Three Different Methods for Measuring Xylem Cavitation and Embolism: A Comparison

Three different methods for measuring xylem embolism due towater cavitation were compared—the acoustic method, thehydraulic method and the anatomical method. Young plants ofCeratonia siliqua L. were water stressed for 9, 16 and 23 d. Xylem cavitation was detected by counting ultrasound (100–300kHz) acoustic emissions (AE) from 1-year-old twigs (acousticmethod). Xylem embolism was detected by measuring the loss ofhydraulic conductivity of twigs of the same age (hydraulic method).The blockage of single xylem conduits was detected by perfusingSafranin into the xylem of 1-year-old twigs of stressed plantsand measuring the number and the diameters of non-conductingxylem conduits, under the microscope (anatomical method). It was noted that: (a) the number of AE and the loss of conductivityincreased with the water stress applied; (b) a linear relationseemed to exist between the number of AE and the loss of conductivity,suggesting that the AE counted could be only (or mainly) producedin the xylem conduits; (c) the vulnerability of the xylem conduitsto embolism was a direct function of their diameter; and (d)the measured loss of conductivity was of the same order of magnitudeas the theoretical one. The three methods gave fairly similar results. Nonetheless,they are not alternative to one another in that: (a) the acousticmethod allows continuous recordings to be made but does notprovide information about the actual damage suffered by plants;(b) the hydraulic method is very informative but destructive;and (c) the anatomical method is very useful both in phytogcographicaland in genetic improvement studies. Ceratonia siliqua L., Carob tree, water stress, xylem embolism, acoustic method, hydraulic method, anatomical method     

Poplar vulnerability to xylem cavitation acclimates to drier soil conditions

Xylem vulnerability to cavitation differs between tree species according to their drought resistance, more xerophilous species being more resistant to xylem cavitation. Variability in xylem vulnerability to cavitation is also found within species, especially between in situ populations. The origin of this variability has not been clearly identified. Here we analyzed the response of xylem hydraulic traits of Populus tremula×Populus alba trees to three different soil water regimes. Stem xylem vulnerability was scored as the xylem water potential causing 12, 50 and 88% loss of conductivity (P₁₂, P₅₀ and P₈₈). Vulnerability to cavitation was found to acclimate to growing conditions under different levels of soil water content, with P₅₀ values of ?1.82, ?2.03 and ?2.45 MPa in well‐watered, moderately water‐stressed and severely water‐stressed poplars, respectively. The value of P₁₂, the xylem tension at which cavitation begins, was correlated with the lowest value of midday leaf water potential (ψm) experienced by each plant, the difference between the two parameters being approximately 0.5 MPa, consistent with the absence of any difference in embolism level between the different water treatments. These results support the hypothesis that vulnerability to cavitation is a critical trait for resistance to drought. The decrease in vulnerability to cavitation under growing conditions of soil drought was correlated with decreased vessel diameter, increased vessel wall thickness and a stronger bordered pit field (t/b)². The links between these parameters are discussed.     

Three Different Methods for Measuring Xylem Cavitation and Embolism: A Comparison

Three different methods for measuring xylem embolism due towater cavitation were compared—the acoustic method, thehydraulic method and the anatomical method. Young plants ofCeratonia siliqua L. were water stressed for 9, 16 and 23 d. Xylem cavitation was detected by counting ultrasound (100–300kHz) acoustic emissions (AE) from 1-year-old twigs (acousticmethod). Xylem embolism was detected by measuring the loss ofhydraulic conductivity of twigs of the same age (hydraulic method).The blockage of single xylem conduits was detected by perfusingSafranin into the xylem of 1-year-old twigs of stressed plantsand measuring the number and the diameters of non-conductingxylem conduits, under the microscope (anatomical method). It was noted that: (a) the number of AE and the loss of conductivityincreased with the water stress applied; (b) a linear relationseemed to exist between the number of AE and the loss of conductivity,suggesting that the AE counted could be only (or mainly) producedin the xylem conduits; (c) the vulnerability of the xylem conduitsto embolism was a direct function of their diameter; and (d)the measured loss of conductivity was of the same order of magnitudeas the theoretical one. The three methods gave fairly similar results. Nonetheless,they are not alternative to one another in that: (a) the acousticmethod allows continuous recordings to be made but does notprovide information about the actual damage suffered by plants;(b) the hydraulic method is very informative but destructive;and (c) the anatomical method is very useful both in phytogeographicaland in genetic improvement studies. Ceratonia siliqua L, Carob tree, water stress, xylem embolism, acoustic method, hydraulic method, anatomical method     

Relations between vulnerability to xylem embolism and xylem conduit dimensions in young trees of Quercus corris

Measurements of xylem conduit length and width and the distribution of xylem conduit ends were made in inter-nodes (I), nodes (N) and twig junctions (J) of 1-, 2- and 3-year-old twigs of plants of Quercus cerris L. Parallel measurements were also made of the loss of hydraulic conductivity of twigs subjected to pressure differentials across conduit pit membranes, equalling the leaf water potential at the turgor loss point. The loss of theoretical hydraulic conductivity was calculated as the ratio of i esivr⁴ (where r is the conduit radius) of the non-conducting conduits to that of all the conduits in the outermost wood ring of I, N and J. Stem zones such as 1-year-old nodes and junctions were localized with narrower and shorter xylem conduits and with higher percentages of conduit ends than internodes. Such ‘constricted zonesrsquo; were less vulnerable to embolism than internodes. Latewood conduits were consistently narrower, shorter and less vulnerable to embolism than earlywood ones. A positive relation therefore existed between conduit diameter and length and vulnerability to embolism. The overall vulnerability to embolism of Q. cerris plants is discussed in terms of xylem conduit width and length and of the distribution of conduit ends.     

Measurement of vulnerability to water stress‐induced cavitation in grapevine: a comparison of four techniques applied to a long‐vesseled species

Among woody plants, grapevines are often described as highly vulnerable to water‐stress induced cavitation with emboli forming at slight tensions. However, we found native embolism never exceeded 30% despite low xylem water potentials (Ψ_x) for stems of field grown vines. The discrepancy between native embolism measurements and those of previous reports led us to assess vulnerability curve generation using four separate methods and alterations (i.e. segment length and with/without flushing to remove embolism prior to measurement) of each. Centrifuge, dehydration and air‐injection methods, which rely on measurement of percentage loss of hydraulic conductivity (PLC) in detached stems, were compared against non‐invasive monitoring of xylem cavitation with nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) imaging. Short segment air‐injection and flushed centrifuge stems reached >90 PLC at Ψ_x of‐0.5 and ?1.5 MPa, respectively, whereas dehydration and long‐segment air‐injection measurements indicated no significant embolism at Ψ_x > ?2.0 MPa. Observations from NMR agreed with the dehydration and long segment air‐injection methods, showing the majority of vessels were still water‐filled at Ψ_x > ?1.5 MPa. Our findings show V. vinifera stems are far less vulnerable to water stress‐induced cavitation than previously reported, and dehydration and long segment air‐injection techniques are more appropriate for long‐vesseled species and organs.     

A new method for vulnerability analysis of small xylem areas reveals that compression wood of Norway spruce has lower hydraulic safety than opposite wood

Compression wood is formed at the underside of conifer twigs to keep branches at their equilibrium position. It differs from opposite wood anatomically and subsequently in its mechanical and hydraulic properties. The specific hydraulic conductivity (k_s) and vulnerability to drought‐induced embolism (loss of conductivity versus water potential ψ) in twigs of Norway spruce [Picea abies (L.) Karst.] were studied via cryo‐scanning electron microscope observations, dye experiments and a newly developed ‘Micro‐Sperry’ apparatus. This new technique enabled conductivity measurements in small xylem areas by insertion of syringe cannulas into twig samples. The hydraulic properties were related to anatomical parameters (tracheid diameter, wall thickness). Compression wood exhibited 79% lower k_s than opposite wood corresponding to smaller tracheid diameters. Vulnerability was higher in compression wood despite its narrower tracheids and thicker cell walls. The P₅₀ (ψ at 50% loss of conductivity) was ?3.6 MPa in opposite but only ?3.2 MPa in compression wood. Low hydraulic efficiency and low hydraulic safety indicate that compression wood has primarily a mechanical function.     

New evidence for large negative xylem pressures and their measurement by the pressure chamber method

Pressure probe measurements have been interpreted as showing that xylem pressures below c. –0.4 MPa do not exist and that pressure chamber measurements of lower negative pressures are invalid. We present new evidence supporting the pressure chamber technique and the existence of xylem pressures well below –0.4 MPa. We deduced xylem pressures in water-stressed stem xylem from the following experiment: (1) loss of hydraulic conductivity in hydrated stem xylem (xylem pressure = atmospheric pressure) was induced by forcing compressed air into intact xylem conduits; (2) loss of hydraulic conductivity from cavitation and embolism in dehydrating stems was measured, and (3) the xylem pressure in dehydrated stems was deduced as being equal and opposite to the air pressure causing the same loss of hydraulic conductivity in hydrated stems. Pressures determined in this way are only valid if cavitation was caused by air entering the xylem conduits (air-seeding). Deduced xylem pressure showed a one-to-one correspondence with pressure chamber measurements for 12 species (woody angiosperms and gymnosperms); data extended to c. –10 MPa. The same correspondence was obtained under field conditions in Betula occidentalis Hook., where pressure differences between air- and water-filled conduits were induced by a combination of in situ xylem water pressure and applied positive air pressure. It is difficult to explain these results if xylem pressures were above –0.4 MPa, if the pressure chamber was inaccurate, and if cavitation occurred by some mechanism other than air-seeding. A probable reason why the pressure probe does not register large negative pressures is that, just as cavitation within the probe limits its calibration to pressures above c. –0.5 MPa, cavitation limits its measurement range in situ.     

Vulnerability to cavitation in populations of two desert species, Hymenoclea salsola and Ambrosia dumosa, from different climatic regions

Seeds from different populations of two desert species, Hymenocleasalsola Torr. and A. Gray and Ambrosia dumosa (A. Gray) Payne,were collected along a climatic gradient, germinated in a greenhouseand the plants tested for their vulnerability to cavitationby the air-pressure method. Differences among populations wereevident in A. dumosa, but not in H. salsola. Greenhouse treatmentssimulating regimes in temperature and relative humidity encounteredin different desert environments did not cause appreciable changesin vulnerability to cavitation. It is suggested that a homeostaticmechanism may have helped in maintaining a constant water potentialdrop in the xylem with little need for an adjustment in theresistance to cavitation. Different plant organs had differentvulnerabilities to cavitation, with roots being the most andwoody stems the least susceptible. Young green twigs were intermediate.A simulation model confirmed that low water potentials are mostlikely to cause runaway cavitation in the roots, not in theother organs. It is hypothesized that green twigs are adaptedto the favourable water conditions of the growing season, whilewoody stems are adapted to endure prolonged periods of droughtstress. Key words: Cavitation, xylem embolism, hydraulic conductance, Hymenoclea salsola, Ambrosia dumosa     

Mechanism of freeze-induced embolism in Fagus sylvatica L.

 The mechanism of freeze stress-induced embolism in Fagus sylvatica L. branches was analyzed under controlled conditions. Excised branches were exposed to successive freeze-thaw cycles in temperature controlled chambers. Thermocouples were placed on the bark to detect sap freezing exotherms. The degree of xylem embolism was estimated after each cycle by the loss of hydraulic conductivity. After one freeze-thaw cycle the degree of embolism was found to decrease with xylem specific hydraulic conductivity, small apical shoots being more susceptible to embolism. Exotherms revealed that distal shoots were freezing first and exuded sap as a result of water expansion. The lower water content in apical shoots upon freezing probably induced higher sap tensions which promoted air bubble expansion and vessel cavitation preferentially near the apices. When the decrease in water content was experimentally prevented, embolism developed to a lesser extent. The higher vulnerability of shoot apices may protect the rest of the branch from winter damage. Received: 29 May 1998 / Accepted: 15 August 1998     

Different vulnerabilities of Quercus ilex L. to freeze- and summer drought-induced xylem embolism: an ecological interpretation

Quercus ilex L. growing in the southern Mediterranean Basin region is exposed to xylem embolism induced by both winter freezing and summer drought. The distribution of the species in Sicily could be explained in terms of the different vulnerability to embolism of its xylem conduits. Naturally occurring climatic conditions were simulated by: (1) maintaining plants for 3h at ambient temperatures of 0, -1.5, -2.5, -5.0 and -11°C; and (2) allowing plants to dry out to ratios of their minimum diurnal leaf water potentials (Ψ₁) to that at the turgor loss point (Ψ_tlp) of 0.6, 0.9, 1.05, 1.20 and 1.33. The loss of hydraulic conductivity of one-year-old twigs reached 40% at -1.5°C and at Ψ₁/Ψ_tlP= 1.05. Recovery from these strains was almost complete 24 h after the release of thermal stress or after one irrigation, respectively. More severe stresses reduced recovery consistently. The percentages of xylem conduits embolized following application of the two stresses, were positively related to xylem conduit diameter. The capability of the xylem conduits to recover from stress was positively related to the conduit diameter in plants subjected to summer drought, but not in the plants subjected to winter freezing stress. The ecological significance of the different vulnerabilities to embolism of xylem conduits under naturally occurring climatic conditions is discussed.     

Intra- and inter-plant variation in xylem cavitation in Betula occidentalis

A modified version of a method that uses positive air pressures to determine the complete cavitation response of a single axis is presented. Application of the method to Betula occidentalis Hook, gave a cavitation response indistinguishable from that obtained by dehydration, thus verifying the technique and providing additional evidence that cavitation under tension occurs by air entry through interconduit pits. Incidentally, this also verified pressure-bomb estimates of xylem tension and confirmed the existence of large (i.e. >0·4 MPa) tensions in xylem, which have been questioned in recent pressure-probe studies. The air injection method was used to investigate variation within and amongst individuals of B. occidentalis. Within an individual, the average cavitation tension increased from 0·66±0·27 MPa in roots (3·9 to 10·7 mm diameter), to 1·17±0·10 MPa in trunks (12 to 16 mm diameter), to 1·36±0·04 MPa in twigs (3·9 to 5 mm diameter). Cavitation tension was negatively correlated with the hydraulically weighted mean of the vessel diameter, and was negatively correlated with the conductance of the xylem per xylem area. Native cavitation was within the range predicted from the measured cavitation response and in situ maximum xylem tensions: roots were significantly cavitated compared with minimal cavitation in trunks and twigs. Leaf turgor pressure declined to zero at the xylem tensions predicted to initiate cavitation in petiole xylem (1·5 MPa). Amongst individuals within B. occidentalis, average cavitation tension in the main axis varied from 0·90 to 1·90 MPa and showed no correlation with vessel diameter. The main axes of juveniles (2–3 years old) had significantly narrower vessel diameters than those of adults, but there was no difference in the average cavitation tension. However, juvenile xylem retained hydraulic conductance to a much higher xylem tension (3·25 MPa) than did adult xylem (2·25 MPa), which could facilitate drought survival during establishment.     

Limitation of transpiration by hydraulic conductance and xylem cavitation in Betula occidentalis

The extent to which stomatal conductance (g_s) was capable of responding to reduced hydraulic conductance (k)and preventing cavitation-inducing xylem pressures was evaluated in the small riparian tree, Betula occidentalis Hook. We decreased k by inducing xylem cavitation in shoots using an air-injection technique. From 1 to 18 d after shoot injection we measured midday transpiration rate (E), g_s, and xylem pressure (Ψ_p-xylem) on individual leaves of the crown. We then harvested the shoot and made direct measurements of k from the trunk (2–3 cm diameter) to the distal tip of the petioles of the same leaves measured for E and g_s. The k measurement was expressed per unit leaf area (k_l, leaf-specific conductance). Leaves measured within 2 d of shoot injection showed reduced g_s and E relative to non-injected controls, and both parameters were strongly correlated with k_l At this time, there was no difference in leaf Ψ_p-xylem between injected shoots and controls, and leaf Ψ_p-xylem was not significantly different from the highest cavitation-inducing pressure (Ψ_p-cav) in the branch xylem (-1.43 ± 0.029 MPa, n=8). Leaves measured 7–18 d after shoots were injected exhibited a partial return of g_s and E values to the control range. This was associated with a decrease in leaf Ψ_p-xylem below Ψ_p-cav and loss of foliage. The results suggest the stomata were incapable of long-term regulation of E below control values and that reversion to higher E caused dieback via cavitation.     

Vulnerability to cavitation differs between current‐year and older xylem: non‐destructive observation with a compact magnetic resonance imaging system of two deciduous diffuse‐porous species

Development of xylem embolism during water stress in two diffuse‐porous hardwoods, Katsura (Cercidiphyllum japonicum) and Japanese white birch (Betula platyphylla var. japonica), was observed non‐destructively under a compact magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) system in addition to conventional quantitation of hydraulic vulnerability to cavitation from excised stem segments. Distribution of white and dark areas in MR images corresponded well to the distribution of water‐filled/embolized vessels observed by cryo‐scanning electron microscopy in both species. Water‐filled vessels were observed in MR images as white areas in Katsura and as white dots in Japanese white birch, respectively, and embolisms could be detected as a change to dark areas. The increase in the relative embolized area (REA: %) in the cross‐sectional area of total xylem during water stress, which was estimated from the binarized MR images, was consistent with the hydraulic vulnerability curves of these species. From the non‐destructive MRI observations, cavitation induced by water stress was shown to develop earlier in 1‐ or 2‐year‐old xylem than in the current‐year xylem in both species; that is, the vulnerability to cavitation differs between vessels in the current‐year xylem and those in older annual rings.     

Interpretation of seasonal changes of xylem embolism and plant hydraulic resistance in Fagus sylvatica

The annual course of xylem embolism in twigs of adult beech trees was monitored, and compared to concurrent changes of tree water status and hydraulic resistances. Xylem embolism was quantified in 1-year-old apical twigs by the hydraulic conductivity as a percentage of the maximum measured after removal of air emboli. Tree and root hydraulic resistances were estimated from water potential differences and sap flux measurements. The considerable degree of twig embolism found in winter (up to 90% loss of hydraulic conductivity) may be attributed to the effect of freeze-thaw cycles in the xylem. A partial recovery from winter embolism occurred in spring, probably because of the production of new functional xylem. Xylem embolism fluctuated around 50% throughout the summer, without significant changes. Almost complete refilling of apical twigs was observed early in autumn. A significant negative correlation was found between xylem embolism and precipitation; thus, an active role of rainfall in embolism reversion is hypothesized. Tree and root hydraulic resistances were found to change throughout the growing period. A marked decrease of hydraulic resistance preceded the refilling of apical twigs in the autumn. Most of the decrease in total tree resistance was estimated to be located in the root compartment.     

Cavitation resistance of peduncle,petiole and stem is correlated with bordered pit dimensions in Magnolia grandiflora

Variation in resistance of xylem to embolism among flowers, leaves, and stems strongly influences the survival and reproduction of plants. However, little is known about the vulnerability to xylem embolism under drought stress and their relationships to the anatomical traits of pits among reproductive and vegetative organs. In this study, we investigated the variation in xylem vulnerability to embolism in peduncles, petioles, and stems in a woody plant, Magnolia grandiflora. We analyzed the relationships between water potentials that induced 50% embolism (P₅₀) in peduncles, petioles, and stems and the conduit pit traits hypothesized to influence cavitation resistance. We found that peduncles were more vulnerable to cavitation than petioles and stems, supporting the hypothesis of hydraulic vulnerability segmentation that leaves and stems are prioritized over flowers during drought stress. Moreover, P₅₀ was significantly correlated with variation in the dimensions of inter-vessel pit apertures among peduncles, petioles and stems. These findings highlight that measuring xylem vulnerability to embolism in reproductive organs is essential for understanding the effect of drought on plant reproductive success and mortality under drought stress.     

Water storage in the wood and xylem cavitation in 1-year-old twigs of Populus deltoides Bartr.

The possible role of water expelled from cavitated xylem conduits in the rehydration of water-stressed leaves has been studied in one-year-old twigs of populus deltoides Bartr. Twigs were dehydrated in air. At desired values of leaf water potential (Ψ_l) (between near full turgor and -1.62 MPa), twigs were placed in black plastic bags for 1–2h. Leaf water content was measured every 3–5 min before bagging and every 10 min in the dark. Hydraulic conductivity and xylem cavitation were measured both in the open and in the dark. Cavitation was monitored as ultrasound acoustic emissions (AE). A critical Ψ_l value of -0.96 MPa was found, at which AE increased significantly while the leaf water deficit decreased by gain of water. Since the twigs were no longer attached to roots, it was concluded that water expelled from cavitated xylem conduits was transported to the leaves, thus contributing to their rehydration. Xylem cavitation is discussed in terms of a ‘leaf water deficit buffer mechanism’, under not very severe water stress conditions.     

Water relations of a tropical vine-like bamboo (Rhipidocladum racemiflorum): root pressures, vulnerability to cavitation and seasonal changes in embolism

The occurrence of root pressure, the vulnerability of xylemvessels to drought-induced cavitation, and the seasonal changesin hydraulic conductivity due to embolism were studied in theculms of Rhipidocladum racemiflorum (Steud.) McClure, a tropicalvine-like bamboo from central Panama. Positive hydrostatic potentialsup to 120 kPa occurred only during the wet season when the transpirationrate of the plant was low, i.e. at night or during rain events.Although the xylem vessels were large and efficient for conductingwater, they were highly resistant to cavitation. Xylem waterpotentials lower than –4.5 MPa were required to induce50% loss of hydraulic conductivity in culms. The minimum waterpotential reached –3.75 MPa at the end of the 1993 dryseason, so loss of hydraulic conductivity due to embolism remained<10%. The species is adapted to drier habitats both by wayof a low vulnerability to xylem cavitation and by root pressuresin the wet season that could refill vessels that became embolizedduring a severe dry season. Key words: Rhipidocladum racemiflorum, root pressure, cavitation, embolism, water relations     

Hydraulic architecture and water relations of Spartium junceum branches affected by a mycoplasm disease

Plant water relations, xylem anatomy and the hydraulic architecture of 1‐year‐old twigs of Spartium junceum, both healthy and affected by a phytoplasm disease, were studied. The disease causes twigs to be either shortened (witches broom disease, WBD) or flat (fasciate disease, FD). WBD twigs show a sevenfold increase in total leaf area, smaller and shorter xylem conduits, a higher stomatal conductance (g_l) and a decline of minimum leaf water potentials ( Ψ _l) below the turgor loss point. FD twigs had nearly twice the leaf area of the healthy controls as well as high g_l values and Ψ _l values below the turgor loss point. Moreover, significant differences between healthy and affected twigs in stem stomatal conductance (g_s) and in the total stem area were recorded. Affected twigs die back under drought stress, which is explained by a pronounced loss of hydraulic conductivity of the infected stems (40 and 60%) in FD and WBD as well as by the unfavourable ratio of weighted conduit radius ( Σ r⁴) to total surface area (A_t), so that the efficiency of the stem in supplying the whole transpiring area with water is strongly reduced.     

Leaf morphology of 40 evergreen and deciduous broadleaved subtropical tree species and relationships to functional ecophysiological traits

We explored potential of morphological and anatomical leaf traits for predicting ecophysiological key functions in subtropical trees. We asked whether the ecophysiological parameters stomatal conductance and xylem cavitation vulnerability could be predicted from microscopy leaf traits. We investigated 21 deciduous and 19 evergreen subtropical tree species, using individuals of the same age and from the same environment in the Biodiversity‐Ecosystem Functioning experiment at Jiangxi (BEF‐China). Information‐theoretic linear model selection was used to identify the best combination of morphological and anatomical predictors for ecophysiological functions. Leaf anatomy and morphology strongly depended on leaf habit. Evergreen species tended to have thicker leaves, thicker spongy and palisade mesophyll, more palisade mesophyll layers and a thicker subepidermis. Over 50% of all evergreen species had leaves with multi‐layered palisade parenchyma, while only one deciduous species (Koelreuteria bipinnata) had this. Interactions with leaf habit were also included in best multi‐predictor models for stomatal conductance (g_s) and xylem cavitation vulnerability. In addition, maximum g_s was positively related to log ratio of palisade to spongy mesophyll thickness. Vapour pressure deficit (vpd) for maximum g_s increased with the log ratio of palisade to spongy mesophyll thickness in species having leaves with papillae. In contrast, maximum specific hydraulic conductivity and xylem pressure at which 50% loss of maximum specific xylem hydraulic conductivity occurred (Ψ₅₀) were best predicted by leaf habit and density of spongy parenchyma. Evergreen species had lower Ψ₅₀ values and lower maximum xylem hydraulic conductivities. As hydraulic leaf and wood characteristics were reflected in structural leaf traits, there is high potential for identifying further linkages between morphological and anatomical leaf traits and ecophysiological responses.