Type III DNA restriction and modification systems EcoP1 and EcoP15. Nucleotide sequence of the EcoP1 operon, the EcoP15 mod gene and some EcoP1 mod mutants

This paper presents the nucleotide sequence of the mod-res operon of phage P1, which encodes the two structural genes for the EcoP1 type III restriction and modification system. We have also sequenced the mod gene of the allelic EcoP15 system. The mod gene product is responsible for binding the system-specific DNA recognition sequences in both restriction and modification; it also catalyses the modification reaction. A comparison of the two mod gene product sequences shows that they have conserved amino and carboxyl ends but have completely different sequences in the middle of the molecules. Two alleles of the EcoP1 mod gene that are defective in modification but not in restriction were also sequenced. The mutations in both alleles lie within the non-conserved regions.     

Structural insights into the assembly and shape of Type III restriction-modification (R-M) EcoP15I complex by small-angle X-ray scattering

EcoP15I is the prototype of the Type III restriction enzyme family, composed of two modification (Mod) subunits to which two (or one) restriction (Res) subunits are then added. The Mod subunits are responsible for DNA recognition and methylation, while the Res subunits are responsible for ATP hydrolysis and cleavage. Despite extensive biochemical and genetic studies, there is still no structural information on Type III restriction enzymes. We present here small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and analytical ultracentrifugation analysis of the EcoP15I holoenzyme and the Mod(2) subcomplex. We show that the Mod(2) subcomplex has a relatively compact shape with a radius of gyration (R(G)) of ～37.4 ? and a maximal dimension of ～110 ?. The holoenzyme adopts an elongated crescent shape with an R(G) of ～65.3 ? and a maximal dimension of ～218 ?. From reconstructed SAXS envelopes, we postulate that Mod(2) is likely docked in the middle of the holoenzyme with a Res subunit at each end. We discuss the implications of our model for EcoP15I action, whereby the Res subunits may come together and form a "sliding clamp" around the DNA.     

Structural domains in the type III restriction endonuclease EcoP15I: characterization by limited proteolysis, mass spectrometry and insertional mutagenesis

The Type III restriction endonuclease EcoP15I forms a hetero-oligomeric enzyme complex that consists of two modification (Mod) subunits and two restriction (Res) subunits. Structural data on Type III restriction enzymes in general are lacking because of their remarkable size of more than 400 kDa and the laborious and low-yield protein purification procedures. We took advantage of the EcoP15I-overexpressing vector pQEP15 and affinity chromatography to generate a quantity of EcoP15I high enough for comprehensive proteolytic digestion studies and analyses of the proteolytic fragments by mass spectrometry. We show here that in the presence of specific DNA the entire Mod subunit is protected from trypsin digestion, whereas in the absence of DNA stable protein domains of the Mod subunit were not detected. In contrast, the Res subunit is comprised of two trypsin-resistant domains of approximately 77-79 kDa and 27-29 kDa, respectively. The cofactor ATP and the presence of DNA, either specific or unspecific, are important stabilizers of the Res subunit. The large N-terminal domain of Res contains numerous functional motifs that are predicted to be involved in ATP-binding and hydrolysis and/or DNA translocation. The C-terminal small domain harbours the catalytic center. Based on our data, we conclude that both structural Res domains are connected by a flexible linker region that spans 23 amino acid residues. To confirm this conclusion, we have investigated several EcoP15I enzyme mutants obtained by insertion mutagenesis in and around the predicted linker region within the Res subunit. All mutants tolerated the genetic manipulation and did not display loss of function or alteration of the DNA cleavage position.     

Characterization of mutations of the bacteriophage P1 mod gene encoding the recognition subunit of the EcoP1 restriction and modification system.

This study characterized several mutations of the bacteriophage P1 mod gene. This gene codes for the subunit of the EcoP1 restriction enzyme that is responsible for DNA sequence recognition and for modification methylation. We cloned the mutant mod genes into expression vectors and purified the mutant proteins to near homogeneity. Two of the mutant mod genes studied were the c2 clear-plaque mutants described by Scott (Virology 41:66-71, 1970). These mutant proteins can recognize EcoP1 sites in DNA and direct restriction but are unable to modify DNA. Methylation assays as well as S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) binding studies showed that the c2 mutants are methylation deficient because they do not bind SAM, and we conclude that the mutations destroy the SAM-binding site. Both of the c2 mutations lie within a region of the EcoP1 mod gene that is not conserved when compared with the mod gene of the related EcoP15 system. EcoP15 and EcoP1 recognize different DNA sequences, and we believe that this region of the protein may code for the DNA-binding site of the enzyme. The other mutants characterized were made by site-directed mutagenesis at codon 240. Evidence is presented that one of them, Ser-240----Pro, simultaneously lost the capacity to bind SAM and may also have changed its DNA sequence specificity.     

Unusual occurrence of EcoP1 and EcoP15 recognition sites and counterselection of type II methylation and restriction sequences in bacteriophage T7 DNA

Selected and counterselected oligodeoxynucleotide sequences were identified in the total sequence of bacteriophage T7 DNA using a statistical criterion derived for a probability model of the Markov chain type. All extremely rare tetra- and pentadeoxynucleotides are (or contain) recognition sequences for the Escherichia coli DNA methylases dam or dcm. Most of the 37 hexadeoxynucleotides absent from T7 DNA are recognition sequences for type II modification/restriction enzymes of E. coli or related species. In contrast to most restriction sites counterselected during evolution, the EcoP1 site GGTCT occurs 126 times in the T7 genome, and phage T7 replication is severely repressed in P1-lysogenic host cells. We demonstrate that the frequency of the EcoP1 site is determined by that of the overlapping recognition sites for T7 primase, an essential phage enzyme. The recognition site of a type III enzyme, EcoP15, is also not counterselected. In T7 DNA all 36 EcoP15 sites are arranged in such a manner that the sequence CAGCAG is confined to the H strand, the complementary sequence CTGCTG to the L strand. This "strand bias" is highly significant and, therefore, very probably selected. A functional relation between this strand bias and the refractive behaviour of phage T7 to EcoP15 restriction is suspected.     

Type III restriction endonucleases translocate DNA in a reaction driven by recognition site-specific ATP hydrolysis.

Type III restriction/modification systems recognize short non-palindromic sequences, only one strand of which can be methylated. Replication of type III-modified DNA produces completely unmethylated recognition sites which, according to classical mechanisms of restriction, should be signals for restriction. We have shown previously that suicidal restriction by the type III enzyme EcoP15I is prevented if all the unmodified sites are in the same orientation: restriction by EcoP15I requires a pair of unmethylated, inversely oriented recognition sites. We have now addressed the molecular mechanism of site orientation-specific DNA restriction. EcoP15I is demonstrated to possess an intrinsic ATPase activity, the potential driving force of DNA translocation. The ATPase activity is uniquely recognition site-specific, but EcoP15I-modified sites also support the reaction. EcoP15I DNA restriction patterns are shown to be predetermined by the enzyme-to-site ratio, in that site-saturating enzyme levels elicit cleavage exclusively between the closest pair of head-to-head oriented sites. DNA restriction is blocked by Lac repressor bound in the intervening sequence between the two EcoP15I sites. These results rule out DNA looping and strongly suggest that cleavage is triggered by the close proximity of two convergently tracking EcoP15I-DNA complexes.     

Functional consequences of mutating conserved SF2 helicase motifs in the Type III restriction endonuclease EcoP15I translocase domain

For efficient DNA hydrolysis, Type III restriction endonuclease EcoP15I interacts with two inversely oriented recognition sites in an ATP-dependent process. EcoP15I consists of two methylation (Mod) subunits and a single restriction (Res) subunit yielding a multifunctional enzyme complex able to methylate or to hydrolyse DNA. Comprehensive sequence alignments, limited proteolysis and mass spectroscopy suggested that the Res subunit is a fusion of a motor or translocase (Tr) domain of superfamily II helicases and an endonuclease domain with a catalytic PD…EXK motif. In the Tr domain, seven predicted helicase motifs (I, Ia, II–VI), a recently discovered Q-tip motif and three additional regions (IIIa, IVa, Va) conserved among Type III restriction enzymes have been identified that are predicted to be involved in DNA binding and ATP hydrolysis. Because DNA unwinding activity for EcoP15I (as for bona fide helicases) has never been found and EcoP15I ATPase rates are only low, the functional importance of the helicase motifs and regions was questionable and has never been probed systematically. Therefore, we mutated all helicase motifs and conserved regions predicted in Type III restriction enzyme EcoP15I and examined the functional consequences on EcoP15I enzyme activity and the structural integrity of the variants by CD spectroscopy. The resulting eleven enzyme variants all, except variant IVa, are properly folded showing the same secondary structure distribution as the wild-type enzyme. Classical helicase motifs I–VI are important for ATP and DNA cleavage by EcoP15I and mutations therein led to complete loss of ATPase and cleavage activity. Among the catalytically inactive enzyme variants three preserved the ability to bind ATP. In contrast, newly assigned motifs Q-tip, Ia and Va are not essential for EcoP15I activity and the corresponding enzyme variants were still catalytically active. DNA binding was only marginally reduced (2–7 fold) in all enzyme variants tested.     

S-adenosyl-L-methionine is required for DNA cleavage by type III restriction enzymes.

The requirement of S-adenosyl-L-methionine (AdoMet) in the cleavage reaction carried out by type III restriction-modification enzymes has been investigated. We show that DNA restriction by EcoPI restriction enzyme does not take place in the absence of exogenously added AdoMet. Interestingly, the closely related EcoP15I enzyme has endogenously bound AdoMet and therefore does not require the addition of the cofactor for DNA cleavage. By employing a variety of AdoMet analogs, which differ structurally from AdoMet, this study demonstrates that the carboxyl group and any substitution at the epsilon carbon of methionine is absolutely essential for DNA cleavage. Such analogs could bring about the necessary conformational change(s) in the enzyme, which make the enzyme proficient in DNA cleavage. Our studies, which include native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, molecular size exclusion chromatography, UV, fluorescence and circular dichroism spectroscopy, clearly demonstrate that the holoenzyme and apoenzyme forms of EcoP15I restriction enzyme have different conformations. Furthermore, the Res and Mod subunits of the EcoP15I restriction enzyme can be separated by gel filtration chromatography in the presence of 2 M NaCl. Reconstitution experiments, which involve mixing of the isolated subunits, result in an apoenzyme form, which is restriction proficient in the presence of AdoMet. However, mixing the Res subunit with Mod subunit deficient in AdoMet binding does not result in a functional restriction enzyme. These observations are consistent with the fact that AdoMet is required for DNA cleavage. In vivo complementation of the defective mod allele with a wild-type mod allele showed that an active restriction enzyme could be formed. Furthermore, we show that while the purified c2-134 mutant restriction enzyme is unable to cleave DNA, the c2-440 mutant enzyme is able to cleave DNA albeit poorly. Taken together, these results suggest that AdoMet binding causes conformational changes in the restriction enzyme and is necessary to bring about DNA cleavage.     

Scanning force microscopy of DNA translocation by the Type III restriction enzyme EcoP15I

Type III restriction enzymes are multifunctional heterooligomeric enzymes that cleave DNA at a fixed position downstream of a non-symmetric recognition site. For effective DNA cleavage these restriction enzymes need the presence of two unmethylated, inversely oriented recognition sites in the DNA molecule. DNA cleavage was proposed to result from ATP-dependent DNA translocation, which is expected to induce DNA loop formation, and collision of two enzyme-DNA complexes. We used scanning force microscopy to visualise the protein interaction with linear DNA molecules containing two EcoP15I recognition sites in inverse orientation. In the presence of the cofactors ATP and Mg(2+), EcoP15I molecules were shown to bind specifically to the recognition sites and to form DNA loop structures. One of the origins of the protein-clipped DNA loops was shown to be located at an EcoP15I recognition site, the other origin had an unspecific position in between the two EcoP15I recognition sites. The data demonstrate for the first time DNA translocation by the Type III restriction enzyme EcoP15I using scanning force microscopy. Moreover, our study revealed differences in the DNA-translocation processes mediated by Type I and Type III restriction enzymes.     

DNA looping and translocation provide an optimal cleavage mechanism for the type III restriction enzymes

EcoP15I is a type III restriction enzyme that requires two recognition sites in a defined orientation separated by up to 3.5 kbp to efficiently cleave DNA. The mechanism through which site-bound EcoP15I enzymes communicate between the two sites is unclear. Here, we use atomic force microscopy to study EcoP15I-DNA pre-cleavage complexes. From the number and size distribution of loops formed, we conclude that the loops observed do not result from translocation, but are instead formed by a contact between site-bound EcoP15I and a nonspecific region of DNA. This conclusion is confirmed by a theoretical polymer model. It is further shown that translocation must play some role, because when translocation is blocked by a Lac repressor protein, DNA cleavage is similarly blocked. On the basis of these results, we present a model for restriction by type III restriction enzymes and highlight the similarities between this and other classes of restriction enzymes.     

DNA cleavage by type III restriction-modification enzyme EcoP15I is independent of spacer distance between two head to head oriented recognition sites

The type III restriction-modification enzyme EcoP15I requires the interaction of two unmethylated, inversely oriented recognition sites 5'-CAGCAG in head to head configuration to allow an efficient DNA cleavage. It has been hypothesized that two convergent DNA-translocating enzyme-substrate complexes interact to form the active cleavage complex and that translocation is driven by ATP hydrolysis. Using a half-automated, fluorescence-based detection method, we investigated how the distance between two inversely oriented recognition sites affects DNA cleavage efficiency. We determined that EcoP15I cleaves DNA efficiently even for two adjacent head to head or tail to tail oriented target sites. Hence, DNA translocation appears not to be required for initiating DNA cleavage in these cases. Furthermore, we report here that EcoP15I is able to cleave single-site substrates. When we analyzed the interaction of EcoP15I with DNA substrates containing adjacent target sites in the presence of non-hydrolyzable ATP analogues, we found that cleavage depended on the hydrolysis of ATP. Moreover, we show that cleavage occurs at only one of the two possible cleavage positions of an interacting pair of target sequences. When EcoP15I bound to a DNA substrate containing one recognition site in the absence of ATP, we observed a 36 nucleotide DNaseI-footprint that is asymmetric on both strands. All of our footprinting experiments showed that the enzyme did not cover the region around the cleavage site. Analyzing a DNA fragment with two head to head oriented recognition sites, EcoP15I protected 27-33 nucleotides around the recognition sequence, including an additional region of 26 bp between both cleavage sites. For all DNA substrates examined, the presence of ATP caused altered footprinting patterns. We assume that the altered patterns are most likely due to a conformational change of the enzyme. Overall, our data further refine the tracking-collision model for type III restriction enzymes.     

Subunit assembly and mode of DNA cleavage of the type III restriction endonucleases EcoP1I and EcoP15I

DNA cleavage by type III restriction endonucleases requires two inversely oriented asymmetric recognition sequences and results from ATP-dependent DNA translocation and collision of two enzyme molecules. Here, we characterized the structure and mode of action of the related EcoP1I and EcoP15I enzymes. Analytical ultracentrifugation and gel quantification revealed a common Res(2)Mod(2) subunit stoichiometry. Single alanine substitutions in the putative nuclease active site of ResP1 and ResP15 abolished DNA but not ATP hydrolysis, whilst a substitution in helicase motif VI abolished both activities. Positively supercoiled DNA substrates containing a pair of inversely oriented recognition sites were cleaved inefficiently, whereas the corresponding relaxed and negatively supercoiled substrates were cleaved efficiently, suggesting that DNA overtwisting impedes the convergence of the translocating enzymes. EcoP1I and EcoP15I could co-operate in DNA cleavage on circular substrate containing several EcoP1I sites inversely oriented to a single EcoP15I site; cleavage occurred predominantly at the EcoP15I site. EcoP15I alone showed nicking activity on these molecules, cutting exclusively the top DNA strand at its recognition site. This activity was dependent on enzyme concentration and local DNA sequence. The EcoP1I nuclease mutant greatly stimulated the EcoP15I nicking activity, while the EcoP1I motif VI mutant did not. Moreover, combining an EcoP15I nuclease mutant with wild-type EcoP1I resulted in cutting the bottom DNA strand at the EcoP15I site. These data suggest that double-strand breaks result from top strand cleavage by a Res subunit proximal to the site of cleavage, whilst bottom strand cleavage is catalysed by a Res subunit supplied in trans by the distal endonuclease in the collision complex.     

Type III restriction endonuclease EcoP15I is a heterotrimeric complex containing one Res subunit with several DNA-binding regions and ATPase activity

For efficient DNA cleavage, the Type III restriction endonuclease EcoP15I communicates with two inversely oriented recognition sites in an ATP-dependent process. EcoP15I consists of methylation (Mod) and restriction (Res) subunits forming a multifunctional enzyme complex able to methylate or to cleave DNA. In this study, we determined by different analytical methods that EcoP15I contains a single Res subunit in a Mod(2)Res stoichiometry. The Res subunit comprises a translocase (Tr) domain carrying functional motifs of superfamily 2 helicases and an endonuclease domain with a PD..D/EXK motif. We show that the isolated Tr domain retains ATP-hydrolyzing activity and binds single- and double-stranded DNA in a sequence-independent manner. To localize the regions of DNA binding, we screened peptide arrays representing the entire Res sequence for their ability to interact with DNA. We discovered four DNA-binding regions in the Tr domain and two DNA-binding regions in the endonuclease domain. Modelling of the Tr domain shows that these multiple DNA-binding regions are located on the surface, free to interact with DNA. Interestingly, the positions of the DNA-binding regions are conserved among other Type III restriction endonucleases.     

Time-resolved fluorescence of 2-aminopurine in DNA duplexes in the presence of the EcoP15I Type III restriction–modification enzyme

EcoP15I is a Type III DNA restriction and modification enzyme of Escherichia coli. We show that it contains two modification (Mod) subunits for sequence-specific methylation of DNA and one copy of a restriction endonuclease (Res) subunit for cleavage of DNA containing unmethylated target sequences. Previously the Mod₂ dimer in the presence of cofactors was shown to use nucleotide flipping to gain access to the adenine base targeted for methylation (Reddy and Rao, J. Mol. Biol. 298 (2000) 597–610.). Surprisingly the Mod₂ enzyme also appeared to flip a second adenine in the target sequence, one which was not subject to methylation. We show using fluorescence lifetime measurements of the adenine analogue, 2-aminopurine, that only the methylatable adenine undergoes flipping by the complete Res₁Mod₂ enzyme and that this occurs even in the absence of cofactors. We suggest that this is due to activation of the Mod₂ core by the Res subunit.     

Single-stranded DNA binding and methylation by EcoP1I DNA methyltransferase

EcoP1I methyltransferase (M.EcoP1I) belongs to the type III restriction-modification system encoded by prophage P1 that infects Escherichia coli. Binding of M.EcoP1I to double-stranded DNA and single-stranded DNA has been characterized. Binding to both single- and double-stranded DNA could be competed out by unlabeled single-stranded DNA. Metal ions did not influence DNA binding. Interestingly, M.EcoP1I was able to methylate single-stranded DNA. Kinetic parameters were determined for single- and double-stranded DNA methylation. This feature of the enzyme probably functions in protecting the phage genome from restriction by type III restriction enzymes and thus could be considered as an anti-restriction system. This study describing in vitro methylation of single-stranded DNA by the type III methyltransferase EcoP1I allows understanding of the mechanism of action of these enzymes and also their role in the biology of single-stranded phages.     

Removal of a frameshift between the hsdM and hsdS genes of the EcoKI Type IA DNA restriction and modification system produces a new type of system and links the different families of Type I systems

The EcoKI DNA methyltransferase is a trimeric protein comprised of two modification subunits (M) and one sequence specificity subunit (S). This enzyme forms the core of the EcoKI restriction/modification (RM) enzyme. The 3′ end of the gene encoding the M subunit overlaps by 1 nt the start of the gene for the S subunit. Translation from the two different open reading frames is translationally coupled. Mutagenesis to remove the frameshift and fuse the two subunits together produces a functional RM enzyme in vivo with the same properties as the natural EcoKI system. The fusion protein can be purified and forms an active restriction enzyme upon addition of restriction subunits and of additional M subunit. The Type I RM systems are grouped into families, IA to IE, defined by complementation, hybridization and sequence similarity. The fusion protein forms an evolutionary intermediate form lying between the Type IA family of RM enzymes and the Type IB family of RM enzymes which have the frameshift located at a different part of the gene sequence.     

EcoA and EcoE: alternatives to the EcoK family of type I restriction and modification systems of Escherichia coli

The genes (hsd A) encoding EcoA, a restriction and modification system first identified in Escherichia coli 15T-, behave in genetic crosses as alleles of the genes (hsd K) encoding the archetypal type I restriction and modification system of E. coli K12. Nevertheless, molecular experiments have failed to detect relatedness between the A and K systems. We have cloned the hsd A genes and have identified, on the basis of DNA homology, related genes (hsd E) conferring a new specificity to a natural isolate of E. coli. We show that the overall organization of the genes encoding EcoA and EcoE closely parallels that for EcoK. Each enzyme is encoded by three genes, of which only one, hsdS, confers the specificity of DNA interaction. The three genes are in the same order as those encoding EcoK, i.e. hsdR, hsdM and hsdS and, similarly, they include a promoter between hsdR and hsdM from which the M and S genes can be transcribed. The evidence indicates that EcoA and EcoE are type I restriction and modification enzymes, but they appear to identify an alternative family to EcoK. For both families, the hsdR polypeptide is by far the largest, but the sizes of the other two polypeptides are reversed, with the smallest polypeptide of EcoK being the product of hsd S, and the smallest for the EcoA family being the product of hsdM. Physiologically, the A restriction and modification system differs from that of K and its relatives, in that A-specific methylation of unmodified DNA is particularly effective.     

Unidirectional translocation from recognition site and a necessary interaction with DNA end for cleavage by Type III restriction enzyme

Type III restriction enzymes have been demonstrated to require two unmethylated asymmetric recognition sites oriented head-to-head to elicit double-strand break 25–27 bp downstream of one of the two sites. The proposed DNA cleavage mechanism involves ATP-dependent DNA translocation. The sequence context of the recognition site was suggested to influence the site of DNA cleavage by the enzyme. In this investigation, we demonstrate that the cleavage site of the R.EcoP15I restriction enzyme does not depend on the sequence context of the recognition site. Strikingly, this study demonstrates that the enzyme can cleave linear DNA having either recognition sites in the same orientation or a single recognition site. Cleavage occurs predominantly at a site proximal to the DNA end in the case of multiple site substrates. Such cleavage can be abolished by the binding of Lac repressor downstream (3′ side) but not upstream (5′ side) of the recognition site. Binding of HU protein has also been observed to interfere with R.EcoP15I cleavage activity. In accordance with a mechanism requiring two enzyme molecules cooperating to elicit double-strand break on DNA, our results convincingly demonstrate that the enzyme translocates on DNA in a 5′ to 3′ direction from its recognition site and indicate a switch in the direction of enzyme motion at the DNA ends. This study demonstrates a new facet in the mode of action of these restriction enzymes.