Recognition of the DNA minor groove by pyrrole-imidazole polyamides: comparison of desmethyl- and N-methylpyrrole

Polyamides consisting of N-methylpyrrole (Py), N-methylimidazole (Im), and N-methyl-3-hydroxypyrrole (Hp) are synthetic ligands that recognize predetermined DNA sequences with affinities and specificities comparable to many DNA-binding proteins. As derivatives of the natural products distamycin and netropsin, Py/Im/Hp polyamides have retained the N-methyl substituent, although structural studies of polyamide:DNA complexes have not revealed an obvious function for the N-methyl. In order to assess the role of the N-methyl moiety in polyamide:DNA recognition, a new monomer, desmethylpyrrole (Ds), where the N-methyl moiety has been replaced with hydrogen, was incorporated into an eight-ring hairpin polyamide by solid-phase synthesis. MPE footprinting, affinity cleavage, and quantitative DNase I footprinting revealed that replacement of each Py residue with Ds resulted in identical binding site size and orientation and similar binding affinity for the six-base-pair (bp) target DNA sequence. Remarkably, the Ds-containing polyamide exhibited an 8-fold loss in specificity for the match site versus a mismatched DNA site, relative to the all-Py parent. Polyamides with Ds exhibit increased water solubility, which may alter the cell membrane permeability properties of the polyamide. The addition of Ds to the repertoire of available monomers may prove useful as polyamides are applied to gene regulation in vivo. However, the benefits of Ds incorporation must be balanced with a potential loss in specificity.     

Expanding the recognition of the minor groove of DNA by incorporation of beta-alanine in hairpin polyamides

In order to expand the recognition code by hairpin polyamides to include DNA sequences of the type 5'-CWWC-3' two polyamides, PyPyPyPy-(R)(H2N)gamma-ImPyPyIm-beta-Dp (1) and PyPyPyPy-(R)(H2N)gamma-ImPy-beta-Im-beta-Dp (2) were synthesized which have in common an Py/Im pair in the terminal position for targeting C x G but differ with respect to internal placement of a beta-alanine residue. The equilibrium association constants (Ka) were determined at four DNA sites which differ at a single common position, 5'-TNTACA-3' (N = T, A, G, C). Quantitative DNase I footprint titration experiments reveal that the eight-ring hairpin PyPyPyPy-(R)(H2N)gamma-ImPyPyIm-beta-Dp (1) binds the four binding sites with similar affinities, Ka = 1.3-1.9 x 10(10) M(-1) indicating that there is no preference for the position N. In contrast, a redesigned polyamide PyPyPyPy-(R)(H2N)gamma-ImPy-beta-Im-beta-Dp (2) that places an internal flexible aliphatic beta-alanine to the 5'-side of a key imidazole group bound the match site 5'-TCTACA-3' with high affinity and good sequence discrimination (Ka(match) = 4.9 x 10(10) M(-1) and the single base pair mismatch sites with 5- to 25-fold lower affinity). These results expand the repertoire of sequences targetable by hairpins and emphasize the importance of beta-alanine as a key element for minor groove recognition.     

Sequence-specific DNA binding by long hairpin pyrrole–imidazole polyamides containing an 8-amino-3,6-dioxaoctanoic acid unit

With the aim of improving aqueous solubility, we designed and synthesized five N-methylpyrrole (Py)–N-methylimidazole (Im) polyamides capable of recognizing 9-bp sequences. Their DNA-binding affinities and sequence specificities were evaluated by SPR and Bind-n-Seq analyses. The design of polyamide 1 was based on a conventional model, with three consecutive Py or Im rings separated by a β-alanine to match the curvature and twist of long DNA helices. Polyamides 2 and 3 contained an 8-amino-3,6-dioxaoctanoic acid (AO) unit, which has previously only been used as a linker within linear Py–Im polyamides or between Py–Im hairpin motifs for tandem hairpin. It is demonstrated herein that AO also functions as a linker element that can extend to 2-bp in hairpin motifs. Notably, although the AO-containing unit can fail to bind the expected sequence, polyamide 4, which has two AO units facing each other in a hairpin form, successfully showed the expected motif and a K_D value of 16 nM was recorded. Polyamide 5, containing a β-alanine–β-alanine unit instead of the AO of polyamide 2, was synthesized for comparison. The aqueous solubilities and nuclear localization of three of the polyamides were also examined. The results suggest the possibility of applying the AO unit in the core of Py–Im polyamide compounds.     

Energetic basis for selective recognition of T*G mismatched base pairs in DNA by imidazole-rich polyamides

To complement available structure and binding results and to develop a detailed understanding of the basis for selective molecular recognition of T·G mismatches in DNA by imidazole containing polyamides, a full thermodynamic profile for formation of the T·G–polyamide complex has been determined. The amide-linked heterocycles f-ImImIm and f-PyImIm (where f is formamido group, Im is imidazole and Py is pyrrole) were studied by using biosensor-surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) with a T·G mismatch containing DNA hairpin duplex and a similar DNA with only Watson–Crick base pairs. Large negative binding enthalpies for all of the polyamide–DNA complexes indicate that the interactions are enthalpically driven. SPR results show slower complex formation and stronger binding of f-ImImIm to the T·G than to the match site. The thermodynamic analysis indicates that the enhanced binding to the T·G site is the result of better entropic contributions. Negative heat capacity changes for the complex are correlated with calculated solvent accessible surface area changes and indicate hydrophobic contributions to complex formation. DNase I footprinting analysis in a long DNA sequence provided supporting evidence that f-ImImIm binds selectively to T·G mismatch sites.     

Alternative heterocycles for DNA recognition: a 3-pyrazole/pyrrole pair specifies for G.C base pairs

Synthetic ligands comprising three aromatic amino acids, pyrrole (Py), imidazole (Im), and hydroxypyrrole (Hp), specifically recognize predetermined sequences as side-by-side pairs in the minor groove of DNA. To expand the repertoire of aromatic rings that may be utilized for minor groove recognition, three five-membered heterocyclic rings, 3-pyrazolecarboxylic acid (3-Pz), 4-pyrazolecarboxylic acid (4-Pz), and furan-2-carboxylic acid (Fr), were examined at the N-terminus of eight-ring hairpin polyamide ligands. The DNA binding properties of 3-Pz, 4-Pz, and Fr each paired with Py were studied by quantitative DNase I footprinting titrations on a 283 bp DNA restriction fragment containing four 6-bp binding sites 5'-ATNCCTAA-3' (N = G, C, A, or T; 6-bp polyamide binding site is underlined). The pair 3-Pz/Py has increased binding affinity and sequence specificity for G.C bp compared with Im/Py.     

Binding of hairpin pyrrole and imidazole polyamides to DNA: relationship between torsion angle and association rate constants

N-methylpyrrole (Py)-N-methylimidazole (Im) polyamides are small organic molecules that bind to DNA with sequence specificity and can be used as synthetic DNA-binding ligands. In this study, five hairpin eight-ring Py–Im polyamides 1–5 with different number of Im rings were synthesized, and their binding behaviour was investigated with surface plasmon resonance assay. It was found that association rate (k_a) of the Py–Im polyamides with their target DNA decreased with the number of Im in the Py–Im polyamides. The structures of four-ring Py–Im polyamides derived from density functional theory revealed that the dihedral angle of the Py amide carbonyl is 14∼18°, whereas that of the Im is significantly smaller. As the minor groove of DNA has a helical structure, planar Py–Im polyamides need to change their conformation to fit it upon binding to the minor groove. The data explain that an increase in planarity of Py–Im polyamide induced by the incorporation of Im reduces the association rate of Py–Im polyamides. This fundamental knowledge of the binding of Py–Im polyamides to DNA will facilitate the design of hairpin Py–Im polyamides as synthetic DNA-binding modules.     

Structure of a beta-alanine-linked polyamide bound to a full helical turn of purine tract DNA in the 1:1 motif

Polyamides composed of N-methylpyrrole (Py), N-methylimidazole (Im) and N-methylhydroxypyrrole (Hp) amino acids linked by beta-alanine (beta) bind the minor groove of DNA in 1:1 and 2:1 ligand to DNA stoichiometries. Although the energetics and structure of the 2:1 complex has been explored extensively, there is remarkably less understood about 1:1 recognition beyond the initial studies on netropsin and distamycin. We present here the 1:1 solution structure of ImPy-beta-Im-beta-ImPy-beta-Dp bound in a single orientation to its match site within the DNA duplex 5'-CCAAAGAGAAGCG-3'.5'-CGCTTCTCTTTGG-3' (match site in bold), as determined by 2D (1)H NMR methods. The representative ensemble of 12 conformers has no distance constraint violations greater than 0.13 A and a pairwise RMSD over the binding site of 0.80 A. Intermolecular NOEs place the polyamide deep inside the minor groove, and oriented N-C with the 3'-5' direction of the purine-rich strand. Analysis of the high-resolution structure reveals the ligand bound 1:1 completely within the minor groove for a full turn of the DNA helix. The DNA is B-form (average rise=3.3 A, twist=38 degrees ) with a narrow minor groove closing down to 3.0-4.5 A in the binding site. The ligand and DNA are aligned in register, with each polyamide NH group forming bifurcated hydrogen bonds of similar length to purine N3 and pyrimidine O2 atoms on the floor of the minor groove. Each imidazole group is hydrogen bonded via its N3 atom to its proximal guanine's exocyclic amino group. The important roles of beta-alanine and imidazole for 1:1 binding are discussed.     

DNA minor-groove recognition by 3-methylthiophene/pyrrole pair

Hairpin polyamides are synthetic oligomers, which fold and bind to specific DNA sequences in a programmable manner. Internal side-by-side pairings of the aromatic amino acid residues 1-methyl-1H-pyrrole (Py), 1-methyl-1H-imidazole (Im), and 3-hydroxy-1-methyl-1H-pyrrole (Hp) confer the ability to distinguish between all four Watson-Crick base pairs in the minor groove of B-form DNA. In a broad search to expand the heterocycle repertoire, we found that when 3-methylthiophene (Tn), which presents a S-atom to the minor groove, is paired with Py, it exhibits a modest threefold specificity for TA>AT presumably by shape-selective recognition. In this study, we explore the scope and limitations of this lead by incorporating multiple Tn residues within a single hairpin polyamide. It was found that hairpin polyamides containing more that one Tn/Py pair exhibit lowered affinities and specificities for their match sites. It appears that little deviation is permissible from the parent five-membered ring 1-methyl-1H-pyrrole-2-carboxamide scaffold for DNA recognition.     

Oligonucleotide--minor groove binder 1:2 conjugates: side by side parallel minor groove binder motif in stabilization of DNA duplex

Synthetic polycarboxamides consisting of N-methylpyrrole (Py), N-methylimidazole (Im), N-methyl-3-hydroxypyrrole (Hp) and beta-alanine (beta) show strong and sequence-specific interaction with the DNA minor groove when they form hairpin structures with side-by-side antiparallel motifs. In the present paper, new conjugates containing two ligands linked to the same terminal phosphate of DNA strand were constructed. The paper describes optimized synthesis and properties of oligonucleotide-linked polyamide strands that insert into the minor groove of a duplex in a parallel or antiparallel orientation. Strong stabilization of DNA duplexes by two attached minor groove ligands is demonstrated by the thermal denaturation method. The unmodified duplex 5'-CGTTTATTp-3'/5'-AATAAACG-3' melts at 20 degrees C. When one tetra(Py) residue was attached to the first strand of this duplex, denaturation temperature was increased to 46 degrees C; attachment of the second tetra(Py) in a parallel orientation resulted in denaturation temperature of 60 degrees C. It is even higher than in case of "classic" octapyrrole hairpin ligand (Tm = 58 degrees C). Sequence-specific character of stabilization by two conjugated ligands was demonstrated for G:C-containing oligonucleotides attached to tetracarboxamide and octacarboxamide ligands constructed from Py, Im and beta units according to established recognition rules (deltaTm = 20 degrees C). The two-strand parallel minor groove binder constructions attached to addressing oligonucleotides could be considered as site-specific ligands recognizing single- and double-stranded DNA similarly to already described hairpin MGB structures with antiparallel orientation of carboxamide units.     

Synthesis and DNA binding properties of 1-(3-aminopropyl)-imidazole-containing triamide f-Im(∗)PyIm: A novel diamino polyamide designed to target 5'-ACGCGT-3'

A novel diamino/dicationic polyamide f-Im(?)PyIm (5) that contains an orthogonally positioned aminopropyl chain on an imidazole (Im(?)) moiety was designed to target 5'-ACGCGT-3'. The DNA binding properties of the diamino polyamide 5, determined by CD, ΔT(M), DNase I footprinting, SPR, and ITC studies, were compared with those of its monoamino/monocationic counterpart f-ImPyIm (1) and its diamino/dicationic isomer f-ImPy(?)Im (2), which has the aminopropyl group attached to the central pyrrole unit (Py(?)). The results gave evidence for the minor groove binding and selectivity of polyamide 5 for the cognate sequence 5'-ACGCGT-3', and with strong affinity (K(eq)=2.3×10(7)M(-1)). However, the binding affinities varied according to the order: f-ImPy(?)Im (2)>f-ImPyIm (1)?f-Im(?)PyIm (5) confirming that the second amino group can improve affinity, but its position within the polyamide can affect affinity.     

Effect of single pyrrole replacement with β-alanine on DNA binding affinity and sequence specificity of hairpin pyrrole/imidazole polyamides targeting 5′-GCGC-3′

N-Methylpyrrole (Py)–N-methylimidazole (Im) polyamides are small organic molecules that can recognize predetermined DNA sequences with high sequence specificity. As many eukaryotic promoter regions contain highly GC-rich sequences, it is valuable to synthesize and characterize Py–Im polyamides that recognize GC-rich motifs. In this study, we synthesized four hairpin Py–Im polyamides 1–4, which recognize 5′-GCGC-3′ and investigated their binding behavior with surface plasmon resonance assay. Py–Im polyamides 2–4 contain two, one, and one β-alanine units, replacing the Py units of 1, respectively. The binding affinities of 2–4 to the target DNA increased 430, 390, and 610-fold, respectively, over that of 1. The association and dissociation rates of 2 to the target DNA were improved by 11 and 37-fold, respectively, compared with those of 1. Interestingly, the association and dissociation rates of 3 and 4 were higher than those of 2, even though the binding affinities of 2, 3, and 4 to the target DNA were comparable to each other. The binding affinity of 2 to DNA with a 2 bp mismatch was reduced by 29-fold, compared with that to the matched DNA. Moreover, the binding affinities of 3 and 4 to the same mismatched DNA were reduced by 270 and 110-fold, respectively, indicating that 3 and 4 have greater specificities than 2 and are suitable as DNA-binding modules for engineered epigenetic regulation.     

Hairpin Polyamides That use Parallel and Antiparallel Side-by-Side Peptide Motifs in Binding to DNA

Abstract

Pt-bis-netropsin is a synthetic sequence-specific DNA-binding ligand comprizing two netropsin-like fragments which are linked in a tail-to-tail manner via a cis-diammineplat-inum (II) residue. The CD studies and thermodynamic characterization of the DNA-binding properties exhibited by this compound reveal that it forms two types of complexes with poly[d(AT)]?poly[d(AT)] and DNA oligomers containing nucleotide sequences 5′-CC (TA)_nCC-3′, with n = 4, 5 and 6. The first type corresponds to the binding of Pt-bis-netropsin in the extended conformation and is characterized by the saturating ratio of one bound Pt-bis-netropsin molecule per 9 AT-base pairs. The second type of the complex corresponds to the binding of Pt-bis-netropsin to DNA in the folded hairpin form. The binding approaches saturation level when one Pt-bis-netropsin molecule is bound per four or five AT-base pairs. The hairpin form of Pt-bis-netropsin complex is built on the basis of parallel side-by-side peptide motif which is inserted in the minor DNA groove. The CD spectral profiles reflecting the binding of Pt-bis-netropsin in the hairpin form are different from those observed for binding of another bis-netropsin with the sequence Lys-Gly-Py-Py-Gly-Gly-Gly-Py-Py-Dp, where Py is a N-propylpyrrole amino acid residue and Dp is a dimethylaminopropylamino residue. The hairpin form of this bis-netropsin is formed on the basis of antiparallel side- by-side peptide motif. The CD spectra obtained for complexes of this polyamide in the hairpin form with poly[dAT)]?poly[d(AT)] exhibit positive CD band with a peak at 325 nm, whereas the CD spectral profiles for the second complex of Pt-bis-Nt with poly[d(AT)] ?poly[d(AT)] and short DNA oligomers have two intense positive CD bands near 290 nm and 328 nm. This reflects the fact that two bis-netropsins use different structural motifs on binding to DNA in the hairpin form.     

Alternative heterocycles for DNA recognition: an N-methylpyrazole/N-methylpyrrole pair specifies for A.T/T.A base pairs

Side-by-side pairs of three five-membered rings, N-methylpyrrole (Py), N-methylimidazole (Im), and N-methylhydroxy-pyrrole (Hp), have been demonstrated to distinguish each of the four Watson Crick base pairs in the minor groove of DNA. However, not all DNA sequences targeted by these pairing rules achieve affinities and specificities comparable to DNA binding proteins. We have initiated a search for new heterocycles which can expand the sequence repetoire currently available. Two heterocyclic aromatic amino acids. N-methylpyrazole (Pz) and 4-methylthiazole (Th), were incorporated into a single position of an eight-ring polyamide of sequence ImImXPy-gamma-lmPyPyPy-beta-Dp to examine the modulation of affinity and specificity for DNA binding by a Pz/Py pair and or a Th/Py pair. The X/Py pairings Pz/Py and Th/Py were evaluated by quantitative DNase I footprint titrations on a DNA fragment with the four sites 5'-TGGNCA-3' (N=T, A, G, C). The Pz/Py pair binds T.A and A.T with similar affinity to a Py/Py pair but with improved specificity. disfavoring both G.C and C.G by about 100-fold. The Th/Py pair binds poorly to all four Watson Crick base pairs. These results demonstrate that in some instances new heterocyclic aromatic amino acid pairs can be incorporated into imidazole-pyrrole polyamides to mimic the DNA specificity of Py/Py pairs which may be relevant as biological criteria in animal studies become important.     

Oligonucleotide—Minor Groove Binder 1:2 Conjugates: Side by Side Parallel Minor Groove Binder Motif in Stabilization of DNA Duplex

Synthetic polycarboxamides consisting of N‐methylpyrrole (Py), N‐methylimidazole (Im), N‐methyl‐3‐hydroxypyrrole (Hp) and β‐alanine (β) show strong and sequence‐specific interaction with the DNA minor groove when they form hairpin structures with side‐by‐side antiparallel motifs. In the present paper, new conjugates containing two ligands linked to the same terminal phosphate of DNA strand were constructed. The paper describes optimized synthesis and properties of oligonucleotide‐linked polyamide strands that insert into the minor groove of a duplex in a parallel or antiparallel orientation. Strong stabilization of DNA duplexes by two attached minor groove ligands is demonstrated by the thermal denaturation method. The unmodified duplex 5′‐CGTTTATTp‐3′/5′‐AATAAACG‐3′ melts at 20°C. When one tetra(Py) residue was attached to the first strand of this duplex, denaturation temperature was increased to 46°C; attachment of the second tetra(Py) in a parallel orientation resulted in denaturation temperature of 60°C. It is even higher than in case of “classic” octapyrrole hairpin ligand (Tm = 58°C). Sequence‐specific character of stabilization by two conjugated ligands was demonstrated for G:C‐containing oligonucleotides attached to tetracarboxamide and octacarboxamide ligands constructed from Py, Im and β units according to established recognition rules (ΔTm = 20°C). The two‐strand parallel minor groove binder constructions attached to addressing oligonucleotides could be considered as site‐specific ligands recognizing single‐ and double‐stranded DNA similarly to already described hairpin MGB structures with antiparallel orientation of carboxamide units.     

Comprehensive high-resolution analysis of hairpin polyamides utilizing a fluorescent intercalator displacement (FID) assay

Four hairpin polyamides bearing subtle N- and C-terminal substitutions were examined in a fluorescent intercalator displacement (FID) assay enlisting a library of 512 DNA hairpins that contain all possible five base pair sequences in a challenging probe of its capabilities for establishing DNA binding sequence selectivity. Not only did the assay define the global sequence selectivity expected based on known structural interactions and Dervan's pairing rules establishing the utility of the method for characterizing such polyamides, but previously unappreciated subtle substituent effects on global sequence selectivity were also revealed. Thus, we report the discovery of a novel five base pair high affinity binding site of the form 5'-WWCWW (vs 5'-WGWWW) for the polyamide ImPyPy-gamma-PyPyPy-beta-Dp and its structural basis.     

Requirement of beta-alanine components in sequence-specific DNA alkylation by pyrrole-imidazole conjugates with seven-base pair recognition

To investigate the effect of incorporation of beta-alanine in alkylating N-methylpyrrole (Py)-N-methylimidazole (Im) polyamide, seco-CBI conjugates 2-8 were synthesized by an Fmoc solid-phase method and subsequent coupling with an alkylating moiety. DNA-alkylating activities of conjugates 2-8 were evaluated by high-resolution denaturing gel electrophoresis with 202-base pair (bp) DNA fragments. Alkylation by conjugates 2 and 3, which have antiparallel pairings of beta-alanine (beta) opposite beta (beta/beta) and Py/beta, occurred mainly at the adenine (A) of the matching sequences, 5'-AGCTCCA-3' (site 1) and 5'-AGCACCA-3' (site 3). However, conjugate 4, with beta/Py, did not show any DNA-alkylating activities. Similarly, conjugate 5, which possessed a Py/Py pair, weakly alkylated the matching sites at micromolar concentrations. Conjugates 6 and 7, which possessed beta/beta and Py/beta pairs, respectively, alkylated at the A of the matching sequences, 5'-ACTACCA-3' (site 2) and 5'-ACAACCA-3' (site 4). In contrast, conjugated 8, with a Py/Py pair, showed lower activity and less alkylated DNA at sites 2 and 4 with mismatched alkylation at site 1 at a higher concentration than that of 6 and 7. These results demonstrate that incorporation of beta-alanine is required for the sequence-specific alkylation by seco-CBI Py-Im conjugates with a seven-base pair sequence.     

Enthalpy/entropy compensation: influence of DNA flanking sequence on the binding of 7-amino actinomycin D to its primary binding site in short DNA duplexes

The effect of the context of the flanking sequence on ligand binding to DNA oligonucleotides that contain consensus binding sites was investigated for the binding of the intercalator 7-amino actinomycin D. Seven self-complementary DNA oligomers each containing a centrally located primary binding site, 5'-A-G-C-T-3', flanked on either side by the sequences (AT)(n) or (AA)(n) (with n = 2, 3, 4) and AA(AT)(2), were studied. For different flanking sequences, (AA)(n)-series or (AT)(n)-series, differential fluorescence enhancements of the ligand due to binding were observed. Thermodynamic studies indicated that the flanking sequences not only affected DNA stability and secondary structure but also modulated ligand binding to the primary binding site. The magnitude of the ligand binding affinity to the primary site was inversely related to the sequence dependent stability. The enthalpy of ligand binding was directly measured by isothermal titration calorimetry, and this made it possible to parse the binding free energy into its energetic and entropic terms. Our results reveal a pronounced enthalpy-entropy compensation for 7-amino actinomycin D binding to this family of oligonucleotides and suggest that the DNA sequences flanking the primary binding site can strongly influence ligand recognition of specific sites on target DNA molecules.