Lysigenous aerenchyma formation in maize root is confined to cortical cells by regulation of genes related to generation and scavenging of reactive oxygen species

To adapt to waterlogging, maize (Zea mays) forms lysigenous aerenchyma in root cortex as a result of ethylene-promoted programmed cell death (PCD). Respiratory burst oxidase homolog (RBOH) gene encodes a homolog of gp91^phox in NADPH oxidase, and has a role in the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). Recently, we found that during aerenchyma formation, RBOH was upregulated in all maize root tissues examined, whereas an ROS scavengingrelated metallothionein (MT) gene was downregulated specifically in cortical cells. Together these changes should lead to high accumulations of ROS in root cortex, thereby inducing PCD for aerenchyma formation. As further evidence of the involvement of ROS in root aerenchyma formation, the PCD was inhibited by diphenyleneiodonium (DPI), an NADPH oxidase inhibitor. Based on these results, we propose a model of cortical cell-specific PCD for root aerenchyma formation.Key words: aerenchyma, ethylene, laser microdissection, maize (Zea mays), metallothionein, programmed cell death, reactive oxygen species, respiratory burst oxidase homologIn both wetland and non-wetland plants, lysigenous aerenchyma is formed in roots by creating gas spaces as a result of death and subsequent lysis of some cortical cells, and allows internal transport of oxygen from shoots to roots under waterlogged soil conditions.^1–3 In rice (Oryza sativa) and some other wetland plant species, lysigenous aerenchyma is constitutively formed under aerobic conditions, and is further enhanced under waterlogged conditions.⁴ On the other hand, in non-wetland plants, including maize (Zea mays), lysigenous aerenchyma does not normally form under well-drained soil conditions, but is induced by waterlogging.⁵ Ethylene is involved in lysigenous aerenchyma formation,^1–3,6,7 but the molecular mechanisms are unclear.We recently identified two reactive oxygen species (ROS)-related genes that were specifically regulated in maize root cortex by waterlogged conditions, but not in the presence of an ethylene perception inhibitor 1-methylcyclopropene (1-MCP).⁵ One was respiratory burst oxidase homolog (RBOH), which has a role in ROS generation and the other was metallothionein (MT), which has a role in ROS scavenging. These results suggest that ROS has a role in ethylene signaling in the PCD that occurs during lysigenous aerenchyma formation.     

Ethylene‐dependent aerenchyma formation in adventitious roots is regulated differently in rice and maize

In roots of gramineous plants, lysigenous aerenchyma is created by the death and lysis of cortical cells. Rice (Oryza sativa) constitutively forms aerenchyma under aerobic conditions, and its formation is further induced under oxygen‐deficient conditions. However, maize (Zea mays) develops aerenchyma only under oxygen‐deficient conditions. Ethylene is involved in lysigenous aerenchyma formation. Here, we investigated how ethylene‐dependent aerenchyma formation is differently regulated between rice and maize. For this purpose, in rice, we used the reduced culm number1 (rcn1) mutant, in which ethylene biosynthesis is suppressed. Ethylene is converted from 1‐aminocyclopropane‐1‐carboxylic acid (ACC) by the action of ACC oxidase (ACO). We found that OsACO5 was highly expressed in the wild type, but not in rcn1, under aerobic conditions, suggesting that OsACO5 contributes to aerenchyma formation in aerated rice roots. By contrast, the ACO genes in maize roots were weakly expressed under aerobic conditions, and thus ACC treatment did not effectively induce ethylene production or aerenchyma formation, unlike in rice. Aerenchyma formation in rice roots after the initiation of oxygen‐deficient conditions was faster and greater than that in maize. These results suggest that the difference in aerenchyma formation in rice and maize is due to their different mechanisms for regulating ethylene biosynthesis.     

Larger adenylate energy charge and ATP/ADP ratios in aerenchymatous roots of Zea mays in anaerobic media as a consequence of improved internal oxygen transport

Internal transport of O₂ from the aerial tissues along the adventitious roots of intact maize plants was estimated by measuring the concentrations of adenine nucleotides in various zones along the root under an oxygen-free atmosphere. Young maize plants were grown in nutrient solution under conditions that either stimulated or prevented the formation of a lysigenous aerenchyma, and the roots (up to 210 mm long) were then exposed to an anaerobic (oxygen-free) nutrient solution. Aerenchymatous roots showed higher values than non-aerenchymatous ones for ATP content, adenylate energy charge and ATP/ADP ratios. We conclude that the lysigenous cortical gas spaces help maintain a high respiration rate in the tissues along the root, and in the apical zone, by improving internal transport of oxygen over distances of at least 210 mm. This contrasted sharply with the low energy status (poor O₂ transport) in non-aerenchymatous roots.Abbreviation AEC adenylate energy charge     

Constraints of root response to waterlogging in Alisma triviale

To understand the economics of root aerenchyma formation in wetland plants, we investigated in detail the response of Alisma triviale to waterlogging. We hypothesized costs being associated with development of a large root air space. In three out-door pot experiments, seedlings (1 experiment) and mature plants (2 experiments) were grown under waterlogged and drained conditions for up to 2?months. Waterlogging promoted growth, and was associated with increased root porosity and decreased root density (fresh mass per volume). The increased formation of aerenchyma was associated with a higher root dry matter content for a given root density. Despite improved growth and earlier flowering, the waterlogged plants also showed signs of being constrained by the anoxic substrate, such as shallower roots, and a higher leaf dry matter content. The formation of aerenchyma was associated with costs, such as increased root dry matter content and reduced metaxylem vessel diameter. The faster growth of the seedlings under the waterlogged conditions, despite some signs of being stressed, was possibly a result of decreased requirements to allocate biomass below ground. In mature plants the increased aerenchyma allowed deeper root penetration, and ameliorated the effects of anoxia, reducing the differences in plant traits between the treatments.     

Lysigenous aerenchyma formation in Arabidopsis is controlled by LESION SIMULATING DISEASE1

Aerenchyma tissues form gas-conducting tubes that provide roots with oxygen under hypoxic conditions. Although aerenchyma have received considerable attention in Zea mays, the signaling events and genes controlling aerenchyma induction remain elusive. Here, we show that Arabidopsis thaliana hypocotyls form lysigenous aerenchyma in response to hypoxia and that this process involves H(2)O(2) and ethylene signaling. By studying Arabidopsis mutants that are deregulated for excess light acclimation, cell death, and defense responses, we find that the formation of lysigenous aerenchyma depends on the plant defense regulators LESION SIMULATING DISEASE1 (LSD1), ENHANCED DISEASE SUSCEPIBILITY1 (EDS1), and PHYTOALEXIN DEFICIENT4 (PAD4) that operate upstream of ethylene and reactive oxygen species production. The obtained results indicate that programmed cell death of lysigenous aerenchyma in hypocotyls occurs in a similar but independent manner from the foliar programmed cell death. Thus, the induction of aerenchyma is subject to a genetic and tissue-specific program. The data lead us to conclude that the balanced activities of LSD1, EDS1, and PAD4 regulate lysigenous aerenchyma formation in response to hypoxia.     

Variation in the Structure and Response to Flooding of Root Aerenchyma in some Wetland Plants

The structure and response to flooding of root cortical aerenchyma(air space tissue) in a variety of wetland (flood-tolerant)species was investigated and compared with some flood-intolerantspecies. In some species aerenchyma consisted of enlarged schizogenousintercellular spaces and in others aerenchyma formation involvedlysigeny. Two types of lysigenous aerenchyma were distinguished.In the first the diaphragms between lacunae were arranged radiallyand consisted of both collapsed and intact cells. In the secondtype, which was confined to the Cyperaceae, the radial diaphragmscontained intact cells, and stretched between them were tangentially-arrangeddiaphragms of collapsed cells. Flooding in sand culture generally increased root porosity (airspace content) although there were exceptions. The flood-intolerantspecies Senecio jacobaea produced aerenchyma but did not survivelong-term flooding. Among the flood-tolerant species, Filipendulaulmaria did not produce extensive aerenchyma even when flooded.Eriophorum angustifolium and E. vaginatum produced extensiveaerenchyma under drained conditions which was not increasedby flooding. In Nardus stricta root porosity was increased bylow nutrient levels as well as by flooding. Aerenchyma, root cortex, wetland plants, waterlogging, flooding-tolerance, Ammophila arenaria, Brachypodium sylvalicum, Caltha palustris, Carex curia, Eriophorum vaginatum, Filipendula ulmaria, Glyceria maxima, Hieracium pilosella, Juncus effusus, Myosotis scorpioides, Nardus stricta, Narthecium ossifragum, Phalaris arundinacea, Senecio jacobaea, Trichophorum cespitosum     

Enhanced formation of aerenchyma and induction of a barrier to radial oxygen loss in adventitious roots of Zea nicaraguensis contribute to its waterlogging tolerance as compared with maize (Zea mays ssp. mays)

Enhancement of oxygen transport from shoot to root tip by the formation of aerenchyma and also a barrier to radial oxygen loss (ROL) in roots is common in waterlogging‐tolerant plants. Zea nicaraguensis (teosinte), a wild relative of maize (Zea mays ssp. mays), grows in waterlogged soils. We investigated the formation of aerenchyma and ROL barrier induction in roots of Z. nicaraguensis, in comparison with roots of maize (inbred line Mi29), in a pot soil system and in hydroponics. Furthermore, depositions of suberin in the exodermis/hypodermis and lignin in the epidermis of adventitious roots of Z. nicaraguensis and maize grown in aerated or stagnant deoxygenated nutrient solution were studied. Growth of maize was more adversely affected by low oxygen in the root zone (waterlogged soil or stagnant deoxygenated nutrient solution) compared with Z. nicaraguensis. In stagnant deoxygenated solution, Z. nicaraguensis was superior to maize in transporting oxygen from shoot base to root tip due to formation of larger aerenchyma and a stronger barrier to ROL in adventitious roots. The relationships between the ROL barrier formation and suberin and lignin depositions in roots are discussed. The ROL barrier, in addition to aerenchyma, would contribute to the waterlogging tolerance of Z. nicaraguensis.     

Formation of aerenchyma in roots of Zea mays in aerated solutions, and its relation to nutrient supply

The formation of lysigenous cavities (aerenchyma) in the root cortex of maize, Zea mays L. cv. Capella, under well-aerated conditions has been studied in relation to the composition of the nutrient solutions. Nitrogen, either supplied as nitrate or as ammonium, reduced the cavity formation by the roots. This reduction was most apparent at nitrate concentrations above 2 mM. Cavities were increasingly formed when the nitrate concentration was decreased and they reached their largest dimensions in roots growing in water. Thus, inadequate availability of nitrogen leads, under acrated conditions, to deterioration of cortex cells and cavity formation in the maize roots. It is suggested that cavity formation in these roots is connected with reduced nitrogen assimilation.     

Nitric oxide is essential for the development of aerenchyma in wheat roots under hypoxic stress

In response to flooding/waterlogging, plants develop various anatomical changes including the formation of lysigenous aerenchyma for the delivery of oxygen to roots. Under hypoxia, plants produce high levels of nitric oxide (NO) but the role of this molecule in plant‐adaptive response to hypoxia is not known. Here, we investigated whether ethylene‐induced aerenchyma requires hypoxia‐induced NO. Under hypoxic conditions, wheat roots produced NO apparently via nitrate reductase and scavenging of NO led to a marked reduction in aerenchyma formation. Interestingly, we found that hypoxically induced NO is important for induction of the ethylene biosynthetic genes encoding ACC synthase and ACC oxidase. Hypoxia‐induced NO accelerated production of reactive oxygen species, lipid peroxidation, and protein tyrosine nitration. Other events related to cell death such as increased conductivity, increased cellulase activity, DNA fragmentation, and cytoplasmic streaming occurred under hypoxia, and opposing effects were observed by scavenging NO. The NO scavenger cPTIO (2‐(4‐carboxyphenyl)‐4,4,5,5‐tetramethylimidazoline‐1‐oxyl‐3‐oxide potassium salt) and ethylene biosynthetic inhibitor CoCl₂ both led to reduced induction of genes involved in signal transduction such as phospholipase C, G protein alpha subunit, calcium‐dependent protein kinase family genes CDPK, CDPK2, CDPK 4, Ca‐CAMK, inositol 1,4,5‐trisphosphate 5‐phosphatase 1, and protein kinase suggesting that hypoxically induced NO is essential for the development of aerenchyma.     

A major locus involved in the formation of the radial oxygen loss barrier in adventitious roots of teosinte Zea nicaraguensis is located on the short‐arm of chromosome 3

A radial oxygen loss (ROL) barrier in roots of waterlogging‐tolerant plants promotes oxygen movement via aerenchyma to the root tip, and impedes soil phytotoxin entry. The molecular mechanism and genetic regulation of ROL barrier formation are largely unknown. Zea nicaraguensis, a waterlogging‐tolerant wild relative of maize (Zea mays ssp. mays), forms a tight ROL barrier in its roots when waterlogged. We used Z. nicaraguensis chromosome segment introgression lines (ILs) in maize (inbred line Mi29) to elucidate the chromosomal region involved in regulating root ROL barrier formation. A segment of the short‐arm of chromosome 3 of Z. nicaraguensis conferred ROL barrier formation in the genetic background of maize. This chromosome segment also decreased apoplastic solute permeability across the hypodermis/exodermis. However, the IL and maize were similar for suberin staining in the hypodermis/exodermis at 40 mm and further behind the root tip. Z. nicaraguensis contained suberin in the hypodermis/exodermis at 20 mm and lignin at the epidermis. The IL with ROL barrier, however, did not contain lignin in the epidermis. Discovery of the Z. nicaraguensis chromosomal region responsible for root ROL barrier formation has improved knowledge of this trait and is an important step towards improvement of waterlogging tolerance in maize.     

Aerenchyma Formed Under Phosphorus Deficiency Contributes to the Reduced Root Hydraulic Conductivity in Maize Roots

Root hydraulic conductivity has been shown to decrease under phosphorus （P） deficiency. This study Investigated how the formation of aerenchyma is related to this change. Root anatomy, as well as root hydraulic conductivity was studied In maize （Zea mays L.） roots under different phosphorus nutrition conditions. Plant roots under P stress showed enhanced degradation of cortical cells and the aerenchyma formation was associated with their reduced root hydraulic conductivity, supporting our hypothesis that air spaces that form in the cortex of phosphorusstressed roots Impede the radial transport of water in a root cylinder. Further evidence came from the variation In aerenchyma formation due to genotypic differences. Five maize inbred lines with different porosity in their root cortex showed a significant negative correlation with their root hydraulic conductivity. Shoot relative water content was also found lower In P-deficient maize plants than that in P-sufficient ones when such treatment was prolonged enough, suggesting a limitation of water transport due to lowered root hydraulic conductivity of P-deficient plants.     

Analysis of proteins in aerenchymatous seminal roots of wheat grown in hypoxic soils under waterlogged conditions

Hypoxia caused by waterlogging results in a severe loss of crop production. At the primary stage of wheat development, the seminal roots have strategies to survive under hypoxia through alternative metabolism coupling root anatomical modification. The present study used a model system of lysigenous aerenchymatous seminal roots from a representative seedling stage of wheat to elucidate the root physiology in response to soil hypoxia. Seminal roots characteristic with lysigenous aerenchyma tissues were developed in pot cultures for 7 days under two hypoxic conditions, water depths of 15 cm below and 3 cm above the soil surface. Proteins from the roots were separated using two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and identified using mass spectrometry. The results showed that approximately 345 distinct protein spots were detected by 2-DE, 29 spots changed in the expression levels between the control and two hypoxic plants, and 10 spots exhibited a reproducible up- or down regulated fluctuation. The up-regulated proteins were thought to be involved in alteration in energy and redox status, defense responses and cell wall turnover. These results suggest the effects of soil hypoxia on the activity of the identified up-regulated proteins and their roles in alternative respiration and cell degeneration in wheat in order to gain metabolic adjustment under hypoxia stress.     

Aerenchyma formation in maize roots

Maize (Zea mays L.) is generally considered to be a plant with aerenchyma formation inducible by environmental conditions. In our study, young maize plants, cultivated in various ways in order to minimise the stressing effect of hypoxia, flooding, mechanical impedance or nutrient starvation, were examined for the presence of aerenchyma in their primary roots. The area of aerenchyma in the root cortex was correlated with the root length. Although 12 different maize accessions were used, no plants without aerenchyma were acquired until an ethylene synthesis inhibitor was employed. Using an ACC-synthase inhibitor, it was confirmed that the aerenchyma formation is ethylene-regulated and dependent on irradiance. The presence of TUNEL-positive nuclei and ultrastructural changes in cortical cells suggest a connection between ethylene-dependent aerenchyma formation and programmed cell death. Position of cells with TUNEL-positive nuclei in relation to aerenchyma-channels was described.     

植物根内通气组织形成的研究进展

植物能否在湿地或淹涝环境中生长,很大程度上取决于植物是否具有健全发达的通气组织。在结合形态学和分子生物学等方面研究的基础上,概述了植物根内通气组织的形成过程,主要涉及生理功能、诱导因子和相关酶等,推测细胞程序性死亡是溶生性通气组织形成的机理,乙烯在整体信号转导网络中起关键性中介作用。     

植物根内通气组织形成机理的研究进展

植物能否在湿地或淹涝环境中生长, 很大程度上取决于植物是否具有健全发达的通气组织。在结合形态学和分子生物学等方面研究的基础上, 概述了植物根内通气组织的形成过程, 主要涉及生理功能、诱导因子和相关酶等, 推测细胞程序性死亡是溶生性通气组织形成的机理, 乙烯在整体信号转导网络中起关键性中介作用。     

Comparative spatiotemporal analysis of root aerenchyma formation processes in maize due to sulphate, nitrate or phosphate deprivation

Nitrate (N), phosphate (P) or sulphate (S) deprivation causes aerenchyma formation in maize (Zea mays L.) nodal roots. The exact mechanisms that trigger the formation of aerenchyma under these circumstances are unclear. We have compared aerenchyma distribution across the nodal roots of first whorl (just emerging in 10-day-old seedlings), which were subject to S, N or P deprivation over a period of 10?days in connection with oxygen consumption, ATP concentration, cellulase and polygalacturonase activity in the whole root. The effect of deprivation on aerenchyma formation was examined using light and electron microscopy, along with in situ detection of calcium and of reactive oxygen species (ROS) by fluorescence microscopy. Aerenchyma was not found in the root base regardless of the deprivation. Programmed cell death (PCD) was observed near the root tip, either within the first two days (-N) or a few days later (-S, -P) of the treatment. Roots at day?6 under all three nutrient-deprived conditions showed signs of PCD 1?cm behind the cap, whereas only N-deprived root cells 0.5?cm behind the cap showed severe ultrastructural alterations, due to advanced PCD. The lower ATP concentration and the higher oxygen consumptions observed at day?2 in N-, P- and S-deprived roots compared to the control indicated that PCD may be triggered by perturbations in energy status of the root. The peaks of cellulase activity located between days?3 (-N) and 6 (-P), along with the respective alterations in polygalacturonase activity, indicated a coordination which preceded aerenchyma formation. ROS and calcium seemed to contribute to PCD initiation, with ROS possessing dual roles as signals and eliminators. All the examined parameters presented both common features and characteristic variations among the deprivations.     

Transduction of an Ethylene Signal Is Required for Cell Death and Lysis in the Root Cortex of Maize during Aerenchyma Formation Induced by Hypoxia

Ethylene has been implicated in signaling cell death in the lysigenous formation of gas spaces (aerenchyma) in the cortex of adventitious roots of maize (Zea mays) subjected to hypoxia. Various antagonists that are known to modify particular steps in signal transduction in other plant systems were applied at low concentrations to normoxic and hypoxic roots of maize, and the effect on cell death (aerenchyma formation) and the increase in cellulase activity that precedes the appearance of cell degeneration were measured. Both cellulase activity and cell death were inhibited in hypoxic roots in the presence of antagonists of inositol phospholipids, Ca2+- calmodulin, and protein kinases. By contrast, there was a parallel promotion of cellulase activity and cell death in hypoxic and normoxic roots by contact with reagents that activate G-proteins, increase cytosolic Ca2+, or inhibit protein phosphatases. Most of these reagents had no effect on ethylene biosynthesis and did not arrest root extension. These results indicate that the transduction of an ethylene signal leading to an increase in intracellular Ca2+ is necessary for cell death and the resulting aerenchyma development in roots of maize subjected to hypoxia.     

Construction of intraspecific linkage maps, detection of a chromosome inversion, and mapping of QTL for constitutive root aerenchyma formation in the teosinte Zea nicaraguensis

The teosinte Zea nicaraguensis, a wild relative of maize, possesses a flooding tolerance-related trait: the formation of constitutive root aerenchyma under drained (non-flooded) soil conditions. A previous study suggested that the degree of constitutive aerenchyma formation varies within Z. nicaraguensis. The objectives of this study were to construct linkage maps, to determine the marker order in a region of chromosome 4 in which recombination between maize and Z. nicaraguensis is suppressed, and to identify quantitative trait loci (QTL) controlling constitutive root aerenchyma formation in two segregating populations of Z. nicaraguensis. A total of 236 simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers were screened for polymorphism in an S1 population of Z. nicaraguensis. Seventy-one polymorphic SSR markers were assigned to 10 chromosomes, and a linkage map was constructed covering 793.5 cM. In the S1 map, a paracentric inversion was detected on the long arm of chromosome 4; this rearrangement was confirmed in an S1 linkage map of a different Z. nicaraguensis accession. Composite interval mapping analysis in 96 S1 plants revealed QTL for aerenchyma formation on chromosomes 1 (bins 1.06–1.07) and 7 (bin 7.01), explaining 17 and 12% of the total phenotypic variance, respectively. The QTL on chromosome 1 was verified by using 156 S2 plants. Near-isogenic lines exhibiting the presence or absence of the aerenchyma QTL have been developed that should be useful for genetic and physiological analyses of root aerenchyma formation.