Soybean Kunitz, C-II and PI-IV inhibitor genes confer different levels of insect resistance to tobacco and potato transgenic plants

In modern, highly intensive agriculture, the control of insect pests is basically achieved with the application of chemical pesticides. Heavy reliance on this sole strategy is associated with several drawbacks, and the development of alternative or complementary methods to chemical control is desirable. In this work, three soybean genes (KTi ₃ , C-II and PI-IV)coding for serine proteinase inhibitors were isolated by PCR and transferred to Agrobacterium tumefaciens EHA 105, which in turn was used for transforming tobacco leaf and potato tuber discs. Biochemical assays confirmed that transgenic plants synthesized serine proteinase inhibitors; rates of expression varied among plants. The level of insect resistance (tested with Spodoptera littoralis Boisduval) was particularly high in tobacco, where many plants caused the death of all larvae. In potatoes, larval mortality was much less frequently achieved, but the results were still encouraging in that larval weight gain was reduced by 50% in the presence of adequate amounts of inhibitor. When 8-day-old larvae were fed different KTi ₃ -expressing tobacco plants, a highly significant (P<0.01) correlation was observed between inhibitor content and larval live weight. Larval weight gain was found to be dependent on midgut proteolytic activity. On the basis of the evidence collected, it is suggested that further work is required to identify more specific inhibitors for the main proteinases of the target insect. Received: 30 March 1998 / Accepted: 9 December 1999     

Physiological adaptation explains the insensitivity of Baris coerulescens to transgenic oilseed rape expressing oryzacystatin I

Larvae of Baris coerulescens Scop. (Coleoptera: Curculionidæ) exhibit a complex array of gut proteinase activities comprising cysteine and serine proteinases. The major cysteine proteinase activity, showing an optimum at pH 6.0, corresponds to at least 4 different proteinases. On the contrary, the minor serine proteinase activity, with an optimum at pH 9.0, seems to be due essentially to a single proteinase. The cysteine proteinase inhibitor oryzacystatin I (OC-I) inhibits completely the cysteine proteinase activity in vitro. However, larval growth and survival were not significantly different on control and transgenic oilseed rape plants expressing high levels of active OC-I. In larvae grown on transgenic plants, cysteine proteinase activity was dramatically decreased, whereas serine proteinase activity was increased by more than 2-fold, when compared to larvae raised on control plants. For both activities, no new proteinase was detected in insects fed plants expressing OC-I. These results suggest that partial compensation of the inhibition of cysteine proteinase activity by the increase in serine proteinase activity allowed the larvae to overcome the effects of OC-I consumption. This case illustrates problems that could arise when trying to achieve high levels of protection for plants against Coleopteran pests possessing a complex digestive proteinase pool.     

Tobacco plants expressing the Cry1AbMod toxin suppress tolerance to Cry1Ab toxin of Manduca sexta cadherin-silenced larvae

Cry toxins produced by Bacillus thuringiensis bacteria are insecticidal proteins used worldwide in the control of different insect pests. Alterations in toxin-receptor interaction represent the most common mechanism to induce resistance to Cry toxins in lepidopteran insects. Cry toxins bind with high affinity to the cadherin protein present in the midgut cells and this interaction facilitates the proteolytic removal of helix ??-1 and pre-pore oligomer formation. Resistance to Cry toxins has been linked with mutations in the cadherin gene. One strategy effective to overcome larval resistance to Cry1A toxins is the production of Cry1AMod toxins that lack helix ??-1. Cry1AMod are able to form oligomeric structures without binding to cadherin receptor and were shown to be toxic to cadherin-silenced Manduca sexta larvae and Pectinophora gossypiella strain with resistance linked to mutations in a cadherin gene.We developed Cry1AbMod tobacco transgenic plants to analyze if Cry1AMod toxins can be expressed in transgenic crops, do not affect plant development and are able to control insect pests. Our results show that production of the Cry1AbMod toxin in transgenic plants does not affect plant development, since these plants exhibited healthy growth, produced abundant seeds, and were virtually undistinguishable from control plants. Most importantly, Cry1AbMod protein produced in tobacco plants retains its functional toxic activity against susceptible and tolerant M. sexta larvae due to the silencing of cadherin receptor by RNAi. These results suggest that CryMod toxins could potentially be expressed in other transgenic crops to protect them against both toxin-susceptible and resistant lepidopteran larvae affected in cadherin gene.     

Expression of the maize proteinase inhibitor (mpi) gene in rice plants enhances resistance against the striped stem borer (Chilo suppressalis): effects on larval growth and insect gut proteinases

The maize proteinase inhibitor (mpi) gene was introduced into two elite japonica rice varieties. Both constitutive expression of the mpi gene driven by the maize ubiquitin 1 promoter and wound-inducible expression of the mpi gene driven by its own promoter resulted in the accumulation of MPI protein in the transgenic plants. No effect on plant phenotype was observed in mpi-expressing lines. The stability of transgene expression through successive generations of mpi rice lines (up to the T(4) generation) and the production of functional MPI protein were confirmed. Expression of the mpi gene in rice enhanced resistance to the striped stem borer (Chilo suppressalis), one of the most important pests of rice. In addition, transgenic mpi plants were evaluated in terms of their effects on the growth of C. suppressalis larvae and the insect digestive proteolytic system. An important dose-dependent reduction of larval weight of C. suppressalis larvae fed on mpi rice, compared with larvae fed on untransformed rice plants, was observed. Analysis of the digestive proteolytic activity from the gut of C. suppressalis demonstrated that larvae adapted to mpi transgene expression by increasing the complement of digestive proteolytic activity: the serine and cysteine endoproteinases as well as the exopeptidases leucine aminopeptidase and carboxypeptidases A and B. However, the induction of such proteolytic activity did not prevent the deleterious effects of MPI on larval growth. The introduction of the mpi gene into rice plants can thus be considered as a promising strategy to protect rice plants against striped stem borer.     

A proteinase inhibitor from Nicotiana alata inhibits the normal development of light-brown apple moth, Epiphyas postvittana in transgenic apple plants

Insecticidal proteins are a potential resource to enhance resistance to insect pests in transgenic plants. Here, we describe the generation and analysis of the apple cultivar ‘Royal Gala’ transgenic for Nicotiana alata (N. alata) proteinase inhibitor (PI) and the impact of this PI on the growth and development of the Epiphyas postvittiana (light-brown apple moth). A cDNA clone encoding a proteinase inhibitor precursor from N. alata (Na-PI) under the control of either a double 35S promoter or a promoter from a ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase small sub-unit gene (rbcS-E9 promoter) was stably incorporated into ‘Royal Gala’ apple using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. A 40.3 kDa Na-PI precursor protein was expressed and correctly processed into 6-kDa proteinase inhibitors in the leaves of transgenic apple lines. The 6-kDa polypeptides accumulated to levels of 0.05 and 0.1% of the total soluble protein under the control of the rbc-E9 promoter and the double 35S promoter, respectively. Light-brown apple moth larvae fed with apple leaves expressing Na-PI had significantly reduced body weight after 7 days of feeding and female pupae were 19–28% smaller than controls. In addition, morphological changes such as pupal cases attached to the wing, deformed wings, deformed body shape, and pupal cases and curled wings attached to a deformed body were observed in adults that developed from larvae fed with apple leaves expressing Na-PI, when compared to larvae fed with the non-transformed apple leaves.     

Improvement of pest resistance in transgenic tobacco plants expressing dsRNA of an insect-associated gene EcR

The adoption of pest-resistant transgenic plants to reduce yield loss and pesticide utilization has been successful in the past three decades. Recently, transgenic plant expressing double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) targeting pest genes emerges as a promising strategy for improving pest resistance in crops. The steroid hormone, 20-hydroxyecdysone (20E), predominately controls insect molting via its nuclear receptor complex, EcR-USP. Here we report that pest resistance is improved in transgenic tobacco plants expressing dsRNA of EcR from the cotton bollworm, Helicoverpa armigera, a serious lepidopteran pest for a variety of crops. When H. armigera larvae were fed with the whole transgenic tobacco plants expressing EcR dsRNA, resistance to H. armigera was significantly improved in transgenic plants. Meanwhile, when H. armigera larvae were fed with leaves of transgenic tobacco plants expressing EcR dsRNA, its EcR mRNA level was dramatically decreased causing molting defects and larval lethality. In addition, the transgenic tobacco plants expressing H. armigera EcR dsRNA were also resistant to another lepidopteran pest, the beet armyworm, Spodoptera exigua, due to the high similarity in the nucleotide sequences of their EcR genes. This study provides additional evidence that transgenic plant expressing dsRNA targeting insect-associated genes is able to improve pest resistance.     

Complexity in specificities and expression of Helicoverpa armigera gut proteinases explains polyphagous nature of the insect pest

Helicoverpa armigera is a devastating pest of cotton and other important crop plants all over the world. A detailed biochemical investigation of H. armigera gut proteinases is essential for planning effective proteinase inhibitor (PI)-based strategies to counter the insect infestation. In this study, we report the complexity of gut proteinase composition of H. armigera fed on four different host plants, viz. chickpea, pigeonpea, cotton and okra, and during larval development. H. armigera fed on chickpea showed more than 2.5- to 3-fold proteinase activity than those fed on the other host plants. H. armigera gut proteinase composition revealed the predominance of serine proteinase activity; however, the larvae fed on pigeonpea revealed the presence of metalloproteases and low levels of aspartic and cysteine proteases as well. Gut proteinase activity increased during larval development with the highest activity seen in the fifth instar larvae which, however, declined sharply in the sixth instar. Over 90% of the gut proteinase activity of the fifth instar larvae was of the serine proteinase type, however, the second instar larvae showed the presence of proteinases of other mechanistic classes like metalloproteases, aspartic and cysteine proteases along with serine proteinase activity as evident by inhibition studies. Analysis of fecal matter of larvae showed significant increase in proteinase activity when fed on an artificial diet with or without non-host PIs than larvae fed on a natural diet. The diversity in the proteinase activity observed in H. armigera gut and the flexibility in their expression during developmental stages and depending upon the diet provides a base for selection of proper PIs for insect resistance in transgenic crop plants.     

Expression of soybean proteinase inhibitors in transgenic sugarcane plants: effects on natural defense against Diatraea saccharalis

The introduction and expression of proteinase inhibitor encoding genes into sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum L.) genome is an interesting strategy for conferring partial resistance to the sugarcane borer Diatraea saccharalis (Lepidoptera: Crambidae), the major insect pest of sugarcane in Brazil. To investigate the role of soybean (Glycine max L.) Kunitz trypsin inhibitor (SKTI) and soybean Bowman–Birk inhibitor (SBBI) in the control of D. saccharalis, the cDNAs encoding these proteinase inhibitors were placed under the control of the maize ubiquitin promoter (Ubi-1), and introduced into sugarcane callus using particle bombardment. Putative transgenic plants were initially identified after regeneration from callus growing in the presence of 30 mg l^–1 geneticin, while molecular characterization of transgenic plants revealed that both genes were incorporated into the sugarcane genome and expressed. We also carried out insect feeding trials using D. saccharalis neonate larvae and leaf tissue excised from propagated transgenic and untransformed plants, and found that the growth of larvae feeding on leaf tissue from transgenic plants containing BBI and Kunitz inhibitors was significantly retarded as compared to larvae fed on leaf tissue from untransformed plants. In greenhouse trials with transgenic sugarcane plants infested with D. saccharalis neonates, we found that these plants still presented the ‘dead heart’ symptom typically observed in susceptible plants in the field, suggesting that the retardation of the growth of D. saccharalis observed in the laboratory-based feeding trials was not sufficient to prevent this type of damage.     

Transgenic tobacco and peas expressing a proteinase inhibitor from Nicotiana alata have increased insect resistance

Proteinase inhibitors have been used to increase resistance to insect pests in transgenic plants. A cDNA clone encoding a multi-domain proteinase inhibitor precursor from Nicotiana alata (Na-PI) was transferred into tobacco and peas under the control of a promoter from a ribulose-1, 5-bisphosphate carboxylase small subunit gene. The Na-PI precursor was cleaved in the leaves of transgenic tobacco and peas, and M_r 6000 polypeptides accumulated to levels of 0.3% and 0.1%, respectively, of the total soluble protein. The Na-PI cDNA segregated as a dominant Mendelian trait and was stably transmitted for at least two generations of both species. Helicoverpa armigera larvae that ingested tobacco or pea leaves containing Na-PI exhibited higher mortality or were delayed in growth and development relative to control larvae.     

Colorado potato beetle larvae on potato plants expressing a locust proteinase inhibitor

The natural defence system of plants often involves inhibitors of digestive enzymes of their pests. Modem and environmental-friendly methods try to increase this plant resistance by expressing heterologous protease inhibitors in crops. Here we report the effects of expressing a gene from desert locust (Schistocerca gregaria) encoding two serine protease inhibitors in potato on Colorado potato beetle (Leptinotarsa decemlineata) larvae. The gene encoding both peptides on a single chain was used for Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of potato plants. The presence of the active inhibitor protein in the leaves was verified. The feeding bioassays in the laboratory showed that despite the low level of the peptide in leaves, CPB larvae on transgenic plants have grown slightly but significantly more slowly than those on control potato plants. The results support the notion that expression of multifunctional proteinase inhibitors of insect origin in plants might be a good strategy to improve insect resistance.     

The effect of GNA lectin on the α-amylase activity of the beet armyworm,Spodoptera exigua Hb. (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

Beet armyworm (Spodoptera exigua Hb.) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) is the major pest of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris). Pesticide applications are the main method of the insect control. So, alternative method/s is/are needed to control this insect species. So, in the current study, the effect of Galanthus nivalis agglutinin (GNA) (snowdrop lectin) on beet armyworm α-amylase was studied. Measurement of the amylase activity of the larval midgut fed on artificial diet and sugar beet leaves showed that the enzyme activity was higher when the larvae fed on artificial diet. However, in both cases, the fourth instar larvae had the greatest amylase activity. Thus, fourth instar larvae were offered artificial diet containing 1 and 2% GNA. Both treatments of the lectin significantly reduced the α-amylase activity of the insect. For example, amylase activity of the fourth instar larvae in the control (fed only on artificial diet) was 2.62 Uml^?1 whilst the activity of the enzyme in the two treatments including diet containing 2 and 1% lectin was 1.45 and 1.75 Uml^?1, respectively. The achieved data showed that lectin, in addition to have toxic effect on the larval growth and development, affects the α-amylase activity of the insect gut.     

Effects of a mustard trypsin inhibitor expressed in different plants on three lepidopteran pests

The effects of mustard trypsin inhibitor MTI-2 expressed at different levels in transgenic tobacco, arabidopsis and oilseed rape lines have been evaluated against three different lepidopteran insect pests. 1. Plutella xylostella (L.) larvae were the most sensitive to the ingestion of MTI-2. The inhibitor expressed at high levels in arabidopsis plants caused rapid and complete mortality. High mortality and significantly delayed larval development were also detectable in oilseed rape expressing MTI-2 at lower levels. 2. Mamestra brassicae (L.) larvae were sensitive only at high MTI-2 expression level, as obtained in transgenic tobacco and arabidopsis, whereas no effects were observed for larvae fed on plants showing relatively low expression levels such as those of oilseed rape lines. 3. Feeding bioassays with Spodoptera littoralis (Boisduval) larvae were carried out using the same oilseed rape lines, showing that at these low expression levels no mortality was observed although a delay in larval development did occur. The levels of insect gut proteolytic activities of the larvae still alive at the end of a 7 day feeding bioassay were usually higher than in the controls, but no new proteinases were expressed in any case. The combined results described in this paper demonstrate altogether the relevance of a case-by-case analysis [target insects and proteinase inhibitor (PI) level of expression in planta] in a PI-based strategy for plant protection.     

Host plant resistance in romaine lettuce affects feeding behavior and biology of Trichoplusia ni and Spodoptera exigua (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

Lettuce quality and yield can be reduced by feeding of several lepidopterous pests, particularly cabbage looper, Trichoplusia ni (Hübner), and beet armyworm, Spodoptera exigua (Hübner) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Host plant resistance to these insects is an environmentally sound adjunct to conventional chemical control. In this study we compared the survival, development, and feeding behavior of cabbage looper and beet armyworm on two romaine lettuce cultivars, resistant 'Valmaine' and susceptible 'Tall Guzmaine'. Larval mortality of both species was significantly higher on resistant Valmaine than on susceptible Tall Guzmaine. The average weight per larva after feeding for 1 wk on Tall Guzmaine plants was 6 times (beet armyworm) and 2 times (cabbage looper) greater than that of larvae feeding on Valmaine plants. Significant reduction in larval growth on Valmaine compared with that on Tall Guzmaine resulted in a 5.9- (beet armyworm) and 2.6-d (cabbage looper) increase in larval duration and almost a 1-d increase in pupal duration. Average pupal and adult weights and successful pupation of cabbage looper and beet armyworm were reduced on Valmaine compared with Tall Guzmaine. The sex ratio of progeny did not deviate from 1:1 when larvae were reared on either Valmaine or Tall Guzmaine. The fecundity of cabbage looper and beet armyworm adults that developed from larvae reared on Valmaine was about one-third that of adults from Tall Guzmaine, but adult longevity did not significantly differ on the two lettuce cultivars. The two insect species showed different feeding preferences for leaves of different age groups on Valmaine and Tall Guzmaine. Cabbage loopers cut narrow trenches on the leaf before actual feeding to block the flow of latex to the intended site of feeding. In contrast, beet armyworms did not trench. The different feeding behavior of the two species on Valmaine may explain the superior performance of cabbage looper compared with beet armyworm.     

Regeneration of Populus nigra transgenic plants expressing a Kunitz proteinase inhibitor (KTi3) gene

Transgenic poplar (Populus nigra, cv. Jean Pourtet) plants were recovered as a result of Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation performed with EHA105 pBI-KUN strain. Plasmid pBI-KUN contains a 650 bp insert derived from the soybean (Glycine max L.) KTi₃, gene, coding for a Kunitz trypsin proteinase inhibitor. A total of 58 independent transgenic lines were obtained from 200 co-cultivated leaf explants. Southern blot hybridization analysis demonstrated the presence of KTi₃ gene in the poplar genome. Northern blot analysis of different kanamycin-resistant plantlets confirmed the accumulation of KTi₃ mRNA and revealed different levels of expression. The trypsin inhibitory activity was determined in poplar transgenic tissues by means of specific assay. Moreover, the trypsin-like digestive proteinases of the polyphagous moth Lymantria dispar (Lepidoptera, Lymantriidae) and Clostera anastomosis (Lepidoptera, Notodontidae) were detected and inhibited in vitro by Kunitz proteinase inhibitor from selected transgenic plants. Two insect bioassays were performed on P. nigra transgenic plant lines, using larvae of the above mentioned insects. In both cases larval mortality and growth as well as pupal weight were not significantly affected when the insects were fed on transgenic leaves and control leaves, respectively.     

Enhanced drought resistance in fructan-producing sugar beet

Fructans are soluble polymers of fructose that are produced by approximately 15 % of the flowering plant species. Production of bacterial fructans in tobacco has been shown previously to lead to improved biomass production under polyethylene glycol-mediated drought stress. Here, we used the same SacB gene from Bacillus subtilis to produce bacterial fructans in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.). The transgenic sugar beets accumulated fructans to low levels (max. 0.5 % of dry weight) in both roots and shoots. Two independent transgenic lines of fructan-producing sugar beets showed significantly better growth under drought stress than untransformed beets. Drought stressed fructan-producing plants attained higher total dry weights (+25–35 %) than wildtype sugar beet, due to higher biomass production of leaves (+30–33 %), storage roots (+16–33 %) and fibrous roots (+37–60 %). Under well-watered conditions, no significant differences were observed between the transgenic and wildtype beets. In conclusion, the introduction of fructan biosynthesis in transgenic plants is a promising approach to improve crop productivity under drought stress.     

High level expression of soybean trypsin inhibitor gene in transgenic tobacco plants failed to confer resistance against damage caused byHelicoverpa armigera

Helicoverpa armigera is a major pest of many tropical crop plants. Soybean trypsin inhibitor (SBTI) was highly effective against the proteolytic activity of gut extract of the insect. SBTI was also inhibitory to insect growth when present in artificial diet. The gene coding for SBTI was cloned from soybean (Glycine max, CVBirsa) and transferred to tobacco plants for constitutive expression. Young larvae ofH. armigera, fed on the leaves of the transgenic tobacco plants expressing high level of SBTI, however, maintained normal growth and development. The results suggest that in certain cases the trypsin inhibitor gene(s) may not be suitable candidates for developing insect resistant transgenic plants.     

Phyto-inspired cyclic peptides derived from plant Pin-II type protease inhibitor reactive center loops for crop protection from insect pests

BackgroundNatural defence of plants against insect pests involves protease inhibitors (PIs) that interfere with insect digestive proteases. Pin-II type plant PIs are wound inducible upon insect damage and possess multiple inhibitory repeat domains that can inhibit trypsin and chymotrypsin-like proteases in the insect midgut. Yet, their agricultural ex-vivo application is limited due to large molecular size and environmental instability, which could be overcome by small peptides.MethodsBicyclic peptides were designed by grafting Pin-II PIs derived reactive center loop (RCL) on synthetic tris(bromomethyl)benzene scaffold. In vitro binding with trypsin-like proteases was evaluated by biochemical and biophysical assays, followed by molecular dynamics simulations. In vivo effects on two major lepidopteran insect pests, Helicoverpa armigera and Spodoptera litura were studied upon feeding with peptide treated leaves. Affinity based pull down assays were used to identify target proteins in insect gut.ResultsBicyclic RCLs showed ten-fold enhanced protease inhibition compared to their linear counterparts. They exhibited feeding deterrence and growth reduction of lepidopteran insects. Bicyclic peptides predominantly interact with midgut serine proteases. Possible binding modes involve simultaneous interaction with the active site and specificity-determining residues of insect gut trypsin.ConclusionBicyclic peptides are potent inhibitors of serine proteases in the insect midgut. They cause feeding aversion and larval growth retardation. Bi-domain cyclic peptides interact with two sites on trypsin, leading to enhanced efficacy over linear RCL peptides.General significanceBicyclic peptides mimic natural PIs by inhibiting insect proteases leading to growth reduction, thus, could be used as pest control molecules in agriculture.     

Effect of jasmonic acid and salicylic acid induced resistance in groundnut on Helicoverpa armigera

Induced resistance in plants affects insect growth and development as a result of the up‐regulation of defence‐related secondary metabolites or enzyme‐binding proteins. In the present study, the effects of jasmonic acid (JA) and salicylic acid (SA) induced resistance in groundnut on Helicoverpa armigera (Hübner) are examined. Larval survival, larval weights and the activities of digestive enzymes (total serine protease and trypsin) and of detoxifying enzymes [glutathione S‐transferase (GST) and esterase (EST)] are studied in insects fed on four groundnut genotypes with moderate levels of resistance to H. armigera (ICGV 86699, ICGV 86031, ICG 2271 and ICG 1697) and a susceptible genotype (JL 24). The plants are pre‐ and/or simultaneously treated with JA and SA, and then infested with H. armigera, which are allowed to feed for 6 days. Significantly lower serine protease and trypsin activities are observed in H. armigera fed on plants treated with JA. Greater GST activity is recorded in insects fed on JA and SA treated plants, whereas EST activity is low in H. armigera larvae fed on plants treated with JA and SA. Serine proteases, trypsin and GST activities and larval weights (r = 0.74–0.95) and larval survival (r = 0.77–0.93) are positively correlated, whereas EST activity and larval weight (r = ?0.55) and larval survival (r = ?0.65) are negatively correlated. The results suggest that midgut digestive and detoxifying enzymes can be used as indicators of the adverse effects of constitutive and/or induced resistance in crop plants on the insect pests and the role of JA and SA in insect pest management.