Discovery of a new fragrance allele and the development of functional markers for the breeding of fragrant rice varieties

The recessive fgr gene on chromosome 8 is associated with rice fragrance. It has been reported that this gene is a non-functional badh2 allele and that the functional Badh2 allele encoding putative betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase (BADH2) could render rice non-fragrant. Here we report the discovery of a new badh2 allele and the development of functional markers for the badh2 locus. A total of 24 fragrant and ten non-fragrant rice varieties were studied and sequenced for their Badh2/badh2 loci. Of the 24 fragrant rice varieties, 12 were found to have the known badh2 allele (badh2-E7), which has an 8-bp deletion and three single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in exon 7; the others had a novel null badh2 allele (badh2-E2), which has a sequence identical to that of the Badh2 allele in exon 7, but with a 7-bp deletion in exon 2. Both null badh2 alleles are responsible for rice fragrance. Based on sequence divergence amongst the functional Badh2 and two null badh2 alleles, we developed functional markers which can be easily used to distinguish non-fragrant from fragrant rice and to differentiate between two kinds of fragrant rice. These functional markers will find their usefulness in breeding for fragrant rice varieties via marker-assisted selection. Weiwei Shi and Yi Yang contributed equally to this work.     

Development of a simple functional marker for fragrance in rice and its validation in Indian Basmati and non-Basmati fragrant rice varieties

Fragrance development in rice has been reported due to a 8-bp deletion in the exon 7 of badh2 gene located on Chromosome 8S. Multiplex markers targeting the functional InDel polymorphism was earlier reported for genotyping fragrance trait, but the marker was observed to be inconsistent and difficult to use. We have developed a simple, co-dominant, functional marker for fragrance trait, which can be resolved in an agarose gel and validated in Basmati and non-Basmati aromatic rice varieties and in a mapping population segregated for fragrance trait. The marker targets the InDel polymorphism in badh2 gene and amplifies 95 and 103 bp fragments in fragrant and non-fragrant genotypes, respectively. The newly developed marker was highly efficient in discriminating all fragrant and non-fragrant genotypes and showed perfect co-segregation with the trait of fragrance in the mapping population. We recommend the use of this simple, low-cost marker in routine genotyping for fragrance trait in large scale breeding materials and germplasm.     

The genetic origin of fragrance in NERICA1

In this study, we investigated the cause and origin of fragrance in NERICA1, a fragrant rice inbred line developed from an interspecific cross between two non-fragrant parents. The genetic cause of fragrance in NERICA1 was found to be due to a previously reported mutation in the BADH2 gene, the same allele responsible for the majority of modern fragrant rice varieties. Haplotype analysis around the BADH2 gene in NERICA1, its parents, and 95 other varieties carrying the badh2.1 allele identified the source of the badh2.1 allele in NERICA1 was a fragrant tropical japonica variety, WAB638-1, which had been growing in the vicinity of the NERICA1 nursery during varietal development. The allele-specific marker for the badh2.1 allele consistently predicted fragrance in the diverse African germplasm tested, making it very useful for marker-assisted breeding of fragrant rice varieties in Africa.     

Genetic and molecular basis of fragrance in rice

Fragrance or aroma in rice is considered as a special trait with huge economic importance that determines the premium price in global trade. With the availability of molecular maps and genome sequences, a major gene for fragrance (badh2) was identified on chromosome 8. An 8-bp deletion in the exon 7 of this gene was reported to result in truncation of betaine aldehyde dehydrogenease enzyme whose loss-of-function lead to the accumulation of a major aromatic compound, 2-acetyl 1-pyrroline (2AP) in fragrant rice. However, several studies have reported exceptions to this mutation and indicated the involvement of other genetic loci in controlling fragrance trait. These studies emphasize the need to characterize the fragrance and its underlying factors in a wide range of genetic resources available for this trait. This review summarizes the new insights gained on the genetic and molecular understanding of fragrance in rice.     

Identification of microsatellite markers for fragrance in rice by analysis of the rice genome sequence

Several chemical constituents are important to the fragrance of cooked rice. However, the chemical compound 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline (AP) is regarded as the most important component of fragrance in the basmati- and jasmine-style fragrant rices. AP is found in all parts of the plant except the roots. It is believed that a single recessive gene is responsible for the production of fragrance in most rice plants. The detection of fragrance can be carried out via sensory or chemical methods, although each has their disadvantages. To overcome these difficulties, we have identified an (AT)₄₀ repeat microsatellite or simple sequence repeat (SSR) marker for fragrant and non-fragrant alleles of the fgr gene. Identification of this marker was facilitated through use of both the publicly available and restricted access sequence information of the Monsanto rice sequence databases. Fifty F₂ individuals from a mapping population were genotyped for the polymorphic marker. This marker has a high polymorphism information content (PIC = 0.9). Other SSR markers linked to fragrance could be identified in the same way of use in other populations. This study demonstrates that analysis of the rice genome sequence is an effective option for identification of markers for use in rice improvement.     

Discovery of a new fragrance allele and development of functional markers for identifying diverse fragrant genotypes in rice

Discovery of new fragrance alleles provides important genetic resources for breeding fragrant rice. In this study, a hybrid complementation test demonstrated the association of a new fragrance allele without mutation in the coding region with flavor formation in a fragrant rice variety Nankai 138. The new allele (badh2-p-5′UTR) has a 3-bp deletion in the 5′ untranslated region and an 8-bp insertion in the promoter (?1,314 site upstream from the initiation codon). Surprisingly, we found that there is also an 8-bp insertion in the promoter of the badh2-E7 allele. We developed a new sequence tagged site functional marker to identify the badh2-p-5′UTR and badh2-E7 alleles according to the 8-bp insertion in their promoters. A cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (AluI) functional marker targeting a common base substitution in the intron 2 of three badh2 alleles, viz. badh2-p-5′UTR, badh2-E7 and badh2-E2, was developed to identify diverse genotypes for fragrance in rice. Based on the results of sequence alignments among the three badh2 alleles, we suggest that the badh2-E7 and badh2-p-5′UTR alleles may have the same genetic origin. In addition, the genetic distance between the badh2-E7 and badh2-p-5′UTR alleles may be closer than that between the badh2-E2 and the badh2-p-5′UTR alleles, or between the badh2-E2 and the badh2-E7 alleles.     

Characterization of the major fragance gene from an aromatic japonica rice and analysis of its diversity in Asian cultivated rice

In Asian cultivated rice (Oryza sativa L.), aroma is one of the most valuable traits in grain quality and 2-ACP is the main volatile compound contributing to the characteristic popcorn-like odour of aromatic rices. Although the major locus for grain fragrance (frg gene) has been described recently in Basmati rice, this gene has not been characterised in true japonica varieties and molecular information available on the genetic diversity and evolutionary origin of this gene among the different varieties is still limited. Here we report on characterisation of the frg gene in the Azucena variety, one of the few aromatic japonica cultivars. We used a RIL population from a cross between Azucena and IR64, a non-aromatic indica, the reference genomic sequence of Nipponbare (japonica) and 93-11 (indica) as well as an Azucena BAC library, to identify the major fragance gene in Azucena. We thus identified a betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase gene, badh2, as the candidate locus responsible for aroma, which presented exactly the same mutation as that identified in Basmati and Jasmine-like rices. Comparative genomic analyses showed very high sequence conservation between Azucena and Nipponbare BADH2, and a MITE was identified in the promotor region of the BADH2 allele in 93-11. The badh2 mutation and MITE were surveyed in a representative rice collection, including traditional aromatic and non-aromatic rice varieties, and strongly suggested a monophylogenetic origin of this badh2 mutation in Asian cultivated rices. Altogether these new data are discussed here in the light of current hypotheses on the origin of rice genetic diversity.     

Opportunities of marker‐assisted selection for rice fragrance through marker–trait association analysis of microsatellites and gene‐based markers

Developing fragrant rice through marker‐assisted/aided selection (MAS) is an economical and profitable approach worldwide for the enrichment of an elite genetic background with a pleasant aroma. The PCR‐based DNA markers that distinguish the alleles of major fragrance genes in rice have been synthesised to develop rice scent biofortification through MAS. Thus, the present study examined the aroma biofortification potential of these co‐dominant markers in a germplasm panel of 189 F₂ progeny developed from crosses between a non‐aromatic variety (MR84) and a highly aromatic but low‐yielding variety (MRQ74) to determine the most influential diagnostic markers for fragrance biofortification. The SSRs and functional DNA markers RM5633 (on chromosome 4), RM515, RM223, L06, NKSbad2, FMbadh2‐E7, BADEX7‐5, Aro7 and SCU015RM (on chromosome 8) were highly associated with the 2AP (2‐acetyl‐1‐pyrroline) content across the population. The alleles traced via these markers were also in high linkage disequilibrium (R² > 0.70) and explained approximately 12.1, 27.05, 27.05, 27.05, 25.42, 25.42, 20.53, 20.43 and 20.18% of the total phenotypic variation observed for these biomarkers, respectively. F₂ plants harbouring the favourable alleles of these effective markers produced higher levels of fragrance. Hence, these rice plants can be used as donor parents to increase the development of fragrance‐biofortified tropical rice varieties adapted to growing conditions and consumer preferences, thus contributing to the global rice market.     

In-silico analysis of Betaine Aldehyde Dehydrogenase2 of Oryza sativa and significant mutations responsible for fragrance

Abstract

Fragrance in rice plays an important characteristic feature in determining the quality of rice. 2-Acetyl-1-pyrroline (2AP) compound is responsible for the fragrance in rice. Betaine-aldehyde-dehydrogenase2 (BADH2) inhibits the biosynthesis of 2AP in nonfragrant rice by converting γ-aminobutyraldehyde (GAB-ald) to γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA). In fragrant rice, truncated BADH2 results in the accumulation of GAB-ald which then leads to the formation of 2AP. Biochemical and enzymatic studies state that the mutants of BADH2 exhibit lower enzymatic activity toward GAB-ald. In this study, we adopted an in-silico approach to explore the interaction behavior of model structures of native and mutant BADH2 enzyme and a substrate GAB-ald, which is responsible for fragrance in rice. Quantitative structural evaluations and salt bridge analysis were performed to identify the stability of BADH2 enzyme upon mutation. Our investigation states that the mutant forms of BADH2 have subsidiary/decisive catalytic efficiency toward GAB-ald, which was also endorsed with earlier in vivo experimental studies. Due to this, mutant forms of BADH2 were not able to interact with its substrate molecule GAB-ald; thus this phenomenon accumulates GAB-ald, and it leads to the formation of 2AP, which is responsible for the fragrance in the mutant variety. Based on the quantitative and docking analyses, we found that the BADH2 ^N162A was considered to be the most fragrant form. We list here the order of fragrance in rice as BADH2 <BADH2^C294A <BADH2^E260A <BADH2^N162A.     

Haplotype variation at Badh2, the gene determining fragrance in rice

Fragrance is an important component of end-use quality in rice. A set of 516 fragrant rice accessions were genotyped and over 80% of them carried the badh2.7 allele. A subset of 144 mostly fragrant accessions, including nine of Oryza rufipogon, was then subjected to a detailed diversity and haplotype analysis. The level of linkage disequilibrium in the Badh2 region was higher among the fragrant accessions. Re-sequencing in the Badh2 region showed that badh2.7, badh2.2 and badh2.4–5 all arose in the japonica genepool, and spread later into the indica genepool as a result of deliberate crossing. However, loss-of-function alleles of Badh2 are also found in the indica genepools, and then transferred into japonica. Evidence for three new possible FNPs was obtained from the Badh2 sequence of 62 fragrant accessions. Based on these data, we have elaborated a model for the evolution of Badh2 and its participation in the rice domestication process.     

Development of Molecular Markers Used to Identify Two Types of Fragrant Rice and Analysis of Mutation Sites of BADH2 Gene in 24 Varieties of Fragrant Rice

Functional molecular markers M7 and M2 have been developed based on the DNA sequence differences of badh2 between fragrant rice varieties and non fragrant varieties in intron2, intron 4, exon7 and exon 2 respectively. PCR analyses on genome DNA of exon7 mutated fragrant rice Wxiang 99075, exon2 mutated fragrant rice Wuxiang14,non fragrant rice 261S and the F1 plants by M7 and M2 showed that M7 and M2 could be absolutely used to the molecular marker assisted rice breeding experiments when exon7 mutated and exon2 mutated fragrant rice varieties are used as parents. The design of M7 primers took mutations both in exons and intrones into account. Moreover, taking 261S,Wxiang 99075 and Wuxiang14 as controls, the mutation sites of badh2 in 22 fragrant rice varieties were analyzed, it was showed that fragrant rice varieties could be classified into 3 types: exon 2 mutated fragrant rice, exon 7 mutated fragrant rice and non exon mutated fragrant rice. At the same time, the mutation sites of badh2 in the main fragrant rice varieties which are grown in Shanghai and the surrounding areas have been verified. This research laid an important foundation for molecular marker assisted selection for novel fragrant rice.     

Biochemical and Enzymatic Study of Rice BADH Wild-Type and Mutants: An Insight into Fragrance in Rice

Betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase 2 (BADH2) is believed to be involved in the accumulation of 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline (2AP), one of the major aromatic compounds in fragrant rice. The enzyme can oxidize ω-aminoaldehydes to the corresponding ω-amino acids. This study was carried out to investigate the function of wild-type BADHs and four BADH2 mutants: BADH2_Y420, containing a Y420 insertion similar to BADH2.8 in Myanmar fragrance rice, BADH2_C294A, BADH2_E260A and BADH2_N162A, consisting of a single catalytic-residue mutation. Our results showed that the BADH2_Y420 mutant exhibited less catalytic efficiency towards γ-aminobutyraldehyde but greater efficiency towards betaine aldehyde than wild-type. We hypothesized that this point mutation may account for the accumulation of γ-aminobutyraldehyde/Δ¹-pyrroline prior to conversion to 2AP, generating fragrance in Myanmar rice. In addition, the three catalytic-residue mutants confirmed that residues C294, E260 and N162 were involved in the catalytic activity of BADH2 similar to those of other BADHs.     

A SNP in GmBADH2 gene associates with fragrance in vegetable soybean variety ��Kaori�� and SNAP marker development for the fragrance

Fragrance in soybean is due to the presence of 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline (2AP). BADH2 gene coding for betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase has been identified as the candidate gene responsible for fragrance in rice (Oryza sativa L.). In this study, using the RIL population derived from fragrant soybean cultivar "Kaori" and non-fragrant soybean cultivar "Chiang Mai 60" (CM60), STS markers designed from BADH2 homolog were found associating with 2AP production. Genetic mapping demonstrated that QTL position of fragrance and 2AP production coincides with the position of GmBADH2 (Glycine max betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase 2). Sequence comparison of GmBADH2 between Kaori and non-fragrant soybeans revealed non-synonymous single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) in exon 10. Nucleotide substitution of G to A in the exon results in an amino acid change of glycine (GGC; G) to aspartic acid (GAC; D) in Kaori. The amino acid substitution changes the conserved EGCRLGPIVS motif of GmBADH2, which is essential for functional activity of GmBADH2 protein, to EGCRLDPIVS motif, suggesting that the SNP in GmBADH2 is responsible for the fragrance in Kaori. Five single nucleotide-amplified polymorphism (SNAP) markers which are PCR-based allele specific SNP markers were developed for fragrance based on the SNP in GmBADH2. Two markers specific to A allele produced a band in only Kaori, while three markers specific to G alleles produced a band in only CM60. The simple PCR-based allele specific SNAP markers developed in the present study are useful in marker-assisted breeding of fragrant soybean.     

Identification of a new fragrance allele in soybean and development of its functional marker

We have previously reported an association between a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) in exon 10 of GmBADH2 gene and fragrance in vegetable soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] cultivar Kaori. The SNP causes amino acid substitution in a highly conserved motif of GmBADH2 protein, which is necessary for functional activity of the protein. In this study, we sequenced GmBADH2 in another fragrant soybean cultivar Chamame and discovered a new fragrance allele, which has a 2-bp (TT) deletion in exon 10. The deletion causes a reading frame shift and introduces a premature stop codon, which could abolish protein function and result in fragrance. The old and new fragrance-promoting alleles were designated Gmbadh2-1 and Gmbadh2-2, respectively. A simple and co-dominant functional marker was developed for genotyping Gmbadh2-2. The marker can discriminate between fragrant and non-fragrant soybeans and distinguish the two different fragrant soybeans, and thus is useful for routine genotyping for the fragrance trait in breeding programs. Quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping in an F₂ population using Chamame as the fragrance donor revealed that the location of the fragrance QTL nearly coincided with that of the functional marker, confirming the association between GmBADH2 and fragrance in Chamame.     

Gene discovery and functional marker development for fragrance in sorghum (Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench)

Key message

Sequence analysis and genetic mapping revealed that a 1,444 bp deletion causes a premature stop codon in SbBADH2 of sorghum IS19912. The non-function of SbBADH2 is responsible for fragrance in sorghum IS19912.

Abstract

2-acetyl-1-pyrroline (2AP) is a potent volatile compound causing fragrance in several plants and foods. Seeds of some varieties of rice, sorghum and soybean possess fragrance. The genes responsible for fragrance in rice and soybean are orthologs that correspond to betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase 2 (BADH2). Genotypes harboring fragrance in rice and soybean contain a premature stop codon in BADH2 which impairs the synthesis of full length functional BADH2 protein leading to the accumulation of 2AP. In this study, we reported an association between the BADH2 gene and fragrance in sorghum. An F₂ population of 187 plants developed from a cross between KU630 (non-fragrant) and IS19912 (fragrant) was used. Leaves of F₂ and F₃ progenies were evaluated for fragrance by organoleptic test, while seeds of F₂ plants were analyzed for 2AP. The tests consistently showed that the fragrance is controlled by a single recessive gene. Gene expression analysis of SbBADH1 and SbBADH2 in leaves of KU630 and IS19912 at various stages revealed that SbBADH1 and SbBADH2 were expressed in both accessions. Sequence comparison between KU630 and IS19912 revealed a continuous 1,444 bp deletion encompassing exon 12 to 15 of SbBADH2 in IS19912 which introduces a frameshift mutation and thus causes a premature stop codon. An indel marker was developed to detect polymorphism in SbBADH2. Bulk segregant and QTL analyses confirmed the association between SbBADH2 and fragrance.     

Is there a second fragrance gene in rice?

Aromatic rice is highly prized by most rice consumers, and many countries cultivate traditional and improved aromatic varieties. 2-Acetyl-1-pyrroline (2AP) is the major aromatic compound in rice, and is believed to accumulate because of an eight-base-pair (8-bp) deletion in an allele at the fragrance locus. In this study, 2AP was quantified and the presence or absence of the fragrance allele ( fgr ) was determined in 464 samples of traditional varieties of rice from the T.T. Chang Genetic Resources Centre at the International Rice Research Institute. It was shown that a number of aromatic varieties, primarily from South and South-East Asia, do not carry the 8-bp deletion, but 2AP was identified in both raw and cooked rice of these varieties. We suggest that the 8-bp deletion in fgr is not the only cause of aroma, and at least one other mutation drives the accumulation of 2AP. The amount of 2AP in most uniform fgr genotypes was not significantly different from that in aromatic n fgr genotypes, but several fgr genotypes, primarily from South Asia, reproducibly accumulated exceptionally large amounts of 2AP. We suggest that the mutation leading to 2AP in aromatic n fgr varieties possibly originated several times and, through either domestication or evolution, the fgr gene and other alleles leading to 2AP have combined in South Asia, leading to several highly aromatic traditional varieties. The identification of multiple mutations for 2AP will enable rice breeding programmes to select actively for multiple genetic sources of 2AP, leading to the development of highly aromatic and, consequently, high-quality varieties of rice.     

水稻米香基因的遗传分析与精细定位

香味是水稻重要的品质性状之一,由100多种挥发性化合物组成,其中2-乙酰基-1-吡咯啉（2AP）是稻米香气中最主要的成分,且由一对隐性基因（fgr）控制,fgr基因位于水稻第八号染色体上。本研究根据初定位结果,利用籼粳稻基因组序列在RG1／RG28区域内发展高密度的分子标记,结合大分离群体来定位水稻的米香基因。结果显示,fgr基因位于第八条染色体的WJ-7和WJ-8分子标记之间约408kb的区间内。这一结果将对于水稻米香基因的克隆与分离提供了重要依据。     

Characterization of fragrance in sorghum (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Sorghum bicolor</Emphasis> (L.) Moench) grain and development of a gene-based marker for selection in breeding

Fragrance is one of the most important and valued quality characters in sorghum and other foods and attracts a premium price in local and global trade. The allele of the SbBADH2 gene in fragrant sorghum cultivar E228 was characterized. A 1441 bp deletion extending from exon 13 to 15 was found rather than a deletion from exon 12 to 15 as had been reported earlier. This allowed the development and validation of a new perfect PCR-based marker for identification of fragrant sorghum accessions in breeding. The concentration of 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline (2AP) in the grain of this cultivar was estimated to be 6.5 ± 0.4 ppb using headspace solid-phase microextraction (HS-SPME) coupled with GC-MS. Flavor components of fragrant sorghum accession E228 (IC 568489) were analyzed and compared with the non-fragrant M35-1 cultivar. PCA analysis revealed that 2AP, benzothiazole, 2,3,5-trimethylpyridine, (1E)-1-ethylidene-1H-indene, cedrene, 2,4-bis(2-methyl-2-propanyl)phenol, 2-hexyl-1-octanol, and 2-butyl-1-octanol were among 25 compounds that were found in sorghum grain that may be contributing toward the aroma of fragrant sorghum. Proline and methylglyoxal contents were found to be higher in E228 than in M35-1, while SbBADH2 expression in E228 was half that in M35-1, suggesting a similar 2AP biosynthetic mechanism to that found in fragrant rice and soybean.