Molecular phylogeny of the genus Hordeum using three chloroplast DNA sequences.

The genus Hordeum consists of three cytotypes (2x, 4x, and 6x). Its reproductive isolation has been incomplete between closely related species and hence the genetic relationship is reticulate and complex. We used 32 taxa of Hordeum and three chloroplast DNA sequences, matK, atpB-rbcL, and trnL-trnF in the current study. Molecular phylogenetic analysis based on sequence data of the three chloroplast DNA regions clearly demonstrated genetic relationships among taxa and origin of polypoids. The formation of H. secalinum likely involved hybridization between Hordeum marinum subsp. marinum and a Eurasian diploid possessing the H genome. The formation of hexaploid Hordeum brachyantherum involved hybridization between tetraploid H. brachyantherum and diploid H. marinum subsp. gussoneanum. The formation of three tetraploids, H. brachyantherum, Hordeum jubatum, and Hordeum guatemalense, probably involved hybridization between H. brachyantherum subsp. californicum and an altered H genome diploid. The formation of Hordeum arizonicum involved the two taxa Hordeum pusillum and H. jubatum.     

Genome discrimination by in situ hybridization in Icelandic species of Elymus and Elytrigia (Poaceae: Triticeae).

The genome constitution of Icelandic Elymus caninus, E. alaskanus, and Elytrigia repens was examined by fluorescence in situ hybridization using genomic DNA and selected cloned sequences as probes. Genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) of Hordeum brachyantherum ssp. californicum (diploid, H genome) probe confirmed the presence of an H genome in the two tetraploid Elymus species and identified its presence in the hexaploid Elytrigia repens. The H chromosomes were painted uniformly except for some chromosomes of Elytrigia repens which showed extended unlabelled pericentromeric and subterminal regions. A mixture of genomic DNA from H. marinum ssp. marinum (diploid, Xa genome) and H. murinum ssp. leporinum (tetraploid, Xu genome) did not hybridize to chromosomes of the Elymus species or Elytrigia repens, confirming that these genomes were different from the H genome. The St genomic probe from Pseudoroegneria spicata (diploid) did not discriminate between the genomes of the Elymus species, whereas it produced dispersed and spotty hybridization signals most likely on the two St genomes of Elytrigia repens. Chromosomes of the two genera Elymus and Elytrigia showed different patterns of hybridization with clones pTa71 and pAes41, while clones pTa1 and pSc119.2 hybridized only to Elytrigia chromosomes. Based on FISH with these genomic and cloned probes, the two Elymus species are genomically similar, but they are evidently different from Elytrigia repens. Therefore the genomes of Icelandic Elymus caninus and E. alaskanus remain as StH, whereas the genomes of Elytrigia repens are proposed as XXH.     

Genetic variation in three species of Hordeum,and the selection of accessions for the Barley Core Collection

Starch gel electrophoresis of isozymes was used to investigate the level and distribution of genetic variation in accessions of three wild, diploid Hordeum species. Allelic variation was assessed for seven isozyme loci and used in the statistical analysis of 18 accessions of Hordeum brachyantherum subsp. californicum, 29 accessions of H. murinum subsp. glaucum and 11 accessions of H. pusillum. A major purpose with this study was to evaluate the selection of accessions for the international Barley Core Collection, complementing existing passport data. Allelic variation was found in all three species. The variation was mainly between accessions, as most accessions were fixed for certain alleles. Since all three species are self-pollinated, this was anticipated. The fact that the accessions have undergone one or several regeneration cycles from a rather limited number of individuals, after being collected, likely also have reduced the variation. The accessions were clustered by subjecting the genetic distances between them to UPGMA statistical treatment. The clusters in the dendrograms displayed for H. brachyantherum subsp. californicum and H. pusillum distinct patterns related to the geographical origin of the accessions. The accessions of H. murinum subsp. glaucum were less variable than the other two, and did not reveal such a clear pattern. By comparing the already made, geographically based, selection of accessions with the results from this study, it was evident that the selection had worked fairly well for H. brachyantherum subsp. californicum, but less so for the other two species.     

The ancestry of Hordeum depressum (Poaceae, Triticeae)

Based on morphological, cytological, and molecular data, three diploid Hordeum species have by various authors been suggested to may have participated in the ancestry of the tetraploid H. depressum . In order to test the different hypotheses we undertook hybridizations between the proposed taxa, H. brachyantherum ssp. californicum, H. intercedens , and H. pusillum . Autoploids and amphiploids were achieved by treatment of young shoots with colchicine. These were then hybridized with H. depressum and the resulting hybrid plants were tested for fertility. The results strongly indicate that H. depressum arose as a consequence of hybridization between H. brachyantherum ssp. californicum and H. intercedens , probably with H. brachyantherum ssp. californicum as the female parent.     

Variation and taxonomy in Hordeum depressum and in the H. brachyantherum complex (Poaceae)

The variation pattern in the perennial Hordeum brachyantherum complex and in the annual H. depressum are described. The diploid form of H. brachyantherum s. lat., endemic to California in USA, previously recognized as a separate species is here treated as a subspecies ( H. brachyantherum ssp. californicum ). Despite its restricted distribution it shows a considerable variation and overlap in morphology with the tetraploid ssp. brachyantherum , and no unambiguous determination based on morphology between the two tax a is possible. The tetraploid cytotype has a large distribution area in western North America and easternmost Asia and a very wide morphological variation. It has also a small disjunct distribution area in easternmost Canada. A single hexaploid population from California is referred to ssp. brachyantherum .     

Molecular phylogeny of diploid Hordeum species and incongruence between chloroplast and nuclear datasets

The phylogeny of diploid Hordeum species has been studied using both chloroplast and nuclear gene sequences. However, the studies of different nuclear datasets of Hordeum species often arrived at similar conclusions, whereas the studies of different chloroplast DNA data generally resulted in inconsistent conclusions. Although the monophyly of the genus is well supported by both morphological and molecular data, the intrageneric phylogeny is still a matter of controversy. To better understand the evolutionary history of Hordeum species, two chloroplast gene loci (trnD-trnT intergenic spacer and rps16 gene) and one nuclear marker (thioreoxin-like gene (HTL)) were used to explore the phylogeny of Hordeum species. Two obviously different types of trnD-trnT sequences were observed, with an approximately 210 base pair difference between these two types: one for American species, another for Eurasian species. The trnD-trnT data generally separated the diploid Hordeum species into Eurasian and American clades, with the exception of Hordeum marinum subsp. gussoneanum. The rps16 data also grouped most American species together and suggested that Hordeum flexuosum has a different plastid type from the remaining American species. The nuclear gene HTL data clearly divided Hordeum species into two clades: the Xu+H genome clade and the Xa+I genome clade. Within clades, H genome species were well separated from the Xu species, and the I genome species were well separated from the Xa genome species. The incongruence between chloroplast and nuclear datasets was found and discussed.     

Interspecific hybridization with Hordeum depressum (Poaceae)

Hordeum depressum is a distinct, reproductively isolated, tetraploid species. The study of meiosis in hybrids with the closest congeneric relatives revealed intermediate to low pairing with most species. The exceptions are Hordeum brachyantherum ssp. californicum and H. arizonicum. H. depressum , probably share one highly similar genome with ssp. californicum and perhaps two with H. arizonicum . However, it is difficult to draw firm conclusions based only on meiotic figures, since the pairing may be disturbed by high autosyndetic pairing between the H. depressurn genomes.     

A new combination in Hordeum (Triticeae, Poaceae)

A new combination is presented in Hordeum viz. H. brachyantherum ssp. californicum comb. & stat. nov., an endemic Californian diploid.     

The 5S DNA sequences in Hordeum bogdanii and in the H. brevisubulatum complex, and the evolution and the geographic dispersal of the diploid Hordeum species (Triticeae: Poaceae).

The molecular diversity of 5S rDNA from the closely related Asiatic diploid species, Hordeum bogdanii and the H. brevisubulatum complex has been catalogued and analysed. As in previous studies in Hordeum, we found that the sequences are constrained in such an manner that unit classes can be defined. The long H1 unit class, known to occur in all Eurasian species, was frequently found in these 2 taxa. In addition, we identified a new unit class, called the short H3 to reflect the H genome found in these 2 taxa. Although the 2 taxa are very close morphologically, the variation in the long H1 DNA units is constrained to such a great degree that, in many cases, the accessions in a unit class from a single species are clustered. In H. bogdanii, the majority of the sequences are grouped in this manner, whereas in the H. brevisubulatum complex, the tendency to be constrained is lower in some but not all subspecies. These results support keeping H. brevisubulatum ssp. violaceum and ssp. iranicum as 1 species with the long H1 and short H1 unit classes, while retaining ssp. nevskianum and ssp. turkestanicum in the H. brevisubulatum complex. We have summarized our work on the presence/absence of the 10 unit classes found in all diploid species of Hordeum. A phylogenetic analysis, based strictly on the presence/absence of unit classes, indicated clearly that all the South American diploids and all the North American diploids possess long H2 and long Y2 unit classes and, except for H. californicum and H. pusillum, which contain long H1 in addition to the long H2 and long Y2 classes, are devoid of the long H1 unit class. This suggests that the gene gain/loss process from a common ancestor has been concomitant with intercontinental dispersal between the Old and the New Worlds.     

Progenitor-derivative relationships of Hordeum polyploids (Poaceae, Triticeae) inferred from sequences of TOPO6, a nuclear low-copy gene region

Polyploidization is a major mechanism of speciation in plants. Within the barley genus Hordeum, approximately half of the taxa are polyploids. While for diploid species a good hypothesis of phylogenetic relationships exists, there is little information available for the polyploids (4×, 6×) of Hordeum. Relationships among all 33 diploid and polyploid Hordeum species were analyzed with the low-copy nuclear marker region TOPO6 for 341 Hordeum individuals and eight outgroup species. PCR products were either directly sequenced or cloned and on average 12 clones per individual were included in phylogenetic analyses. In most diploid Hordeum species TOPO6 is probably a single-copy locus. Most sequences found in polyploid individuals phylogenetically cluster together with sequences derived from diploid species and thus allow the identification of parental taxa of polyploids. Four groups of sequences occurring only in polyploid taxa are interpreted as footprints of extinct diploid taxa, which contributed to allopolyploid evolution. Our analysis identifies three key species involved in the evolution of the American polyploids of the genus. (i) All but one of the American tetraploids have a TOPO6 copy originating from the Central Asian diploid H. roshevitzii, the second copy clustering with different American diploid species. (ii) All hexaploid species from the New World have a copy of an extinct close relative of H. californicum and (iii) possess the TOPO6 sequence pattern of tetraploid H. jubatum, each with an additional copy derived from different American diploids. Tetraploid H. bulbosum is an autopolyploid, while the assumed autopolyploid H. brevisubulatum (4×, 6×) was identified as allopolyploid throughout most of its distribution area. The use of a proof-reading DNA polymerase in PCR reduced the proportion of chimerical sequences in polyploids in comparison to Taq polymerase.     

Phylogenetic relationships in Elymus (Poaceae: Triticeae) based on the nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacer and chloroplast trnL-F sequences

To estimate the phylogenetic relationship of polyploid Elymus in Triticeae, nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacer (ITS) and chloroplast trnL-F sequences of 45 Elymus accessions containing various genomes were analysed with those of five Pseudoroegneria (St), two Hordeum (H), three Agropyron (P) and two Australopyrum (W) accessions. The ITS sequences revealed a close phylogenetic relationship between the polyploid Elymus and species from the other genera. The ITS and trnL-F trees indicated considerable differentiation of the StY genome species. The trnL-F sequences revealed an especially close relationship of Pseudoroegneria to all Elymus species included. Both the ITS and trnL-F trees suggested multiple origins and recurrent hybridization of Elymus species. The results suggested that: the St, H, P, and W genomes in polyploid Elymus were donated by Pseudoroegneria, Hordeum, Agropyron and Australopyrum, respectively, and the St and Y genomes may have originated from the same ancestor; Pseudoroegneria was the maternal donor of the polyploid Elymus; and some Elymus species showed multiple origin and experienced recurrent hybridization.     

Ancestry of American polyploid Hordeum species with the I genome inferred from 5S and 18S-25S rDNA

* BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The genus Hordeum exists at three ploidy levels (2x, 4x and 6x) and presents excellent material for investigating the patterns of polyploid evolution in plants. Here the aim was to clarify the ancestry of American polyploid species with the I genome. * METHODS: Chromosomal locations of 5S and 18S-25S ribosomal RNA genes were determined by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). In both polyploid and diploid species, variation in 18S-25S rDNA repeated sequences was analysed by the RFLP technique. * KEY RESULTS: Six American tetraploid species were divided into two types that differed in the number of rDNA sites and RFLP profiles. Four hexaploid species were similar in number and location of both types of rDNA sites, but the RFLP profiles of 18S-25S rDNA revealed one species, H. arizonicum, with a different ancestry. * CONCLUSIONS: Five American perennial tetraploid species appear to be alloploids having the genomes of an Asian diploid H. roshevitzii and an American diploid species. The North American annual tetraploid H. depressum is probably a segmental alloploid combining the two closely related genomes of American diploid species. A hexaploid species, H. arizonicum, involves a diploid species, H. pusillum, in its ancestry; both species share the annual growth habit and are distributed in North America. Polymorphisms of rDNA sites detected by FISH and RFLP analyses provide useful information to infer the phylogenetic relationships of I-genome Hordeum species because of their highly conserved nature during polyploid evolution.     

Molecular phylogeny of RPB2 gene reveals multiple origin, geographic differentiation of H genome, and the relationship of the Y genome to other genomes in Elymus species

It has been hypothesized from isozymic and cytological studies of Elymus species that the Old and New World taxa may be of separate origin of the H genome in the StH genome species. To test this hypothesis, and estimate the phylogenetic relationships of polyploid Elymus species within the Triticeae, the second largest subunit of RNA polymerase II (RPB2) sequence of 36 Elymus accessions containing StH or StY genomes was analyzed with those of Pseudoroegneria (St), Hordeum (H), Agropyron (P), Australopyrum (W), Lophopyrum(Ee), Thinopyrum(Eb) and Dasypyrum (V). Our data indicated that the H genome in Elymus species is differentiated in accordance with geographical origin, and that the Eurasian and American StH genome species have independent alloploid origins with different H-genome donors. Phylogenetic analysis of Y genome sequences with other genome donors (St, H, P, W) of Elymus revealed that W and P genomes are sister to Y genome with a 87% bootstrap support, and that StY and StH species group might have acquired their RPB2 St sequences from distinct Pseudoroegneria gene pools. Our data did not support the suggestion that the St and Y genomes have the same origin as put forward in a previous study using ITS data. Our result provides some insight on the origin of Y genome and its relationship to other genomes in Elymus.     

A study of 28 Elymus species using repetitive DNA sequences.

Four repetitive DNA sequences cloned from the barley (Hordeum vulgare) genome and common for different Triticeae species were used for a molecular study of phylogenetic relationships among 28 Elymus species. Two wild Hordeum species (H genome), two Pseudoroegneria species (S genome), Agropyron cristatum (P genome), and Australopyrum velutinum (W genome) were included as genomic representatives for the genomes that supposedly were involved in the evolution of the genus Elymus. Our results are essentially congruent with the genomic classification system. This study demonstrates that Elymus is not a monophyletic genus. Based on an analysis of Southern blot hybridization we could discriminate between SY and SH species owing to the strong specific hybridization pattern of the H genome. Hexaploid SYH species gave a hybridization pattern similar to SH species for the same reason. The results support the genomic composition of Elymus batalinii as SYP and also indicated the presence of at least one H genome in Elymus enysii with a hitherto unknown genomic constitution. Elymus erianthus had a hybridization pattern distinctly different from all other species in the investigation. Key words : Elymus, RFLP, phylogeny, repetitive DNA.     

Phylogenetic analysis in some Hordeum species (Triticeae; Poaceae) based on two single-copy nuclear genes encoding acetyl-CoA carboxylase

We investigate the phylogenetic relationship, and evolutionary history of 18 diploid and polyploid Hordeum species including 22 taxa based on two single-copy nuclear ACC1 and ACC2 genes using maximum parsimony, maximum likelihood, and Bayesian inference. The results of molecular phylogenetic analysis demonstrated genetic relationships among taxa and origin of polyploids. Our phylogenetic analyses revealed a clear alloploid origin of Hordeum capense, with Eurasian Hordeum marinum subsp. gussoneanum as the Xa genome donor and diploid Asian Hordeum roshevitzii as the H genome donor. The formation of hexaploid Hordeum lechleri likely involves hybridization between tetraploid Hordeum brachyantherum subsp. brachyantherum and a diploid possessing the I genome. The Acc1 and Acc2 gene data analyses suggested that Siberian Hordeum bogdanii might have be the common ancestor of the diploid New World Hordeum species. Perennial diploid South American species, Hordeum comosum was the first-diverging group within the clade of diploid American species in the analyses.     

Phylogenetic relationships in Leymus (Poaceae: Triticeae) revealed by the nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacer and chloroplast trnL-F sequences

Using the nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacer (ITS) sequences and the chloroplasttrnL-F sequence, phylogeneic analysis was performed on 57 accessions of species in the tribe Triticeae including 13 Leymus species (N(s)) with different ploidy levels and 40 diploid species from 18 genera. The ITS sequences revealed that ployploid Leymus has close phylogentic relationships with Psathyrostachys and an undefined genus in Triticeae. The trnL-F tree demonstrated close relationships between certain Leymus species and Psathyrostachys, and other Leymus species distributed in North America were far from Psathyrostachys. Based on these results, it is unlikely that the unknown genome in Leymus species originated from one of the sampled diploid species in the present study. The maternal donor of all the Leymus species with a natural distribution in Eurasia were N(s) genome. Furthermore, Elymus californicus should be transferred from the genus Elymus to Leymus.     

Phylogeny and molecular evolution of the Acc1 gene within the StH genome species in Triticeae (Poaceae)

To estimate the phylogeny and molecular evolution of a single-copy gene encoding plastid acetyl-CoA carboxylase (Acc1) within the StH genome species, two Acc1 homoeologous sequences were isolated from nearly all the sampled StH genome species and were analyzed with those from 35 diploid taxa representing 19 basic genomes in Triticeae. Sequence diversity patterns and genealogical analysis suggested that (1) the StH genome species from the same areas or neighboring geographic regions are closely related to each other; (2) the Acc1 gene sequences of the StH genome species from North America and Eurasia are evolutionarily distinct; (3) Dasypyrum has contributed to the nuclear genome of Elymus repens and Elymus mutabilis; (4) the StH genome polyploids have higher levels of sequence diversity in the H genome homoeolog than the St genome homoeolog; and (5) the Acc1 sequence may evolve faster in the polyploid species than in the diploids. Our result provides some insight on evolutionary dynamics of duplicate Acc1 gene, the polyploidy speciation and phylogeny of the StH genome species.     

Genetic diversity and phylogeny in Hystrix (Poaceae, Triticeae) and related genera inferred from Giemsa C-banded karyotypes

The phylogenetic relationships of 15 taxa from Hystrix and the related genera Leymus (NsXm), Elymus (StH), Pseudoroegneria (St), Hordeum (H), Psathyrostachys (Ns), and Thinopyrum (E) were examined by using the Giemsa C-banded karyotype. The Hy. patula C-banding pattern was similar to those of Elymus species, whereas C-banding patterns of the other Hystrix species were similar to those of Leymus species. The results suggest high genetic diversity within Hystrix, and support treating Hy. patula as E. hystrix L., and transferring Hy. coreana, Hy. duthiei ssp. duthiei and Hy. duthiei ssp. longearistata to the genus Leymus. On comparing C-banding patterns of Elymus species with their diploid ancestors (Pseudoroegneria and Hordeum), there are indications that certain chromosomal re-arrangements had previously occurred in the St and H genomes. Furthermore, a comparison of the C-banding patterns of the Hystrix and Leymus species with the potential diploid progenitors (Psathyrostachys and Thinopyrum) suggests that Hy. coreana and some Leymus species are closely related to the Ns genome of Psathyrostachys, whereas Hy. duthiei ssp. duthiei, Hy. duthiei ssp. longearistata and some of the Leymus species have a close relationship with the E genome. The results suggest a multiple origin of the polyploid genera Hystrix and Leymus.     

Ancient differentiation of the H and I haplomes in diploid Hordeum species based on 5S rDNA.

5S rDNA clones from 12 South American diploid Hordeum species containing the HH genome and 3 Eurasian diploid Hordeum species containing the II genome, including the cultivated barley Hordeum vulgare, were sequenced and their sequence diversity was analyzed. The 374 sequenced clones were assigned to "unit classes", which were further assigned to haplomes. Each haplome contained 2 unit classes. The naming of the unit classes reflected the haplomes, viz. both the long H1 and short I1 unit classes were identified with II genome diploids, and both the long H2 and long Y2 unit classes were recognized in South American HH genome diploids. Based upon an alignment of all sequences or alignments of representative sequences, we tested several evolutionary models, and then subjected the parameters of the models to a series of maximum likelihood (ML) analyses and various tests, including the molecular clock, and to a Bayesian evolutionary inference analysis using Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC). The best fitting model of nucleotide substitution was the HKY+G (Hasegawa, Kishino, Yano 1985 model with the Gamma distribution rates of nucleotide substitutions). Results from both ML and MCMC imply that the long H1 and short I unit classes found in the II genome diploids diverged from each other at the same rate as the long H2 and long Y2 unit classes found in the HH genome diploids. The divergence among the unit classes, estimated to be circa 7 million years, suggests that the genus Hordeum may be a paleopolyploid.     

Phylogenetic analysis of North American Elymus and the monogenomic Triticeae (Poaceae) using three chloroplast DNA data sets.

Although the monogenomic genera of the Triticeae have been analyzed in numerous biosystematic studies, the allopolyploid genera have not been as extensively studied within a phylogenetic framework. We focus on North American species of Elymus, which, under the current genomic system of classification, are almost all allotetraploid, combining the St genome of Pseudoroegneria with the H genome of Hordeum. We analyze new and previously published chloroplast DNA data from Elymus and from most of the monogenomic genera of the Triticeae in an attempt to identify the maternal genome donor of Elymus. We also present a cpDNA phylogeny for the monogenomic genera that includes more data than, and thus builds on, those previously published. The chloroplast DNA data indicate that Pseudoroegneria is the maternal genome donor to all but one of the Elymus individuals. There is little divergence among the Elymus and Pseudoroegneria chloroplast genomes, and as a group, they show little divergence from the rest of the Triticeae. Within the monogenomic Triticeae, the problematic group Thinopyrum is resolved as monophyletic on the chloroplast DNA tree. At the intergeneric level, the data reveal several deeper-level relationships that were not resolved by previous cpDNA trees.