EcoA and EcoE: alternatives to the EcoK family of type I restriction and modification systems of Escherichia coli

The genes (hsd A) encoding EcoA, a restriction and modification system first identified in Escherichia coli 15T-, behave in genetic crosses as alleles of the genes (hsd K) encoding the archetypal type I restriction and modification system of E. coli K12. Nevertheless, molecular experiments have failed to detect relatedness between the A and K systems. We have cloned the hsd A genes and have identified, on the basis of DNA homology, related genes (hsd E) conferring a new specificity to a natural isolate of E. coli. We show that the overall organization of the genes encoding EcoA and EcoE closely parallels that for EcoK. Each enzyme is encoded by three genes, of which only one, hsdS, confers the specificity of DNA interaction. The three genes are in the same order as those encoding EcoK, i.e. hsdR, hsdM and hsdS and, similarly, they include a promoter between hsdR and hsdM from which the M and S genes can be transcribed. The evidence indicates that EcoA and EcoE are type I restriction and modification enzymes, but they appear to identify an alternative family to EcoK. For both families, the hsdR polypeptide is by far the largest, but the sizes of the other two polypeptides are reversed, with the smallest polypeptide of EcoK being the product of hsd S, and the smallest for the EcoA family being the product of hsdM. Physiologically, the A restriction and modification system differs from that of K and its relatives, in that A-specific methylation of unmodified DNA is particularly effective.     

Sequence diversity among related genes for recognition of specific targets in DNA molecules

Escherichia coli strains K12 and B, and a new strain designated D, each encode a characteristic restriction and modification enzyme. These enzymes (EcoK, EcoB and presumably EcoD) comprise three subunits of which one, that encoded by the so-called specificity gene (hsdS), is responsible for recognition of the DNA sequence specific to that system. The other two subunits, encoded by hsdR and hsdM, are interchangeable between systems, and the available molecular evidence suggests that the hsdR and hsdM genes are highly conserved. The DNA sequence of a segment of the hsd region that includes the hsdS gene has been determined for each of the three strains. The hsdS gene varies in length from 1335 to 1425 base-pairs and the only regions showing obvious homology, one of about 100 base-pairs and a second of about 250 base-pairs, are highly conserved. The remainder of each hsd S gene shares little, or no, homology with either of the other related specificity genes. Thus, the specificity subunits, though components of a family of closely related enzymes with very similar functions, have remarkably dissimilar primary structure.     

A third family of allelic hsd genes in Salmonella enterica: sequence comparisons with related proteins identify conserved regions implicated in restriction of DNA

Salmonella enterica serovar blegdam has a restriction and modification system encoded by genes linked to serB . We have cloned these genes, putative alleles of the hsd locus of Escherichia coli  K-12, and confirmed by the sequence similarities of flanking DNA that the hsd genes of S. enterica serovar blegdam have the same chromosomal location as those of E. coli K-12 and Salmonella enterica serovar typhimurium LT2. There is, however, no obvious similarity in their nucleotide sequences, and while the gene order in S. enterica serovar blegdam is serB hsdM , S and R , that in E. coli K-12 and S. enterica serovar typhimurium LT2 is serB hsdR , M and S . The hsd genes of S. enterica serovar blegdam identify a third family of serB -linked hsd genes (type ID). The polypeptide sequence predicted from the three hsd genes show some similarities (18–50% identity) with the polypeptides of known and putative type I restriction and modification systems; the highest levels of identity are with sequences of Haemophilus influenzae Rd. The HsdM polypeptide has the motifs characteristic of adenine methyltransferases. Comparisons of the HsdR sequence with those for three other families of type I systems and three putative HsdR polypeptides identify two highly conserved regions in addition to the seven proposed DEAD-box motifs.     

The effect of the phage lambda ral gene on the level of synthesis of the EcoK restriction endonuclease beta-subunit

E. coli hsd genes were subcloned from lambda 642 (ral+) into lambda L47.1 vector (ral-after replacement). The influence of bacteriophage lambda ral gene on the expression efficiency of hsdS kappa, hsdM kappa genes was investigated. It was shown, that its presence in vitro enhanced the synthesis of beta-subunit, hsdM gene product, and the increase of modification in vivo was observed. It is proposed that the increase of modification rate of lambda phage fully unmodified DNA is connected with the appearance of E. coli DNA methylase consisting of beta- and gamma-subunits but lacking alpha-subunit.     

The EcoDXX1 restriction and modification system: cloning the genes and homology to type I restriction and modification systems

The Escherichia coli plasmid pDXX1 codes for a type I restriction and modification system, EcoDXX1. A 15.5-kb BamHI fragment from pDXX1 has been cloned and contains the hsdR, hsdM, and hsdS genes that encode the EcoDXX1 system. The EcoDXX1 hsd genes can complement the gene products of the EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 hsd systems, but not those of EcoK and EcoB. Hybridization experiments using EcoDXX1 hsd genes as a probe demonstrate homology between EcoDXX1 and EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 restriction-modification systems, but weak or no homology between EcoDXX1 and EcoK or EcoB systems.     

The EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 restriction and modification systems: Cloning the genes

The Escherichia coli plasmid R124 codes for a type I restriction and modification system EcoR124 and carries genetic information, most probably in the form of a "silent copy," for the expression of a different R-M specificity R124/3. Characteristic DNA rearrangements have been shown to accompany the switch in specificity from R124 to R124/3 and vice versa. We have cloned a 14.2-kb HindIII fragment from R124 and shown that it contains the hsdR, hsdM, and hsdS genes which code for the EcoR124 R-M system. An equivalent fragment from the plasmid R124/3 following the switch in R-M specificity has also been cloned and shown to contain the genes coding for the EcoR124/3 R-M system. These fragments, however, lack a component present on the wild-type plasmid essential for the switch in specificity. Restriction fragment maps and preliminary heteroduplex analysis indicate the near identity of the genes that encode the two different DNA recognition specificities. Transposon mutagenesis was used to locate the positions of the hsdR, hsdM, and hsdS genes on the cloned fragments in conjunction with complementation tests for gene function. Indirect evidence indicates that hsdR is expressed from its own promoter and that hsdM and hsdS are expressed from a single promoter, unidirectionally.     

Sau1: a novel lineage-specific type I restriction-modification system that blocks horizontal gene transfer into Staphylococcus aureus and between S. aureus isolates of different lineages

The Sau1 type I restriction-modification system is found on the chromosome of all nine sequenced strains of Staphylococcus aureus and includes a single hsdR (restriction) gene and two copies of hsdM (modification) and hsdS (sequence specificity) genes. The strain S. aureus RN4220 is a vital intermediate for laboratory S. aureus manipulation, as it can accept plasmid DNA from Escherichia coli. We show that it carries a mutation in the sau1hsdR gene and that complementation restored a nontransformable phenotype. Sau1 was also responsible for reduced conjugative transfer from enterococci, a model of vancomycin resistance transfer. This may explain why only four vancomycin-resistant S. aureus strains have been identified despite substantial selective pressure in the clinical setting. Using a multistrain S. aureus microarray, we show that the two copies of sequence specificity genes (sau1hsdS1 and sau1hsdS2) vary substantially between isolates and that the variation corresponds to the 10 dominant S. aureus lineages. Thus, RN4220 complemented with sau1hsdR was resistant to bacteriophage lysis but only if the phage was grown on S. aureus of a different lineage. Similarly, it could be transduced with DNA from its own lineage but not with the phage grown on different S. aureus lineages. Therefore, we propose that Sau1 is the major mechanism for blocking transfer of resistance genes and other mobile genetic elements into S. aureus isolates from other species, as well as for controlling the spread of resistance genes between isolates of different S. aureus lineages. Blocking Sau1 should also allow genetic manipulation of clinical strains of S. aureus.     

Basis for changes in DNA recognition by the EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 type I DNA restriction and modification enzymes

EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 are type I DNA restriction and modification systems. The EcoR124/3 system arose from the EcoR124 system some 15 years ago and at the electron microscopic DNA heteroduplex level the genes for both systems are still apparently identical. We have shown that the DNA sequences recognized by the two systems are GAA(N6)RTCG for EcoR124 and GAA(N7)RTCG for EcoR124/3. The sequences thus differ only in the length of the non-specific spacer. This difference nevertheless places the two specific domains of the EcoR124/3 recognition sequence 0.34 nm further apart and rotates them 36 degrees with respect to those of EcoR124, which implies major structural differences in the proteins recognizing these sequences. We have now determined the nucleotide sequences of the hsdS and hsdM genes of both systems and of the hsdR gene of EcoR124/3. The hsdS gene products provide DNA sequence specificity in both restriction and modification, the hsdM gene products are necessary for modification and all three hsd gene products are required for restriction. The only difference that we have detected between the two systems is that a 12 base-pair sequence towards the middle of the hsdS gene is repeated twice in the EcoR124 gene and three times in the EcoR124/3 gene. We have deleted one of the repeats in the EcoR124/3 gene and shown that this changes the specificity to that of EcoR124. Thus, the extra four amino acids in the middle of the EcoR124/3 hsdS gene product, which in an alpha-helical configuration would extend 0.6 nm, are sufficient to explain the differences in sequence recognition. We suggest that the EcoR124/3 system was generated by an unequal crossing over and argue that this kind of specificity change should not be rare in Nature.     

Analysis of type I restriction modification systems in the Neisseriaceae: genetic organization and properties of the gene products

The hsd locus (host specificity of DNA) was identified in the Neisseria gonorrhoeae genome. The DNA fragment encoding this locus produced an active restriction and modification (R/M) system when cloned into Escherichia coli. This R/M system was designated NgoAV. The cloned genomic fragment (7800 bp) has the potential to encode seven open reading frames (ORFs). Several of these ORFs had significant homology with other proteins found in the databases: ORF1, the hsdM, a methylase subunit (HsdM); ORF2, a homologue of dinD; ORF3, a homologue of hsdS; ORF4, a homologue of hsdS; and ORF5, an endonuclease subunit hsdR. The endonuclease and methylase subunits possessed strongest protein sequence homology to the EcoR124II R/M system, indicating that NgoAV belongs to the type IC R/M family. Deletion analysis showed that only ORF3 imparted the sequence specificity of the RM.NgoAV system, which recognizes an interrupted palindrome sequence (GCAN(8-)TGC). The genetic structure of ORF3 (208 amino acids) is almost identical to the structure of the 5' truncated hsdS genes of EcoDXXI or EcoR124II R/M systems obtained by in vitro manipulation. Genomic sequence analysis allowed us to identify hsd loci with a very high homology to RM.NgoAV in two strains of Neisseria meningitidis. However, significant differences in the organization and structure of the hsdS genes in both these systems suggests that, if functional, they would possess recognition sites that differ from the gonococcus and from themselves.     

DNA restriction and modification in Escherichia coli: functional analysis of the role of the dnaC(D) gene product

Escherichia coli strain PC-7 carries two independent temperature-sensitive mutations, one affecting the restriction and modification (R-M) phenotype and the other the DnaC(D) phenotype. The results of complementation and P1 transduction analysis of the mutation affecting the R-M phenotype implicate a fourth gene, designated hsdX, located close to the hsd three-gene complex. The properties of merodiploids constructed between appropriate recipients and F' elements with different mutations in hsdS, hsdR and hsdM genes might indicate that in strain PC-7 the temperature-sensitive products, determined by hsdR and hsdSK cistrons, are synthesized. The role of the temperature-sensitive dnaC(D) gene product in the formation of the restriction endonuclease was studied and no direct relation was found between the DnaC(D) and R-M phenotypes.     

The type IC hsd loci of the enterobacteria are flanked by DNA with high homology to the phage P1 genome: implications for the evolution and spread of DNA restriction systems

Eco R124I, Eco DXXI and Eco prrI are the known members of the type IC family of DNA restriction and modification systems. The first three are carried on large, conjugative plasmids, while Eco prrI is chromosomally encoded. The enzymes are coded by three genes, hsdR , hsdM and hsdS . Analysis of the DNA sequences upstream and downstream of the type IC hsd loci shows that all are highly homologous to each other and also to sequences present in the bacteriophage P1 genome. The upstream sequences include functional phd and doc genes, which encode an addiction system that stabilizes the P1 prophage state, and extend to and beyond pac , the site at which phage DNA packaging begins. Downstream of the hsd loci, P1 DNA sequences begin at exactly the same place for all of the systems. For Eco DXXI and Eco prrI the P1 homology extends for thousands of base pairs while for Eco R124I an IS 1 insertion and an associated deletion have removed most of the P1-homologous sequences. The significance of these results for the evolution of DNA restriction and modification systems is discussed.     

Cloning, production and characterisation of wild type and mutant forms of the R.EcoK endonucleases.

The hsdR, hsdM and hsdS genes coding for R.EcoK restriction endonuclease, both with and without a temperature sensitive mutation (ts-1) in the hsdS gene, were cloned in pBR322 plasmid and introduced into E.coli C3-6. The presence of the hsdSts-1 mutation has no effect on the R-M phenotype of this construct in bacteria grown at 42 degrees C. However, DNA sequencing indicates that the mutation is still present on the pBR322-hsdts-1 operon. The putative temperature-sensitive endonuclease was purified from bacteria carrying this plasmid and the ability to cleave and methylate plasmid DNA was investigated. The mutant endonuclease was found to show temperature-sensitivity for restriction. Modification was dramatically reduced at both the permissive and non-permissive temperatures. The wild type enzyme was found to cleave circular DNA in a manner which strongly suggests that only one endonuclease molecule is required per cleavage event. Circular and linear DNA appear to be cleaved using different mechanisms, and cleavage of linear DNA may require a second endonuclease molecule. The subunit composition of the purified endonucleases was investigated and compared to the level of subunit production in minicells. There is no evidence that HsdR is prevented from assembling with HsdM and HsdSts-1 to produce the mutant endonuclease. The data also suggests that the level of HsdR subunit may be limiting within the cell. We suggest that an excess of HsdM and HsdS may produce the methylase in vivo and that assembly of the endonuclease may be dependent upon the prior production of this methylase.     

Distribution and diversity of hsd genes in Escherichia coli and other enteric bacteria.

We screened Salmonella typhimurium, Citrobacter freundii, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Shigella boydii, and many isolates of Escherichia coli for DNA sequences homologous to those encoding each of two unrelated type I restriction and modification systems (EcoK and EcoA). Both K- and A-related hsd genes were identified, but never both in the same strain. S. typhimurium encodes three restriction and modification systems, but its DNA hybridized only to the K-specific probe which we know to identify the StySB system. No homology to either probe was detected in the majority of E. coli strains, but in C. freundii, we identified homology to the A-specific probe. We cloned this region of the C. freundii genome and showed that it encoded a functional, A-related restriction system whose specificity differs from those of known type I enzymes. Sequences immediately flanking the hsd K genes of E. coli K-12 and the hsd A genes of E. coli 15T- were shown to be homologous, indicating similar or even identical positions in their respective chromosomes. E. coli C has no known restriction system, and the organization of its chromosome is consistent with deletion of the three hsd genes and their neighbor, mcrB.     

Characterization of lambda Escherichia coli hybrids carrying chemotaxis genes.

Molecular cloning techniques were used to construct hybrid Escherichia coli lambda phage and isolate Col E1 factors that carried the cheB region of the E. coli genome. The products of these genes were examined by using a series of deletions in the phage to stimulate specific polypeptide synthesis in ultraviolet-irradiated cells and by using Col factor to program protein synthesis in minicells. Seven flagellar related polypeptides were synthesized. Three of these with apparent molecular weights of 38,000, 28,000, and 8,000 were associated with the cheB region; three polypeptides 63,000, 61,000, and 60,000 were associated with the region that maps between cheB and cheA. These bands were referred to as the triplet group. We suggest that these polypeptides are the same as the methyl-accepting chemotaxis protein described by Kort et al. (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 72:3939-3943, 1975). Another polypeptide with a molecular weight of 12,000 is associated with the cheA region which also produces at least three gene products. We conclude that the cheA-cheB region in E. coli is complex. Further genetic and biochemical analyses are required to describe all of these products.     

Structural homologies among type I restriction-modification systems.

Structural homologies among different restriction systems of Escherichia coli and several Salmonella species have been investigated by immunological methods using antibodies prepared against two subunits of the E. coli K12 restriction enzyme, and by DNA hybridization experiments using different fragments of the E. coli K12 hsd genes as probes. The results with both techniques show a strong homology between the E. coli K12 and B restriction-modification systems, weaker but nevertheless marked homology between E. coli K12 and the Salmonella systems SB, SP, and SQ and, surprisingly, no homology between the E. coli K12 and A systems.