Reactivation and refolding of a partially folded creatine kinase modified by 5,5'-dithio-bis(2-nitrobenzoic acid).

Creatine kinase with its thiol groups modified by 5, 5'-dithio-bis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) has been shown to be partially folded in a monomeric state using fluorescence, circular dichroism, proteolysis, and size exclusion chromatography studies. In the presence of DTT, the partially folded modified creatine kinase can be reactivated and refolded following a biphasic course, suggesting the existence of a monomeric intermediate during the refolding of CK. The results provide evidence for our previously suggested model of the refolding pathway of urea-denatured creatine kinase.     

Effect of Zn2+ during reactivation and refolding of urea-denatured creatine kinase

The courses of refolding and reactivation of urea-denatured creatine kinase (CK) (ATP:creatine N-phosphotrans-ferase, EC 2.7.3.2) have been studied in the absence and presence of zinc ions. The presence of Zn²⁺ at low concentrations blocks the reactivation and refolding of urea-denatured CK and keeps it in a partially folded state. The partially folded state proved to be a monomeric state which resembles the molten globule state in the CK folding pathway. During refolding in the presence of Zn²⁺ , creatine kinase forms aggregates with the aggregation dependent on zinc concentration and temperature. In the presence of EDTA, the partially folded creatine kinase can be reactivated and refolded following a biphasic course, suggesting the existence of a monomeric intermediate during the refolding of CK. The results also suggest that low concentrations of zinc ions might be toxic to some proteins such as creatine kinase by disrupting their proper folding.     

Capture of monomeric refolding intermediate of human muscle creatine kinase

Human muscle creatine kinase (CK) is an enzyme that plays an important physiological role in the energy metabolism of humans. It also serves as a typical model for studying refolding of proteins. A study of the refolding and reactivation process of guanidine chloride-denatured human muscle CK is described in the present article. The results show that the refolding process can be divided into fast and slow folding phases and that an aggregation process competes with the proper refolding process at high enzyme concentration and high temperature. An intermediate in the early stage of refolding was captured by specific protein molecules: the molecular chaperonin GroEL and alpha(s)-casein. This intermediate was found to be a monomer, which resembles the "molten globule" state in the CK folding pathway. To our knowledge, this is the first monomeric intermediate captured during refolding of CK. We propose that aggregation is caused by interaction between such monomeric intermediates. Binding of GroEL with this intermediate prevents formation of aggregates by decreasing the concentration of free monomeric intermediates, whereas binding of alpha(s)-casein with this intermediate induces more aggregation.     

Monomeric creatine kinase aggregation and sodium dodecyl sulfate-cyclodextrin assisted refolding

The monomeric state of creatine kinase (CK) was stably captured at the equilibrium state by employing cysteine residue modifications in the presence of a denaturant, and at a partially folded state. The partially folded monomeric CK (PF-CK) was aggregated with kinetic order, which was mainly caused by the hydrophobic surface interactions between the CK subunits. The artificial chaperone, described as a SDS-cyclodextrin, was applied to prevent aggregation as well as to refold the PF-CK: SDS treatment onto the monomeric CK can significantly block aggregation and can be successfully refolded in the solutions containing cyclodextrins and DTT. Three types of cyclodextrins such as alpha-, beta-, and gamma-cyclodextrins were applied to strip SDS from the enzyme molecule, and each kinetic course was measured. The intrinsic fluorescence changes showed that reactivation occurred and this accompanied the conformational changes. The size exclusion chromatography detected the variously trapped monomeric CKs such as the thiol residue modified PF-CK, the SDS-binding PF-CK, the cyclodextrin treated PF-CK, and the DTT treated SDS-binding PF-CK. Our study demonstrated monomer CK aggregation for the first time; we also demonstrated the complex reassociation of CK during refolding with the aid of the SDS-cyclodextrin, and these pathways followed first-order kinetics.     

Monomeric Creatine Kinase Aggregation and Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate-cyclodextrin Assisted Refolding

Abstract

The monomelic state of creatine kinase (CK) was stably captured at the equilibrium state by employing cysteine residue modifications in the presence of a dénaturant, and at a partially folded state. The partially folded monomeric CK (PF-CK) was aggregated with kinetic order, which was mainly caused by the hydrophobic surface interactions between the CK subunits. The artificial chaperone, described as a SDS-cyclodextrin, was applied to prevent aggregation as well as to refold the PF-CK: SDS treatment onto the monomeric CK can significantly block aggregation and can be successfully refolded in the solutions containing cyclodextrins and DTT. Three types of cyclodextrins such as α-, β-, and γ-cyclodextrins were applied to strip SDS from the enzyme molecule, and each kinetic course was measured. The intrinsic fluorescence changes showed that reactivation occurred and this accompanied the conformational changes. The size exclusion chromatography detected the variously trapped monomeric CKs such as the thiol residue modified PF-CK, the SDS- binding PF-CK, the cyclodextrin treated PF-CK, and the DTT treated SDS-binding PF-CK. Our study demonstrated monomer CK aggregation for the first time; we also demonstrated the complex reassociation of CK during refolding with the aid of the SDS-cyclodextrin, and these pathways followed first-order kinetics.     

Conformational specificity of the chaperonin GroEL for the compact folding intermediates of alpha-lactalbumin.

The chaperonin GroEL binds unfolded polypeptides, preventing aggregation, and then mediates their folding in an ATP-dependent process. To understand the structural features in non-native polypeptides recognized by GroEL, we have used alpha-lactalbumin (alpha LA) as a model substrate. alpha LA (14.2 kDa) is stabilized by four disulfide bonds and a bound Ca2+ ion, offering the possibility of trapping partially folded disulfide intermediates between the native and the fully unfolded state. The conformers of alpha LA with high affinity for GroEL are compact, containing up to three disulfide bonds, and have significant secondary structure, but lack stable tertiary structure and expose hydrophobic surfaces. Complex formation requires almost the complete alpha LA sequence and is strongly dependent on salts that stabilize hydrophobic interactions. Unfolding of alpha LA to an extended state as well as the burial of hydrophobic surface upon formation of ordered tertiary structure prevent the binding to GroEL. Interestingly, GroEL interacts only with a specific subset of the many partially folded disulfide intermediates of alpha LA and thus may influence in vitro the kinetics of the folding pathways that lead to disulfide bonds with native combinations. We conclude that the chaperonin interacts with the hydrophobic surfaces exposed by proteins in a flexible compact intermediate or molten globule state.     

Mimicking the action of GroEL in molecular dynamics simulations: application to the refinement of protein structures

Bacterial chaperonin, GroEL, together with its co-chaperonin, GroES, facilitates the folding of a variety of polypeptides. Experiments suggest that GroEL stimulates protein folding by multiple cycles of binding and release. Misfolded proteins first bind to an exposed hydrophobic surface on GroEL. GroES then encapsulates the substrate and triggers its release into the central cavity of the GroEL/ES complex for folding. In this work, we investigate the possibility to facilitate protein folding in molecular dynamics simulations by mimicking the effects of GroEL/ES namely, repeated binding and release, together with spatial confinement. During the binding stage, the (metastable) partially folded proteins are allowed to attach spontaneously to a hydrophobic surface within the simulation box. This destabilizes the structures, which are then transferred into a spatially confined cavity for folding. The approach has been tested by attempting to refine protein structural models generated using the ROSETTA procedure for ab initio structure prediction. Dramatic improvements in regard to the deviation of protein models from the corresponding experimental structures were observed. The results suggest that the primary effects of the GroEL/ES system can be mimicked in a simple coarse-grained manner and be used to facilitate protein folding in molecular dynamics simulations. Furthermore, the results support the assumption that the spatial confinement in GroEL/ES assists the folding of encapsulated proteins.     

The Folding Free-Energy Surface of HIV-1 Protease: Insights into the Thermodynamic Basis for Resistance to Inhibitors

Spontaneous mutations at numerous sites distant from the active site of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease enable resistance to inhibitors while retaining enzymatic activity. As a benchmark for probing the effects of these mutations on the conformational adaptability of this dimeric β-barrel protein, the folding free-energy surface of a pseudo-wild-type variant, HIV-PR^?, was determined by a combination of equilibrium and kinetic experiments on the urea-induced unfolding/refolding reactions. The equilibrium unfolding reaction was well described by a two-state model involving only the native dimeric form and the unfolded monomer. The global analysis of the kinetic folding mechanism reveals the presence of a fully folded monomeric intermediate that associates to form the native dimeric structure. Independent analysis of a stable monomeric version of the protease demonstrated that a small-amplitude fluorescence phase in refolding and unfolding, not included in the global analysis of the dimeric protein, reflects the presence of a transient intermediate in the monomer folding reaction. The partially folded and fully folded monomers are only marginally stable with respect to the unfolded state, and the dimerization reaction provides a modest driving force at micromolar concentrations of protein. The thermodynamic properties of this system are such that mutations can readily shift the equilibrium from the dimeric native state towards weakly folded states that have a lower affinity for inhibitors but that could be induced to bind to their target proteolytic sites. Presumably, subsequent secondary mutations increase the stability of the native dimeric state in these variants and, thereby, optimize the catalytic properties of the resistant human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease.     

The group II chaperonin Mm-Cpn binds and refolds human γD crystallin

Chaperonins assist in the folding of nascent and misfolded proteins, though the mechanism of folding within the lumen of the chaperonin remains poorly understood. The archeal chaperonin from Methanococcus marapaludis, Mm-Cpn, shares the eightfold double barrel structure with other group II chaperonins, including the eukaryotic TRiC/CCT, required for actin and tubulin folding. However, Mm-Cpn is composed of a single species subunit, similar to group I chaperonin GroEL, rather than the eight subunit species needed for TRiC/CCT. Features of the β-sheet fold have been identified as sites of recognition by group II chaperonins. The crystallins, the major components of the vertebrate eye lens, are β-sheet proteins with two homologous Greek key domains. During refolding in vitro a partially folded intermediate is populated, and partitions between productive folding and off-pathway aggregation. We report here that in the presence of physiological concentrations of ATP, Mm-Cpn suppressed the aggregation of HγD-Crys by binding the partially folded intermediate. The complex was sufficiently stable to permit recovery by size exclusion chromatography. In the presence of ATP, Mm-Cpn promoted the refolding of the HγD-Crys intermediates to the native state. The ability of Mm-Cpn to bind and refold a human β-sheet protein suggests that Mm-Cpn may be useful as a simplified model for the substrate recognition mechanism of TRiC/CCT.     

Designing a High Throughput Refolding Array Using a Combination of the GroEL Chaperonin and Osmolytes

Although GroE chaperonins and osmolytes had been used separately as protein folding aids, combining these two methods provides a considerable advantage for folding proteins that cannot fold with either osmolytes or chaperonins alone. This technique rapidly identifies superior folding solution conditions for a broad array of proteins that are difficult or impossible to fold by other methods. While testing the broad applicability of this technique, we have discovered that osmolytes greatly simplify the chaperonin reaction by eliminating the requirement for the co-chaperonin GroES which is normally involved in encapsulating folding proteins within the GroEL–GroES cavity. Therefore, combinations of soluble or immobilized GroEL, osmolytes and ATP or even ADP are sufficient to refold the test proteins. The first step in the chaperonin/osmolyte process is to form a stable long-lived chaperonin–substrate protein complex in the absence of nucleotide. In the second step, different osmolyte solutions are added along with nucleotides, thus forming a ‘folding array’ to identify superior folding conditions. The stable chaperonin–substrate protein complex can be concentrated or immobilized prior to osmolyte addition. This procedure prevents-off pathway aggregation during folding/refolding reactions and more importantly allows one to refold proteins at concentrations (~mg/ml) that are substantially higher than the critical aggregation concentration for given protein. This technique can be used for successful refolding of proteins from purified inclusion bodies. Recently, other investigators have used our chaperonin/osmolyte method to demonstrate that a mutant protein that misfolds in human disease can be rescued by GroEL/osmolyte system. Soluble or immobilized GroEL can be easily removed from the released folded protein using simple separation techniques. The method allows for isolation of folded monomeric or oligomeric proteins in quantities sufficient for X-ray crystallography or NMR structural determinations.     

GroE facilitates refolding of citrate synthase by suppressing aggregation.

The molecular chaperone GroE facilitates correct protein folding in vivo and in vitro. The mode of action of GroE was investigated by using refolding of citrate synthase as a model system. In vitro denaturation of this dimeric protein is almost irreversible, since the refolding polypeptide chains aggregate rapidly, as shown directly by a strong, concentration-dependent increase in light scattering. The yields of reactivated citrate synthase were strongly increased upon addition of GroE and MgATP. GroE inhibits aggregation reactions that compete with correct protein folding, as indicated by specific suppression of light scattering. GroEL rapidly forms a complex with unfolded or partially folded citrate synthase molecules. In this complex the refolding protein is protected from aggregation. Addition of GroES and ATP hydrolysis is required to release the polypeptide chain bound to GroEL and to allow further folding to its final, active state.     

Significant hydrogen exchange protection in GroEL-bound DHFR is maintained during iterative rounds of substrate cycling.

An unresolved key issue in the mechanism of protein folding assisted by the molecular chaperone GroEL is the nature of the substrate protein bound to the chaperonin at different stages of its reaction cycle. Here we describe the conformational properties of human dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) bound to GroEL at different stages of its ATP-driven folding reaction, determined by hydrogen exchange labeling and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Considerable protection involving about 20 hydrogens is observed in DHFR bound to GroEL in the absence of ATP. Analysis of the line width of peaks in the mass spectra, together with fluorescence quenching and ANS binding studies, suggest that the bound DHFR is partially folded, but contains stable structure in a small region of the polypeptide chain. DHFR rebound to GroEL 3 min after initiating its folding by the addition of MgATP was also examined by hydrogen exchange, fluorescence quenching, and ANS binding. The results indicate that the extent of protection of the substrate protein rebound to GroEL is indistinguishable from that of the initial bound state. Despite this, small differences in the quenching coefficient and ANS binding properties are observed in the rebound state. On the basis of these results, we suggest that GroEL-assisted folding of DHFR occurs by minor structural adjustments to the partially folded substrate protein during iterative cycling, rather than by complete unfolding of this protein substrate on the chaperonin surface.     

Monomeric form of the molecular chaperone GroEL: structure, stability, and oligomerization]

The structure and stability in solution of the monomeric form of GroEL were studied by the methods of circular dichroism, binding of a hydrophobic probe, limited proteolysis, modification of thiol groups, sedimentation, and size-exclusion chromatography. The monomeric GroEL at 23 degrees C was shown to be a globular protein with a pronounced secondary and a rigid tertiary structure. It exhibited no marked tendency to oligomerization in the absence of adenine nucleotides. However, the free monomeric GroEL was substantially less stable to urea and heat than the corresponding subunit in the composition of native oligomeric particles. The monomeric form also bound the hydrophobic probe, 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid, by an order of magnitude better than the subunit in the oligomeric particles. The ATP-induced oligomerization process of both folded and unfolded GroEL monomers was studied. The oligomerization rate was found to be the same for both monomers, and, therefore, should be limited by the ATP-dependent "arrangement" of the sites in the folded monomers responsible for the oligomerization rather than by the spontaneous refolding of monomers.     

A stable cold folding intermediate of rabbit muscle D-glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase.

With decreasing temperature the reactivation yield of denatured D-glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) upon dilution increases but the reactivation rate decreases. Neither reactivation nor aggregation during refolding can be detected at 4 degrees C in 48 h, and at 3 degrees C even in 6 days. However, the reactivation takes place once the temperature is raised with little decrease of the yield after incubation for 6 days at 3 degrees C. A cold folding intermediate forms in a burst phase of refolding at 4 degrees C as shown by a fast change of the intrinsic fluorescence followed by further conformational adjustment to a stable state in about 1 h. The stable folding intermediate has been characterized to be a dimer of partially folded GAPDH subunit with secondary structure between that of the native and denatured enzymes, a hydrophobic cluster not found in either the native or the denatured state, and an active site similar to but different from that of the native state. Chaperonin 60 (GroEL) binds with all intermediates formed at 4 degrees C, but the intermediates formed at the early folding stage reactivate with higher yield than those formed after conformational adjustment when dissociated from GroEL in the presence of ATP and further folded and assembled into the native tetramer.     

High salt-induced conversion of Escherichia coli GroEL into a fully functional thermophilic chaperonin

The GroE chaperonin system can adapt to and function at various environmental folding conditions. To examine chaperonin-assisted protein folding at high salt concentrations, we characterized Escherichia coli GroE chaperonin activity in 1.2 m ammonium sulfate. Our data are consistent with GroEL undergoing a conformational change at this salt concentration, characterized by elevated ATPase activity and increased exposure of hydrophobic surface, as indicated by increased binding of the fluorophore bis-(5, 5')-8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonic acid to the chaperonin. The presence of the salt results in increased substrate stringency and dependence on the full GroE system for release and productive folding of substrate proteins. Surprisingly, GroEL is fully functional as a thermophilic chaperonin in high concentrations of ammonium sulfate and is stable at temperatures up to 75 degrees C. At these extreme conditions, GroEL can suppress aggregation and mediate refolding of non-native proteins.     

Chaperones GroEL/GroES Accelerate the Refolding of a Multidomain Protein through Modulating On-pathway Intermediates

Despite a vast amount information on the interplay of GroEL, GroES, and ATP in chaperone-assisted folding, the molecular details on the conformational dynamics of folding polypeptide during its GroEL/GroES-assisted folding cycle is quite limited. Practically no such studies have been reported to date on large proteins, which often have difficulty folding in vitro. The effect of the GroEL/GroES chaperonin system on the folding pathway of an 82-kDa slow folding protein, malate synthase G (MSG), was investigated. GroEL bound to the burst phase intermediate of MSG and accelerated the slowest kinetic phase associated with the formation of native topology in the spontaneous folding pathway. GroEL slowly induced conformational changes on the bound burst phase intermediate, which was then transformed into a more folding-compatible form. Subsequent addition of ATP or GroES/ATP to the GroEL-MSG complex led to the formation of the native state via a compact intermediate with the rate several times faster than that of spontaneous refolding. The presence of GroES doubled the ATP-dependent reactivation rate of bound MSG by preventing multiple cycles of its GroEL binding and release. Because GroES bound to the trans side of GroEL-MSG complex, it may be anticipated that confinement of the substrate underneath the co-chaperone is not required for accelerating the rate in the assisted folding pathway. The potential role of GroEL/GroES in assisted folding is most likely to modulate the conformation of MSG intermediates that can fold faster and thereby eliminate the possibility of partial aggregation caused by the slow folding intermediates during its spontaneous refolding pathway.     

Towards creatine kinase aggregation due to the cysteine modification at the flexible active site and refolding pathway

The dimeric native state of creatine kinase (CK) was aggregated at conspicuous levels during cysteine modification at the active site with using 5,5'-dithiobis-(2-nitrobenzoic acid) (DTNB) under a high enzyme concentration. Measuring the ANS-binding fluorescence revealed that the hydrophobic surface of CK was increased by cysteine modification due to the flexible active site, and this resulted in insoluble aggregation, probably via non-specific hydrophobic interactions. To determine whether the aggregates can be refolded, 3M guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) was used to dissolve the aggregates into the denatured form. Refolding of the solubilized enzyme sample was then conducted, accompanied by deprivation of DTNB from the CK in the presence of DTT. As a result, CK was reactivated by up to 40% with partial recovery of the tertiary (78%) and secondary structures (77%). To further elucidate its kinetic refolding pathway, both time interval measurements and a continuous substrate reaction were performed. The results showed that the refolding behavior was similar to the manner of normal CK folding with respect to the following two-phase kinetic courses. Additionally, the rate constants for the dimerization of the unfolded CK were dependent on the enzyme concentration and this was irrespective to the DTT concentrations, suggesting the rate-limiting steps of CK reassociation. The present study will expand our insight into the flexibility of the enzyme active site, which might act as a risk factor for inducing the unfavorable aggregation and partial refolding pathway of CK, as well as inducing an intermediate-like state recovery from aggregation.     

Folding mechanism of ketosteroid isomerase from Comamonas testosteroni

Ketosteroid isomerase (KSI) from Comamonas testosteroni is a homodimeric enzyme with 125 amino acids in each monomer catalyzing the allylic isomerization reaction at rates comparable to the diffusion limit. Kinetic analysis of KSI refolding has been carried out to understand its folding mechanism. The refolding process as monitored by fluorescence change revealed that the process consists of three steps with a unimolecular fast, a bimolecular intermediate, and most likely unimolecular slow phases. The fast refolding step might involve the formation of structured monomers with hydrophobic surfaces that seem to have a high binding capacity for the amphipathic dye 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonate. During the refolding process, KSI also generated a state that can bind equilenin, a reaction intermediate analogue, at a very early stage. These observations suggest that the KSI folding might be driven by the formation of the apolar active-site cavity while exposing hydrophobic surfaces. Since the monomeric folding intermediate may contain more than 83% of the native secondary structures as revealed previously, it is nativelike taking on most of the properties of the native protein. Urea-dependence analysis of refolding revealed the existence of folding intermediates for both the intermediate and slow steps. These steps were accelerated by cyclophilin A, a prolyl isomerase, suggesting the involvement of a cis-trans isomerization as a rate-limiting step. Taken together, we suggest that KSI folds into a monomeric intermediate, which has nativelike secondary structure, an apolar active site, and exposed hydrophobic surface, followed by dimerization and prolyl isomerizations to complete the folding.     

Unfolding and refolding of Escherichia coli chaperonin GroES is expressed by a three-state model.

The guanidine-hydrochloride (Gdn-HCl) induced unfolding and refolding characteristics of the co-chaperonin GroES from Escherichia coli, a homoheptamer of subunit molecular mass 10,000 Da, were studied by using intrinsic fluorescence, 1-anilino-8-naphthalene sulfonate (ANS) binding, and size-exclusion HPLC. When monitored by tyrosine fluorescence, the unfolding reaction of GroES consisted of a single transition, with a transition midpoint at around 1.0 M Gdn-HCl. Interestingly, however, ANS binding and size-exclusion HPLC experiments strongly suggested the existence of an intermediate state in the transition. In order to confirm the existence of an intermediate state between the native heptameric and unfolded monomeric states, a tryptophan residue was introduced into the interface of GroES subunits as a fluorescent probe. The unfolding reaction of GroES I48W as monitored by tryptophyl fluorescence showed a single transition curve with a transition midpoint at 0.5 M Gdn-HCl. This unfolding transition curve as well as the refolding kinetics were dependent on the concentration of GroES protein. CD spectrum and size-exclusion HPLC experiments demonstrated that the intermediates assumed a partially folded conformation at around 0.5 M Gdn-HCl. The refolding of GroES protein from 3 M Gdn-HCl was probed functionally by measuring the extent of inhibition of GroEL ATPase activity and the enhancement of lactate dehydrogenase refolding yields in the presence of GroEL and ADP. These results clearly demonstrated that the GroES heptamer first dissociated to monomers and then unfolded completely upon increasing the concentration of Gdn-HCl, and that both transitions were reversible. From the thermodynamic analysis of the dissociation reaction, it was found that the partially folded monomer was only marginally stable and that the stability of GroES protein is governed mostly by the association of the subunits.     

Structural plasticity and noncovalent substrate binding in the GroEL apical domain. A study using electrospay ionization mass spectrometry and fluorescence binding studies

Advances in understanding how GroEL binds to non-native proteins are reported. Conformational flexibility in the GroEL apical domain, which could account for the variety of substrates that GroEL binds, is illustrated by comparison of several independent crystallographic structures of apical domain constructs that show conformational plasticity in helices H and I. Additionally, ESI-MS indicates that apical domain constructs have co-populated conformations at neutral pH. To assess the ability of different apical domain conformers to bind co-chaperone and substrate, model peptides corresponding to the mobile loop of GroES and to helix D from rhodanese were studied. Analysis of apical domain-peptide complexes by ESI-MS indicates that only the folded or partially folded apical domain conformations form complexes that survive gas phase conditions. Fluorescence binding studies show that the apical domain can fully bind both peptides independently. No competition for binding was observed, suggesting the peptides have distinct apical domain-binding sites. Blocking the GroES-apical domain-binding site in GroEL rendered the chaperonin inactive in binding GroES and in assisting the folding of denatured rhodanese, but still capable of binding non-native proteins, supporting the conclusion that GroES and substrate proteins have, at least partially, distinct binding sites even in the intact GroEL tetradecamer.