A role for redox factors in shaping root architecture under phosphorus deficiency

The developmental response of the Arabidopsis root system to low phosphorus (P) availability involves the reduction in primary root elongation accompanied by the formation of numerous lateral roots. We studied the roles of selected redox metabolites, namely, radical oxygen species (ROS) and ascorbic acid (ASC) in the regulation of root system architecture by different P availability. Rapidly growing roots of plants grown on P-sufficient medium synthesize ROS in root elongation zone and quiescent centre. We have demonstrated that the arrest of root elongation at low P medium coincides with the disappearance of ROS from the elongation zone. P-starvation resulted in a decrease in ascorbic acid level in roots. This correlated with a decrease in cell division activity. On the other hand, feeding P-deficient plants with ASC, stimulated mitotic activity in the primary root meristem and partly reversed the inhibition of root growth imposed by low P conditions. In this paper, we discuss the idea of the involvement of redox agents in the regulation of root system architecture under low P availability.Key words: ascorbic acid, phosphate deficiency, primary root, radical oxygen species, root growth, root system architecture     

低磷供应对拟南芥根系构型的影响

在人工气候箱中,采用Johnson培养基对拟南芥在低磷供应条件下根系构型的变化进行了研究,结果表明：拟南芥在磷饥饿诱导下,主根缩短,侧根密度、根毛的数量和长度显著增加,并且,根尖到第一侧根和第一根毛的距离也大大缩短。这些改变增加了根系比表面积,并且使得根系分布更加靠近土壤表层,有利于提高植物吸收土壤中有机磷的效率。低磷胁迫还导致拟南芥根系分生组织区细胞形状变异,柱细胞数量减少;主根生长和细胞伸长的动力学分析显示,磷饥饿促使拟南芥主根生长变缓,细胞长度随磷饥饿程度的加深迅速缩小。CycB1;1:GUS染色分析结果表明,低磷破坏拟南芥根系分生组织细胞分裂能力,这些结果说明磷胁迫同时抑制了细胞的伸长和分裂,从而引起拟南芥主根的缩短。     

磷空间有效性对拟南芥根形态构型的影响

磷空间有效性显著影响拟南芥主、侧根生长。在均一的磷处理下,极度磷胁迫或过量供磷均会导致拟南芥主根变短和侧根密度降低。在分层的磷处理下,上层高磷下层低磷能明显促进主根伸长生长,提高侧根在高磷区域的密度,说明植物根系在下层低磷区感受到磷胁迫信号后,可促进上层高磷区侧根的形成和发育。     

Root growth, developmental changes in the apex, and hydraulic conductivity for Opuntia ficus-indica during drought

Developmental changes in the root apex and accompanying changes in lateral root growth and root hydraulic conductivity were examined for Opuntia ficus-indica (L.) Miller during rapid drying, as occurs for roots near the soil surface, and more gradual drying, as occurs in deeper soil layers. During 7 d of rapid drying (in containers with a 3-cm depth of vermiculite), the rate of root growth decreased sharply and most root apices died; such a determinate pattern of root growth was not due to meristem exhaustion but rather to meristem mortality after 3 d of drying. The length of the meristem, the duration of the cell division cycle, and the length of the elongation zone were unchanged during rapid drying. During 14 d of gradual drying (in containers with a 6-cm depth of vermiculite), root mortality was relatively low; the length of the elongation zone decreased by 70%, the number of meristematic cells decreased 30%, and the duration of the cell cycle increased by 36%. Root hydraulic conductivity ( L _P) decreased to one half during both drying treatments; L _P was restored by 2 d of rewetting owing to the emergence of lateral roots following rapid drying and to renewed apical elongation following gradual drying. Thus, in response to drought, the apical meristems of roots of O. ficus-indica near the surface die, whereas deeper in the substrate cell division and elongation in root apices continue. Water uptake in response to rainfall in the field can be enhanced by lateral root proliferation near the soil surface and additionally by resumption of apical growth for deeper roots.     

Phosphate Availability Alters Lateral Root Anatomy and Root Architecture of Fraxinus mandshurica Rupr. Seedlings

Plants have evolved some mechanisms to maximize the efficiency of phosphorus acquisition.Changes in root architecture are one such mechanism. When Fraxinus mandshurica Rupr. seedlings were grown under conditions of low phosphorus availability, the length of cells in the meristem zone of the lateral roots was longer, but the length of cells in the elongation and mature zones of the lateral roots was shorter,compared with seedlings grown under conditions of high phosphorus availability. The elongation rates of primary roots increased as phosphorus availability increased, but the elongation rates of the branched zones of the primary roots decreased. The number of lateral root primordia and the length of the lateral roots decreased as phosphorus availability increased. The topological index (altitude slope) decreased as phosphorus availability increased, suggesting that root architecture tended to be herringbone-like when seedlings were grown under conditions of low phosphate availability. Herringbone-like root systems exploit nutrients more efficiently, but they have higher construction costs than root systems with a branching pattern.     

Effect of sub-optimal root zone temperatures at varied nutrient supply and shoot meristem temperature on growth and nutrient concentrations in maize seedlings (Zea mays L.)

Maize seedlings were grown for 10 to 20 days in either nutrient solution or in soils with or without fertilizer supply. Air temperature was kept uniform for all treatments, while root zone temperature (RZT) was varied between 12 and 24°C. In some treatments the basal part of the shoot (with apical shoot meristem and zone of leaf elongation) was lifted up to separate the indirect effects of root zone temperature on shoot growth from the direct effects of temperature on the shoot meristem.Shoot and root growth were decreased by low RZT to a similar extent irrespective of the growth medium (i.e. nutrient solution, fertilized or unfertilized soil). In all culture media Ca concentration was similar or even higher in plants grown at 12 as compared to 24°. At lower RZT concentrations of N, P and K in the shoot dry matter decreased in unfertilized soil, whereas in nutrient solution and fertilized soil only the K concentration decreased.When direct temperature effects on the shoot meristem were reduced by lifting the basal part of the shoot above the temperature-controlled root zone, shoot growth at low RZT was significantly increased in nutrient solution and fertilized soil, but not in unfertilized soil. In fertilized soil and nutrient solution at low RZT the uptake of K increased to a similar extent as plant growth, and thus shoot K concentration was not reduced by increasing shoot growth rates. In contrast, uptake of N and P was not increased, resulting in significantly decreased shoot concentrations.It is concluded that shoot growth at suboptimal RZT was limited both by a direct temperature effect on shoot activity and by a reduced nutrient supply through the roots. Nutrient concentrations in the shoot tissue at low RZT were not only influenced by availability in the substrate and dilution by growth, but also by the internal demand for growth.     

Effect of mutations in the PINHEAD gene of Arabidopsis on the formation of shoot apical meristems

The primary shoot apical meristem of angiosperm plants is formed during embryogenesis. Lateral shoot apical meristems arise postembryonically in the axils of leaves. Recessive mutations at the PINHEAD locus of Arabidopsis interfere with the ability of both the primary shoot apical meristem as well as lateral shoot apical meristems to form. However, adventitious shoot apical meristems can form in pinhead mutant seedlings from the axils of the cotyledons and also from cultred root explants. In this report, the phenotype of pinhead mutants is described, and a hypothesis for the role of the wild-type PINHEAD gene product in shoot meristem initiation is presented. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Die for living better: Plants modify root system architecture through inducing PCD in root meristem under severe water stress

Plant root development is highly plastic in order to cope with various environmental stresses; many questions on the mechanisms underlying developmental plasticity of root system remain unanswered. Recently, we showed that autophagic PCD occurs in the region of root apical meristem in response to severe water deficit. We provided evidence that reactive oxygen species (ROS) accumulation may trigger the cell death process of the meristematic cells in the stressed root tips. Analysis of BAX inhibitor-1 (AtBI1) expression and the phenotypic response of atbi1-1 mutant under the severe water stress revealed that AtBI1 and the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress response pathway modulate water stress-induced PCD. As a result, the thick and short lateral roots with increased tolerance to the stress are induced. We propose that under severe drought condition, plants activate PCD program in the root apical root meristem, so that apical root dominance is removed. In this way, they can remodel their root system architecture to adapt the stress environment.Key words: Arabidopsis, adaptation, PCD, root system architecture, water stressPlant shoot apical dominance is well known. The axillary buds are inhibited by the growing shoot apical meristem, and they would not grow until the shoot apical meristems are decapitated.¹ The same phenomenon has been found in the roots of dicot plants. Primary roots exhibit apical dominance over lateral roots and are able to penetrate deeply into the soil. Lateral root primordia were rapidly activated when primary root tips of lettuce (Lactuca sativa) were removed.² It is apparent that apical meristem activity in shoots and roots determines lateral organs and the shapes of above ground and root system architecture under normal conditions. Many plants have active meristematic activity in their shoot and root tips through their whole life resulting in indeterminate development of their shoots and primary roots, whereas others generate branches at certain developmental stages when the meristematic activity and apical dominance become low.It has long been known that plants modify their root morphology, orientation and increase root biomass to maximize water and nutrient absorption.^3,4 However, how the root morphology and architecture are changed in response to water shortage and what the underlying mechanisms are largely unknown. Previously, it has been reported that plants, due to their sessile nature, have developed a very important adaptive mechanism, namely hydrotropism to avoid the damage caused by water shortage. Plant roots can sense the moisture gradient and grow toward to water or moisture when they are grown at conditions with non-uniform water distribution.⁵ Recently, we found another key mechanism through which plants can remove root apical dominance and remodel their root system architecture, thus to minimize the damage caused by a uniform severe water shortage condition.⁶Firstly, we found that growth rates of the Arabidopsis plants germinated on normal conditions were reduced when the concentrations of PEG in the growth media was increased, and primary roots of the stressed plants completely ceased growth when the PEG concentrations reached 40% (w/v) in the agar medium, a severe water stress. The results showed that growth cessation of the stressed plants was caused by PCD of the cells in the region of root apical meristems, and the cells underwent autophagic cell death upon the most severe water deficit. Secondly, we demonstrated that AtBI-1, a marker gene which plays a critical role in protecting the cells from ER stress-induced PCD in plants, mediates water stress-induced PCD of the root meristem. Further observation of ROS accumulation in the root tips upon to the severe water stress suggests that the high level of the ROS may disrupt the ER homeostasis and ROS may act as a signal to trigger the PCD. Importantly, we found that the occurrence of PCD of the meristematic cells of the stressed plants promoted the development of lateral roots. These short and tublized lateral roots grew slowly under severe water stress, but they could immediately become normal lateral roots and resume their elongation and after rehydration. Plant growth is subsequently restored to complete their entire life cycle. However, the lateral roots induced by decapitating primary root tips under normal conditions did not continue elongation like the stress induced lateral roots, and they cannot restore their growth after rehydration.Based on these results, we propose that plants can sense the severity of water stress, initiate autophagic PCD of meristematic cells in Arabidopsis root tips through ER stress signaling pathway and stimulate lateral root development (Fig. 1). Death of meristematic cells results in the loss of mitotic cell division activity in meristem and eventual root meristem function. The outcome of PCD caused-loss of root meristem activity is same as the surgical removal of apical root tips. In both cases, lateral root primordia are activated and lateral root emergence is promoted. However, the main difference between water stress induced-loss of root meristem function and surgical decapitation of root tips is that the former induces lateral roots with enhanced stress tolerance plays key roles in post-stress recovery, whereas the latter promotes development of lateral roots do not alter stress response. This implicates that stress-induced loss of meristem function and subsequent occurrence of specified lateral roots are adaptive mechanisms for plants to cope with the severe water stress. In other words, plants induce cell death of root meristem for living better.Open in a separate windowFigure 1A simplified model depicting the role of PCD in root meristem in plastic development of root system architecture in response to water stress.It is known that auxin distribution and maxima play key roles in lateral root initiation and emergence.^7–10 Alteration in auxin polar transport has been proposed as the main reason of decapitation induced lateral root development.¹¹ It is conceivable that auxin is also involved in stress induced-lateral root formation and development, but it is clear that interplay between stress signaling cascades and developmental signalings occurs after perception of the stress signals by plant cells resulting in root system development remodeling. These findings provide novel insights into mechanisms of plants to adapt to the uniform severe water stress at organ, cellular and molecular levels. However, the research of plastic development of root system in response to water stress is still in its infancy. Combinatorial strategies for the investigation of stress induced-PCD of root meristematic cells and subsequent lateral root development will help to uncover the molecular mechanisms underlying this positive response of plants in response to severe water stress. In particular, further study of auxin redistribution under water stress and interaction between auxin and stress hormone signalings in remodeling root system architecture will further our understanding of how developmental plasticity of plant root system is regulated. The results will facilitate the improvement of drought tolerance in crops.     

Studies on the behavior of organelles and their nucleoids in the root apical meristem of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Col.

The behavior of cell nuclei, mitochondrial nucleoids (mt-nucleoids) and plastid nucleoids (ptnucleoids) was studied in the root apical meristem of Arabidopsis thaliana. Samples were embedded in Technovit 7100 resin, cut into thin sections and stained with 4′-6-diamidino-2-phenylindole for light-microscopic autoradiography and microphotometry. Synthesis of cell nuclear DNA and cell division were both active in the root apical meristem between 0 μm and 300 μm from the central cells. It is estimated that the cells generated in the lower part of the root apical meristem enter the elongation zone after at least four divisions. Throughout the entire meristematic zone, individual cells had mitochondria which contained 1–5 mt-nucleoids. The number of mitochondria increased gradually from 65 to 200 in the meristem of the central cylinder. Therefore, throughout the meristem, individual mitochondria divided either once or twice per mitotic cycle. By contrast, based on the incorporation of [³H]thymidine into organelle nucleoids, syntheses of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and plastid DNA (ptDNA) occurred independently of the mitotic cycle and mainly in a restricted region (i.e., the lower part of the root apical meristem). Fluorimetry, using a videointensified microscope photon-counting system, revealed that the amount of mtDNA per mt-nucleoid in the cells in the lower part of the meristem, where mtDNA synthesis was active, corresponded to more than 1 Mbp. By contrast, in the meristematic cells just below the elongation zone of the root tip, the amount of mtDNA per mt-nucleoid fell to approximately 170 kbp. These findings strongly indicate that the amount of mtDNA per mitochondrion, which has been synthesized in the lower part of the meristem, is gradually reduced as a result of continual mitochondrial divisions during low levels of mtDNA synthesis. This phenomenon would explain why differentiated cells in the elongation zone have mitochondria that contain only extremely small amounts of mtDNA. This work was supported by a Grant-in Aid (T.K.) for Special Research on Priority Areas (Project No. 02242102, Cellular and Molecular Basis for Reproduction Processes in Plants) from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture of Japan and by a Grant-in Aid (T.K.) for Original and Creative Research Project on Biotechnology from the Research Council, Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of Japan.     

Inhibition of tobacco mosaic virus replication in lateral roots is dependent on an activated meristem-derived signal

Summary. Viral invasion of the root system of Nicotiana benthamiana was studied noninvasively with a tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) vector expressing the green-fluorescent protein (GFP). Lateral root primordia, which developed from the pericycle of primary roots, became heavily infected as they emerged from the root cortex. However, following emergence, a progressive wave of viral inhibition occurred that originated in the lateral-root meristem and progressed towards its base. Excision of source and sink tissues suggested that the inhibition of virus replication was brought about by the basipetal movement of a root meristem signal. When infected plants were inoculated with tobacco rattle virus (TRV) expressing the red-fluorescent protein, DsRed, TRV entered the lateral roots and suppressed the host response, leading to a reestablishment of TMV infection in lateral roots. By infecting GFP-expressing transgenic plants with TMV carrying the complementary GFP sequence it was possible to silence the host GFP, leading to the complete loss of fluorescence in lateral roots. The data suggest that viral inhibition in lateral roots occurs by a gene-silencing-like mechanism that is dependent on the activation of a lateral-root meristem. Received July 23, 2001 Accepted October 11, 2001     

Microsurgical removal of epidermal and cortical cells: evidence that the gravitropic signal moves through the outer cell layers in primary roots of maize

There is general agreement that during root gravitropism some sort of growth-modifying signal moves from the cap to the elongation zone and that this signal ultimately induces the curvature that leads to reorientation of the root. However, there is disagreement regarding both the nature of the signal and the pathway of its movement from the root cap to the elongation zone. We examined the pathway of movement by testing gravitropism in primary roots of maize (Zea mays L.) from which narrow (0.5 mm) rings of epidermal and cortical tissue were surgically removed from various positions within the elongation zone. When roots were girdled in the apical part of the elongation zone gravitropic curvature occurred apical to the girdle but not basal to the girdle. Filling the girdle with agar allowed curvature basal to the girdle to occur. Shallow girdles, in which only two or three cell layers (epidermis plus one or two cortical cell layers) were removed, prevented or greatly delayed gravitropic curvature basal to the girdle. The results indicate that the gravitropic signal moves basipetally through the outermost cell layers, perhaps through the epidermis itself.     

Phosphate Availability Alters Lateral Root Anatomy and Root Architecture of Fraxinus mandshurica Rupr. Seedlings

Plants have evolved some mechanisms to maximize the efficiency of phosphorus acquisition. Changes in root architecture are one such mechanism. When Fraxinus mandshurica Rupr. seedlings were grown under conditions of low phosphorus availability, the length of cells in the meristem zone of the lateral roots was longer, but the length of cells in the elongation and mature zones of the lateral roots was shorter,compared with seedlings grown under conditions of high phosphorus availability. The elongation rates of primary roots increased as phosphorus availability increased, but the elongation rates of the branched zones of the primary roots decreased. The number of lateral root primordia and the length of the lateral roots decreased as phosphorus availability increased. The topological index (altitude slope) decreased as phosphorus availability increased, suggesting that root architecture tended to be herringbone-like when seedlings were grown under conditions of low phosphate availability. Herringbone-like root systems exploit nutrients more efficiently, but they have higher construction costs than root systems with a branching pattem.     

甘蓝型油菜根系突变体lrn1、prl1和野生型根系显微结构的差异

油菜外源细胞分裂素不敏感突变体lrn1和prl1表现为磷高效。营养液培养0.2μmol/L细胞分裂素(6-BA)处理,与甘蓝型油菜野生型‘宁油7号’(WT)相比,突变体lrn1侧根较多,prl1主根较长。本研究利用体式显微技术、非切片压片法以及石蜡切片等技术,对3个基因型在ddH2O和0.2μmol/L 6-BA处理下的根毛、根表皮细胞分化及根尖解剖结构的差异进行了观察,结果表明:ddH2O处理,种子发芽后第1、3、6、9 d,lrn1、prl1和WT根尖成熟区根毛较少。0.2μmol/L 6-BA处理,种子发芽后第3 d,lrn1、prl1和WT根尖形成大量根毛,其中WT根毛最多、密度最大;prl1根毛最少,密度也最小;lrn1处于两者之间。种子发芽后第6 d,lrn1、prl1和WT分生区和伸长区明显缩短,lrn1和prl1分生区面积无显著差异,但两者均显著大于WT;lrn1和prl1根冠细胞结构较正常,而WT根冠细胞结构畸形;lrn1皮层原细胞之间排列较WT和prl1紧密。种子发芽后第9 d,lrn1已有4条侧根,但prl1与WT无侧根形成。6-BA处理,prl1主根较长,与其根尖分生区面积较大密切相关;lrn1侧根较多,可能与中柱原细胞排列密度较高密切相关。     

Primary Root Growth and the Pattern of Root Apical Meristem Organization are Coupled

Root apical meristems (RAMs) in dicotyledonous plants have two organizational schemes; closed (with highly organized tiers) and open (tiers lacking or disorganized). These schemes are commonly believed to remain unchanged during the growth of the root axis. Individual roots are commonly thought to have indeterminate growth. We challenge these two generalizations through the study of five species with closed apical organization: Clarkia unguiculata L., Oxalis corniculata L., Dianthus caryophyllus L., Blumenbachia hieronymi Urb., and Salvia farinaceae Benth. cv. Strata. These roots have phased growth patterns where early growth is followed by deceleration, after which the initial cells stop dividing, elongation ceases, and the root reaches its determinate length. At or before reaching determinacy, the root apical meristem stops maintaining its closed organization and becomes less organized. These observations will be placed in context with observations from the literature to suggest two new generalizations, namely, that apical organization does change over the growth phases of roots, and that roots are determinate.     

Morphogenetic Effect of the Herbicide Cinch on Arabidopsis thaliana Root Development

Cinch is a morphogenetically active herbicide that inhibits primary root growth and induces abnormal ``nodule-like' lateral roots on Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings. Using 200 nm Cinch, the early stages of lateral root formation occurred along the apical half of the root axis; but once emerged, they were inhibited from further growth. Second-order lateral roots formed at the base of stunted first-order lateral roots after 5 days of Cinch treatment. Results from Cinch experiments suggested that pericycle cells are determined in the meristem to be potential sites of lateral root formation, and the developmental transition point between emerged lateral roots and subsequent growth is inhibited. Results using 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid and 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid suggest that Cinch is not a chemical analog of auxin. Received August 8, 1997; accepted February 23, 1998     

The possible action mechanisms of indole-3-acetic acid methyl ester in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis>

We previously reported that Arabidopsis indole-3-acetic acid (IAA)-methyltransferase-1 (IAMT1) catalyzes the conversion of IAA, an essential phytohormone, to methyl-IAA (MeIAA) and that IAMT1 plays an important role in leaf development. Here, we present the possible mechanisms of action of MeIAA in Arabidopsis. We showed that MeIAA was more potent than IAA in the inhibition of hypocotyl elongation and that MeIAA and naphthalene-acetic acid (NAA), but not IAA, rescued the hypocotyl gravitropic defects in dark-grown aux1. However, MeIAA was less potent than IAA in the inhibition of primary root elongation in light-grown seedlings, and could not rescue the agravitropic root phenotype of aux1. MeIAA had a stronger capacity to induce lateral roots than both IAA and NAA and rescued the defective lateral root phenotype of aux1 seedlings. However, its capacity to induce root hairs was weaker than IAA and NAA and did not rescue the defective root hair phenotype of aux1 seedlings. These data indicate that MeIAA is an inactive form of IAA. The different sensitivities to MeIAA among different organs probably resulted from different expression localization and capacities of a putative MeIAA esterase to convert MeIAA to IAA.     

Constitutive Autophagy in Plant Root Cells

In previous studies, using a membrane-permeable protease inhibitor, E-64d, we showed that autophagy occurs constitutively in the root cells of barley and Arabidopsis. In the present study, a fusion protein composed of the autophagy-related protein AtAtg8 and green fluorescent protein (GFP) was expressed in Arabidopsis to visualize autophagosomes. We first confirmed the presence of autophagosomes with GFP fluorescence in the root cells of seedlings grown on a nutrient-sufficient medium. The number of autophagosomes changed as the root cells grew and differentiated. In cells near the apical meristem, autophagosomes were scarcely found. However, a small but significant number of autophagosomes existed in the elongation zone. More autophagosomes were found in the differentiation zone where cell growth ceases but the cells start to form root hair. In addition, we confirmed that autophagy is activated under starvation conditions in Arabidopsis root cells. When the root tips were cultured in a sucrose-free medium, the number of autophagosomes increased in the elongation and differentiation zones, and a significant number of autophagosomes appeared in cells near the apical meristem. The results suggest that autophagy in plant root cells is involved not only in nutrient recycling under nutrient-limiting conditions but also in cell growth and root hair formation.

Addendum to:

AtATG Genes, Homologs of Yeast Autophagy Genes, are Involved in Constitutive Autophagy in Arabidopsis Root Tip Cells

Y. Inoue, T. Suzuki, M. Hattori, K. Yoshimoto, Y. Ohsumi and Y. Moriyasu

Plant Cell Physiol 2006; 47:1641-52