Update on chloroplast proteomics

Currently, relatively few proteomics studies of chloroplast have been published, but the field has just started emerging and is likely to develop more rapidly in the future. While the complex membrane structure of the chloroplast makes it difficult to study its entire proteome by global approaches, proteomics has considerably increased our knowledge of the proteins of single compartments such as, for instance, the envelope and the thylakoid lumen. Proteomics has also succeeded in the subunit characterisation of select protein complexes such as the ribosomes and the cytochrome b (6)f complex. In addition, proteomics was successfully applied to find new potential target pathways for thioredoxin-mediated signal transduction. In this review, we present an overview of the latest developments in the field of chloroplast proteomics and discuss their impact on photosynthesis research. In addition, we summarise the current state of research in proteomics of the photosynthetic cyanobactrium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803.     

Thioredoxin targets of the plant chloroplast lumen and their implications for plastid function

The light‐dependent regulation of stromal enzymes by thioredoxin (Trx)‐catalysed disulphide/dithiol exchange is known as a classical mechanism for control of chloroplast metabolism. Recent proteome studies show that Trx targets are present not only in the stroma but in all chloroplast compartments, from the envelope to the thylakoid lumen. Trx‐mediated redox control appears to be a common feature of important pathways, such as the Calvin cycle, starch synthesis and tetrapyrrole biosynthesis. However, the extent of thiol‐dependent redox regulation in the thylakoid lumen has not been previously systematically explored. In this study, we addressed Trx‐linked redox control in the chloroplast lumen of Arabidopsis thaliana. Using complementary proteomics approaches, we identified 19 Trx target proteins, thus covering more than 40% of the currently known lumenal chloroplast proteome. We show that the redox state of thiols is decisive for degradation of the extrinsic PsbO1 and PsbO2 subunits of photosystem II. Moreover, disulphide reduction inhibits activity of the xanthophyll cycle enzyme violaxanthin de‐epoxidase, which participates in thermal dissipation of excess absorbed light. Our results indicate that redox‐controlled reactions in the chloroplast lumen play essential roles in the function of photosystem II and the regulation of adaptation to light intensity.     

Central functions of the lumenal and peripheral thylakoid proteome of Arabidopsis determined by experimentation and genome-wide prediction

Experimental proteome analysis was combined with a genome-wide prediction screen to characterize the protein content of the thylakoid lumen of Arabidopsis chloroplasts. Soluble thylakoid proteins were separated by two-dimensional electrophoresis and identified by mass spectrometry. The identities of 81 proteins were established, and N termini were sequenced to validate localization prediction. Gene annotation of the identified proteins was corrected by experimental data, and an interesting case of alternative splicing was discovered. Expression of a surprising number of paralogs was detected. Expression of five isomerases of different classes suggests strong (un)folding activity in the thylakoid lumen. These isomerases possibly are connected to a network of peripheral and lumenal proteins involved in antioxidative response, including peroxiredoxins, m-type thioredoxins, and a lumenal ascorbate peroxidase. Characteristics of the experimentally identified lumenal proteins and their orthologs were used for a genome-wide prediction of the lumenal proteome. Lumenal proteins with a typical twin-arginine translocation motif were predicted with good accuracy and sensitivity and included additional isomerases and proteases. Thus, prime functions of the lumenal proteome include assistance in the folding and proteolysis of thylakoid proteins as well as protection against oxidative stress. Many of the predicted lumenal proteins must be present at concentrations at least 10,000-fold lower than proteins of the photosynthetic apparatus.     

Plant membrane proteome databases

In all living organisms transmembrane (TM) proteins are crucially involved in many physiological processes and constitute 20-30% of the proteome. An important class of TM proteins are transporters that interconnect biochemical pathways across the plasma membrane and intracellular membranes, e.g. the mitochondrial membranes and chloroplast envelope membranes. In recent years, bioinformatical tools to predict TM domains and subcellular localization were developed and used to analyze the first complete plant genomes of Arabidopsis and rice. This review focuses on plant TM proteome databases that compile topology and intracellular targeting predictions and different kinds of experimental data. In addition, other web sites are discussed that contribute useful experimental and/or bioinformatical data.     

A Psb27 homologue in Arabidopsis thaliana is required for efficient repair of photodamaged photosystem II

Psb27 has been identified as a lumenal protein associated with photosystem II (PSII). To gain insight into the function of Psb27, we isolated a mutant Arabidopsis plant with a loss of psb27 function. The quantity of PSII complexes and electron transfer within PSII remained largely unaffected in the psb27 mutant. Our results also showed that under high-light-illumination, PSII activity and the content of the PSII reaction center protein D1 decreased more significantly in the psb27 mutant than in wild-type (WT) plant. Treatment of leaves with a chloroplast protein synthesis inhibitor resulted in similar light-induced PSII inactivation levels and D1 protein degradation rates in the WT and psb27 mutant plants. Recovery of PSII activity after photoinhibition was delayed in the psb27 mutant, suggesting that Psb27 is required for efficient recovery of the photodamaged PSII complex. Overall, these results demonstrated that Psb27 in Arabidopsis is not essential for oxygenic photosynthesis and PSII formation. Instead, our results provide evidence for the involvement of this lumenal protein in the recovery process of PSII. Hua Chen and Dongyuan Zhang contribute equally to this work.     

Targeted overexpression of the Escherichia coli MinC protein in higher plants results in abnormal chloroplasts

Higher plant chloroplast division involves some of the same types of proteins that are required in prokaryotic cell division. These include two of the three Min proteins, MinD and MinE, encoded by the min operon in bacteria. Noticeably absent from annotated sequences from higher plants is a MinC homologue. A higher plant functional MinC homologue that would interfere with FtsZ polymerization, has yet to be identified. We sought to determine whether expression of the bacterial MinC in higher plants could affect chloroplast division. The Escherichia coli minC (EcMinC) gene was isolated and inserted behind the Arabidopsis thaliana RbcS transit peptide sequence for chloroplast targeting. This TP-EcMinC gene driven by the CaMV 35S² constitutive promoter was then transformed into tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.). Abnormally large chloroplasts were observed in the transgenic plants suggesting that overexpression of the E. coli MinC perturbed higher plant chloroplast division.     

Proteomics of chloroplast envelope membranes

Proteomics is a very powerful approach to link the information contained in sequenced genomes, like Arabidopsis, to the functional knowledge provided by studies of plant cell compartments, such as chloroplast envelope membranes. This review summarizes the present state of proteomic analyses of highly purified spinach and Arabidopsis envelope membranes. Methods targeted towards the hydrophobic core of the envelope allow identifying new proteins, and especially new transport systems. Common features were identified among the known and newly identified putative envelope inner membrane transporters and were used to mine the complete Arabidopsis genome to establish a virtual plastid envelope integral protein database. Arabidopsis envelope membrane proteins were extracted using different methods, that is, chloroform/methanol extraction, alkaline or saline treatments, in order to retrieve as many proteins as possible, from the most to the less hydrophobic ones. Mass spectrometry analyses lead to the identification of more than 100 proteins. More than 50% of the identified proteins have functions known or very likely to be associated with the chloroplast envelope. These proteins are (a) involved in ion and metabolite transport, (b) components of the protein import machinery and (c) involved in chloroplast lipid metabolism. Some soluble proteins, like proteases, proteins involved in carbon metabolism or in responses to oxidative stress, were associated with envelope membranes. Almost one third of the newly identified proteins have no known function. The present stage of the work demonstrates that a combination of different proteomics approaches together with bioinformatics and the use of different biological models indeed provide a better understanding of chloroplast envelope biochemical machinery at the molecular level.     

Thylakoid membrane proteomics

Proteomics seeks to monitor the global complement of proteins within a cell or organism and accompanying plasticity with respect to development and environment. The proteome is dynamic, the product of current and past gene expression, countless protein-protein interactions and selective proteolytic systems. Consequently the snapshot that a proteomic measurement yields must be integrated into proteome flux; the flow of nutrients and energy through the protein pathways that catalyze and drive life. The thylakoid membrane proteome poses many technical challenges for proteomics. Integral membrane proteins present awkward physico-chemical properties and the abundant photosynthetic machinery conceals much less abundant and no less important proteins such as channels and transporters that control the interaction of stroma and lumen. Discussed here are contrasting approaches to thylakoid proteomics; 'shotgun' techniques that provide throughput benefits by cleaving proteins into smaller more-manageable peptide chunks versus intact protein techniques that provide more detailed and accurate pictures. A two-dimensional chromatography system directly interfaced to electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry has allowed the direct visualization of large reaction-center proteins (up to 83 kDa) from both Photosystems 1 and 2 providing an attractive avenue for characterization of thylakoid membrane proteomes under different conditions because of the ability to resolve molecular heterogeneity resulting from post-translational modifications such as phosphorylation and oxidation. A high-resolution spectrum of Bacteriorhodopsin recorded to an accuracy of 8 ppm using Fourier-transform mass spectrometry demonstrates the first application of this technique to intact polytopic integral membrane proteins.     

Chloroplast Proteases

The chloroplast within the plant cell has a dynamic environment where proteases play an important role in processing of precursor proteins, degradation of incomplete proteins lacking cofactors, stress-induced degradation and removal of damaged proteins. A number of proteases in the chloroplast are well characterized and found to be localized within different compartments such as stroma, thylakoids and lumen. In recent years, an increasing number of proteases in chloroplasts have been discovered and identified as bacterial protease homologues. These include the stromal Clp, thylakoidal FtsH and lumenal DegP. The current focus is to understand their role in chloroplast regulation both at the enzyme-substrate and genetic levels.     

Chloroplast sulfate transport in green algae – genes,proteins and effects

This review summarizes evidence at the molecular genetic, protein and regulatory levels concerning the existence and function of a putative ABC-type chloroplast envelope-localized sulfate transporter in the model unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. From the four nuclear genes encoding this sulfate permease holocomplex, two are coding for chloroplast envelope-targeted transmembrane proteins (SulP and SulP2), a chloroplast stroma-targeted ATP-binding protein (Sabc) and a substrate (sulfate)-binding protein (Sbp) that is localized on the cytosolic side of the chloroplast envelope. The sulfate permease holocomplex is postulated to consist of a SulP–SulP2 chloroplast envelope transmembrane heterodimer, flanked by the Sabc and the Sbp proteins on the stroma side and the cytosolic side of the inner envelope, respectively. The mature SulP and SulP2 proteins contain seven transmembrane domains and one or two large hydrophilic loops, which are oriented toward the cytosol. The corresponding prokaryotic-origin genes (SulP and SulP2) probably migrated from the chloroplast to the nuclear genome during the evolution of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. These genes, or any of its homologues, have not been retained in vascular plants, e.g. Arabidopsis thaliana, although they are encountered in the chloroplast genome of a liverwort (Marchantia polymorpha). The function of the SulP protein was probed in antisense transformants of C. reinhardtii having lower expression levels of the SulP gene. Results showed that cellular sulfate uptake capacity was lowered as a consequence of attenuated SulP gene expression in the cell, directly affecting rates of de novo protein biosynthesis in the chloroplast. The antisense transformants exhibited phenotypes of sulfate-deprived cells, displaying slow rates of light-saturated oxygen evolution, low levels of Rubisco in the chloroplast and low steady-state levels of the Photosystem II D1 reaction center protein. The role of the chloroplast sulfate transport in the uptake and assimilation of sulfate in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii is discussed along with its impact on the repair of Photosystem II from a frequently occurring photo-oxidative damage and H₂-evolution related metabolism in this green alga.     

Lateral roots affect the proteome of the primary root of maize (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Zea mays</Emphasis> L.)

Lateral roots are initiated from the pericycle cells of other types of roots and remain in contact with these roots throughout their life span. Although this physical contact has the potential to permit the exchange of signals, little is known about the flow of information from the lateral roots to the primary root. To begin to study these interactions the proteome of the primary root system of the maize (Zea mays L.) lrt1 mutant, which does not initiate lateral roots, was compared with the corresponding proteome of wild-type seedlings 9 days after germination. Approximately 150 soluble root proteins were resolved by two-dimensional electrophoresis and analyzed by MALDI-ToF mass spectrometry and database searching. The 96 most abundant proteins from a pH 4–7 gradient were analyzed; 67 proteins representing 47 different Genbank accessions were identified. Interestingly, 10 (15/150) of the detected proteins were preferentially expressed in lrt1 roots that lack lateral roots. Eight of these lrt1-specific proteins were identified and four are involved in lignin metabolism. This study demonstrates for the first time the influence of lateral roots on the proteome of the primary root system. To our knowledge this is the first study to demonstrate an interaction between two plant organs (viz., lateral and primary roots) at the level of the proteome.     

Chloroplast proteomics: potentials and challenges

With the available Arabidopsis genome and near-completion of the rice genome sequencing project, large-scale analysis of plant proteins with mass spectrometry has now become possible. Determining the proteome of a cell is a challenging task, which is complicated by proteome dynamics and complexity. The biochemical heterogeneity of proteins constrains the use of standardized analytical procedures and requires demanding techniques for proteome analysis. Several proteome studies of plant cell organelles have been reported, including chloroplasts and mitochondria. Chloroplasts are of particular interest for plant biologists because of their complex biochemical pathways for essential metabolic functions. Information from the chloroplast proteome will therefore provide new insights into pathway compartmentalization and protein sorting. Some approaches for the analysis of the chloroplast proteome and future prospects of plastid proteome research are discussed here.     

Evidence for nucleotide-dependent processes in the thylakoid lumen of plant chloroplasts - an update

The thylakoid lumen is an aqueous chloroplast compartment enclosed by the thylakoid membrane network. Bioinformatic and proteomic studies indicated the existence of 80-90 thylakoid lumenal proteins in Arabidopsis thaliana, having photosynthetic, non-photosynthetic or unclassified functions. None of the identified lumenal proteins had canonical nucleotide-binding motifs. It was therefore suggested that, in contrast to the chloroplast stroma harboring nucleotide-dependent enzymes and other proteins, the thylakoid lumen is a nucleotide-free compartment. Based on recent findings, we provide here an updated view about the presence of nucleotides in the thylakoid lumen of plant chloroplasts, and their role in function and dynamics of photosynthetic complexes.     

Analysis of the chloroplast protein complexes by blue-native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE)

Blue-native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) is a powerful procedure for the separation and characterization of the protein complexes from mitochondria. Membrane proteins are solubilized in the presence of aminocaproic acid and n-dodecylmaltoside and Coomassie-dyes are utilized before electrophoresis to introduce a charge shift on proteins. Here, we report a modification of the procedure for the analysis of chloroplast protein complexes. The two photosystems, the light-harvesting complexes, the ATP synthase, the cytochrome b ₆ f complex and the ribulose-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase are well resolved. Analysis of the protein complexes on a second gel dimension under denaturing conditions allows separation of more than 50 different proteins which are part of chloroplast multi-subunit enzymes. The resolution capacity of the blue-native gels is very high if compared to 'native green gel systems' published previously. N-terminal amino acid sequences of single subunits can be directly determined by cyclic Edman degradation as demonstrated for eight proteins. Analysis of chloroplast protein complexes by blue-native gel electrophoresis will allow the generation of 'protein maps' from different species, tissues and developmental stages or from mutant organelles. Further applications of blue-native gel electrophoresis are discussed.     

Chloroplast transit peptides from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii share features with both mitochondrial and higher plant chloroplast presequences

Chloroplast transit peptides from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii have been analyzed and compared with chloroplast transit peptides from higher plants and mitochondrial targeting peptides from yeast, Neurospora and higher eukaryotes. In terms of length and amino acid composition, chloroplast transit peptides from C. reinhardtii are more similar to mitochondrial targetting peptides than to chloroplast transit peptides from higher plants. They also contain the potential amphiphilic α-helix characteristic of mitochondrial presequences. However, in similarity with chloroplast transit peptides from higher plants, they contain a C-terminal region with the potential to form an amphiphilic β-strand. As in higher plants, transit peptides that route proteins to the thylakoid lumen consist of an N-tenninal domain similar to stroma-targeting transit peptides attached to a C-terminal apolar domain that share many characteristics with secretory signal peptides.     

Characterization of a T-DNA insertion mutant for the protein import receptor atToc33 from chloroplasts

In Arabidopsis thaliana, the Toc34 receptor component of the chloroplast import machinery is encoded by two independent but highly homologous genes, atToc33 and atToc34. We have isolated a T-DNA insertion mutant of atToc33 which is characterized by a pale phenotype, due to reductions in the levels of photosynthetic pigments, and alterations in protein composition. The latter involve not only chloroplast proteins but also some cytosolic polypeptides, including 14-3-3 proteins which, among other functions, have been proposed to be cytosolic targeting factors for nucleus-encoded chloroplast proteins. Within the chloroplast, many, though not all, proteins of the photosynthetic apparatus, as well as proteins not directly involved in photosynthesis, are found in significantly reduced amounts in the mutant. However, the accumulation of other chloroplast proteins is unaffected. This suggests that the atToc33 receptor is responsible for the import of a specific subset of nucleus-encoded chloroplast proteins. Supporting evidence for this conclusion was obtained by antisense repression of the atToc34 gene in the atToc33 mutant, which results in an exacerbation of the phenotype.Communicated by R. Hagemann     

Molecular and genetic analysis of the chloroplast ATPase of chlamydomonas

Summary We have carried out a molecular and genetic analysis of the chloroplast ATPase in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Recombination and complementation studies on 16 independently isolated chloroplast mutations affecting this complex demonstrated that they represent alleles in five distinct chloroplast genes. One of these five, the ac-u-c locus, has been positioned on the physical map of the chloroplast DNA by deletion mutations. The use of cloned spinach chloroplast ATPase genes in heterologous hybridizations to Chlamydomonas chloroplast DNA has allowed us to localize three or possibly four of the ATPase genes on the physical map. The beta and probably the epsilon subunit genes of Chlamydomonas CF₁ lie within the same region of chloroplast DNA as the ac-u-c locus, while the alpha and proteolipid subunit genes appear to map adjacent to one another approximately 20 kbp away. Unlike the arrangement in higher plants, these two pairs of genes are separated from each other by an inverted repeat.