Comparative protein accumulation patterns in soybean somatic and zygotic embryos

Summary The relative maturity and competence of somatic embryos is often estimated on the basis of their morphologic similarity to various stages of immature zygotic embryo development. Morphologic abnormalities noted in soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] somatic embryos are similar to those observed in zygotic embryos maturing in vitro and may reflect common interruptions of normal developmental processes. We provide here a more objective means of assessing the point(s) at which cultured embryos deviate from the normal embryogenical pathway by comparing the accumulation of the embryo-specific marker proteins (11S and 7S storage globulins, soybean agglutinin, and seed lipoxygenase) between somatic and immature zygotic embryos maturing in culture to zygotic embryos maturingin planta. Immature (heart-stage) soybean (cv. ‘McCall’) zygotic embryos were removed from the testa and cultured for 5, 15, or 45 days in nien modified Linsmaer-Skoog salts, 5% sucrose liquid medium. Somatic embryos were induced from immature cotyledon explants on a medium containing either naphthalene acetic acid or 2,4 dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (10 mg·liter⁻¹). The measured level of the marker proteins present in cultured embryos never exceeded those observed in mature soybean seeds. During the culture period, immature zygotic embryos accumulated significant levels of all marker proteins except a 29 kDa soybean agglutinin associated with the final stages of seed maturationin planta. Somatic embryos of all morphologic classes exhibited similar levels of the marker proteins suggesting that morphology may not accurately represent the developmental state of the culture-derived embryos. Somatic embryos induced on naphthalene acetic acid-containing medium accumulated detectable levels of all maturation-specific marker proteins except the 7S β and 29-kD soybean agglutinin antigen and seemed similar in most respects to the cultured zygotic embryos. Embryos induced on 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid accumulated none of the mature 7S or 11S storage globulin subunits nor any soybean agglutinin antigen, and yet the synthesis of 7S and 11S precursor polypeptides was similar in both naphthalene acetic acid-and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid-induced somatic embryos. These observations are consistent with the view that embryos induced on high 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic are arrested at a relatively earlier developmental stage than naphthalene acetic acid-induced embryos of similar morphology and may indicate that some external signal (e.g., abscisic acid or desiccation or both) is necessary for the transition to the late maturation stage of seed ontogeny.     

Protein patterns associated with <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pisum sativum</Emphasis> somatic embryogenesis

Total protein patterns were studied in the course of development of pea somatic embryos using simple protocol of direct regeneration from shoot apical meristems on auxin supplemented medium. Protein content and total protein spectra (SDS-PAGE) of somatic embryos in particular developmental stages were analysed in Pisum sativum, P. arvense, P. elatius and P. jomardi. Expression of seed storage proteins in somatic embryos was compared with their accumulation in zygotic embryos of selected developmental stages. Pea vegetative tissues, namely leaf and root, were used as a negative control not expressing typical seed storage proteins. The biosynthesis and accumulation of seed storage proteins was observed during somatic embryo development (since globular stage), despite of the fact that no special maturation treatment was applied. Major storage proteins typical for pea seed (globulins legumin, vicilin, convicilin and their subunits) were detected in somatic embryos. In general, the biosynthesis of storage proteins in somatic embryos was lower as compared to mature dry seed. However, in some cases the cotyledonary somatic embryos exhibited comparatively high expression of vicilin, convicilin and pea seed lectin, which was even higher than those in immature but morphologically fully developed zygotic embryos. Desiccation treatments did not affect the protein content of somatic embryos. The transfer of desiccated somatic embryos on hormone-free germination medium led to progressive storage protein degradation. The expression of true seed storage proteins may serve as an explicit marker of somatic embryogenesis pathway of regeneration as well as a measure of maturation degree of somatic embryos in pea.     

A hormonal misunderstanding in Acca sellowiana embryogenesis: levels of zygotic embryogenesis do not match those of somatic embryogenesis

Endogenous levels of IAA, ABA and four types of CKs were analyzed in zygotic and indirect (ISE) and direct somatic embryogenesis of Acca sellowiana. Zygotic and somatic embryos at different developmental stages were sampled for morphological and hormonal analysis. Both embryo types showed substantial asymmetry in hormone levels. Zygotic embryos displayed a conspicuous peak of IAA in early developmental stages. The results outlined the hormonal variations occurring during zygotic and somatic embryogenesis regarding the timing, nature and hormonal status involved in both processes. The short transient pulse of IAA observed on the 3rd day in culture was suggested to be involved with the signaling for the induction of somatic embryogenesis. Fertilized ovule development was associated with increased IAA levels 21?C24?days after pollination, followed by a sharp decrease in the cotyledonary stage, both in zygotic and somatic embryos. There was a prominent increase in ABA levels in cultures which generated ISE 24?C30?days after pollination, a period that corresponds to the heart and torpedo stages. The levels of total CKs (Z, [9R]Z, iP and [9R]iP) were also always higher in zygotic than in somatic embryogenesis. While zygotic embryogenesis was dominated by the presence of zeatin, the somatic process, contrarily, was characterized by a large variation of the other cytokinin forms and amounts studied. The above results, when taken together, could be related to the previously observed high frequency formation of anomalous somatic embryos formed in A. sellowiana, as well as to their low germination ability.     

杉木未成熟胚胚性愈伤组织诱导影响因素探析

该研究从基因型、6-BA浓度、外植体接种方式和合子胚发育阶段等方面,分析杉木未成熟胚胚性愈伤组织诱导的影响因素。结果表明:基因型、6-BA浓度、外植体接种方式和合子胚发育阶段均对胚性愈伤组织诱导频率有不同程度影响。6种基因型中,有3种基因型诱导出胚性愈伤组织,其中基因型S18胚性愈伤组织诱导频率最高,为11.7%。6-BA浓度在1.0~1.5 mg·L~(-1)范围内时,基因型S18的胚性组织诱导频率较高。以在去皮种子的一端切开一个小口的接种方式为最优,将合子胚剥出的方式易造成合子胚褐化死亡,将未剥皮的种子切开一个小口后直接接入培养基的方式不利于愈伤组织生成。适合胚性愈伤组织诱导的合子胚发育阶段为受精至胚器官分化阶段,合子胚进入成熟阶段后不利于胚性愈伤组织诱导,合子胚易生长成完整植株。     

Proteomic Analysis of Developing Somatic Embryos of Coffea arabica

Differential protein profiles of three stages of somatic embryogenesis, including globular, torpedo, and cotyledonary somatic embryos, of Coffea arabica cv. Catuaí Vermelho were analyzed in an attempt to better understand somatic embryogenesis in coffee plants. Somatic embryos at these different stages of development were collected from in vitro-grown cultures, and then macerated in liquid nitrogen. Proteins were extracted with phenol and further quantified using the Bradford method. The bidimensional electrophoresis analysis revealed a wide range of proteins ranging between 10 and 160?kDa and of pH values ranging from 3 to 10. Several differentially expressed proteins were identified by mass spectrometry, and some were found to be specific to these different stages of somatic embryogenesis in coffee. The enolase and 11S storage globulin proteins, for example, could be used as molecular markers for somatic embryo development stages and for embryogenic and non-embryogenic genotype differentiation, respectively.     

Patterns of somatic embryo formation in Siberian larch: embryological aspects

Somatic embryogenesis was induced in Siberian larch by in vitro culturing zygotic embryos at different developmental stages. Cultures were grown in modified Murashige and Skoog medium supplemented with hormones 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2 mg/l) and 6-benzylaminopurine (0.5-1 mg/l). The success of somatic embryogenesis in this species depended on the tree genotype and developmental stage of embryos used for culturing. Somatic embryogenesis from immature zygotic embryos at the stage of cotyledon initiation was most active. After 5-10 days, such embryos formed the embryogenic tissue including two cell types--elongated highly vacuolated embryonic tubes and small embryonic cells. Somatic embryos were isolated from proliferating embryogenic tissues after 2 months of culture.     

Fatty acid changes during development of zygotic and microspore-derived embryos of Brassica napus

Cultured microspores of Brassica napus L. cvs Topas and Reston initiated cell divisions within 3 to 4 days, and globular, heart and torpedo shaped embryos were prevalent after approximately 6, 8, and 10 days, respectively. Embryos with rudimentary cotyledons were evident within 2 weeks, but those that reached this stage of development represented only 1–5% of the original microspore population. The fresh weight of microspore-derived embryos at all stages of development was significantly greater than that for zygotic embryos, but the pattern of change in fresh weight and fatty acid accumulation was similar in developing zygotic and microspore embryos. In freshly isolated microspores of both Topas (low erucic acid) and Reston (high erucic acid), the predominant fatty acid was 18:3, while 18:1 comprised less than 15% of total fatty acids. During development in both zygotic and microspore embryos, the level of 18:3 declined markedly while 18:1 rapidly increased. Erucic acid (22:1) was not detected in the early stages of embryogenesis in Reston. However, small amounts of 22:1 appeared by early cotyledonary stage and the level gradually increased in both zygotic and microspore embryos through the later stages of development. The fatty acid compositions of mature embryos was nearly identical to that of dry seed, except the level of 22:1 in Reston embryos was consistently less than in the seed. Triacylglycerols comprised only 15% of total lipids in freshly isolated microspores, but increased to more than 90% by 4 weeks. The fatty acid composition of the triacylglycerol fraction was generally similar to that of total lipids at all stages of development of microspore-derived embryos.     

Patterns of somatic embryo formation in Siberian larch: Embryological aspects

Somatic embryogenesis was induced in Siberian larch by in vitro culturing zygotic embryos at different developmental stages. Cultures were grown in modified Murashige and Skoog medium supplemented with hormones 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2 mg/l) and 6-benzylaminopurine (0.5–1 mg/l). The success of somatic embryogenesis in this species depended on the tree genotype and developmental stage of embryos used for culturing. Somatic embryogenesis from immature zygotic embryos at the stage of cotyledon initiation was most active. After 5–10 days, such embryos formed the embryogenic tissue including two cell types—elongated highly vacuolated embryonic tubes and small embryonic cells. Somatic embryos were isolated from proliferating embryogenic tissues after 2 months of culture.     

Proteomic analyses of somatic and zygotic embryos of Cyclamen persicum Mill. reveal new insights into seed and germination physiology

In the horticulturally important ornamental species Cyclamen persicum Mill., somatic embryogenesis is an efficient vegetative propagation method and the development of artificial seeds is an ultimate aim. This study aims at a systematic comparison of the proteomes of zygotic embryos, somatic embryos grown in liquid medium containing 30 or 60 g l⁻¹ sucrose, germinating embryos of both types and endosperm in order to obtain novel insights into seed and germination physiology. Using high resolution two-dimensional isoelectric focussing/sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2D IEF/SDS PAGE), 74% of the proteins expressed in zygotic embryos were found in similar abundance in somatic embryos grown in 60 g l⁻¹ sucrose. Somatic embryos grown in 30 g l⁻¹ sucrose accumulated fewer protein species than those grown in 60 g l⁻¹. Selected proteins were identified following mass spectrometry (nano-LC-MS/MS). Four enzymes involved in glycolysis (UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase, fructose bisphosphate aldolase, triosephosphate isomerase and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase GAPDH) were specifically induced in somatic embryos. 11S globulin proteins identified by MS were present in high levels in somatic embryos, zygotic embryos and endosperm, whereas 7S globulins were detected mainly in endosperm and zygotic embryos. These are the first storage proteins identified in C. persicum. Xyloglucans are known to be another group of seed storage compounds in C. persicum. Interestingly, xyloglucan endotransglycosylases were found to be highly expressed in endosperm tissue. We discuss the physiological implications of these observations.     

Accumulation pattern and identification of seed storage proteins in zygotic embryos of Pinus strobus and in somatic embryos from different maturation treatments

Somatic embryogenesis (SE) of Pinus strobus L. has been greatly improved over the last few years with respect to both the initiation frequencies from a number of seed families and production of mature somatic embryos that readily convert to plants. However, there are no data on biochemical characterization of somatic embryos in relation to zygotic embryos of eastern white pine and on the optimal duration of the maturation stage. It is believed that somatic embryos closely resembling zygotic embryos not only morphologically but biochemically would display more vigorous growth. Hence, in this study the accumulation pattern of the most abundant seed storage proteins in zygotic and somatic embryos were characterized by sodium dodecyl sulphate‐polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS‐PAGE) and identified by amino acid sequencing and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). This showed that somatic embryos accumulated storage proteins in a similar manner to zygotic embryos and that the most abundant were the buffer‐insoluble 11S‐ globulins MW 59.6 kDa, which dissociated under reduced conditions to 38.2–40.0 and 22.5–23.5 kDa range polypeptides, and buffer‐soluble 7S vicilin‐like proteins MW 46.0–49.0 kDa, which did not separate under reduced conditions. Other relatively abundant soluble proteins were in the ranges of 25–27 and 27–29 kDa. The only group of proteins that showed different migration profiles in the presence of β‐mercaptoethanol (ME) were the low molecular mass proteins of 14.6–16.5 kDa. Somatic embryos that matured for 9 weeks on medium with 6% sucrose accumulated more storage proteins than those matured on medium with 3% sucrose and the extension of the maturation period to 12 weeks resulted in significant reduction of the storage proteins on both media. As expected, somatic embryos matured on medium with 6% sucrose had lower water potential (Ψ) than those from medium with 3% sucrose. Nonetheless, the somatic embryos matured under the best of tested conditions (6% sucrose for 9 weeks) had slightly higher water content; 1.35 ± 0.28 g H₂O g^?1 DM (mean ± sd ) than the mature non‐dried zygotic embryos; (1.16 ± 0.09 g H₂O g^?1 DM), and accumulated less storage proteins, whose amounts were either similar to (7S‐vicilins) or below (11S‐globulins) those found in the immature zygotic embryos collected 2 weeks prior to the usual cone collection. The implications of these results for further research and development of viable artificial seed is discussed.     

Proteomic Analysis of Somatic Embryogenesis in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cyclamen persicum</Emphasis> Mill

Cyclamen persicum Mill. is a widely grown ornamental species that is clonally propagated by somatic embryogenesis. To better understand the biology of somatic embryo development in C. persicum, detailed proteomic (two-dimensional gel electrophoresis) and mass spectrometric analyses of somatic embryos at globular, torpedo, and germinating stages of development, along with nonembryogenic callus and zygotic embryos, were conducted. Of ~460 proteins resolved in two-dimensional gels, 35 proteins were differentially expressed and could be reproducibly displayed across an isoelectric focusing range of 5 to 8. Among those proteins, five were constitutively expressed, 13 were upregulated, nine were downregulated, and eight were deemed as novel proteins during the torpedo stage. A total of 35 protein spots were analyzed by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS), and only four proteins were identified and these were available in public protein databases. The remaining protein spots were subsequently analyzed by MALDI-TOF-TOF-MS, and six proteins were then identified. These findings suggested that specific proteins are involved in the regulation of somatic embryogenesis.     

Evaluation of somatic embryos of interior spruce. Characterization and developmental regulation of storage proteins

Storage proteins of interior spruce ( Picea glauca engelmanii complex) somatic embryos were compared to those of zygotic embryos by sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and immunoblotting. Somatic embryos contain the same storage proteins as zygotic embryos based on similarities of molecular weight, isoelectric variants, solubility characteristics and disulfide linkages. Storage protein levels varied among different somatic embryo genotypes; however, all genotypes tested accumulated significant amounts of storage proteins. Zygotic and somatic embryos display a similar developmental accumulation of storage proteins. The 22, 24, 33 and 35 kDa proteins appear in early stage embryos, while the 41 kDa protein begins to accumulate during mid cotyledon development. The 22, 24 and 41 kDa proteins accumulate continuously during cotyledon development in somatic embryos cultured on abscisic acid. In contrast, zygotic embryos display a more rapid and transient accumulation of these proteins.     

Development of white spruce somatic embryos: I. Storage product deposition

Summary The growth and development of white spruce somatic embryos was followed from the filamentous immature to the mature cotyledonary embryo stage. Histochemical examination of the various stages of embryo development showed that lipids, proteins, and polysaccharides were produced to varying degrees during the process. During early stages (1 to 2 wk on ABA), mostly polysaccharide was produced, whereas during later stages, polysaccharides, lipids, and protein accumulated. Electron microscopy indicated that lipid deposition in somatic embryos started during the first week after transfer to ABA-containing medium. Deposition of the storage products began at the basal end of the embryonal mass and within the proximal zone of the suspensors. Accumulation continued to the peripheral regions and then inward toward the cortex of the developing embryo. In all cases, polysaccharide accumulated first, followed by lipid and lastly, protein. Quantitatively, cotyledonary stage somatic embryos had less lipid and protein and more starch when compared to zygotic embryos at the same developmental stage. Total protein profiles elucidated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis indicated that the majority of proteins were similar in zygotic and somatic embryos. Prominent protein bands were found at 30, 20, 19.5, 15, 14.4, 12, and 10 Kd. However, protein bands at 40, 15, and 12 Kd in total protein from somatic embryos were either absent or highly underexpressed.     

Spatio-temporal accumulation and activity of calcium-dependent protein kinases during embryogenesis, seed development, and germination in sandalwood

Western-blot analysis and protein kinase assays identified two Ca(2+)-dependent protein kinases (CDPKs) of 55 to 60 kD in soluble protein extracts of embryogenic cultures of sandalwood (Santalum album L.). However, these sandalwood CDPKs (swCDPKs) were absent in plantlets regenerated from somatic embryos. swCDPKs exhibited differential expression (monitored at the level of the protein) and activity in different developmental stages. Zygotic embryos, seedlings, and endosperm showed high accumulation of swCDPK, but the enzyme was not detected in the soluble proteins of shoots and flowers. swCDPK exhibited a temporal pattern of expression in endosperm, showing high accumulation and activity in mature fruit and germinating stages; the enzyme was localized strongly in the storage bodies of the endosperm cells. The study also reports for the first time to our knowledge a post-translational inhibition/inactivation of swCDPK in zygotic embryos during seed dormancy and early stages of germination. The temporal expression of swCDPK during somatic/zygotic embryogenesis, seed maturation, and germination suggests involvement of the enzyme in these developmental processes.     

Induction of green ash embryogenic cultures with potential for scalable somatic embryo production using suspension culture

Key message

The developmental sequences of zygotic embryos of green ash collected from the same tree were widely asynchronous and an intermediate developmental stage was the best explant for inducing somatic embryogenesis.

Abstract

All North American ash (Fraxinus) species are under threat of extirpation from their native ranges by the emerald ash borer (EAB; Agrilus planipennis), an exotic wood-boring beetle that has already destroyed millions of ash trees in 15 U.S. states and Canada. We tested treatments aimed at initiating embryogenic cultures from seeds of green ash (F. pennsylvanica), with the long-term goal of using these cultures to aid in research to generate EAB-resistant ash trees for restoration. In preparation for somatic embryogenesis induction experiments, we first defined specific stage(s) of green ash zygotic embryo development using time-tracing sampling by collecting samaras of two green ash trees from May to August in 2012. Seed development was divided into seven stages according to both seed and embryo size, and the numbers of seeds and embryos in each stage were recorded for each collection date. Surprisingly, a broad range of seed and embryo developmental stages could be found in samaras collected from the same tree on the same date, in particular for the later collection dates. Using this information, single-date collections of seeds with embryos at various stages of development were made from three local Athens, GA green ash trees and one horticultural cultivar and cultured on two different basal media with different combinations of plant growth regulators (PGRs). A low percentage of zygotic embryo explants at an intermediate stage of development from all three local source trees produced proembryogenic masses (PEMs) when cultured on a modified Woody Plant Medium with 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid and benzyladenine. Although embryogenesis was also induced from explants of the horticultural cultivar, these cultures failed to produce germinable somatic embryos. Transfer of PEMs to PGR-free medium resulted in highly dense production of somatic embryos, some of which were germinated to produce somatic seedlings.     

Comparison between somatic and zygotic embryo development in Quercus robur L.

ABSTRACT

Somatic embryogenesis from juvenile explants as an efficient way for oak clonal propagation is drastically limited by the low rate of embryo germination. A comparison of the development of immature somatic and zygotic embryos, and a study of the changes in sugar content and lignin accumulation during somatic versus zygotic embryo development were conducted in view of understanding the effect of reserve substance deficiency upon somatic embryo maturation. A morphological comparison of somatic and zygotic embryos led to the identification of 4 to 7 similar developmental stages in both types of embryos, thus indicating that the accumulation phase in both zygotic and somatic embryos occurs at the same stage, when the cotyledons became thicker and opaque. Carbohydrate analysis showed the presence of glycerol, inositol, mannitol, galactose, trehalose, xylose, arabinose, glucose, fructose and sucrose in all stages of zygotic and somatic embryo development, but in different amounts. The amount of glycerol, inositol, glucose and sucrose during the early stages is larger in zygotic embryos than in somatic ones, but the time course of their accumulation is similar in both types of embryos. Lignin content, which increased continuously during development, showed a similar behaviour in zygotic and somatic embryos. In somatic embryos which were able to germinate, lignin content was higher than in nongerminating embryos at the same stage.     

Significance of the zygotic seed coat on quiescence and desiccation tolerance of Medicago sativa L. somatic embryos

Summary The influence of the zygotic seed coat on precocious germination and desiccation tolerance of somatic embryos has been studied using alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.). When cultured in contact with somatic embryos, seed coats at certain developmental stages inhibited precocious germination and induced desiccation tolerance in the somatic embryos. Germination of somatic embryos was inhibited by seed coats at the age of 16–26 days after pollination (DAP) and desiccation tolerance was induced after 20–26 DAP. Both phenomena were related to the synthesis of abscisic acid in the seed coat. The absence of a quiescent phase and desiccation tolerance in alfalfa somatic embryos may be related to the lack of developmental control by the seed coat.Abbreviations ABA Abscisic acid - DAP Days after pollination