Ribosomal RNA gene sequences and hominoid phylogeny

Sequences totaling 3,500 bases from the 28S rRNA gene and from one of the ribosomal internal transcribed spacers (ITS1) have been determined for human, chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes), gorilla (Gorilla gorilla), and orangutan (Pongo pygmaeus). Analyses of the rRNA alignments show (1) a clustering of substitutions in the "variable regions" of the 28S gene, (2) a 1.5-3-fold increase in divergence in the transcribed spacer over that in the exon, and (3) that human and chimpanzee are the most closely related pair, in agreement with the results of Miyamoto et al., Sibley and Ahlquist, and Caccone and Powell.     

The phylogeny of the hominoid primates: a statistical analysis of the DNA-DNA hybridization data

Sibley and Ahlquist compared the single-copy nuclear DNA sequences of the hominoid primates using DNA-DNA hybridization. From this data set they estimated a phylogeny that clusters man and chimpanzees using a distance Wagner procedure. However, no assessment of statistical confidence in this estimated phylogeny was made, despite the fact that their data set contains internal inconsistencies concerning the correct branching order. This paper presents a modification of Pielou's Q- statistic that allows one to make nonparametric tests of phylogenetic relationship from distance data. The results of this analysis indicate that the estimated phylogeny of Sibley and Ahlquist is without statistical significance owing to the internal inconsistencies of the data set. A survey and additional analyses of other types of molecular data indicate that the phylogeny that clusters chimpanzees and gorillas and has the human lineage splitting off earlier is statistically consistent with all the molecular data (including the DNA-DNA hybridization data), whereas the phylogeny estimated by Sibley and Ahlquist can be rejected at the 5% level using the data on restriction- endonuclease sites in the mitochondrial genome.      

A complete sequence of the mitochondrial genome of the western lowland gorilla

The complete mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) molecule of the gorilla was sequenced. The entire sequence, 16,412 nucleotides, was determined by analysis of natural (not polymerase chain reaction) restriction fragments covering the whole molecule. The sequence was established from one individual and thus nonchimeric. After comparison with the COII gene of gorilla specimens with known geographical origin, the sequence was identified as characteristic of the Western lowland gorilla, Gorilla gorilla gorilla. With the exception of the NADH2 gene, all genes have a methionine start codon. The inferred start codon of NADH2 is ATT (isoleucine). The COIII, NASDH4, and cytochrome b genes are not terminated by a stop codon triplet, and the COI gene is probably terminated by an AAA triplet rather than by a regular stop codon. The great majority of genic sequences (rRNAs, peptide-coding genes, tRNAs) of the complete mtDNAs of Gorilla, Pan, and Homo show a greater similarity between Pan and Homo than between either of these genera to Gorilla. The analysis of the peptide-coding genes suggest that relative to comparison between Homo and Pan a certain degree of transition saturation has taken place in codon position 3 in comparisons between Gorilla to either Homo or Pan.      

Parasitological evidence pertaining to the phylogeny of the hominoid primates

A systematic review of parasitological data pertaining to the phylogeny of hominoid primates revealed considerable internal consistency and congruence with non-parasitological data. Hylobatids are supported as the sister-group of Pongo + Pan + Gorilla , the 'Great Apes'. Within the Great Apes, Pan + Gorilla are sister taxa. Multiple analyses of presence/absence data place Homo with cercopithecids, probably an artefact of humans' widespread occurrence and polymorphic feeding and living habits. Explicit phylogenetic hypotheses are available for only two parasite groups. Hookworms of the genus Oesophagostomum subgenus Conoweberia place Homo as the sister-group of Pan + Gorilla , whereas pinworms of the genus Enterobius place Homo as the sister-group of Pongo + Pan + Gorilla . This disagreement among data sets with regards to the placement of Homo , combined with the complete agreement about the placement of the other hominoids, is consistent with uncertainties in current findings from other sets of data.     

Structure of the gorilla alpha-fetoprotein gene and the divergence of primates.

The sequence of the gorilla alpha-fetoprotein gene, including 869 base pairs of the 5' flanking region and 4892 base pairs of the 3' flanking region (24,607 in total), was determined from two overlapping lambda phage clones. The sequence extends 18,846 base pairs from the Cap site to the polyadenylation site, and it reveals that the gene is composed of 15 exons, which are symmetrically placed within three domains of alpha-fetoprotein. The deduced polypeptide chain is composed of a 19-amino-acid leader peptide, followed by 590 amino acids of the mature protein. The RNA polymerase II binding site, TATAAAA, and the promoter element, CCAAC, are positioned at -21 and -65 from the Cap site, respectively. The polyadenylation signal, AATAAA, is located in the last exon, which is untranslated. The sequence for the gorilla alpha-fetoprotein gene was compared with that of the previously published human alpha-fetoprotein gene (P. E. M. Gibbs, R. Zielinski, C. Boyd, and A. Dugaiczyk, 1987, Biochemistry 26: 1332-1343). Four types of repetitive sequence elements were found in identical positions in both species. However, one Alu and one Xba DNA repeat within introns 4 and 7, respectively, of the human gene are absent from orthologous positions in the gorilla. The Alu and the Xba DNA repeats probably emerged in the human genome after the human/gorilla divergence and became established novelties in the human lineage. There are 363/21,523 mutational changes between human and gorilla, amounting to 1.69% DNA divergence between the two primate species. The value of 1.69% is lower than the 2.27% obtained from melting temperatures of hybrids between human and gorilla genomic DNA (C. G. Sibley and J. E. Ahlquist, 1984, J. Mol. Evol. 26: 99-121). At the protein level, Homo sapiens differs from Gorilla gorilla only at 4 of 609 amino acid positions (0.66%) in the alpha-fetoprotein sequence. This difference signifies a lower rate of molecular divergence for the alpha-fetoprotein gene in primates, as compared to rodents.     

Mass spectral analyses of the two major apolipoproteins of great ape high density lipoproteins

The two major apolipoproteins associated with human and chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes) high density lipoproteins (HDL) are apoA-I and dimeric apoA-II. Although humans are closely related to great apes, apolipoprotein data do not exist for bonobos (Pan paniscus), western lowland gorillas (Gorilla gorilla gorilla) and the Sumatran orangutans (Pongo abelii). In the absence of any data, other great apes simply have been assumed to have dimeric apoA-II while other primates and most other mammals have been shown to have monomeric apoA-II. Using mass spectrometry, we have measured the molecular masses of apoA-I and apoA-II associated with the HDL of these great apes. Each was observed to have dimeric apoA-II. Being phylogenetically related, one would anticipate these apolipoproteins having a high percentage of invariant sequences when compared with human apolipoproteins. However, the orangutan, which diverged from the human lineage between 16 and 21 million years ago, had an apoA-II with the lowest monomeric mass, 8031.3 Da and the highest apoA-I value, 28,311.7 Da, currently reported for various mammals. Interestingly, the gorilla that diverged from the lineage leading to the human–chimpanzee branch after the orangutan had almost identical mass values to those reported for human apoA-I and apoA-II. But chimpanzee and the bonobo that diverged more recently had identical apoA-II mass values that were slightly larger than reported for the human apolipoprotein. The chimpanzee A-I mass values were very close to those of humans; however, the bonobo had values intermediate to the molecular masses of orangutan and the other great apes. With the already existing genomic data for chimpanzee and the recent entries for the orangutan and gorilla, we were able to demonstrate a close agreement between our mass spectral data and the calculated molecular weights determined from the predicted primary sequences of the respective apolipoproteins. Post-translational modification of these apolipoproteins, involving truncation and oxidation of methionine, are also reported.     

Deconstructing reconstruction: the OH 62 humerofemoral index

The humerus and femur of the fossil hominid OH 62 are badly damaged and their lengths are not directly measurable (Johanson et al., 1987). Nevertheless, using relatively intact reference materials from another early hominid, AL 288-1, Johanson et al. (1987) reconstructed the bones to estimate the humerofemoral index, which falls well above the range for modern Homo, above the estimate for AL 288-1, and within the range for Pan paniscus. The reconstruction of missing bone by the method originally employed for OH 62 is broadly reproducible in a representative modern sample of Homo, making possible the estimation of an associated error term intrinsic to this method. Using the approximate variance of the ratio mean (Kish, 1965), shown here to be a good estimator of the sample variance of the humerofemoral index, the analysis of this modern sample extrapolated to other living hominoids gives quite acceptable results. Applied to OH 62, it suggests an error term associated with the estimated humerofemoral index so substantial that it is only possible to situate the index somewhere between the distributions for Homo and Gorilla, and quite possibly not above the index for AL 288-1. On the other hand, the predicted distribution for the humerofemoral index of AL 288-1 is more securely placed between the distributions for Homo and Pan paniscus.     

Electromyography of pronators and supinators in great apes.

We obtained electromyographic recordings from the supinator, biceps brachii, pronator quadratus, and pronator teres muscles of a chimpanzee and a gorilla and from the supinator, pronator quadratus, and biceps brachii muscles of an orangutan as they stood and walked quadrupedally on horizontal and inclined surfaces, engaged in suspensory behavior, reached overhead, and manipulated a variety of foods and artifacts. In Pan troglodytes and Pan gorilla, as in Homo sapiens, the supinator muscle is the prime supinator, with the biceps brachii muscle serving to augment speed or force of supination. Primary of the pronator quadratus muscle over the pronator teres muscle during pronation is less clear in the African apes than in humans. Possibly, pongid radial curvature or forelimb elongation or both factors are related to the somewhat different patterns of activity that we observed in the pronator muscles of Pan versus those reported for Homo sapiens. In Pongo pygmaeus, as in P. troglodytes and P. gorilla, the pronator quadratus muscle acts as a pronator and the supinator muscle acts to supinate the hand at the radioulnar joints. The biceps brachii muscle is active at low levels as the orangutan supinates its hand with the elbow flexed.     

Systematic affinities of the lyrebirds (Passeriformes: Menura), with a novel classification of the major groups of passerine birds

Phylogenetic relationships of the lyrebirds are investigated using DNA sequence data. The aligned data matrix consists of 4027 bp obtained from three nuclear genes (c-myc, RAG-1 and myoglobin intron II) and two mitochondrial genes (cytochrome b and ND2). Both maximum-likelihood and parsimony analyses show that the lyrebirds unambiguously belong to the oscine radiation, and that they are the sister taxon to all other oscines. The results do not support the suggestion based on DNA-DNA hybridization data (Sibley and Ahlquist, 1990) that the treecreepers and bowerbirds are part of the lyrebird clade. Nevertheless, treecreepers and bowerbirds are sister taxa to all other oscines (except the lyrebirds) and may constitute a monophyletic group, although bootstrap support values for this clade are low. A major disagreement between the present analysis and that based on DNA-DNA hybridization data is that the Corvida (sensu Sibley and Ahlquist, 1990) and Passerida are not reciprocally monophyletic, as we find the latter group be nested within the Corvida. Also, the superfamilies Meliphagoidea and Corvoidea sensu, are not recovered as monophyletic in the present study. Within the oscine radiation, all taxa belonging to the earliest splits are confined to the Australo-Papuan region. This suggests strongly that the origins and early radiation of the oscines occurred in the southern supercontinent Gondwana. A new classification of the major groups of passerines is presented following from the results presented in the present study, as well as those published recently on analyses of sequence data from the nuclear c-myc and RAG-1 genes (Ericson et al., 2002; Irestedt et al., 2001).     

Molecular evolution of IgG subclass among nonhuman primates: implication of differences in antigenic determinants among Apes

The cross-reactivity of five different rabbit polyclonal antibodies to human IgG and IgG subclass (IgG1, IgG2, IgG3, and IgG4) was determined by competitive ELISA with nine nonhuman primate species including five apes, three Old World monkeys, and one New World monkey. As similar to those previously reported, the reactivity of anti-human IgG antibody with plasma from different primate species was closely related with phylogenic distance from human. Every anti-human IgG subclass antibody showed low cross-reactivity with plasma from Old World and New World monkeys. The plasma from all apes except for gibbons (Hylobates spp.) showed 60 to 100% of cross-reactivity with anti-human IgG2 and IgG3 antibodies. On the other hand, chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes andPan paniscus) and orangutan (Pongo pygmaeus) plasma showed 100% cross-reactivity with anti-human IgG1 antibody, but gorilla (Gorilla gorilla) and gibbon plasma showed no cross-reactivity. The chimpanzee and gorilla plasma cross-reacted with anti-human IgG4 antibody at different reactivity, 100% in chimpanzee and 50% in gorilla, but no cross-reactivity was observed in orangutan and gibbon plasma. These results suggest the possibilities that the divergence of “human-type” IgG subclasses might occur at the time of divergence ofHomo sapience fromHylobatidae, and that the molecular evolution of IgG1 as well as IgG4 is different from that of IgG2 and IgG3 in great apes, this is probably caused by different in development of immune function in apes during the course of evolution.     

Fluorescent (F) bodies in the spermatozoa of man and the great apes

Mature spermatozoa of the chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes), the gorilla (Gorilla gorilla), and the orangutan (Pongo pygmaeus) were stained with quinacrine dihydrochloride. Fluorescent (F) bodies were visualized in the spermatozoa of the chimpanzee and gorilla but were absent in the orangutan, in which there is no brilliant fluorescence in any chromosome. The F bodies appeared to be randomly located in the sperm heads of these two species, as they usually are in human spermatozoa. However, the proportion of sperm showing one or more F bodies in the chimpanzee and gorilla was not comparable to what is usually found in man. The F bodies in the chimpanzee presumably represent brilliant regions in the autosomes, since the Y chromosome has no brilliant fluorescence in this species. This is contrary to man, in which the F body is an useful indicator of the Y chromosome. In the gorilla, the F bodies probably correspond to both the Y chromosome and to some brilliant regions in the autosomes.     

Growth changes in internal and craniofacial flexion measurements.

Growth changes in both internal and craniofacial flexion angles are presented for Pan troglodytes, Gorilla gorilla, and modern humans. The internal flexion angle (IFA) was measured from lateral radiographs, and the craniofacial flexion angle (CFA) was calculated from coordinate data. Stage of dental development is used as a baseline for examination of growth changes and nonparametric correlations between flexion angles and dental development stage are tested for significance. In Gorilla, the IFA increases during growth. The IFA is relatively stable in Pan and modern humans. Pan and Gorilla display an increase in the CFA. However, this angle decreases during growth in modern humans. Flexion angles were derived from coordinate data collected for several early hominid crania. Measurements for two robust australopithecine crania indicate strong internal flexion. It has been suggested that cerebellar expansion in this group may relate to derived features of the posterior cranial base. In general, australopithecine crania exhibit craniofacial flexion intermediate between great apes and modern humans. The "archaic" Homo sapiens specimen from Kabwe is most similar to modern humans.     

Characterization of the gorilla carboxyl ester lipase locus, and the appearance of the carboxyl ester lipase pseudogene during primate evolution.

In this study we report on the isolation and characterization of the gorilla carboxyl ester lipase gene, CEL, and the corresponding CEL pseudogene. We also report on the age of the CEL pseudogene.The gorilla CEL gene is 10.5kb long and comprises 11exons intervened by introns similar to the situation in man, mouse and rat. The encoded protein is 998amino acids long and includes a 23amino acid-long leader peptide. Comparison of the coding sequence, excluding exon 11, of CEL from gorilla and man reveals a 97% similarity. Exon 11, which encodes the characteristic proline rich repeats, contains 39 repeated units in gorilla compared to 16 in man. A truncated CEL pseudogene, with the same organization as that found in man, is also shown to be present in the gorilla genome. The gorilla CEL pseudogene is 4.9kb in length and consists of 5exons interrupted by introns. Southern analysis of the gorilla CEL locus shows that the locus is arranged in a similar way as in man with the functional CEL gene being the most 5' one.To bring further insight to the events involved in the rearrangement of the CEL locus, genomic Southern analyses were performed across several primates; Homo sapiens, Pan troglodytes, Gorilla gorilla, Pongo pygmaeus and Macaca arctoides. Results presented show that the CEL gene duplication occurred prior to the separation of Hominidae (man, chimpanzee, gorilla and orangutan) from Old World monkeys (macaque). The deletion of the original CEL gene giving rise to the truncated version of the CEL gene seems, however, to be restricted to man and the great apes only.     

Phylogeny, neoteny and growth of the cranial base in hominoids

This study tests the hypothesis that there is a general pattern in the growth of the cranial base of Homo sapiens that is 'essentially neotenous' [Gould, 1977]. Juvenile and adult crania of Homo sapiens, Gorilla gorilla, Pan troglodytes and Pongo pygmaeus were studied and the cross-sectional growth curves for 10 measurements made on the cranial base (as viewed in norma basilaris) were compared. The results of this study suggest that relatively simple modifications to the timing or pattern of growth are insufficient to explain the observed morphological differences between the cranial base of modern Homo sapiens and the great apes.     

DNA sequence polymorphism within hominoid species exceeds the number of phylogenetically informative characters for a HOX2 locus.

Within- and between-species variability was examined in a noncoding 238-bp segment of the HOX2 cluster. DNA of 4-26 individuals of four species (Pongo pygmaeus, Pan troglodytes, Gorilla gorilla, and Homo sapiens) was PCR amplified and electrophoresed in a denaturing gradient gel to screen for variability. Coupled amplification and sequencing was used to determine the complete sequence for each of the different alleles identified, one each in humans and orangutans, two in chimpanzees, and four in gorillas. Maximum-parsimony methods were used to construct a gene tree for these sequences. Alleles in all four species cluster into groups consisting of only one species (i.e., alleles within a species are monophyletic). The number of base-pair differences observed among alleles within P. troglodytes and within G. gorilla is larger than the number of base-pair substitutions that phylogenetically link Pan with Homo. Given these and other published data, it is premature to accept any particular phylogenetic tree that relates these three genera through two separate speciation events.     

Ectocranial suture closure in Pan troglodytes and Gorilla gorilla: pattern and phylogeny

The order in which ectocranial sutures undergo fusion displays species-specific variation among primates. However, the precise relationship between suture closure and phylogenetic affinities is poorly understood. In this study, we used Guttman Scaling to determine if the modal progression of suture closure differs among Homo sapiens, Pan troglodytes, and Gorilla gorilla. Because DNA sequence homologies strongly suggest that P. troglodytes and Homo sapiens share a more recent common ancestor than either does with G. gorilla, we hypothesized that this phylogenetic relationship would be reflected in the suture closure patterns of these three taxa. Results indicated that while all three species do share a similar lateral-anterior closure pattern, G. gorilla exhibits a unique vault pattern, which, unlike humans and P. troglodytes, follows a strong posterior-to-anterior gradient. P. troglodytes is therefore more like Homo sapiens in suture synostosis.     

Comparison of cranial ontogenetic trajectories among great apes and humans

Molecular data suggest that humans are more closely related to chimpanzees than either is to the gorillas, yet one finds the closest similarity in craniofacial morphology to be among the great apes to the exclusion of humans. To clarify how and when these differences arise in ontogeny, we studied ontogenetic trajectories for Homo sapiens, Pan paniscus, Pan troglodytes, Gorilla gorilla and Pongo pygmaeus. A total of 96 traditional three-dimensional landmarks and semilandmarks on the face and cranial base were collected on 268 adult and sub-adult crania for a geometric morphometric analysis. The ontogenetic trajectories are compared by various techniques, including a new method, relative warps in size-shape space. We find that adult Homo sapiens specimens are clearly separated from the great apes in shape space and size-shape space. Around birth, Homo sapiens infants are already markedly different from the great apes, which overlap at this age but diverge among themselves postnatally. The results suggest that the small genetic differences between Homo and Pan affect early human ontogeny to induce the distinct adult human craniofacial morphology. Pure heterochrony does not sufficiently explain the human craniofacial morphology nor the differences among the African apes.     

Genomic divergences between humans and other hominoids and the effective population size of the common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees

To study the genomic divergences among hominoids and to estimate the effective population size of the common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees, we selected 53 autosomal intergenic nonrepetitive DNA segments from the human genome and sequenced them in a human, a chimpanzee, a gorilla, and an orangutan. The average sequence divergence was only 1.24% +/- 0.07% for the human-chimpanzee pair, 1.62% +/- 0.08% for the human-gorilla pair, and 1.63% +/- 0.08% for the chimpanzee-gorilla pair. These estimates, which were confirmed by additional data from GenBank, are substantially lower than previous ones, which included repetitive sequences and might have been based on less-accurate sequence data. The average sequence divergences between orangutans and humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas were 3.08% +/- 0.11%, 3.12% +/- 0.11%, and 3.09% +/- 0.11%, respectively, which also are substantially lower than previous estimates. The sequence divergences in other regions between hominoids were estimated from extensive data in GenBank and the literature, and Alus showed the highest divergence, followed in order by Y-linked noncoding regions, pseudogenes, autosomal intergenic regions, X-linked noncoding regions, synonymous sites, introns, and nonsynonymous sites. The neighbor-joining tree derived from the concatenated sequence of the 53 segments--24,234 bp in length--supports the Homo-Pan clade with a 100% bootstrap value. However, when each segment is analyzed separately, 22 of the 53 segments (approximately 42%) give a tree that is incongruent with the species tree, suggesting a large effective population size (N(e)) of the common ancestor of Homo and Pan. Indeed, a parsimony analysis of the 53 segments and 37 protein-coding genes leads to an estimate of N(e) = 52,000 to 96,000. As this estimate is 5 to 9 times larger than the long-term effective population size of humans (approximately 10,000) estimated from various genetic polymorphism data, the human lineage apparently had experienced a large reduction in effective population size after its separation from the chimpanzee lineage. Our analysis assumes a molecular clock, which is in fact supported by the sequence data used. Taking the orangutan speciation date as 12 to 16 million years ago, we obtain an estimate of 4.6 to 6.2 million years for the Homo-Pan divergence and an estimate of 6.2 to 8.4 million years for the gorilla speciation date, suggesting that the gorilla lineage branched off 1.6 to 2.2 million years earlier than did the human-chimpanzee divergence.