Bacterial genome variability and its impact on vaccine design

The majority of currently available successful vaccines induce host responses against antigens that are highly conserved in the targeted pathogens. The diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis vaccines confer protection by inducing neutralizing antibodies to the conserved bacterial toxins that are the major virulence factors. The Hemophilus influenzae B vaccine induces responses to conserved epitopes in the sugar structure of the bacterial capsular polysaccharide. However, the efficacy of more recently developed vaccines is limited by antigen variation, which also presents a challenge for future vaccine development. This review will explore bacterial genome variability and its impact on vaccine development.     

The benefits of using diverse animal models for studying pertussis

Pertussis, a respiratory disease caused by infection with Bordetella pertussis, represents one of the most devastating diseases in infants and young children worldwide. Significant research efforts over the last five decades have led to the introduction of two types of vaccines, which are now available worldwide and which have significantly reduced the global incidence of pertussis. The use of animal models and, in particular, the mouse model has benefited in the development of these vaccines tremendously. However, open questions regarding the duration of immunity, the type of immune response needed for protection and the role of mucosal and innate immunity in disease protection still remain. Here, we review the various animal models available currently and their benefits for studying this important disease.     

Composition of acellular pertussis and combination vaccines: a general review.

Since the development and introduction of the acellular pertussis vaccine in Japan in the early eighties, we have come a long way in using this component in combination with other vaccines. However, the basic problem in development of an effective and safe pertussis vaccine is that the antigens to induce complete protection against clinical pertussis and the precise mechanism by which pertussis vaccine confers immunity is yet unknown. Hence, the composition of future acellular pertussis vaccine remains an open issue. Recently, acellular pertussis vaccine has been licensed for the booster doses in the U.S.A. and for primary immunization of infants in Italy and Germany. A multicentric trial has been carried out to compare the serological response and adverse reactions of 13 acellular pertussis vaccines. These vaccines contained one or more of the four components, i.e. FHA, PT, 69 kDa OMP and fimbriae. All vaccines were associated with substantially fewer and less adverse reactions and were more immunogenic with respect to antibodies against the added antigens. DTP vaccines in the near future will have combinations of other components and the key antigen for combination will be acellular pertussis component which is going to replace whole cell pertussis component in DTP vaccines. In view of this, manufacturers like ourselves from the developing countries are still groping in the dark, uncertain whether we should have a single component acellular pertussis vaccine or multicomponent one. This will have a major impact on the cost of production, the final cost of the combination vaccines and the regulatory issues that we will have to tackle in view of the recent thinking on harmonization in the pharmaceutical industry.     

Standardization of acellular pertussis vaccines.

In comparison with the current whole cell pertussis vaccine, the new generation of acellular pertussis vaccines opens new opportunities to improve the standardization of the product, because well defined and characterized components are used in these new products.However, different compositions, purification and inactivation methods are used by different manufacturers. Consequently the various acellular pertussis vaccines in the world are difficult to compare in a meaningful manner using simple laboratory tests. In addition, the absence of a reliable animal model and serological correlates with protection in children are other complicating factors.For that reason it seems that the consistency in manufacturing based on a clinically validated production process is the best way to ensure the safety and efficacy of routinely produced acellular pertussis vaccines.Laboratory tests to monitor the antigen content, purity, safety and immunogenicity seem to be the best approach to standardize this new generation of pertussis vaccines against homologous standard vaccines with known clinical efficacy and safety and to support the consistency in manufacture.     

Evaluation of whole-cell and acellular pertussis vaccines effectiveness in clearance of experimental B. pertussis infection in mice

The study is based on assumption that B. pertussis strains harbouring different allele variants of genes encoding subunit S1 of pertussis toxin and pertactin might be eliminated with different efficiency from lung tissue of mice which were immunized with whole-cell and acellular pertussis vaccines. It has been assumed that strains containing combinations of genes alleles which were not prevalent since 1990-ties are consisting of mutated strains in respect to pertussis toxin subunit S1 and pertactin, and are capable to decrease efficiency of pertussis vaccines. Experiments performed in vivo dealt with activity of tested vaccines against B. pertussis strains of different combinations of ptxS1/prn. The study indicated for lowered efficiency of whole-cell and acellular pertussis vaccines in elimination of mutated strains of B. pertussis from animal lung tissue in comparison with strains currently used for vaccine production.     

Neonatal immunization with a single dose of recombinant BCG expressing subunit S1 from pertussis toxin induces complete protection against Bordetella pertussis intracerebral challenge

The currently used pertussis vaccines are highly efficacious; however, neonates are susceptible to whooping cough up to the sixth month. In agreement, DTP-immunized neonate mice were not protected against intracerebral challenge with Bordetella pertussis. Neonate mice immunized with either DTP or a recombinant-BCG strain expressing the genetically detoxified S1 subunit of pertussis toxin do not show a humoral immune response against PT. On the other hand, rBCG-Pertussis induces higher PT-specific IFN-gamma production and an increase in both IFN-gamma(+) and TNF-alpha(+)-CD4(+)-T cells than the whole cell pertussis vaccine and confers protection against a lethal intracerebral challenge with B. pertussis.     

Attenuated Bordetella pertussis BPZE1 as a live vehicle for heterologous vaccine antigens delivery through the nasal route

Whereas the great majority of the current vaccines are delivered through the parenteral route, mucosal administration has been increasingly considered for controlling infection and preventing disease. Mucosal vaccination can trigger both humoral and cell-mediated protection, not only at the targeted mucosal surface, but also systemically. In this regard, nasal vaccination has shown great potential. The live attenuated strain of Bordetella pertussis, BPZE1, is particularly attractive and promising as a nasal vaccine delivery vector of heterologous antigen vaccine candidates. BPZE1 was originally developed as a live nasal pertussis vaccine candidate, and is currently undergoing phase I clinical trial in human (http://www.child-innovac.org). Highly adapted to the human respiratory tract and offering several potential protein carriers for presentation of the heterologous antigen vaccine candidates, BPZE1 represents an appealing platform for the development of live recombinant vaccines delivered via the nasal route that would confer simultaneous protection against pertussis and the targeted infectious disease(s).     

Antitoxin in human pertussis immune globulins

The level of antitoxin i.e. neutralizing antibodies to pertussis toxin, or lymphocytosis promoting factor, was determined in six pertussis immune globulin preparations from different manufactures. A comparison with antitoxin levels after natural pertussis disease in adults showed that pertussis immune globulins did not contain more antitoxin than convalescent phase sera, i.e. they had very low antitoxin content for specific immune globulins. Agglutinin and anti-FHA titres were relatively higher in immune globulins, probably reflecting a difference between the antibody response elicited by whole cell vaccines used for hyperimmunization in immune globulin production and by natural disease. The low antitoxin content of currently available pertussis immune globulin preparations could explain the inefficacy or conflicting results obtained with these products in prophylaxis and therapy of whooping cough.     

An international collaborative study of the effect of active pertussis toxin on the modified Kendrick test for acellular pertussis vaccines

Speculation that the Japanese modified intra-cerebral challenge assay, which is used in several countries for control of acellular pertussis vaccines, depends on the presence of small amounts of active pertussis toxin led to an assumption that it may not be appropriate for highly toxoided or genetically detoxified vaccines. Consequently, at the recommendation of a World Health Organisation AD Hoc Working Group on mouse protection models for testing and control of acellular pertussis vaccine, the effect of pertussis toxin on the modified intra-cerebral challenge assay (modified Kendrick, MICA) was evaluated in an international collaborative study. Results of this study showed that for genetically detoxified vaccines both with and without active pertussis toxin the MICA clearly distinguished mice vaccinated with acellular vaccines from unvaccinated mice and gave a significant dose–response relationship. However, vaccine samples containing active pertussis toxin (5 or 50 ng/single human dose) appeared to be more potent than the equivalent sample without active pertussis toxin. Similar results were also given by two respiratory infection models (intranasal and aerosol) included in the study. The results also indicated that the effect of pertussis toxin may vary depending on mouse strain.     

Protective effects of in vivo‐expressed autotransporters against Bordetella pertussis infection

Bordetella pertussis causes whooping cough, a severe and prolonged respiratory disease that results inhas high morbidity and mortality rates, particularly in developing countries. The number incidence of whooping cough cases is increasing in many countries despite high vaccine coverage. Causes for the re‐emergence of the disease include the limited duration of protection conferred by the acellular pertussis vaccines (aP)s and pathogenic adaptations that involve antigenic divergence from vaccine strains. Therefore, current vaccines therefore need to be improved. In the present study, we focused on five autotransporters: namely SphB1, BatB, SphB2, Phg, and Vag8, which were previously found to be expressed by B. bronchiseptica during the course of infection in rats and examined their protective efficiencies as vaccine antigens. The passenger domains of these proteins were produced in recombinant forms and used as antigens. An intranasal murine challenge assay showed that immunization with a mixture of SphB1 and Vag8 (SV) significantly reduced bacterial load in the lower respiratory tract and a combination of aP and SV acts synergistically in effects of conferring protection against B. pertussis infection, implying that these antigens have potential as components to for improvinge th the currently available acellular pertussis vaccine.

     

Efficacy of whooping-cough vaccines used in the United Kingdom before 1968: A preliminary report by the public health laboratory service whooping-cough committee and working party

In a large survey of the efficacy of pertussis vaccines made in 33 areas in the United Kingdom during the period 1 November 1966 to 31 October 1967 a total of 3,564 households were investigated. Nine hundred and seventy-seven strains of Bordetella pertussis and 6 strains of Bord. parapertussis were isolated from persons in 792 households.After contact in the home 56% of fully vaccinated children under 5 years of age developed a paroxysmal cough, and in more than two-thirds of these patients the diagnosis was confirmed bacteriologically. This suggests that pertussis vaccination was not very effective. A comparison with the attack rate in unvaccinated children also indicates a poor protection from vaccination.None of the following factors appeared to be responsible for the poor protection afforded by vaccination: vaccination in early infancy, a long interval since vaccination, and the absence of booster doses.Almost all the children in the survey had been given vaccines from a single manufacturer, and therefore a comparison of the efficacy of vaccines prepared by different manufacturers was inconclusive. All the vaccinated children in the survey had been vaccinated before or during 1967. The efficacy of current preparations will require to be assessed by continuing surveillance.     

T- and B-Cell-Mediated Protection Induced by Novel,Live Attenuated Pertussis Vaccine in Mice. Cross Protection against Parapertussis

Background

Despite the extensive use of efficacious vaccines, pertussis still ranks among the major causes of childhood mortality worldwide. Two types of pertussis vaccines are currently available, whole-cell, and the more recent acellular vaccines. Because of reduced reactogenicity and comparable efficacy acellular vaccines progressively replace whole-cell vaccines. However, both types require repeated administrations for optimal efficacy. We have recently developed a live attenuated vaccine candidate, named BPZE1, able to protect infant mice after a single nasal administration.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We determined the protective mechanism of BPZE1-mediated immunity by using passive transfer of T cells and antibodies from BPZE1-immunized mice to SCID mice. Clearance of Bordetella pertussis from the lungs was mediated by both BPZE1-induced antibodies and CD4⁺, but not by CD8⁺ T cells. The protective CD4⁺ T cells comprised IFN-γ-producing and IL-17-producing subsets, indicating that BPZE1 induces both Th1 and Th17 CD4⁺ T cells. In addition, and in contrast to acellular pertussis vaccines, BPZE1 also cross-protected against Bordetella parapertussis infection, but in this case only the transfer of CD4⁺ T cells conferred protection. Serum from BPZE1-immunized mice was not able to kill B. parapertussis and did not protect SCID mice against B. parapertussis infection.

Conclusions/Significance

The novel live attenuated pertussis vaccine BPZE1 protects in a pre-clinical mouse model against B. pertussis challenge by both BPZE1-induced antibodies and CD4⁺ T cell responses. It also protects against B. parapertussis infection. However, in this case protection is only T cell mediated.     

Approaches to the control of acellular pertussis vaccines.

The quality control of acellular pertussis vaccines presents particular problems related to the differences in composition and method of detoxification used in the various type of preparation. These vaccines are not amenable to potency assay by the active mouse protection test used for whole-cell pertussis vaccines and assurance of protective activity is problematic.In contrast, monitoring of these vaccines for safety is relatively straightforward and is centred on assays for the lipooligosaccharide endotoxin, active pertussis toxin and absence of reversion to toxicity of detoxified product. The absence of heat-labile toxin, tracheal cytotoxin and adenyl cyclase toxin is assumed provided that adequate validation of the process has been performed.Confirmation of the antigenic content of the detoxified bulk components is difficult to achieve by conventional binding assays based on monoclonal antibodies because of changes in accessibility of reactive sites post-toxoiding. However, single radial diffusion assay using polyclonal antisera permits estimation of pertussis toxoid (PT), filamentous haemagglutinin (FHA) and pertactin (P69). Dot blot immunoassay can be used for the fimbrial agglutinogens 2 and 3 (Fim 2 and 3) and potentially could also be used to check the composition of final filling lots for PT, FHA, P69 and Fim 2 and 3.Gel electrophoresis and immunoblotting can be applied to monitor purity of purified bulk components and the characteristics of these change after chemical detoxification. Electron microscopy provides a useful semi-quantitative supporting method for checking purity of bulk components. Physico-chemical examination, particularly CD and fluorescence spectroscopy, offer a means of monitoring the consistency of detoxified bulk components.No completely satisfactory method is available for monitoring potency. Immunogenicity assays may be useful for checking consistency but do not necessarily correlate with protection. At present, active protection against aerosol challenge offers the best prospect of a functional assay.     

Bordetella pertussis serotypes in Canada.

A study was done to determine the major antigenic factors of Bordetella pertussis strains isolated throughout Canada and whether these isolates have the same antigenic structure as the bacilli in the currently used vaccines. Testing for the major pertussis antigens, factors 1, 2 and 3, was conducted with 440 freshly isolated strains of B. pertussis received from seven canadian provinces between August 1976 and February 1978 and six batches of pertussis vaccine or immunizing agents containing pertussis vaccine. With the aid of specific antisera prepared in rabbits, the antigenic factors were detected by a slide agglutination technique. Almost all (98.9%) of the pertussis strains examined were serotype 1,3.All six batches of pertussis vaccine or immunizing agents containing pertussis vaccine proved to be rich in each of the three main pertussis agglutinogens.     

A common vaccination strategy to solve unsolved problems of tuberculosis and pertussis?

Respiratory pathogens are amongst the world's most successful killers. Tuberculosis kills approximately 2 million individuals each year, and pertussis is responsible for roughly 300,000 annual deaths. Although the two diseases are fundamentally different in the expression of their pathogenesis and in the biology of their causative agents, a common heterologous prime/boost vaccination strategy is proposed, using live attenuated vaccines against tuberculosis (the already existing BCG) and pertussis (a novel attenuated Bordetella pertussis strain) early in life for priming, followed by a booster with acellular vaccines, based on the novel heparin-binding haemagglutinin for tuberculosis, and already available acellular vaccines against pertussis.     

A New Approach to Bacterial Vaccines

Immunizing antigens against only 10 bacterial diseases—cholera, diphtheria, paratyphoid, pertussis, plague, scarlet fever, staphylococcal disease, tetanus, tuberculosis and typhoid—have been licensed for sale in Canada and the United States. Convincing evidence of efficacy is available for only four of these—diphtheria and tetanus toxoids, and pertussis and typhoid vaccines.The principles which determine the efficacy of different immunizing antigens are not always the same. Toxoids, for example, stimulate the formation of antitoxin-producing mechanisms which can neutralize toxins produced by invading organisms, thereby rendering them harmless. Conversely, vaccines stimulate the formation of antibacterial mechanisms which stop the growth of organisms before they can produce disease.Use of enzyme-lysed vaccines for prevention of staphylococcal disease represents a new approach in vaccine research. Animal tests have shown lysed vaccines to be 10 to 100 times less toxic, and about eight times more effective, than whole bacterial vaccines. Studies with lysed vaccines for other diseases are now in progress.     

Toxic and reactogenic properties of pertussis bacteria (experimental and clinical studies).

The results of the study revealed correlation between the reactogenicity of pertussis vaccines in epidemiological observations and the toxic properties of pertussis bacteria in experiment. Quantitative and qualitative differences were found between the toxic factors in pertussis bacteria depending on their type-specific serological activity. Serotype 1.0.3 microbes exhibit more pronounced toxicity which accounts for the greater reactogenicity of vaccines prepared from this serotype as compared with the preparation produced from the serotype 1.2.3. The obtained results suggest the necessity of considering the greater toxicity of the serotype 1.0.3 in the preparation of pertussis vaccines.     

Overview of recent clinical trials of acellular pertussis vaccines.

The evidence from pre-licensure studies does not suggest that there are clinically important differences in reactogenicity between acellular vaccines. The merits of different acellular products will therefore have to be compared on efficacy criteria. Ideally, acellular vaccines with the minimum antigen content necessary to ensure optimum protection should be used in order to avoid administration of superfluous antigens to children and to simplify licensing and batch release procedures.On the basis of the evidence so far available it seems unlikely that monocomponent pertussis toxin (PT) vaccines provide optimal protection and that multicomponent vaccines are needed to achieve a level of disease control that approaches that of a good whole-cell vaccine. It is unclear whether all two component vaccines containing PT and filamentous haemagglutinin (FHA) have similar efficacy but on the available evidence the safest option for policy makers would seem to be to use a vaccine with at least three components, PT+FHA+pertactin. There is now good evidence that the five component vaccine which contains agglutinogens 2 and 3 in addition to PT/FHA and pertactin provides the best protection and is the only acellular vaccine whose efficacy matches that of a good whole cell vaccine. However, the public health advantage of the five component vaccine over other acellular vaccines may not become apparent until they have been in routine use for some decades and their ability to protect against transmission as well as clinical pertussis has emerged.The decision to replace an effective whole-cell vaccine by an acellular vaccine for primary immunisation needs careful consideration. Apart from the probable sacrifice of efficacy for reduced reactogenicity (at least for vaccines which do not contain agglutinogens 2 and 3) there is the question of value for money and the ease with which acellular DTP vaccines can be combined with conjugate polysaccharide vaccines such as Haemophilus influenzae type b.Whatever the decision of policy makers, the need for continued follow up of trial cohorts and active surveillance of the efficacy and safety of those acellular vaccines that are introduced into routine use must be accorded a high priority.     

Investigation of an Aerosol Challenge Model as Alternative to the Intracerebral Mouse Protection Test for Potency Assay of Whole Cell Pertussis Vaccines

The current potency test for whole cell pertussis vaccines, the intracerebral mouse protection test, is still the only assay which has shown a correlation with protection in children. However, it has considerable disadvantages as it uses a severe challenge procedure and the results tend to show significant intra- and inter-laboratory variation. An alternative assay based on non-lethal aerosol challenge of mice has been investigated as a replacement for the current intracerebral mouse protection test. Evaluation of this indicated that the aerosol system allowed consistent inoculation of bacteria into mice and gave good reproducibility. The protective capacity of different vaccine preparations was distinguished by this assay. Furthermore, the viable counts of Bordetella pertussis in the lungs of challenged mice were immunisation dose-dependent, which allowed the relative potency of vaccines to be calculated. Comparison of potency of five batches of vaccine from different manufacturers assayed by both the intracerebral and the aerosol challenge methods ranked the vaccines in identical order. The results suggest that this method has potential for use as a potency test for whole cell pertussis vaccine which would result in a great reduction in the number of animals used. It would also replace the lethal challenge by a non-lethal procedure and thereby avoid the use of the severe intracerebral challenge procedure.     

Molecular aspects of Bordetella pertussis pathogenesis.

The molecular mechanisms of Bordetella virulence are now well understood, and many virulence factors have been identified and characterized at the molecular level. These virulence factors can be grouped into two major categories: adhesins, such as filamentous hemagglutinin, pertactin and fimbriae, and toxins, such as pertussis toxin, adenylate cyclase, dermonecrotic toxin and tracheal cytotoxin. The production of most virulence factors is coordinately regulated by a two-component signal transduction system composed of the regulator BvgA and the sensor protein BvgS. The adhesins and toxins act in concert to establish infection. Some adhesins exert their effects synergically or are redundant functioning only in the absence of another adhesin, illustrating the importance of adhesion in infection. Most virulence factors are secreted into the culture supernatant or exposed at the surface of the bacterial cell. A notable exception is dermonecrotic toxin, which remains in the cytoplasmic compartment of bacterial cells. Most virulence factors are produced by all of the three major Bordetella species, B. pertussis, B. parapertussis and B. bronchiseptica. However, some, such as pertussis toxin and the tracheal colonization factor, are only produced by B. pertussis. Our understanding of Bordetella virulence at the molecular level has led to the development of new acellular vaccines against whooping cough, and of genetically attenuated B. pertussis strains to be used as recombinant live bacterial vaccine vectors for homologous and heterologous protection.