The response of phytoplankton community to anthropogenic pressure gradient in the coastal waters of the eastern Adriatic Sea

In order to test the response of phytoplankton to anthropogenic pressure, data of chlorophyll a concentration, phytoplankton abundance, and composition are analyzed in relation to anthropogenic pressure gradient and environmental variables such as temperature, salinity and nutrients. Investigated sites encompassed wide tropic range according to a preliminary determination of anthropogenic pressure, quantified through the LUSI index. Statistical analyses indicated nitrates and silicates as proxies of freshwater influence, and phytoplankton single metrics such as concentrations of chlorophyll a and abundances as indicators of anthropogenic pressure. Boundary values for different water quality classes for coastal waters under indirect freshwater influence (Type II) are obtained according to gradient between concentration of chlorophyll a and pressure index (LUSI), which empirically fit to exponential equation. The response of phytoplankton diversity was not linear, as the highest diversity was observed in the area with intermediate disturbance level. CCA analysis identified Skeletonema marinoii, Scrippsiella trochoidea, Guinardia flaccida, Leptocylindrus spp., Prorocentrum spp., Proboscia alata, Eutreptiella spp., and Pseudonitzschia spp. as local eutrophication indicators, whose abundances increased with nutrients loads.     

Macrophyte communities in unimpacted European streams: variability in assemblage patterns, abundance and diversity

Macrophytes are an important component of aquatic ecosystems and are used widely within the Water Framework Directive (WFD) to establish ecological quality. In the present paper we investigated macrophyte community structure, i.e., composition, richness and diversity measures in 60 unimpacted stream and river sites throughout Europe. The objectives were to describe assemblage patterns in different types of streams and to assess the variability in various structural and ecological metrics within these types to provide a basis for an evaluation of their suitability in ecological quality assessment. Macrophyte assemblage patterns varied considerably among the main stream types. Moving from small-sized, shallow mountain streams to medium-sized, lowland streams there was a clear transition in species richness, diversity and community structure. There was especially a shift from a predominance of species-poor mosses and communities dominated by liverwort in the small-sized, shallow mountain streams to more species-rich communities dominated by vascular plants in the medium-sized, lowland streams. The macrophyte communities responded to most of the features underlying the typological framework defined in WFD. The present interpretation of the WFD typology may not, however, be adequate for an evaluation of stream quality based on macrophytes. First and most important, by using this typology we may overlook an important community type, which is characteristic of small-sized, relatively steep-gradient streams that are an intermediate type between the small-sized, shallow mountain streams and the medium-sized, lowland streams. Second, the variability in most of the calculated metrics was slightly higher when using the pre-defined typology. The consistency of these results should be investigated by analysing a larger number of sites. Particularly the need of re-defining the typology to improve the ability to detect impacts on streams and rivers from macrophyte assemblage patterns should be investigated. Electronic supplementary material Electronic supplementary material is available for this article at and accessible for authorised users.     

Recent histories of six productive lakes in the Irish Ecoregion based on multiproxy palaeolimnological evidence

Palaeolimnological data from six mesotrophic, eutrophic and hypertrophic lakes in the Irish Ecoregion, in the form of microfossil (cladocera, diatoms and pollen) and sediment chemistry data from radiometrically dated sediment cores, were used to reconstruct past variations in lake water quality and catchment conditions. Basal sediments from sediment cores from the six sites ranged in age from the late 18th century to the early 20th century. A weighted averaging partial least squares regression model was developed to reconstruct past epilimnetic total phosphorus concentrations. The results indicate that all but one of the study sites currently are in a far more productive state compared with the beginning of the sediment core record and that those same five lakes have experienced accelerated enrichment post c. 1980. Two of the sites demonstrated long-term enrichment, in one case beginning in the late 19th century, while both eutrophication and oligotrophication have occurred at three sites. The results highlight the difficulties in applying a general temporal end-point for reference conditions and demonstrate that productive lakes in the Irish Ecoregion have complex, locally specific and often long histories of enrichment. These may not be responsive to reduced external loadings of phosphorus and, as a result, restoration could prove particularly challenging. The results also provide evidence of the ways in which palaeolimnological techniques can assist implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive. Electronic supplementary material Electronic supplementary material is available for this article at and accessible for authorised users.     

Temporal and Spatial Distribution Patterns of Larval Trichoptera in Madeiran Streams

Temporal and spatial distribution patterns of lotic larval trichopteran assemblages in relation to environmental variables were investigated in Madeiran streams using multivariate analyses. TWINSPAN classification detected distinct faunal assemblages related to spatial factors between non-polluted high altitude sites and lower lying enriched sites where tolerant taxa were predominant but showed strong seasonal shifts in species composition and abundance. The 15 TWINSPAN end groups were grouped into five arbitrary clusters based upon the seasonal and spatial changes in the trichopteran assemblages detected by the analysis. Significant differences between environmental variables (distance from source, altitude, temperature, conductivity, alkalinity and nitrate) and the trichopteran assemblages (using trichopteran based metrics) of these clusters were confirmed by the Kruskal-Wallis test (H) and Dunn’s test. Chemical classification of samples within the clusters revealed a strong association between trichopteran assemblages and water quality. Canonical Correspondence Analysis and Monte Carlo global permutation tests also identified significant associations between the larval assemblages and physicochemical variables such as temperature and conductivity along a strong physical gradient (altitude, slope) and nitrate along a weaker seasonal gradient. Analysis of functional feeding group distribution patterns clearly showed that mid to high altitude indigenous woodland sites were trophically diverse whilst the lower reaches of the islands streams are trophically impoverished with strong seasonal shifts between two feeding groups of enrichment tolerant taxa. Trichopteran shredders are exclusive to indigenous woodland sites, indicating a limited distribution associated with land use, allochthonous input and habitat destruction. The results indicate that several ‘environmental filters’ operate at different levels upon the islands trichopteran fauna, producing temporally and spatially distinct ‘subsets’ of species best able to exploit conditions and resources at a given site or time, confounding the direct comparison of these insular systems with the findings of the River Continuum Concept, traditionally associated with unaffected continental lotic systems.     

The Benthic Invertebrates Floodplain Index – Extending the assessment approach

Floodplains are highly diverse landscape elements within river systems and among the most endangered ecosystems worldwide. In this paper we complement indices developed to assess the ecological status of floodplain systems, compliant with the EU Water Framework Directive, to an overall “Benthic Invertebrate Floodplain Index” (BIFI). With the addition of taxa (mainly oligochaetes, chironomidae and amphipoda) to the floodplain index (FI), caddisfly (CHI), and dragon fly (OHI) indices a new extended BIFI can be calculated. We provide values for the calculation of the index derived from a comprehensive dataset of Austrian floodplain waters complemented by literature data. Values are given for those taxonomic groups which are abundant in the Austrian Danube and determinable in reasonable time. The new index was compared to published floodplain indices and tested with an independent data set at two floodplain segments along the Austrian Danube. The newly classified benthic invertebrates (NCBI) showed a good performance in comparison to the so far published indices and extend these to a better coverage of dynamic water bodies. Further the inclusion of abundant and species rich taxa improves the robustness of calculated values already with a low sampling effort. Altogether it is a promising tool for the integrated assessment of the ecological status of river-floodplain systems according to the EU Water Framework Directive.     

The Water Framework Directive’s “percentage of surface water bodies at good status”: unveiling the hidden side of a “hyperindicator”

The Water Framework Directive (WFD) has provided the means of standardizing the way surface water bodies are monitored throughout the European Union (EU), using a common evaluation measure, the percentage of surface water bodies at good status, based largely on the structure and functioning of aquatic ecosystems. However, the evaluation of good status is based on the way the WFD is implemented, which differs in each country. In this article, we analyze how the WFD is implemented in France, how the water agencies divide up the water bodies, the areas covered by their monitoring networks, and the modalities of obtaining data to provide the EU with the percentage of water bodies at good status. This analysis reveals that it is this hyperindicator itself that is at stake, obtained by successively aggregating values measured in time and space, from the monitoring station to the River Basin District (RBD), reducing vast amounts of information to a single measure per RBD, while long-term monitoring of the major European rivers and their sedimentary budgets, which show improvements in certain quality aspects, are largely overlooked by the WFD. When drawing up the indicator, the agencies identify certain biases but not others. This raises the question of its use and relevance for managers and politicians, at both national and European level.     

Analysis of long-term ecological status of Lake Balaton based on the ALMOBAL phytoplankton database

Lake Balaton (Hungary), one of the largest lakes in Europe, has undergone eutrophication and restoration during the last two decades. The first quantitative phytoplankton records date back to the 1930s, and since that time thousands of data have been published or accumulated in counting protocols or computer sheets. These data provide material for both scientific analyses (e.g. effects of global change) and applications (e.g. estimation of reference state for the Water Framework Directive). The ALMOBAL phytoplankton database was developed to provide computing support for these applications. It stores data in standardized forms, handles synonyms and allows analyses to be conducted on the basis of floral records, numbers or biomass. The analysis includes records of about 3000 phytoplankton samples taken during the past 60 years from two representative basins in Lake Balaton. This article represents the first attempt at historical reconstruction of the ecological status and compares it with changes in trophic state and current water quality. The results indicate that the phytoplankton biomass and community structure found in the early 1960s could be regarded as reference conditions. Statistical analyses support the view that late summer phytoplankton assemblages are the most sensitive indicators of trophic change, and clearly show the eutrophication of the lake that occurred from the mid-1970s to the mid-1990s and the restoration during the last decade. An additional advantage is that, since quality estimation is based on relative biomass, the method can be used to reconstruct water quality in cases when counting protocols are available, but some basic data for quantitative estimates are missing.     

Nutrient optima and tolerances of benthic invertebrates,the effects of taxonomic resolution and testing of selected metrics in lakes using an extensive European data base

A large dataset from 1,077 lakes in Finland, Ireland, Sweden and the United Kingdom was collated to analyse the relationship between nutrient status and occurrence of different taxa, as well as between total phosphorus or chlorophyll and commonly used macroinvertebrate metrics developed for river assessment. We found that most taxa were associated with mesotrophic conditions (sensu OECD). Species associated with oligotrophic status included Baetis rhodani, Gammarus lacustris and plecopteran larvae, a group commonly associated with low nutrient status also in rivers. Species tolerant of eutrophic conditions were the chironomid larvae (Chironomus plumosus and Cryptochironomus defectus); and two species of tubificids (Psammoryctides barbatus and Potamothrix hammoniensis). For a number of taxa the associations of benthic invertebrates with nutrient state reported in the literature were not supported by analysis of the REBECCA data. The analysis indicated a variable response of littoral macroinvertebrates to eutrophication pressure when using common metrics developed for macroinvertebrates in rivers. Several metrics showed significantly different responses in lakes with different alkalinity, justifying the use of alkalinity for typing water bodies. These significant responses suggest that benthic invertebrates may be a useful component for classification of ecological status in lakes. The low amount of variance explained by the regressions (<30%), however, suggests that further harmonisation of sampling methods, as well as statistically more robust assessment tools are needed to increase the comparability of datasets and to improve the precision in the dose–response relationships.     

Aggregated indices for trends in eutrophication of different types of fresh water in the Netherlands

As in many European countries, eutrophication of surface waters is a key problem in the Netherlands, caused by high concentrations of nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P). For implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive (WFD) in the Netherlands, surface water types have been identified and for each water type environmental quality standard concentrations (EQS) were determined for both nutrients. With these standards, a new method was developed to quantify trends in water quality with respect to eutrophication on a national scale for the period 1990–2010. Firstly, monitoring data were aggregated to seven classes of surface water. Next, for each water class and each nutrient, a Nutrient Index was developed to express the degree of exceedance of EQS (distance-to-target method). The Nutrient Index for N shows a minor exceedance of EQS as well as an improvement in all water types; for P, the index shows a major exceedance in small stagnant waters throughout the 1990–2010 period, whereas in major rivers and lakes levels were close to EQS. Thirdly, the indices for seven surface water classes were aggregated to one index for each nutrient, and finally to a national Eutrophication Index combining N and P. This Eutrophication Index integrates all monitoring data and shows an improvement in the period 1990–2003 and stabilization since 2004.