Comparative analysis of twin-arginine (Tat)-dependent protein secretion of a heterologous model protein (GFP) in three different Gram-positive bacteria

In contrast to the general protein secretion (Sec) system, the twin-arginine translocation (Tat) export pathway allows the translocation of proteins across the bacterial plasma membrane in a fully folded conformation. Due to this feature, the Tat pathway provides an attractive alternative to the secretory production of heterologous proteins via the Sec system. In this study, the potential for Tat-dependent heterologous protein secretion was compared in the three Gram-positive bacteria Staphylococcus carnosus, Bacillus subtilis, and Corynebacterium glutamicum using green fluorescent protein (GFP) as a model protein. In all three microorganisms, fusion of a Tat signal peptide to GFP resulted in its Tat-dependent translocation across the corresponding cytoplasmic membranes. However, striking differences with respect to the final localization and folding status of the exported GFP were observed. In S. carnosus, GFP was trapped entirely in the cell wall and not released into the supernatant. In B. subtilis, GFP was secreted into the supernatant, however, in an inactive form. In contrast, C. glutamicum effectively secreted active GFP. Our results clearly demonstrate that a comparative evaluation of different Gram-positive host microorganisms is a crucial step on the way to an efficient Tat-mediated secretory production process for a desired heterologous target protein. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. This paper is dedicated to Hermann Sahm on the occasion of his 65th birthday.     

The roles of signal peptide and mature protein in RNase (barnase) export from Bacillus subtilis

Barnase, an extracellular RNAse from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens is secreted post-translationally from B. subtilis. The rate of secretion of barnase from B. subtilis was improved by replacement of the barnase signal peptide with a heterologous signal peptide. However, the barnase signal peptide exported Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase faster than mature barnase. Heat shock of B. subtilis cells did not significantly alter the export of barnase using the barnase signal peptide. The slow rate of export of barnase from B. subtilis is due to both the signal peptide and the mature protein sequence rather than either alone.     

Generalized transposon shuttle mutagenesis in Neisseria gonorrhoeae: a method for isolating epithelial cell invasion-defective mutants

Hybrid genes were constructed to express bifunctional hybrid proteins in which staphyloccal nuclease A with or without an amino-terminai OmpA signal sequence was fused with TEM β-lactamase (at the carboxyl terminal side) using the signal peptide of the major outer membrane lipoprotein of Escherichia coli as an internal linker. The hybrid proteins were found to be inserted in the membrane. Orientation of the hybrid protein with the OmpA signal peptide showed that the nuclease was translocated into the periplasm and the β-lactamase remained in the cytoplasm. This indicates that the cleavable OmpA signal peptide served as a secretory signal for nuclease and the internal lipoprotein signal served as the transmembrane anchor, in the absence of the OmpA signal sequence the topology of the hybrid protein was reversed indicating that the internal lipoprotein signal peptide initially served as the signal peptide for the secretion of the carboxy terminal β-lactamase domain across the membrane and subsequently as a membrane anchoring signal. The role of charged amino acids in the translocation and transmembrane orientation of membrane proteins was also analysed by introducing charged amino acids to either or both sides of the internal lipoprotein signal sequence in the bifunctional hybrid proteins in the absence of the amino-terminal signal sequence. Introduction of two lysine residues at the carboxy-terminal side of the internal signal sequence reversed the topology of the transmembrane protein by translocating the aminoterminal nuclease domain across the membrane, leaving the carboxyl terminal β-actamase domain in the cytoplasm. When three more lysine residues were added to the amino-terminal side of the internal signal sequence of the same construct the membrane topology flipped back to the original orientation. A similar reversion of the topology could be obtained by introducing negatively charged residues at the amino-terminal side of the internal signal sequence. Present results demonstrate for the first time that a bifunctional transmembrane protein can be engineered to assume either of the two opposite orientations and that charge balance around the transmembrane domain is a major factor in controlling the topology of a transmembrane protein.     

Signal peptide mutants ofEscherichia coli

Numerous secretory proteins of the Gram-negative bacteriaE. coli are synthesized as precursor proteins which require an amino terminal extension known as the signal peptide for translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane. Following translocation, the signal peptide is proteolytically cleaved from the precursor to produce the mature exported protein. Signal peptides do not exhibit sequence homology, but invariably share common structural features: (1) The basic amino acid residues positioned at the amino terminus of the signal peptide are probably involved in precursor protein binding to the cytoplasmic membrane surface. (2) A stretch of 10 to 15 nonpolar amino acid residues form a hydrophobic core in the signal peptide which can insert into the lipid bilayer. (3) Small residues capable of -turn formation are located at the cleavage site in the carboxyl terminus of the signal peptide. (4) Charge characteristics of the amino terminal region of the mature protein can also influence precursor protein export. A variety of mutations in each of the structurally distinct regions of the signal peptide have been constructedvia site-directed mutagenesis or isolated through genetic selection. These mutants have shed considerable light on the structure and function of the signal peptide and are reviewed here.     

High-Salinity Growth Conditions Promote Tat-Independent Secretion of Tat Substrates in Bacillus subtilis

The Gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis contains two Tat translocases, which can facilitate transport of folded proteins across the plasma membrane. Previous research has shown that Tat-dependent protein secretion in B. subtilis is a highly selective process and that heterologous proteins, such as the green fluorescent protein (GFP), are poor Tat substrates in this organism. Nevertheless, when expressed in Escherichia coli, both B. subtilis Tat translocases facilitated exclusively Tat-dependent export of folded GFP when the twin-arginine (RR) signal peptides of the E. coli AmiA, DmsA, or MdoD proteins were attached. Therefore, the present studies were aimed at determining whether the same RR signal peptide-GFP precursors would also be exported Tat dependently in B. subtilis. In addition, we investigated the secretion of GFP fused to the full-length YwbN protein, a strict Tat substrate in B. subtilis. Several investigated GFP fusion proteins were indeed secreted in B. subtilis, but this secretion was shown to be completely Tat independent. At high-salinity growth conditions, the Tat-independent secretion of GFP as directed by the RR signal peptides from the E. coli AmiA, DmsA, or MdoD proteins was significantly enhanced, and this effect was strongest in strains lacking the TatAy-TatCy translocase. This implies that high environmental salinity has a negative influence on the avoidance of Tat-independent secretion of AmiA-GFP, DmsA-GFP, and MdoD-GFP. We conclude that as-yet-unidentified control mechanisms reject the investigated GFP fusion proteins for translocation by the B. subtilis Tat machinery and, at the same time, set limits to their Tat-independent secretion, presumably via the Sec pathway.     

Protein synthesis in Bacillus subtilis. II. Selective translation of natural mRNAs and its possible relation to the species-specific inhibition of protein synthesis by lincomycin and erythromycin.

Vacant ribosomal couples from Bacillus subtilis W168 incorporate only very small amounts of amino acids into polypeptides in response to Escherichia coli cellular RNA or bacteriophage f2 RNA, but are observed to form initiation complexes in the presence of f2 RNA. Vacant ribosomal couples from E. coli acquire pressure-resistance, but do not bind fMet-tRNA, when incubated with B. subtilis RNA in the absence of ribosomal wash fraction. The implied mRNA binding in the absence of salt wash fraction, taken with previously reported observations of salt wash-independent translation of mRNAs from Grampositive bacteria, suggests that mRNAs from Gram-positive bacteria have an active functional character which is masked or absent in mRNAs from Gram-negative sources. It is proposed that this property of B. subtilis mRNAs is required by B. subtilis ribosomes for some translational function subsequent to the formation of the 70 S initiation complex, and that f2 RNA, while it is bound by B. subtilis ribosomes in initiation complexes, is not translated because it lacks this feature.The antibiotic lincomycin has been found to inhibit translation of natural mRNAs in vitro in systems from Gram-positive bacteria at concentrations 10 to 100 times lower than those necessary to inhibit translation in systems from Gram-negative species. Lincomycin does not inhibit formation of initiation complexes by vacant couples from B. subtilis or E. coli. Taken with the published findings of other investigators, these results are interpreted as indicating that the first translocation step following assembly of the initiation complex may coincide with a transition between distinct “initiating” and “elongating” states of the ribosome, and that this transition may involve structural elements, and possibly mechanisms, which are different in Gram-positive systems than in Gram-negative systems.A comprehensive model is constructed to account for the results of these studies and for the published findings of other investigators. It is proposed that some feature of Gram-positive mRNA, perhaps a vestige of early protein synthetic systems, is required by the ribosomes of Gram-positive bacteria to facilitate the transition between initiating and elongating ribosomal states. Inhibition of protein synthesis by lincomycin and the similarly species-specific macrolide antibiotic erythromycin is interpreted as an allosteric effect on the transition between initiating and elongating ribosomal states, in which the different binding affinities of ribosomes from Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria for the drugs are related to the functional differences between the two types of systems at this critical step. The implications of this interpretation of interspecies translational specificity for mechanisms of translational control in the cell and for the nature of the divergence of bacterial protein synthesis systems into Gram-positive and Gram-negative types are discussed.     

Export and sorting of theEscherichia coli outer membrane protein OmpA

Results of studies, mostly using the outer membrane, 325 residue protein OmpA, are reviewed which concern its translocation across the plasma membrane and incorporation into the outer membrane ofEscherichia coli. For translocation, neither a unique export signal, acting in a positive fashion within the mature part of the precursor, nor a unique conformation of the precursor is required. Rather, the mature part of a secretory protein has to be export-compatible. Export-incompatibility can be caused by a stretch of 16 (but not 8 or 12) hydrophobic residues, too low a size of the polypeptide (smaller than 75 residue precursors), net positive charge at the N-terminus, or lack of a turn potential at the same site. It is not yet clear whether binding sites for chaperonins (SecB, trigger factor, GroEL) within OmpA are importantin vivo. The mechanism of sorting of outer membrane proteins is not yet understood. The membrane part of OmpA, encompassing residues 1 to about 170, it thought to traverse the membrane eight times in antiparallel -sheet conformation. At least the structure of the last -strand (residues 160–170) is of crucial importance for membrane assembly. It must be amphiphilic or hydrophobic, these properties must extend over at least nine residues, and it must not contain a proline residue at or near its center. Membrane incorporation of OmpA involves a conformational change of the protein and it could be that the last -strand initiates folding and assembly in the outer membrane.     

The roles of signal peptide and mature protein in RNase (barnase) export from Bacillus subtilis

Barnase, an extracellular RNAse from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens is secreted post-translationally from B. subtilis. The rate of secretion of barnase from B. subtilis was improved by replacement of the barnase signal peptide with a heterologous signal peptide. However, the barnase signal peptide exported Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase faster than mature barnase. Heat shock of B. subtilis cells did not significantly alter the export of barnase using the barnase signal peptide. The slow rate of export of barnase from B. subtilis is due to both the signal peptide and the mature protein sequence rather than either alone.     

On the role of the mature part of an Escherichia coli outer membrane protein (OmpA) in translocation across the plasma membrane

The 325-residue OmpA protein, which is synthesized as a precursor with a 21-residue signal sequence, is a polypeptide of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K-12. The signal peptide is able to direct translocation across the plasma membrane of virtually any fragment of this protein. It had, therefore, been concluded that information required for this translocation does not exist within the mature part of the protein. This view has been criticized and it was suggested that our data showed that both the signal sequence and residues within the first 44 amino acid residues of the mature protein contributed to an optimal translocation mechanism. It is shown that, at least as far as is detectable, this is not so. The apparent rates of processing of various pro-OmpA constructs were measured. It was found that these rates did not depend on the presence of amino acid residues 4 through 45 but on the size of the polypeptides; the processing rate decreased with decreasing size. A possible explanation for this phenomenon is offered. While the results do not exclude the possibility that a defined area of the mature protein is involved in optimizing translocation, there is so far no evidence for it.     

Synthesis of OmpA protein of Escherichia coli K12 in Bacillus subtilis

We have inserted a C-terminally truncated gene of the major outer membrane protein OmpA of Escherichia coli downstream from the promoter and signal sequence of the secretory alpha-amylase of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens in a secretion vector of Bacillus subtilis. B. subtilis transformed with the hybrid plasmid synthesized a protein that was immunologically identified as OmpA. All the protein was present in the particulate fraction. The size of the protein compared to the peptide synthesized in vitro from the same template indicated that the alpha-amylase derived signal peptide was not removed; this was verified by N-terminal amino acid sequence determination. The lack of cleavage suggests that there was little or no translocation of OmpA protein across the cytoplasmic membrane. This is an unexpected difference compared with periplasmic proteins, which were both secreted and processed when fused to the same signal peptide. A requirement of a specific component for the export of outer membrane proteins is suggested.     

A double WAP domain (DWD)-containing protein with proteinase inhibitory activity in Chinese white shrimp, Fenneropenaeus chinensis

The whey major component, whey acidic protein (WAP), has one or more WAP domains characterized by a four-disulfide core (4-DSC) structure. These kinds of proteins are involved in multiple functions, including proteinase inhibitor activity, antimicrobial activity, ATPase inhibitor activity, and regulatory function in cell proliferation. Recent research indicates that WAP domain-containing proteins play an important role in the innate immunity of crustaceans. In this study, a novel double WAP domain (DWD)-containing protein named Fc-DWD was found for the first time in Chinese white shrimp, Fenneropenaeus chinensis. The open reading frame of Fc-DWD encodes a protein of 117 amino acids, including a signal peptide of 16 amino acids and two WAP domains. The predicted molecular mass of the mature protein is 12.78 kDa with an estimated pI of 8.49. The first WAP domain, named WAP 1, composed of 49 amino acids locates in the amino-terminal of Fc-DWD, and the second WAP domain, named WAP 2, composed of 45 amino acids locates in the carboxy-terminal. Fc-DWD mRNA was upregulated in hemocytes, hepatopancreas, gills, and stomach of bacteria- and virus-challenged shrimp. Results of the binding assay showed that rFc-DWD could bind to both Gram-negative bacteria and Gram-positive bacteria. rWAP 1 could only bind to Gram-positive bacteria, but rWAP 2 could bind to both Gram-negative and positive bacteria. Moreover, rFc-DWD exhibited proteinase inhibitory activity against the secretory proteinase(s) from Bacillus subtilis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. All of these findings suggest that Fc-DWD may play an important role in enabling the host defense to execute its proteinase inhibitory activity against pathogens.     

Lethal mutations in the structural gene of an outer membrane protein (OmpA) of Escherichia coli K12

Summary The gene ompA encodes a major outer membrane protein of Escherichia coli. Localized mutagenesis of the part of the gene corresponding to the 21-residue signal sequence and the first 45 residues of the protein resulted in alterations which caused cell lysis when expressed. DNA sequence analyses revealed that in one mutant type the last CO₂H-terminal residue of the signal sequence, alanine, was replaced by valine. The proteolytic removal of the signal peptide was much delayed and most of the unprocessed precursor protein was fractioned with the outer membrane. However, this precursor was completely soluble in sodium lauryl sarcosinate which does not solubilize the OmpA protein or fragments thereof present in the outer membrane. Synthesis of the mutant protein did not inhibit processing of the OmpA or OmpF proteins. In the other mutant type, multiple mutational alterations had occurred leading to four amino acid substitutions in the signal sequence and two affecting the first two residues of the mature protein. A reduced rate of processing could not be clearly demonstrated. Membrane fractionation suggested that small amounts of this precursor were associated with the plasma membrane but synthesis of this mutant protein also did not inhibit processing of the wild-type OmpA or OmpF proteins. Several lines of evidence left no doubt that the mature, mutant protein is stably incorporated into the outer membrane. It is suggested that the presence, in the outer membrane, of the mutant precursor protein in the former case, or of the mutant protein in the latter case perturbs the membrane architecture enough to cause cell death.     

Effect of signal peptide changes on the extracellular processing of streptokinase from Escherichia coli : requirement for secondary structure at the cleavage junction

Streptokinase (SK), an extracellular protein from Streptococcus equisimilis, is secreted post-translationally by Escherichia coli using both its native and E. coli-derived transport signals. In this communication we report that cleavage specificity of signal peptidase I, and thus efficiency of secretion, varies in E. coli when SK export is directed by different transport signals. The native (+1) N-terminus of mature SK was retained when it was transported under the control of its own, PelB or LamB signal peptide. However, when translocation of SK was controlled by the OmpA or MalE signal peptide, Ala2 of mature SK was preferred as a cleavage site for the pre-SK processing. Our results indicate that compatibility of the leader peptide with the mature sequences of SK, which fulfils the requirement for a given secondary structure within the cleavage region, is essential for maintaining the correct processing of pre-SK. An OmpA-SK fusion, which results in the deletion of two N-terminal amino acid residues of mature SK, was further studied with respect to the recognition of alternative cleavage site in E. coli. The alanine at +2 in mature SK was changed to glycine or its relative position was changed to +3 by introducing a methionine residue at the +1 position. Both alterations resulted in the correct cleavage of pre-SK at the original OmpA fusion site. In contrast, introduction of an additional alanine at +4, creating three probable cleavage sites (Ala-x-Ala-x-Ala-x-Ala), resulted in the recognition of all three target sites for cleavage, with varying efficiency. The results indicate that the nature of the secondary structure generated at the cleavage junction of pre-SK, resulting from the fusion of different signal peptides, modulates the cleavage specificity of signal peptidase I during extracellular processing of SK. Based on these findings it is proposed that flexibility in the interaction of the active site of signal peptidase I with the cleavage sites of signal peptides may occur when it encounters two or more juxtaposed cleavage sites. Preference for one cleavage site over another, then, may depend on fulfillment of secondary structure requirements in the vicinity of the pre-protein cleavage junction. Received: 22 September 1997 / Accepted: 17 December 1997     

Export incompatibility of N-terminal basic residues in a mature polypeptide of Escherichia coli can be alleviated by optimising the signal peptide

Summary Export of the outer membrane protein, OmpA, across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli was severely inhibited by the presence of two, three, four or six additional basic residues at the N-terminus of the mature polypeptide, but not by three similarily positioned acidic residues. Because a few bacterial proteins do possess basic residues close to the leader peptidase cleavage site and because the type of inhibition described here could pose problems in the construction of hybrid secretory proteins, we also studied means of alleviating this form of export incompatibility. Inhibition was abolished when basic residues were preceded by acidic ones. Also, the processing rates of the mutants with two or six basic residues could be partially restored by increasing the length of the hydrophobic core of the signal peptide. Taking this as a precedent, it is suggested that the structure of the signal peptide is an important feature for maintenance of a reasonable rate of translocation of those exported proteins which possess basic residue(s) at the N-terminus of the mature polypeptide.     

Extracellular Production of a Serratia marcescens Serine Protease in Escherichia coli

The Serratia marcescens serine protease (SSP) is one of the extracellular enzymes secreted from this Gram-negative bacterium. When the ssp gene, which encodes a SSP precursor (preproSSP) composed of a typical NH₂-terminal signal peptide, a mature enzyme domain, and a large COOH-terminal pro-region, is expressed in Escherichia coli, the mature protease is excreted through the outer membrane into the medium. The COOH-terminal pro-region, which is integrated into the outer membrane, provides the essential function for the export of the mature protein across the outer membrane. This is a very simple pathway, in contrast to the general secretory pathway exemplified by the secretion of a pullulanase from Klebsiella oxytoca, in which many separately encoded accessory proteins are required for the transport through the outer membrane. Moreover, the NH₂-terminal region of 71 amino acid residues of the COOH-terminal pro-sequence plays an essential role, as an “intramolecular chaperone,” in the folding of the mature enzyme in the medium. In addition to ssp, the S. marcescens strain contains two ssp homologues encoding proteins similar to SSP in amino acid sequence and size, but with no protease activity. Characterization of the homologue proteins and chimeric proteins between the homologues and SSP, all of which are produced in E. coli, has shown that they are membrane proteins that are localized in the outer membrane in the same manner as for SSP. By use of the COOH-terminal domain of SSP, pseudoazurin was exported to the cell surface of E. coli, which proves the usefulness of the SSP secretory system in the export of foreign proteins across the outer membrane.     

Iron-hydroxamate uptake systems in Bacillus subtilis: identification of a lipoprotein as part of a binding protein-dependent transport system

Bacillus subtilis was shown to utilize three types of hydroxamate siderophores, ferrichromes, ferrioxamines and shizokinen, each of which is taken up by different transport systems. Mutants deficient in the uptake of ferrichrome and/or ferrioxamine B were isolated. The gene fhuD, which was able to complement a mutant defective in ferrichrome uptake, was cloned. The deduced sequence of FhuD showed low but significant homology to the binding proteins FepB, FecB and FhuD of Escherichia coli, which are all components of binding protein-dependent, ferric siderophore transport systems. The first 23 amino acids of FhuD of B. subtilis possessed all characteristics of a lipoprotein signal sequence. The processing of FhuD in E. coli was inhibited by globomycin. Inhibition by globomycin indicated a lipid modification at the N-terminal cysteine in E. coli. It is highly likely that this step may also take place in B. subtilis. As in other binding protein-dependent transport systems of Gram-positive organisms it is proposed that the lack of a periplasm is compensated for by the lipid through which the binding protein is anchored to the cytoplasmic membrane.     

Characterization of the secretion efficiency of a plant signal peptide in Bacillus subtilis.

Summary The ability of the Bacillus subtilis secretion machinery to interact with a heterologous signal peptide was studied using a plant (wheat -amylase) signal peptide. The plant signal peptide was capable of mediating secretion of Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase and B. amyloliquefaciens levansucrase from B. subtilis. This secretion was dependent on the plant signal peptide, as deletion of five amino acids from the hydrophobic core resulted in a block of secretion. Attempts to improve the efficiency of the plant signal peptide in B. subtilis were made by increasing the length of the hydrophobic core from 10 to 16 residues by insertion of 2, 4, 5 or 6 amino acids. None of the alterations improved the secretion efficiency relative to the wild-type plant signal peptide.     

Efficient expression of an alkaline pectate lyase gene from Bacillus subtilis and the characterization of the recombinant protein

The gene encoding a novel alkaline pectate lyase (Apel) from Bacillus subtilis was cloned and expressed in B. subtilis WB600. Apel contained an ORF of 1,260 bp, encoding a signal peptide of 21 amino acids and a mature protein of 399 amino acids with a calculated molecular mass of 45497.9 Da. The mature Apel was structurally related to the enzymes in the polysaccharide lyase family 1. After purification, the recombinant Apel had a specific activity of 445 U mg⁻¹. The enzyme was optimally active at 50°C and pH 9.     

Cloning and characterization of a secY homolog from Chlamydia trachomatis

Characterization of the genes involved in the process of protein translocation is important in understanding their structure-function relationships. However, little is known about the signals that govern chlamydial gene expression and translocation. We have cloned a 1.7 kb HindIII-PstI fragment containing the secY gene of Chlamydia trachomatis. The complete nucleotide sequence reveals three open reading frames. The amino acid sequence shows highest homology with Escherichia coli proteins L15, SecY and S13, corresponding to the spc- ribosomal protein operons. The product of the C. trachomatis secY gene is composed of 457 amino acids with a calculated molecular mass of 50 195 Daltons. Its amino acid sequence shows 27.4% and 35.7% identity to E. coli and Bacillus subtilis SecY proteins, respectively. The distribution of hydrophobic amino acids in the C. trachomatis secY gene product is suggestive of it being an integral membrane protein with ten transmembrane segments, the second, third and seventh membrane segments sharing > 45% identity with E. coli SceY. Our results suggest that despite evolutionary differences, eubacteria share a similar protein export apparatus.     

Aperiplasmic protein (Skp) of Escherichia coli selectively binds a class of outer membrane proteins

A search was performed for a periplasmic molecular chaperone which may assist outer membrane proteins of Escherichia coli on their way from the cytoplasmic to the outer membrane. Proteins of the periplasmic space were fractionated on an affinity column with sepharose-bound outer membrane porin OmpF. A 17kDa polypeptide was the predominant protein retained by this column. The corresponding gene was found in a gene bank; it encodes the periplasmic protein Skp. The protein was isolated and it could be demonstrated that it bound outer membrane proteins, following SDS-PAGE, with high selectivity. Among these were OmpA, OmpC, OmpF and the maltoporin LamB. The chromosomal skp gene was inactivated by a deletion causing removal of most of the signal peptide plus 107 residues of the 141-residue mature protein. The mutant was viable but possessed much-reduced concentrations of outer membrane proteins. This defect was fully restored by a plasmid-borne skp gene which may serve as a periplasmic chaperone.