Suppressive effect of human natural killer cells on Epstein-Barr virus-induced immunoglobulin synthesis

The suppressive effect of human natural killer (NK) cells on Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-induced immunoglobulin (Ig) synthesis by autologous B cells was investigated. By Percoll discontinuous density gradient centrifugation, low-density fractions enriched for NK cells were isolated from human peripheral blood lymphocytes. These NK-enriched fractions were added to purified autologous B cells in the presence of EBV, were cultivated for 8 days, and were examined for their suppressive effect on Ig synthesis by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The fractions markedly suppressed both IgM and IgG synthesis induced by EBV. It was possible to reduce the suppressive effect of NK-enriched cells by complement-dependent lysis of NK cells and Leu-11, but not by OKT3 monoclonal antibody, indicating that NK cells may be responsible for the suppression of Ig synthesis. Upon close examination of interferon (IFN) activity, it was revealed that the co-cultures of NK-enriched cells and EBV-infected B cells generated production of IFN-alpha, which might be produced by NK cells in response to EBV-stimulated B cells. Addition of anti-IFN-alpha but not anti-IFN-gamma serum almost completely abrogated the suppressive effect of NK-enriched cells on Ig synthesis, indicating that IFN-alpha produced are required for the NK cell-mediated suppression of Ig synthesis. However, addition of IFN-alpha into purified B cells showed no direct suppressive effect on EBV-induced Ig synthesis by B cells in the absence of NK cells. Nevertheless, NK cells when previously incubated with IFN-alpha and added to B cells showed a suppressor activity on Ig synthesis to a level higher than that of untreated NK controls. These results strongly suggest the possibility that NK cells display an interaction with EBV-infected B cells and produce IFN-alpha, which in turn activates NK cells. These activated NK cells suppress the Ig synthesis by B cells, which undergo transformation induced by EBV.     

Functional analysis of human T cell subsets defined by monoclonal antibodies. III. Regulation of helper factor production by T cell subsets

In the present report we extended our previous studies demonstrating that obligatory T-T interactions are important in regulating human immune responses in vitro. Functionally distinct human T cell subsets were isolated by complement-mediated lysis using the monoclonal antibodies OKT4 and OKT8. Evidence was obtained that during allogeneic interactions, OKT4+, but not OKT8+, responder T cells are required to generate helper factor(s) capable of polyclonally activating human B cells independent of additional T cell help. Importantly, the alloantigen-induced helper factor(s) production and/or release was found to be suppressed by addition of graded numbers of radiosensitive OKT8+ cells. On the other hand, no evidence was obtained that supernatant derived from alloactivated OKT8+ cells could counterbalance the helper activity generated in the presence of supernatant from alloactivated OKT4+ cells. Furthermore, OKT8+ cells, known to suppress PWM-driven B cell differentiation in the presence of OKT4+ cells, do not suppress B cell differentiation induced by preformed helper factor even in the presence of OKT4+ cells. These data further underscore the importance of functional T-T interactions in immunoregulation in vitro and support the idea that the target of suppression of B cell differentiation, induced either by alloantigen-triggered helper factor or PWM, are OKT4+ cells and not B cells themselves.     

Human B cell differentiation. II. Suppression by T cells of T-dependent and T-independent plasma cell maturation.

In vitro human plasma cell generation induced by both T-dependent (PWM) and T-independent (NWSM) mitogens was found to be suppressed by peripheral blood lymphocytes preincubated with human aggregated IgG. T cells, but not B lymphocytes, were able to mediate the suppressive activity; since aggregated (Fab)'2 fragments were found unable to generate suppressor cells, it was concluded that the suppressor cell was a T lymphocyte bearing Fcgamma receptors. These cells appeared to be largely radiosensitive. In most cases the proliferative responses remained unchanged. Since NWSM-induced activation is not dependent on the presence of T cells, these results show that, at least in this case, T cells exert their suppressor function directly on B lymphocytes. Whether PWM-induced B cell differentiation is suppressed by the same mechanism or/and by inactivation of T helper lymphocytes remains under investigation.     

Induction of interferon-gamma production by human natural killer cells stimulated by hydrogen peroxide

Interferon (IFN)-inducing activity of hydrogen peroxide in human peripheral mononuclear cells was investigated. Among the mononuclear cells, purified nonadherent cells produced IFN, but not B cells and monocytes. The maximal titer of IFN by purified nonadherent cells was observed after a 72-hr cultivation in the presence of 10(-2) mM H2O2 without affecting their viability. Furthermore, the purified nonadherent cells, but not the unpurified mononuclear cells, showed an augmented cytotoxicity to K562 when stimulated with hydrogen peroxide. By using Percoll discontinuous density gradient centrifugation, peripheral blood nonphagocytic and nonadherent mononuclear cells were divided into the low and high density fractions for which natural killer (NK) cells and T cells were enriched, respectively. The NK-enriched low density fractions, but not the T cell-enriched high density fractions, showed IFN production by the stimulation of hydrogen peroxide. IFN production as well as large granular lymphocytes and HNK-1+, Leu-11+ cells of the NK-enriched fractions were abrogated by treatment of the cells with monoclonal antibody against human NK cells (HNK-1+) but not against T cells (OKT3) in the presence of complement. Moreover, hydrogen peroxide-inducing IFN production seems to be regulated by monocytes. The antiserum neutralizing IFN-alpha and IFN-beta failed to neutralize substantially IFN-produced NK cells. The treatment with either pH 2 or antiserum-neutralizing human IFN-gamma resulted in marked reduction, indicating that a major part of IFN was IFN-gamma. The purified nonadherent cells showed IFN production and augmented cytotoxicity when cultured separately from activated macrophages by opsonized zymosan; furthermore, both IFN production and enhancement of cytotoxicity were abrogated by catalase. These results suggest that both exogenous and endogenous hydrogen peroxide might be responsible for a part of immunoregulation.     

Functional characterization of T lymphocytes grown in semisolid agar

T lymphocyte colony forming cells (TL-CFC) grown in agar in the presence of PHA were assayed for their capacity to induce or suppress polyclonal PWM dependent B lymphocyte differentiation into plasma cells. This was measured by identifying cells containing intracytoplasmatic immunoglobulins by direct immunofluorescence. To validate the helper and suppressor system used in this paper, the inductive capacity of unfractionated T lymphocytes and their subpopulations bearing Fc-receptors for IgM (TM) and for IgG (TG) was measured. The unfractionated T cells and the TM fraction showed helper activity, whereas the TG cells expressed suppressor activity. The TL-CFC grown in agar in the presence of PHA manifested helper activity at low cell concentration. However, increasing the TL-CFC concentration finally caused suppression of B cell differentiation. The suppressor effect could be abolished by prior irradiation of the TL-CFC before seeding them in agar. These results indicate that T cells grown in agar have the functional capacity of T helper and T suppressor cells to induce and suppress polyclonal PWM dependent B lymphocyte differentiation into plasma cells.     

Modulation of human B cell immunoglobulin secretion by the C3b component of complement

The human C3b component of complement was found to inhibit the differentiation of human B lymphocytes into immunoglobulin-secreting cells in vitro. Pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-induced plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses were inhibited by C3-coated zymosan particles and by purified human C3b. C3b inhibited the PWM-driven responses in a dose-dependent fashion, and it was necessary for C3b to be present in the early phases of the cultures. C3b acted directly on B cells rather than on helper T cells because it inhibited the PFC responses of MNC depleted of T cells and subsequently stimulated with a T cell-independent Epstein Barr virus mitogen. Furthermore, C3b failed to stimulate the generation of suppressor lymphocytes and/or monocytes that might have been responsible for the inhibition of B cell responses. Our results indicate that C3b or its fragments exert negative modulatory effects on human B lymphocyte responses.     

The role of interleukin 2 in inducing Ig production in a pokeweed mitogen-stimulated mononuclear cell system

Cyclosporin A (CsA) has been found previously to block mitogen-stimulated T cell proliferation and production of discrete T cell-derived lymphokines such as interleukin 2 (IL 2) and interferon (IFN)-gamma. In addition, CsA blocks pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-driven T cell-dependent differentiation of B cells into immunoglobulin (Ig)-secreting cells. Recently, we reported that CsA (1 microgram/ml) inhibited PWM-induced T cell production of IL 2 and IFN-gamma, but supernatants retained B cell differentiation factor (BCDF)-like activity. The present study demonstrates the ability of CsA to suppress T cell functions in PWM-driven Ig production in mononuclear cells (MNC), and the capacity of exogenous T cell lymphokines to reverse CsA-induced suppression. CsA profoundly suppressed PWM-driven PFC formation (greater than 95%). However, Ig production was substantially reconstituted by the addition of IL 2 at concentrations of 10 to 50 U/ml. In contrast, no effects were observed by the addition of IFN-gamma or BCGF. The kinetics of CsA inhibition of Ig production and IL 2 secretion were found to be closely related. In addition, to obtain effective reconstitution in the CsA-treated PWM-MNC system it was necessary to add IL 2 at the initiation of culture. T cells themselves were also required for B cell differentiation in this system. However, surface Ig+ cells obtained by cell sorting after 3 days of culture could differentiate in the absence of T cells but only in response to IL 2, not in response to IFN-gamma or BCDF. Thus, in PWM-driven B cell differentiation T cells are necessary early in culture, whereas IL 2 is essential from the initial stage of B cell activation through the final stage of B cell differentiation.     

Asialo-GM1+ natural killer cells directly suppress antibody-producing B cells

Natural killer (NK) cells were tested for their ability to suppress antigen-induced antibody responses in vitro. Asialo-GM1+ (ASGM1+) cells were prepared from nylon-wool-nonadherent spleen cells obtained from normal mice. After depletion of Ig+, L3T4+ and Lyt-2+ cells, the ASGM1+-enriched cell population had high NK activity which was abrogated by treatment with anti-ASGM1 and C'. This NK-enriched ASGM1+ cell fraction significantly suppressed the generation of antibody-producing cells when added to in vitro immunization cultures of primed spleen cells. Treatment of the NK-enriched cell population with anti-ASGM1 and C' abrogated the ability of these cells to suppress antibody responses. In vitro antibody production by purified B cells was also suppressed in the presence of the NK-enriched cell population, although the kinetics of the suppression differed from that observed with unfractionated spleen cells. In addition, the NK-enriched cell population suppressed the proliferation of the B cell line WEHI-279.1. Suppression of WEHI-279.1 cells was abrogated when the NK-enriched cell population was treated with anti-ASGM1 and C'. These results suggest that normal NK cells suppress the generation of antibody-producing B cells and that this occurs, at least in part, through a direct regulation of the B cell.     

Modulation of in vitro myelopoiesis by LGL: different effects on early and late progenitor cells

We describe here the modulatory activity of human peripheral blood natural killer (NK) cells on the growth and differentiation of myeloid progenitor cells at different stages of maturation. NK-enriched cell fractions containing 54 to 75% large granular lymphocytes (LGL) and displaying high levels of NK activity significantly inhibited the growth of late (7 day) granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming cells (CFU-GM) from about 50% of normal human bone marrow samples. However, the same fractions strongly enhanced the growth of early (14 day) stem cells from peripheral blood. Enhancing activity on early CFU-GM from blood was greater in highly purified NK cell preparations containing 96% LGL than in NK-depleted T cell preparations from the same donors. Analogous to the results when using the NK-enriched fractions, the NK-purified preparations inhibited late CFU-GM and stimulated the early ones. We conclude from these observations that human LGL have a modulatory effect on myelopoiesis depending on the maturation stage of the progenitor cell.     

Control of human B lymphocyte responsiveness: enhanced suppressor T cell activity after in vitro incubation.

Human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBM) lost the capacity to generate immunoglobulin-secreting cells (ISC) in response to pokeweed mitogen (PWM) after a period of preincubation in vitro. When fresh PBM were co-cultured with preincubated PBM their response to PWM was inhibited, indicating that enhanced suppressor activity developed in the aged PBM concomitant with the loss of PWM responsiveness. Suppressor cell activity of aged PBM was present within the T lymphocyte population. The suppressor T cell inhibited PWM responsiveness of autologous and homologous PBM to an equivalent degree. The action of the suppressor cell was abrogated by inhibitors of DNA synthesis or by hydrocortisone. A suppressor T cell population with similar characteristics was found in freshly prepared PBM before in vitro incubation. Expansion of this suppressor T cell population during preincubation required cell division. There was no change in the functional capability of the helper T cell population as a result of similar in vitro culture. These observations indicate that a T cell population capable of suppressing PWM-induced generation of ISC can be selectively expanded by in vitro incubation of normal human PBM without additional mitogenic stimulation. Moreover, these data emphasize that control of B lymphocyte differentiation involves a critical interrelationship between T lymphocyte subpopulations exerting both positive and negative influences.