Splicing thermotolerance maintains pre-mRNA transcripts in the splicing pathway during severe heat shock

Thermotolerance, the ability of cells and organisms to withstand severe elevated temperatures after brief exposure to mild elevated temperatures, has been studied in numerous laboratories. Survival thermotolerance is defined as the increase in cell or organism survival at severe elevated temperatures after a pretreatment at mild elevated temperatures. This study examines splicing thermotolerance in Drosophila melanogaster, the ability to splice pre-mRNAs made at the severe temperature (38 degrees C) after a brief pretreatment at a milder temperature (35 degrees C). It is probably one of a number of mechanisms by which cells adapt to heat shock. These experiments demonstrate that pre-mRNAs synthesized at the severe temperatures in splicing thermotolerant cells, although protected in splicing-competent complexes, are not actually processed to mature mRNAs until the cells are returned to their normal temperature. We have also studied the kinetics of acquisition and loss of splicing thermotolerance. As little as 10 min of pretreatment at 35 degrees C was sufficient to provide full splicing thermotolerance to a 30-min severe heat shock of 38 degrees C. Pretreatments of less than 10 min provide partial splicing thermotolerance for a 30-min severe heat shock. Full splicing thermotolerance activity begins to decay about 4 h after the cessation of the 35 degrees C incubation and is completely lost by 8 h after the pretreatment. The kinetics experiments of pre-mRNAs synthesized during the 38 degrees C treatment in splicing thermotolerant cells indicate that one or more splicing thermotolerance factors are synthesized during the 35 degrees C pretreatment which interact with pre-mRNA-containing complexes to keep them in a splicing-competent state. These kinetic experiments also indicate that in cells which are partially splicing thermotolerant, the pre-mRNAs synthesized early during the 38 degrees C incubation are protected, whereas those synthesized late are not. In the absence of splicing thermotolerant factors, the pre-mRNA-containing complexes leave the normal splicing pathway and are allowed to exit to the cytoplasm.     

Hyperthermia induces apoptosis in thymocytes.

Mild hyperthermia (43 degrees C for 1 h) induces extensive double-stranded DNA fragmentation and, at a later time, cell death in murine thymocytes. The cleavage of DNA into oligonucleosome-sized fragments resembles that observed in examples of apoptosis including radiation-induced death of thymocytes. Following hyperthermia, incubation at 37 degrees C is necessary to detect DNA fragmentation, although protein and RNA synthesis do not seem to be required. Two protein synthesis inhibitors, cycloheximide and emetine, and two RNA synthesis inhibitors, actinomycin D and 5,6-dichloro-1-beta-D-ribofuranosylbenzimidazole, do not inhibit DNA fragmentation or cell death in heated thymocytes at concentrations which significantly block these effects in irradiated thymocytes. We have used this difference in sensitivity to show that the DNA fragmentation induced in thymocytes which are irradiated and then heated seems to be caused only by the heating and not by the irradiation.     

Hsp72-mediated suppression of c-Jun N-terminal kinase is implicated in development of tolerance to caspase-independent cell death

Pretreatment with mild heat shock is known to protect cells from severe stress (acquired thermotolerance). Here we addressed the mechanism of this phenomenon by using primary human fibroblasts. Severe heat shock (45 degrees C, 75 min) of the fibroblasts caused cell death displaying morphological characteristics of apoptosis; however, it was caspase independent. This cell death process was accompanied by strong activation of Akt, extracellular signal-regulated kinase 1 (ERK1) and ERK2, p38, and c-Jun N-terminal (JNK) kinases. Suppression of Akt or ERK1 and -2 kinases increased cell thermosensitivity. In contrast, suppression of stress kinase JNK rendered cells thermoresistant. Development of thermotolerance was not associated with Akt or ERK1 and -2 regulation, and inhibition of these kinases did not reduce acquired thermotolerance. On the other hand, acquired tolerance to severe heat shock was associated with downregulation of JNK. Using an antisense-RNA approach, we found that accumulation of the heat shock protein Hsp72 is necessary for JNK downregulation and is critical for thermotolerance. The capability of naive cells to withstand moderate heat treatment also appears to be dependent on the accumulation of Hsp72 induced by this stress. Indeed, exposure to 45 degrees C for 45 min caused only transient JNK activation and was nonlethal, while prevention of Hsp72 accumulation prolonged JNK activation and led to massive cell death. We also found that JNK activation by UV irradiation, interleukin-1, or tumor necrosis factor was suppressed in thermotolerant cells and that Hsp72 accumulation was responsible for this effect. Hsp72-mediated suppression of JNK is therefore critical for acquired thermotolerance and may play a role in tolerance to other stresses.     

DNA polymerase activity in heat killing and hyperthermic radiosensitization of mammalian cells as observed after fractionated heat treatments

Possible relations between hyperthermic inactivation of alpha and beta DNA polymerase activity and hyperthermic cell killing or hyperthermic radiosensitization were investigated. Ehrlich Ascites Tumor (EAT) cells and HeLa S3 cells were treated with fractionated doses of hyperthermia. The heating schedules were chosen such that the initial heat treatment resulted in either thermotolerance or thermosensitization (step-down heating) for the second heat treatment. The results show that for DNA polymerase activity and heat radiosensitization (cell survival) no thermotolerance or thermosensitization is observed. Thus hyperthermic cell killing and DNA polymerase activity are not correlated. The correlation of hyperthermic radiosensitization and DNA polymerase activity was substantially less than observed in previous experiments with normotolerant and thermotolerant HeLa S3 cells. We conclude that alpha and beta DNA polymerase inactivation is not always the critical cellular process responsible for hyperthermic cell killing or hyperthermic radiosensitization. Other possible cellular systems that might determine these processes are discussed.     

Thermotolerance induced at a mild temperature of 40 degrees C protects cells against heat shock-induced apoptosis

Apoptosis constitutes a response of organisms to various physiological or pathological stimuli, and to different stresses. The ability of thermotolerance induced at a mild temperature of 40 degrees C to protect against activation of the apoptotic cascade by heat shock was investigated. When Chinese hamster ovary and human adenocarcinoma cervical cells were pretreated at 40 degrees C for 3 h, they were resistant to subsequent lethal heat shock at 43 degrees C. Induction of thermotolerance at 40 degrees C led to increased expression of heat shock proteins 27, 32, 72, and 90. Heat shock induced apoptotic events at the mitochondrial level, involving a decrease in membrane potential, translocation of Bax to mitochondria, and liberation of cytochrome c into the cytosol. These events were diminished in thermotolerant cells. Heat shock (42-45 degrees C) caused activation of initiator caspase-9 and effector caspases-3, -6, and -7, relative to controls at 37 degrees C. Activation of caspases was decreased in thermotolerant cells. Heat shock caused fragmentation of the caspase substrate, inhibitor of caspase-activated DNase. Fragmentation was diminished in thermotolerant cells. Thermotolerance afforded protection against heat shock-induced nuclear chromatin condensation, but not against necrosis.     

Effect of amino acid analogs on the development of thermotolerance and on thermotolerant cells

Exposure of HA-1 Chinese hamster fibroblasts to amino acid analogs has been shown to have a heat-sensitizing effect as well as inducing the heat shock response (Li and Laszlo, 1985a). In this study, we have examined the effect of amino acid analogs on the development of thermotolerance after a brief heat shock or exposure to sodium arsenite and the effect of amino acid analogs on cells that are already thermotolerant. Exposure of HA-1 cells to amino acid analogs inhibited the development of thermotolerance following a mild heat shock or treatment with sodium arsenite. However, cells that were already thermotolerant were resistant to the sensitizing action of amino acid analogs. The refractoriness of thermotolerant cells to amino acid analog treatment developed in parallel with thermotolerance. The uptake of the arginine analog, canavanine, and its incorporation into proteins was not altered in the thermotolerant cells. Furthermore, another biological consequence of exposure to amino acid analogs, sensitization to ionizing radiation, also was not altered in the thermotolerant cells. The inhibition of the development of thermotolerance by amino acid analogs and the refractoriness of thermotolerant cells to the heat-sensitizing action of amino acid analogs lend further support the role of heat-shock proteins in the phenomenon of thermotolerance. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The cellular apoptosis of murine BW5147 thymoma during cold shock]

The mode of T-lymphoma cell death induced by cold shock was studied. The rewarming of cells at 37 degrees C following a brief period of cold (0 degrees C) resulted in internucleosomal DNA fragmentation. The cells underwent cold shock-mediated apoptosis only at a reduced (2%) serum concentration. The apoptosis was not blocked by macromolecular synthesis inhibitors such as cycloheximide and antinomycin D, or by Quin-2. EGTA per se was responsible for the initiation of cell death. Colchicine also induced internucleosomal fragmentation of DNA. Our findings suggest that cold shock induced apoptosis is associated with low temperature mediated disruption of microtubules. The role of Ca2+ and growth factors in cold shock induced cell death is discussed.     

Reduction of levels of nuclear-associated protein in heated cells by cycloheximide, D2O, and thermotolerance.

Hyperthermia increases levels of nuclear-associated proteins in a manner that correlates with cell killing. If the increase in nuclear-associated proteins represents a lethal lesion then treatments that protect against killing by heat should reduce and/or facilitate the recovery of levels of the proteins in heated cells. This hypothesis was tested using three heat protection treatments: cycloheximide, D2O, and thermotolerance. All three treatments reduced levels of the proteins measured immediately following hyperthermia at 43.0 or 45.5 degrees C, with the greatest reduction occurring at 43.0 degrees C. In addition to reducing the proteins, thermotolerance facilitated the recovery of the proteins to control levels following hyperthermia. Thus thermotolerance may protect cells by both reducing the initial heat damage and facilitating recovery from that damage. Cycloheximide and D2O did not facilitate recovery of nuclear-associated proteins, suggesting that their protection against cytotoxicity related to the proteins resulted solely from their reduction of increases in levels of the proteins. All three treatments have been shown to stabilize cellular proteins against thermal denaturation. The results of this study suggest that the increase in nuclear-associated proteins may result from thermally denatured proteins adhering to the nucleus and that it is the ability of cycloheximide, D2O, and thermotolerance to thermostabilize proteins that reduces the increase in levels of the proteins within heated cells.     

The role of energy in hyperthermia-induced mammalian cell inactivation: A study of the effects of glucose starvation and an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation

When cultured Chinese hamster cells were exposed to 43°C hyperthermia, effects due to glucose deprivation and to the presence of the uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation, carbonylcyanide-3-chlorophenylhydrazone, during the 43°C treatment proved to be strongly accelerated compared to the effects at normal temperature (37°C). This strongly indicates that the availability of energy plays an important role in the response of these cells to hyperthermia. One of the reasons cells die after hyperthermia may be a lethal lack of energy. Cells heated before glucose deprivation were able to maintain viability for a longer period during deprivation than cells without the preheat treatment. As the cells might develop thermotolerance after the heat exposure, this suggests that cells in the thermotolerant state use energy in a more economical way.     

Cellular ATP content of heated Chinese hamster ovary cells

Hyperthermia at either 41.5 or 45 degrees C with variable heating times to reduce cell survival up to three orders of magnitude did not decrease significantly cellular ATP content when measured either immediately or up to 7 hr after a heat treatment. Similarly, cellular ATP content was not significantly reduced with step-down heating, precooling prior to hyperthermia, or thermotolerance induction. The data suggest that heat-induced depletion of intracellular ATP content is not a critical factor in the thermal death of cells heated under normal culture conditions.     

Inhibition of protein synthesis sensitizes thermotolerant cells to heat shock induced apoptosis

Hyperthermia is a potent inducer of apoptosis in many cell lines. A brief exposure to mildly elevated temperatures elicits a transient state of augmented resistance to subsequent thermal stress. Here we show that a hyperthermic treatment of 43°C for 1 h is sufficient to induce apoptosis in the cell line HL-60. This observation is based on morphologic evaluation and on comet assay results (an extremely sensitive method of detecting and quantifying apoptotic DNA fragmentation in individual cells). The thermotolerance phenomenon was also verified in the same manner by giving the cells a brief 30 min sub-lethal heat conditioning treatment at 43°C followed by a 6 h incubation time prior to the administration of a lethal heat load (43°C for 1 h). We observed a dramatic decrease in resultant apoptoses in the thermotolerized cells in comparison to unconditioned cells. We assessed the necessity of de novo protein synthesis in the protective phenomenon. When the conditioned cells were given a cycloheximide treatment prior to heat conditioning we saw a sensitization of the conditioned cells to secondary thermal injury. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Heat shock protein synthesis and thermotolerance in Salmonella typhimurium

The resistance of stationary phase Salmonella typhimurium to heating at 55 degrees C was greater in cells grown in nutritionally rich than in minimal media, but in all media tested resistance was enhanced by exposing cells to a primary heat shock at 48 degrees C. Chloramphenicol reduced the acquisition of thermotolerance in all media but did not completely prevent it in any. The onset of thermotolerance was accompanied by increased synthesis of major heat shock proteins of molecular weight about 83, 72, 64 and 25 kDa. When cells were shifted from 48 degrees C to 37 degrees C, however, thermotolerance was rapidly lost with no corresponding decrease in the levels of these proteins. There is thus no direct relationship between thermotolerance and the cellular content of the major heat shock proteins. One minor protein of molecular weight about 34 kDa disappeared rapidly following a temperature down-shift. Its presence in the cell was thus correlated with the thermotolerant state.     

Morphological response and survival of hepatoma cells during fractionated hyperthermia: effect of glycerol

Reuber H35 rat hepatoma cells rounded and became spherical during hyperthermia at 42.5 degrees C. When returned to 37 degrees C, the cells recovered and spread out again. As soon as the cells had recovered from the morphologically expressed stress, they expressed tolerance to a second hyperthermia treatment as measured by the same end point. Fractionated hyperthermia made the cells thermotolerant as judged by both the morphological and the cell survival response. Glycerol protected the cells against heat damage as measured by less morphological alteration and decreased cell lethality. Protection depended on the glycerol concentration and maximal protection was observed at 6-8%. After heating in the presence of 7% glycerol, cells expressed thermotolerance at an earlier time than in the absence of glycerol, although the rates of development were approximately similar. Cell survival data and morphological responses showed good correlation.     

T lymphocyte stress response. II. Protection of translation and DNA replication against some forms of stress by prior hyperthermic stress

We have compared the effects of a mild heat shock and febrile temperatures on heat-shock protein (hsp) synthesis and development of stress tolerance in T lymphocytes. Our previous studies demonstrated that febrile temperatures (less than or equal to 41 degrees C) induced the synthesis of hsp110, hsp90, and the constitutive or cognate form of hsp70 (hscp70; a weak induction of the strongly stress-induced hsp70 was also observed. In the studies reported herein, we demonstrate that a mild heat shock (42.5 degrees C) reverses this ratio; that is, hsp70 and not hscp70 is the predominate member of this family synthesized at this temperature. Modest heat shock also enhanced the synthesis of hsp110 and hsp90. In order to assess the relationship between hsp synthesis and the acquisition of thermotolerance, purified T cells were first incubated at 42.5 degrees C (induction temperature) and then subsequently subjected to a severe heat-shock challenge (45 degrees C, 30 min). T cells first incubated at a mild heat-shock temperature were capable of total protein synthesis at a more rapid rate following a severe heat shock than control cells (induction temperature 37 degrees C). This phenomenon, which has been previously termed translational tolerance, did not develop in cells incubated at the febrile temperature (induction temperature 41 degrees C). Protection of translation also extended to immunologically relevant proteins such as interleukin-2 and the interleukin-2 receptor. Because clonal expansion is a critical event during an immune response, the effects of hyperthermic stress on DNA replication (mitogen-induced T cell proliferation) was also evaluated in thermotolerant T cells. DNA synthesis in control cells (induction temperature 37 degrees C) was severely inhibited following heat-shock challenge at 44 degrees C or 45 degrees C; in contrast, T cells preincubated at 42.5 degrees C rapidly recovered their DNA synthetic capacity. T cells preincubated at a febrile temperature were moderately protected against hyperthermic stress. The acquisition of thermotolerance was also associated with enhanced resistance to chemical (ethanol)-induced stress but not to heavy metal toxicity (cadmium) or dexamethasone-induced immunosuppression. These studies suggest that prior hsp synthesis may protect immune function against some forms of stress (e.g., febrile episode) but would be ineffective against others such as elevated glucocorticoid levels which normally occur during an immune response.     

Thermal tolerance during S phase for cell killing and chromosomal aberrations

Synchronous Chinese hamster ovary cells in early S phase were obtained by selecting mitotic cells, accumulating them at the G1/S border by incubating them in aphidicolin for 12 h, and then incubating them for 2 h after releasing them from the aphidicolin block. To determine if thermotolerance could be induced, the cells were heated at 43 degrees C for 20 min in early S phase, incubated for 160 min, and then heated a second time at 43 degrees C for different durations (30-100 min). For the control, nontolerant population, the cells in early S phase were incubated for 50 min and then heated once at 43 degrees C for different durations (20-60 min). Flow cytometric analysis indicated that the population receiving the second heat dose was in the same part of S phase as the population receiving the single heat dose. A comparison of the heat response for the two populations indicated that heating during early S phase induced thermotolerance for both cell killing and chromosomal aberrations; i.e., for 10% survival, which corresponded to 10% of the cells being cytologically normal, the thermal dose was twofold greater in the thermotolerant cells than in the control, nontolerant cells. Furthermore, this thermotolerance developed during S phase. These observations support the hypothesis that heating during S phase kills cells primarily by inducing chromosomal aberrations.     

Effect of heat shock on the intracellular distribution of proteins

Exposure of cells to heat induces thermotolerance, a transient resistance to subsequent heat challenges. It has been shown that thermotolerance is correlated in time with the enhanced synthesis of heat shock proteins. In this study, the association of induced heat shock proteins with various cellular fractions was investigated and the heat-induced changes in skeletal protein composition in thermotolerant and control cells was compared. All three major heat shock proteins induced in Chinese hamster fibroblasts after a 46 degrees C, 4-min heat treatment (70, 87, and 110 kDa) were purified with the cytoplasmic fraction, whereas only the 70-kDa protein was also found in other cell fractions, including that containing the cellular skeleton. Immediately after a second heat treatment at 45 degrees C for 45 min, the 110-kDa protein from thermotolerant cells also purified extensively with the cellular skeletal fraction. In this regard, the 110-kDa protein behaved similarly to many other cellular proteins, since we observed an overall temperature-dependent increase in the total labeled protein content of the high-salt-resistant cellular skeletal fraction after heat shock. Pulse-chase studies demonstrated that this increased protein content gradually returned to normal levels after a 3-hr incubation at 37 degrees C. The alteration or recovery kinetics of the total labeled protein content of the cellular skeletal fraction after heat shock did not correlate with the dramatic increase in survival observed in thermotolerant cells. The relationship between heat shock proteins and thermotolerance, therefore, does not correlate directly with changes in the heat-induced cellular alterations leading to differences in protein fractionation.     

Thermal radiosensitization and thermotolerance in cultured cells from a murine mammary carcinoma

Cultured murine mammary carcinoma cells M8013 could be made thermotolerant by a priming heat treatment, 30 min at 43 degrees C, applied 5 h prior to subsequent heat treatment. The sensitivity of non-tolerant and thermotolerant cells to either radiation or heat combined with radiation was investigated. Analysis of survival curves with respect to D0 and N showed that thermotolerance had no influence on the radiation sensitivity of the cells. Thermal enhancement of radiation effects (in combined heat/irradiation treatments) was however reduced as a result of thermotolerance. When thermal enhancement ratios were (D0) plotted as a function of the cell killing effects of heat treatment alone, thermotolerance did not seem to have any influence. This latter observation suggests that thermotolerance modifies the effectiveness of the heat treatment for heat-induced cell lethality and radiosensitization equally. Comparison of our in vitro results with several in vivo data on normal tissues suggest that the reduction in 'effective' treatment temperature which has been observed in the in vivo studies as a result of thermotolerance may be explained by equal modification of the effects of heat by thermotolerance both for its direct effects and the radiosensitization.     

Effect of pH on quercetin-induced suppression of heat shock gene expression and thermotolerance development in HT-29 cells.

When cells were heated for 15 min at 45 degrees C, they became thermotolerant to a second heat exposure at 45 degrees C. Thermotolerance developed rapidly, reached its maximum 6 hr after heat shock, and then gradually decayed. The development of thermotolerance was partially suppressed by treatment with various concentrations of quercetin (0.05-0.2 mM) at pH 7.4 after the initial heat treatment. In contrast, the drug markedly inhibited thermotolerance development at pH 6.5. Furthermore, a combination of low pH and quercetin treatment distinctively altered the expression of HSP70 gene compared with that of HSP28 or HSP90 gene. These results demonstrate a good correlation between the amount of HSP70 gene expression and development of thermotolerance.     

Involvement of rRNA synthesis in the enhanced survival and recovery of protein synthesis seen in thermotolerance

Although acquired thermotolerance has been linked to the induction of heat shock proteins, the molecular mechanism(s) by which cells become resistant to heat is unknown. The present study shows a strong correlation between the survival of cells following heat shock and the rate of recovery of protein, total RNA, and rRNA synthesis. Increasing exposure of CHO cells to 45 degrees C was found to decrease survival and cause a lengthening delay in these synthetic processes. The same reciprocal correlation was seen in thermotolerant cells. As thermotolerance develops, more cells survive a heat challenge and the delay in synthesis decreases. These data argue that enhanced recovery of protein and RNA synthesis is one factor which plays a key role in thermotolerance. The involvement of rRNA synthesis was further investigated by using actinomycin D at 0.1 microgram m1(-1), a concentration at which rRNA synthesis is selectively inhibited. When the drug was present during the recovery from a challenge heat treatment, the survival of thermotolerant cells was approximately 3-fold lower than expected from the mild toxicity of the drug. As this could not be accounted for by an interaction of the drug with the response of cells to single heat treatments, it is concluded that the drug inhibits the expression of thermotolerance in cells which would otherwise express a full degree of thermotolerance. The time and concentration dependence of this effect indicates that the drug acts though inhibition of rRNA synthesis. Therefore, enhanced recovery of RNA synthesis, presumably rRNA synthesis, is identified as one of the mechanisms responsible for enhanced survival of thermotolerant cells following heat shock.