DEVELOPMENTAL SELECTION IN RESPONSE TO ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS OF THE MATERNAL PARENT IN MIMULUS GUTTATUS

Copper tolerance is expressed in the diploid sporophyte as well as the microgametophyte of Mimulus guttatus. Previous studies, based on reproductive output, suggested that selection for copper tolerance could occur within the pistil. The objective of this study was to determine if selection within the pistil can increase sporophytic tolerance to copper and to determine whether this selection occurs pre- or postzygotically. Mixtures of pollen from copper tolerant or sensitive sources or from plants heterozygous for tolerance to copper were applied at two intensities to plants cloned and grown in control or copper supplemented solutions. The proportion of copper tolerant progeny showed a small, 7%, but significant increase when pollen recipients were grown with added copper. Comparisons of the numbers of tolerant progeny, as well as various components of reproduction, following light and heavy pollinations suggested that microgametophytic selection was unlikely to account for this increase. However, the 8 to 10% decrease in the seed/zygote ratio, compared to control values, was sufficient to account for the difference in proportion of copper tolerant progeny from control and copper treated plants. Thus, it appeared likely that selection for copper tolerance could occur within the pistil, and that much of this selection occurred postzygotically through the early failure of developing seeds.     

Haplo-diploid gene expression and pollen selection for tolerance to acetochlor in maize

The objectives of this research were to determine if genes controlling the reaction to the herbicide acetochlor in maize (Zea mays L.) are active during both the haploid and the diploid phases of the life cycle and if pollen selection can be utilized for improving sporophytic resistance. Pollen of eight inbred lines, previously characterized through sporophytic analysis for the level of tolerance to acetochlor, showed a differential reaction to the herbicide forin vitro tube length; moreover, such pollen reactions proved to be significantly correlated (r =0.786^*,df=6) with those of the sporophytes producing the pollen. Pollen analysis of two inbred lines (i.e. Mo17, tolerant, and B79, susceptible) and their single cross showed that thein vitro pollen-tube length reaction of the hybrid was intermediate between those of two parents. An experiment on pollen selection was then performed by growing tassels of Mo17xB79 in the presence of the herbicide. Pollen obtained from treated tassels showed a greater tolerance to acetochlor, assessed asin vitro tube length reaction, than pollen obtained from control tassels. Moreover, the backcross [B79 (Mo17xB79)] sporophytic population obtained using pollen from the treated tassels was more tolerant (as indicated by the fresh weight of plants grown in the presence of the herbicide) than was the control backcross population. The two populations did not differ when grown without the herbicide. These findings indicate that genes controlling the reaction to acetochlor in maize have haplodiploid expression; consequently, pollen selection can be applied for improving plant tolerance.     

Sporophytic response to pollen selection for Alachlor tolerance in maize

In order to assess the efficiency of male gametophytic selection (MGS) for crop improvement, pollen selection for tolerance to herbicide was applied in maize. The experiment was designed to test the parallel reactivity to Alachlor of pollen and plants grown in controlled conditions or in the field, the response to pollen selection in the sporophytic progeny, the response to a second cycle of MGS, and the transmission of the selected trait to the following generations. The results demonstrated that pollen assay can be used to predict Alachlor tolerance under field conditions and to monitor the response to selection. A positive response to selection applied to pollen in the sporophytic progeny was obtained in diverse genetic backgrounds, indicating that the technique can be generally included in standard breeding programs; the analysis of the data produced in a second selection cycle indicated that the selected trait is maintained in the next generation.     

Pollen selection for low temperature adaptation in tomato

Summary Pollen selection experiments were conducted in tomato to determine the effects of low temperature conditions during pollination on the rate of root elongation of the progeny. Pollen was harvested from an F₁ interspecific hybrid between a high altitude Lycopersicon hirsutum accession and the cultivated tomato L. esculentum. The pollen was applied to stigmas of malesterile L. esculentum plants maintained in growth chambers set at either 12°C/7°C or 24°C/18°C. BC₁ seeds from the low and normal temperature crosses were germinated and root elongation rate was measured at either 9°C or 24°C. At 9°C, the rate of root elongation for progeny of the low temperature crosses was higher than for progeny of crosses at normal temperatures; at 24°C the rate of root elongation was similar for the two crossing treatments. To compare the temperature responses of the two backcross populations we also calculated the relative inhibitory effect of low temperature on the rate of root elongation: the ratio between the rate of root elongation at 9°C to that at 24°C. Root elongation of seedlings from the low temperature crosses was less inhibited by the cold than root elongation for progeny of the normal temperature crosses. These results suggest a relationship between pollen selection at low temperatures and the expression of a sporophytic trait under the same environmental stress.     

Procedures for identifying S-allele genotypes of Brassica

Summary Procedures are described for efficient selection of: (1) homozygous and heterozygous S-allele genotypes; (2) homozygous inbreds with the strong self- and sib-incompatibility required for effective seed production of single-cross F₁ hybrids; (3) heterozygous genotypes with the high self- and sib-incompatibility required for effective seed production of 3- and 4-way hybrids.From reciprocal crosses between two first generation inbred (I₁) plants there are three potential results: both crosses are incompatible; one is incompatible and the other compatible; and both are compatible. Incompatibility of both crosses is useful information only when combined with data from other reciprocal crosses. Each compatible cross, depending on whether its reciprocal is incompatible or compatible, dictates alternative reasoning and additional reciprocal crosses for efficiently and simultaneously identifying: (A) the S-allele genotype of all individual I₁ plants, and (B) the expressions of dominance or codominance in pollen and stigma (sexual organs) of an S-allele heterozygous genotype. Reciprocal crosses provide the only efficient means of identifying S-allele genotypes and also the sexual-organ x S-allele-interaction types.Fluorescent microscope assay of pollen tube penetration into the style facilitates quantitation within 24–48 hours of incompatibility and compatibility of the reciprocal crosses. A procedure for quantitating the reciprocal difference is described that maximizes informational content of the data about interactions between S alleles in pollen and stigma of the S-allele-heterozygous genotype.Use of the non-inbred I_o generation parent as a known heterozygous S-allele genotype in crosses with its first generation selfed (I₁) progeny usually reduces at least 7 fold the effort required for achieving objectives 1, 2, and 3, compared to the method of making reciprocal crosses only among I₁ plants.Identifying the heterozygous and both homozygous S-allele genotypes during the I₁ generation facilitates, during subsequent inbred generations, strong selection for or against modifier genes that influence the intensity of self- and sib-incompatibility. Selection for strong self and sib incompatibility can be effective for both homozygous inbreds and also for the S-allele heterozygote, thus facilitating production of single-cross F₁ hybrids and also of 3-and 4-way hybrids.Department of Plant Breeding and Biometry paper No. 690     

Effects of pollination intensity on the vigor of the sporophytic and gametophytic generation of Cucurbita texana

 We examined the effects of pollen competition (pollen load size) on sporophytic vigor and gametophytic performance in Cucurbita texana, a wild gourd, while controlling for alternative interpretations of the data. Under field conditions we compared the vigor of progeny produced from large and small pollen loads and examined the in vitro performance of the pollen produced by the progeny. We found that the progeny from large pollen loads germinated faster and had a greater reproductive output (male flowers and fruits) than progeny produced from small pollen loads. In addition, we found that the pollen produced on plants derived from large pollen loads grew faster in vitro than the pollen produced on plants derived from small pollen loads. These findings indicate that pollen competition affects the performance of the resulting sporophytic generation and the microgametophytes they produce. Received: 26 January 1997 / Revision accepted: 25 June 1997     

The parallel expression of metal tolerance in pollen and sporophytes of Silene dioica (L.) Clairv., S. alba (mill.) krause and Mimulus guttatus DC

Summary The purpose of this paper was to determine if heavy metal tolerance was expressed in pollen and if its expression was correlated with the tolerance of the pollen source. Clones of Silene dioica, tolerant to zinc, closely related but nontolerant S. alba and clones of Mimulus guttatus tolerant and sensitive to copper were grown in the greenhouse in either standard potting soil or nutrient culture. Pollen was collected shortly after dehiscence, hydrated, and tested over a broad range of metal concentrations. The tolerance of the pollen source was determined by comparing root growth in solutions with and without heavy metals. In both Silene species and M. guttatus, the tolerance of the parental clone was expressed in its pollen. Pollen from tolerant individuals was able to germinate and grow at concentrations of metals which markedly inhibited pollen from nontolerants.     

Evidence of apomixis in hemisexual dogroses, Rosa section Caninae

All members of Rosa section Caninae, dogroses are polyploid and characterized by their unbalanced meiosis, which in most cases leads to a pronounced morphological influence from the maternal parent. In a previous investigation on a pair of reciprocal crosses between two species in this section, Rosa dumalis and R. rubiginosa (2n=35), nine offspring plants (approximately 10%) did not receive any of the 21 RAPD markers present in the respective pollen parent. This was interpreted as a possible occurrence of apomixis. These nine plants have now been subjected to a further study with additional markers. Thirteen new RAPD markers showed the same result as in the previous investigation: none of the nine plants inherited any of the pollen donor markers. The reproducibility of the RAPD markers was checked by mixing DNA samples to obtain a series of artificial hybrids between the two parent plants. Twelve RAPD markers gave the expected result, whereas one marker appeared only 50% of the time. In addition, pollen viability, mean number of seeds per hip, mean seed weight, and mean weight of fruit flesh per hip have been studied on the four progeny groups: R. dumalis×R. rubiginosa plants which received pollen donor markers (PM plants), R. dumalis×R. rubiginosa plants which did not receive any pollen donor markers (NPM plants), R. rubiginosa×R. dumalis PM plants and R. rubiginosa×R. dumalis NPM plants. A canonical discriminant analysis based on these four reproductive characters separated the four progeny groups. There were significant differences between the two PM groups in all investigated characters, and also between the PM and the NPM groups in pollen viability. The result from the RAPD markers together with the differences in pollen viability between the PM and NPM progeny groups is taken as an indication that apomixis occurs within the Caninae section. Received: 13 October 1999 / Revision accepted: 28 January 2000     

DIFFERENTIAL SEED PRODUCTION IN MIMULUS GUTTATUS IN RESPONSE TO INCREASING CONCENTRATIONS OF COPPER IN THE PISTIL BY POLLEN FROM COPPER TOLERANT AND SENSITIVE SOURCES

Selection can occur in the pistil, during a series of stages that include both pre-zygotic (pollen germination, pollen tube growth, and fertilization) and post-zygotic events. This study explores the extent to which selection, at this level, could be due to the environmental conditions under which the maternal parent is growing. Five plants of Mimulus guttatus, tolerant to copper, were vegetatively cloned and each clone was grown in control and in solutions to which copper was added. The maternal plants received pollen from plants either tolerant or sensitive to copper. Seeds and ovules were counted to estimate the number of seeds/capsule, the seed/ovule ratio, the percent fertilization, and the proportion of zygotes aborting for each clone, treatment and pollen source combination. There were large differences among the pollen recipients for each of the measurements. However, there was a consistent pattern to seed production depending on the pollen source and copper treatment. The seed/ovule ratio was unaffected if pollen came from tolerant sources but was reduced by an average of 24% for both copper supplemented treatments if pollen came from copper sensitive sources. Thus, the data indicated that selection due to environmental factors could occur within the pistil. Differences in percent fertilization were not statistically significant, but the seed/zygote ratio showed a pattern that was similar to seed production suggesting that abortion of immature seeds was responsible for most of the difference in seed production.     

Self-incompatibility and interspecific incompatibility: relationships in intra- and interspecific crosses of Zinnia elegans Jacq. and Z. angustifolia HBK (Compositae)

Summary Intraspecific and reciprocal interspecific crosses involving Zinnia angustifolia clones and Z. elegans lines showed that in both species, sporophytic self-incompatibility (SI) systems were present. Intensity of SI varied among clones and lines, and high self seed set was associated with a concomitant decrease in callose fluorescence in papillae and pollen tubes. Incomplete stigmatic inhibition of pollen germination and tube growth was observed in reciprocal interspecific crosses and associated with callose synthesis, suggesting S-gene activity. Seed set and progeny obtained following Z. angustifolia×Z. elegans matings was comparable to intraspecific compatible matings of Z. angustifolia although the rate of pollen tube growth through the style was slower. In Z. elegans × Z. angustifolia matings, additional prezygotic barriers were present and acted between pollen tube penetration of the stigma and syngamy. SI X SI interspecific incompatibility was essentially unilateral, with no embryos or progeny obtained when Z. elegans was the pistillate parent. It was hypothesized that nonfunctioning of Z. elegans × Z. angustifolia crosses was due to S-gene expression at the stigmatic surface and to other isolating mechanisms in the stylar or ovarian transmitting tissue.Scientific Article No. A-4448, Contribution No. 7439 of the Maryland Agricultural Experiment Station, Department of HorticultureA portion of this paper was presented in the report: Boyle TH, Stimart DP (1986) Incompatibility relationships in intra- and interspecific crosses of Z. elegans Jacq. and Z. angustifolia HBK (Compositae). In: Mulcahy D (ed) Biotechnology and ecology of pollen. Springer, New York     

Pollen competitive ability in maize: within population variability and response to selection

Summary Male gametophytic selection can play a special role in the evolution of higher plant populations. The main assumption — gametophytic-sporophytic gene expression of a large portion of a plant's genes — has been proven by a number of studies. Population analyses have revealed a large amount of variability for male gametophytic fitness. However, the data available do not prove that at least a portion of this variability is due to postmeiotic gene expression. This paper reports the analysis of a synthetic population of maize based on a gametophytic selection experiment, carried out according to a recurrent scheme. After two cycles of selection, the response was evaluated for gametophytic and sporophytic traits. A parameter representing pollen viability and time to germination, although showing a large amount of genetic variability, was not affected by gametophytic selection, indicating that this variability is largely sporophytically controlled. Pollen tube growth rate was significantly affected by gametophytic selection: 21.6% of the genetical variability was released by selection. Correlated response for sporophytic traits was observed for mean kernel weight: 15.67% of the variability was released. The results are a direct demonstration that pollen competitive ability due to pollen tube growth rate and kernel development are controlled, to a considerable extent, by genes expressed in both tissues. They also indicate that gametophytic selection in higher plants can produce a higher evolution rate than sporophytic selection; it can thus serve to regulate the amount of genetic variability in the populations by removing a large amount of the genetic load produced by recombination.     

An unusual heteromorphic incompatibility system

Summary By means of intra- and intermorph crosses it has been shown that the distyly in Anchusa officinalis L. is governed by a single diallelic locus with dominance. Presence of the dominant allele is reflected in the short-styled morph, while homozygous recessives become long-styled. Most of the short-styled plants are heterozygous, but homozygotes have been found among the raised progeny resulting from crossings. Diallel crosses have revealed that at least two incompatibility loci must exist. These and the morphological locus segregate independently. The type of incompatibility system is as yet unknown, though the great frequency of non-reciprocal incompatibility points to a sporophytic system.     

Pollen genotype selection for a simply inherited qualitative factor determining resistance to chlorsulfuron in maize

Pollen genotype selection for genes expressed in both the haploid and diploid phases of the plant life cycle can lead to correlated responses detectable in the sporophyte. A pollen selection was conducted in two genetic backgrounds of maize (Zea mays L.) for chlorsulfuron resistance, conferred by the XA17 allele. Plants of two backcross (BC) lines segregating 1 (heterozygote, resistant) : 1 (homozygote, susceptible) for chlorsulfuron resistance were used as pollen donor. Selection treatment was applied during microspore development, and tassels were cut about 10 days before anthesis and placed into a liquid medium with or without 40 mg l^–1 of chlorsulfuron. Pollen was used to fertilize an unrelated susceptible genotype (tester). The resulting testcrosses (TC) were evaluated in the greenhouse by spraying seedlings with chlorsulfuron at 23 g ha^–1. Non-selected TC progenies derived from heterozygous BC plants showed a proportion of resistant and susceptible plants close to the expected 1:1 ratio, while non-selected TC progenies derived from homozygous BC plants showed susceptible plants only. Selected TC progenies derived from heterozygous BC plants showed a frequency of resistant plants ranging from 89% to 100%. BC plants homozygous for the susceptible allele, subjected to selection treatment, gave poor seed set, and no resistant plants were found in their TC progenies. Resistant TC plants obtained through pollen genotype selection were selfed, and the proportion of resistant plants was close to 3:1 in all selfed families, in accordance with the hypothesis that all of them inherited the XA17 allele through selection. In this study, pollen genotype selection was extremely effective, and its effect persisted in the second sporophytic generation. Received: 19 November 1999 / Accepted: 30 April 2000     

Sporophytic-gametophytic herbicide tolerance in sugarbeet

Summary In vitro selection procedures for herbicide tolerance were initially developed in the sporophytic generation of sugarbeet (Beta vulgaris L.), and then tested in the gametophytic generation. The primary objective of our study was to develop and evaluate in vitro techniques for identifying genotypes within heterogeneous seedling populations tolerant to specific herbicides, and to use meristematic cloning procedures to synthesize clones genetically tolerant to the herbicide. Seed from cloned selections tolerant to the herbicide ethofumesate were obtained and compared to plants from seed of the original population (using germination, central bud development, and root dry weight). Verification for in vitro selection accuracy was accomplished by pollen germination studies in the gametophyte. The results indicate that in vitro selection of germinated seedlings in the presence of the proper concentration of challenging agent can be effective in identifying genotypes tolerant to ethofumesate. Such identification was accomplished in fully differentiated tissue, but without the necessity of mature plants. Gametophytic studies, via pollen germination, indicated an association between genes operating in the sprophyte and those in the gametophyte. Cloning the seedlings identified as tolerant genotypes, and subsequent intercrossing of these clones provided a convenient method of synthesizing populations with gene frequencies shifted in the direction desired.Joint contribution of the Agricultural Research Service, USDA, and the Colorado State University Experiment Station. Published with the approval of the Director of the Colorado State University Experiment Station as Scientific Series Paper No. 2952     

Pollen germination and tube growth in rye (Secade cereale L.) homozygous and heterozygous for reciprocal translocations

Summary To contribute to the knowledge of the role of reciprocal translocations in rye, a component of fertility was estimated by comparing germination and pollen tube growth in homozygous and heterozygous plants for reciprocal translocations. The results obtained indicate that there are no differences in germination and pollen tube growth rate when homozygous and heterozygous plants as a whole are compared. However, there are significant differences in pollen tube growth between plants carrying different translocations. This suggests that the chromosome constitution of a plant is relevant to these fitness-estimating parameters together with its particular genetic background.     

Effects of simulated microgravity on male gametophyte of Prunus, Pyrus, and Brassica species

Summary. In this study we evaluated the effect of simulated microgravity on pollen germination of both herbaceous and woody species in order to investigate the possibility of applying gametophytic selection for plant growth in the space environment. The behaviour of gametophytes exposed to the stress of clinostat rotation could be used to screen the degree of tolerance of the sporophyte to simulated microgravity. The use of male gametophyte selection overcomes the problems generally encountered by sporophytic selection in space especially for woody plants: the large size of plants and their long juvenile phase. In this experiment, pollen collected from just bloomed flowers of Prunus persica, P. avium, P. domestica, Pyrus communis, and Brassica rapa was subjected to tests assessing its viability by techniques such as fluorochromatic reaction. Once pollen viability was ascertained by fluorescence microscopy, pollen was placed on the growth medium in petri dishes both at 1 g and on the clinostat. After incubating for 1 day at room temperature, pollen was observed under a light microscope in order to detect parameters such as the percentage of germination and the growth direction. Then histochemical analyses were performed in order to verify the presence and distribution of nuclei, cytoplasm, and storage substances. Moreover, the presence, size, and morphology of callose plugs were observed. Results showed that the response of gametophytes to simulated microgravity is dependent on the species, some showing altered metabolism, others being unaffected. Correspondence and reprints: Laboratorio di Botanica ed Ecologia Riproduttiva, Dipartimento di Arboricoltura, Botanica e Patologia Vegetale, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II, Via Università 100, I 80055 Portici (Naples), Italy.     

Microgametophytic selection in two alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) clones

Summary Microgametophytic selection was investigated using two ecologically diverse autotetraploid clones of alfalfa. Several selection pressures (drying, aging, freezing, and high and low temperatures) were applied to microgametophytes at three stages of the life cycle, 1) during microsporogenesis, 2) post-anthesis, and 3) pollen tube growth. Pollen aging produced a progeny population with a greater mean plant size and a lower coefficient of variation than the control progeny. High temperature (29.5 °C) applied both during microsporogenesis and pollen tube growth resulted in progeny populations which were significantly taller and, in one case, had a larger leaf number than the control populations. In contrast, air dried pollen resulted in a progeny population which had significantly smaller character means and larger coefficients of variation than the control population. Also, low temperature (15 °C) during pollen tube growth yielded progeny with reduced branch number and a larger coefficient of variation than the control progeny. In cases where progeny derived from selected microgametophytes were found to differ from the control offspring, corresponding shifts in the reciprocal cross were not observed. For the temperature stress treatments, the lack of reciprocal differences may be related to the different temperature adaptations of the two ecotypes. These results suggest that microgametophytic selection can be effective in shifting the mean of the progeny generation; however, the results obtained will vary depending upon the selection pressure, stage of selection, and the parents used.     

Effects of Alternaria alternata f.sp. lycopersici toxins on pollen

Summary Effects of the phytotoxic compounds (AAL-toxins) isolated from cell-free culture filtrates of Alternaria alternata f.sp. lycopersici on in vitro pollen development were studied. AAL-toxins inhibited both germination and tube growth of pollen from several Lycopersicon genotypes. Pollen from susceptible genotypes, however, was more sensitive for AAL-toxins than pollen from resistant plants, while pollen of species not belonging to the host range of the fungus was not significantly affected by the tested toxin concentrations. AAL-toxins elicit symptoms in detached leaf bioassays indistinguishable from those observed on leaves of fungal infected tomato plants, and toxins play a major role in the pathogenesis. Apparently, pathogenesis-related processes and mechanisms involved in disease resistance are expressed in both vegetative and generative tissues. This overlap in gene expression between the sporophytic and gametophytic level of a plant may be advantageously utilized in plant breeding programmes. Pollen may be used to distinguish susceptible and resistant plants and to select for resistances and tolerances against phytotoxins and other selective agents.     

Gene expression during the male gametophytic phase

Abstract

In recent years a number of experimental findings have indicated that in higher plants the gametophytic phase is able to express its own genetic information, a large part of which it shares with the sporophytic generation. Quantitative estimates of haploid and haplodiploid gene expression have been obtained by mRNA and isozyme analysis in several plant species: 60-70% of the genes are expressed in both pollen and plant, about 10% are pollen-specific, and 20% represent the sporophytic domain. Moreover, it has been demonstrated that stage-specific genes are expressed in the gametophytic generation: at least two sets of genes are activated during pollen development, others are expressed only in the postshedding period, during germination and tube growth. Studies have been made to ascertain the role played by gametophyte-expressed genes in pollen development; the in vivo and in vitro pollen tube growth rate has been revealed to be controlled by the gametophyte genome itself. Differential effects of specific chromosomal deficiencies on the development of maize pollen grains have indicated that components of normal microspore development are controlled by genes located in specific parts of the genome. For single gene analysis, gene transfer can be used; on the contrary, for traits with a multifactorial genetic control, direct proof of gene expression both in the gametophytic and the sporophytic generation can be obtained when selection is applied to the pollen population of a hybrid plant, and response to selection is observed in the resulting sporophytic progeny. Response to selection, applied at different stages of the gametophytic phase, has been described in the sporophytic progeny and this with regard to many adaptive traits; thus the phenomenon can have an important bearing on the genetic structure of natural populations and on higher plant evolution, it can also be used as a breeding tool to increase the efficiency of conventional selection methods.