Relation of structural features to pyrrolic metabolites in livers of rats given pyrrolizidine alkaloids and derivatives

Levels of pyrrolic metabolites have been measured in the livers of rats given some pyrrolizidine alkaloids and semisynthetic derivatives. Structural and chemical features favouring the formation of such metabolites have been defined. The most important of these were: steric hindrance or chemical properties giving resistance to ester hydrolysis; lipophilic character, allowing access to hepatic microsomal enzymes; a conformation favoring microsomal oxidation of the pyrroline ring in preference to N-oxidation. In addition, the presence of ester groups gave the resulting pyrroles high chemical reactivity, leading to tissue binding.Amounts of pyrroles bound to liver were very low when animals were given either highly water soluble pyrrolizidine derivatives, including non-esterified bases or more-lipophilic esters if these were easily hydrolysed. Compounds prone to hydrolysis gave increased pyrrole levels in rats pretreated to deplete their esterase activity. Whereas heliotridine-based alkaloids usually give more pyrrole than similar retronecine esters, heliotridine ditiglate gave less pyrrole than retronecine ditiglate because the former was more open to hydrolytic attack.Among the carboxylic diesters, the cyclic retronecine diesters, in which the pyrrolizidine nucleus is more exposed to oxidative metabolism, gave the highest pyrrole levels in rats.Liver pyrrole measurements are useful for studying relationships between molecular structure, metabolism and toxicity of pyrrolizidine derivatives. They can be used for screening alkaloids for potential toxicity and for assessing dose levels suitable for toxicity tests when limited material is available.     

Hepato- and pneumotoxicity of pyrrolizidine alkaloids and derivatives in relation to molecular structure.

62 pyrrolizidine alkaloids and derivatives have been screened for acute and chronic hepato- and pneumotoxicity by the single dose method previously described. This procedure is satisfactory for the compounds of medium to high hepatotoxicity but failed to detect toxicity in certain other compounds of known, low hepatotoxicity. New findings significant in relation to hepatotoxicity are as follows: (i) On a molar basis, diesters of heliotridine and retronecine are about 4 times as toxic as the respective mono-esters and heliotridine esters are 2-4 times as toxic as retronecine esters. (ii) Crotanecine esters are less toxic than retronecine esters, and the 6,9-diester madurensine, 2-4 times less toxic than the 7,9-diester anacrotine (the difference being ascribed to there being only one reactive alkylating centre in the toxic metabolite from madurensine). (iii) Hepatotoxicity was confirmed for 7-angelylheliotridine but not observed for 9-angelyheliotridine and 7- and 9-angelylretronecine. (iv) Other significant compounds failing to induce hepatotoxicity were 9-pivalyl- and 7,9-dipivalyheliotridine, the alpha- and beta-epoxides of monocrotaline, 7-angelyl-1-methylenepyrrolizidine and the methiodides of monocrotaline and senecionine. The following compounds are readily converted by rat liver microsomes in vitro into dehydroheliotridine (or dehydroretronecine): 7- and 9-angelyheliotridine, 7- and 9-angelylretronecine, 7,9-dipivalylheliotridine and otosenine. 7,9-Divalerylheliotridine, the alpha- and beta-epoxides of monocrotaline, and retusamine yield pyrrolic metabolites more slowly. The preparation and characterisation of several alkaloid derivatives are described. Chronic lung lesions were produced by most compounds which gave chronic liver lesions, although a higher dose was required in some instances. This requirement may sometimes mean that chronic lung lesions cannot be induced because of the intervention of acute or peracute deaths. Apart from this factor, structure activity requirements for pneumotoxicity are the same as for hepatotoxicity, consistent with their being both caused by the same toxic metabolites.     

The toxic effects in rats of some synthanecine carbamate and phosphate esters analogous to hepatotoxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids

Five synthetic compounds analogous to pyrrolizidine alkaloids have been tested for toxicity in rats. These were the bis-N-ethylcarbamate esters of synthanecines A, B, C and D (Compounds I–IV) and the bis-diethylphosphate ester (V) of synthanecine A. The amino alcohol moiety in each of these had a single 5-membered heterocyclic ring in place of the pyrrolizidine amino alcohol (necine) moiety of natural pyrrolizidine alkaloids.The toxicity of these compounds differed considerably. The synthanecine A carbamate (I) was the most toxic, male and female rats being similarly susceptible. Like many hepatotoxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids, a single dose of compound I caused acute centrilobular necrosis of the liver, chronic hepatotoxicity involving the development of persistent giant hepatocytes, and chronic lung injury. Compound III had similar actions but was less toxic. The synthanecine D carbamate (IV) caused acute liver necrosis but no chronic hepatotoxicity, whereas the synthanecine A phosphate (V) had the opposite effect, with only chronic hepatotoxicity.The different toxic effects were related to the structure and metabolism of the compounds. Doses of compounds I, III and IV associated with a similar degree of acute hepatotoxicity led to similar levels of pyrrolic metabolites in the liver. Compound II, which was not hepatotoxic, gave very little liver pyrrole. The liver level of pyrrolic metabolite from the phosphate ester (V) decreased more rapidly than that from (I), and was not associated with acute toxicity.Antimitotic activity, indicated by the appearance of bizarre giant cells, was shown by compounds capable of forming pyrrolic metabolites which were bifunctional alkylating agents, but not by compound IV, which could only form a monofunctional alkylating agent. Pretreatment with phenobarbitone lowered the susceptibility of rats to compound I and greatly increased the liver level of pyrrolic metabolites associated with acute hepatotoxicity. Some rats given compounds I and III had kidney lesions primarily involving the glomerulus. The results confirm that toxic effects characteristic of many natural pyrrolizidine alkaloids can be reproduced using simplified synthetic analogues, and that such toxicity is associated with pyrrolic metabolites.     

13C NMR spectroscopy of Pyrrolizidine alkaloids

The ¹³C NMR spectra of nine pyrrolizidine alkaloids of the macrocyclic diester type, seven of the corresponding N-oxides and of the parent base retronecine have been recorded and the signals assigned. The 13C NMR signals were found to be sensitive to structural variation in both the diester moiety and the heterocyclic ring system, providing useful information for structural elucidation, particularly when the ¹H NMR spectra may be difficult to interpret.     

Pyrrolizidine alkaloids from Ageratum houstonianum Mill.

Four pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PA) were isolated from Ageratum houstonianum and their structures elucidated by spectroscopical methods. Besides the already known lycopsamine three new PA were found. Their structures are the 2S-2-hydroxy-2,3-dimethyl-butanoyl-O(9) as well as the O(7) esters of retronecine and the O(9) derivative of heliotridine.     

Pyrrolic Metabolites from Non-toxic Pyrrolizidine Alkaloids

THERE is evidence that some or all of the cytotoxic effects of unsaturated pyrrolizidine alkaloids are, in some animals, caused by pyrrolic metabolites formed by enzymatic dehydro-genation of the alkaloids in the liver^1,2. These metabolites are dihydropyrrolizine alcohols like I in Fig. 1 or their esters II; one such alcohol has been identified³. Compared with the parent alkaloids these metabolites are highly reactive alkylating agents, capable of reacting chemically with tissue constituents^1,2,4.     

Active Metabolites in the Chronic Hepatotoxicity of Pyrrolizidine Alkaloids,including Otonecine Esters

WHEN she reported the chronic hepatotoxicity of the alkaloids senkirkine and hydroxysenkirkine, which are esters of the aminoalcohol otonecine, Schoental¹ suggested that 1,2-epoxides rather than pyrrolic derivatives^2,3 are the active metabolites of hepatotoxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids. We have results which confirm the hepatotoxicity of otonecine esters but argue against the suggested involvement of 1,2-epoxides.     

Necines of alkaloids in Heliotropium species from Mexico and the U.S.A.

The qualitative and quantitative compositions of necines in plants of 20 Heliotropium species collected in Mexico and the U.S.A. and one species from Spain are reported. Trachelanthamidine, supinidine and retronecine were found in all species after hydrolysis of their alkaloids; lindelofidine was detected in most species, whereas heliotridine only in four. Trachelanthamidine, lindelofidine, and supinidine were dominant in four, two and one species, respectively; retronecine was dominant in 15 species, whereas heliotridine only in one. The dominant necine in H. ternatum was either retronecine or lindelofidine depending on the collection locality. Qualitative as well as quantitative differences depending on the collection locality were found in H. curassavicum. Plants from Oaxaca, Mexico, contained lindelofidine and a pyrrolizidine-diol as major necines, trachelanthamidine as minor, and traces of retronecine. Plants originating from two other localities contained trachelanthamidine (dominant), retronecine, and supinidine. The necine patterns found in the examined species differ significantly from those previously reported for 21 species mainly collected in Asia, the Middle East and Australia.     

Metabolism and toxicity of synthetic analogues of macrocyclic diester pyrrolizidine alkaloids

Seven macrocyclic diesters analogous to hepatotoxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids have been tested in male weanling Wistar rats. The compounds were the succinate (VII), 2,3-dimethylsuccinate (VIII), phthalate (IX), glutarate (X), 2,4-dimethylglutarate (XI), 3,3-dimethylglutarate (XII) and 3,3-pentamethyleneglutarate (XIII) of the synthetic amino dialcohol, synthanecine A. Single doses of these compounds were given i.p. to rats, and liver levels of pyrrolic metabolites were measured 2 h later. For these experiments both normal rats and rats pretreated with the esterase inhibitor tri-orthocresylphosphate (TOCP) were used. In normal rats, low levels of pyrrolic metabolites were formed from compounds VII, IX, X and XI, but these levels were greatly enhanced in rats with inhibited esterase activity. Much higher pyrrole levels were formed from compounds VIII, XII and XIII in normal rats, and esterase inhibition had relatively little effect on their metabolic conversion to pyrroles. This indicated that the last mentioned compounds were relatively resistant to enzymic hydrolysis, whereas VII, IX, X and XI were easily hydrolysed in normal rats, providing an alternative metabolic path which limited their conversion to pyrrolic metabolites. Comparison of results obtained using the 2,4-dimethylglutarate (XI), the 3,3-dimethylglutarate (XII) and the 3,3,-pentamethyleneglutarate (XIII) showed that 3,3-disubstitution but not 2,4-disubstitution in the glutaric acid moiety conferred high resistance to esterase attack. Toxicity tests using four of the compounds confirmed that acute hepatotoxicity was dose related, and associated with the formation of pyrrolic metabolites in the liver. The 3,3-dimethylglutarate (XII) was highly toxic both in normal and in TOCP treated rats, doses of 25-30 mg/kg causing moderate to severe centrilobular necrosis of the liver. In contrast the toxicity of the unsubstituted succinate (VII), glutarate (X) and 2,4-dimethylglutarate (XI) was very low in normal rats but high in rats with inhibited esterase activity. Thus, the glutarate (X) was non-toxic at 200 mg/kg in normal rats, but in TOCP treated rats, in which pyrrolic metabolite formation was enhanced by a factor of 17.5, a 50 mg/kg dose of this compound was severely hepatotoxic. Kidney damage, which was generally limited to the presence of isolated necrotic cells, sometimes accompanied the liver damage caused by these compounds, but acute toxic effects were not observed in any other tissues.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Metabolic profiling in Echium plantagineum: presence of bioactive pyrrolizidine alkaloids and napthoquinones from accessions across southeastern Australia

Geographically distinct populations of Paterson’s curse (Echium plantagineum L., Boragineacea), found near roadsides across New South Wales and Victoria, Australia were surveyed along 3 distinct longitudinal transects in spring of 2011 for presence of pyrrolizidine alkaloids and naphthoquinones in sampled plants. Composite samples of shoots and roots were collected from each of 45 sites; shoot extracts were subjected to solid phase extraction and LC-ESI/MS for determination of pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) and related N-oxides (PANOs), while root periderm extracts were analysed for naphthoquinone content spectrophotometrically and by LC-ESI/MS. Metabolic profiling of 12 possible PAs and PANOs showed their consistent appearance in all shoot extracts, with lepthamine N-oxide, echimidine-N oxide and echumine N-oxide predominant. The three major PANOs were significantly higher in northern sampling locations than those further south. Root extracts contained shikonin and several related naphthoquinones, as well as two of the major PANOs found in the leaves. Naphthoquinones were highest in the northwest corner of the sampled region. The patterns of abundance of secondary metabolites in E. plantagienum suggest that climate change might result in greater production of defensive compounds by E. plantagineum, making this weed increasingly toxic to livestock.     

Specific recognition, detoxification and metabolism of pyrrolizidine alkaloids by the polyphagous arctiid Estigmene acrea

Evidence is presented that the polyphagous arctiid Estigmene acrea is well adapted to sequester and specifically handle pyrrolizidine alkaloids of almost all known structural types representative of the major plant families with pyrrolizidine alkaloid-containing species, i.e. Asteraceae with the tribes Senecioneae and Eupatorieae, Boraginaceae, Fabaceae, Apocynaceae and Orchidaceae. The adaptation of E. acrea to pyrrolizidine alkaloids includes a number of specialized characters: (i) highly sensitive recognition of alkaloid sources by pyrrolizidine alkaloid-specific taste receptors; (ii) detoxification of pyrrolizidine alkaloids by N-oxidation catalyzed by a specific flavin-dependent monooxygenase; (iii) transfer and maintenance of all types of pyrrolizidine N-oxides through all developmental stages; (iv) conversion of the various structures into the male courtship pheromone hydroxydanaidal most probably through retronecine and insect specific retronecine esters (creatonotines) as common intermediates; (v) specific integration into mating behavior and defense strategies. Toxic otonecine derivatives, e.g. the senecionine analogue senkirkine, which often accompany the common retronecine derivatives and which cannot be detoxified by N-oxidation do not affect the development of E. acrea larvae. Senkirkine is not sequestered at all. Non-toxic 1,2-saturated platynecine derivatives that frequently occur together with toxic retronecine esters are sequestered and metabolized to hydroxydanaidal, indicating the ability of E. acrea to aromatize saturated pyrrolizidines. Although pyrrolizidine alkaloids, even if they are offered continuously at a high level (2%) in the larval diet, are non-toxic, E. acrea larvae are not able to develop exclusively on a pyrrolizidine alkaloid-containing plant like Crotalaria. Therefore, E. acrea appears to be specifically adapted to exploit pyrrolizidine alkaloid-containing plants as "drug source" but not as a food source.     

Pyrrolizidine alkaloids and other constituents from Emilia fosbergii Nicolson

Emilia fosbergii is a member of the tribe Senecioneae (Asteraceae), most species of which contain pyrrolizidine alkaloids. Notwithstanding, the phytochemistry of E. fosbergii is poorly understood, and pyrrolizidine alkaloids produced by this species have yet to be characterized. In this work, the presence of 11 pyrrolizidine alkaloids, three caffeoylquinic acid derivatives, and six flavonoids were detected by liquid chromatography coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry analyses. Pyrrolizidine alkaloids of otonecine, retronecine, and platynecine bases are annotated in different parts of the plant. Furthermore, emiline was isolated, possibly indicating that E. fosbergii has a close phylogenetic relationship with E. coccinea. The chemophenetic implications of the presence of pyrrolizidine alkaloids in E. fosbergii and tribe Senecioneae are discussed.     

1H NMR Spectroscopy of pyrrolizidine alkaloids

The ¹H NMR spectra of three pyrrolizidine alkaloids of the macrocyclic diester type, retrorsine, seneciphylline and senecionine, plus their three N-oxides have been assigned. Previous ¹H NMR studies of these pyrrolizidine alkaloids have stressed the difficulties of spectral intrepretation. The results reported here will provide a useful resource for analysis of tertiary structure in these and related compounds.     

Recovery of the pyrrolic nucleus of pyrrolizidine alkaloid metabolites from sulphur conjugates in tissues and body fluids

Reactive pyrrolic metabolites formed when pyrrolizidine alkaloids are given to rats can alkylate soluble and tissue-bound thiol groups. Pyrrolic thioethers thus formed are relatively stable, and may persist in tissues for long periods. A simple procedure has been developed for recovering the nucleus of the pyrrolic metabolite from such S-binding, whether in solution or attached to solid tissues, in an easily identifiable form. The thioether bond was broken by silver nitrate and the pyrrolic moiety allowed to react with ethanol or methanol to form an ethoxy or methoxy derivative. The chemical basis of the procedure was established by model experiments on a preparative scale, but for small scale recovery from tissues, pyrrolic ethers were extracted and identified by TLC, HPLC, capillary GC and mass spectrometry. Because the pyrrolic derivatives thus formed were easily recognised and unrelated to any physiological compound, the recovery method described, especially when applied to blood samples, provided a way to monitor animals for previous exposure to toxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids.     

Sequestration, metabolism and partial synthesis of tertiary pyrrolizidine alkaloids by the neotropical leaf-beetle Platyphora boucardi

Platyphora boucardi leaf-beetles sequester tertiary pyrrolizidine alkaloids of the lycopsamine type acquired from their host-plant Prestonia portobellensis (Apocynaceae) and synthesize their own alkaloids from exogenous retronecine and aliphatic 2-hydroxy acids. Tracer studies with [14C]rinderine and its N-oxide revealed that P. boucardi sequesters both alkaloidal forms with the same efficiency, but accumulates exclusively tertiary alkaloids. There is no substantial alkaloid accumulation in the body outside the defensive glands. Feeding studies with [2H][14C]rinderine confirmed that P. boucardi specifically epimerizes rinderine to its stereoisomers intermedine and lycopsamine. Feeding studies with [2H][14C]retronecine proved the ability of P. boucardi to synthesize O7- and O9-(2-hydroxyisovaleryl)-retronecine and O7-lactyl-O9-(2-hydroxyisovaleryl)-retronecine. Both, alkaloids of the lycopsamine type and self-synthesized retronecine esters accumulate in the defensive secretions at concentrations up to 38 mM and 33 mM, respectively. The different biochemical strategies to maintain pro-toxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids and to prevent self-poisoning, developed by specialized insects, are compared. There are two major findings: (1) the chemical defense mediated by plant acquired pyrrolizidine alkaloids in the taxonomically related palaearctic Oreina and neotropical Platyphora leaf beetles have been evolved independently, since the biochemical mechanisms of storing and maintaining the alkaloids is completely different in the two genera; (2) unexpected parallels exist between taxonomically unrelated Coleoptera and Lepidoptera in their ability to synthesize the same retronecine esters and to catalyze the same site-specific epimerizations of the lycopsamine stereoisomers.     

Derivatives of characiol,macrocyclic diterpene esters of the jatrophane type from Euphorbia characias

Eight non-irritant macrocyclic diterpene esters of the jatrophane type were obtained from an irritant acetone extract of latex and from an irritant methanol extract of roots of Euphorbia characias. They were shown to be diesters of the new parent alcohols characiol, characiol-5β,6β-oxide and 5β-hydroxyisocharaciol and pentaesters of 2,5β,8-trihydroxyisocharaciol.     

Ideamine N-Oxides: Pyrrolizidine Alkaloids Sequestered by the Danaine Butterfly,Idea leuconoe

Two new pyrrolizidine alkaloids, ideamines A and B, together with other analogs (lycopsamine and parsonsine) were isolated in the N-oxide forms from adult bodies of the Apocynaceae-feeding danaine butterfly, Idea leuconoe. Ideamine A was characterized as a homolog of lycopsamine, in which the viridifloric acid moiety was replaced by a 2-ethyl-2,3-dihydroxybutanoic moiety. Likewise, ideamine B was identified as a nor-derivative of parsonsine, in which the trachelanthic acid moiety was replaced by a 2-ethyl-2,3-dihydroxybutanoic moiety diastereomeric to the necic acid from ideamine A.     

Acute hepatotoxicity and pyrrolic metabolites in rats dosed with pyrrolizidine alkaloids

Relationships can be demonstrated between the acute hepatotoxicity of some pyrrolizidine alkaloids and the amounts of pyrrolic metabolites found in livers of rats given the alkaloids.     

Induction of endogenous avian tumor virus gene expression by pyrrolizidine alkaloids

The pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PA) are toxic compounds which occur naturally in plant species throughout the world. They have been implicated as both carcinogenic and mutagenic agents. An active metabolite of the alkaloids, the pyrrole, which is a strong alkylating agent, is thought to be the toxicant. The naturally occurring alkaloid, jacobine , is able to induce the production of endogenous avian RNA tumor virus particles in cultured chick embryo fibroblasts (CEF). When jacobine was modified to form retronecine it no longer induced virus particles. Conversion of retronecine to its pyrrole resulted in a compound capable of inducing virus particle production. The isobutyryl monoester of retronecine was also able to induce virus particle production, but the isobutyryl monoester pyrrole was unexpectedly inactive as an inducer. This type of viral induction system is useful for studying the effect of modification of the inducer on its biological activity.     

Biomarkers for ragwort poisoning in horses: identification of protein targets

Background

Ingestion of the poisonous weed ragwort (Senecio jacobea) by horses leads to irreversible liver damage. The principal toxins of ragwort are the pyrrolizidine alkaloids that are rapidly metabolised to highly reactive and cytotoxic pyrroles, which can escape into the circulation and bind to proteins. In this study a non-invasive in vitro model system has been developed to investigate whether pyrrole toxins induce specific modifications of equine blood proteins that are detectable by proteomic methods.

Results

One dimensional gel electrophoresis revealed a significant alteration in the equine plasma protein profile following pyrrole exposure and the formation of a high molecular weight protein aggregate. Using mass spectrometry and confirmation by western blotting the major components of this aggregate were identified as fibrinogen, serum albumin and transferrin.

Conclusion

These findings demonstrate that pyrrolic metabolites can modify equine plasma proteins. The high molecular weight aggregate may result from extensive inter- and intra-molecular cross-linking of fibrinogen with the pyrrole. This model has the potential to form the basis of a novel proteomic strategy aimed at identifying surrogate protein biomarkers of ragwort exposure in horses and other livestock.