Expression of ovule and integument‐associated genes in reduced ovules of Santalales

SUMMARY Santalales comprise mainly parasitic plants including mistletoes and sandalwoods. Bitegmic ovules similar to those found in most other angiosperms are seen in many members of the order, but other members exhibit evolutionary reductions to the unitegmic and ategmic conditions. In some mistletoes, extreme reduction has resulted in the absence of emergent ovules such that embryo sacs appear to remain embedded in placental tissues. Three santalalean representatives (Comandra, Santalum, and Phoradendron), displaying unitegmic, and ategmic ovules, were studied. Observed ovule morphologies were consistent with published reports, including Phoradendron serotinum, which we interpret as having reduced ategmic ovules, consistent with earlier reports on this species. For further understanding of the nature of the ovule reductions we isolated orthologs of the Arabidopsis genes AINTEGUMENTA (ANT) and BELL1 (BEL1), which are associated with ovule development in this species. We observed ovular expression of ANT and BEL1 in patterns largely resembling those seen in the integumented ovules of Arabidopsis. These genes were found to be expressed in the integument of unitegmic ovules and in the surface layers of ategmic ovules, and in some cases, expression of BEL1 was also observed in the surrounding carpel tissue. We hypothesize that ategmic ovules derive from a fusion of the integuments with the nucellus or that the nucellus has taken on some of the characteristics confined to integuments in ancestral species.     

Angiosperm ovules: diversity, development, evolution

Background

Ovules as developmental precursors of seeds are organs of central importance in angiosperm flowers and can be traced back in evolution to the earliest seed plants. Angiosperm ovules are diverse in their position in the ovary, nucellus thickness, number and thickness of integuments, degree and direction of curvature, and histological differentiations. There is a large body of literature on this diversity, and various views on its evolution have been proposed over the course of time. Most recently evo–devo studies have been concentrated on molecular developmental genetics in ovules of model plants.

Scope

The present review provides a synthetic treatment of several aspects of the sporophytic part of ovule diversity, development and evolution, based on extensive research on the vast original literature and on experience from my own comparative studies in a broad range of angiosperm clades.

Conclusions

In angiosperms the presence of an outer integument appears to be instrumental for ovule curvature, as indicated from studies on ovule diversity through the major clades of angiosperms, molecular developmental genetics in model species, abnormal ovules in a broad range of angiosperms, and comparison with gymnosperms with curved ovules. Lobation of integuments is not an atavism indicating evolution from telomes, but simply a morphogenetic constraint from the necessity of closure of the micropyle. Ovule shape is partly dependent on locule architecture, which is especially indicated by the occurrence of orthotropous ovules. Some ovule features are even more conservative than earlier assumed and thus of special interest in angiosperm macrosystematics.     

Developmental morphology of the ovules of Amborella trichopoda (Amborellaceae) and Chloranthus serratus (Chloranthaceae)

The developmental morphology of the outer integument in the pendent orthotropous ovules of Amborella trichopoda (Amborellaceae) and Chloranthus serratus (Chloranthaceae) was studied. In both species the outer integument is semiannular at an early stage and becomes cup-shaped but dorsiventrally somewhat asymmetric at later stages. The outer integument, which is initiated first on the concave and lateral sides of the ovule, differs from that of the anatropous ovules of other basal families with the outer integument semiannular at an early stage or throughout development. The bilateral symmetry of the outer integument is shared by these orthotropous and anatropous ovules. The developmental pattern of the outer integument and ovule incurving characterize the ovule of the Amborellaceae and Chloranthaceae, which is not equivalent to typical orthotropous ovules of eudicots. A phylogenetic analysis of ovule characters in basal angiosperms suggests that anatropous ovules with cup-shaped outer integuments and orthotropous ovules were derived independently in several clades and that the ovules of Amborella and Chloranthus might also be derivative.     

OVULE ABORTION IN ‘NONPAREIL’ ALMOND (PRUNUS DULCIS [MILL.] D. A. WEBB)

The earliest indication of ovule abortion in almond (Prunus dulcis [Mill.] D. A. Webb ‘Nonpareil‘) is the deposition of callose (as indicated by aniline blue fluorescence) 2 days after pollination which is 2 days before clear histological symptoms of ovule degeneration are evident and 6 days before fertilization of the viable ovule. Callose deposition begins in the chalazal region of the nucellus where the funicular trace enters the ovule and ramifies into the integuments. As ovule abortion progresses, callose deposition in the inner integument extends as a ring around the nucellus. Movement of the fluorescent dye disodium fluorescein (uranin) indicated that translocation from the vascular trace into abortive ovules becomes blocked at the chalazal position. The dye freely penetrates and diffuses into viable ovules but fails to penetrate abortive ovules. Lack of, or delayed and irregular, megagametophyte development was another characteristic of abortive ovules. Biochemical and histochemical analyses of abortive and viable ovules indicated that carbohydrate depletion parallels ovule abortion. These observations lead to the conclusion that ovule abortion is accompanied by blockage in metabolite supply although whether this blockage is the primary cause or a consequence of ovule abortion is uncertain.     

The origin of the ovule

Of several theories for the origin of the ovule advanced in this century and based largely on fossil evidence, the telomic concept is widely considered the most plausible. Its principal tenet is the evolution of the integument through fusion of sterile branches or telomes around a terminal megasporangium. The only point of agreement in these theories is that the entire nucellus is a megasporangium that retains a single megaspore and the endosporic female gametophyte. Their differences center on the origin of the integument. A new concept offered here on evidence from ovules of both Paleozoic and extant seed plants significantly alters the telomic theory. It proposes that the nucellus is a sporangiophore of stem origin that bears a terminal megasporangium; that at least some of the fused integumentary telomes were fertile; and that among all features cited to characterize ovules, the unique nature of the retained megaspore alone defines the seed habit. Changes in the seed plant megaspore that extended the period of nutrient absorption over the whole course of female gametophyte development, along with complex physiological changes in the nucellus, were probably achieved along a single phylogenetic line beginning in a Late Devonian population of progymnosperms. For such a combination of events to have occurred more than once is highly unlikely, and, therefore, a monophyletic origin for seed plants is proposed. Several primitive features in ovule structure, some not evidenced since the Lower Carboniferous Period, occur in a mutant form of Arabidopsis thaliana isolated from genetically transformed plants. Their recurrence provides additional support for the proposed concept of ovule origin and also suggests that the genetic mechanisms for expression of primitive features in advanced taxa could be initiated in each case by mutation of a single homeotic gene.     

Resolving the systematic and phylogenetic position of isolated ovules: a case study on a new genus from the Permian of China

Isolated ovules occur in many fossil plant assemblages, where they provide important insights into seed‐plant diversity and evolution. However, in many cases, the ovules cannot be attributed to individual groups of seed plants, restricting systematic and evolutionary assessments that can be made from otherwise well‐characterized fossil taxa. In the present paper, we describe a new kind of ovule discovered in tuffaceous sediments from the Permian‐aged Xuanwei Formation in Guizhou Province, China. This ovule has 180° rotational symmetry and an integument comprising a variably thick sarcotesta, a uniformly thick sclerotesta and a uniformly thin endotesta. The nucellus is attached to the integument at least basally and contains a collapsed seed megaspore; a nucellar apex is absent. Both the integument and nucellus are vascularized by paired bundles in the major plane of the ovule; the integumentary bundles are considerably larger than the nucellar bundles and the nucellar bundles emerge from a conical vascular pad. Generation of a three‐dimensional reconstruction based on serial peels revealed the gross morphology and organization of the ovule and highlighted the presence of features consistent with cardiocarpalean‐type ovules (ovule shape, histological features of the integument) and also features more typical of lagenostomalean‐ and trigonocarpalean‐type ovules (large integumentary bundles, presence of nucellar bundles). To assess the affinity and evolutionary significance of the ovule, it has been included in a cladistic matrix of cardiocarpalean‐, lagenostomalean‐ and trigonocarpalean‐type ovules. Results place the ovule within the cardiocarpalean group of ovules known to have been produced by several plant groups, including cordaitean coniferophytes, pteridosperms and Palaeozoic conifers. The cladistic topology supports generic level distinction of the present species, requiring the establishment of Muricosperma guizhouensis Seyfullah & J.Hilton gen. & sp. nov . Lagenostomalean ovules produced by hydrasperman pteridosperms form a basal paraphyletic grade, whereas trigonocarpalean ovules produced by medullosan pteridosperms form a monophyletic group in which Stephanospermum is paraphyletic with respect to Rhynchosperma and Pachytesta. The results also place the Mississippian ovule Mitrospermum bulbosum apart from all of the Pennsylvanian species of Mitrospermum that form a strongly supported clade. Consequently, M. bulbosum is transferred to the new genus Whitaddera Seyfullah & J.Hilton as W. bulbosa (Long) Seyfullah & J.Hilton. © 2010 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2010, 164 , 84–108.     

ONTOGENY OF THE PALEOZOIC OVULE,CALLOSPERMARION PUSILLUM

The ontogeny of the upper Pennsylvanian age gymnospermous ovule, Callospermarion pusillum, is described from petrifaction specimens collected at the Berryville locality in Illinois. Ovules exhibit a wide range of dimensional and structural features that indicate an extensive developmental sequence. Specimens range from ovules with indistinct zonation of the thin-walled integument to those with thick-walled cells of the sclerotesta. The apex of the fleshy nucellus in some specimens is preserved as a cellular mound, while in others a well-formed cellular pollen chamber is present; still other ovules are characterized by a papery-thin nucellus and pollen chamber wall. The megagametophyte of most specimens is represented by a hollow megaspore membrane that may be restricted to the base of the nucellus, or occupy the entire seed cavity. In a few specimens cellular gametophytes are preserved, and in one ovule archegonia with supposed eggs are also present. Variability in each of the features is compared with ontogenetic changes in comparable structures of living gymnospermous ovules and is correlated with ovule size. A developmental sequence for the fossil ovules is proposed.     

The phenotype of Arabidopsis ovule mutants mimics the morphology of primitive seed plants

In seed plants, the ovule is the female reproductive structure, which surrounds and nourishes the gametophyte and embryo. This investigation describes the PRETTY FEW SEEDS2 (PFS2) locus, which regulates ovule patterning. The pfs2 mutant exhibited developmental defects in the maternal integuments and gametophyte. This mutation was inherited as a maternal trait, indicating that gametophyte defects resulted from ovule patterning aberrations. Specifically, the boundary between the chalaza and the nucellus, two regions of the ovule primordia, shifted towards the distal end of pfs2 ovule primordia. Results indicated that the PFS2 locus could: (i) be involved in the development of either the nucellus or the chalaza; or (ii) establish a boundary between these two regions. Examination of genetic interactions of the pfs2 mutation with other well-characterized ovule loci indicates that this locus affects integument morphogenesis. Interestingly, the pfs2 inner no outer and pfs2 strubbelig double mutants had inner integuments that appeared similar to their ancestral precursor. The fossil record indicates that the inner integument evolved by fusion of sterilized sporangia or branches around a central megasporangium. The question of whether the structures observed in these double mutants are homologous or merely analogous to the ancestral precursors of the inner integument is discussed.     

依兰(番荔枝科)雌配子体发育研究

荔枝科是被子植物的基部类群之一,依兰属是番荔枝科较为原始的类群,其有性生殖过程,特别是胚胎发生与发育的研究结果,可以补充被子植物胚胎学原始特征的相关基础资料。该研究利用常规石蜡切片技术,对依兰胚珠、大孢子和雌配子体的发生发育过程进行了观察。结果表明:依兰的胚珠为倒生胚珠、厚珠心、三层珠被,第三层珠被(中间珠被)发生在大孢子母细胞时期,于外珠被与内珠被之间、胚珠合点端两侧发生并隆起;雌配子体为蓼型。此外,依兰的个别胚珠中存在双雌配子体现象,且两个雌配子体均由大孢子母细胞发育而来,大小、形状相近,呈线形排列。该研究结果对于揭示原始被子植物胚胎发育特征具有重要意义。     

Ovule morphogenesis in Ranunculaceae and its systematic significance

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Ranunculaceae has a prominent phylogenetic position in Ranunculales which appears at the base of eudicots. The aims of the present paper are to reveal the features of ovule morphogenesis in different taxa and gain a better understanding of the systematics of Ranunculaceae. METHODS: Flowers of 17 species from three subfamilies, nine tribes and 16 genera of Ranunculaceae, at successive developmental stages, were collected in the wild and studied with a scanning electron microscope. KEY RESULTS: The integuments in the unitegmic ovules in Helleborus, Ranunculus and Oxygraphis, as well as the inner integuments in the bitegmic genera, initiate annularly and eventually become cup-shaped. However, the integuments in the unitegmic ovules in Anemone and Clematis, as well as the outer integuments in the bitegmic genera, arise semi-annularly and eventually become hood-shaped. Different kinds of appendages appear on the ovules during development. In Coptis of subfamily Coptidoideae, a wrap-shaped appendage arises outside the ovule and envelopes the ovule entirely. In the genera of subfamily Thalictroideae and tribe Anemoneae of subfamily Ranunculoideae, appendages appear on the placenta, the funicle or both. In tribe Helleboreae of subfamily Ranunculoideae, an alary appendage is initiated where the integument and the funicle join and becomes hood-shaped. CONCLUSIONS: Ovule morphogenesis characteristics are significant in classification at the levels of subfamilies and tribes. The initiation patterns of the integuments and the development of appendages show diversity in Ranunculaceae. The present observations suggest that the bitegmic, hood-shaped outer integument and endostomic micropyle are primitive while the unitegmic, cupular-shaped outer integument and bistomic micropyle are derivative.     

Expression-based discovery of candidate ovule development regulators through transcriptional profiling of ovule mutants

Background  

Arabidopsis ovules comprise four morphologically distinct parts: the nucellus, which contains the embryo sac, two integuments that become the seed coat, and the funiculus that anchors the ovule within the carpel. Analysis of developmental mutants has shown that ovule morphogenesis relies on tightly regulated genetic interactions that can serve as a model for developmental regulation. Redundancy, pleiotropic effects and subtle phenotypes may preclude identification of mutants affecting some processes in screens for phenotypic changes. Expression-based gene discovery can be used access such obscured genes.     

Development of ovule,fruit and seed of Xyris (Xyridaceae,Poales) and taxonomic considerations

The development of the ovule, fruit and seed of Xyris spp. was studied to assess the embryological characteristics of potential taxonomic usefulness. All of the studied species have (1) orthotropous, bitegmic and tenuinucellate ovules, with a micropyle formed by both the endostoma and exostoma; (2) a cuticle in the ovules and seeds between the nucellus/endosperm and the inner integument and between the inner and outer integuments; (3) helobial, starchy endosperm; (4) a reduced, campanulate and undifferentiated embryo; (5) a seed coat formed by a tanniferous endotegmen, endotesta with thick‐walled cells and exotesta with thin‐walled cells; and (6) a micropylar operculum formed from inner and outer integuments. The pericarp is composed of a mesocarp with cells containing starch grains and an endocarp and exocarp formed by cells with U‐shaped thickened walls. The studied species differ in the embryo sac development, which can be of the Polygonum or Allium type, and in the pericarp, which can have larger cells in either endocarp or exocarp. The Allium‐type embryo sac development was observed only in Xyris spp. within Xyridaceae. Xyris also differs from the other genera of Xyridaceae by the presence of orthotropous ovules and a seed coat formed by endotegmen, endotesta and exotesta, in agreement with the division of the family into Xyridoideae and Abolbodoideae. © 2015 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2015, 177 , 619–628.     

Morphological and ontogenetic studies on southern African podocarps. Initiation of the seed scale complex and early development of integument, nucellus and epimatium

STOFFBERG, E., 1991. Morphological and ontogenetic studies on southern African podocarps. Initiation of the seed scale complex and early development of integument, nucellus and epimatium. The primordium of the seed scale complex (ssc) (ovule with epimatium) is initiated in the axil of the first or second cone bracts (prophylls) as a dome shaped structure consisting of a group of uniform, meristematic cells. A distinct protodermal layer develops. The nucellus is a dome on the ventral side of the ssc primordium. In the species of section Podocarpus the integument is initiated as a circular ridge around the nucellus, while in P.falcatus two protrusions on the anterior and posterior sides of the nucellus are the first indications of integumentary differentiation. The integument of all species studied is of subdermal origin. The epimatium (sensu stricto) is initiated after the integument, is of subdermal origin and forms a hood around the developing ovule. Considering research results, together with related literature, it is concluded that the integument of gymnosperms may be homologous with the outer integument of a bitegmic angiospermous ovule, that the position of integumentary initiation may be specific for certain taxa and that there seems to be no constant sequence of emergence of ovular envelopes in gymnosperms.     

Latisemenia longshania,gen. et sp. nov., a new Late Devonian seed plant from China

The earliest known ovules in the Late Devonian (Famennian) are borne terminally on fertile branches and are typically enclosed in a cupule. Among these ovules are some that have terete integumentary lobes with little or no fusion. Here, we report a new taxon, Latisemenia longshania, from the Famennian of South China, which bears cupulate ovules that are terminal as well as opposite on the fertile axis. Each ovule has four broad integumentary lobes, which are extensively fused to each other and also to the nucellus. The cupule is uniovulate, and the five flattened cupule segments of each terminal ovule are elongate cuneate and shorter than the ovule. Associated but not attached pinnules are laminate and Sphenopteris-like, with an entire or lobate margin. Latisemenia is the earliest known plant with ovules borne on the side of the fertile axis and may foreshadow the diverse ovule arrangements found among younger seed plant lineages that emerge in the Carboniferous. Following the telome theory, Latisemenia demonstrates derived features in both ovules and cupules, and the shape and fusion of integumentary lobes suggest effective pollination and protection to the nucellus. Along with other recent discoveries from China, Latisemenia extends the palaeogeographic range of the earliest seed plants.     

Comparative embryology of Bambusa tulda Roxb. and Thyrsostachys siamensis Gamble (Poaceae: Bambuseae)

Bambusa tulda and Thyrsostachys siamensis resemble each other in having an obovate ovary which is hairy and thickened along the apex, a pseudo-crassinucellate ovule with a wide region of attachment, poorly-developed and ephemeral outer integument, an inner integument which fails to grow beyond the nucellus, 'Polygonum' type of embryo sac ontogeny, parallel orientation of embryo sac to the long axis of the ovule, multiple antipodals which retain apical position in the embryo sac even during post-fertilization phase of development, an ephemeral nucellus, relatively small bambusoid embryos, and many-layered and apically thickened pericarp. However, they differ from each other in their gynoecial structure, the extent of the development of the outer integument, organization of megaspore tetrads and development-stage-related behaviour of the inner integument in the fertilized ovules. These taxa also differ from other members of the subfamily Bambusoideae in the structure of the mature ovule, endosperm and pericarp.     

Ovule and gametophyte development in Nicotiana glauca Graham (Solanaceae)

Abstract

The development of ovule and megagametophyte is examined in Nicotiana glauca, using light microscopy. The ovules proved unitegmic, tenuinucellate and endothelial as in all the Solanaceae so far studied. The ovule primordia are of the three-zonate type. The integument, which is of dermal origin, is at first two-layered but later produces additional intermediate cells whose origin is not constant. The nucellus, whose initial curvature bears no relation to the origin of the integument, has, like other Solanaceae, a one or two-celled archesporium from which a single meiocyte develops. The gametophyte is confirmed to be bisporic in origin and its development follows the Allium type. Furthermore, the hypostase, which is rare in the family, is observed below the antipodal cells.