In vitro physiological approach to classification ofFrankia isolates of ‘the Alnus group’, based on urease,protease and β-glucosidase activities

Summary Most of theFrankia strains isolated fromAlnus andMyrica species are morphologically almost indistinguishable, when grown under standard culture conditions. They form similar vegetative hyphae while sporangia are produced in variable amounts from strain to strain.Physiological reactions were assessed in order to compare 20 strains isolated from various species ofAlnus and one species ofMyrica in Europe and North America. Among invariant negative or positive characteristics, differences in urease, protease and -glucosidase activities appeared to be of significant value.     

Effect of the flavonoid quercetin on culture and isolation ofFrankia fromCasuarina root nodules

The growth of threeFrankia strains (HFPCcl3, ORS021001, ORS020607), isolated from nodules ofCasuarina, was unaffected by 5–15 μmol/L quercetin. Re-isolation ofFrankia strain HFPCc13 fromCasuarina root nodules was carried out with the addition of 15 μmol/L quercetin to three different media. The flavonoid significantly reduced fungal contaminants in the isolation plates and increased the number ofFrankia colonies per plate compared to controls without the flavonoid.     

Ultrastructure of freeze-substitutedFrankia strain HFPCcI 3, the actinomycete isolated from root nodules ofCasuarina cunninghamiana

Summary Frankia strain HFPCcI 3 is an actinomycete isolated from root nodules ofCasuarina cunninghamiana. In culture it exhibits typicalFrankia morphology and may produce three distinct morphological forms: branching septate hyphae, terminal or intercalary sporangia, and specialized structures termed vesicles which are the purported site of nitrogenase activity. An examination of the ultrastructure of all three morphological forms using both conventional chemical fixation (CF) and quick-freezing followed by freeze-substitution (FS) reveals some interesting differences between the two fixation methods. Unique to FS material are: 1. smooth membrane profiles; 2. lack of mesosomes; 3. lack of discernible nucleoid regions with condensed chromatin; 4. clarity of cytoplasmic elements such as ribosomes and granular bodies; 5. large cytoplasmic tubules in hyphae and young sporangia; 6. outer wall layer not widely separated from the spherical portion of the vesicle, and 7. bundles of microfilaments in vesicles. The quality of preservation after FS appears to be far superior to that obtained with CF. Accordingly the structures observed after FS are thought to represent more faithfully the structure of the living cell.     

Variable compatibility of clonedAlnus glutinosa ecotypes against ineffectiveFrankia strains

Nodulation tests onin-vitro propagated clones ofAlnus glutinosa ecotypes (forest ecotype, pioneer ecotype) withFrankia strains originating from both ecotypes indicated differences in host-plant compatibility. Inoculated plants of the pioneer ecotype clone were not infected by strains, that were unable to fix nitrogen in pure culture. Nodulation could only be induced on the clone of the forest ecotype, but no nitrogen-fixing activity could be detected. Ultra-structural observations of the nodules by SEM and TEM indicated that ineffectivity of these strains was correlated with the lack of vesicles in the infected cells. Cells were only filled with hyphae: neither sporangia nor vesicles could be detected. In contrast, effective nodules could be obtained on both alder clones after inoculation with an effective strain, showing normal development of vesicle clusters in infected cells. In pure culture the ineffective strains produced no vesicles; sporangia were found only during early stage of growth. The results demonstrate the existence ofFrankia strains which were either non-infective or ineffective on different clones ofAlnus glutinosa.     

Morphology,physiology and infectivity of twoFrankia isolates An 1 and An 2 from root nodules ofAlnus nitida

Summary Two different strains, An 1 and An 2, were obtained from root nodules ofAlnus nitida Endl., collected from one locality in the area of its natural habitat near Bahrin, District Swat, Pakistan. The light and electron microscopy of the isolates revealed the occurrence of septate and branched hyphae bearing sporangia and vesicles. The strains differed in their growth requirements, nitrogen-fixing ability and production of extracellular pigments, thus indicating the existence of more than oneFrankia strain in the same locality. In the absence of combined nitrogen in the medium strain An 1 formed vesicles and fixed N₂ (up to 200 nmol C₂H₄. mg protein^–1.h^–1), while strain An 2 under the experimental conditions formed only few vesicles and fixed N₂ at a very low rate (ca 10 nmol C₂H₄. mg protein^–1 .h^–1). The nitrogenase activity of strain An 1 was strongly affected by the O₂ concentration.Frankia An 1 and An 2 were infective and effective onA. nitida andA. glutinosa but not onDatisca cannabina andElaeagnus umbellata. Both An 1 and An 2 strains were more infective and effective onA. glutinosa thanFrankia strains AvcIl and CpI1.     

Studies of an effective strain ofFrankia fromAllocasuarina lehmanniana of the Casuarinaceae

Summary Seedlings ofCasuarina spp. andAllocasuarina spp. were grown from seed in the greenhouse and inoculated with a nodule suspension fromC. equisetifolia. Plants ofCasuarina spp. nodulated regularly and were effective in nitrogen-fixation. Only one species ofAllocasuariona, A. lehmanniana formed root nodules. Using these plants as source of inoculum, the isolation of a newFrankia sp. HFPA11I1 (HFP022 801) was made and the strain was grown in pure culture.Frankia sp. HFPA11I1 grows well in a defined medium and shows typical morphological characteristics. In media lacking combined nitrogen, the filamentours bacterium forms terminal vesicles in abundance and differentiaties large intrahyphal or terminal sporangia containing numerous spores. This strain, used as inoculum, nodulates effectively seedlings ofC. equisietifolia andC. cunninghamiana, forming nodules with verically-growing nodule roots. Although effective in acetylene reduction, the endophyte within the nodules is filamentous and lacks veiscles. When used to inoculated seedlings ofA llocasuarina lehmanniana, Frankia sp. HFPA11I1 induces root nodules which are coralloid and lacking nodule roots. The nodules are effective in acetylene reduction and the filamentous hyphae ofFrankia within the nodule lobes lack vesicles. Effective nodulation inA. Lehmanniana depends upon environmental conditions of the seedlings and proceeds much more slowly than in Casuariana.     

Frankia-Alnus incana symbiosis: Effect of endophyte on nitrogen fixation and biomass production

The efficiency of different FinnishFrankia strains as symbionts onAlnus incana (L.) Moench was evaluated in inoculation experiments by measuring nitrogen fixation and biomass production. Since all available pure cultures ofFrankia are of the Sp⁻ type (sporangia not formed in nodules), but the dominant nodule endophyte ofA. incana in Finland is of the Sp⁺ type (sporangia formed in nodules), crushed nodules of thisFrankia type were included. The Sp⁻ pure cultures, whether originating fromA. incana orA. glutinosa, produced with one exception, similar biomass withA. incana. The highest biomass was produced with an American reference strain fromA. viridis crispa. Using Sp⁺ nodule homogenates fromA. incana as inoculum, the biomass production was only one third of that produced by Sp⁻ pure cultures from the same host. Hence, through selection of the endophyte it is possible to exert a considerable influence on the productivity ofAlnus incana.     

Presence of sporangia of Frankia in the rhizosphere of Discaria (Rhamnaceae)

Discaria trinervis and Discaria americana are native actinorhizal plants in Argentina. Discaria seedlings growing in N-free liquid culture, inoculated with dry soils, developed Frankia colonies in the rhizosphere. The occurrence of hyphae, vesicles and sporangia characteristic of Frankia are described in these colonies. The presence of sporangia of Frankia has previously neither been reported in the genus Discaria, nor in the other genera of the tribe Colletieae inside root nodules or outside roots. The infective capacity of the colonies has been demonstrated.     

Response of field-grownCasuarina equisetifolia to inoculation withFrankia strain ORS 021001 entrapped in alginate beads

A large scale field experiment (ca 1 ha) was carried out in Senegal, to evaluate the response ofCasuarina equisetifolia to inoculation withFrankia strain ORS 021001 entrapped in alginate beads. Biomasses (expressed as dry weight or total nitrogen) of assimilatory branchlets, wood and roots, and nodules were measured in uninoculated and inoculated trees, randomly sampled 1,2 and 3 years after transplantation in the field. When biomasses were expressed as dry weight, increases due to inoculation were similar at the three sampling dates, 45, 36 and 40%, respectively. When biomasses were expressed as total nitrogen, the response to inoculation with time was much higher in the 2nd year than in the 1st and 3rd year. N₂ fixation, estimated using the difference method reached 2.48, 12.25 and 13.44 g N₂ fixed annually per tree. Correspondingly, nodule dry weights, expressed in g per tree, were 2.5, 12.18 and 22.75 at the end of the 1 st, 2nd and 3rd year, respectively. In spite of the positive response of field-grownCasuarina equisetifolia to inoculation, the decrease of N₂ fixation observed in the third year was probably due to unfavorable climatic conditions coupled with insect attacks at the beginning of the third year.     

The influence of fertilizers on root rot of field peas caused by Fusarium oxysporum,Pythium vexans and Rhizoctonia solani inoculated singly or in combination

A Frankia strain ISU 0224887 was isolated from spore negative root nodules of Gymnostoma sumatranum and was grown in pure culture. It was infective and effective for Gymnostoma species but failed to nodulate Allocasuarina and Casuarina seedlings. Light and scanning electron microscopy of it in nitrogen free medium revealed a filamentous mat of septate and branched hyphae bearing sporangia and vesicles capable of fixing nitrogen. The strain also produced an orange pigment after 2 weeks culture. The strain utilized only TWEEN 80 and propionate as sole carbon sources. The different antibiotics used showed varying effects on its growth.     

Selection and micropropagation of nodulating and non-nodulating clones ofAlnus crispa (Ait.) Pursh

Summary 600,000 seedlings ofAlnus crispa were inoculated with a 111 mixture of theFrankia strains ACN1 ^AG , AGN1 _exo ^AG and MGP10i. After 3 successive inoculations and screenings, one individual, AC-4, was selected as non-nodulating (Nod^–) with Frankiae. This selected individual AC-4 (Nod^–) and two other clones ofA. crispa, AC-2 and AC-5, known for their ability to nodulate (Nod⁺) and two other clones ofA. crispa, AC-2 and AC-5, known for their ability to nodulate (Nod⁺) withFrankia werein vitro propagated. The different clones ofA. crispa in culture required different kinds and concentrations of sugar during the in vitro multiplication and rooting stages. Nodulation tests using 7Frankia strains indicated that the clone AC-4 (Nod^–) was non-nodulating with 6 of the 7Frankia strains tested. One strain,Frankia ANNI, isolated from one unique nodule produced on the mother-plant AC-4, induced 38% of the AC-4 plantlets to nodulate but with a number of nodules 10 to 20 times less than the clones AC-2 (Nod⁺) and AC-5 (Nod⁺). Morphological observations of the roots of AC-4 (Nod^–) indicated that this clone had few and abnormally short root hairs.     

A comparison of cultural characteristics and infectivity ofFrankia isolates from root nodules ofCasuarina species

Summary The isolations of three new strains ofFrankia were made from root nodules ofCasuarina cunninghamiana growing aeroponically. Two strains, HFPCCI1 and HFPCcI2 isolated by Lopez are typicalFrankia strains, producing sporangia among filamentous mats in culture and, in the absence of combined nitrogen, forming vesicles and showing acetylene reduction. They are red-pigmented and, although failing to nodulateCasuarina hosts, effectively nodulatedElaeagnus andHippophae. A third strain HFPCcI3 isolated by Zhang from the same source, also a typicalFrankia, can form sporangia and vesicles in culture and reduce acetylene, is unpigmented, fails to nodulateElaeagnus but effectively nodulatesC. cunninghamiana andC. equisetifolia. Comparisons are made among all of theCasuarina isolates in our collection from around the world (twelve in all) with regard to their cultural characteristics and capacity to infect host plant species. Questions are raised about the specificity of the various isolates and their possible affinities. Opportunities are suggested for inoculation of seedlings for forestry and field application using the infective, effective strains now available.     

Rapid,exponential growth and increased biomass yield of someFrankia strains in buffered and stirred mineral medium (BAP) with phosphatidyl choline

Rapid, exponential growth ofFrankia sp. BR (ORS 020608) isolated fromCasuarina equisetifolia was found to require stirring (magnetic bar) and adequate buffering (MES or MOPS buffers). We used a mineral medium (BAP) at 28°C with propionate and NH₄ ⁺ as the sole carbon and nitrogen source respectively. Sporulation was enhanced by stirring, but the addition of phosphatidyl choline was found to impair sporulation and slightly improve growth. In these conditions a generation time of 14–16 hours was observed with a maximal biomass yield of 108 g of protein × mL^-1 (Bicinchoninic acid) at day 4 when growth ceased. In stirred conditionFrankia growth as microcolonies (30–200 m diameter) showing an open mesh type of mycelium and also a random distribution of growing hyphae inside and in the periphery of the microcolonies (acridine orange vital staining). In static conditions macrocolonies and only peripheric growth can be observed. Optimal growth in buffered and stirred conditions in mineral medium has been also observed with Cj and CeFFrankia isolates. The reasons for rapid and balanced hyphal growth in stirred conditions are discussed.     

Survival ofFrankia strains introduced into soil

Factors affecting the establishment of Alnus/Frankia symbioses were studied partly by following the survival ofFrankia strains exposed to different soil conditions, and partly by investigating the effect of pH on nodulation. TwoFrankia strains were used, both of the Sp⁻ type (sporangia not formed in nodules). One of the strains sporulated heavily, while the other formed mainly hyphae. The strains originated fromAlnus incana root nodules growing in soils of pH 3.5 and 5.0. The optimum pH for their growth in pure culture was found to be 6.7 and 6.2, respectively. The strains were introduced into twoFrankia-free soils, peat and fine sand. Their survival, measured as the persistance of nodulation capacity using the plant infection technique, was followed for 14 months. The survival curves of the strains were similar despite the morphological differences between the strains in pure culture. The nodulation capacities declined over time both at 14 and 22°C. Survival was better in soils limed to a pH above 6 than in soils at their original pH (peat 2.9, fine sand 4.2). The effect of pH on nodule formation in Alnus seedlings by theFrankia strains was studied in liquid culture. The number of nodules increased linearly within the pH range studied (3.5–5.8). No nodules were formed at pH 3.5.     

Identification of the endophypte ofDryas andRubus (Rosaceae)

Summary Root nodules ofDryas drummondii are of the coralloid type (Alnus type). The endophyte is present in the middle cortical cells of the root-nodule tissue. Transmission electron micrographs revealed an actinorhizal endophyte with septate hyphae and non-septate spherical or ovoid vesicles. Vesicles always possess at the base a septum; septa formation in the endophyte is always associated with the presence of mesosomes. Branching of the endophyte is not necessarily correlated with septum formation. Hyphal structures are more prominent in the apical part of the root nodule and vesicles are more numerous in a broad zone below this. In the middle and towards the base of the root nodule the endophytic structures appear in a stage of disintegration. Vesicles appear in a broad region near the periphery of the host cell and regularly show no strict orientation towards the host-cell wall. In the center of the host cells only hyphae occur. In the intercellular spaces between the host cells theFrankia endophyte produces spore-like structures although the outline of the sporangia is often faint.The coralloid root ofRubus ellipticus shows characteristically a basal rootlet initiated below the dichotomous branching of the nodular lobes, but extending beyond the root nodule. The endophyte is only present in the outer cortex of the root nodule in a 1–2 cell wide layer. This endophytic layer is bounded, internally as well as externally, with a 4–5 cell wide layer of tannin-filled host cells. The implications of this situation are discussed. Tannin-filled cells occur regularly inRubus species and their arrangement has been used for taxonomic purposes within the genus. TheRubus endophyte is aFrankia species with septate hyphae and distinctly septate spherical vesicles. The ultrastructure of the vesicles of theRubus endophyte is very similar to that of theAlnus endophyte.     

The taxonomy of the genusFrankia

Summary A discussion covering the problems ofFrankia taxonomy was held at the Frankia Workshop in Wageningen, September 4–6, 1983. It was agreed that the genusFrankia can be satisfactorily defined, but that solid criteria for species determination are not now available and that use of specific names should be avoided for the present.     

Effect of oxygen on substrate utilization for nitrogen fixation and growth in Frankia spp.

Frankia, the actinomycete partner in the nitrogenfixing symbiosis of certain woody non-legumes, has been shown to fix nitrogen in pure culture under aerobic conditions. The sensitivity of in vivo nitrogen-fixation (acetylene reduction) to oxygen tension in the gas phase was measured in short-term assays with two Frankia isolates designated ARI3 and CcI3. The carbon source utilized had an effect on the optimum O₂ concentration for acetylene reduction. Cells utilizing an organic acid, e.g., propionate or pyruvate had maximum nitrogenase activity at an oxygen concentration of 15 to 20%. In contrast, cells respiring a sugar, e.g., trehalose or glucose, or endogenous reserves (glycogen or trehalose) had maximum acetylene reduction activity at 5 to 10% in the gas phase. Oxygen uptake kinetics showed that respiration in vesicle-containing cells utilizing trehalose had a biphasic response to oxygen concentration with a diffusion limited component at oxygen concentrations of 20 M to more than 300 M. These results suggested that trehalose was oxidized in the vesicles as well as in the vegetative hyphae. Oxygen concentration also had an effect on the trehalose-supported growth of cells (non nitrogenfixing, [⁺NH₄Cl]). Cells grown with 5–10% O₂ in the gas phase had a doubling time approximately half those grown with 20% O₂ (atmospheric). Propionate-grown cells showed similar growth rates at the two oxygen tensions, and grew faster (almost 2x) than the trehalose cells at 5–10% O₂. Trehalose also supported approximately 40% lower rates of oxygen uptake than propionate in vesicle-containing cells.     

Oxygen protection of nitrogenase in Frankia sp. HFPArI3

O₂ protection of nitrogenase in a cultured Frankia isolate from Alnus rubra (HFPArI3) was studied in vivo. Evidence for a passive gas diffusion barrier in the vesicles was obtained by kinetic analysis of in vivo O₂ uptake and acetylene reduction rates in response to substrate concentration. O₂ of NH ₄ ⁺ -grown cells showed an apparent K _m O₂ of approximately 1M O₂. In N₂-fixing cultures a second K _m O₂ of about 215 M O₂ was observed. Thus, respiration remained unsaturated by O₂ at air-saturation levels. In vivo, the apparent K _m for acetylene was more than 10-fold greater than reported in vitro values. These data were inter oreted as evidence for a gas diffusion barrier in the vesicles but not vegetative filaments of Frankia sp. HFPArI3.     

Patterns of [13N]ammonium uptake and assimilation by Frankia HFPArl3

Nitrogen-starved cells of Frankia strain HFPArl3 incorporated [¹³N]-labeled ammonium into glutamine serine (glutamate, alanine, aspartate), after five-minute radioisotope exposures. High initial endogenous pools of glutamate were reduced, while total glutamine increased, during short term NH _inf4 ^sup+ incubation. Preincubation of cells in methionine sulfoximine (MSX) resulted in [¹³N]glutamine reduced by more than 80%, while [¹³N]glutamate and [¹³N]alanine levels increased. The results suggest that glutamine synthetase is the primary enzyme of ammonium assimilation, and that glutamate dehydrogenase and alanine dehydrogenase may also function in ammonium assimilation at low levels. Efflux of [¹³N]serine and lesser amounts of [¹³N]glutamine was detected from the Frankia cells. The identity of both Ser and Gln in the extracellular compartment was confirmed with gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. Serine efflux may be of significance in nitrogen transfer in Frankia.Abbreviations Pthr phosphothreonine - Aad -amino-adipate - MSX methionine sulfoximine     

Cell-wall abnormalities of a Chlamydomonas reinhardtii mutant strain under suboptimal growth conditions

Sporangia were accumulated in autotrophically and mixotrophically growing cultures of the Chlamydomonas reinhardtii mutant strain ls entering the stationary phase. Such an accumulation of sporangia was never observed in stationary-phase cultures of wildtype strains. Sporangia harvested from stationary-phase cultures of the mutant strain ls released their zoospores after being resuspended in fresh culture medium. Liberation of zoospores was also observed during fixation of these sporangia with glutaraldehyde and OsO₄. Release of zoospores during fixation was prevented by pretreatment with 3 mol·l^–1 LiCl. Ultrastructural analyses of these LiCl-pretreated sporangia revealed that they contained abnormal sporangial walls: sporangia containing sporangia and sporangia surrounded by additional multilayered cell walls have been observed. Similar abnormal cell-wall structures were found in sporangia accumulated at the end of the dark period, when the mutant strain ls was grown photoautotrophically under a 12 h light-12 h dark regime with suboptimal aeration. When grown under optimal conditions, this particular mutant did not show any abnormal wall structures.This work has been supported by a grant from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft. The authors thank Mrs. C. Adami for the photographic work.