Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains I. The Staining Properties of Thionin and its Derivatives as Compared with Their Chemical Formulae

An investigation has been made of the staining properties of eight dyes of the thionin group. The dyes studied are as follows: tetra-ethyl thionin, asymmetrical di-ethyl thionin, tetra-methyl thionin (methylene blue), tri-methyl thionin (azure B), asymmetrical di-methyl thionin (azure A), symmetrical di-methyl thionin, mono-methyl thionin (azure C), and unsubstituted thionin. The staining properties were tested on sections of paraffin embedded material following five different methods of fixation. No counterstain was employed. It was shown that there was a general correlation between the extent of ethylation or methylation of the dyes and their staining properties. As one passes from tetra-ethyl thionin down the series to thionin itself, there is a progressive decrease in the amount of green showing in the preparations, and an increase in the amount of red present, also an increase in the metachromatic effects, and in the intensity of nuclear staining. There seems, also, to be a similar relation between staining qualities on the one hand and the color and solubility of the dye base on the other.     

Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains I. The Staining Properties of Thionin and its Derivatives as Compared with Their Chemical Formulae

An investigation has been made of the staining properties of eight dyes of the thionin group. The dyes studied are as follows: tetra-ethyl thionin, asymmetrical di-ethyl thionin, tetra-methyl thionin (methylene blue), tri-methyl thionin (azure B), asymmetrical di-methyl thionin (azure A), symmetrical di-methyl thionin, mono-methyl thionin (azure C), and unsubstituted thionin. The staining properties were tested on sections of paraffin embedded material following five different methods of fixation. No counterstain was employed. It was shown that there was a general correlation between the extent of ethylation or methylation of the dyes and their staining properties. As one passes from tetra-ethyl thionin down the series to thionin itself, there is a progressive decrease in the amount of green showing in the preparations, and an increase in the amount of red present, also an increase in the metachromatic effects, and in the intensity of nuclear staining. There seems, also, to be a similar relation between staining qualities on the one hand and the color and solubility of the dye base on the other.     

Metal Contaminants in Commercial Thiazine Dyes

The iron, potassium, sodium and zinc contents of commercial samples of the thiazine dyes azure A (C.I. 52005), azure B (C.I. 52010), azure C (C.I. 52002), methylene blue (C.I. 52015), new methylene blue (GI. 52030), polychrome methylene blue, thionine (C.I. 52000) and toluidme blue (C.I. 52040) have been determined by atomic absorption spectrophotometry.

The metal concentrations varied widely in the 38 samples examined—iron, potassium, sodium and zinc together comprised between 0.02% and 25.35% of individual samples.     

Zinc Chloride Methylene Blue, Ii. Preparation of Giesma and Wright Type Low Azure B Blood Stains from Dichromate Oxidized Commercial Dye

TO determine the amount of K₂Cr₂O₇ required to produce optimal Giemsa type staining, six 1 g amounts (corrected for dye content) of zinc methylene blue were oxidized with graded quantities of K₂Cr₂O₇ to produce 4, 8, 12, 16, 20 and 24% conversion of methylene blue to azure B. These were heated with a blank control 15 minutes at 100 C in 60-65 ml 0.4 N HCI. cooled, and adjusted to 50 ml to give 20 mg original dye/ml. Aliquots were then diluted to 1% and stains were made by the “Wet Giemsa” technic (Lillie and Donaldson 1979) using 6 ml 1% polychrome methylene blue, 4 ml 1% cosin (corrected for dye content), 2 ml 0.1 M pH 6.3 phosphate buffer, 5 ml acetone, and 23 ml distilled water. The main is added last and methanol fixed blood films are stained immediately for 20-40 min.

For methylene blue supplied by MCB 12-H-29, optimal stains were obtained with preparations containing 20 and 24% conversion of methylene blue to azure B. With methylene blue supplied by Aldrich (080787), 16% conversion of methylene blue to azure B was optimal. Eosinates prepared from a low azure B/methylene blue preparation selected in this way give good stains when used as a Wright stain in 0.3% methanol solution. However, when the 600 mg eosinate solution in glycerol methanol is supplemented with 160 mg of the same azure B/methylene blue chloride the mixture fails to perform well. The HCI precipitation of the chloride apparently produces the zinc methylene blue chloride salt which is poorly soluble in alcohol. It appears necessary to have a zinc-free azure B/methylene blue chloride to supplement the probably zinc-free eosinate used in the Giemsa mixture.     

Thiazin Dyes in Supravital Staining of nerve Fibers

Supravital staining by thiazins of segments of small intestine and mesentery of young dogs was studied with reference to specificity for nervous tissue. Attempts to secure a purer form of methylene blue by alumina adsorption and alcohol elution of the commercial, medicinal dye yielded a product which appeared to be structurally different from the original dye. The treated dye had absorption maxima from 620 to 655 mμ in contrast with 665 for the untreated. Small nerve bundles were stained by the treated dye after 2 to 4 hours of immersion, but staining was always incomplete. Staining by untreated methylene blue was compared with that by the leucobase, thionol, methylene green, toluidine blue, new methylene blue and the azures. It was concluded that the specificity for nerve fibers resides mainly in the =N(CH₃)₂Cl radical, although some specificity appears to be effected by the methyl groups on the trivalent nitrogen, since azure A (dimethyl) and azure C (mono-methyl) stained weakly, but thionin did not. Methylene green showed some specificity but stained weakly. The leucobase was less active than the reoxidized dye obtained from it.     

Mechanisms of Giemsa banding

Summary We investigated the capability of individual thiazins in Giemsa mixtures (methylene blue and azures A, B, and C) and of two related dyes (toluidine blue and thionin) to produce G-banding. We further tested the effects of variations of buffer composition and concentration, dye concentration, and staining time.G-banding was produced by all of the dyes at low concentrations, although differences were noted. Overall, methylene blue and azure B produced the best banding, azures A, C, and toluidine blue produced moderately good banding, and thionin produced poor banding. This order did not appear to be altered essentially by different treatments. The optimal conditions for G-banding for all dyes and treatments included the use of (1) 0.025–0.05M phosphate buffer, (2) dye concentrations of 0.002%–0.005%, and (3) staining times of 6–15 min.     

Borax Methylene Blue: A Spectroscopic And Staining Study

Borax methylene blue is quite stable at room temperatures of 22-25 C. At 30 C polychroming is slow; during 50 days in a water bath at this temperature the absorption peak moves from 665 to 656 nm. At 35 C, the absorption peak reaches 660 nm in 7 days, 654 nm in 14. At 60 C polychroming is rapid, the absorption peak reaching 640-620 nm in 3 days. When the pH of the borax methylene blue solutions, normally about 9.0, is adjusted to pH 6.5, the absorption peak remains at 665 nm even when incubated at 60 C for extended periods.

When used as a blood stain 0.4 ml borax methylene blue (1% methylene blue in 1% borax), 4 ml acetone, 2 ml borax-acid phosphate buffer to bring the solution to pH 6.5, and distilled water to make 40 ml, with 0.2 ml 1% eosin added just before using, an excellent Nocht-Giemsa type stain is achieved after 30 minutes staining. The material plasmodia P. falciparum, P. vivax, and P. berghei stain moderate blue with dark red chromatin and green to black pigment granules.

The study confirms Malacnowski's 1891 results and explains Gautier's 1896-98 failure to duplicate it.     

Metallic Lakes of the oxazines (Gallamin Blue, Gallocyanin and Coelestin Blue) as Nuclear Stain Substitutes for Hematoxylin

Becher's investigations upon the soluble metallic lakes of the oxazines have been re-investigated, extended and results described. Gallamin blue, gallocyanin and coelestin blue in combination with ferric ammonium sulfate gave the best results. The dyes are dissolved in a five per cent aqueous solution of ferric ammonium sulfate. The solution is boiled for 2-3 minutes, cooled, filtered and ready for immediate use. The iron lakes of these dyes stain nuclei excellently giving a deep blue or blue black in 3-5 minutes. No differentiation with acid is required. Coelestin blue gives the most stable solution and is recommended as a routine nuclear stain. The protoplasm remains practically colorless and counter-staining with acid dyes such as ethyl-eosin, orange G, or fuchsin gives pictures which cannot be distinguished from a good hematoxylin stain.

Counter-staining with van Gieson solution is also possible. Benda's modification of the van Gieson solution is recommended. Staining of fat with Sudan, scarlet red, etc., does not interfere with nuclear staining by these dyes.

As applied to the central nervous system these dyes are far superior to hematoxylin. Ganglion and glia cells are as excellently stained as with thionin.

The most widely used fixatives, namely formaldehyde, Mueller-formaldehyde, Zenker's and alcohol, give equally as good results. The nature of the staining process is briefly discussed and a prospectus offered.     

Zinc Chloride Methylene Blue. I. Biological Stain History, Physical Characteristics and Approximation of Azure B Content of Commercial Samples

Zinc chloride methylene blue appeared on the market almost contemporaneously with the zinc-free medicinal form. The former has rarely been reported as being used in blood stains. Recent suspension of manufacture of medicinal methylene blue by it. principal American producer has excited interest in the use of the zinc chloride form for the preparation of blood stains. According to Lillie (1944a,b) the azure B content of zinc chloride methylene blue may have varied from 5 to 30% in the samples studied. Taking the Merck Index (1968, 1976) figures for the spectroscopic absorption maximum (λmax) of 667.8 and 668 nm as standard, recent samples of zinc chloride methylene blue are calculated to contain 6-8% azure B. These figures are baaed on 1) the shift of λmax after exhaustive pH 9.5 chloroform extraction, 2) evaluation of the actual ratio of the observed TiCl₂ dye content to the theoretical for pure zinc chloride methylene blue, 3) comparison of spectroscopic and staining effects of graded hot dichromate oxidation products with those of highly purified azure B-methylene blue mixtures of known proportions.

As far as can be found, medicinal methylene blue is almost the exclusive source of cosin polychrome methylene blue blood stains. Lillie (1944c) included a short series comparing 5 zinc chloride methylene blues with a dozen medicinal methylene blue samples; all were oxidized with hot dichromate to produce successful Wright stains. No effort was made to remove the zinc Exhaustive pH 9.5 chloroform extraction of zinc chloride methylene blue (lot MCB 12-H-29) yielded a small amount of red dye which when extracted into 0.1 N HCI gave λmax = 650. The extraction moved the absorption peak of the zinc chloride methylene blue from 667 to 668 nm and the midpoint of the 90% maximum absorption band, 18 nm wide, from 666.5 to 667.5 nm.     

Microspectrophotometric Studies of Romanowsky Stained Blood Cells. III. The Action of Methylene Blue and Azure B

The performances of two standardized Romanowsky stains (azure B/eosin and azure B/methylene blue/eosin) have been compared with each other and with a methylene blue/eosin stain. Visible-light absorbance spectra of various hematological substrates have been measured. These have been analyzed in terms of the quantities of bound azure B, methylene blue and eosin dimers and monomers, and in terms of the CIE color coordinates. It has been found that the addition of methylene blue to azure B/eosin produces little change in performance, at least using these two analytical methods. Methylene blue/eosin does not produce the purplish colorations typical of the Romanowsky effect. This is due not to differences between the spectra of methylene blue and azure B, but to the fact that methylene blue does not facilitate the binding of eosin to cellular substrates to the same extent as azure B.     

Microspectrophotometric studies of Romanowsky stained blood cells. III. The action of methylene blue and azure B

The performances of two standardized Romanowsky stains (azure B/eosin and azure B/methylene blue/eosin) have been compared with each other and with a methylene blue/eosin stain. Visible-light absorbance spectra of various hematological substrates have been measured. These have been analyzed in terms of the quantities of bound azure B, methylene blue and eosin dimers and monomers, and in terms of the CIE color coordinates. It has been found that the addition of methylene blue to azure B/eosin produces little change in performance, at least using these two analytical methods. Methylene blue/eosin does not produce the purplish colorations typical of the Romanowsky effect. This is due not to differences between the spectra of methylene blue and azure B, but to the fact that methylene blue does not facilitate the binding of eosin to cellular substrates to the same extent as azure B.     

The Germicidal Effect of Staining Solutions

Gentian violet, crystal violet and carbol fuchsin applied to cover slip preparations for one minute will destroy the majority of non-spore-forming bacteria and yeasts, tho they can not be relied upon to do this consistently and in all cases.

The Gram staining procedure is more effective and non-spore-formers were never found to survive this process.

Methylene blue stains exert very little if any germicidal power and most organisms survived them readily. India ink was totally ineffective.

Several species of yeasts and yeast-like molds were killed in every instance by the Gram stain, gentian violet, crystal violet and carbol fuchsin, but survived both Loeffler's methylene blue and a plain aqueous solution of methylene blue.     

The Azure Dyes: Their Purification and Physicochemical Properties. I. Purification of Azure A

A method is described for the separation of azure A from commezcial samples of polychrome methylene blue. Up to 300 mg of the pure dye may be isolated in this way. The method is based on chromatography using columns 90 cm high, 7 cm in diameter, loaded with 3 g of polychrome methylene blue. The absorbent is silica gel, the eluent a mixture of acetic and formic acid.

Poor solubility of the dye acetate in water necessitates dissociation of the acetate by alkalinization and subsequent conversion of the dye to the chloride with diluted Ha. Demethylation that occasionally occurs during this procedure is negligible. Pure azure A does not spontaneously demethylate under ordinary conditions.     

Phloxine-Methylene Blue Staining of Formalin-Fixed Tissue

It is at present difficult to obtain a good phloxine-metbylene blue stain on formalin-fixed tissue. When phloxine has been used, it is washed out in the process of staining with methylene blue and differentiating with colophony (rosin). In the original technic of Mallory, Zenker's fixation is used. The tissue is first stained with a 2.5% aqueous solution of phloxine, then with a solution of 1% methylene blue plus 1% azure II and differentiated in colophony.¹     

Composition of J.S.B. stain and Factors Affecting its Quality

Several samples of J.S.B. stain (Jaswant Singh and Bhattacharjee, 1944) solution 1 (polychrome methylene blue) were prepared with 3-8 hr for dichromate-acid oxidation and addition of varying quantities of Na₂HPO₄ buffer for pH adjustment. Storage under severe tropical conditions and periodical checks by staining Plasmodium cynomolgi smears revealed that staining solutions oxidized 6-7 hr with a final pH of 7.8 gave optimum results. Some precipitation of azures, due to heat after 5 mo, adversely affected the quality of staining solutions, while cooler storage conditions were most favorable. Spectrophotometric and chromatographic studies indicated that the J.S.B. solution 1 was composed of blue and purple components, corresponding to higher methylene azures with methylene blue and thionin with allied products respectively.     

Methods for the Standardization of Biological Stains Part V

In this paper are given the methods for determining the suitability of certain dyes of the pyronin, thiazin, oxazin, azin and natural dye groups for certification by the Commission on Standardization of Biological Stains. These methods have been developed by the Commission in cooperation with the Color and Farm Waste Division, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils, U. S. Department of Agriculture. The dyes for which the methods are given in the present paper are: Pyronin G, pyronin B, neutral red, safranin, nigrosin water-soluble, brilliant cresyl blue, cresyl violet, Nile blue A, thionin, methylene blue, methylene azure (azure A), azure C, toluidine blue O, indigo carmin (indigotine) and carmin. For each of these dyes methods are discussed under the following headings: (1) identification or qualitative examination; (2) quantitative analysis; and (3) biological tests.     

Methods for the Standardization of Biological Stains Part V

In this paper are given the methods for determining the suitability of certain dyes of the pyronin, thiazin, oxazin, azin and natural dye groups for certification by the Commission on Standardization of Biological Stains. These methods have been developed by the Commission in cooperation with the Color and Farm Waste Division, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils, U. S. Department of Agriculture. The dyes for which the methods are given in the present paper are: Pyronin G, pyronin B, neutral red, safranin, nigrosin water-soluble, brilliant cresyl blue, cresyl violet, Nile blue A, thionin, methylene blue, methylene azure (azure A), azure C, toluidine blue O, indigo carmin (indigotine) and carmin. For each of these dyes methods are discussed under the following headings: (1) identification or qualitative examination; (2) quantitative analysis; and (3) biological tests.     

Qualitative Analysis by Thin-Layer Chromatography of Some Common Dyes Used in Biological Staining

Thin-layer chromatography will resolve impurities in commercial dyes, and will do so much faster than paper chromatography. Solvent systems consisting of (a) n-propanol: n-butanol: NH₄OH (conc.): H₂O—4:4:1:1; (b) n-propanol: NH₄OH (conc.): H₂O—8:1:1 on silica gel G plates; and (c) n-propanol: NH₄OH (conc.): H₂O-7:2:1 on Adsorbosil plates were found to be the most effective. Dyes studied were azure A, azure B, azure C, methylene blue, toluidine blue O, thionin, pyronin B, pyronin Y, methyl green, crystal violet amido black 10B and buffalo black (NBR).     

Brilliant Cresyl Blue as a Stain for Plant Chromosomes

Methods are proposed for staining plant chromosomes with the dye brilliant cresyl blue, and for making these stained preparations permanent by using polyvinyl alcohol mounting medium.

The stain, which is composed of 2% brilliant cresyl blue in 45% aqueous acetic or propionic acid, is used with fixed material in making smear preparations. The technics for staining are similar to those employed in the aceto-carmine method.

The mounting medium is made by mixing 56% polyvinyl alcohol, which is diluted in water to the consistency of thick molasses, with 22% lactic acid and 22% phenol by volume. The permanent slides are made by floating off the cover slip of the temporary slide in 70% alcohol, then applying the mounting medium and replacing the cover slip.

The chief advantages of the methods described are:

1)The preparation of the stain is rapid and simple. The batch of stain will be good with the first try.

2)The staining procedure in some instances is shorter than when using aceto-carmine.

3)The stain shows a high degree of specificity for nuclear structures and gives better results than aceto-carmine when used on certain plant tissues.

4)A minimum number of cells is lost in making the slides permanent when using polyvinyl alcohol mounting medium as the slide and cover slip are run through only one solution prior to mounting.

5)The mounting medium dries rapidly and this shortens the time required before critical examination of the permanent mounts can be made.     

Giemsa stain's 100th year

Research work associated with the development of Giemsa stain is revived, with emphasis on the methylene blue polychromes. A short biographical sketch of Dr. Berthold Gustav Carl Giemsa is presented, along with the composition of his original formulation and its mec. HPLC analyses of his azur II indicated the following composition: methylene blue 63.6%, azur B 28.6%, azur A 4.4%, azur C 1.4%, thionin 1.9%. Azur I was not "pure", but rather a mixture of thionin and all of its 3 and 7 N-methylated derivatives. Lillie inferred that it was probably prepared by an acid oxidation process. Applications of Giemsa stain reported in the last 32 years are tabulated.