Evaluating levels of PCR efficiency and genotyping error in DNA extracted from engorged and non‐engorged female Dermacentor variabilis ticks

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR)‐based methods are increasingly used to elucidate tick biology. However, DNA extracted from ticks may provide poor PCR templates as a result of PCR inhibition by mammalian blood or contamination by male DNA (in fertilized females). In this study, the effects of removing the bloodmeal and reproductive organs were evaluated through paired DNA extractions in engorged and non‐engorged Dermacentor variabilis (Say) (Acari: Ixodidae), prior to PCR amplification at 12 microsatellites. The first extraction utilized only mouthparts and legs (‘mouthpart’ samples) and the second utilized tick bodies (‘body’ samples). The results indicated that contamination by male DNA was an unlikely source of genotyping error in mouthpart and body samples. Engorged females showed higher levels of PCR inhibition in body vs. mouthpart samples, with a 29% decrease in amplification success rates per PCR and a 10‐fold increase in levels of missing genotypes in body samples. By contrast, non‐engorged females showed little difference in amplification success rates or numbers of missing genotypes in body vs. mouthpart samples. We discuss analytical concerns related to this systematic bias in PCR problems and recommend the removal of the bloodmeal and reproductive organs prior to DNA extraction, especially in engorged female ticks.     

DNA extraction from bronchial aspirates for molecular cytology: which method to take?

OBJECTIVE: To date, there are only few systematic reports on the quality of DNA extracted from routine diagnostic cytologic specimens. It was the aim of the present study to evaluate the ability of 50% ethanol/2% carbowax (Saccomanno fixative) to preserve bronchial secretions with high quality genomic DNA as well as to compare different DNA extraction methods. METHODS: DNA was extracted from 45 bronchial aspirates by four different extraction protocols. Beside DNA yield, DNA quality with regard to purity, integrity, and PCR success rate were investigated. RESULTS: No fragmentation of sample DNA due to the fixative was detected. It was preserved as high molecular weight DNA. DNA yield, purity, and integrity were dependent on the DNA extraction method to some extend. Irrespective of the DNA extraction method the PCR success rate for amplification of beta-globin gene fragments (268, 536, and 989 bp) was 100%. CONCLUSION: A fixative containing 50% ethanol/2% carbowax preserves high quality DNA which is well suited for PCR-based assays regardless of the extraction protocol used. The selection of the DNA extraction protocol has to be adjusted to the circumstances of application.     

A method for extraction and analysis of high quality genomic DNA from ixodid ticks

Currently, no published methods describe the extraction of high molecular weight genomic DNA from ixodid ticks (Acari: Ixodidae) and commonly used methods of extraction are not well adapted for use with members of this family. A method for extraction of minimally degraded genomic DNA from ixodid ticks that can be completed in one or two days is described. The method produces DNA which is of sufficient size (>24 kb) for use in Southern analysis and which is readily digestible by restriction endonucleases. Southern analysis using a cytochrome P450 gene probe, demonstrates the success of our method with genomic DNA extracted from two species of Ixodidae, the lone star tick, Amblyomma americanum (Linnaeus) and the cattle fever tick, Boophilus microplus (Canestrini).     

松墨天牛成虫标本保存及其DNA提取质量比较

【目的】探讨适合DNA提取的天牛成虫标本保存方法。【方法】采用SDS-蛋白酶K消化法对液氮中冷冻保存、无水乙醇-20℃冷冻保存、无水乙醇室温保存和干标本室温保存且保存时间在2年以上的松墨天牛Monochamus alternates Hope成虫标本基因组DNA进行提取,并对不同保存方式提取的DNA样本进行了质量比较和分析。【结果】在上述常见的松墨天牛成虫标本4种保存方式中,以液氮中冷冻保存效果最佳,其次为无水乙醇-20℃冷冻保存,插针干标本室温保藏效果最差。利用昆虫线粒体基因CO I和CO II的通用引物从上述DNA中均能够成功扩增出目的片段,测序结果证实扩增片段符合预期。【结论】液氮和无水乙醇-20℃冷冻保存适合松墨天牛成虫标本长期保存,且不影响后续的PCR扩增和测序。     

Validation and rapid extraction of nucleic acids from alcohol-preserved ticks

A method has been developed to extract DNA from alcohol-preserved ticks (Acari: Ixodidae and Argasidae). The method combines the lysing property of the chaotropic agent guanidinium thiocyanate (GuSCN) and the nucleic acid-binding property of diatomaceous earth (fossilized cell walls of unicellular algae). Debris from the tick is removed in several sequential washing steps. To monitor the efficiency of this method, a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was designed to amplify the 16S mt rRNA gene of five tick genera (Dermacentor Fabricius, Haemaphysalis Koch, Rhipicephalus Koch, Argas Latreille and Ixodes Latreille). Detection of amplification products from this PCR indicated that DNA had been successfully extracted and that Taq-polymerase inhibitors were absent. The extraction method, therefore, enables purification of DNA such that enzymatic analysis is possible.     

Factors affecting mitochondrial DNA quality from museum preserved Drosophila simulans

In this study we investigate how traditional killing methods and storage regimes affected mitochondrial DNA quality in Drosophila simulans. Here we define quality with three criteria: (1) size of extracted DNA, (2) extraction yield, and (3) ability to amplify from four target regions. Killing methods had a significant effect on extraction yield, but not on PCR success. Highest DNA yields were extracted from specimens exposed to cyanide, while the lowest were from specimens killed in 70% ethanol. Specimens stored for two years contained badly sheared DNA, which translated into a significant decrease in PCR success compared to freshly assayed specimens. The most dramatic decrease in PCR success occurred in the 1822 bp and 1332 bp amplicons, compared to the 959 bp and 291 bp fragments. Naphthalene did not affect any aspect of DNA quality; time of storage affected PCR success regardless of naphthalene environment. This study serves to further refine our understanding of DNA degradation.     

Lessons from genome skimming of arthropod‐preserving ethanol

Field‐collected specimens of invertebrates are regularly killed and preserved in ethanol, prior to DNA extraction from the specimens, while the ethanol fraction is usually discarded. However, DNA may be released from the specimens into the ethanol, which can potentially be exploited to study species diversity in the sample without the need for DNA extraction from tissue. We used shallow shotgun sequencing of the total DNA to characterize the preservative ethanol from two pools of insects (from a freshwater habitat and terrestrial habitat) to evaluate the efficiency of DNA transfer from the specimens to the ethanol. In parallel, the specimens themselves were subjected to bulk DNA extraction and shotgun sequencing, followed by assembly of mitochondrial genomes for 39 of 40 species in the two pools. Shotgun sequencing from the ethanol fraction and read‐matching to the mitogenomes detected ~40% of the arthropod species in the ethanol, confirming the transfer of DNA whose quantity was correlated to the biomass of specimens. The comparison of diversity profiles of microbiota in specimen and ethanol samples showed that ‘closed association’ (internal tissue) bacterial species tend to be more abundant in DNA extracted from the specimens, while ‘open association’ symbionts were enriched in the preservative fluid. The vomiting reflex of many insects also ensures that gut content is released into the ethanol, which provides easy access to DNA from prey items. Shotgun sequencing of DNA from preservative ethanol provides novel opportunities for characterizing the functional or ecological components of an ecosystem and their trophic interactions.     

Assessing DNA for fish identifications from reference collections: the good,bad and ugly shed light on formalin fixation and sequencing approaches

Natural history collections are repositories of biodiversity and are potentially used by molecular ecologists for comparative taxonomic, phylogenetic, biogeographic and forensic purposes. Specimens in fish collections are preserved using a combination of methods with many fixed in formalin and then preserved in ethanol for long-term storage. Formalin fixation damages DNA, thereby limiting genetic analyses. In this study, the authors compared the DNA barcoding and identification success for frozen and formalin-fixed tissues obtained from specimens in the CSIRO Australian National Fish Collection. They studied 230 samples from fishes (consisting of >160 fish species). An optimized formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded DNA extraction method resulted in usable DNA from degraded tissues. Four mini barcoding assays of the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) were characterized with Sanger and Illumina amplicon sequencing. In the good quality DNA (without exposure to formalin), up to 88% of the specimens were correctly matched at the species level using the cytochrome oxidase subunit 1 (COI) mini barcodes, whereas up to 58% of the specimens exposed to formalin for less than 8 weeks were correctly identified to species. In contrast, 16S primers provided higher amplification success with formalin-exposed tissues, although the COI gene was more successful for identification. Importantly, the authors found that DNA of a certain size and quality can be amplified and sequenced despite exposure to formalin, and Illumina sequencing provided them with greater power of resolution for taxa identification even when there was little DNA present. Overall, within parameter constraints, this study highlights the possibilities of recovering DNA barcodes for identification from formalin-fixed fish specimens, and the authors provide guidelines for when successful identification could be expected.     

Noncryogenic Preservation of Mammalian Tissues for DNA Extraction: An Assessment of Storage Methods

Reliable field methods for the storage of tissues to be used for DNA extraction and amplification are critical to many studies employing molecular techniques. Protection from DNA degradation was compared among three commonly used methods of noncryogenic storage of tissues over a time scale of 2 years. All three methods prevented DNA degradation during storage for at least 6 months. DMSO (dimethyl sulfoxide)-salt solution provided the best protection from DNA degradation of tissues stored for up to 2 years. High molecular weight DNA was recovered from lysis buffer in which tissue was stored for 2 years, however, moderate amounts of degraded DNA was also present. High molecular weight DNA was recovered from tissues stored in ethanol for 2 years, however, the yield was relatively small compared to the other two noncryogenic storage techniques. Much of the DNA degradation in ethanol preserved tissues appeared to occur during the extraction procedure and can be reduced by soaking the tissue in lysis buffer for a few hours prior to beginning the extraction. The yield of PCR products was greatest from DNA extracted from DMSO-salt solution preserved tissues, whereas DNA from tissues stored in either lysis buffer or ethanol produced lower yields.     

Effects of storage type and time on DNA amplification success in tropical ungulate faeces

The present study compares the effect of three storage media (silica, RNAlater®, ethanol) and time to extraction (1 week, 1 month and 3 months) on mitochondrial and nuclear marker amplification success in faecal DNA extracts from a sympatric community of small to medium‐sized Central African forest ungulates (genera Cephalophus, Tragelaphus, Hyemoschus). The effect of storage type and time on nuclear DNA concentrations, genotyping errors and percentage recovery of consensus genotypes was also examined. Regardless of storage method, mitochondrial and nuclear amplification success was high in DNA extracted within the first week after collection. Over longer storage periods, RNAlater yielded better amplification success rates in the mitochondrial assay. However, samples stored on silica showed (i) highest nuclear DNA concentrations, (ii) best microsatellite genotyping success, (iii) lowest genotyping errors, and (iv) greatest percentage recovery of the consensus genotype. The quantity of nuclear DNA was generally a good predictor of microsatellite performance with 83% amplification success or greater achieved with sample DNA concentrations of ≥ 50 pg/µL. If faecal DNA samples are to be used for nuclear microsatellite analyses, we recommend silica as the best storage method. However, for maximum mitochondrial amplification success, RNAlater appears to be the best storage medium. In contrast, ethanol appeared inferior to the other two methods examined here and should not be used to store tropical ungulate faeces. Regardless of storage method, samples should be extracted as soon as possible after collection to ensure optimal recovery of DNA.     

Museum fish specimens and molecular taxonomy: A comparative study on DNA extraction protocols and preservation techniques

Museum fish specimens are invaluable resources for genetic studies, but extraction of high quality DNA is often problematic. In this study, hairtail fishes of the genera Trichiurus and Lepturacanthus (family: Trichiuridae) representing a wide range of preservation histories and three different methods of preservation were analyzed for mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) extraction, amplification and sequencing of marker genes. A total of six protocols, including a commercially available kit, were compared in this study. Amplification of conserved genes such as16S rRNA and 12S rRNA were done using polymerase chain reaction with sequence analyses using automated capillary sequencing techniques. The results show that mtDNA extraction, amplification and sequencing of conserved genes could be obtained successfully from frozen (?20°C) preserved specimens (1–5 years) and also from ethanol (95%) fixed specimens (2–5 years) but not from any of the formalin (10%) fixed specimens (3–4 years). However, specimens that have been fixed for only 7 days in buffered formalin (10% formalin with phosphate buffer containing 173 mm salt) and ethanol (95%) could yield successful mtDNA extraction, amplification and sequence information of both 16S rRNA and 12S rRNA.     

Inhibition of DNA amplification in marine fish larvae preserved in formalin

Recent advances in molecular biology open the possibility touse formalin-preserved specimens stored in ichthyoplankton collectionsfor population genetics studies. Nine DNA extraction techniqueswere tested on Engraulis mordax larvae preserved in bufferedformalin. However, none of the DNA extracts resulted in thepositive amplification of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) (NADH1,16srRNA, 12srRNA and control region fractions). An experimentwith different length-time exposure to formalin done with Cynoscionparvipinnis larvae allowed us to confirm the difficulty of amplifyingmtDNA from larvae preserved in formalin for long time periodsand the possibility of DNA extraction and amplification fromshort-term (less than 48 h) formalin-fixed marine fish larvaepreserved in ethanol (70%). We discuss the possible influenceof physical–chemical complexes associated with the durationof preservation to inhibition of amplification reactions.     

Effects of post-ingestion and physical conditions on PCR amplification of host blood meal DNA in mosquitoes

The effects of post-ingestion and physical conditions under which killed mosquitoes are stored on the success of detecting blood meal DNA of Anopheles stephensi and Culex quinquefasiatus were investigated by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification at the human mitochondrial DNA cytochrome b (cytB) gene. Host DNA extracted from the blood meal up to 33 h post-ingestion in both species acts as an efficient template for PCR amplification. However, more DNA concentration is needed for meals digested for a longer time, and successful PCR amplification from meals digested for 36 h,dropped to a faint band. There were no differences between PCR success rate for samples stored at +4 or -20 degrees C, but less successful products were observed in samples kept at 4 degrees C for the periods longer than 30 h digestion. The results of this study are important for conducting malaria epidemiological studies that provide information about the degree of contact between human hosts and mosquito vectors, impact of vector controls such as bed nets and repellents, and the transmission dynamics of human malaria and other vector-borne diseases.     

Diagnostic DNA amplification from individual tick eggs,larvae and nymphs

The species of single tick eggs, larvae and nymphs was determined by PCR amplification and characterization of the hypervariable, second transcribed spacer (ITS2) of the multicopy ribosomal RNA gene (rDNA). Engorgement of larvae and nymphs did not preclude species identification. The method is generally applicable for ixodid and argasid ticks and can be used for epidemiological studies requiring the identification of individuals from pre-adult stages.     

A host species‐informative internal control for molecular assessment of African swine fever virus infection rates in the African sylvatic cycle Ornithodoros vector

African swine fever virus (ASFV) infection in adult Ornithodoros porcinus (Murry 1877, sensu Walton 1979 ) ticks collected from warthog burrows in southern and East Africa was assessed using a duplex genomic amplification approach that is informative with respect to the invertebrate host species and infecting sylvatic cycle virus. DNA extracted from individual ticks was used as template for the simultaneous amplification of a C‐terminal 478‐bp ASFV p72 gene region and a ～313‐bp fragment of the tick mitochondrial 16S rRNA gene, under optimized reaction conditions. Within‐warthog burrow infection rates ranged from 0% to 43% using this approach, and phylogenetic analysis of 16S gene sequences revealed the presence of three geographically discrete O. porcinus lineages, but no support for subspecies recognition. False negatives are precluded by the inclusion of host species‐informative primers that ensure the DNA integrity of cytoplasmically located genome extracts. In addition, infection rate estimates are further improved as false positives arising from carry‐over contamination when performing a two‐step nested polymerase chain reaction are negated by the one‐step approach. Phylogenetic comparison of full‐length virus gene sequences with the partial C‐terminal p72 gene target confirmed the epidemiological utility of the latter in a sylvatic setting. The method is therefore of particular value in studies assessing the prevalence and diversity of ASFV in relation to the African sylvatic tick vector and holds potential for investigating the role of alternative tick species in virus maintenance and transmission.     

DNA Extraction from Museum Specimens of Parasitic Hymenoptera

At the same time that molecular researchers are improving techniques to extract DNA from museum specimens, this increased demand for access to museum specimens has created tension between the need to preserve specimens for maintaining collections and morphological research and the desire to conduct molecular analyses. To address these concerns, we examined the suitability of non-invasive DNA extraction techniques on three species of parasitic Hymenoptera (Braconidae), and test the effects of body size (parasitoid species), age (time since collection), and DNA concentration from each extract on the probability of amplifying meaningful fragments of two commonly used genetic loci. We found that age was a significant factor for determining the probability of success for sequencing both 28S and COI fragments. While the size of the braconid parasitoids significantly affected the total amount of extracted DNA, neither size nor DNA concentration were significant factors for the amplification of either gene region. We also tested several primer combinations of various lengths, but were unable to amplify fragments longer than ∼150 base pairs. These short fragments of 28S and COI were however sufficient for species identification, and for the discovery of within species genetic variation.     

Identifying the last supper: utility of the DNA barcode library for bloodmeal identification in ticks

Ticks are among the most important vectors of disease in the Northern Hemisphere, and a better understanding of their feeding behaviour and life cycle is critical to the management and control of tick-borne zoonoses. DNA-based tools for the identification of residual bloodmeals in hematophagous arthropods have proven useful in the investigation of patterns of host use in nature. Using a blind test approach, we challenged the utility of the DNA barcode library for the identification of vertebrate bloodmeals in engorged, field-collected Ixodes scapularis. Universal vertebrate primers for the COI barcode region successfully amplified DNA from the host bloodmeal and only rarely amplified tick DNA. Of the 61 field-collected ticks, conclusive genus- and species-level identification was possible for 72% of the specimens. In all but two cases, barcode-based identification of the bloodmeal was consistent with the morphological identification of the vertebrate host the ticks were collected from. Possible explanations for mismatches or ambiguities are presented. This study validates the utility of the DNA barcode library as a valuable and reliable resource for the identification of unknown bloodmeals in arthropod vectors of disease. Future directions aimed at the refinement of these techniques to gain additional information and to improve the amplification success of digested vertebrate DNA in tick bloodmeals are discussed.     

How useful is DNA extracted from the legs of archived insects for microsatellite-based population genetic analyses?

DNA obtained from museum specimens provides a historical perspective on levels of genetic diversity. Archived samples are irreplaceable so it is desirable that only parts of the specimens are used, which constrains the amount of DNA obtained from small taxa. However, at present there are no quantitative data on yields of DNA from such samples. In this paper we determine the amount of DNA that may be extracted from the legs of museum-archived specimens of the damselfly Coenagrion mercuriale (Charpentier) and the suitability of this DNA for PCR-amplification of nuclear genetic loci (microsatellites). We find that (i) the yield of DNA correlates with the genotyping success rate and (ii) the amount of DNA obtained from the legs decreases with time since sample collection until 1954, before which no DNA could be detected (although DNA may be present in very low quantities). This cut-off point for successful DNA extraction corresponds with the date until reliable genotypes could be obtained by routine PCR. Thus, air-dried insect legs more than 50 years old appear to have limited usefulness for studies that seek to amplify many nuclear loci without the use of other techniques that may be used to increase the possible low-quantities of template DNA present.     

短尾猴陈旧粪便中DNA的提取

分子粪便学（Molecular scatology）是一门将传统粪便分析方法与分子生物学技术相结合,以动物粪便为实验材料进行多领域研究的学科（魏辅等,2001）。虽然该方法已在野生濒危动物保护遗传学和分子生态学研究中发挥了很大作用（Kohnand Wayne,1997）,但目前大多数分子粪便学研究中使用的材料是新鲜粪便,从保存时间很长的陈旧粪便中很难提取到高质量的DNA用于PCR扩增以及序列分析,严重制约了分子粪便学的广泛应用（Wasser et al．,1997;Constable et al．,2001;Murphy et al．．2002）。     

A quantitative evaluation of two methods for preserving hair samples

Hair samples are an increasingly important DNA source for wildlife studies, yet optimal storage methods and DNA degradation rates have not been rigorously evaluated. We tested amplification success rates over a one‐year storage period for DNA extracted from brown bear (Ursus arctos) hair samples preserved using silica desiccation and ?20 °C freezing. For three nuclear DNA microsatellites, success rates decreased significantly after a six‐month time point, regardless of storage method. For a 1000 bp mitochondrial fragment, a similar decrease occurred after a two‐week time point. Minimizing delays between collection and DNA extraction will maximize success rates for hair‐based noninvasive genetic sampling projects.