T cell regulation of B cell activation. An antigen-mediated tripartite interaction of Ts cells, Th cells, and B cells is required for suppression

To determine the requirements underlying the antigen specificity observed in T cell-mediated immune response suppression, cloned major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T suppressor (Ts) cells specific for keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and cloned MHC-restricted T helper (Th) cells specific for fowl gamma-globulin (FGG) were employed to study the regulation of trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific B cell responses. Neither antigen bridging between Ts cells and Th cells (FGG=KLH) nor bridging between Ts cells and B cells (TNP-KLH) was sufficient to allow suppression; a mixture of FGG=KLH and TNP-KLH was also insufficient for suppression. In contrast, suppression was induced by KLH-specific Ts cells only when suppressor determinants (KLH), helper determinants (FGG), and B cell determinants (TNP) were covalently linked on the same molecule (TMP-FGG)=(TNP-KLH) or TNP-(FGG=KLH)). These findings imply that a tripartite antigen-mediated interaction of Ts cells, Th cells, and responding B cells is necessary for the mediation of this antigen-specific suppression.     

Antigen-specific helper factor production by immortalized clone of OVA-specific T cells. I. In vitro activity

Immortalized clones of virally transformed OVA-specific T cells produce antigen-specific helper factor upon stimulation in vitro. The helper factor activate DNP-primed B cells to multiply and synthesize IgG anti-DNP antibodies. The trigger of the helper clone is antigen specific and the B cell-stimulating hapten must be coupled to the specific T cell carrier in order to transfer the help signal from the activated T clone to the B lymphocytes. Activation of the helper clone is performed by antigen-pulsed macrophages and cannot be achieved by the free soluble antigen. However, cell-free supernatant of the antigen-pulsed macrophages can stimulate the helper cells. Thus the antigenic determinant must be presented to the helper cell in the form of macrophage-processed antigen. These requirements for antigenic stimulation and the activity of the secreted helper factor demonstrate that the immortalized helper clone preserved the cellular components which control the antigen-specific immune function of the normal T lymphocyte.     

Cyclosporin A-induced autologous graft-versus-host disease: a prototypical model of autoimmunity and active (dominant) tolerance coordinately induced by recent thymic emigrants.

Cyclosporin A (CSA)-induced autologous graft-vs-host disease (autoGVHD) is an autoimmune syndrome initiated by autoeffector T cells presumed to be exported from the thymus during CSA treatment. The appearance of noncytotoxic immunoregulatory T cell activity after cessation of CSA treatment is also thymus dependent. In the present study, we have tested the hypothesis that both autoeffector and immunoregulatory T cells in CSA-treated rats are recent thymic emigrants (RTEs). Local syngeneic graft-vs-host reaction (synGVHR) and timed thymectomy (Tx) assays revealed that autoeffector T cells appear initially in the thymus and are promptly exported to lymph nodes (LN) during the first week of CSA treatment. In contrast, immunoregulatory thymocytes are first detectable by local synGVHR inhibition assays during the second week of CSA treatment but are not exported to LN until approximately 4 days post-CSA. Both the autoeffector and immunoregulatory T cells in LN express Thy-1, a selective marker for RTEs in the rat. However, the autoeffector RTEs have a CD4+8+ phenotype, whereas the immunoregulatory RTEs have a CD4+8- phenotype. Thus, the coordinate formation in and release from the thymus cortex and medulla of autoeffector and immunoregulatory T cells in CSA-treated rats directly demonstrates that centrally induced, nondeletional tolerance can serve as a fail-safe mechanism by which clones of autoeffector T cells that have escaped intrathymic negative selection for self-MHC class II Ag can be suppressed postthymically.     

T cell control of the antibody response to the T-independent antigen, DAGG-Ficoll

C57BL/6J nu/nu mice respond to the type 2 TI antigen DAGG-Ficoll, but not to the TD antigen SRC. A comparable difference can also be seen in vitro, but only at high spleen cell density and in the presence of selected batches of FBS. At low spleen cell density and in the absence of FBS, the DAGG-Ficoll-induced B cell response is strictly dependent on soluble helper factors or cloned specific helper T cells. The B cell response so induced requires that the T cell-depleted spleen cells be compatible in the I-A subregion of the H-2 complex. These helper factors, induced by antigen in an I-A-restricted T cell-macrophage interaction, provide helper for T cell-depleted spleen cells irrespective of their H-2 haplotype. Under conventional culture conditions, the stringent requirement for helper factors in the in vitro response to DAGG-Ficoll is obscured by FBS. In vitro culture of low numbers of spleen cells, in serum-free medium instead of FBS, provides a sensitive assay for helper factors. We have compared the helper activity for a B cell response to SRC or DAGG-Ficoll as provided by antigen-induced supernatants of various individual EA-specific T cell clones. There was a remarkable and consistent heterogeneity among individual T cell clones: their helper activity in the response to TI and TD antigens did not correlate, nor was there any correlation between helper activity and antigen-induced TCGF (interleukin 2) activity.     

Comparative functional analysis of helper T lymphocyte responses to soluble and particulate antigens

An adaptable and sensitive assay to analyze the roles of helper T lymphocytes (TH) which recognize soluble or cell-surface bound antigens in the induction of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTLp) is described. Long-term T cell lines that recognize purified protein derivative, keyhole limpet hemocyanin, or Corynebacterium parvum were used in these studies. The ability of T cells from these lines to induce cytotoxic T lymphocyte or antibody responses were compared with their ability to proliferate or release interleukin 2 (IL 2). The results demonstrate that these T cell lines are able to react to soluble antigen by proliferation and IL 2 release. Moreover, the same cell lines are able to interact with CTLp or with the precursors of antibody-secreting B cells to induce a response. In the induction of CTLp we observed an inverse correlation between the number of TH cells required and the concentration of antigen used to pulse the antigen presenting cells. However the correlation between the ability of TH lines to proliferate specifically in response to antigen and to act as helpers for CTLp and B cells was not absolute as cells with compromised proliferative capacity were able to efficiently deliver inductive signals.     

Development and characterization of interleukin-2-independent antigen-specific human T cell clones that produce multiple lymphokines

The development of antigen-specific T lymphocyte lines and clones has greatly facilitated the investigation of T-cell recognition of and response to foreign antigens. In the present study, human antigen-specific helper T cell lines and clones which are completely independent of exogenous interleukin-2 (IL-2) have been developed by cyclic restimulation with the soluble antigen keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) to which the T cell donor had previously been immunized. These T cells uniformly bear the OKT4 phenotype and were shown to require both histocompatible antigen-presenting cells (APC) and antigen for optimal proliferation. The T cell line was composed of a highly antigen-specific and clonable T cell population. Following four cycles of antigen stimulation, limiting dilution cloning analysis showed a Poisson distribution of clonable T cells with a precursor frequency of 0.62, and from 88 to 92% of viable clones were specific for the stimulating antigen. Individual clones were obtained which recognized KLH with either DR 1 (one parental Ia haplotype of the donor) or DR 2 (the other parental Ia haplotype) allogeneic APC, but not both. Following stimulation with KLH, the T cell clones produced IL-2. Peak amounts of IL-2 were assayable in the first 6 to 24 hr after stimulation. In contrast, virtually no IL-2 was detectable in supernatants at 72 to 96 hr, suggesting autoutilization by the proliferating T cells. In addition, some clones were also capable of producing both B cell growth factor and IL-2 following KLH stimulation. These IL-2-independent T cells appeared to be derived from a discrete Leu 8-negative subclass of T4⁺ cells and expressed the full complement of Ia antigen of the donor. Thus, soluble antigen-specific human helper T cell clones have been produced which can be maintained in the absence of exogenous IL-2, elaborate their own growth factors and other immunoregulatory lymphokines, and show fine DR-related restriction to either one or the other parental DR haplotypes in antigen-stimulated proliferative responses.     

Macrophages and T cells control distinct phases of B cell differentiation in the humoral immune response in vitro

The differentiation of B cells in the in vitro PFC-response to red blood cell antigen proceeds through 2 phases. Antigen-reactive B cells acquire the ability to interact with helper T cells in the first phase. This phase is controlled by macrophages through a mediator that they release (Interleukin 1 ([Il-1]). B cells convert into antibody-secreting cells (PFC) in the second phase, which is controlled by helper T cells or by a mediator that they release (T cell-replacing factors [TRF]). This is demonstrated in experiments in which Il-1 increases the number of B cells capable of responding to T cell help. The majority of antigen-reactive B cells reaches that state of differentiation within 40 hr of incubation with Il-1. After this time, the response of B cells depends no longer on the presence of Il-1 but on the presence of T cells or TRF. The presented data suggest that antigen-primed helper T cells (but not unprimed T cells) induce the release of Il-1 by macrophages, thereby also influencing the early phase of B cell differentiation.     

Differences in the regulation of humoral responses between mice infected with Trypanosoma cruzi and mice administered T. cruzi-induced suppressor substance

In the present study, the effects of Trypanosoma cruzi and the T. cruzi-induced serum suppressor substance (SSS) on antibody responses were compared. Although infection with T. cruzi led to an alteration in T cell helper activity and a reduced specific B cell precursor frequency, SSS did not have a similar effect on either of these cell populations. The characteristics of the altered T cell helper activity was further investigated, and it was found that helper activity appeared earlier in infected mice than in normal or SSS-suppressed mice, and less antigen was required for optimal elicitation of T helper cells in infected mice. The potency of T cell helper activity also was shown to differ, and in the order T. cruzi-infected 6E normal 6E SSS-suppressed mice. It was found that spleen cells from T. cruzi-infected mice elaborated more potent specific helper factors than spleen cells from normal or SSS-suppressed mice, but did not produce a detectable nonspecific helper factor in vitro. Finally, the addition of B cells from low-dose primed, T. cruzi-infected mice to cultures of normal spleen cells resulted in subnormal responses to the priming antigen (sheep erythrocytes) but not to another unrelated antigen (trinitrophenyl-haptenated Brucella abortus), whereas similarly sensitized B cells from normal or SSS-suppressed mice caused no such effect.     

Transfer of memory cells into antigen-pretreated hosts. I. Functional detection of migration sites for antigen-specific B cells.

The distribution of functionally active hapten-specific B memory cells was investigated. Using antigen-pretreated lethally irradiated recipients, a marked accumulation of adoptively transferred B memory cells was demonstrated in lymph nodes containing specific antigen, but not in lymph nodes containing non-cross-reacting hapten conjugates. This difference in responsiveness between lymph nodes containing specific versus those containing nonspecific antigen developed over a period 3–5 days after memory cell transfer. The localization of antigen specific cells was T-cell independent; both carrier-primed T helper cells and specific antigenic challenge, however, were required to trigger the localized B memory cells into antibody production. Specific B memory cell accumulation did not result from an expansion of the antigen-specific cell population due to local proliferation induced by antigen depots in the lymph nodes to challenge. Rather, the results indicated that recirculating B memory cells had progressively accumulated through retention by antigen in the lymph node. These findings suggest that, in the absence of T-cell help and specific antigenic challenge, B memory cells accumulate in lymphoid tissue (follicles) without responding and provide persistent local memory for the humoral immune response.     

Helper cell factors restore antibody responses of allogeneic bone marrow chimeras: evidence for ineffective cellular interactions

We investigated the nature of deficient antibody responses to SRBC in stable, fully allogeneic bone marrow chimeras. No evidence for a suppressor cell-mediated mechanism was found. Chimera spleens possessed adequate numbers of antigen-reactive B cells to produce a normal antibody response. Using separated chimera cell populations and soluble helper factors, we assessed the functional capabilities of chimera B cells, T cells, and macrophages. Our data suggest that the failure of allogeneic chimeras to produce antibody is not the result of impaired B cell, T cell, or macrophage function, but rather that it is due in ineffective cellular interactions that normally result in the generation of helper factors. In vitro stimulation of chimera macrophages with LPS, and of chimera spleen cells with Con A, resulted in the release of soluble helper factors that were capable of fully restoring chimera B cell responses.     

Two types of murine helper T cell clone. II. Delayed-type hypersensitivity is mediated by TH1 clones

We have previously shown that at least two types of Lyt-1+, Lyt-2-, L3T4+ helper T cell clones can be distinguished in vitro by different patterns of lymphokine secretion and by different forms of B cell help. Evidence is presented here to show that one type of helper T cell clone (TH1) causes delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) when injected with the appropriate antigen into the footpads of naive mice. The antigen-specific, major histocompatability complex (MHC)-restricted footpad swelling reaction peaked at approximately 24 hr. Footpad swelling was induced by all TH1 clones tested so far, including clones specific for soluble, particulate, or allogeneic antigens. In contrast, local transfer of TH2 cells and antigen did not produce a DTH reaction, even when supplemented with syngeneic spleen accessory cells. Similarly, local transfer of an alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocyte clone into appropriate recipients did not produce DTH. The requirements for the DTH reaction induced by TH1 cells were investigated further by using TH1 clones with dual specificity for both foreign antigens and M1s antigens. Although these clones responded in vitro to either antigen + syngeneic presenting cells, or M1s disparate spleen cells, they responded in vivo only to antigen + MHC and did not cause footpad swelling in an M1s-disparate mouse in the absence of antigen. Moreover, in vitro preactivation of TH1 or TH2 cells with the lectin concanavalin A was insufficient to induce DTH reactions upon subsequent injection into footpads. From these results, we conclude that the lack of DTH given by TH2 clones in vivo could be due to the inability of the TH2 cells to produce the correct mediators of DTH, or to a lack of stimulation of TH2 clones in the footpad environment.     

Helper T cell lines to major and to minor histocompatibility antigens are equally effective in the regulation of B cell responses in vivo

Long-term lines of helper T (Th) cells, reactive to minor histocompatibility (minor-H) antigens, were grown by antigen restimulation in the absence of exogenous interleukin-2. These lines were antigen specific and H-2b restricted. When introduced in vivo by adoptive transfer, these Th cells helped syngeneic B cells in an antibody response to other alloantigens. Linked recognition was required for effective help to occur, this suggests B cell presentation of antigen to Th cells in vivo. Parallel titration experiments performed with long-term cultured Th lines to MHC and to minor-H antigens showed that, on a per cell basis, they are equivalent in their ability to help in vivo B cell responses. This shows that any inability to produce antisera to minor-H antigens is not due to a Th or APC defect, but results from either a B cell defect or from suppression.     

Cloned protein antigen-specific, Ia-restricted T cells with both helper and cytolytic activities: mechanisms of activation and killing

Myoglobin-specific, Iad-restricted cloned helper T cells and T hybridomas were found to directly kill Iad-bearing, myoglobin-pulsed B lymphoma targets and could also kill bystander targets, but only in the presence of antigen-pulsed antigen presenting cells (APC). The induction of the killing requires recognition of processed antigen in the context of class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. Despite the specificity of induction, the bystander killing suggests a nonspecific lytic mechanism. The direct killing can be inhibited only by cold specific targets, whereas the bystander killing can be blocked by both specific and nonspecific targets. The cold target inhibition seems to be due to interference with effector-to-target contact or proximity rather than due to high-dose suppression of T-cell activation. Experiments using T-cell supernatants or cyclosporin A suggested that the helper T cells kill targets by synthesizing short-range soluble factor(s) with nonspecific killing activity de novo during the effector phase, but only while antigen-specific signal transduction is occurring. The mechanism of cold target inhibition appears to be absorption or consumption of a short-acting cytotoxic lymphokine by cells which must be able to interact closely with the effector cell. Normal spleen B cells, despite their capability for activating the helper T cells, cannot inhibit specific killing or be killed by helper T cells, even after lipopolysaccharide stimulation. Thus, although killing by helper T cells may play a negative feedback role in the normal immune response, our data raise the possibility that the helper T-cell-mediated killing may contribute to the immune surveillance against malignancy by virtue of the preferential killing of tumor cells either directly or indirectly.     

Maintenance of hyporesponsiveness to antigen by a distinct subclass of T lymphocytes.

Immunization with increasing doses of SRBC, in excess of 10(8), results in a progressive decline in the anti-SRBC PFC response. This hyporesponsive state is antigen specific and is reflected in a decrease of both T helper and B antibody-forming activity. We asked whether the apparent defect of T helper activity reflected a) an absence of alphaSRBC helper T cell activity, or b) the presence of SRBC-specific suppressor T cells within the hyporesponsive population. Our results indicate that at least a portion of hyporesponsiveness noted after antigen exposure to large doses of antigen can be ascribed to specific suppressor T cell activation. Fractionation of the suppressive T cell population using Ly antiserum showed that specific suppressive activity was mediated by a subclass of T cells (Ly2+), distinct from that committed to express helper function (Ly1).     

Soluble factor-independent stimulation of human B cell response by mouse thymoma cells. Cyclosporine A-resistant and -sensitive cell contact signals

In a Th cell-dependent antibody response, the Th act on B cells partly via a helper activity that is cell contact-dependent and cyclosporine A (CsA)-resistant. This activity seems to be required to induce responsiveness of the B cells toward T cell-derived soluble factors (cytokines) generally believed to be essential for B cell proliferation as well as for Ig secretion. In our study, we have investigated a system in which human B cells are stimulated by mutant EL-4 thymoma cells of mouse origin. It was found that human B cells proliferate and secrete Ig (either 1) in the presence of EL-4 cells plus human T cell supernatant (T-SUP), or 2) in the presence of EL-4 cells alone which have been induced with PMA or IL-1. The first situation conformed to the known synergy between CsA-resistant Th signal and cytokines. However, the B response due to PMA-induced EL-4 cells was special. The PMA-inducible helper activity was CsA-sensitive at the same CsA concentration that inhibited IL-2 secretion of EL-4 cells, but the murine factors in EL-4 supernatant had no effect on human B cells; the helper effect did not occur across a semipermeable membrane. Any contribution of soluble factors from contaminating human T cells was ruled out by adding single human B cells by flow microfluorimetry to cultures with EL-4 cells and PMA. Such B cells generated clonal IgM, IgG, and/or IgA responses. CsA, thus, interfered with some cell contact-mediated signal. However, CsA did not reduce the amount of LFA-1 molecules on EL-4 cells. In conclusion, EL-4 cells can induce proliferation and differentiation of human B cells in a soluble factor-independent manner, via CsA-resistant and CsA-sensitive helper activities. This may represent an alternative pathway of B cell activation.     

Molecular programming of B cell memory

The development of high-affinity B cell memory is regulated through three separable phases, each involving antigen recognition by specific B cells and cognate T helper cells. Initially, antigen-primed B cells require cognate T cell help to gain entry into the germinal centre pathway to memory. Once in the germinal centre, B cells with variant B cell receptors must access antigens and present them to germinal centre T helper cells to enter long-lived memory B cell compartments. Following antigen recall, memory B cells require T cell help to proliferate and differentiate into plasma cells. A recent surge of information - resulting from dynamic B cell imaging in vivo and the elucidation of T follicular helper cell programmes - has reshaped the conceptual landscape surrounding the generation of memory B cells. In this Review, we integrate this new information about each phase of antigen-specific B cell development to describe the newly unravelled molecular dynamics of memory B cell programming.     

IL 2 restores memory B cell activation by antigen-specific T cell clone variants

It has recently been demonstrated that there are at least two separate pathways by which a single keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) reactive T cell clone can induce B cell differentiation. With the use of the high-dose antigen-driven system (10 micrograms/ml trinitrophenyl (TNP)-KLH), a KLH-specific T cell clone was able to induce a primary anti-TNP response in unprimed B cells. In the presence of aliquots of the same T cell clone, a low-dose of antigen (5 X 10(-2) micrograms/ml TNP-KLH) induced an immunoglobulin (Ig)G response in primed B cells. It has also been demonstrated that there are variant subclones of such KLH-specific helper T cell clones that are unable to provide antigen-specific help in the presence of low-dose antigen but maintain the high-dose antigen-driven helper response. This study was undertaken to investigate whether interleukin 2 (IL 2) had some activity in the low-dose, antigen-driven response induced by the T cell clone. With the use of a variant T cell clone (which lost low-dose, antigen-driven helper activity), it was demonstrated that IL 2 was capable of reconstituting the low-dose, antigen-driven helper activity. To investigate whether accessory cells were required in this system, we removed the adherent cell population from the primed spleen cells added to culture. Interestingly, removal of the G10-adherent cells eliminated the low-dose, antigen-driven response induced by IL 2. Additionally by add-back experiments, we were able to demonstrate that the necessary adherent cell population did not require major histocompatibility complex (MHC) restriction for reconstitution of the IL 2-dependent, low-dose, antigen-driven response. Furthermore, 1% concanavalin A (Con A) supernatant (Sn), but not interleukin 1 (IL 1), could replace this adherent cell function. These data suggest that in this system, IL 2 bypasses the MHC-restricted interaction between T cells and antigen-charged adherent cells; B cells can present antigen to cloned helper T cells efficiently for primary responses but need an added factor(s) to induce IgG production; and adherent cells are essential for IgG production in primed B cells, possibly through the release of soluble factor(s) included in Con A Sn.     

T cell development in B cell-deficient mice. IV. The role of B cells as antigen-presenting cells in vivo

B cell-deficient, rabbit anti-mouse IgM-treated mice were compared with normal or normal rabbit immunoglobulin-treated controls in their ability to develop proliferative T cell responses, delayed hypersensitivity, and primary or secondary cytotoxic T cell responses. Immunization with hapten-coupled autologous spleen cells resulted in anti-mu-treated mice generating only marginal T cell responses. This decreased responsiveness was shown to be attributable not to an intrinsic T cell defect or to changes in the ability of macrophages from anti-mu-treated mice to present soluble antigen, but rather to the greatly diminished capacity of B cell-deficient spleen cells to present antigen. The results support the concept that B cells play a significant role in antigen presentation required for T cell activation.     

Requirements for triggering of lysis by cytolytic T lymphocyte clones

Cloned murine cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) having defined specificity were triggered by the phorbol ester together with a calcium ionophore (either A23187 or Ionomycin) to lyse syngeneic or third party target cells efficiently. Neither phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) nor calcium ionophore alone induced efficient lysis. The characteristics of the lytic process induced by these signals are similar to those of antigen-specific or lectin-facilitated lysis by CTL. Lysis is calcium and temperature dependent and shows kinetics which are not grossly different from lysis mediated via the antigen receptor. Two helper T lymphocyte clones were not induced to lyse efficiently EL-4 target cells by concanavalin A or PMA + ionophore. Triggering of lysis induced with PMA plus ionophore by the CTL clone L3 differed from antigen-mediated lysis in specificity and in the susceptibility to inhibition by cytochalasin B. Properties of the target cell determine which cell surface associative recognition structures are important in the efficient lysis of these cells. Anti-LFA-1 monoclonal antibodies inhibited efficiently both antigen-mediated and PMA + ionophore-induced lysis of P-815 or EL-4 target cells which are of hematopoietic origin. However, anti-LFA-1 antibodies do not inhibit antigen-mediated, lectin-facilitated, or PMA + Ionomycin-induced CTL cytolysis of target cells derived from the L cell fibroblast line. We conclude that two intracellular signals, which can be provided by the combination of PMA + ionophore, are required for efficient lysis by antigen-specific murine CTL clones. When the T cell receptor for antigen is bypassed using PMA + ionophore to trigger lysis, we show that Lyt-2 and LFA-1 molecules may be required for efficient lysis. These associative recognition structures appear to play an important role in postactivation steps leading to efficient delivery of the lethal hit to the target cell.     

Antigen-specific B cells efficiently present low doses of antigen for induction of T cell proliferation

Previous experiments suggested a role for specific B cells in the induction of antigen (SRBC)-specific T cell proliferation. Two models were proposed: in the first, B cells directly presented antigen to T cells; alternatively, B cells secreted antibody, which opsonized antigen for presentation by macrophages. Experiments to distinguish between these possibilities are presented here. Three lines of evidence support the conclusion that antigen is presented directly by specific B cells. First, nonimmune splenic adherent cells (SAC), which efficiently induced proliferation of appropriately primed T cells to antigens such as OVA and GAT, were unable to induce SRBC-specific proliferation. Secondly, a slope analysis of the logarithmic plot of T cell proliferation vs the number of irradiated B cells suggested that two cells were limiting within the presenting population. The addition of IL 1 or SAC reduced the slope to 1 (although in serum-free conditions, the addition of IL 1, but not SAC, reduced the slope of the line). Specificity of the B cells for the antigen continued to be required in the presence of exogenous IL 1 or SAC. These results suggested that presentation by specific B cells and the amount of IL 1 were the limiting requirements for the induction of SRBC-specific T cell proliferation. The third line of evidence was the demonstration of a restricted interaction between T cells and B cells. The addition of irradiated, allogeneic SRBC-specific B cells to T cell lines and syngeneic SAC failed to support proliferative responses. We further show that a GAT-specific T cell clone was triggered to proliferate by either SAC or B cells, but that antigen-specific B cells were necessary at low doses of antigen. This finding is important in two respects. First, the T cell clone previously has been shown to act as a helper; secondly, when low doses of antigen are used, the requirement for priming of the B cells to the specific antigen is true for a soluble, as well as a particulate, antigen. We propose that at low (physiologic) doses of antigen, presentation to secondary T cells takes place mainly at the surface of antigen-specific B cells. At high doses of antigen,h presentation can also be accomplished by nonspecific cells such as other B cells, macrophages, or dendritic cells.