The role of Math1 in inner ear development: Uncoupling the establishment of the sensory primordium from hair cell fate determination

During embryonic development of the inner ear, the sensory primordium that gives rise to the organ of Corti from within the cochlear epithelium is patterned into a stereotyped array of inner and outer sensory hair cells separated from each other by non-sensory supporting cells. Math1, a close homolog of the Drosophila proneural gene atonal, has been found to be both necessary and sufficient for the production of hair cells in the mouse inner ear. Our results indicate that Math1 is not required to establish the postmitotic sensory primordium from which the cells of the organ of Corti arise, but instead is limited to a role in the selection and/or differentiation of sensory hair cells from within the established primordium. This is based on the observation that Math1 is only expressed after the appearance of a zone of non-proliferating cells that delineates the sensory primordium within the cochlear anlage. The expression of Math1 is limited to a subpopulation of cells within the sensory primordium that appear to differentiate exclusively into hair cells as the sensory epithelium matures and elongates through a process that probably involves radial intercalation of cells. Furthermore, mutation of Math1 does not affect the establishment of this postmitotic sensory primordium, even though the subsequent generation of hair cells is blocked in these mutants. Finally, in Math1 mutant embryos, a subpopulation of the cells within the sensory epithelium undergo apoptosis in a temporal gradient similar to the basal-to-apical gradient of hair cell differentiation that occurs in the cochlea of wild-type animals.     

The lateral line canal sensory organs of the Epaulette Shark (Hemiscyllium ocellatum)

Examination of the lateral line canals in the Epaulette Shark reveals a much more differentiated sensory system than previously reported from any elasmobranch. Two main types of lateral line canals are found. In one type rounded patches of sensory epithelia are separated by elevations of the canal floor. The other type is a straight canal without restrictions and with an almost continuous sensory epithelium. In addition, we found epithelia (type A) with very long apical microvilli on the supporting cells. These microvilli reach beyond the stereovilli of the hair cells. Another type (B) of sensory epithelium has short microvilli on the supporting cells. In this latter type of epithelium the stereovilli of the hair cells are comparatively tall and reach out beyond the supporting cell microvilli.
  New hair cells are found widely in both types of sensory epithelia. These always occur as single cells, unlike those described in teleost lateral line canal sensory epithelia where new hair cells seem to form in pairs. Dying hair cells are also widespread, indicating a continuous turnover of hair cells.     

The ultrastructure and innervation of the ear of the gar, Lepisosteus osseus

The endorgans of the inner ear of the gar were examined using transmission and scanning electron microscopy as well as nerve staining. The ultrastructure of the sensory hair cells and supporting cells of the gar ear are similar to cells in other bony fishes, whereas there are significant differences between the gar and other bony fishes in the orientations patterns of the sensory hair cells on the saccular and lagenar sensory epithelia. The saccular sensory epithelium has two regions, a main region and a secondary region ventral to the main region. The ciliary bundles on the main region are divided into two groups, one oriented dorsally and the other ventrally. Furthermore, as a result of curvature of the saccular sensory epithelium, the dorsal and ventral ciliary bundles on the rostral portion of the epithelium are rotated ninety degrees and are thus oriented on the animal's rostro-caudal axis. Hair cells on the secondary region are generally oriented ventrally. The lagenar epithelium has three groups of sensory hair cells. The groups on the rostral and caudal ends of the macula are oriented dorsally, whereas the middle group is oriented ventrally. Hair cell orientations on the utricular epithelium and macula neglecta are similar to those in other bony fishes. Nerve fiber diameters can be divided into three size classes, 1-8 microns, 9-13 microns, and 14 microns or more, with the smallest size class containing the majority of fibers. The distribution of the various classes of fiber diameters is not the same in nerve branches to each of the end organs. Similarly, the ratio of hair cells to axons differs in each end organ. The highest hair cell to axon ratio is in the utricle (23:1) and the smallest is in the macula neglecta (7:1). The number of sensory hair cells far exceed the number of eighth nerve axons in all sensory epithelia.     

The auditory sensory epithelium: the instrument of sound perception

The auditory sensory epithelium is the specialized region of the cochlear epithelium that transduces sound. It is composed of a highly ordered, repeated array of mechanosensory hair cells and nonsensory supporting cells that run along the length of the cochlea. On the apical surface of the hair cells is a specialized structure called the hair bundle that deflects in response to sound vibration, resulting in depolarization of the hair cell and neurotransmitter release. Formation of the auditory sensory epithelium during embryogenesis involves strict control of both cell proliferation and cell patterning. Misregulation of these events can lead to congenital hearing loss, and damage to the auditory sensory epithelium during adult life can lead to adult-onset deafness. This paper reviews recent data on the formation of the auditory sensory epithelium during embryogenesis, the identification of components of the sound transduction apparatus, and advances in the treatment of hearing impairment.     

Non-neural ectoderm is really neural: evolution of developmental patterning mechanisms in the non-neural ectoderm of chordates and the problem of sensory cell homologies

In chordates, the ectoderm is divided into the neuroectoderm and the so-called non-neural ectoderm. In spite of its name, however, the non-neural ectoderm contains numerous sensory cells. Therefore, the term "non-neural" ectoderm should be replaced by "general ectoderm." At least in amphioxus and tunicates and possibly in vertebrates as well, both the neuroectoderm and the general ectoderm are patterned anterior/posteriorly by mechanisms involving retinoic acid and Hox genes. In amphioxus and tunicates the ectodermal sensory cells, which have a wide range of ciliary and microvillar configurations, are mostly primary neurons sending axons to the CNS, although a minority lack axons. In contrast, vertebrate mechanosensory cells, called hair cells, are all secondary neurons that lack axons and have a characteristic eccentric cilium adjacent to a group of microvilli of graded lengths. It has been highly controversial whether the ectodermal sensory cells in the oral siphons of adult tunicates are homologous to vertebrate hair cells. In some species of tunicates, these cells appear to be secondary neurons, and microvillar and ciliary configurations of some of these cells approach those of vertebrate hair cells. However, none of the tunicate cells has all the characteristics of a hair cell, and there is a high degree of variation among ectodermal sensory cells within and between different species. Thus, similarities between the ectodermal sensory cells of any one species of tunicate and craniate hair cells may well represent convergent evolution rather than homology.     

The structure of a hair mechanoreceptor in the antennule of crayfish (Crustacea)

Summary In this study we examine the fine structure of mechanosensory hairs in the antennule of crayfish. The sensory hair is a stiff shaft with feather-like filaments. The hair's base is a large expansion of membrane which allows the hair shaft to deflect. The sensory transducing elements are located far from the hair, but are coupled mechanically with the hair shaft by a fine extracellular chorda. The sensory element is a type of scolopidium which consists of a scolopale cell and three sensory cells with a 9 + 0 type ciliary process.This type of scolopidium is characteristic of the chordotonal organ that has no cuticular structure on the surface of the exoskeleton. In this crustacean hair receptor, the deflection of the cuticular hair is transmitted through the chorda to the scolopidium which is a tension-sensitive transducer. The present study reveals that the mechanosensory hair of decapod crustaceans is a chordotonal organ accompanied by a cuticular hair structure. We also discuss comparative aspects of cuticular and subcuticular chordotonal organs in arthropods.     

The retinoblastoma gene pathway regulates the postmitotic state of hair cells of the mouse inner ear

Precursors of cochlear and vestibular hair cells of the inner ear exit the cell cycle at midgestation. Hair cells are mitotically quiescent during late-embryonic differentiation stages and postnatally. We show here that the retinoblastoma gene Rb and the encoded protein pRb are expressed in differentiating and mature hair cells. In addition to Rb, the cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor (CKI) p21 is expressed in developing hair cells, suggesting that p21 is an upstream effector of pRb activity. p21 apparently cooperates with other CKIs, as p21-null mice exhibited an unaltered inner ear phenotype. By contrast, Rb inactivation led to aberrant hair cell proliferation, as analysed at birth in a loss-of-function/transgenic mouse model. Supernumerary hair cells expressed various cell type-specific differentiation markers, including components of stereocilia. The extent of alterations in stereociliary bundle morphology ranged from near-normal to severe disorganization. Apoptosis contributed to the mutant phenotype, but did not compensate for the production of supernumerary hair cells, resulting in hyperplastic sensory epithelia. The Rb-null-mediated proliferation led to a distinct pathological phenotype, including multinucleated and enlarged hair cells, and infiltration of hair cells into the mesenchyme. Our findings demonstrate that the pRb pathway is required for hair cell quiescence and that manipulation of the cell cycle machinery disrupts the coordinated development within the inner ear sensory epithelia.     

Interconnections between the stereovilli of the fish inner ear

Summary The maculae utriculi and sacculi of the inner ear from the European roach (Rutilus rutilus) were investigated by transmission electron microscopy. The stereovilli of peripherally and centrally located sensory cells differ in several features that suggest a developmental gradient. The stereovilli of the peripheral sensory cells, shown to be differentiating cells by other research groups, are short and less steeply graded in height than in central hair cells. All stereovilli in both kinds of hair bundles are interconnected. In the central bundles of stereovilli basal, tip, and vertical connectors are separated by unconnected regions. In contrast, filaments and sometimes other additional structures connect the stereovilli of peripheral bundles over their entire length, but vertical connectors are usually absent. Osmiophilic material occurring inside peripheral stereovilli is interpreted to be monomeric actin. Central and peripheral hair bundles also differ in their reaction to ruthenium red and cationized ferritin. Only the stereovilli of the central cells can be fused by these polycations. Ruthenium red also discriminates between supporting and sensory cells indicating differences in amount or distribution of extracellular material. Hair bundles, intermediate in properties and position between central and peripheral sensory cells, were also found, so that it became possible to propose a scheme of developmental steps leading from microvilli or microvillus-like stereovilli to the fully differentiated hair bundle.     

Hair cells without supporting cells: further studies in the ear of the zebrafish mind bomb mutant

Each sensory hair cell in the ear is normally surrounded by supporting cells, which separate it from the next hair cell. In the mind bomb mutant, as a result of a failure of lateral inhibition, cells that would normally become supporting cells differentiate as hair cells instead, creating sensory patches that consist of hair cells only. This provides a unique opportunity to pinpoint the functions for which supporting cells are required in normal hair cell development. We find that hair cells in the mutant develop an essentially normal cytoskeleton, with a correctly structured hair bundle and well-defined planar polarity, and form apical junctional complexes with one another in standard epithelial fashion. They fail, however, to form a basal lamina or to adhere properly to the adjacent non-sensory epithelial cells, which overgrow them. The hair cells are eventually expelled from the ear epithelium into the underlying mesenchyme, losing their hair bundles in the process. It is not clear whether they undergo apoptosis: many cells staining strongly with the TUNEL procedure are seen but do not appear apoptotic by other criteria. Supporting cells, therefore, are needed to hold hair cells in the otic epithelium and, perhaps, to keep them alive, but are not needed for the construction of normal hair bundles or to give the hair bundles a predictable polarity. Moreover, supporting cells are not absolutely required as a source of materials for otoliths, which, though small and deformed, still develop in their absence.     

In vitro growth and differentiation of mammalian sensory hair cell progenitors: a requirement for EGF and periotic mesenchyme

The sensory hair cells and supporting cells of the organ of Corti are generated by a precise program of coordinated cell division and differentiation. Since no regeneration occurs in the mature organ of Corti, loss of hair cells leads to deafness. To investigate the molecular basis of hair cell differentiation and their lack of regeneration, we have established a dissociated cell culture system in which sensory hair cells and supporting cells can be generated from mitotic precursors. By incorporating a Math1-GFP transgene expressed exclusively in hair cells, we have used this system to characterize the conditions required for the growth and differentiation of hair cells in culture. These conditions include a requirement for epidermal growth factor, as well as the presence of periotic mesenchymal cells. Lastly, we show that early postnatal cochlear tissue also contains cells that can divide and generate new sensory hair cells in vitro.     

Sox2 is required for maintenance and regeneration, but not initial development, of hair cells in the zebrafish inner ear

Sox2 has been variously implicated in maintenance of pluripotent stem cells or, alternatively, early stages of cell differentiation, depending on context. In the developing inner ear, Sox2 initially marks all cells in the nascent sensory epithelium and, in mouse, is required for sensory epithelium formation. Sox2 is eventually downregulated in hair cells but is maintained in support cells, the functional significance of which is unknown. Here we describe regulation and function of sox2 in the zebrafish inner ear. Expression of sox2 begins after the onset of sensory epithelium development and is regulated by Atoh1a/b, Fgf and Notch. Knockdown of sox2 does not prevent hair cell production, but the rate of accumulation is reduced due to sporadic death of differentiated hair cells. We next tested the capacity for hair cell regeneration following laser ablation of mature brn3c:gfp-labeled hair cells. In control embryos, regeneration of lost hair cells begins by 12 h post-ablation and involves transdifferentiation of support cells rather than asymmetric cell division. In contrast, regeneration does not occur in sox2-depleted embryos. These data show that zebrafish sox2 is required for hair cell survival, as well as for transdifferentiation of support cells into hair cells during regeneration.     

Hearing loss caused by progressive degeneration of cochlear hair cells in mice deficient for the Barhl1 homeobox gene

The cochlea of the mammalian inner ear contains three rows of outer hair cells and a single row of inner hair cells. These hair cell receptors reside in the organ of Corti and function to transduce mechanical stimuli into electrical signals that mediate hearing. To date, the molecular mechanisms underlying the maintenance of these delicate sensory hair cells are unknown. We report that targeted disruption of Barhl1, a mouse homolog of the Drosophila BarH homeobox genes, results in severe to profound hearing loss, providing a unique model for the study of age-related human deafness disorders. Barhl1 is expressed in all sensory hair cells during inner ear development, 2 days after the onset of hair cell generation. Loss of Barhl1 function in mice results in age-related progressive degeneration of both outer and inner hair cells in the organ of Corti, following two reciprocal longitudinal gradients. Our data together indicate an essential role for Barhl1 in the long-term maintenance of cochlear hair cells, but not in the determination or differentiation of these cells.     

Structure and Innervation of Inner Ear Sensory Epithelia in the European Eel (Anguilla anguilla L.)

Hair cell orientations of all inner ear sensory epithelia in glass eel, yellow eel and silver eel are presented. The patterns of hair cell orientation do not change with age. All sensory epithelia increase in area during growth of the eel. Examination of the hair cell population in macula utriculi show constant hair cell densities and increased hair cell population during development. Further, regional differences in hair cell densities and hair cell types are observed. The hair cells/axons ratio increases 3-fold from glass eel to silver eel stadium. Nerve stainings in silver eel reveal complex innervation patterns with large stubby fibres confined to restricted regions. Histograms of nerve fiber diameters show marked differences from glass eel to silver eel. Growth of sensory epithelia is discussed.     

Ethanol Affects the Development of Sensory Hair Cells in Larval Zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Children born to mothers with substantial alcohol consumption during pregnancy can present a number of morphological, cognitive, and sensory abnormalities, including hearing deficits, collectively known as fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS). The goal of this study was to determine if the zebrafish lateral line could be used to study sensory hair cell abnormalities caused by exposure to ethanol during embryogenesis. Some lateral line sensory hair cells are present at 2 days post-fertilization (dpf) and are functional by 5 dpf. Zebrafish embryos were raised in fish water supplemented with varying concentrations of ethanol (0.75%–1.75% by volume) from 2 dpf through 5 dpf. Ethanol treatment during development resulted in many physical abnormalities characteristic of FAS in humans. Also, the number of sensory hair cells decreased as the concentration of ethanol increased in a dose-dependent manner. The dye FM 1-43FX was used to detect the presence of functional mechanotransduction channels. The percentage of FM 1-43-labeled hair cells decreased as the concentration of ethanol increased. Methanol treatment did not affect the development of hair cells. The cell cycle markers proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) demonstrated that ethanol reduced the number of sensory hair cells, as a consequence of decreased cellular proliferation. There was also a significant increase in the rate of apoptosis, as determined by TUNEL-labeling, in neuromasts following ethanol treatment during larval development. Therefore, zebrafish are a useful animal model to study the effects of hair cell developmental disorders associated with FAS.     

Mosaic arrangement of SCPb-, FMRFamide-, and histamine-like immunoreactive sensory hair cells in the statocyst of the gastropod mollusc Pleurobranchaea japonica

A pair of statocysts are located in the periganglionic connective tissue of the pedal ganglia of the opisthobranch mollusc Pleurobranchaea japonica. Light- and electron-microscopic observations show that the sensory epithelium of the statocyst consists of 13 disk-shaped hair cells. Each hair cell sends a single axon to the cerebral ganglion through the static nerve. Neurotransmitters in the hair cells were examined by means of immunocytochemistry. Our results show that the 13 sensory hair cells include two SCPB-, three FMRFamide-, and eight histamine-like immunoreactive cells. One hair cell contains a transmitter substance other than SCPB-, FMRFamide, histamine, serotonin, or GABA. One of the two SCPB-like immunoreactive cells, located in the ventral region of the statocyst, is the largest cell in the statocyst. The other, located in the anterodorsal region, shows co-immunoreactivity to both SCPB and FMRFamide antisera. Among the three FMRFamide-like immunoreactive hair cells, one is located in the posteroventral region, separated from the other two, which are adjacent to each other in the anterodorsal region. All the eight histamine-like immunoreactive hair cells are adjacent to one another, occupying the remainder of a triangular pyramid-shaped region. These immunoreactive cells are symmetrically placed in the right and left statocysts. This mosaic arrangement was identical among specimens. Thus the static nerve may code information about position or movement of the statoliths, with the use of different transmitters in the mosaic arrangement of the hair cells.     

Emx2 and early hair cell development in the mouse inner ear

Emx2 is a homeodomain protein that plays a critical role in inner ear development. Homozygous null mice die at birth with a range of defects in the CNS, renal system and skeleton. The cochlea is shorter than normal with about 60% fewer auditory hair cells. It appears to lack outer hair cells and some supporting cells are either absent or fail to differentiate. Many of the hair cells differentiate in pairs and although their hair bundles develop normally their planar cell polarity is compromised. Measurements of cell polarity suggest that classic planar cell polarity molecules are not directly influenced by Emx2 and that polarity is compromised by developmental defects in the sensory precursor population or by defects in epithelial cues for cell alignment. Planar cell polarity is normal in the vestibular epithelia although polarity reversal across the striola is absent in both the utricular and saccular maculae. In contrast, cochlear hair cell polarity is disorganized. The expression domain for Bmp4 is expanded and Fgfr1 and Prox1 are expressed in fewer cells in the cochlear sensory epithelium of Emx2 null mice. We conclude that Emx2 regulates early developmental events that balance cell proliferation and differentiation in the sensory precursor population.     

Survival of bundleless hair cells and subsequent bundle replacement in the bullfrog's saccule.

Our senses of hearing and balance depend upon hair cells, the sensory receptors of the inner ear. Millions of people suffer from hearing and balance deficits caused by damage to hair cells as a result of exposure to noise, aminoglycoside antibiotics, and antitumor drugs. In some species such damage can be reversed through the production of new cells. This proliferative response is limited in mammals but it has been hypothesized that damaged hair cells might survive and undergo intracellular repair. We examined the fate of bullfrog saccular hair cells after exposure to a low dose of the aminoglycoside antibiotic gentamicin to determine whether hair cells could survive such treatment and subsequently be repaired. In organ cultures of the bullfrog saccule a combination of time-lapse video microscopy, two-photon microscopy, electron microscopy, and immunocytochemistry showed that hair cells can lose their hair bundle and survive as bundleless cells for at least 1 week. Time-lapse and electron microscopy revealed stages in the separation of the bundle from the cell body. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) of cultures fixed 2, 4, and 7 days after antibiotic treatment showed that numerous new hair bundles were produced between 4 and 7 days of culture. Further examination revealed hair cells with small repaired hair bundles alongside damaged remnants of larger surviving bundles. The results indicate that sensory hair cells can undergo intracellular self-repair in the absence of mitosis, offering new possibilities for functional hair cell recovery and an explanation for non-proliferative recovery.