Crystal Structure of the Homing Endonuclease I-CvuI Provides a New Template for Genome Modification

Homing endonucleases recognize and generate a DNA double-strand break, which has been used to promote gene targeting. These enzymes recognize long DNA stretches; they are highly sequence-specific enzymes and display a very low frequency of cleavage even in complete genomes. Although a large number of homing endonucleases have been identified, the landscape of possible target sequences is still very limited to cover the complexity of the whole eukaryotic genome. Therefore, the finding and molecular analysis of homing endonucleases identified but not yet characterized may widen the landscape of possible target sequences. The previous characterization of protein-DNA interaction before the engineering of new homing endonucleases is essential for further enzyme modification. Here we report the crystal structure of I-CvuI in complex with its target DNA and with the target DNA of I-CreI, a homologue enzyme widely used in genome engineering. To characterize the enzyme cleavage mechanism, we have solved the I-CvuI DNA structures in the presence of non-catalytic (Ca²⁺) and catalytic ions (Mg²⁺). We have also analyzed the metal dependence of DNA cleavage using Mg²⁺ ions at different concentrations ranging from non-cleavable to cleavable concentrations obtained from in vitro cleavage experiments. The structure of I-CvuI homing endonuclease expands the current repertoire for engineering custom specificities, both by itself as a new scaffold alone and in hybrid constructs with other related homing endonucleases or other DNA-binding protein templates.     

Homing endonuclease I-CreI derivatives with novel DNA target specificities

Homing endonucleases are highly specific enzymes, capable of recognizing and cleaving unique DNA sequences in complex genomes. Since such DNA cleavage events can result in targeted allele-inactivation and/or allele-replacement in vivo, the ability to engineer homing endonucleases matched to specific DNA sequences of interest would enable powerful and precise genome manipulations. We have taken a step-wise genetic approach in analyzing individual homing endonuclease I-CreI protein/DNA contacts, and describe here novel interactions at four distinct target site positions. Crystal structures of two mutant endonucleases reveal the molecular interactions responsible for their altered DNA target specificities. We also combine novel contacts to create an endonuclease with the predicted target specificity. These studies provide important insights into engineering homing endonucleases with novel target specificities, as well as into the evolution of DNA recognition by this fascinating family of proteins.     

A highly sensitive selection method for directed evolution of homing endonucleases

Homing endonucleases are enzymes that catalyze DNA sequence specific double-strand breaks and can significantly stimulate homologous recombination at these breaks. These enzymes have great potential for applications such as gene correction in gene therapy or gene alteration in systems biology and metabolic engineering. However, homing endonucleases have a limited natural repertoire of target sequences, which severely hamper their applications. Here we report the development of a highly sensitive selection method for the directed evolution of homing endonucleases that couples enzymatic DNA cleavage with the survival of host cells. Using I-SceI as a model homing endonuclease, we have demonstrated that cells with wild-type I-SceI showed a high cell survival rate of 80–100% in the presence of the original I-SceI recognition site, whereas cells without I-SceI showed a survival rate <0.003%. This system should also be readily applicable for directed evolution of other DNA cleavage enzymes.     

The C-terminal loop of the homing endonuclease I-CreI is essential for site recognition, DNA binding and cleavage

Meganucleases are sequence-specific endonucleases with large cleavage sites that can be used to induce efficient homologous gene targeting in cultured cells and plants. These enzymes open novel perspectives for genome engineering in a wide range of fields, including gene therapy. A new crystal structure of the I-CreI dimer without DNA has allowed the comparison with the DNA-bound protein. The C-terminal loop displays a different conformation, which suggests its implication in DNA binding. A site-directed mutagenesis study in this region demonstrates that whereas the C-terminal helix is negligible for DNA binding, the final C-terminal loop is essential in DNA binding and cleavage. We have identified two regions that comprise the Ser138–Lys139 and Lys142–Thr143 pairs whose double mutation affect DNA binding in vitro and abolish cleavage in vivo. However, the mutation of only one residue in these sites allows DNA binding in vitro and cleavage in vivo. These findings demonstrate that the C-terminal loop of I-CreI endonuclease plays a fundamental role in its catalytic mechanism and suggest this novel site as a region to take into account for engineering new endonucleases with tailored specificity.     

Homing endonuclease I-TevIII: dimerization as a means to a double-strand break

Homing endonucleases are unusual enzymes, capable of recognizing lengthy DNA sequences and cleaving site-specifically within genomes. Many homing endonucleases are encoded within group I introns, and such enzymes promote the mobility reactions of these introns. Phage T4 has three group I introns, within the td, nrdB and nrdD genes. The td and nrdD introns are mobile, whereas the nrdB intron is not. Phage RB3 is a close relative of T4 and has a lengthier nrdB intron. Here, we describe I-TevIII, the H–N–H endonuclease encoded by the RB3 nrdB intron. In contrast to previous reports, we demonstrate that this intron is mobile, and that this mobility is dependent on I-TevIII, which generates 2-nt 3′ extensions. The enzyme has a distinct catalytic domain, which contains the H–N–H motif, and DNA-binding domain, which contains two zinc fingers required for interaction with the DNA substrate. Most importantly, I-TevIII, unlike the H–N–H endonucleases described so far, makes a double-strand break on the DNA homing site by acting as a dimer. Through deletion analysis, the dimerization interface was mapped to the DNA-binding domain. The unusual propensity of I-TevIII to dimerize to achieve cleavage of both DNA strands underscores the versatility of the H–N–H enzyme family.     

Mutations altering the cleavage specificity of a homing endonuclease

The homing endonuclease I-CreI recognizes and cleaves a particular 22 bp DNA sequence. The crystal structure of I-CreI bound to homing site DNA has previously been determined, leading to a number of predictions about specific protein–DNA contacts. We test these predictions by analyzing a set of endonuclease mutants and a complementary set of homing site mutants. We find evidence that all structurally predicted I-CreI/DNA contacts contribute to DNA recognition and show that these contacts differ greatly in terms of their relative importance. We also describe the isolation of a collection of altered specificity I-CreI derivatives. The in vitro DNA-binding and cleavage properties of two such endonucleases demonstrate that our genetic approach is effective in identifying homing endonucleases that recognize and cleave novel target sequences.     

Flow cytometric analysis of DNA binding and cleavage by cell surface-displayed homing endonucleases

LAGLIDADG homing endonucleases (LHEs) cleave 18–24bp DNA sequences and are promising enzymes for applications requiring sequence-specific DNA cleavage amongst genome-sized DNA backgrounds. Here, we report a method for cell surface display of LHEs, which facilitates analysis of their DNA binding and cleavage properties by flow cytometry. Cells expressing surface LHEs can be stained with fluorescently conjugated double-stranded oligonucleotides (dsOligos) containing their respective target sequences. The signal is absolutely sequence specific and undetectable with dsOligos carrying single base-pair substitutions. LHE–dsOligo interactions facilitate rapid enrichment and viable recovery of rare LHE expressing cells by both fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) and magnetic cell sorting (MACS). Additionally, dsOligos conjugated with unique fluorophores at opposite termini can be tethered to the cell surface and used to detect DNA cleavage. Recapitulation of DNA binding and cleavage by surface-displayed LHEs provides a high-throughput approach to library screening that should facilitate rapid identification and analysis of enzymes with novel sequence specificities.     

Biochemical and mutagenic analysis of I-CreII reveals distinct but important roles for both the H-N-H and GIY-YIG motifs

Homing endonucleases typically contain one of four conserved catalytic motifs, and other elements that confer tight DNA binding. I-CreII, which catalyzes homing of the Cr.psbA4 intron, is unusual in containing two potential catalytic motifs, H-N-H and GIY-YIG. Previously, we showed that cleavage by I-CreII leaves ends (2-nt 3′ overhangs) that are characteristic of GIY-YIG endonucleases, yet it has a relaxed metal requirement like H-N-H enzymes. Here we show that I-CreII can bind DNA without an added metal ion, and that it binds as a monomer, akin to GIY-YIG enzymes. Moreover, cleavage of supercoiled DNA, and estimates of strand-specific cleavage rates, suggest that I-CreII uses a sequential cleavage mechanism. Alanine substitution of a number of residues in the GIY-YIG motif, however, did not block cleavage activity, although DNA binding was substantially reduced in several variants. Substitution of conserved histidines in the H-N-H motif resulted in variants that did not promote DNA cleavage, but retained high-affinity DNA binding—thus identifying it as the catalytic motif. Unlike the non-specific H-N-H colicins, however; substitution of the conserved asparagine substantially reduced DNA binding (though not the ability to promote cleavage). These results indicate that, in I-CreII, two catalytic motifs have evolved to play important roles in specific DNA binding. The data also indicate that only the H-N-H motif has retained catalytic ability.     

A combinatorial approach to create artificial homing endonucleases cleaving chosen sequences

Meganucleases, or homing endonucleases (HEs) are sequence-specific endonucleases with large (>14 bp) cleavage sites that can be used to induce efficient homologous gene targeting in cultured cells and plants. These findings have opened novel perspectives for genome engineering in a wide range of fields, including gene therapy. However, the number of identified HEs does not match the diversity of genomic sequences, and the probability of finding a homing site in a chosen gene is extremely low. Therefore, the design of artificial endonucleases with chosen specificities is under intense investigation. In this report, we describe the first artificial HEs whose specificity has been entirely redesigned to cleave a naturally occurring sequence. First, hundreds of novel endonucleases with locally altered substrate specificity were derived from I-CreI, a Chlamydomonas reinhardti protein belonging to the LAGLIDADG family of HEs. Second, distinct DNA-binding subdomains were identified within the protein. Third, we used these findings to assemble four sets of mutations into heterodimeric endonucleases cleaving a model target or a sequence from the human RAG1 gene. These results demonstrate that the plasticity of LAGLIDADG endonucleases allows extensive engineering, and provide a general method to create novel endonucleases with tailored specificities.     

Engineering of large numbers of highly specific homing endonucleases that induce recombination on novel DNA targets

The last decade has seen the emergence of a universal method for precise and efficient genome engineering. This method relies on the use of sequence-specific endonucleases such as homing endonucleases. The structures of several of these proteins are known, allowing for site-directed mutagenesis of residues essential for DNA binding. Here, we show that a semi-rational approach can be used to derive hundreds of novel proteins from I-CreI, a homing endonuclease from the LAGLIDADG family. These novel endonucleases display a wide range of cleavage patterns in yeast and mammalian cells that in most cases are highly specific and distinct from I-CreI. Second, rules for protein/DNA interaction can be inferred from statistical analysis. Third, novel endonucleases can be combined to create heterodimeric protein species, thereby greatly enhancing the number of potential targets. These results describe a straightforward approach for engineering novel endonucleases with tailored specificities, while preserving the activity and specificity of natural homing endonucleases, and thereby deliver new tools for genome engineering.     

Comprehensive homing endonuclease target site specificity profiling reveals evolutionary constraints and enables genome engineering applications

Homing endonucleases (HEs) promote the evolutionary persistence of selfish DNA elements by catalyzing element lateral transfer into new host organisms. The high site specificity of this lateral transfer reaction, termed homing, reflects both the length (14–40 bp) and the limited tolerance of target or homing sites for base pair changes. In order to better understand molecular determinants of homing, we systematically determined the binding and cleavage properties of all single base pair variant target sites of the canonical LAGLIDADG homing endonucleases I-CreI and I-MsoI. These Chlorophyta algal HEs have very similar three-dimensional folds and recognize nearly identical 22 bp target sites, but use substantially different sets of DNA-protein contacts to mediate site-specific recognition and cleavage. The site specificity differences between I-CreI and I-MsoI suggest different evolutionary strategies for HE persistence. These differences also provide practical guidance in target site finding, and in the generation of HE variants with high site specificity and cleavage activity, to enable genome engineering applications.     

Survey and mapping of restriction endonuclease cleavage sites in bacteriophage T7 DNA.

A survey of restriction endonucleases having different cleavage specificities has identified 10 that do not cut wild-type bacteriophage T7 DNA, 11 that cut at six or fewer sites, four that cut at 18 to 45 sites, and 12 that cut at more than 50 sites. All the cleavage sites for the 13 enzymes that cut at 26 or fewer sites have been mapped. Cleavage sites for each of the 10 enzymes that do not cut T7 DNA would be expected to occur an average of 9 to 10 times in a random nucleotide sequence the length of T7 DNA. A possible explanation for the lack of any cleavage sites for these enzymes might be that T7 encounters enzymes having these specificities in natural hosts, and that the sites have been eliminated from T7 DNA by natural selection. Five restriction endonucleases were found to cut within the terminal repetition of T7 DNA; one of these, KpnI, cuts at only three additional sites in the T7 DNA molecule. The length of the terminal repetition was estimated by two independent means to be approximately 155 to 160 base-pairs.     

Oligomeric Structure Diversity within the GIY-YIG Nuclease Family

The GIY-YIG nuclease domain has been identified in homing endonucleases, DNA repair and recombination enzymes, and restriction endonucleases. The Type II restriction enzyme Eco29kI belongs to the GIY-YIG nuclease superfamily and, like most of other family members, including the homing endonuclease I-TevI, is a monomer. It recognizes the palindromic sequence 5′-CCGC/GG-3′ (“/” marks the cleavage position) and cuts it to generate 3′-staggered ends. The Eco29kI monomer, which contains a single active site, either has to nick sequentially individual DNA strands or has to form dimers or even higher-order oligomers upon DNA binding to make a double-strand break at its target site. Here, we provide experimental evidence that Eco29kI monomers dimerize on a single cognate DNA molecule forming the catalytically active complex. The mechanism described here for Eco29kI differs from that of Cfr42I isoschisomer, which also belongs to the GIY-YIG family but is functional as a tetramer. This novel mechanism may have implications for the function of homing endonucleases and other enzymes of the GIY-YIG family.     

Protein footprinting approach to mapping DNA binding sites of two archaeal homing enzymes: evidence for a two-domain protein structure.

The archaeal intron-encoded homing enzymes I-PorI and I-DmoI belong to a family of endonucleases that contain two copies of a characteristic LAGLIDADG motif. These endonucleases cleave their intron- or intein- alleles site-specifically, and thereby facilitate homing of the introns or inteins which encode them. The protein structure and the mechanism of DNA recognition of these homing enzymes is largely unknown. Therefore, we examined these properties of I-PorI and I-DmoI by protein footprinting. Both proteins were susceptible to proteolytic cleavage within regions that are equidistant from each of the two LAGLIDADG motifs. When complexed with their DNA substrates, a characteristic subset of the exposed sites, located in regions immediately after and 40-60 amino acids after each of the LAGLIDADG motifs, were protected. Our data suggest that the enzymes are structured into two, tandemly repeated, domains, each containing both the LAGLIDADG motif and two putative DNA binding regions. The latter contains a potentially novel DNA binding motif conserved in archaeal homing enzymes. The results are consistent with a model where the LAGLIDADG endonucleases bind to their non-palindromic substrates as monomeric enzymes, with each of the two domains recognizing one half of the DNA substrate.     

Type II restriction endonuclease R.KpnI is a member of the HNH nuclease superfamily

The restriction endonuclease (REase) R.KpnI is an orthodox Type IIP enzyme, which binds to DNA in the absence of metal ions and cleaves the DNA sequence 5′-GGTAC^C-3′ in the presence of Mg²⁺ as shown generating 3′ four base overhangs. Bioinformatics analysis reveals that R.KpnI contains a ββα-Me-finger fold, which is characteristic of many HNH-superfamily endonucleases, including homing endonuclease I-HmuI, structure-specific T4 endonuclease VII, colicin E9, sequence non-specific Serratia nuclease and sequence-specific homing endonuclease I-PpoI. According to our homology model of R.KpnI, D148, H149 and Q175 correspond to the critical D, H and N or H residues of the HNH nucleases. Substitutions of these three conserved residues lead to the loss of the DNA cleavage activity by R.KpnI, confirming their importance. The mutant Q175E fails to bind DNA at the standard conditions, although the DNA binding and cleavage can be rescued at pH 6.0, indicating a role for Q175 in DNA binding and cleavage. Our study provides the first experimental evidence for a Type IIP REase that does not belong to the PD…D/EXK superfamily of nucleases, instead is a member of the HNH superfamily.     

Perpetuating the homing endonuclease life cycle: identification of mutations that modulate and change I-TevI cleavage preference

Homing endonucleases are sequence-tolerant DNA endonucleases that act as mobile genetic elements. The ability of homing endonucleases to cleave substrates with multiple nucleotide substitutions suggests a high degree of adaptability in that changing or modulating cleavage preference would require relatively few amino acid substitutions. Here, using directed evolution experiments with the GIY-YIG homing endonuclease I-TevI that targets the thymidylate synthase gene of phage T4, we readily isolated variants that dramatically broadened I-TevI cleavage preference, as well as variants that fine-tuned cleavage preference. By combining substitutions, we observed an ∼10 000-fold improvement in cleavage on some substrates not cleaved by the wild-type enzyme, correlating with a decrease in readout of information content at the cleavage site. Strikingly, we were able to change the cleavage preference of I-TevI to that of the isoschizomer I-BmoI which targets a different cleavage site in the thymidylate synthase gene, recapitulating the evolution of cleavage preference in this family of homing endonucleases. Our results define a strategy to isolate GIY-YIG nuclease domains with distinct cleavage preferences, and provide insight into how homing endonucleases may escape a dead-end life cycle in a population of saturated target sites by promoting transposition to different target sites.     

Engineering variants of the I-SceI homing endonuclease with strand-specific and site-specific DNA-nicking activity

The number of strand-specific nicking endonucleases that are currently available for laboratory procedures and applications in vivo is limited, and none is sufficiently specific to nick single target sites within complex genomes. The extreme target specificity of homing endonucleases makes them attractive candidates for engineering high-specificity nicking endonucleases. I-SceI is a monomeric homing enzyme that recognizes an 18 bp asymmetric target sequence, and cleaves both DNA strands to leave 3′-overhangs of 4 bp. In single turnover experiments using plasmid substrates, I-SceI generates transient open circle intermediates during the conversion of supercoiled to linear DNA, indicating that the enzyme cleaves the two DNA strands sequentially. A novel hairpin substrate was used to demonstrate that although wild-type I-SceI cleaves either the top or bottom DNA strand first to generate two nicked DNA intermediates, the enzyme has a preference for cleaving the bottom strand. The kinetics data are consistent with a parallel sequential reaction mechanism. Substitution of two pseudo-symmetric residues, Lys122 and Lys223, markedly reduces top and bottom-strand cleavage, respectively, to generate enzymes with significant strand- and sequence-specific nicking activity. The two active sites are partially interdependent, since alterations to one site affect the second. The kinetics analysis is consistent with X-ray crystal structures of I-SceI/DNA complexes that reveal a role for the lysines in establishing important solvent networks that include nucleophilic water molecules thought to attack the scissile phosphodiester bonds.     

Investigating the endonuclease activity of four Pyrococcus abyssi inteins

Among the 14 inteins of the Pyrococcus abyssi genome, 10 harbour the LAGLIDADG motifs of dodecapeptide endonucleases. Four of these were cloned, expressed in Escherichia coli and purified to assay their potential endonuclease activity. PabRIR1-2 and PabRIR1-3 are specific endonucleases, named PI-PabI and PI-PabII, respectively, cleaving the sequence spanning their homing site. This is consistent with their size and with the relative positions and sequences of their endonuclease motifs. However, PI-PabI is 10-fold more active than PI-PabII and a discrepancy of the DNA recognition and cleavage mechanisms was observed between the two inteins. In particular, analysis of the DNA cleavage reactions by MALDI-TOF highlighted that while the cleavage of DNA by PI-PabI consists of two steps corresponding to the cleavage of each DNA strand, PI-PabII processes the two DNA strands simultaneously. Furthermore, the two inteins interact differently with DNA. In addition, we did not detect any endonuclease activity for PabLon and PabRIR1-1. Deletions in the intein sequences and mutations in the putative endonuclease motifs probably abolish this activity. Hence, inteins from the same archaebacteria, even if contained in the same host protein, did not evolve uniformly and are presumably at different stages of the invasion cycle.     

The nicking homing endonuclease I-BasI is encoded by a group I intron in the DNA polymerase gene of the Bacillus thuringiensis phage Bastille

Here we describe the discovery of a group I intron in the DNA polymerase gene of Bacillus thuringiensis phage Bastille. Although the intron insertion site is identical to that of the Bacillus subtilis phages SPO1 and SP82 introns, the Bastille intron differs from them substantially in primary and secondary structure. Like the SPO1 and SP82 introns, the Bastille intron encodes a nicking DNA endonuclease of the H-N-H family, I-BasI, with a cleavage site identical to that of the SPO1-encoded enzyme I-HmuI. Unlike I-HmuI, which nicks both intron-minus and intron-plus DNA, I-BasI cleaves only intron-minus alleles, which is a characteristic of typical homing endonucleases. Interestingly, the C-terminal portions of these H-N-H phage endonucleases contain a conserved sequence motif, the intron-encoded endonuclease repeat motif (IENR1) that also has been found in endonucleases of the GIY-YIG family, and which likely comprises a small DNA-binding module with a globular ββααβ fold, suggestive of module shuffling between different homing endonuclease families.