultaneously in the same cells during endochondral skeletal development using beta-catenin and patched 1 floxed alleles. We uncovered previously unexpected roles of Ihh signaling in synovial joint formation and the essential function of Wnt/beta-catenin signaling in regulating chondrocyte survival. More importantly, we found that Wnt and Ihh signaling interact with each other in distinct ways to control osteoblast differentiation, chondrocyte proliferation, hypertrophy, survival and synovial joint formation in the developing endochondral bone. Beta-catenin is required downstream of Ihh signaling and osterix expression for osteoblast differentiation. But in chondrocyte survival, beta-catenin is required upstream of Ihh signaling to inhibit chondrocyte apoptosis. In addition, Ihh signaling can inhibit chondrocyte hypertrophy and synovial joint formation independently of beta-catenin. However, there is a strong synergistic interaction between Wnt/beta-catenin and Ihh signaling in regulating synovial joint formation.     

Fibroblast growth factor (FGF) 18 signals through FGF receptor 3 to promote chondrogenesis

Signaling by fibroblast growth factor (FGF) 18 and FGF receptor 3 (FGFR3) have been shown to regulate proliferation, differentiation, and matrix production of articular and growth plate chondrocytes in vivo and in vitro. Notably, the congenital absence of either FGF18 or FGFR3 resulted in similar expansion of the growth plates of fetal mice and the addition of FGF18 to human articular chondrocytes in culture enhanced proliferation and matrix production. Based on these and other experiments it has been proposed that FGF18 signals through FGFR3 to promote cartilage production by chondrocytes. Its role in chondrogenesis remains to be defined. In the current work we used the limb buds of FGFR3(+/+) and FGFR3(-/-) embryonic mice as a source of mesenchymal cells to determine how FGF18 signaling affects chondrogenesis. Confocal laser-scanning microscopy demonstrated impaired cartilage nodule formation in the FGFR3(-/-) cultures. Potential contributing factors to the phenotype were identified as impaired mitogenic response to FGF18, decreased production of type II collagen and proteoglycan in response to FGF18 stimulation, impaired interactions with the extracellular matrix resulting from altered integrin receptor expression, and altered expression of FGFR1 and FGFR2. The data identified FGF18 as a selective ligand for FGFR3 in limb bud mesenchymal cells, which suppressed proliferation and promoted their differentiation and production of cartilage matrix. This work, thus, identifies FGF18 and FGFR3 as potential molecular targets for intervention in tissue engineering aimed at cartilage repair and regeneration of damaged cartilage.     

BMP and Ihh/PTHrP signaling interact to coordinate chondrocyte proliferation and differentiation.

During endochondral ossification, two secreted signals, Indian hedgehog (Ihh) and parathyroid hormone-related protein (PTHrP), have been shown to form a negative feedback loop regulating the onset of hypertrophic differentiation of chondrocytes. Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs), another family of secreted factors regulating bone formation, have been implicated as potential interactors of the Ihh/PTHrP feedback loop. To analyze the relationship between the two signaling pathways, we used an organ culture system for limb explants of mouse and chick embryos. We manipulated chondrocyte differentiation by supplementing these cultures either with BMP2, PTHrP and Sonic hedgehog as activators or with Noggin and cyclopamine as inhibitors of the BMP and Ihh/PTHrP signaling systems. Overexpression of Ihh in the cartilage elements of transgenic mice results in an upregulation of PTHrP expression and a delayed onset of hypertrophic differentiation. Noggin treatment of limbs from these mice did not antagonize the effects of Ihh overexpression. Conversely, the promotion of chondrocyte maturation induced by cyclopamine, which blocks Ihh signaling, could not be rescued with BMP2. Thus BMP signaling does not act as a secondary signal of Ihh to induce PTHrP expression or to delay the onset of hypertrophic differentiation. Similar results were obtained using cultures of chick limbs. We further investigated the role of BMP signaling in regulating proliferation and hypertrophic differentiation of chondrocytes and identified three functions of BMP signaling in this process. First we found that maintaining a normal proliferation rate requires BMP and Ihh signaling acting in parallel. We further identified a role for BMP signaling in modulating the expression of IHH: Finally, the application of Noggin to mouse limb explants resulted in advanced differentiation of terminally hypertrophic cells, implicating BMP signaling in delaying the process of hypertrophic differentiation itself. This role of BMP signaling is independent of the Ihh/PTHrP pathway.     

Wnt/beta-catenin signaling in mesenchymal progenitors controls osteoblast and chondrocyte differentiation during vertebrate skeletogenesis

Chondrocytes and osteoblasts are two primary cell types in the skeletal system that are differentiated from common mesenchymal progenitors. It is believed that osteoblast differentiation is controlled by distinct mechanisms in intramembranous and endochondral ossification. We have found that ectopic canonical Wnt signaling leads to enhanced ossification and suppression of chondrocyte formation. Conversely, genetic inactivation of beta-catenin, an essential component transducing the canonical Wnt signaling, causes ectopic formation of chondrocytes at the expense of osteoblast differentiation during both intramembranous and endochondral ossification. Moreover, inactivation of beta-catenin in mesenchymal progenitor cells in vitro causes chondrocyte differentiation under conditions allowing only osteoblasts to form. Our results demonstrate that beta-catenin is essential in determining whether mesenchymal progenitors will become osteoblasts or chondrocytes regardless of regional locations or ossification mechanisms. Controlling Wnt/beta-catenin signaling is a common molecular mechanism underlying chondrocyte and osteoblast differentiation and specification of intramembranous and endochondral ossification.     

L-type calcium channels in growth plate chondrocytes participate in endochondral ossification

Longitudinal bone growth occurs by a process called endochondral ossification that includes chondrocyte proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis. Recent studies have suggested a regulatory role for intracellular Ca(2+) (Ca(i) (2+)) in this process. Indirect studies, using Ca(2+) channel blockers and measurement of Ca(i) (2+), have provided evidence for the existence of Ca(2+) channels in growth plate chondrocytes. Furthermore, voltage-gated Ca(2+) channels (VGCC), and specifically L- and T-type VGCCs, have been recently described in murine embryonic growth plates. Our aim was to assess the effect of L-type Ca(2+) channel blockers on endochondral ossification in an organ culture. We used cultures of fetal rat metatarsal rudiments at 20 days post gestational age, with the addition of the L-type Ca(2+) channel blockers verapamil (10-100 microM) or diltiazem (10-200 microM) to the culture medium. Longitudinal bone growth, chondrocyte differentiation (number of hypertrophic chondrocytes), and cell proliferation (incorporation of tritiated thymidine) were measured. Verapamil dose-dependently decreased growth, the number of hypertrophic chondrocytes, and cell proliferation, at concentrations of 10-100 microM. Growth and the number of hypertrophic chondrocytes decreased significantly with diltiazem at 50-100 microM, and proliferation decreased significantly at concentrations of 10-200 microM. Additionally, there was no increase in apoptosis over physiological levels with either drug. We confirmed the presence of L-type VGCCs in rat rudiments using immunohistochemistry, and showed that the antagonists did not alter the pattern of VGCC expression. In conclusion, our data suggest that L-type Ca(2+) channel activity in growth plate chondrocytes is necessary for normal longitudinal growth, participating in chondrocyte proliferation and differentiation.     

FGF upregulates osteopontin in epiphyseal growth plate chondrocytes: Implications for endochondral ossification

Fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) signaling pathways are essential for normal longitudinal bone growth. Mutations in this receptor lead to various human growth disorders, including Achondroplasia, disproportionately short-limbed dwarfism, characterized by narrowing of the hypertrophic region of the epiphyseal growth plates. Here we find that FGF9, a preferred ligand for FGFR3 rapidly induces the upregulation and secretion of the matrix resident phosphoprotein, osteopontin (OPN) in cultured chicken chondrocytes. This effect was observed as early as two hours post stimulation and at FGF9 concentrations as low as 1.25 ng/ml at both mRNA and protein levels. OPN expression is known to be associated with chondrocyte and osteoblast differentiation and osteoclast activation. Unexpectedly, FGF9 induced OPN was accompanied by inhibition of differentiation and increased proliferation of the treated chondrocytes. Moreover, FGF9 stimulated OPN expression irrespective of the differentiation stage of the cells or culture conditions. In situ hybridization analysis of epiphyseal growth plates from chicken or mice homozygous for the Achondroplasia, G369C/mFGFR3 mutation demonstrated co-localization of OPN expression and osteoclast activity, as evidenced by tartarate resistant acid phosphatase positive cells in the osteochondral junction. We propose that FGF signaling directly activates OPN expression independent of chondrocytes differentiation. This may enhance the recruitment and activation of osteoclasts, and increase in cartilage resorption and remodeling in the chondro-osseus border.     

Proliferation of rabbit chondrocyte and inhibition of IL-1β-induced apoptosis through MEK/ERK signaling by statins

Chondrocyte plays a critical role in endochondral ossification and cartilage repair by maintaining the cartilaginous matrix. Statins have been widely used to lower the cholesterol level in patients with cardiovascular disorders. Previous research has demonstrated potential role of statins in chondrocyte proliferation. This study addresses the proliferation-regulatory effect of lovastatin in rabbit chondrocytes as well as the underlying signaling mechanisms, thereby exploring its potential application in chondrocyte-related disorders, such as cartilage damage and osteoarthritis. Rabbit chondrocytes were treated with lovastatin at multiple concentrations, and the proliferation rate was measured by CCK-8 test. The results showed significant increase in chondrocyte proliferation under lovastatin treatment. Using real-time quantitative PCR, it was observed that the expression levels of COL2A1, SOX-9, Caspase-3, and MMP-3 genes were significantly changed by lovastatin treatment. Western blotting analysis showed that the abundance of COL2A1, SOX-9, MEK1/2, p-MEK1/2, ERK1/2, p-ERK1/2, Caspase-3, and MMP-3 proteins was also significantly influenced by lovastatin treatment. Interleukine-1 beta (IL-1β) is involved in the progression of osteoarthritis (OA) by inducing articular cartilage and chondrocyte aging and senescence. In this study, we observed that lovastatin treatment inhibited IL-1β-induced chondrocyte apoptosis, while the combined treatment of lovastatin and U0126 evidently offset the apoptosis-inhibiting effect of lovastatin in chondrocyte proliferation. The expressional level and protein abundance of COL2A1, SOX-9, MEK1/2, p-MEK1/2, ERK1/2, p-ERK1/2, caspase-3, and MMP-3 genes showed significant alterations under the combined treatment. Together, our results suggested that lovastatin significantly promoted proliferation and inhibited the IL-1β-induced apoptosis in rabbit chondrocytes, which was mediated by the MEK/ERK signaling.     

Inhibitory effect of lactoferrin on hypertrophic differentiation of ATDC5 mouse chondroprogenitor cells

The skeleton is formed by two different mechanisms. In intramembranous ossification, osteoblasts form bone directly, whereas in endochondral ossification, chondrocytes develop a cartilage template, prior to osteoblast-mediated skeletogenesis. Lactoferrin is an iron-binding glycoprotein belonging to the transferrin family. It is known to promote the growth and differentiation of osteoblasts. In this study, we investigated the effects of bovine lactoferrin on the chondrogenic differentiation of ATDC5 chondroprogenitor cells. This mouse embryonic carcinoma-derived clonal cell line provides an in vitro model of chondrogenesis. Lactoferrin treatment of differentiating ATDC5 cells promoted cell proliferation in the initial stage of the differentiation process. However, lactoferrin treatment resulted in inhibition of hypertrophic differentiation, characterized by suppression of alkaline phosphatase activity, aggrecan synthesis and N-cadherin expression. This inhibitory effect was accompanied by sustained Sox9 expression, as well as increased Smad2/3 expression and phosphorylation, suggesting that lactoferrin regulates chondrogenic differentiation by up-regulating the Smad2/3-Sox9 signaling pathway.     

Differential regulation of endochondral bone growth and joint development by FGFR1 and FGFR3 tyrosine kinase domains

Fibroblast growth factor receptors (FGFR) 1 and 3 have distinct mitogenic activities in vitro. In several cultured cell lines, FGFR1 transmits a potent mitogenic signal, whereas FGFR3 has little or no mitogenic activity. However, in other in vitro assays the FGFR3 intracellular domain is comparable with that of FGFR1. In vivo, FGFR3 negatively regulates chondrocyte proliferation and differentiation, and activating mutations are the molecular etiology of achondroplasia. By contrast, FGFR1 transmits a proliferative signal in various cell types in vivo. These observations suggest that inhibition of the proliferating chondrocyte could be a unique property of FGFR3 or, alternatively, a unique property of the proliferating chondrocyte. To test this hypothesis, FGFR1 signaling was activated in the growth plate in cells that normally express FGFR3. Comparison of transgenic mice with an activated FGFR1 signaling pathway with an achondroplasia-like mouse that expresses a similarly activated FGFR3 signaling pathway demonstrated that both transgenes result in a similar achondroplasia-like dwarfism. These data demonstrate that suppression of mitogenic activity by FGFR signaling is a property that is unique to growth plate chondrocytes. Surprisingly, we observed that in transgenic mice expressing an activated FGFR, some synovial joints failed to develop and were replaced by cartilage. The defects in the digit joints phenocopied the symphalangism that occurs in Apert syndrome and the number of affected joints was dependent on transgene dose. In contrast to the phenotype in the growth plate, the joint phenotype was more severe in transgenic mice with an activated FGFR1 signaling pathway. The failure of joint development resulted from expanded chondrification in the presumptive joint space, suggesting a crucial role for FGF signaling in regulating the transition of condensed mesenchyme to cartilage and in defining the boundary of skeletal elements.