Factors Affecting Biological Control of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum by Fungal Antagonists

Studies were conducted to determine the effects of soil moisture (9, 16 or 24% w/w) and temperature (5, 15, 20 or 25°C) on the control of sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum by five fungal agents in sterile and natural field soil. All five biocontrol agents were effective in reducing the survival of sclerotia of S. sclerotiorum in sterile soil under dry (9% moisture) or wet (24% moisture) conditions at 20°C, but only Coniothyrium minitans was effective in natural soil. Coniothyrium minitans was the most effective in reducing sclerotial viability at the temperature range of 15–25°C. Trichoderma virens was effective against sclerotia of S. sclerotiorum to a lesser extent than C. minitans , and in non-autoclaved soil, it performed best at 25°C. Although Epicoccum purpurascens , Talaromyces flavus and Trichothecium roseum were effective against sclerotia of S. sclerotiorum in some instances, they were less effective than C. minitans and T. virens . Sclerotia of S. sclerotiorum conditioned for myceliogenic germination were more vulnerable to attack by the biocontrol agents than dormant sclerotia. The implications are discussed with respect to enhancement of biological control of crop diseases caused by S. sclerotiorum in different geographic regions.     

Production of macrosphelide A by the mycoparasite Coniothyrium minitans

Coniothyrium minitans, a mycoparasite of sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum and Sclerotium cepivorum, produced four closely related metabolites inhibitory to fungal growth. The major metabolite, identified as macrosphelide A, had IG(50) values (the concentration of metabolite to inhibit growth by 50%) of 46.6 and 2.9 microgram ml(-1) against S. sclerotiorum and S. cepivorum, respectively. This is the first report of both antifungal activity due to macrosphelide A as well as isolation of macrosphelide A from C. minitans.     

Contribution of aerial hyphae of Aspergillus oryzae to respiration in a model solid-state fermentation system

Oxygen transfer is for two reasons a major concern in scale-up and process control in industrial application of aerobic fungal solid-state fermentation (SSF): 1) heat production is proportional to oxygen uptake and it is well known that heat removal is one of the main problems in scaled-up fermenters, and 2) oxygen supply to the mycelium on the surface of or inside the substrate particles may be hampered by diffusion limitation. This article gives the first experimental evidence that aerial hyphae are important for fungal respiration in SSF. In cultures of A. oryzae on a wheat-flour model substrate, aerial hyphae contributed up to 75% of the oxygen uptake rate by the fungus. This is due to the fact that A. oryzae forms very abundant aerial mycelium and diffusion of oxygen in the gas-filled pores of the aerial hyphae layer is rapid. It means that diffusion limitation in the densely packed mycelium layer that is formed closer to the substrate surface and that has liquid-filled pores is much less important for A. oryzae than was previously reported for R. oligosporus and C. minitans. It also means that the overall oxygen uptake rate for A. oryzae is much higher than the oxygen uptake rate that can be predicted in the densely packed mycelium layer for R. oligosporus and C. minitans. This would imply that cooling problems become more pronounced. Therefore, it is very important to clarify the physiological role of aerial hyphae in SSF.     

Water potential affects Coniothyrium minitans growth, germination and parasitism of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum sclerotia

Water availability is an important environmental factor which has major effects on fungal activity. The effects of osmotic (KCl amended agar) and matric Polyethylene glycol ((PEG) 8000 amended agar) potentials over the range -0.1 to -5.0MPa on mycelial growth and conidial germination of eight isolates of the sclerotial parasite Coniothyrium minitans was assessed. The influence of soil water potential on the ability of three selected isolates (LU112, LU545, and T5R42i) to parasitise sclerotia of the plant pathogen Sclerotinia sclerotiorum was determined. For all eight C. minitans isolates, decreasing osmotic and matric potentials caused a reduction in mycelial growth and conidial germination. Isolates were more sensitive to decreasing matric potential than osmotic potential. Across the isolates, growth at an osmotic potential of -5.0MPa was 30-70% of the growth seen in the control, whereas less than 20% of the control growth was seen at the corresponding matric potential. Across all isolates no conidial germination was seen at matric potential of -5.0MPa. The C. minitans isolates varied in their sensitivity to decreasing water potentials. Mycelial growth and conidial germination of three isolates (LU112, Conio, and CH1) were more tolerant of low osmotic potential and matric potential with respect to mycelial growth. Isolates T5R42i and LU430 were least tolerant. In contrast, conidial germination of isolates Conio, LU545, and T5R42i were less sensitive to decreasing matric potential. Soil water potential was seen to affect infection and viability of sclerotia by the three C. minitans isolates. Isolate LU545 reduced sclerotial viability over a wider water potential range (-0.01 to -1.5MPa) compared with LU112 (-0.01 to -1.0MPa), with isolate T5R42i being intermediate. Indigenous soil fungi (Trichoderma spp. and Clonostachys rosea) were recovered from sclerotia but did not result in reduction in sclerotial viability. The relevance of these results in relation to biocontrol activity of C. minitans in soil is discussed.     

植病生防菌盾壳霉的研究进展

盾壳霉是世界性病原真菌核盘菌的主要拮抗真菌之一。许多研究表明盾壳霉具有控制温室和田间多种作物菌核病的潜力。目前欧洲一些国家已有盾壳霉商品制剂销售。为了加速盾壳霉产业化进程和更好地发挥其控制菌核病的作用 ,以及为了使人们对盾壳霉的研究不断深入 ,综述了盾壳霉生态学特性、遗传改良、对核盘菌的生防机制、在菌核病防治上的应用及基因工程研究等方面的研究进展。     

Effect of volume and concentration of conidial suspensions of Coniothyrium minitans on infection of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum sclerotia

White mould, caused by Sclerotinia sclerotiorum, is a serious disease affecting a wide range of agricultural and horticultural crops. Biological control is one option available to limit its damage. Field experiments to evaluate various concentrations and volumes of Coniothyrium minitans spore suspensions applied to S. sclerotiorum-infected bean crops were conducted in 1997 and 1998. Percentage sclerotia infected by C. minitans were scored. Three replicate experiments were performed in time in 1997 with 21 combinations of isolates, volumes and concentrations, including two controls. In 1998, 22 combinations of isolates, volumes and concentrations plus two controls were used, combined with the absence or presence of a maize buffer, with two replicates for each. Isolates as well as concentration and volume had no effect on infection by C. minitans, but there was a significant effect of total dose (volume×concentration) of inoculum applied over the full range from 100 L ha^-1 at 10⁴ conidia mL^-1 to 1000 L ha^-1 at 10⁷ conidia mL^-1. Percentage infected sclerotia increased linearly with log (dose) as well as from 1 to 4 weeks after application of C. minitans, and reached a level of about 100% at high doses under the humid conditions of 1998. Apothecia of S. sclerotiorum developing from sclerotia in collected soil samples from the 1997 experiment showed no significant effect of C. minitans inoculum dose, but there was a significant effect of the replicate experiments. The influence of weather conditions is highlighted, and the implications of the results for cost-effective biocontrol of S. sclerotiorum are discussed.     

Validation of a model for process development and scale-up of packed-bed solid-state bioreactors.

We have validated our previously described model for scale-up of packed-bed solid-state fermenters (Weber et al., 1999) with experiments in an adiabatic 15-dm(3) packed-bed reactor, using the fungi Coniothyrium minitans and Aspergillus oryzae. Effects of temperature on respiration, growth, and sporulation of the biocontrol fungus C. minitans on hemp impregnated with a liquid medium were determined in independent experiments, and the first two effects were translated into a kinetic model, which was incorporated in the material and energy balances of the packed-bed model. Predicted temperatures corresponded well with experimental results. As predicted, large amounts of water were lost due to evaporative cooling. With hemp as support no shrinkage was observed, and temperatures could be adequately controlled, both with C. minitans and A. oryzae. In experiments with grains, strong shrinkage of the grains was expected and observed. Nevertheless, cultivation of C. minitans on oats succeeded because this fungus did not form a tight hyphal network between the grains. However, cultivation of A. oryzae failed because shrinkage combined with the strong hyphal network formed by this fungus resulted in channeling, local overheating of the bed, and very inhomogeneous growth of the fungus. For cultivation of C. minitans on oats and for cultivation of A. oryzae on wheat and hemp, no kinetic models were available. Nevertheless, the enthalpy and water balances gave accurate temperature predictions when online measurements of oxygen consumption were used as input. The current model can be improved by incorporation of (1) gas-solids water and heat transfer kinetics to account for deviations from equilibrium observed with fast-growing fungi such as A. oryzae, and (2) the dynamic response of the fungus to changes in temperature, which were neglected in the isothermal kinetic experiments.     

植病生防菌盾壳霉的分子生物学研究进展

盾壳霉是一种重要的核盘菌寄生茵.近年来,该菌在分子水平的研究取得了一定的进展.本文概述了盾壳霉在产孢调控、与核盘菌互作、遗传转化以及动态检测和遗传多样性等方面的研究现状,并对研究中存在的问题进行了讨论.希望在此基础上能够促进该茵分子生物学研究的不断深入,更好地开发利用该菌的基因资源.     

Analysis of cDNA transcripts from Coniothyrium minitans reveals a diverse array of genes involved in key processes during sclerotial mycoparasitism

Coniothyrium minitans colonises and destroys the sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum in nature exhibiting ecologically obligate mycoparasitism as its spores remain dormant in soil and only grow actively in the presence of the sclerotia. Molecular mechanisms underlying sclerotial mycoparasitism are poorly defined. We identified 251 unisequences representing genes preferentially expressed by C. minitans during sclerotial mycoparasitism, substantially increasing the molecular knowledge of this commercially important biocontrol agent. Genes associated with signalling and cellular communication, degradation of host cell walls and energy reserves, nutrient utilisation, detoxification and stress response were identified suggesting that C. minitans employs a number of key processes during host colonisation. Several of these genes are novel to fungal-fungal interactions (e.g. PTH11-like GPCR and the ETP gene cluster). Secretin receptor-like GPCR and the TGF-beta signalling system have not yet been characterised in filamentous fungi. This study provides the basis for in-depth gene function analysis in sclerotial mycoparasitism.     

Some Nutritional Factors Affecting Production of Biomass and Antifungal Metabolites of Coniothyrium minitans

The ability of the mycoparasite Coniothyrium minitans to utilize a range of C and N sources and vitamins for growth, pycnidial formation and antifungal metabolite production was examined using a defined liquid medium. Coniothyrium minitans was able to use all the C sources tested, with the exception of D -xylose, and all the N sources tested, although growth was generally better on organic N sources rather than NO 3 -N. Increasing C:N ratios from 9:1-202:1 with N constant (2.0 g L -l L -alanine) resulted in steadily increasing yields, whereas increasing C:N ratios with C constant (40.0 g L -l D -glucose) gradually decreased yield. Addition of thiamine to the glucose-alanine basal medium resulted in the greatest increase in growth but biomass was still less than that achieved using an undefined molasses-yeast medium. Pycnidial production was generally low or failed to occur in the basal medium + C + N sources in the absence of vitamins, but addition of thiamine consistently led to abundant pycnidial formation. Molasses-yeast static culture provided greater biomass and conidial yields than molasses-yeast shaken culture. Incorporation of C. minitans culture medium into potato dextrose broth (10% v/v) resulted in consistent reduction in growth of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum irrespective of C, N or vitamin content of the basal medium or whether molasses-yeast medium was used. This is the first report of consistent production of antifungal metabolites by C. minitans .     

Effects on Diversity of Soil Fungal Community and Fate of an Artificially Applied Beauveria bassiana Strain Assessed Through 454 Pyrosequencing

The entomopathogenic fungus Beauveria bassiana is widely used as a biological control agent (BCA) for insect pest control, with fungal propagules being either incorporated into the potting media or soil or sprayed directly onto the foliage or soil. To gain a better understanding of entomopathogenic fungal ecology when applied as a BCA to the soil environment, a case study using tag-encoded 454 pyrosequencing of fungal ITS sequences was performed to assess the fate and potential effect of an artificially applied B. bassiana strain on the diversity of soil fungal communities in an agricultural field in India. Results show that the overall fungal diversity was not influenced by application of B. bassiana during the 7 weeks of investigation. Strain-specific microsatellite markers indicated both an establishment of the applied B. bassiana strain in the treated plot and its spread to the neighboring nontreated control plot. These results might be important for proper risk assessment of entomopathogenic fungi-based BCAs.     

Ecological fitness of the biocontrol agent Fusarium oxysporum Fo47 in soil and its impact on the soil microbial communities

Some nonpathogenic strains of Fusarium oxysporum can control Fusarium diseases responsible for severe damages in many crops. Success of biological control provided by protective strains requires their establishment in the soil. The strain Fo47 has proved its efficacy under experimental conditions, but its ecological fitness has not been carefully studied. In a series of microcosm studies, the ability of a benomyl-resistant mutant Fo47b10 to establish in two different soils was demonstrated. One year after its introduction at two concentrations in the disinfected soils, the biocontrol agent (BCA) established at similar high population densities, whereas in the nondisinfected soils it survived at lower densities, related to the initial concentrations at which it was introduced. The BCA behaved similarly in the two soils at temperatures ranging from 5 to 25 °C and soil water potentials between −0.01 and −1.5 MPa. In addition, terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis of 16S and 18S rRNA showed that the structures of the bacterial and fungal communities evolved with time but were not significantly affected by the introduction of the BCA. Overall, the results showed that Fo47 is potentially a good BCA, able to establish in different soil environments without perturbing the investigated microbial structures.     

Pre-germinated conidia of Coniothyrium minitans enhances the foliar biological control of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum

The relatively slow germination rate of Coniothyrium minitans limits its control efficiency against Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Pre-germinated conidia of C. minitans enhanced its efficiency significantly: in foliar experiments with oilseed rape, hyphal extension of S. sclerotiorum was inhibited by 68%, while formation of sclerotia was completely inhibited when pre-germinated conidia were applied.     

A fungal cell wall integrity-associated MAP kinase cascade in Coniothyrium minitans is required for conidiation and mycoparasitism

Coniothyrium minitans is an important biocontrol agent against Sclerotinia diseases. Previously, a conidiation-deficient mutant ZS-1T1000 was screened out from a T-DNA insertional library of C. minitans. CmBCK1, encoding MAP kinase kinase kinase and homologous to BCK1 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, was disrupted by T-DNA insertion in this mutant. Targeted disruption of CmBCK1 led to the mutants undergoing autolysis and displaying hypersensitivity to the cell wall-degrading enzymes. The △CmBCK1 mutants lost the ability to produce pycnidia and conidia compared to the wild-type strain ZS-1. △CmBCK1 mutants could grow on the surface of sclerotia of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum but not form conidia, which resulted in much lower ability to reduce the viability of sclerotia of S. sclerotiorum. Furthermore, CmSlt2, a homolog of Slt2 encoding cell wall integrity-related MAP kinase and up-regulated by BCK1 in S. cerevisiae, was identified and targeted disrupted. The △CmSlt2 mutants had a similar phenotype to the △CmBCK1 mutants. The △CmSlt2 mutants also had autolytic aerial hyphae, hypersensitivity to cell wall-degrading enzymes, lack of conidiation and reduction of sclerotial mycoparasitism. Taken together, our results suggest that CmBCK1 and CmSlt2 are involved in conidiation and the hyperparasitic activities of C. minitans.     

Growth and sporulation stoichiometry and kinetics of Coniothyrium minitans on agar media

Coniothyrium minitans was cultivated on agar media with different concentrations of starch, urea, and trace elements. By means of elemental balances, the stoichiometry of growth and sporulation was established. C. minitans produced byproducts on all media, especially in the medium with high urea concentrations, where 30% of the starch was converted into byproducts. Simple empirical models were used to describe the kinetics of growth, sporulation, CO(2) production, and substrate consumption on all media. Total biomass and mycelium could be described reasonably well with the logistic law. Starch, urea, and oxygen consumption and CO(2) production could be described as a function of total biomass by the linear-growth model of Pirt. There were almost no differences between media for the estimates of yield coefficients and maintenance coefficients. Only at high urea concentrations were maintenance coefficients much higher. Similar to substrate consumption and CO(2) production, the kinetics of sporulation could be described as a function of mycelium production with the linear-growth model. It is shown that sporulation of C. minitans is growth-associated. Based on kinetics, the process costs for producing spores are roughly calculated. In addition, it is shown that fermentor costs represent the majority of production costs.     

Model-based bioreactor selection for large-scale solid-state cultivation of Coniothyrium minitans spores on oats

Non-mixed and mixed SSF reactors were evaluated for their applicability in large-scale spore production of the biocontrol fungus Coniothyrium minitans. The major problem to overcome in large-scale SSF is heat accumulation. Testing various cooling strategies in large-scale bioreactors would be very expensive and time consuming, therefore lab experiments in combination with mathematical simulations were used instead. The metabolic heat production rate, estimated from the oxygen consumption rate of C. minitans on oats in Erlenmeyer flasks, was about 500 Watt per m(3) bed. Conductive cooling in packed-bed reactors was insufficient to cool large reactor volumes (radius > 0.2 m). The poor thermal conductivity of the bed (lambda(b) = 0.1 W m(-2) K(-1)) resulted in steep radial temperature profiles. Adequate temperature control could be achieved with forced aeration, but concomitant water losses lead to significant shrinkage of the oats (30%) and critically low water activities, even though the bed was assumed to be aerated with water saturated air. Mixed systems, however, allowed heat removal without the need of evaporative cooling. Simulations showed that large volumes could be cooled via the wall at low mixing intensities and small temperature driving forces. Experimental studies showed no detrimental effect of mixing on spore production by C. minitans. The spore production yield in a continuously mixed scraped-drum reactor (0.2 rpm) was 5 x 10(12) spores per kg dry oats after 450 hours. Based on the scale-up potential of the mixed system and the absence of detrimental mixing effects it is believed that a mixed bioreactor is superior to a non-mixed system for large-scale production of C. minitans spores.     

A generic theoretical model for biological control of foliar plant diseases

We have developed a generic modelling framework to understand the dynamics of foliar pathogen and biocontrol agent (BCA) populations in order to predict the likelihood of successful biocontrol in relation to the mechanisms involved. The model considers biocontrol systems for foliar pathogens only and, although it is most applicable to fungal BCA systems, does not address a specific biocontrol system. Four biocontrol mechanisms (competition, antibiosis, mycoparasitism and induced resistance) were included within the model rubric. Because of the wide range of mechanisms involved we use Trichoderma/Botrytis as an exemplar system. Qualitative analysis of the model showed that the rates of a BCA colonising diseased and/or healthy plant tissues and the time that the BCA remains active are two of the more important factors in determining the final outcome of a biocontrol system. Further evaluation of the model indicated that the dynamic path to the steady-state population levels also depends critically on other parameters such as the host-pathogen infection rate. In principle, the model can be extended to include other potential mechanisms, including spatio-temporal heterogeneity, fungicide effects, non-fungal BCA and strategies for BCA application, although with a cost in model tractability and ease of interpretation.     

Biological control of Botrytis gray mould and Sclerotinia drop in lettuce

Research was carried out to evaluate the effectiveness of the biological control of two most important fungal diseases of lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.): 1) Botrytis Gray Mould caused by Botrytis cinerea Pers. ex Fr.; 2) Sclerotinia Drop caused by two pathogenic fungi, Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (Lib.) De Bary and/or Sclerotinia minorJagger. Biological control in lettuce was carried out: 1) using Coniothyrium minitans Campbell, an antagonist fungus that attacks and destroys sclerotia within the soil; 2) identifying lettuce genotypes showing less susceptibility or tolerance. The object of this research was to find control strategies to reduce chemical treatments. The use of resistant varieties is one of the most economical ways to control vegeTable diseases. The lettuce genotypes showing in preliminary trials the best behaviour to the sclerotial diseases were compared in a randomized complete block experiment design and replicated four times. Observations were carried out from February up to April registering the number of diseased plants and yield. The pathogens were isolated on PDA medium and identified. The isolates grown onto PDA plates, after incubation for 6 weeks, allowed obtaining sclerotia that were the target of C. minitans in biological control trials. In laboratory, in controlled conditions, 27 small plots (30 cm in diameter each) with disinfected soil were performed. In 18 plots 9 sclerotia were inoculated (per plot, three of each fungus) and in 9 plots of them a suspension of the antagonist fungus was added. Subsequently, three lettuce varieties were transplanted. For each variety were compared: 1) untreated plots; 2) treated plots with sclerotia only; 3) treated plots with sclerotia and C. minitans suspension. The number of diseased plants was recorded. According to symptom evaluation scale, ranged from 0 (no disease) up to 10 (100% necrotic leaves or dead plants) the plants were grouped into infection classes, calculating the McKinney index. In greenhouse trials, "LM 1307" genotype showed less significant susceptibility to Botrytis Gray Mould (0-2% of affected plants), while "Ninja" and "Charmy" showed 4-11% and 16-26% of diseased plants, respectively. The yields were 69.7, 62.7, 55.3 t/Ha, respectively. In laboratory tests, the McKinney index gave the following results: no disease in all untreated plants; 38.3, 54.2 and 89.2% in "LM 1307", "Ninja" and "Charmy" treated with sclerotia only, respectively; 2.5, 7.5 and 20.8% in "LM 1307", "Ninja" and "Charmy" treated with sclerotia and C. minitans, respectively. In conclusion, the less susceptibility of the genotypes to sclerotial diseases and the use of hyperparasites of sclerotia of phytopathogenic fungi exhibited best results.     

Fabrication of single carbonic anhydrase nanogel against denaturation and aggregation at high temperature

A two-step procedure to encapsulate a single bovine carbonic anhydrase (BCA) molecule into a spherical nanogel was proposed. BCA was reacted first with N-acryloxysuccinimide to introduce surface vinyl groups, followed by in-situ aqueous polymerization. Characterization of the nanogel by dynamic light scattering, transmission electron microscopy, and atomic force microscopy confirmed that each nanogel contained a single BCA molecule. The encapsulated BCA maintained 70% of the activity of its free counterpart, but exhibited an increase in the molten temperature from 64 to 81 degrees C demonstrated by differential scanning calorimetry and an extension of the half-life from less than 3 to over 90 min at 75 degrees C. Circular dichroism spectroscopy indicated that the encapsulation and the multi-point covalent linkage between BCA and the polymer shell strengthened the secondary structure and thus inhibited the aggregation at high temperature. The uniform BCA nanogel with enhanced structural stability against denaturation and aggregation expands the applications of BCA catalysis, particularly those carried out at high temperatures.