Measurements in vivo of parameters pertinent to ROS/RNS using EPR spectroscopy

The technique of in vivo EPR spectroscopy can provide useful and even unique information pertinent to the study of oxygen/ nitrogen radicals and related processes. The parameters that can be measured include: (a) Oxygen centered radicals (by spin trapping); (b) carbon centered radicals (by spin trapping and sometimes by direct observation); (c) sulfur centered radicals (by spin trapping and sometimes by direct observation); (d) nitric oxide (by spin trapping); (e) oxygen (using oxygen sensitive paramagnetic materials); (f) redox state (using metabolism of nitroxides); (g) thiol groups (using special nitroxides); (h) pH (using special nitroxides); (h) perfusion (using washout of paramagnetic tracers); (i) some redox active metal ions (chromium, manganese). The current state of the art for these and other measurements is discussed, especially in relationship to experiments that are likely to be useful for studies of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and/or reactive nitrogen species (RNS).     

Protein oxidative damage and redox imbalance induced by ionising radiation in CHO cells

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are important mediators of the cytotoxicity induced by the direct reaction of ionising radiation (IR) with all critical cellular components, such as proteins, lipids, and nucleic acids. The derived oxidative damage may propagate in exposed tissues in a dose- and spatiotemporal dependent manner to other cell compartments, affecting intracellular signalling, and cell fate. To understand how cell damage is induced, we studied the oxidative events occurring immediately after cell irradiation by analysing the fate of IR-derived ROS, the intracellular oxidative damage, and the modification of redox environment accumulating in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) within 1?h after cell irradiation (dose range 0–10?Gy). By using the immuno-spin trapping technique (IST), spectrophotometric methods, and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, we showed that IR-derived ROS (i) induced an IST-detectable, antioxidant-inhibitable one-electron oxidation of specific intracellular proteins; (ii) altered the glutathione (GSH) content (which was found to increase below 2?Gy, and decrease at higher doses, leading to a redox imbalance); (iii) decreased glutathione peroxidase and glutaredoxin activity; (iv) modified neither glutathione reductase nor thioredoxin reductase activity; (v) were detected by spin trapping technique, but adduct intensity decreased due to cell competition for ROS; and (vi) induced no EPR-detectable radicals assignable to oxidised cellular components. In conclusion, our results showed that IR generated an early high oxidising potential (protein radical intermediates, redox imbalance, modified redox enzyme activity) in irradiated cells potentially able to propagate the damage and induce oxidative modification of secondary targets.     

Detection and characterisation of radicals in biological materials using EPR methodology

Background

Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy (also known as electron spin resonance, ESR, spectroscopy) is widely considered to be the “gold standard” for the detection and characterisation of radicals in biological systems.

Scope of review

The article reviews the major positive and negative aspects of EPR spectroscopy and discusses how this technique and associated methodologies can be used to maximise useful information, and minimise artefacts, when used in biological studies. Consideration is given to the direct detection of radicals (at both ambient and low temperature), the use of spin trapping and spin scavenging (e.g. reaction with hydroxylamines), the detection of nitric oxide and the detection and quantification of some transition metal ions (particularly iron and copper) and their environment.

Major conclusions

When used with care this technique can provide a wealth of valuable information on the presence of radicals and some transition metal ions in biological systems. It can provide definitive information on the identity of the species present and also information on their concentration, structure, mobility and interactions. It is however a technique that has major limitations and the user needs to understand the various pitfalls and shortcoming of the method to avoid making errors.

General significance

EPR remains the most definitive method of identifying radicals in complex systems and is also a valuable method of examining radical kinetics, concentrations and structure. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Current methods to study reactive oxygen species — pros and cons and biophysics of membrane proteins. Guest Editor: Christine Winterbourn.     

Identification and quantification of free radicals during myocardial ischemia and reperfusion using electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy

There is general agreement that free radicals are involved in reperfusion injury. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy can be considered as the more suitable technique to directly measure and characterize free radical generation during myocardial ischemia and reperfusion. There are essentially two approaches used in the detection of unstable reactive species: freezing technique and spin traps. The detection of secondary free radicals or ascorbyl free radicals during reperfusion might provide an index of oxidative stress. Spin trapping can also characterize nitric oxide. EPR spectroscopy can provide important data regarding redox state and free radical metabolism but ideally, the spin traps must not interfere with cell or organism function.     

Nitroxides prevent exacerbation of indomethacin-induced gastric damage in adjuvant arthritis rats

Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs are the drugs of choice in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) because of their rapid analgesic effect. However, they induce severe gastric damage in RA patients and animals by a process mediated by reactive oxygen species (ROS). Nitroxides (nitroxyl radicals) are widely used as imaging agents and antioxidants to explore the role of ROS generation in the pathogenesis of disease. In this study, the effectiveness of the newly synthesized nitroxides 8-aza-7,7,9,9-tetramethyl-1,4-dioxaspiro[4.5]undecan-8-oxyl (compound 1) and 4-oxo-2,2,6,6-tetraethylpiperidine-1-oxyl (compound 2) in the prevention of gastric ulcers in adjuvant arthritis rats treated with indomethacin was evaluated by monitoring the reaction of reactive oxygen species in gastric tissue with Overhauser-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (OMRI). Pretreatment with all tested nitroxides suppressed the ulcers induced by indomethacin treatment in arthritic rats. OMRI using compounds 1 and 2 as well as 4-hydroxy-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPOL) demonstrated a redox imbalance in the stomach of these rats. Lipid peroxide and interleukin (IL)-1β levels in the gastric mucosa were significantly suppressed by compound 1 and TEMPOL, whereas CINC/gro, a member of the IL-8 family, was significantly suppressed by compound 1 only. These results suggest that the preventive effects of nitroxides on gastric ulcers may operate by different mechanisms.     

UV-induced free radicals in the skin detected by ESR spectroscopy and imaging using nitroxides

Reactive free radicals and reactive oxygen species (ROS) induced by ultraviolet irradiation in human skin are strongly involved in the occurrence of skin damages like aging and cancer. In the present work an ex vivo method for the detection of free radicals/ROS in human skin biopsies during UV irradiation is presented. This method is based on the Electron Spin Resonance (ESR) spectroscopy and imaging and uses the radical trapping properties of nitroxides. The nitroxides 2,2,6,6-Tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO), 3-Carbamoyl-2,2,5,5-tetramethylpyrrolidine-1-oxyl (PCM), and 3-Carboxy-2,2,5,5-tetramethylpyrrolidine-1-oxyl (PCA), were investigated for their applicability of trapping reactive free radicals and reactive oxygen species in skin during UV irradiation. As a result of the trapping process the nitroxides were reduced to the EPR silent hydroxylamins. The reduction rate of TEMPO was due to both the UV radiation and the enzymatic activity of the skin. The nitroxides PCM and PCA are sufficiently stable in the skin and are solely reduced by UV-generated free radicals/ROS. The nitroxide PCA was used for imaging the spatial distribution of UV-generated free radicals/ROS. As a result of the homogeneous distribution of PCA in the skin, it was possible to estimate the penetration of UVA and UVB irradiation: The UV irradiation decreased the PCA intensity corresponding to its irradiance and penetration into the skin. This reduction was shown to be caused mainly by UVA radiation (320-400 nm).     

Kinetic analysis-based quantitation of free radical generation in EPR spin trapping

Because short-lived reactive oxygen radicals such as superoxide have been implicated in a variety of disease processes, methods to measure their production quantitatively in biological systems are critical for understanding disease pathophysiology. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spin trapping is a direct and sensitive technique that has been used to study radical formation in biological systems. Short-lived oxygen free radicals react with the spin trap and produce paramagnetic adducts with much higher stability than that of the free radicals. In many cases, the quantity of the measured adduct is considered to be an adequate measure of the amount of the free radical generated. Although the intensity of the EPR signal reflects the magnitude of free radical generation, the actual quantity of radicals produced may be different due to modulation of the spin adduct kinetics caused by a variety of factors. Because the kinetics of spin trapping in biochemical and cellular systems is a complex process that is altered by the biochemical and cellular environment, it is not always possible to define all of the reactions that occur and the related kinetic parameters of the spin-trapping process. We present a method based on a combination of measured kinetic data for the formation and decay of the spin adduct alone with the parameters that control the kinetics of spin trapping and radical generation. The method is applied to quantitate superoxide trapping with 5-diethoxyphosphoryl-5-methyl-1-pyrroline N-oxide (DEPMPO). In principle, this method is broadly applicable to enable spin trapping-based quantitative determination of free radical generation in complex biological systems.     

Sensitivity of Ca2+ Transport of Mitochondria to Reactive Oxygen Species

The relationship between Ca²⁺ transport and energy transduction of myocardial mitochondria in the presence of reactive oxygen species was investigated. Following treatment with oxygen free radicals [superoxide(O ₂ ) or hydroxyl radical ()OH], lipid free radicals in myocardial mitochondrial membrane could be detected by using the method of EPR spin trap. Simultaneously there were obvious alterations in the free Ca²⁺ ([Ca²⁺]_m) in the mitochondrial matrix; the physical state of membrane lipid; the efficiency of oxidative phosphorylation (ADP/O); the value of the respiratory control ratio (RCR); and the membrane potential of the inner membrane of myocardial mitochondria. If the concentrations of reactive oxygen species were reduced by about 30%, the alterations in the physical state of the membrane lipid and energy transduction of myocardial mitochondria were not observed, but the changes in Ca²⁺ homeostasis remained. We conclude that Ca²⁺ transport by myocardial mitochondria is more sensitive to agents such as (O ₂ ) or OH, etc. than are oxidation phosphorylation and the respiratory chain.     

Metabolic activation of sulfur mustard leads to oxygen free radical formation

We recently published electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spin trapping results that demonstrated the enzymatic reduction of sulfur mustard sulfonium ions to carbon-based free radicals using an in vitro system containing sulfur mustard, cytochrome P450 reductase, NADPH, and the spin trap α-(4-pyridyl-1-oxide)-N-tert-butylnitrone (4-POBN) in buffer (A.A. Brimfield et al., 2009, Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 234:128-134). Carbon-based radicals have been shown to reduce molecular oxygen to form superoxide and, subsequently, peroxyl and hydroxyl radicals. In some cases, such as with the herbicide paraquat, a cyclic redox system results, leading to magnified oxygen free radical concentration and sustained tissue damage. Low mustard carbon radical concentrations recorded by EPR in our in vitro system, despite a robust (4.0mM) sulfur mustard starting concentration, led us to believe a similar oxygen reduction and redox cycling process might be involved with sulfur mustard. A comparison of the rate of mustard radical-POBN adduct formation in our in vitro system by EPR at atmospheric and reduced oxygen levels indicated a sixfold increase in 4-POBN adduct formation (0.5 to 3.0 μM) at the reduced oxygen concentration. That result suggested competition between oxygen and POBN for the available carbon-based mustard radicals. In parallel experiments we found that the oxygen radical-specific spin trap 5-tert-butoxycarbonyl-5-methylpyrroline-N-oxide (BMPO) detected peroxyl and hydroxyl radicals directly when it was used in place of POBN in the in vitro system. Presumably these radicals originated from O(2) reduced by carbon-based mustard radicals. We also showed that reactive oxygen species (ROS)-BMPO EPR signals were reduced or eliminated when mustard carbon radical production was impeded by systematically removing system components, indicating that carbon radicals were a necessary precursor to ROS production. ROS EPR signals were completely eliminated when superoxide dismutase and catalase were included in the complete in vitro enzymatic system, providing additional proof of oxygen radical participation. The redox cycling hypothesis was supported by density functional theory calculations and frontier molecular orbital analysis.     

Quinolinic acid — Iron(II) complexes: Slow autoxidation,but enhanced hydroxyl radical production in the Fenton reaction

Quinolinate (pyridine-2,3-dicarboxylic acid, Quin) is a neurotoxic tryptophan metabolite produced mainly by immune-activated macrophages. It is implicated in the pathogenesis of several brain disorders including HIV-associated dementia. Previous evidence suggests that Quin may exert its neurotoxic effects not only as an agonist on the NMDA subtype of glutamate receptor, but also by a receptor-independent mechanism. In this study we address ability of ferrous quinolinate chelates to generate reactive oxygen species. Autoxidation of Quin-Fe(II) complexes, followed in Hepes buffer at pH 7.4 using ferrozine as the Fe(II) detector, was found to be markedly slower in comparison with iron unchelated or complexed to citrate or ADP. The rate of Quin-Fe(II) autoxidation depends on pH (squared hydroxide anion concentration), is catalyzed by inorganic phosphate, and in both Hepes and phosphate buffers inversely depends on Quin concentration. These observations can be explained in terms of anion catalysis of hexaaquairon(II) autoxidation, acting mainly on the unchelated or partially chelated pool of iron. In order to follow hydroxyl radical generation in the Fenton chemistry, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spin trapping with 5,5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline-N-oxide (DMPO) was employed. In the mixture consisting of 100 mM DMPO, 0.1 mM Fe(II), and 8.8 mM hydrogen peroxide in phosphate buffer pH 7.4, 0.5 mM Quin approximately doubled the yield of DMPO-OH adduct, and higher Quin concentration increased the spin adduct signal even more. When DMPO-OH was pre-formed using Ti³⁺/hydrogen peroxide followed by peroxide removal with catalase, only addition of Quin-Fe(II), but not Fe(II), Fe(III), or Quin-Fe(III), significantly promoted decomposition of pre-formed DMPO-OH. Furthermore, reaction of Quin-Fe(II) with hydrogen peroxide leads to initial iron oxidation followed by appearance of iron redox cycling, detected as slow accumulation of ferrous ferrozine complex. This phenomenon cannot be abolished by subsequent addition of catalase. Thus, we propose that redox cycling of iron by a Quin derivative, formed by initial attack of hydroxyl radicals on Quin, rather than effects of iron complexes on DMPO-OH stability or redox cycling by hydrogen peroxide, is responsible for enhanced DMPO-OH signal in the presence of Quin. The present observations suggest that Quin-Fe(II) complexes display significant pro-oxidant characteristics that could have implications for Quin neurotoxicity.     

Production of nitric oxide-derived reactive nitrogen species in human oral cavity and their scavenging by salivary redox components

Nitrite is reduced to nitric oxide (NO) in the oral cavity. The NO generated can react with molecular oxygen producing reactive nitrogen species. In this study, reduction of nitrite to NO was observed in bacterial fractions of saliva and whole saliva. Formation of reactive nitrogen species from NO was detected by measuring the transformation of 4,5-diaminofluorescein (DAF-2) to triazolfluorescein (DAF-2T). The transformation was fast in bacterial fractions but slow in whole saliva. Salivary components such as ascorbate, glutathione, uric acid and thiocyanate inhibited the transformation of DAF-2 to DAF-2T in bacterial fractions without affecting nitrite-dependent NO production. The inhibition was deduced to be due to scavenging of reactive nitrogen species, which were formed from NO, by the above reagents. The transformation of DAF-2 to DAF-2T was faster in bacterial fractions and whole saliva which were prepared 1–4?h after tooth brushing than those prepared immediately after toothbrushing. Increase in the rate as a function of time after toothbrushing seemed to be due to the increase in population of bacteria which could reduce nitrite to NO. The results obtained in this study suggest that reactive nitrogen species derived from NO are continuously formed in the oral cavity and that the reactive nitrogen species are effectively scavenged by salivary redox components in saliva but the scavenging is not complete.     

Production of nitric oxide-derived reactive nitrogen species in human oral cavity and their scavenging by salivary redox components

Nitrite is reduced to nitric oxide (NO) in the oral cavity. The NO generated can react with molecular oxygen producing reactive nitrogen species. In this study, reduction of nitrite to NO was observed in bacterial fractions of saliva and whole saliva. Formation of reactive nitrogen species from NO was detected by measuring the transformation of 4,5-diaminofluorescein (DAF-2) to triazolfluorescein (DAF-2T). The transformation was fast in bacterial fractions but slow in whole saliva. Salivary components such as ascorbate, glutathione, uric acid and thiocyanate inhibited the transformation of DAF-2 to DAF-2T in bacterial fractions without affecting nitrite-dependent NO production. The inhibition was deduced to be due to scavenging of reactive nitrogen species, which were formed from NO, by the above reagents. The transformation of DAF-2 to DAF-2T was faster in bacterial fractions and whole saliva which were prepared 1-4 h after tooth brushing than those prepared immediately after toothbrushing. Increase in the rate as a function of time after toothbrushing seemed to be due to the increase in population of bacteria which could reduce nitrite to NO. The results obtained in this study suggest that reactive nitrogen species derived from NO are continuously formed in the oral cavity and that the reactive nitrogen species are effectively scavenged by salivary redox components in saliva but the scavenging is not complete.     

活性氮、活性氧及植物激素在种子休眠解除中的作用及相互关系研究进展

休眠是植物种子对环境变化的适应机制,其机理至今未完全清楚阐明。前期对种子休眠机制的研究主要集中在激素调节上,近期的研究结果表明,一氧化氮（nitric oxide,NO）参与打破种子的休眠,并与其所引起的种子中活性氧的变化有关。本文简要综述活性氮（reactive nitrogen species,RNS）、活性氧（reactive oxygen species,R0s）和植物激素在种子休眠解除中的作用及相互关系研究进展。     

The Effect of Oxygen at Physiological Levels on the Detection of free Radical Intermediates by Electron Paramagnetic Resonance

It is well known that oxygen enhances Che relaxation of free radical EPR probes through spin lattice and Heisenberg spin-spin interactions with consequent effect on the line height and width. The two relaxation processes have opposing effects on the signal heights and depend on the concentration of oxygen, the incident microwave power, and the presence of other paramagnetic species. During EPR studies of chemical, biochemical, and cellular processes involving free radicals, molecular oxygen has significant magnetic influence on the EPR signal intensity of the free radical species under investigation in addition to affecting the rates of production of the primary species and the stability of the spin adduct nitroxides. These effects are often overlooked and can cause artifacts and lead to erroneous interpretation. In the present study, the effects of oxygen and ferricyanide on the EPR signal height of stable and persistent spin adduct nitroxides at commonly employed microwave powers were examined. The results show that under commonly adopted EPR spectrometer instrumental conditions, artifactual changes in the EPR signal of spin adducts occur and the best way to avoid them is by keeping the oxygen level constant using a gas-permeable cell.     

Ascorbic acid induced degradation of beta-glucan: Hydroxyl radicals as intermediates studied by spin trapping and electron spin resonance spectroscopy

The formation of hydroxyl radicals in beta-glucan solutions treated with ascorbic acid and iron(II) was demonstrated by ESR spin trapping based methods. Two different spin traps were tested, namely DMPO which is commonly used to detect hydroxyl radicals, and POBN often used to detect carbon centered radicals. The experiments performed showed that the presence of iron(II) with DMPO led to low DMPO-OH adduct stability and further to DMPO dimerization. The level of hydroxyl radicals formed during the beta-glucan radical mediated degradation was evaluated using two ESR spin trapping methods based on the use POBN together with either 2% (v/v) EtOH or DMSO. The addition of ascorbic acid together with iron(II) in beta-glucan solution led to an immediate maximal production of hydroxyl radicals while the presence of ascorbic acid alone led to a progressive production of radical. Further hydroxyl radicals were found to be formed when iron(II) was added alone in beta-glucan solutions. The viscosity loss observed in the three last mentioned beta-glucan solutions were found to relate with the formation of hydroxyl radicals. These data confirm the involvement of hydroxyl radical in the beta-glucan degradation.     

Immuno-spin trapping of DNA radicals

The detection of DNA radicals by immuno-spin trapping (IST) is based on the trapping of radicals with 5,5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline N-oxide (DMPO), forming stable nitrone adducts that are then detected using an anti-DMPO serum. DNA radicals are very reactive species, and because they are paramagnetic they have previously been detected only by electron spin resonance (ESR) with or without spin trapping, which is not available in most bioresearch laboratories. IST combines the simplicity, reliability, specificity and sensitivity of spin trapping with heterogeneous immunoassays for the detection of DNA radicals, and complements existing methods for the measurement of oxidatively generated DNA damage. Here we have used IST to demonstrate that DMPO traps Cu(II)-H(2)O(2)-induced DNA radicals in situ and in real time, forming DMPO-DNA nitrone adducts, but preventing both 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-dG) formation and DNA fragmentation. We also applied IST to detect DNA radicals in rat hepatocytes exposed to Cu(II) and H(2)O(2) under nonlethal conditions.     

氧化还原与细胞凋亡的关联

细胞内氧化还原状态与细胞凋亡相互关联的机理仍然存在很大争议。细胞内氧化还原状态的改变促进了氧自由基(ROS)的产生和凋亡诱导因子的激活,致使细胞凋亡的同时又加剧了细胞内氧化还原状态的改变。通过激活细胞凋亡信号激酶(ASK-1)、氧化还原转录因子NF-κB、AP-1及Caspase激活,揭示了细胞内氧化还原状态伴随细胞凋亡的不同阶段。     

应用ESR检测探讨急性热暴露大鼠肝脏氧化还原状态的动态变化

目的:通过电子顺磁自旋共振技术(ESR)动态观察大鼠在过热条件下肝脏的氧化还原状态.方法:将52只雄性Wistar大鼠随机分成4组:①加温组:麻醉后进行整体加温到直肠温达(43.0±0.5)℃,持续15 min;②对照组:只进行麻醉处理;③,MPG预处理组:用抗氧化剂MPG预处理后,再进行与上述①同样条件的加温处理;④非MPG预处理组:在③中用生理盐水代替MPG.经过以上处理后在不同时间点取肝脏制备组织匀浆,测定ESR波谱.结果:与对照组比较,加温组热暴露处理后记录的ESR波谱振幅-时间直线斜率增大,2 h达最大值.以后逐渐恢复,24 h接近对照组水平.经抗氧化剂预处理上述反应减弱.结论:过热能诱导肝脏产生活性氧,增强其氧化还原反应.     

Concomitant reduction of matrix metalloproteinase-2 secretion and intracellular reactive oxygen species following anti-sense inhibition of telomerase activity in PC-3 prostate carcinoma cells

Background: The level of activity of the telomerase has been shown to correlate with the degree of invasiveness in several tumor types. In addition, cellular redox state is believed to regulate the secretion of matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2).Aims: To determine the effect of anti-sense telomerase treatment of prostate cancer cells on MMP-2 activity, and the reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (two effectors of cellular redox state).Methods: Anti-sense oligonucleotide against RNA component of human telomerase (hTR) was introduced into the cells using Fugene-6 transfection reagent. The activity of telomerase was assessed using Telomere Repeat Amplification Protocol (TRAP assay). Activity of matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2) was determined by zymography. Levels of intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) and nitric oxide metabolites were measured by dichlorofluorescein diacetate (DCFH-DA) staining and Griess reagent, respectively. The level of apoptosis was determined using TUNEL assay.Results: TRAP assay showed more than 90% inhibition of telomerase activity after 72 h of transfection. Pro-MMP-2 activity was decreased down to 50% of the control levels. Intracellular reactive oxygen species were also significantly decreased. Neither apoptosis rate nor the level of nitric oxide metabolites was significantly different between anti-sense treated and control cells.Conclusions: Concomitant reduction of the pro-MMP-2 secretion and ROS in PC-3 cells following hTR inhibition suggests that over-activity of telomerase in cancer cells might increase the level of matrix metalloproteinase-2 and thus, be directly involved in the invasion process through enhancement of intracellular oxidative stress.     

Redox signaling

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) have recently been shown to be involved in a multiplicity of physiological responses through modulation of signaling pathways. Some of the specific signaling components altered by reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (RONS) have begun to be identified. We will discuss RONS signaling by detailing the chemistry of signaling, the roles of antioxidant enzymes as signaling components, thiol chemistry in the specificity of RONS signaling, NO-heme interactions, and some do's and don'ts of redox signal research. The principal points raised are that: (1) as with classic signaling pathways, signaling by RONS is regulated; (2) antioxidant enzymes are essential 'turn-off' components in signaling; (3) spatial relationships are probably more important in RONS signaling than the overall 'redox state' of the cell; (4) deprotonation of cysteines to form the thiolate, which can react with RONS, occurs in specific protein sites providing specificity in signaling; (5) although multiple chemical mechanisms exist for producing nitrosothiols, their formation in vivo remains unclear; and (6) caution should be taken in the use of 'antioxidants' in signal transduction.