Transport-coupled ubiquitination of the borate transporter BOR1 for its boron-dependent degradation

Plants take up and translocate nutrients through transporters. In Arabidopsis thaliana, the borate exporter BOR1 acts as a key transporter under boron (B) limitation in the soil. Upon sufficient-B supply, BOR1 undergoes ubiquitination and is transported to the vacuole for degradation, to avoid overaccumulation of B. However, the mechanisms underlying B-sensing and ubiquitination of BOR1 are unknown. In this study, we confirmed the lysine-590 residue in the C-terminal cytosolic region of BOR1 as the direct ubiquitination site and showed that BOR1 undergoes K63-linked polyubiquitination. A forward genetic screen identified that amino acid residues located in vicinity of the substrate-binding pocket of BOR1 are essential for the vacuolar sorting. BOR1 variants that lack B-transport activity showed a significant reduction of polyubiquitination and subsequent vacuolar sorting. Coexpression of wild-type (WT) and a transport-defective variant of BOR1 in the same cells showed degradation of the WT but not the variant upon sufficient-B supply. These findings suggest that polyubiquitination of BOR1 relies on its conformational transition during the transport cycle. We propose a model in which BOR1, as a B transceptor, directly senses the B concentration and promotes its own polyubiquitination and vacuolar sorting for quick and precise maintenance of B homeostasis.

The borate transporter BOR1 senses the boron concentration through its borate transport activity for K63-linked polyubiquitination and subsequent degradation.     

Ubiquitin initiates sorting of Golgi and plasma membrane proteins into the vacuolar degradation pathway

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: In yeast and mammals, many plasma membrane (PM) proteins destined for degradation are tagged with ubiquitin. These ubiquitinated proteins are internalized into clathrin-coated vesicles and are transported to early endosomal compartments. There, ubiquitinated proteins are sorted by the endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT) machinery into the intraluminal vesicles of multivesicular endosomes. Degradation of these proteins occurs after endosomes fuse with lysosomes/lytic vacuoles to release their content into the lumen. In plants, some PM proteins, which cycle between the PM and endosomal compartments, have been found to be ubiquitinated, but it is unclear whether ubiquitin is sufficient to mediate internalization and thus acts as a primary sorting signal for the endocytic pathway. To test whether plants use ubiquitin as a signal for the degradation of membrane proteins, we have translationally fused ubiquitin to different fluorescent reporters for the plasma membrane and analyzed their transport. RESULTS: Ubiquitin-tagged PM reporters localized to endosomes and to the lumen of the lytic vacuole in tobacco mesophyll protoplasts and in tobacco epidermal cells. The internalization of these reporters was significantly reduced if clathrin-mediated endocytosis was inhibited by the coexpression of a mutant of the clathrin heavy chain, the clathrin hub. Surprisingly, a ubiquitin-tagged reporter for the Golgi was also transported into the lumen of the vacuole. Vacuolar delivery of the reporters was abolished upon inhibition of the ESCRT machinery, indicating that the vacuolar delivery of these reporters occurs via the endocytic transport route. CONCLUSIONS: Ubiquitin acts as a sorting signal at different compartments in the endomembrane system to target membrane proteins into the vacuolar degradation pathway: If displayed at the PM, ubiquitin triggers internalization of PM reporters into the endocytic transport route, but it also mediates vacuolar delivery if displayed at the Golgi. In both cases, ubiquitin-tagged proteins travel via early endosomes and multivesicular bodies to the lytic vacuole. This suggests that vacuolar degradation of ubiquitinated proteins is not restricted to PM proteins but might also facilitate the turnover of membrane proteins in the early secretory pathway.     

Ubiquitination of transporters at the forefront of plant nutrition

In plants, the tight regulation of plasma membrane transporters is essential to maintain nutrient homeostasis. The mechanisms controlling the abundance of transporters, and other integral plasma membrane proteins, now come to light. Ubiquitination appears as a major signal initiating cargo endocytosis and sorting into multivesicular bodies prior to degradation in the vacuole. We have indeed demonstrated that the root iron transporter IRT1 is subjected to ubiquitin-dependent trafficking in root epidermal cells. This control is crucial to keep IRT1 levels at the cell surface low and to cope with the toxicity associated with other readily available metal substrates of IRT1. Our work combined with recent report on the BOR1 boron transporter establishes ubiquitination as a conserved mechanism of plasma membrane protein trafficking in plants and highlights its importance for plant nutrition.Key words: Endocytosis, Iron, IRT1, BOR1, Degradation, monoubiquitinPlasma membrane transporters play a pivotal role in all living organisms by providing the cell surface with a selective barrier for a wide range of nutrients, small molecules and ions. These transport proteins are very often under the control of sophisticated molecular mechanisms to adapt to changing environmental conditions and to ensure optimal absorption of their cognate substrates. Although the molecular events controlling the abundance of plasma membrane proteins at the cell surface are largely documented in non-plant model organisms, the situation in plants is much less understood. This is particularly true for the well-established ubiquitin-dependent endocytosis and sorting in late endosomes of plasma membrane proteins, for which evidence is still lacking in plants.Recently, we showed that the root iron transporter IRT1 from the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana, which mediates Fe²⁺ and other divalent metal absorption from the soil,¹ surprisingly localizes to the early endosomes/trans-Golgi network compartment (EE/TGN).² Pharmacological interference with vesicular trafficking highlighted the dynamic behavior of IRT1 in root epidermal cells. IRT1, although localized to EE/TGN, rapidly cycles to the plasma membrane to perform iron uptake from the soil. We demonstrated that IRT1 is ubiquitinated in vivo and carries monoubiquitin moieties on several cytosol-exposed lysine residues, a process known as multiubiquitination. Reminiscent of the ubiquitin-dependent endocytosis and degradation of animal receptor tyrosine kinases and yeast nutrient permeases,^3,4 we hypothesized that IRT1 ubiquitination may control its dynamics in the cell. Transgenic plants expressing a mutant version of IRT1 in which two lysine residues were replaced by arginine (IRT1_K154K179R) indeed show accumulation of IRT1 protein at the plasma membrane. This clearly establishes the role of ubiquitination in driving IRT1 intracellular trafficking.Whether the cell surface localization of IRT1_K154K179R reflects a role of ubiquitination in the internalization from the plasma membrane, in the sorting at the multivesicular bodies, or both is an open question. Interestingly, IRT1_K154K179R-expressing plants displayed dramatic growth reduction, likely due to uncontrolled uptake of metals. Altogether, our work demonstrates the existence of monoubiquitin-dependent endocytosis in plants and reveals its crucial role in keeping IRT1 level at the plasma membrane low to prevent metal toxicity. The uptake of Fe²⁺ by IRT1 indeed requires the prior reduction of Fe³⁺ by the FRO2 ferric chelate reductase, whose activity was shown to be limiting for iron uptake.^5–7 The amount of Fe²⁺ produced by FRO2 is therefore low and favors the uptake of other substrates of IRT1 such as Zn²⁺, Mn²⁺, Co²⁺ and Cd²⁺. Limiting the pool of IRT1 at the plasma membrane by ubiquitin-dependent endocytosis appears as a protective mechanism to limit the absorption of readily available metals other than iron. This also highlights the necessity for a strict co-regulation of FRO2 and IRT1 to optimize iron uptake. The overexpression of IRT1 in transgenic Arabidopsis plants consequently leads to a strong overload of Zn and Mn in roots and aerial tissues, while iron only very mildly accumulates. This, combined with the existence of point mutants of IRT1 with altered selectivity,⁸ offers the long term perspective of engineering transgenic plants designed to phytoremediate polluted soil for a given element.Only a handful of plasma membrane proteins were shown to be ubiquitinated in plants, including the PIN2 auxin efflux carrier,⁹ the FLS2 flagellin receptor¹⁰ and the PIP2;1 water channel.¹¹ Yet, the role of ubiquitination for such proteins remained unclear until very recently. Along with our recent report of monoubiquitin-dependent trafficking of IRT1 came a similar study on the Arabidopsis BOR1 boron transporter. Like iron, boron is essential for plants but toxic when present in excess. BOR1 has been previously shown to be regulated by boron-inducible endocytosis and degradation in the vacuole.¹² Kasai et al.¹³ now showed that high boron concentrations induced BOR1 mono- or diubiquitination and that mutation of a single lysine residue affected BOR1 trafficking to the vacuole.¹³ In yeast and mammals, ubiquitination has been shown to trigger the internalization of plasma membrane proteins from the cell surface and sorting in multivesicular bodies/late endosomes (MVBs/LEs) for targeting and degradation in the vacuole/lysosomes,^3,4 although recent reports emphasize the role of ubiquitination in later stages of endocytosis.¹⁴ Similarly, BOR1 ubiquitination is not required for endocytosis from the plasma membrane, this step being probably mediated by tyrosine-based motives found on its cytosolic face,¹⁵ but is crucial for the sorting of BOR1 in multivesicular bodies for subsequent targeting and degradation in the vacuole.¹³It will be interesting to pinpoint the exact role of IRT1 ubiquitination in either the control of its internalization from the plasma membrane, the targeting to the internal vesicles of multivesicular bodies for delivery to the vacuole, or both. Hence, ubiquitination constitutes a conserved process controlling the localization and the fate of plasma membrane proteins, and appears as a critical mechanism to maintain iron and boron homeostasis in plants (Fig. 1). The quest for the machinery driving the ubiquitination of plasma membrane proteins has now begun. Already, the PUB12 and PUB13 U-box E3 ubiquitin ligases have just been reported to polyubiquitinate the FLS2 flagellin receptor, driving its flagellin-dependent degradation and preventing excessive or prolonged activation of immune responses.¹⁶ Whether these E3 ubiquitin ligases, or members from the same family, act on other plasma membrane proteins will have to be determined in the future. This will provide breakthrough information on how the dynamics and the fate of integral plasma membrane proteins are driven, and will highlight the importance of ubiquitination in important biological processes such as nutrition, response to pathogens and hormone transport.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Ubiquitin-dependent trafficking of plasma membrane proteins in plants. Diagram illustrating the role of ubiquitination throughout the endocytic pathway of plant plasma membrane proteins with the example of IRT 1 (in orange) and BOR1 (in blue). IRT 1 multiubiquitination (red circles) controls either its internalization from the plasma membrane and/or its sorting in late endosomes required for vacuolar targeting, to maintain IRT 1 low at the plasma membrane independently of iron nutrition. BOR1 mono- or diubiquitination (yellow circle) is required when plants are exposed to high boron for BOR1 sorting in multivesicular bodies and subsequent targeting to the vacuole for degradation. The interplay of ubiquitin ligases and deubiquitinases thereby controls the dynamics of plasma membrane proteins. PM, plasma membrane; EE /TGN, Early endosome/Trans-Golgi network; MVB/LE , Multivesicular body/Late endosome compartment; B, Boron; M²⁺, Metals transported by IRT 1 in addition to Fe²⁺.     

Plant endosomal trafficking pathways

Endosomes regulate both the recycling and degradation of plasma membrane (PM) proteins, thereby modulating many cellular responses triggered at the cell surface. Endosomes also play a role in the biosynthetic pathway by taking proteins to the vacuole and recycling vacuolar cargo receptors. In plants, the trans-Golgi network (TGN) acts as an early/recycling endosome whereas prevacuolar compartments/multivesicular bodies (MVBs) take PM proteins to the vacuole for degradation. Recent studies have demonstrated that some of the molecular complexes that mediate endosomal trafficking, such as the retromer, the ADP-ribosylation factor (ARF) machinery, and the Endosomal Sorting Complexes Required for Transport (ESCRTs) have both conserved and specialized functions in plants. Whereas there is disagreement on the subcellular localization of the plant retromer, its function in recycling vacuolar sorting receptors (VSRs) and modulating the trafficking of PM proteins has been well established. Studies on Arabidopsis ESCRT components highlight the essential role of this complex in cytokinesis, plant development, and vacuolar organization. In addition, post-translational modifications of plant PM proteins, such as phosphorylation and ubiquitination, have been demonstrated to act as sorting signals for endosomal trafficking.     

Artificial ubiquitylation is sufficient for sorting of a plasma membrane ATPase to the vacuolar lumen of Arabidopsis cells

Sorting of transmembrane proteins into the inner vesicles of multivesicular bodies for subsequent delivery to the vacuole/lysosome can be induced by attachment of a single ubiquitin or K63-linked ubiquitin chains to the cytosolic portion of the cargo in yeast and mammals. In plants, large efforts have been undertaken to elucidate the mechanisms of vacuolar trafficking of soluble proteins. Sorting of transmembrane proteins, by contrast, is still largely unexplored. As a proof of principle, that ubiquitin is involved in vacuolar sorting in plants we show that a translational fusion of a single ubiquitin to the Arabidopsis plasma membrane ATPase PMA-EGFP is sufficient to induce its endocytosis and sorting into the vacuolar lumen. Sorting of the artificial reporter is not dependent on ubiquitin chain formation, but involves ubiquitin's hydrophobic patch and can be inhibited by coexpression of a dominant-negative version of the ESCRT (endosomal sorting complex required for transport) related protein AtSKD1 (SUPPRESSOR OF K+ TRANSPORT GROWTH DEFECT1). Our results suggest that ubiquitin can in principle act as vacuolar sorting signal in plants.     

Endocytosis: the DUB version

Dynamic modification of endosomal cargo proteins, such as the epidermal growth factor receptor, by ubiquitin can regulate their sorting into the lumen of multivesicular bodies through interactions with a complex protein network incorporating the endosomal sorting complexes required for transport (ESCRTs). Two deubiquitinating enzymes, AMSH and UBPY, interact with ESCRT protein components but exert opposite effects upon the rate of epidermal growth factor receptor downregulation. This might reflect their distinct specificities for different types of polyubiquitin chain linkage. We propose that AMSH might rescue ubiquitinated cargo from lysosomal degradation through disassembly of K63-linked polyubiquitin chains. UBPY function is essential for effective downregulation but is likely to be multifaceted, encompassing activity against both K63-linked and K48-linked polyubiquitin chains and including regulation of the stability of ESCRT-associated proteins such as STAM, by reversing their ubiquitination.     

Direct sorting of the yeast uracil permease to the endosomal system is controlled by uracil binding and Rsp5p-dependent ubiquitylation

The yeast uracil permease, Fur4p, is downregulated by uracil, which is toxic to cells with high permease activity. Uracil promotes cell surface Rsp5p-dependent ubiquitylation of the permease, signaling its endocytosis and further vacuolar degradation. We show here that uracil also triggers the direct routing of its cognate permease from the Golgi apparatus to the endosomal system for degradation, without passage via the plasma membrane. This early sorting was not observed for a variant permease with a much lower affinity for uracil, suggesting that uracil binding is the signal for the diverted pathway. The FUI1-encoded uridine permease is similarly sorted for early vacuolar degradation in cells exposed to a toxic level of uridine uptake. Membrane proteins destined for vacuolar degradation require sorting at the endosome level to the intraluminal vesicles of the multivesicular bodies. In cells with low levels of Rsp5p, Fur4p can be still diverted from the Golgi apparatus but does not reach the vacuolar lumen, being instead missorted to the vacuolar membrane. Correct luminal delivery is restored by the biosynthetic addition of a single ubiquitin, suggesting that the ubiquitylation of Fur4p serves as a specific signal for sorting to the luminal vesicles of the multivesicular bodies. A fused ubiquitin is also able to sort some Fur4p from the Golgi to the degradative pathway in the absence of added uracil but the low efficiency of this sorting indicates that ubiquitin does not itself act as a dominant signal for Golgi-to-endosome trafficking. Our results are consistent with a model in which the binding of intracellular uracil to the permease signals its sorting from the Golgi apparatus and subsequent ubiquitylation ensures its delivery to the vacuolar lumen.     

Split-ubiquitin two-hybrid assay to analyze protein-protein interactions at the endosome: application to Saccharomyces cerevisiae Bro1 interacting with ESCRT complexes, the Doa4 ubiquitin hydrolase, and the Rsp5 ubiquitin ligase

Targeting of membrane proteins into the lysosomal/vacuolar lumen for degradation requires their prior sorting into multivesicular bodies (MVB). The MVB sorting pathway depends on ESCRT-0, -I, -II, and -III protein complexes functioning on the endosomal membrane and on additional factors, such as Bro1/Alix and the ubiquitin ligase Rsp5/Nedd4. We used the split-ubiquitin two-hybrid assay to analyze the interaction partners of yeast Bro1 at its natural cellular location. We show that Bro1 interacts with ESCRT-I and -III components, including Vps23, the Saccharomyces cerevisiae homologue of human Tsg101. These interactions do not require the C-terminal proline-rich domain (PRD) of Bro1. Rather, this PRD interacts with the Doa4 deubiquitinating enzyme to recruit it to the endosome. This interaction is disrupted by a single amino acid substitution in the conserved ELC box motif in Doa4. The PRD of Bro1 also mediates an association with Rsp5, and this interaction appears to be conserved, as Alix, the human homologue of Bro1, coimmunoprecipitates with Nedd4 in yeast lysates. We further show that the Bro1 PRD domain is essential to MVB sorting of only cargo proteins whose sorting to the vacuolar lumen is dependent on their own ubiquitination and Doa4. The Bro1 region preceding the PRD, however, is required for MVB sorting of proteins irrespective of whether their targeting to the vacuole is dependent on their ubiquitination and Doa4. Our data indicate that Bro1 interacts with several ESCRT components and contributes via its PRD to associating ubiquitinating and deubiquitinating enzymes with the MVB sorting machinery.     

Hrs and SNX3 functions in sorting and membrane invagination within multivesicular bodies

After internalization, ubiquitinated signaling receptors are delivered to early endosomes. There, they are sorted and incorporated into the intralumenal invaginations of nascent multivesicular bodies, which function as transport intermediates to late endosomes. Receptor sorting is achieved by Hrs—an adaptor-like protein that binds membrane PtdIns3P via a FYVE motif—and then by ESCRT complexes, which presumably also mediate the invagination process. Eventually, intralumenal vesicles are delivered to lysosomes, leading to the notion that EGF receptor sorting into multivesicular bodies mediates lysosomal targeting. Here, we report that Hrs is essential for lysosomal targeting but dispensable for multivesicular body biogenesis and transport to late endosomes. By contrast, we find that the PtdIns3P-binding protein SNX3 is required for multivesicular body formation, but not for EGF receptor degradation. PtdIns3P thus controls the complementary functions of Hrs and SNX3 in sorting and multivesicular body biogenesis.     

ALIX binds a YPX(3)L motif of the GPCR PAR1 and mediates ubiquitin-independent ESCRT-III/MVB sorting

The sorting of signaling receptors to lysosomes is an essential regulatory process in mammalian cells. During degradation, receptors are modified with ubiquitin and sorted by endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT)-0, -I, -II, and -III complexes into intraluminal vesicles (ILVs) of multivesicular bodies (MVBs). However, it remains unclear whether a single universal mechanism mediates MVB sorting of all receptors. We previously showed that protease-activated receptor 1 (PAR1), a G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) for thrombin, is internalized after activation and sorted to lysosomes independent of ubiquitination and the ubiquitin-binding ESCRT components hepatocyte growth factor-regulated tyrosine kinase substrate and Tsg101. In this paper, we report that PAR1 sorted to ILVs of MVBs through an ESCRT-III-dependent pathway independent of ubiquitination. We further demonstrate that ALIX, a charged MVB protein 4-ESCRT-III interacting protein, bound to a YPX(3)L motif of PAR1 via its central V domain to mediate lysosomal degradation. This study reveals a novel MVB/lysosomal sorting pathway for signaling receptors that bypasses the requirement for ubiquitination and ubiquitin-binding ESCRTs and may be applicable to a subset of GPCRs containing YPX(n)L motifs.     

Endosomal functions in plants

Plant endosomes are highly dynamic organelles that are involved in the constitutive recycling of plasma membrane cargo and the trafficking of polarized plasma membrane proteins such as auxin carriers. In addition, recent studies have shown that surface receptors such as the plant defense-related FLS2 receptor and the brassinosteroid receptor BRI1 appear to signal from endosomes upon ligand binding and internalization. In yeast and mammals, endosomes are also known to recycle vacuolar cargo receptors back to the trans Golgi network and sort membrane proteins for degradation in the vacuole/lysosome. Some of these sorting mechanisms are mediated by the retromer and endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT) complexes. Plants contain orthologs of all major retromer and ESCRT complex subunits, but they have also evolved variations in endosomal functions connected to plant-specific features such as the diversity of vacuolar transport pathways. This review focuses on recent studies in plants dealing with the regulation of endosomal recycling functions, architecture and formation of multivesicular bodies, ligand-mediated endocytosis and receptor signaling from endosomes as well as novel endosomal markers and the function of endosomes in the transport and processing of soluble vacuolar proteins.     

Functional characterization of ice plant SKD1, an AAA-type ATPase associated with the endoplasmic reticulum-Golgi network, and its role in adaptation to salt stress

A salt-induced gene mcSKD1 (suppressor of K+ transport growth defect) able to facilitate K+ uptake has previously been identified from the halophyte ice plant (Mesembryanthemum crystallinum). The sequence of mcSKD1 is homologous to vacuolar protein sorting 4, an ATPase associated with a variety of cellular activities-type ATPase that participates in the sorting of vacuolar proteins into multivesicular bodies in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae). Recombinant mcSKD1 exhibited ATP hydrolytic activities in vitro with a half-maximal rate at an ATP concentration of 1.25 mm. Point mutations on active site residues abolished its ATPase activity. ADP is both a product and a strong inhibitor of the reaction. ADP-binding form of mcSDK1 greatly reduced its catalytic activity. The mcSKD1 protein accumulated ubiquitously in both vegetative and reproductive parts of plants. Highest accumulation was observed in cells actively engaging in the secretory processes, such as bladder cells of leaf epidermis. Membrane fractionation and double-labeling immunofluorescence showed the predominant localization of mcSKD1 in the endoplasmic reticulum-Golgi network. Immunoelectron microscopy identified the formation of mcSKD1 proteins into small aggregates in the cytosol and associated with membrane continuum within the endomembrane compartments. These results indicated that this ATPase participates in the endoplasmic reticulum-Golgi mediated protein sorting machinery for both housekeeping function and compartmentalization of excess Na+ under high salinity.     

Routing misfolded proteins through the multivesicular body (MVB) pathway protects against proteotoxicity

The secretory pathway maintains multiple quality control checkpoints. Initially, endoplasmic reticulum-associated degradation pathways monitor protein folding to retain and eliminate aberrant products. Despite its broad client range, some molecules escape detection and traffic to Golgi membranes. There, a poorly understood mechanism termed Golgi quality control routes aberrant proteins for lysosomal/vacuolar degradation. To better understand Golgi quality control, we examined the processing of the obligate substrate Wsc1p. Misfolded Wsc1p does not use routes of typical vacuolar membrane proteins. Instead, it partitions into intralumenal vesicles of the multivesicular body (MVB) pathway, mediated by the E3 ubiquitin ligase Rsp5p. Its subsequent transport to the vacuolar lumen is essential for complete molecule breakdown. Surprisingly, the transport mode plays a second crucial function in neutralizing potential substrate toxicity. Eliminating the MVB sorting signal diverted molecules to the vacuolar limiting membrane, resulting in the generation of toxic by-products. These data demonstrate a new role of the MVB pathway in protein quality control.     

A single ubiquitin is sufficient for cargo protein entry into MVBs in the absence of ESCRT ubiquitination

ESCRTs (endosomal sorting complexes required for transport) bind and sequester ubiquitinated membrane proteins and usher them into multivesicular bodies (MVBs). As Ubiquitin (Ub)-binding proteins, ESCRTs themselves become ubiquitinated. However, it is unclear whether this regulates a critical aspect of their function or is a nonspecific consequence of their association with the Ub system. We investigated whether ubiquitination of the ESCRTs was required for their ability to sort cargo into the MVB lumen. Although we found that Rsp5 was the main Ub ligase responsible for ubiquitination of ESCRT-0, elimination of Rsp5 or elimination of the ubiquitinatable lysines within ESCRT-0 did not affect MVB sorting. Moreover, by fusing the catalytic domain of deubiquitinating peptidases onto ESCRTs, we could block ESCRT ubiquitination and the sorting of proteins that undergo Rsp5-dependent ubiquitination. Yet, proteins fused to a single Ub moiety were efficiently delivered to the MVB lumen, which strongly indicates that a single Ub is sufficient in sorting MVBs in the absence of ESCRT ubiquitination.     

AP-3 regulates PAR1 ubiquitin-independent MVB/lysosomal sorting via an ALIX-mediated pathway

The sorting of signaling receptors within the endocytic system is important for appropriate cellular responses. After activation, receptors are trafficked to early endosomes and either recycled or sorted to lysosomes and degraded. Most receptors trafficked to lysosomes are modified with ubiquitin and recruited into an endosomal subdomain enriched in hepatocyte growth factor-regulated tyrosine kinase substrate (HRS), a ubiquitin-binding component of the endosomal-sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT) machinery, and then sorted into intraluminal vesicles (ILVs) of multivesicular bodies (MVBs)/lysosomes. However, not all receptors use ubiquitin or the canonical ESCRT machinery to sort to MVBs/lysosomes. This is exemplified by protease-activated receptor-1 (PAR1), a G protein-coupled receptor for thrombin, which sorts to lysosomes independent of ubiquitination and HRS. We recently showed that the adaptor protein ALIX binds to PAR1, recruits ESCRT-III, and mediates receptor sorting to ILVs of MVBs. However, the mechanism that initiates PAR1 sorting at the early endosome is not known. We now report that the adaptor protein complex-3 (AP-3) regulates PAR1 ubiquitin-independent sorting to MVBs through an ALIX-dependent pathway. AP-3 binds to a PAR1 cytoplasmic tail-localized tyrosine-based motif and mediates PAR1 lysosomal degradation independent of ubiquitination. Moreover, AP-3 facilitates PAR1 interaction with ALIX, suggesting that AP-3 functions before PAR1 engagement of ALIX and MVB/lysosomal sorting.     

Permease recycling and ubiquitination status reveal a particular role for Bro1 in the multivesicular body pathway

Ubiquitination of the yeast Gap1 permease at the plasma membrane triggers its endocytosis followed by targeting to the vacuolar lumen for degradation. We previously identified Bro1 as a protein essential to this down-regulation. In this study, we show that Bro1 is essential neither to ubiquitination nor to the early steps of Gap1 endocytosis. Bro1 rather intervenes at a late step of the multivesicular body (MVB) pathway, after the core components of the endosome-associated ESCRT-III protein complex and before or in conjunction with Doa4, the ubiquitin hydrolase mediating protein deubiquitination prior to their incorporation into MVB vesicles. Bro1 markedly differs from other class E vacuolar protein sorting factors involved in MVB sorting as lack of Bro1 leads to recycling of the internalized permease back to the plasma membrane by passing through the Golgi. This recycling seems to be accompanied by deubiquitination of the permease and unexpectedly requires a normal endosome-to-vacuole transport function.     

Direct binding to Rsp5p regulates ubiquitination-independent vacuolar transport of Sna3p

The sorting of integral membrane proteins such as carboxypeptidase S (Cps1p) into the luminal vesicles of multivesicular bodies (MVBs) in Saccharomyces cerevisiae requires ubiquitination of their cytosolic domains by the ubiquitin ligases Rsp5p and/or Tul1p. An exception is Sna3p, which does not require ubiquitination for entry into MVBs. The mechanism underlying this ubiquitination-independent MVB sorting pathway has not yet been characterized. Here, we show that Sna3p sorting into the MVB pathway depends on a direct interaction between a PPAY motif within its C-terminal cytosolic tail and the WW domains of Rsp5p. Disruption of this interaction inhibits vacuolar targeting of Sna3p and causes its accumulation in a compartment that overlaps only partially with MVBs. Surprisingly, Sna3p does require a functional ubiquitin-ligase HECT domain within Rsp5p; however, the dependence of Sna3p on HECT domain activity is distinct from that of Cps1p. Last, we show that Sna3p requires neither Tul1p nor the transmembrane adaptor protein Bsd2p for its MVB sorting. Our data demonstrate that Sna3p follows a novel ubiquitination-independent, but Rsp5p-mediated, sorting pathway to the vacuole.     

ESCRT proteins in physiology and disease

As a mechanism of signal attenuation, receptors for growth factors, peptide hormones and cytokines are internalized in response to ligand binding, followed by degradation in lysosomes. Receptor ubiquitination is a key signal for such downregulation, and four protein complexes known as endosomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT)-0, -I, -II and -III have been identified as the machinery required for degradative endosomal sorting of ubiquitinated membrane proteins in yeast and metazoans. Three of these complexes contain ubiquitin-binding domains whereas ESCRT-III instead recruits deubiquitinating enzymes. The concerted action of the ESCRTs not only serves to sort ubiquitinated cargo but is also thought to cause inward vesiculation of endosomal membranes, thereby mediating biogenesis of multivesicular endosomes (MVEs). Because ligand-mediated receptor downregulation plays an important role in signal attenuation, it is not surprising that dysfunction of ESCRT components is associated with disease. In this review we discuss the possible roles of ESCRTs in protection against cancer, neurodegenerative diseases and bacterial infections, and we highlight the fact that many RNA viruses exploit the ESCRT machinery for the final abscission step of their budding from cells. We also review the additional functions of ESCRT proteins in cytokinesis and discuss how these may be related to ESCRT-associated pathologies.     

Interaction of AMSH with ESCRT-III and deubiquitination of endosomal cargo

The "class E" vacuolar protein sorting (VPS) pathway mediates sorting of ubiquitinated cargo into the forming vesicles of the multivesicular bodies (MVB), and it is essential for down-regulation of signaling by growth factors and budding of enveloped viruses such as Ebola and HIV-1. Work in yeast has identified DOA4 as a gene that is recruited by the class E machinery to remove ubiquitin from the endosomal cargo before it is incorporated into MVB vesicles, but the identity of the mammalian counterpart is unclear. Here we report the interaction of AMSH (associated molecule with the SH3 domain of STAM), an endosomal deubiquitinating enzyme, with the endodomal sorting complex required for transport (ESCRT-III) subunits CHMP1A, CHMP1B, CHMP2A, and CHMP3. We also show that a catalytically inactive AMSH inhibits retroviral budding in a dominant-negative manner and induces the accumulation of ubiquitinated forms of an endosomal cargo, namely murine leukemia virus Gag. Finally, VPS4 and AMSH compete for binding to the C-terminal regions of CHMP1A and CHMP1B, revealing a coordinated interaction with ESCRT-III. Taken together, these results are consistent with a role of AMSH in the deubiquitination of the endosomal cargo preceding lysosomal degradation.