Effects of agitation intensity on mycelial morphology and protein production in chemostat cultures of recombinant Aspergillus oryzae

The effects of agitation on fragmentation of a recombinant strain of Aspergillus oryzae and its consequential effects on protein production have been investigated. Constant mass, 5.3-L chemostat cultures at a dilution rate of 0.05 h-1 and a dissolved oxygen level of 75% air saturation, have been conducted at 550, 700, and 1000 rpm. These agitation speeds were chosen to cover a range of specific power inputs (2.2 to 12 kW m-3) from realistic industrial levels to much higher values. The use of a constant mass chemostat linked to a gas blender allowed variation of agitation speed and hence gas hold-up without affecting the dilution rate or the concentration of dissolved oxygen. The morphology of both the freely dispersed mycelia and clumps was characterized using image analysis. Statistical analysis showed that it was possible to obtain steady states with respect to morphology. The mean projected area at each steady state under growing conditions correlated well with the 'energy dissipation/circulation" function, [P/(kD3tc)], where P is the power input, D the impeller diameter, tc the mean circulation time, and k is a geometric constant for a given impeller. Rapid transients of morphological parameters in response to a speed change from 1000 to 550 rpm probably resulted from aggregation. Protein production (alpha-amylase and amyloglucosidase) was found to be independent of agitation speed in the range 550 to 1000 rpm (P/V = 2.2 and 12.6 kW m-3, respectively), although significant changes in mycelial morphology could be measured for similar changes in agitation conditions. This suggests that mycelial morphology does not directly affect protein production (at a constant dilution rate and, therefore, specific growth rate). An understanding of how agitation affects mycelial morphology and productivity would be valuable in optimizing the design and operation of large-scale fungal fermentations for the production of recombinant proteins. Copyright 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Vancomycin production is enhanced in chemostat culture with biomass-recycle

Production of the glycopeptide antibiotic vancomycin by Amycolatopsis orientalis ATCC 19795 was examined in phosphate-limited chemostat cultures with biomass-recycle, employing an oscillating membrane separator, at a constant dilution rate (D= 0. 14 h-1). Experiments made under low agitation conditions (600 rpm) showed that the biomass concentration could be increased 3.9-fold with vancomycin production kinetics very similar to that of chemostat culture without biomass-recycle. The specific production rate (qvancomycin) was maximal when the biomass-recycle ratio (R) was 0.13 (D= 0.087 h-1). When the dissolved oxygen tension dropped below 20% (air saturation), the biomass and vancomycin concentrations decreased and an unidentified red metabolite was released into the culture medium. Using increased agitation (850 rpm), used to maintain the dissolved oxygen tension above 20% air saturation, maximum increases in biomass concentration (7.9-fold) and vancomcyin production 1.6-fold (0.6 mg/g dry weight/h) were obtained when R was 0.44 (D= 0.056 h -1) compared to chemostat culture without biomass-recycle. Moreover, at this latter recycle ratio the volumetric vancomycin production rate was 14.7 mg/L/h (a 7-fold increase compared to chemostat culture without biomass-recycle). These observations encourage further research on biomass-recycling as a means of optimising the production of antibiotics.     

Effects of dissolved oxygen tension and agitation rate on the production of heat-shock protein glycoprotein 96 by MethA tumor cell suspension culture in stirred-tank bioreactors

Heat-shock protein glycoprotein (gp96) serves as a natural adjuvant for chaperoning antigenic peptide into the immune surveillance pathway. In our laboratory, MethA tumor cell suspension culture process has been recently developed for gp96 production in spinner flask. In this work, effects of dissolved oxygen tension (DOT) and agitation rate on this process were studied in stirred-tank bioreactor. The optimal conditions for gp96 production were different with those for MethA tumor cell growth. MethA tumor cell growth pattern was not much changed by various levels of DOT and agitation rate, while gp96 biosynthesis was more sensitive to DOT and agitation rate. Compared with 50% of DOT, the production and specific productivity of gp96 was increased by 27 and 66% at 10% of DOT, respectively. Compared with the agitation rate of 100 rpm, the production and volumetric productivity of gp96 was increased by 48 and 144% at the agitation rate of 200 rpm, respectively. Low DOT (i.e., 10% of air saturation) and high agitation rate (i.e., 200 rpm) were identified to be favorable for gp96 biosynthesis. The results of this work might be useful to scale-up the bioprocess into the pilot scale.     

Influence of dissolved oxygen tension and agitation speed on alginate production and its molecular weight in cultures of Azotobacter vinelandii*

The alginate production by Azotobacter vinelandii, as well as the molecular weight of the polymer, are strongly influenced by the dissolved oxygen tension (DOT) and stirring speed of the culture. Under high DOT (5% of air saturation), the bacteria produced more alginate (4.5 g/l) than that obtained at low (0.5%) oxygen tension (1.0 g/l) in cultures conducted at 300 rpm. On the other hand, under constant DOT (3%), the higher the stirring speed (from 300 to 700 rev./min), the higher the specific growth rate and the alginate production rate. However, low agitation speed (300 rev./min) lead the culture to produce a polymer of high molecular weight (680 000 g/g mol) whereas a low molecular weight (352 000 g/g mol) alginate was isolated from cultures conducted at high (700 rev./min) stirring speed. At 700 rev./min, the MMW increased to a plateau between 1 and 3% DOT and then decreased to a minimum of 0.11 x 10(6) g/g mol at 7%. Microscopic observations revealed the presence of cell aggregates (one order of magnitude larger than individual cells) when the culture was conducted at 300 rev./min. Oxygen gradients occurring within the aggregates could be responsible of this phenomenon. At high agitation rate, the MMW of the alginate dropped towards the end of the culture in all conditions evaluated. Alginase activity was detected, which would be responsible for this phenomenon.     

Pellet morphology, culture rheology and lovastatin production in cultures of Aspergillus terreus

Pellet growth of Aspergillus terreus ATCC 20542 in submerged batch fermentations in stirred bioreactors was used to examine the effects of agitation (impeller tip speed u(t) of 1.01-2.71 ms(-1)) and aeration regimens (air or an oxygen-enriched mixture containing 80% oxygen and 20% nitrogen by volume) on the fungal pellet morphology, broth rheology and lovastatin production. The agitation speed and aeration methods used did not affect the biomass production profiles, but significantly influenced pellet morphology, broth rheology and the lovastatin titers. Pellets of approximately 1200 microm initial diameter were reduced to a final stable size of approximately 900 microm when the agitation intensity was >/=600 rpm (u(t)>/=2.03 ms(-1)). A stable pellet diameter of approximately 2500 microm could be attained in less intensely agitated cultures. These large fluffy pellets produced high lovastatin titers when aerated with oxygen-enriched gas but not with air. Much smaller pellets obtained under highly agitated conditions did not attain high lovastatin productivity even in an oxygen-enriched atmosphere. This suggests that both an upper limit on agitation intensity and a high level of dissolved oxygen are essential for attaining high titers of lovastatin. Pellet size in the bioreactor correlated equally well with the specific energy dissipation rate and the energy dissipation circulation function. The latter took into account the frequency of passage of the pellets through the high shear regions of the impellers. Pellets that gave high lovastatin titers produced highly shear thinning cultivation broths.     

The effect of culture conditions on the production of erythromycin by Saccharopolyspora erythraea in batch culture

Summary Saccharopolyspora erythraea growth is inhibited when grown at a low constant dissolved oxygen tension (DOT) of 10% air saturation. However, the specific erythromycin production is virtually identical to that of a culture where the DOT did not fall below 65%. In addition, at constant DOT (10%) a stirrer speed of 750 rpm in a 7 litre causes mechanical damage to the mycelia in comparison with result at 500 rpm.     

Investigation of liquid-solid hydrodynamic boundary layers and oxygen requirements in hairy root cultures.

Rates of oxygen uptake, growth and alkaloid production by hairy roots in submerged culture were investigated using a recirculation reactor allowing operation at high liquid velocities for removal of hydrodynamic boundary layers. Measurements were performed at dissolved oxygen tensions of 31-450% air saturation. Critical oxygen concentrations for Atropa belladonna hairy roots were above air saturation, viz. 100-125% air saturation for oxygen uptake and 150% air saturation for growth, demonstrating that these roots cultivated in reactors with air sparging are oxygen-limited. The critical oxygen tension for oxygen uptake by Solanum aviculare hairy roots was 75% air saturation. Both the specific oxygen uptake rate and specific growth rate of A. belladonna hairy roots were dependent on the mass (g dry weight) of roots present; even in the absence of boundary layers, growth did not remain exponential over the entire culture period. Cryo-scanning electron microscopy showed that hairy roots grown submerged in liquid medium were covered with thick layers of hydrated mucilage and root hairs, representing a significant additional barrier to oxygen transfer. Roots protruding out of the liquid medium showed no evidence of mucilage accumulation. The specific oxygen demand of A. belladonna root tips was 3.3-11.5 times higher than for the remainder of the roots, the ratio increasing as the dissolved oxygen tension was reduced. Specific growth rates, biomass yields from sugar, and atropine levels were maximum at around 150% air saturation, but decreased significantly with oxygen concentrations above ca. 200%.     

Effect of cycling dissolved oxygen concentrations on product formation in penicillin fermentations

Summary Limitations in mass and momentum transfer coupled with high hydrostatic pressures create significant spatial variations in dissolved gas concentrations in large fermenters. Microorganisms are subjected to fluctuating environmental conditions as they pass through the zones in a stirred vessel or along a closed loop fermenter.A 7-litre fermenter was modified to simulate the dissolved gas and hydrostatic pressure gradients in large vessels.The effect of cycling dissolved oxygen tension (DOT) on penicillin production by Penicillium chrysogenum P1 was investigated. The fermentation was affected by evironmental conditions such as medium composition, pH, size of inoculum, stirrer speed and DOT. Inoculum size below 10% (v/v) and stirrer speeds above 850 rpm caused significant reductions in specific prenicillin production rates (q_pen). q_pen values were measured at different constant DOT levels. Below 30% air saturation q_pen decreased sharply and no production was observed at 10%. Penicillin synthesis was impaired irreversibly below 10% DOT. The same profile was observed at higher stirrer speeds and air flow rates indicating that the effect was a physiological one. Oxygen uptake of the culture was affected significantly below 7% DOT, demonstrating that the critical DOT values for penicillin production and oxygen uptake are two distinct parameters. Carrying out the fermentation at one atmosphere over pressure was found to have no effect. When the dissolved oxygen concentration of the culture medium was cycled around the critical DOT for penicillin production, a considerable decrease in the specific penicillin production rate was observed. The effect was reversible but not transient, indicating a shift in cell metabolism.These results demonstrate the unfavourable effect of fluctuating environmental conditions on culture performance in stirred tanks. They suggest that these effects should be accounted for during strain selection, process development and scale up stages of an industrial process if the productivities in small scale vessels are to be obtained.     

The role of aeration and agitation in the production of glucose oxidase in submerged culture

The influence of agitation and aeration on growth and on production of glucose oxidase of Asp. niger has been studied. It was found that both rate of growth and glucose oxidase production was higher at an agitation speed of 700 rpm than at 460 rpm. Further increase in speed of agitation resulted in neither a higher rate of growth nor a higher glucose oxidase activity. Total glucose oxidase activity was highest in a medium containing 5% sugar (at an agitation speed of 700 rpm) and did not get higher when the sugar concentration of the medium was increased to 7%. When pure oxygen was bubbled through the culture the rate of growth of the culture (in the linear phase) was 95 mg. mycelial dry wt./100 ml./hr., and only 61 mg. when air was applied. The glucose oxidase activity of oxygenated culture was double the activity of aerated culture. Viscosity of the homogenized culture became higher with higher concentration of mycelia. The viscosity of oxygenated culture was found to be lower than that of aerated culture.     

Dependence of morphology on agitation intensity in fed-batch cultures of Aspergillus oryzae and its implications for recombinant protein production

We previously reported that, although agitation conditions strongly affected mycelial morphology, such changes did not lead to different levels of recombinant protein production in chemostat cultures of Aspergillus oryzae (Amanullah et al., 1999). To extend this finding to another set of operating conditions, fed-batch fermentations of A. oryzae were conducted at biomass concentrations up to 34 g dry cell weight/L and three agitation speeds (525, 675, and 825 rpm) to give specific power inputs between 1 and 5 kWm(-3). Gas blending was used to control the dissolved oxygen level at 50% of air saturation except at the lowest speed where it fell below 40% after 60-65 h. The effects of agitation intensity on growth, mycelial morphology, hyphal tip activity, and recombinant protein (amyloglucosidase) production in fed-batch cultures were investigated. In the batch phase of the fermentations, biomass concentration, and AMG secretion increased with increasing agitation intensity. If in a run, dissolved oxygen fell below approximately 40% because of inadequate oxygen transfer associated with enhanced viscosity, AMG production ceased. As with the chemostat cultures, even though mycelial morphology was significantly affected by changes in agitation intensity, enzyme titers (AGU/L) under conditions of substrate limited growth and controlled dissolved oxygen of >50% did not follow these changes. Although the measurement of active tips within mycelial clumps was not considered, a dependency of the specific AMG productivity (AGU/g biomass/h) on the percentage of extending tips was found, suggesting that protein secretion may be a bottle-neck in this strain during fed-batch fermentations.     

Effects of dissolved oxygen concentration on hybridoma growth and metabolism in continuous culture

Oxygen transport is a major limitation in large-scale mammalian cell culture. The effects of the dissolved oxygen concentration (DO; from 0.1 to 100% saturation with air) on Sp2/0-derived mouse hybridomas were investigated using continuous culture. The steady-state concentration of viable cells increased with decreasing DO until a critical dissolved oxygen concentration of 0.5% of air saturation was reached. The cell concentration declined at lower DO because of incomplete glutamine oxidation, and the specific lactate production from glucose increased to offset the reduced energy production from glutamine. Cell viability increased as the DO was decreased; the viability continued to increase even when the DO was reduced below 0.5%. The specific oxygen uptake rate was essentially constant for DO greater than or equal to 10% of air saturation and then decreased with decreasing DO. The P/O ratio (ATP molecules produced per O atom consumed) appears to change from 2 to 3 between 10 and 0.5% DO. The specific ATP production rate calculated using this assumption decreases only slightly with decreasing DO. The optimum DO of 50% for antibody production is different than the optimum (approximately 0.5% DO) for cell growth.     

Production of rosmarinic acid by<Emphasis Type="Italic">Lavandula vera</Emphasis> MM cell suspension in bioreactor: effect of dissolved oxygen concentration and agitation

The relationship between dissolved oxygen (DO) concentration, agitation rate and growth of Lavandula vera MM and rosmarinic acid biosynthesis was investigated in 3 l laboratory bioreactor. Lavandula vera MM cell suspension accumulated the highest amounts of biomass (34.8 g/l) and rosmarinic acid (1870.6 mg/l) on day 12 of cultivation at 50% dissolved oxygen and agitation speed 100 rpm and at 30% dissolved oxygen and agitation speed 300 rpm, respectively.     

Impact of dissolved oxygen concentration on some key parameters and production of rhG-CSF in batch fermentation

The impact of different levels of agitation speed, carbondioxide and dissolved oxygen concentration on the key parameters and production of rhG-CSF in Escherichia coli BL21(DE3)PLysS were studied. Lower carbondioxide concentrations as well as higher agitation speeds and dissolved oxygen concentrations led to reduction in the acetate concentrations, and enhanced the cell growth, but inhibited plasmid stability and rhG-CSF expression. Similarly, higher carbondioxide concentrations and lower agitation speeds as well as dissolved oxygen concentrations led to enhanced acetate concentrations, but inhibited the cell growth and protein expression. To address the bottlenecks, a two-stage agitation control strategy (strategy-1) and two-stage dissolved oxygen control strategy (strategy-2) were employed to establish the physiological and metabolic conditions, so as to improve the expression of rhG-CSF. By adopting strategy-1 the yields were improved 1.4-fold over constant speed of 550 rpm, 1.1-fold over constant dissolved oxygen of 45%, respectively. Similarly, using strategy-2 the yields were improved 1.6-fold over constant speed of 550 rpm, 1.3-fold over constant dissolved oxygen of 45%, respectively.     

Enhancement of pyruvate production by Torulopsis glabrata using a two-stage oxygen supply control strategy

The effect of agitation speeds on the performance of producing pyruvate by a multi-vitamin auxotrophic yeast, Torulopsis glabrata, was investigated in batch fermentation. High pyruvate yield on glucose (0.797 g g(-1)) was achieved under high agitation speed (700 rpm), but the glucose consumption rate was rather low (1.14 g l(-1) h(-1)). Glucose consumption was enhanced under low agitation speed (500 rpm), but the pyruvate yield on glucose decreased to 0.483 g g(-1). Glycerol production was observed under low agitation speed and decreased with increasing agitation speed. Based on process analysis and carbon flux distribution calculation, a two-stage oxygen supply control strategy was proposed, in which the agitation speed was controlled at 700 rpm in the first 16 h and then switched to 500 rpm. This was experimentally proven to be successful. Relatively high concentration of pyruvate (69.4 g l(-1)), high pyruvate yield on glucose (0.636 g g(-1)), and high glucose consumption rate (1.95 g l(-1)h(-1)) were achieved by applying this strategy. The productivity (1.24 g l(-1) h(-1)) was improved by 36%, 23% and 31%, respectively, compared with fermentations in which agitation speeds were kept constant at 700 rpm, 600 rpm, and 500 rpm. Experimental results indicate that the difference between the performances for producing pyruvate under a favorable state of oxygen supply (dissolved oxygen concentration >50%) was caused by the different regeneration pathways of NADH generated from glycolysis.     

Effect of agitation and aeration on the citric acid production by Yarrowia lipolytica grown on glycerol

The effects of agitation rates from 400 to 900 rpm and aeration rates ranging from 0.18 to 0.6 vvm on biomass and citric acid production on glycerol media by acetate-negative mutants of Yarrowia lipolytica, Wratislavia 1.31 and Wratislavia AWG7, in batch culture were studied. The agitation rates of 800 and 900 rpm (at a constant aeration rate of 0.36 vvm) and aeration rates within the range of 0.24-0.48 vvm (at a constant agitation rate of 800 rpm), which generated dissolved oxygen concentration (DO) higher than 40%, were found the best for citric acid biosynthesis from glycerol. An increase in agitation rate (higher than 800 rpm) and aeration rate (higher than 0.36 vvm) had no impact on DO and citric acid production. The highest citric acid concentration (92.8 g/L) and yield (0.63 g/g) were obtained with Wratislavia 1.31 strain at 0.24 vvm. The highest volumetric citric acid production rate (1.15 g/Lh) and specific citric acid production rate (0.071 g/gh) were reached at 0.48 vvm.     

Improved poly-ε-lysine biosynthesis using Streptomyces noursei NRRL 5126 by controlling dissolved oxygen during fermentation

The growth kinetics of Streptomyces noursei NRRL 5126 was investigated under different aeration and agitation combinations in a 5.0 l stirred tank fermenter. Poly-epsilon-lysine biosynthesis, cell mass formation, and glycerol utilization rates were affected markedly by both aeration and agitation. An agitation speed of 300 rpm and aeration rate at 2.0 vvm supported better yields of 1,622.81 mg/l with highest specific productivity of 15 mg/l.h. Fermentation kinetics performed under different aeration and agitation conditions showed poly- epsilon-lysine fermentation to be a growth-associated production. A constant DO at 40% in the growth phase and 20% in the production phase increased the poly-epsilon-lysine yield as well as cell mass to their maximum values of 1,992.35 mg/l and 20.73 g/l, respectively. The oxygen transfer rate (OTR), oxygen utilization rate (OUR), and specific oxygen uptake rates (qO2) in the fermentation broth increased in the growth phase and remained unchanged in the stationary phase.     

Use of the glucose oxidase system to measure oxygen transfer rates

This investigation used the glucose oxidase system to simulate oxygen transfer rate in fermentation broths. It was demonstrated that the fungal preparation contained sufficient lactonase activity so that D -glucono-δ-lactone did not accumulate and that the rate of production of gluconic acid was proportional to the oxygen uptake rate. Enzyme concentrations of 1.5–2 g/1 were found adequate to determine oxygen absorption rates in shake flasks while maintaining the dissolved oxygen concentration of low levels. The apparent Michaelis constant for oxygen, K_m(O₂), was found to be 27% saturation with air; this value along with experimentally determined uptake rates could be used to calculate dissolved oxygen concentration in lieu of using a dissolved oxygen probe. Enzyme concentrations of 5 g/l were sufficient to give linear acid production and low dissolved oxygen concentrations in a bench-scale fermenter with no foaming or enzyme deactivation. The method is considered more valid and easier to employ than previously utilized techniques such as sulfite oxidation. Extension of the system to evaluating aeration effectiveness and scaleup of fermentation equipment is discussed.     

Comparative study on the influence of dissolved oxygen control approaches on the microbial hyaluronic acid production of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Streptococcus zooepidemicus</Emphasis>

Three different dissolved oxygen (DO) control approaches were proposed to improve hyaluronic acid (HA) production: a three-stage agitation speed control approach, a two-stage DO control approach, and an oxygen vector perfluorodecalin (PFC) applied approach. In the three-stage agitation speed control approach, agitation speed was 200 rpm during 0–8 h, 400 rpm during 8–12 h, and 600 rpm during 12–20 h. In the two-stage DO control strategy, DO was controlled at above 10% during 0–8 h and at 5% during 8–20 h. In the PFC applied approach, PFC (3% v/v) was added at 8 h. HA production reached 5.5 g/L in the three-stage agitation speed control culture model, and 6.3 g/L in two-stage DO control culture model, and 6.6 g/L in the PFC applied culture model. Compared with the other two DO control approaches, the PFC applied approach had a lower shear stress and thus a higher HA production was achieved.     

Influence of oxygen transfer on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pseudomonas putida</Emphasis> effects on growth rate and biodesulfurization capacity

The growth rate and desulfurization capacity accumulated by the cells during the growth of Pseudomonas putida KTH2 under different oxygen transfer conditions in a stirred and sparged tank bioreactor have been studied. Hydrodynamic conditions were changed using different agitation conditions. During the culture, several magnitudes associated to growth, such as the specific growth rate, the dissolved oxygen concentration and the carbon source consumption have been measured. Experimental results indicate that cultures are influenced by the fluid dynamic conditions into the bioreactor. An increase in the stirrer speed from 400 to 700 rpm has a positive influence on the cell growth rate. Nevertheless, the increase of agitation from 700 to 2000 rpm hardly has any influence on the growth rate. The effect of fluid dynamics on the cells development of the biodesulfurization (BDS) capacity of the cells during growth is different. The activities of the intracellular enzymes involved in the 4S pathway change with dissolved oxygen concentration. The enzyme activities have been evaluated in cells at several growth time and different hydrodynamic conditions. An increase of the agitation from 100 to 300 rpm has a positive influence on the development of the overall BDS capacity of the cells during growth. This capacity shows a decrease for higher stirrer speeds and the activity of the enzymes monooxygenases DszC and DszA decreases dramatically. The highest value of the activity of DszB enzyme was obtained with cells cultured at 100 rpm, while this activity decreases when the stirrer speed was increased higher than this value.