Selection for altruism through random drift in variable size populations

Background

Seed storage proteins are a major source of dietary protein, and the content of such proteins determines both the quantity and quality of crop yield. Significantly, examination of the protein content in the seeds of crop plants shows a distinct difference between monocots and dicots. Thus, it is expected that there are different evolutionary patterns in the genes underlying protein synthesis in the seeds of these two groups of plants.

Results

Gene duplication, evolutionary rate and positive selection of a major gene family of seed storage proteins (the 11S globulin genes), were compared in dicots and monocots. The results, obtained from five species in each group, show more gene duplications, a higher evolutionary rate and positive selections of this gene family in dicots, which are rich in 11S globulins, but not in the monocots.

Conclusion

Our findings provide evidence to support the suggestion that gene duplication and an accelerated evolutionary rate may be associated with higher protein synthesis in dicots as compared to monocots.     

New insights into the evolutionary history of resistance gene candidates in coconut palms and their expression profiles in palms affected by lethal yellowing disease

The nucleotide binding site and leucine rich repeat (NBS–LRR) class of R genes is the most comprehensively studied in terms of sequence evolution; however, in coconut palm and, more generally, in the family of Arecaceae, our understanding of the evolution of these genes is rather limited. In this study, disease resistance gene candidates (RGCs) of the nucleotide binding site (NBS) type of coconut palm were used to investigate evolutionary relationships in Arecaceae, Poaceae and Brassicaceae species. The results indicate a species-specific evolution of RGCs in coconut palm. However, strikingly similar RGCs between species of Arecales indicate a high conservation of specific RGCs of this family, suggesting a monophyletic origin of three genera. The phylogenetic relationship between RGCs of Arecales and Brassicales suggests that these sequences possibly emerged before being divided between monocots and dicots. Finally the comparative analysis of the expression of four RGCs in healthy coconut palm and those affected with lethal yellowing disease revealed differences in their expression profiles. This study provides new insights for future efforts towards the improvement of disease resistance in coconut palm and other species of Arecaceae.     

18S gene trees are positively misleading for monocot/dicot phylogenetics

Monocots are consistently paraphyletic in 18S gene trees in all studies to date. This anomaly is generally expressed in the phylogenetic associations of two lineages, that of Acoraceae, which is excluded from the monocots, and Ceratophyllaceae, which sometimes clusters within the monocots. Six explanations for these unexpected results are proposed: (1) erroneous published sequences, (2) actual paraphyly of monocots with dicots, (3) insufficient taxon density among relevant taxa; (4) long-branch attraction between selected taxa, (5) an anomalous 18S paralogue in the basal species of monocots, and (6) differential lineage sorting or other molecular evolutionary events. Tests of each of these hypotheses were conducted. For the first five hypotheses, test results refuted the hypothesis. Support for the sixth hypothesis, differential lineage sorting, is the strongest. Since lineage sorting seems to be restricted to a few species, identification and removal of these species prior to performing separate or combined phylogenetic analysis of DNA data incorporating sequences from 18S may be advisable.     

Genome-wide analyses of ATP sulfurylase (ATPS) genes in higher plants and expression profiles in sorghum (Sorghum bicolor) under cadmium and salinity stresses

ATP sulfurylase (ATPS, EC: 2.7.7.4) is a crucial enzyme for sulfate assimilation pathway in both plastids and cytosol in plants. In this study, genome-wide and comparative analyses of ATPSs in 11 higher plant species, including sequence and structural analyses have been performed. Expression of ATPS genes in sorghum under cadmium (Cd) and salinity (NaCl) stresses were also investigated to provide a model experimental data for the regulation of ATPS genes under stress conditions. Thirty-one ATPS genes from 11 plant species were found. It showed that ATPSs from different species have high sequence divergences, which cause structural differences among them. Phylogenetic analysis has shown that there are two major types of ATPSs evolved in dicots while monocots were evolved to have one type of ATPs. Finally, expression analysis of ATPS genes revealed tissue and stress dependent expression pattern, which indicates expressions of ATPS genes are tightly regulated.     

The evolution of pyrroline-5-carboxylate synthase in plants: a key enzyme in proline synthesis

Many plants synthesize and accumulate proline in response to osmotic stress conditions. A central enzyme in the proline biosynthesis is the bifunctional enzyme Δ¹-pyrroline-5-carboxylate synthase (P5CS) that includes two functional catalytic domains: the γ-glutamyl kinase and the glutamic-γ-semialdehyde dehydrogenase. This enzyme catalyzes the first two steps of the proline biosynthetic pathway and plays a central role in the regulation of this process in plants. To determine the evolutionary events that occurred in P5CS genes, partial sequences from four Neotropical trees were cloned and compared to those of other plant taxa. Molecular phylogenetic analysis indicated that P5CS duplication events have occurred several times following the emergence of flowering plants and at different frequencies throughout the evolution of monocots and dicots. Despite the high number of conserved residues in plant P5CS sequences, positive selection was observed at different regions of P5CS paralogous genes and also when dicots and monocots were contrasted.     

Diversification of genes encoding granule-bound starch synthase in monocots and dicots is marked by multiple genome-wide duplication events

Starch is one of the major components of cereals, tubers, and fruits. Genes encoding granule-bound starch synthase (GBSS), which is responsible for amylose synthesis, have been extensively studied in cereals but little is known about them in fruits. Due to their low copy gene number, GBSS genes have been used to study plant phylogenetic and evolutionary relationships. In this study, GBSS genes have been isolated and characterized in three fruit trees, including apple, peach, and orange. Moreover, a comprehensive evolutionary study of GBSS genes has also been conducted between both monocots and eudicots. Results have revealed that genomic structures of GBSS genes in plants are conserved, suggesting they all have evolved from a common ancestor. In addition, the GBSS gene in an ancestral angiosperm must have undergone genome duplication ～251 million years ago (MYA) to generate two families, GBSSI and GBSSII. Both GBSSI and GBSSII are found in monocots; however, GBSSI is absent in eudicots. The ancestral GBSSII must have undergone further divergence when monocots and eudicots split ～165 MYA. This is consistent with expression profiles of GBSS genes, wherein these profiles are more similar to those of GBSSII in eudicots than to those of GBSSI genes in monocots. In dicots, GBSSII must have undergone further divergence when rosids and asterids split from each other ～126 MYA. Taken together, these findings suggest that it is GBSSII rather than GBSSI of monocots that have orthologous relationships with GBSS genes of eudicots. Moreover, diversification of GBSS genes is mainly associated with genome-wide duplication events throughout the evolutionary course of history of monocots and eudicots.     

The question of cotyledon homology in angiosperms

The flowering plants (Magnoliophyta) are separated into two large classes distinguished by the morphology of their embryos. The embryos of monocots (class Liliopsida) have a single terminal cotyledon, while the embryos of dicots (class Magnoliopsida) usually have two lateral cotyledons. The cotyledons of monocots and dicots also differ in form, and there are no true intermediates. In addition, the third leaf of Nymphaealean seedlings appears to be identical to the single cotyledon of monocots. From this it is concluded that the cotyledons of monocots and dicots are not homologous. In addition, dissimilarity of cotyledons and succeeding leaves in dicots, together with recent genetic studies, suggests that the two cotyledons of dicots are not homologous with the succeeding leaves of the same plant. This interpretation is consistent with the view that the Nymphaealean embryo’s third leaf is homologous to the first leaf (cotyledon) of monocots. Because dicotyledonous embryos are common among seed plants and are present in the Gnetopsids, the most likely scenario is that the dicots share a widespread seed plant symplesiomorphy and that the monocots have lost this character state. A less parsimonious hypothesis of monocotyledonous embryos as plesiomorphic for angiosperms is also discussed. Genetic analysis of early embryo development in a variety of vascular plants may be the only way to conclusively determine the evolutionary origin of the distinctive difference between monocot and dicot embryos.     

Comparative phylogenetic analysis of aquaporins provides insight into the gene family expansion and evolution in plants and their role in drought tolerant and susceptible chickpea cultivars

Aquaporins (AQPs) are water channel proteins that play a significant role in drought stress. Although the AQPs identified in multiple plant species, there is no detailed evolutionary and comparative study of AQPs regarding chickpea plant. The current study involved evolutionary analyses coupled with promoter and expression analyses of chickpea AQPs (CaAQPs). A total of 924 non-redundant AQPs were studied in 24 plant species including algae, mosses, lycophytes, monocots and dicots. Phylogenetic analysis demonstrated a clear divergence of eight AQP subfamilies (LIPs, SIPs, GIPs, NIPs, XIPs, PIPs, HIPs and TIPs). The comparative phylogenetic trees of AQP subfamilies among Arabidopsis, soybean, common bean, maize and chickpea demonstrated that the AQPs were highly species-specific. Interestingly, the dual NPA motif was conserved in all species. However, the ar/R selectivity filter signatures [W/T/S/N/G/A]-[V/S/L/I/A]-[S/G/A]-R (in NIPs), F-H-T-R (in PIPs), [H/N/Q/S]-[A/I/L/S/V]-[A/G]-[A/C/L/M/R/V] (in TIPs) and [V/I/L/M]-[V/I/A/F/M]-[A/S/F/C]-[N/F/L/I/A/S (in SIPs) were found in five species. Moreover, the Froger's positions (P1-P5) were found as [F/L/Y]-[S/T]-A-Y-[L/I/M/V/F] (in NIPs), [Q/E/M]-S-A-F-W (in PIPs), [A/L/S/T/V]-[A/C/N/S/T/V]-[P/R/S]-[Y/N/F]-[W/Q] (in TIPs) and [I/M/F]-[A/V]-[A/V]-Y-W (in SIPs). The MEME motif analyses showed that most of the motifs were specific to subfamily and subgroups. Tissue-specific expression profiling of CaAQPs revealed that CaTIPs and CaPIPs are highly expressed in most of the tissues, while CaNIPs and CaSIPs have low expression. In promoter analysis of CaAQPs, multiple stress-related cis-acting elements e.g. MYB, MYC, ABRE, etc. were found. Semi-quantitative RT-PCR analysis showed that CaPIP2;3 and CaNIP3;1 are positive regulator, while CaSIP1;1 and CaPIP2;1 have a negative role in drought tolerance. The findings and implications of this study are discussed in detail.     

Does phylogenetic relatedness influence the strength of competition among vascular plants?

A widely assumed but largely untested hypothesis central to ecology and evolutionary biology has been Charles Darwin's suggestion that closely related species will be more ecologically similar, and thus will compete more strongly with each other than they will with more distantly related species. We provide one of the first direct tests of the “competition-relatedness hypothesis” by combining two data sets: the relative competitive ability of 50 vascular plant species competing against 92 competitor species measured in five multi-species experiments, and measures of the phylogenetic relatedness of these species. In contrast to Darwin's assertion, there were weak relationships between the strength of competition and phylogenetic relatedness. Across all species studied, the competition-relatedness relationship was weak and not significant. This overall lack of pattern masked different responses of monocot and eudicot focal (phytometer) species. When monocots served as the focal (phytometer) species, the intensity of competition increased with the phylogenetic distance separating species, while competition decreased with phylogenetic distance for eudicot phytometers. These results were driven by the monocot-eudicot evolutionary split, such that monocots were poor competitors against eudicots, while eudicots are most strongly suppressed by other eudicots. There was no relationship between relatedness and competition for eudicots competing with other eudicots, while monocots did compete more intensely with closely related monocots than with distantly related monocots. Overall, the relationships between competition intensity and relatedness were weak compared to the strong and consistent relationships between competitive ability and functional traits such as plant size that have been reported by other studies. We suggest that Darwin's assertion that competition will be strongest among closely related species is not supported by empirical data, at least for the 142 vascular plant species in this study.     

Tracing the origin and evolution of plant TIR-encoding genes

Toll-interleukin-1 receptor (TIR)-encoding proteins represent one of the most important families of disease resistance genes in plants. Studies that have explored the functional details of these genes tended to focus on only a few limited groups; the origin and evolutionary history of these genes were therefore unclear. In this study, focusing on the four principal groups of TIR-encoding genes, we conducted an extensive genome-wide survey of 32 fully sequenced plant genomes and Expressed Sequence Tags (ESTs) from the gymnosperm Pinus taeda and explored the origins and evolution of these genes. Through the identification of the TIR-encoding genes, the analysis of chromosome positions, the identification and analysis of conserved motifs, and sequence alignment and phylogenetic reconstruction, our results showed that the genes of the TIR-X family (TXs) had an earlier origin and a wider distribution than the genes from the other three groups. TIR-encoding genes experienced large-scale gene duplications during evolution. A skeleton motif pattern of the TIR domain was present in all spermatophytes, and the genes with this skeleton pattern exhibited a conserved and independent evolutionary history in all spermatophytes, including monocots, that followed their gymnosperm origin. This study used comparative genomics to explore the origin and evolutionary history of the four main groups of TIR-encoding genes. Additionally, we unraveled the mechanism behind the uneven distribution of TIR-encoding genes in dicots and monocots.     

The importance of plant relatedness for host utilization among phytophagous insects

Current methods for measuring similarity among phytophagous insect communities fail to consider the phylogenetic relationship between host plants. We analysed this relation based on 3580 host observations of 1174 beetle species associated with 100 species of angiosperms in two different forest types in Panama. We quantified the significance of genetic distance as well as taxonomic rank among angiosperms in relation to species overlap in beetle assemblages. A logarithmic model describing the decrease in beetle species similarity between host-plant species of increasing phylogenetic distance explains 35% of the variation. Applied to taxonomic rank categories the results imply that except for the ancient branching of monocots from dicots, only adaptive radiations of plants on the family and genus level are important for host utilization among phytophagous beetles. These findings enable improvements in estimating host specificity and species richness through correction for phylogenetic relatedness between hosts and consideration of the host-specific fauna associated with monocots.     

5′ Regulatory region of ubiquitin 2 gene from Porteresia coarctata makes efficient promoters for transgene expression in monocots and dicots

Key message

Porteresia ubiquitin 5′ regulatory region drives transgene expression in monocots and dicots.

Abstract

Ubiquitin promoters are promising candidates for constitutive transgene expression in plants. In this study, we isolated and characterized a novel 5′ regulatory sequence of a ubiquitin gene from Porteresia coarctata, a stress-tolerant wild grass species. Through functional analysis in heterologous plant systems, we have demonstrated that full length (Port Ubi2.3) or truncated sequence (PD2) of the isolated regulatory fragment can drive constitutive expression of GUS in monocots and/or dicots. In silico analysis of Port Ubi2.3 has revealed the presence of a 640 bp core promoter region followed by two exons and two introns with numerous putative cis-acting sites scattered throughout the regulatory region. Transformation and expression studies of six different deletion constructs in rice, tobacco and sugarcane revealed that the proximal intron has an enhancing effect on the activity of the core promoter in both monocots and dicots, whereas, Port Ubi2.3 was able to render strong expression only in monocots. This regulatory sequence is quite distinct from the other reported ubiquitin promoters in structure and performs better in monocots compared to other commonly used promoters—maize Ubi1 and Cauliflower Mosaic Virus 35S.     

Genome-wide analysis of WOX gene family in rice, sorghum, maize, Arabidopsis and poplar

WUSCHEL-related homeobox(WOX)genes form a large gene family specifically expressed in plants.They are known to play important roles in regulating the development of plant tissues and organs by determining cell fate.Recent available whole genome sequences allow us to do more comprehensive phylogenetic analysis of the WOX genes in plants.In the present study,we identified 11 and 21 WOXs from sorghum(Sorghum bicolor)and maize(Zea mays),respectively.The 72 WOX genes from rice(Oryza sativa),sorghum,maize,Arabidopsis(Arabidopsis thaliana)and poplar(Populus trichocarpa)were grouped into three well supported clades with nine subgroups according to the amino acid sequences of their homodomains.Their phylogenetic relationship was also supported by the observation of the motifs outside the homodomain.We observed the variation of duplication events among the nine sub-groups between monocots and eudicots,for instance,more gene duplication events of WOXs within subgroup A for monocots,while,less for dicots in this subgroup.Furthermore,we observed the conserved intron/exon structural patterns of WOX genes in rice,sorghum and Arabidopsis.In addition,WUS(Wuschel)-box and EAR(the ERF-associated amphiphilic repression)-like motif were observed to be conserved among several WOX subgroups in these five plants.Comparative analysis of expression patterns of WOX genes in rice and Arabidopsis suggest that the WOX genes play conserved and various roles in plants.This work provides insights into the evolution of the WOX gene family and is useful for future research.     

Factors influencing changes in trait correlations across species after using phylogenetic independent contrasts

Comparative interspecific data sets have been analyzed routinely by phylogenetic methods, generally using Felsenstein’s phylogenetic independent contrasts (PIC) method. However, some authors have suggested that it may not be always necessary to incorporate phylogenetic information into statistical analyses of comparative data due to the low influence of shared history on the distribution of␣character states. The main goal of this paper was to undertake a comparison of results from non-phylogenetic Pearson correlation of tip values (TIPs) and phylogenetic independent contrasts analyses (PICs), using 566 correlation coefficients derived from 65 published papers. From each study we collected the following data: taxonomic group, number of species, type of phylogeny, number of polytomies in the phylogenetic tree, if branch length was transformed or not, trait types, the original correlation coefficient between the traits (TIPs) and the correlation coefficient between the traits using the independent contrasts method (PICs). The slope estimated from a regression of PIC correlations on TIP correlations was lower than one, and a paired t-test showed that correlations from PIC are significantly smaller than those obtained by TIP. Thus, PIC analyses tend to decrease the correlation between traits and usually increases the P-value and, thus, favoring the acceptance of the null hypothesis. Multiple factors, including taxonomic group, trait type and use of branch length transformations affected the change in decision regarding the acceptance of the null hypotheses and differences between PIC and TIP results. Due to the variety of factors affecting the differences between results provided by these methods, we suggest that comparative methods should be applied as a conservative approach to cross-species studies. Despite difficulties in quantifying precisely why these factors affect the differences between PIC and TIP, we also suggest that a better evaluation of evolutionary models underlying trait evolution is still necessary in this context and might explain some of the observed patterns.     

A transcontinental comparison of the diversity and composition of tropical forest understory herb assemblages

Although tropical forests are renowned for their high plant diversity, to date there has been no global quantitative evaluation of the local species richness of terrestrial forest herbs in tropical forests. In this paper, richness and composition of terrestrial herb assemblages is compared in tropical forests of America, Africa and South East Asia. We established 86 non-continuous transects of 445 m each. Herb species richness was analysed and compared to six environmental parameters using minimal adequate regression models and simultaneous autoregressive models. At the global scale, we found a close relationship between herb species richness and temperature parameters, with no differences between continents. The subdivision into three main taxonomic groups (ferns, monocots, dicots) showed that each group has distinct relations to environmental factors and differences in richness between continents. Most of the 72 families found have pantropical distributions but 12, 11, and 16 families were significantly over-represented in America, Africa, and Asia, respectively. Although total species richness was closely related to climatic factors, ferns, monocots and dicots were represented by distinct sets of families with varying species richness on each continent. Which species are found at a given site may thus reflect group-specific evolutionary and historical factors.     

两个水稻GDP-甘露糖-3',5'-异构酶基因特征及表达模式的研究

GDP-甘露糖-3',5'-异构酶(GME)可以催化GDP-甘露糖转化为左旋GDP-半乳糖,该反应对于高等植物体内抗坏血酸的合成是非常重要的.但目前在分子水平上还没有对GME基因进行研究的报道.通过逆转录PCR(RT-RCR)技术从水稻成熟叶片中克隆到两个GME基因的cDNA序列,并与其他植物物种中的GMEs进行比对,结果显示,GME基因在所有植物物种中高度保守,尽管进化树分析表明单子叶植物GMEs和双子叶植物GMEs在进化上相互独立.同时,分析这两个水稻GME基因的剪切模式揭示了二者也存在高度相似性.采用半定量RT-PCR技术对两个GME基因在不同组织和不同胁迫条件下的表达模式进行研究表明,OsGME1基因在冷胁迫条件下表达水平上调,这和先前水稻冷胁迫蛋白质组学研究的结果是一致的.而OsGME2和OsGME1基因在用赤霉素处理条件下表达水平均下调,暗示赤霉素可能通过调节GME基因的表达来调控植物体内的抗坏血酸合成.