Does EEG activity during painful stimulation mirror more closely the noxious stimulus intensity or the subjective pain sensation?

Abstract

Background: Many researchers have tried to investigate pain by studying brain responses. One method used to investigate pain-related brain responses is continuous electroencephalography (EEG). The objective of the current study is to add on to our understanding of EEG responses during pain, by differentiation between EEG patterns indicative of (i) the noxious stimulus intensity and (ii) the subjective pain sensation.

Methods: EEG was recorded during the administration of tonic experimental pain, consisting of six minutes of contact heat applied to the leg via a thermode. Two stimuli above pain threshold, one at pain threshold and two non-painful stimuli were administered. Thirty-six healthy participants provided a subjective pain rating during thermal stimulation. Relative EEG power was calculated for the frequency bands alpha1, alpha2, beta1, beta2, delta, and theta.

Results: Whereas EEG activity could not be predicted by stimulus intensity (except in one frequency band), subjective pain sensation could significantly predict differences in EEG activity in several frequency bands. An increase in the subjective pain sensation was associated with a decrease in alpha2, beta1, beta2 as well as in theta activity across the midline electrodes.

Conclusion: The subjective experience of pain seems to capture unique variance in EEG activity above and beyond what is captured by noxious stimulus intensity.     

Local Properties of Vigilance States: EMD Analysis of EEG Signals during Sleep-Waking States of Freely Moving Rats

Understanding the inherent dynamics of the EEG associated to sleep-waking can provide insights into its basic neural regulation. By characterizing the local properties of the EEG using power spectrum, empirical mode decomposition (EMD) and Hilbert-spectral analysis, we can examine the dynamics over a range of time-scales. We analyzed rat EEG during wake, NREMS and REMS using these methods. The average instantaneous phase, power spectral density (PSD) of intrinsic mode functions (IMFs) and the energy content in various frequency bands show characteristic changes in each of the vigilance states. The 2nd and 7th IMFs show changes in PSD for wake and REMS, suggesting that those modes may carry wake- and REMS-associated cognitive, conscious and behavior-specific information of an individual even though the EEG may appear similar. The energy content in θ₂ (6Hz-9Hz) band of the 1st IMF for REMS is larger than that of wake. The decrease in the phase function of IMFs from wake to REMS to NREMS indicates decrease of the mean frequency in these states, respectively. The rate of information processing in waking state is more in the time scale described by the first three IMFs than in REMS state. However, for IMF5-IMF7, the rate is more for REMS than that for wake. We obtained Hilbert-Huang spectral entropy, which is a suitable measure of information processing in each of these state-specific EEG. It is possible to evaluate the complex dynamics of the EEG in each of the vigilance states by applying measures based on EMD and Hilbert-transform. Our results suggest that the EMD based nonlinear measures of the EEG can provide useful estimates of the information possessed by various oscillations associated with the vigilance states. Further, the EMD-based spectral measures may have implications in understanding anatamo-physiological correlates of sleep-waking behavior and clinical diagnosis of sleep-pathology.     

The reflection of different aspects of brain activation in the electroencephalogram: Quantitative electroencephalography of the states of rest with the eyes open and closed

The rest states with the eyes open (RSEO) and closed (RSEC) were subjected to quantitative EEG study as states similar in the pattern of mental activity and subjective assessments but different in the EEG pattern. The mean values of the spectral power and EEG coherence function were compared in 74 subjects for the following bands: Δ, ?, α₁, α₂, β₁, β₂, and γ. Upon the transition from the RSEC to the RSEO, the EEG local power significantly decreased over the whole cortex for the α, ?, and β bands. A simultaneous decrease in the EEG power in all the bands (including β and γ) was most pronounced (as judged by relative changes and tests of significance of difference) in the parietooccipital derivations immediately related to the cortical zones where an increase in the neuronal activity upon opening the eyes is most probable. A significant increase in the EEG power was observed only for the γ band in frontal derivations F ₃ and F ₄. Significant differences in the mean EEG coherence in the RSEO-RSEC comparison were present in many derivation pairs, especially in the α₂, β₁, β₂, and γ bands. For each of these bands, the number of differences determined on the basis of Fisher test was more than 70% of the maximum possible number. In the overwhelming majority of cases, the coherence was lower in the RSEO; however, in the caudal cortical zones, a higher coherence in the α₁, ?, and Δ bands in the RSEO was rather typical. The results confirmed that the two states under study differ in a number of averaged EEG parameters with high statistical significance and may be used as reference states during performance of tasks with the eyes open and closed, respectively. The differences between the RSEC and the RSEO may be caused by the fact that the RSEC is a functional state oriented predominantly to the analysis of internal information (internally oriented), and the RSEO, predominantly to the analysis of information coming from the outside (externally oriented). The pattern of the observed EEG differences points to a combination of effects both localized in the visual zone and reflecting changes in the network cortical activity, i.e., simultaneous, although nonuniform, changes over all the main zones of the cortex. Comparison of the results with published estimations of differences in the local cerebral blood flow (ICBF) between the RSEO and the RSEC shows that increase in the ICBF may be associated with a local decrease in the EEG spectral power in any frequency band, including the high-frequency β and γ bands, or several frequency bands simultaneously.     

Electroencephalographic Correlates of Brain States during Verbal Learning: II. Characteristics of EEG Spatial Synchronization

Spatial EEG synchronization was studied using mean EEG coherences in 57 subjects in a resting state with the eyes open, during memorization of verbal bilingual semantic pairs (Latin and Russian), and during retrieval (monitoring) of the learned information. Statistical comparison of the EEG spectral power in the frequency bands θ, α ₁, α₂, β₁, β₂, and γ showed that induction of the states of memorization and retrieval of the verbal information resulted in multiple significant increases in the mean coherence (spatial synchronization) as compared to the state of rest. These increases were significantly higher in the state of retrieval than in the state of memorization. Such changes simultaneously occurred in different frequency bands and over the entire cortex. The highest relative augmentations of coherence with the highest significance estimates were observed in long-distance derivation pairs involving the temporal areas or combining the anterofrontal and frontal derivations with the parietal and occipital ones. The results are discussed in combination with data obtained in the same study for changes in EEG local synchronization and reported earlier. The intense rearrangements of the bioelectrical activity of the cortex may be determined both by the effect of cognitively specific mechanisms of encoding-decoding of information in the memory system and by a cognitively nonspecific modulating system of the brain.     

Comparison of the effects of the subjective complexity and verbal creativity on EEG spectral power parameters

The EEG recording was made when the subjects performed tasks that involved overcoming the stereotype (creative) and retrieving information from memory (noncreative) with the usual and complicated presentation of the initial material (incomplete proverbs and sayings without concluding words). The subjective complexity of the task performance under different conditions was assessed. The EEG power from 19 EEG derivations was compared in the β₂ and γ frequency bands. The creative task performance was associated with a marked increase in the EEG power; significantly more complicated noncreative tasks were not accompanied by marked changes in the EEG power in these bands.     

Antinociceptive activity of clonidine in the mouse, rat and dog

The antinociceptive activities of clonidine have been determined against several qualitatively different noxious stimuli in the mouse, rat and dog. In these tests clonidine given subcutaneously was 6 to 7 times more potent than morphine. Both clonidine and morphine were more potent against responses to heat induced nociceptive stimuli than against responses to heat induced nociception or that induced by electrical tail stimulation. However, unlike morphine the effects of clonidine in these latter tests were only seen at doses that also caused sedation and so these animals were less able to respond to the nociceptive stimuli. In contrast in pressure, chemical and tooth pulp stimulation tests clonidine produced increases in nociceptive thresholds at doses which caused no overt signs of behavioural depression. Comparisons of the relative potencies of clonidine and the less lipophilic analogue 4-hydroxyclonidine given subcutaneously and intracerebroventricularly indicate that clonidine induced antinociception is predominantly centrally mediated. However, a peripheral component may also be present in the inhibition of acetylcholine-induced abdominal constriction in the mouse.     

Electroencephalographic characteristics of cognitive-specific attention in verbal learning—II: General characteristics of EEG spatial synchronization

Electroencephalograms (EEGs) were recorded in 19 standard derivations in 88 subjects (students) in states of: rest with the eyes open; memorization (learning) of verbal bilingual semantic pairs (Latin and Russian); and recollection (control) of the memorized information. Estimates of EEG coherence in these states were compared using statistical methods for the frequency bands θ, α₁, α₂, β₁, β₂, and γ. The results of this comparison showed that transition from the state of rest to those of memorization and recollection was accompanied by numerous changes in coherence in all the frequency bands. These changes varied in intensity and embrace practically the entire convexital cerebral cortex. Decrease in EEG coherence was predominant during the transition to the memorization state in various frequency bands, whereas during the transition from the rest state to that of recollection, EEG coherence increased in most of the frequency bands except for the band α₂. The reproducibility of this pattern of changes in EEG coherence is confirmed by the results in the subgroups formed by randomly subdividing the subjects into two groups. We think that the observed intense rearrangement of the spatial synchronization of the cortex electrical activity reflects the reorganization of the functional systems of neuronal ensembles to provide efficient memorization and recollection, respectively.     

Electroencephalographic Correlates of Brain States during Verbal Learning: I. Characteristics of EEG Local Synchronization

Electroencephalograms (EEGs) were recorded by 19 standard derivations in 57 subjects in a resting state with the eyes opened, during memorization of verbal bilingual semantic pairs (Latin and Russian), and during retrieval (monitoring) of the learned information. Statistical comparison of the EEG spectral power in the frequency bands θ, α₁, α₂, β₁, β₂, and γ showed that induction of the states of memorization (encoding) and retrieval of the verbal information led to multiple significant changes in the EEG absolute power (local synchronization) as compared to the state of rest. Such changes took place simultaneously in different frequency bands over the entire cortex. The relative values and significance of changes in different cortical regions varied. The main features of the EEG power-difference patterns were an increase in the power of the γ band over the entire cortex, a bilateral increase in the power of the β₂ band in the temporal areas, and a decrease in the power of the α₂ and α₁ bands over a large part of the cortical surface. In the state of retrieval, synchronization in the γ- and β₂ bands and desynchronization in the α₂ band were significantly stronger than in the state of encoding. In the α₁ band, desynchronization was more pronounced in the state of encoding than in the state of retrieval. The results are discussed in combination with the available data of the EEG studies of different types of memory.     

Topography of alpha and theta oscillatory responses upon auditory and visual stimuli in humans

Brain resonance phenomena and induced rhythms in the brain recently gained importance in electroencephalographic, magnetoencephalographic and cellular studies (Ba\c sar and Bullock 1992). It was hypothesized that evoked potentials are superpositions of induced rhythms caused by resonance phenomena in neural populations (Ba\c sar et al. 1992). According to Ba\c sar (1972), such resonance phenomena are reflected in the main peaks of the amplitude frequency characteristics computed from EEG responses. The present study is based on a frequency domain approach for the evaluation of topography- and modality-dependent properties of oscillatory brain responses. EEG and evoked potentials were recorded from vertex, parietal and occipital scalp locations in 24 volunteers. Two combined methods were applied: (1) amplitude frequency characteristics were computed from the transient evoked responses, and (2) frequency components of the transient responses were obtained by adaptive digital filtering. Our main goal was to investigate theta (4--7 Hz) and alpha (8--15 Hz) response components. (1) Amplitude frequency characteristics. Auditory stimuli elicited theta-alpha compound responses in the 4--11 Hz frequency band (e.g. typical peaking frequency around 7 Hz for vertex recordings). Visual stimuli elicited alpha responses (e.g. typical peaking frequency for vertex recordings around 9--12 Hz). Frequency maxima for visual stimuli thus had main peaks at higher frequency values than frequency maxima for auditory stimuli. (2) Digital filtering confirmed these results: for vertex recordings, theta vs. alpha response amplitudes were 9 vs 6 for auditory stimuli and 5 vs 5 for visual stimuli, thus confirming a shift towards higher frequencies, i.e. a more prominent contribution of the alpha range, in the case of visual stimulation. We hypothesize that these properties might reflect site- and modality-specific features of stimulus encoding in the brain in which resonance properties of neuron populations are involved. Furthermore we emphasize the utility of the systems theory approach for a better understanding of brain function by means of EPs. Received: 25 February 1994 / Accepted in revised form: 5 August 1994     

Electroencephalographic characteristics of cognitive-specific alerting attention in verbal learning: III. Localized characteristics of EEG spatial synchronization

Electroencephalograms (EEGs) were recorded in 19 standard derivations in 88 healthy subjects (students) in the state of rest with eyes open and during memorization (learning) of verbal bilingual semantic pairs (the Latin and Russian languages) and retrieval of information from memory (control). The estimates of EEG coherence in these states were compared for the following frequency bands: θ (4–7 Hz), α₁ (7–10 Hz), α₂ (10–13 Hz), β₁ (13–18 Hz), β₂ (18–30 Hz), and γ (30–40 Hz). Compared to the state of rest, the decrease in coherence in the pairs of derivations from the frontal and central cortical areas in all EEG frequency bands was the most pronounced for memorization, and the increase in coherence in the interhemispheric derivation pairs of the parietal-occipital region in most of the frequency bands was the most pronounced for retrieval. In addition, in the pairs formed by derivations from the parietal-occipital region with derivations from the frontal and central regions, retrieval is also characterized by an increase in coherence in the β₂ and γ bands along with its decrease in the low-frequency ranges. The dynamics of EEG coherence, when comparing the states of memorization and retrieval, is more statistically significant in the interhemispheric and cross-hemispheric pairs of derivations than in the intrahemispheric pairs. The revealed topographic specificity of the dynamics of EEG coherence owing to the change of state is considered in terms of the notion on cognitive-specific forms of sustained goal-directed mental attention.     

The Narcotrend Index: classification algorithm, correlation with propofol effect-site concentrations, and comparison with spectral parameters.

A reliable assessment of the depth of hypnosis during sedation and general anaesthesia using the EEG is a subject of current interest. The Narcotrend Index implemented in the latest version 4.0 of the EEG monitor Narcotrend provides an automatic classification of the EEG on a scale ranging from 100 (awake) to 0 (very deep hypnosis, EEG suppression). The classification algorithms implemented in the EEG monitor Narcotrend are described. In a study the correlation of the propofol effect-site concentration with the Narcotrend Index and with the traditional spectral parameters total power, relative power in the standard frequency bands delta, theta, alpha, and beta, median frequency, 95% spectral edge frequency, burst-compensated spectral edge frequency, and spectral entropy was investigated. The Narcotrend Index had the highest average correlation with the propofol effect-site concentration and the smallest variability of the individual correlation values. Moreover, the Narcotrend Index was the only parameter which showed a monophasic trend over the whole investigated time period. The Narcotrend monitor can make a significant contribution to the improvement of the quality of anaesthesia by adjusting the dosage of hypnotics to individual patient needs.     

EEG characteristics determining the quality of subsequent recognition of visual images

Recognition of noisy pictures of Arabic numerals was accompanied by an increase in EEG coherence in the frontal cortical regions, especially in the left hemisphere, and between the frontal and occipital areas in both left and right hemispheres. Coherence values decreased in the temporo-centro-occipital areas of both hemispheres. A correlation was found between the coherence pattern in the prestimulus period and the quality of subsequent activity. Correct recognition was preceded by left-side asymmetry of the EEG coherence. Before erroneous recognition, EEG coherence levels were higher than before a correct response, and the increase in coherence was widely generalized over the cortex (especially in the Δ, ?, and α₁ frequency bands). The frequency of expression of an increased integral EEG coherence was higher before erroneous recognition than before a correct response. These changes in coherence were symmetrical.     

EEG beta and gamma powers when comparing certain psychophysiological states with normal and weakened electromyogram of facial muscles

With the advancement of contemporary techniques for studies of high-frequency electroencephalograms (EEGs), possible contamination of the EEG with the electromyogram (EMG) of pericranial muscles has raised more and more concern. The aim of the present study was to demonstrate if certain EEG correlates of mental activities can be revealed in a high-frequency scalp EEG in spite of EMG contamination. Nineteen healthy women who performed similar test tasks before and after cosmetic injections of Dysport in various facial regions for reduction of the activity of facial muscles took part in the study. Inductions of emotional states with different valences, memory storing, and extraction of verbal information were used in the test tasks. The default state of rest was examined as well. During performance of the tasks, parallel registrations of the EEG from the scalp surface (19 channels) and EMG from several facial muscles (6 channels) were carried out. Changes in the spectral power in β₂ and low γ frequency bands (18–40 Hz) in EEG- and EMG-derivations after Dysport injections were analyzed. Changes in the spectral power in the same bands in pairwise comparisons for the test tasks before and after Dysport injections were also analyzed separately. It was demonstrated that Dysport injections lead to reduction of the EMG power in areas of the injections and to reduction of EEG power in the frontal and temporal derivations. However, the EEG-correlates revealed when comparing different test tasks remained qualitatively invariable as for after and before Disport injections. These facts confirm that EMG makes a noticeable contribution to the electric activity registered from the scalp in the frequency ranges greater than 18 Hz. At the same time, one can see that at least in certain experimental situations the influence of EMG does not make impossible identification of EEG-correlates of mental activity with EEG registration from the head surface at least in the β₂ and low γ frequency bands (18–40 Hz).     

Decrease of theta response in euthymic bipolar patients during an oddball paradigm

Theta oscillations are related to cognitive functions and reflect functional integration of frontal and medial temporal structures into coherent neurocognitive networks. This study assessed event-related theta oscillations in medication-free, euthymic patients with bipolar disorder upon auditory oddball paradigm. Twenty-two DSM-IV euthymic bipolar I (n = 19) and II (n = 3) patients and twenty-two healthy subjects were included. Patients were euthymic for at least 6 months, and psychotropic-free for at least 2 weeks. EEG was recorded at 30 electrode sites. Auditory oddball paradigm and sensory stimuli were used. Event-related Oscillations were analyzed using adaptive filtering in two different theta frequency bands (4–6 Hz, 6–8 Hz). In healthy subjects, slow theta (4–6 Hz) responses were significantly higher than those of euthymic patients upon target, non-target and sensory stimuli (p < 0.05). Fast theta (6–8 Hz) responses of healthy subjects were significantly higher than those of euthymic patients upon target-only stimuli (p < 0.05). Reduced theta oscillations during auditory processing provide strong quantitative evidence of activation deficits in related networks in bipolar disorder. Fast theta responses are related to cognitive functions, whereas slow theta responses are related to sensory processes more than cognitive processes.     

Nociceptive Transmission to Rat Primary Somatosensory Cortex – Comparison of Sedative and Analgesic Effects

CO₂-laser C-fibre evoked cortical potentials (LCEPs) is a potentially useful animal model for studies of pain mechanisms. A potential confounding factor when assessing analgesic effects of systemically administered drugs using LCEP is sedation. This study aims to clarify: 1) the relation between level of anaesthesia and magnitude of LCEP, 2) the effects of a sedative and an analgesic on LCEP and dominant EEG frequency 3) the effects of a sedative and analgesic on LCEP when dominant EEG frequency is kept stable. LCEP and EEG were recorded in isoflurane/nitrous-oxide anaesthetized rats. Increasing isoflurane level gradually reduced LCEPs and lowered dominant EEG frequencies. Systemic midazolam (10 μmol/kg) profoundly reduced LCEP (19% of control) and lowered dominant EEG frequency. Similarly, morphine 1 and 3 mg/kg reduced LCEP (39%, 12% of control, respectively) and decreased EEG frequency. When keeping the dominant EEG frequency stable, midazolam caused no significant change of LCEP. Under these premises, morphine at 3 mg/kg, but not 1 mg/kg, caused a significant LCEP reduction (26% of control). In conclusion, the present data indicate that the sedative effects should be accounted for when assessing the analgesic effects of drug. Furthermore, it is suggested that LCEP, given that changes in EEG induced by sedation are compensated for, can provide information about the analgesic properties of systemically administrated drugs.     

Focus: Sex and Gender Health: Tobacco Smoking and the Resting Maternal Brain: A Preliminary Study of Frontal EEG

Tobacco smoking has been attributed to a wide range of detrimental health consequences for both women and their children. In addition to its known physical health effects, smoking may also impact maternal neural responses and subsequent caregiving behavior. To begin investigating this issue, we employed electroencephalography (EEG) to examine resting neural oscillations of tobacco-smoking mothers (n = 35) and non-smoking mothers (n = 35). We examined seven EEG frequency bands recorded from frontal electrode sites (delta, theta, alpha, alpha₁, alpha₂, beta, and gamma). While no between-group differences were present in high-frequency bands (alpha₂, beta, gamma), smokers showed greater spectral power in low-frequency bands (delta, theta, alpha, alpha₁) compared to non-smokers. This increased power in low-frequency bands of tobacco-smoking mothers is consistent with a less aroused state and may be one mechanism through which smoking might affect the maternal brain and caregiving behavior.     

Cortical Response Similarities Predict which Audiovisual Clips Individuals Viewed,but Are Unrelated to Clip Preference

Cortical responses to complex natural stimuli can be isolated by examining the relationship between neural measures obtained while multiple individuals view the same stimuli. These inter-subject correlation’s (ISC’s) emerge from similarities in individual’s cortical response to the shared audiovisual inputs, which may be related to their emergent cognitive and perceptual experience. Within the present study, our goal is to examine the utility of using ISC’s for predicting which audiovisual clips individuals viewed, and to examine the relationship between neural responses to natural stimuli and subjective reports. The ability to predict which clips individuals viewed depends on the relationship of the EEG response across subjects and the nature in which this information is aggregated. We conceived of three approaches for aggregating responses, i.e. three assignment algorithms, which we evaluated in Experiment 1A. The aggregate correlations algorithm generated the highest assignment accuracy (70.83% chance = 33.33%) and was selected as the assignment algorithm for the larger sample of individuals and clips within Experiment 1B. The overall assignment accuracy was 33.46% within Experiment 1B (chance = 06.25%), with accuracies ranging from 52.9% (Silver Linings Playbook) to 11.75% (Seinfeld) within individual clips. ISC’s were significantly greater than zero for 15 out of 16 clips, and fluctuations within the delta frequency band (i.e. 0-4 Hz) primarily contributed to response similarities across subjects. Interestingly, there was insufficient evidence to indicate that individuals with greater similarities in clip preference demonstrate greater similarities in cortical responses, suggesting a lack of association between ISC and clip preference. Overall these results demonstrate the utility of using ISC’s for prediction, and further characterize the relationship between ISC magnitudes and subjective reports.     

Differences in brain activity during olfactory testing of female body odors between young men with and without sexual experience

Olfactory testing was performed in two groups of young men aged 18–22 years with and without sexual experience. Multichannel EEG was recorded at rest and upon the presentation of 45 natural body odors of young women in different phases of the menstrual cycle. The odors were either intact or mixed with J’Adore L’Absolu perfume (Christian Dior) with or without a female pheromone. Changes in spectral power within narrow frequency ranges in response to olfactory stimulation were estimated by multivariate analysis of variance. It was found that background electrical activity of the brain in young men with regular sex life had lower spectral power in all frequency ranges. The EEG responses to the intact olfactory stimuli in all young men were associated with a decrease in spectral power in the majority of the frequency ranges and especially in the θ₂ and high- and low-frequency α rhythms. Presentation of female odors masked with a perfume resulted in bidirectional EEG responses; i.e., the spectral power in the θ₁ and β₁ ranges increased or decreased depending on the sexual experience of men and the menstrual cycle phase of a female donor as compared with an intact odor. The comparison of the EEG responses to intact or perfume-masked odors showed that individual odor remains dominant.     

Mating Signals Indicating Sexual Receptiveness Induce Unique Spatio-Temporal EEG Theta Patterns in an Anuran Species

Female mate choice is of importance for individual fitness as well as a determining factor in genetic diversity and speciation. Nevertheless relatively little is known about how females process information acquired from males during mate selection. In the Emei music frog, Babina daunchina, males normally call from hidden burrows and females in the reproductive stage prefer male calls produced from inside burrows compared with ones from outside burrows. The present study evaluated changes in electroencephalogram (EEG) power output in four frequency bands induced by male courtship vocalizations on both sides of the telencephalon and mesencephalon in females. The results show that (1) both the values of left hemispheric theta relative power and global lateralization in the theta band are modulated by the sexual attractiveness of the acoustic stimulus in the reproductive stage, suggesting the theta oscillation is closely correlated with processing information associated with mate choice; (2) mean relative power in the beta band is significantly greater in the mesencephalon than the left telencephalon, regardless of reproductive status or the biological significance of signals, indicating it is associated with processing acoustic features and (3) relative power in the delta and alpha bands are not affected by reproductive status or acoustic stimuli. The results imply that EEG power in the theta and beta bands reflect different information processing mechanisms related to vocal recognition and auditory perception in anurans.     

Electrographical correlates of adequate and erroneous responses caused by conditioned signals of different functional sign during instrumental conditioning in dogs

Power spectral (in the broad frequency band of 1-225 Hz) of short-term (less than 1 s) EEG reactions were studied in dogs in the course of instrumental food conditioning. These reactions appeared in different cortical areas in response to differentiating signals under conditions of both adequate and erroneous responses. The EEG power of such reactions was several times lower as compared to responses to positive signals, mainly, at the expense of the frequencies in the band of 90-225 Hz (the power of which was higher than that of the traditional band of 1-30 Hz and the gamma band of 30-80 Hz). The frequency composition of EEG reactions accompanying adequate responses was defined, mainly, by discrete subgroups of high-frequency components. During erroneous responses, the discrete structure of the corresponding EEG reactions was broken.