Embryonic skin development and repair

Fetal cutaneous wounds have the unique ability to completely regenerate wounded skin and heal without scarring. However, adult cutaneous wounds heal via a fibroproliferative response which results in the formation of a scar. Understanding the mechanism(s) of scarless wound healing leads to enormous clinical potential in facilitating an environment conducive to scarless healing in adult cutaneous wounds. This article reviews the embryonic development of the skin and outlines the structural and functional differences in adult and fetal wound healing phenotypes. A review of current developments made towards applying this clinical knowledge to promote scarless healing in adult wounds is addressed.     

Scarless fetal skin wound healing update

Scar formation, a physiologic process in adult wound healing, can have devastating effects for patients; a multitude of pathologic outcomes, affecting all organ systems, stems from an amplification of this process. In contrast to adult wound repair, the early‐gestation fetal skin wound heals without scar formation, a phenomenon that appears to be intrinsic to fetal skin. An intensive research effort has focused on unraveling the mechanisms that underlie scarless fetal wound healing in an attempt to improve the quality of healing in both children and adults. Unique properties of fetal cells, extracellular matrix, cytokine profile, and gene expression contribute to this scarless repair. Despite the great increase in knowledge gained over the past decades, the precise mechanisms regulating scarless fetal healing remain unknown. Herein, we describe the current proposed mechanisms underlying fetal scarless wound healing in an effort to recapitulate the fetal phenotype in the postnatal environment. Birth Defects Research (Part C) 96:237–247, 2012. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Immunohistochemical localization of growth factors in fetal wound healing

Fetal wound healing occurs rapidly, in a regenerative fashion, and without scar formation, by contrast with adult wound healing, where tissue repair results in scar formation which limits tissue function and growth. The extracellular matrix deposited in fetal wounds contains essentially the same structural components as that in the adult wound but there are distinct differences in the spatial and temporal distribution of these components. In particular the organization of collagen in the healed fetal wound is indistinguishable from the normal surrounding tissue. Rapidity of healing, lack of an inflammatory response, and an absence of neovascularization also distinguish fetal from adult wound healing. The mechanisms controlling these differing processes are undefined but growth factors may play a critical role. The distribution of growth factors in healing fetal wounds is unknown. We have studied, by immunohistochemistry, the localization of platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF), transforming growth factor beta (TGF beta), and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), in fetal, neonatal, and adult mouse lip wounds. TGF beta and bFGF were present in neonatal and adult wounds, but were not detected in the fetal wounds, while PDGF was present in fetal, neonatal, and adult wounds. This pattern correlates with the known effects in vitro of these factors, the absence of an inflammatory response and neovascularization in the fetal wound, and the patterns of collagen deposition in both fetal and adult wounds. The results suggest that it may be possible to manipulate the adult wound to produce more fetal-like, scarless, wound healing.     

Scarless skin wound repair in the fetus.

The ability of a fetus to heal without scar formation depends on its gestational age at the time of injury and the size of the wound defect. In general, linear incisions heal without scar until late in gestation whereas excisional wounds heal with scar at an earlier gestational age. The profiles of fetal proteoglycans, collagens, and growth factors are different from those in adult wounds. The less-differentiated state of fetal skin is probably an important characteristic responsible for scarless repair. There is minimal inflammation in fetal wounds. Fetal wounds are characterized by high levels of hyaluronic acid and its stimulator(s) with more rapid, highly organized collagen deposition. The roles of peptide growth factors such as transforming growth factor-beta and basic fibroblast growth factor are less prominent in fetal than in adult wound healing. Platelet-derived growth factor has been detected in scarless fetal skin wounds, but its role is unknown. An understanding of scarless tissue repair has possible clinical application in the modulation of adult fibrotic diseases and abnormal scar-forming conditions.     

Diminished interleukin 6 (IL-6) production during scarless human fetal wound repair

Fetal wound healing is characterized by minimal inflammation and scarless repair. IL-6 stimulates inflammation in postnatal wound healing. We hypothesized that fetal skin has a diminished IL-6 response and that exogenous IL-6 will result in scar formation. Human adult or fetal skin was placed subcutaneously in SCID mice and incisionally wounded. Wounds were excised after 4, 12, 24 or 72 h for IL-6 mRNA quantification by RT-PCR. In other grafts, 5 microgram of IL-6 was injected at wounding and then harvested at 7 days for analysis of scar formation. IL-6 production was examined in primary cultures of human fetal or adult dermal fibroblasts incubated for 8 h with 0, 0.1, 1 or 10 ng/ml of PDGF-BB. IL-6 mRNA was detected 4 h after wounding in fetal and adult wounds, but by 12 h there was no IL-6 mRNA in the fetal wounds. Adult wounds had IL-6 mRNA persisting to 72 h. IL-6 administration to fetal wounds resulted in scar formation. Fetal fibroblasts produced less IL-6 protein and mRNA at all points examined (P<0.01 vs adult). Diminished production of inflammatory cytokines such as IL-6 may be responsible for the lack of inflammation seen during fetal wound healing. Diminished inflammation may provide a permissive environment for scarless wound healing.     

Elastin signaling in wound repair

Skin is an important organ to the human body as it functions as an interface between the body and environment. Cutaneous injury elicits a complex wound healing process, which is an orchestration of cells, matrix components, and signaling factors that re‐establishes the barrier function of skin. In adults, an unavoidable consequence of wound healing is scar formation. However, in early fetal development, wound healing is scarless. This phenomenon is characterized by an attenuated inflammatory response, differential expression of signaling factors, and regeneration of normal skin architecture. Elastin endows a range of mechanical and cell interactive properties to skin. In adult wound healing, elastin is severely lacking and only a disorganized elastic fiber network is present after scar formation. The inherent properties of elastin make it a desirable inclusion to adult wound healing. Elastin imparts recoil and resistance and induces a range of cell activities, including cell migration and proliferation, matrix synthesis, and protease production. The effects of elastin align with the hallmarks of fetal scarless wound healing. Elastin synthesis is substantial in late stage in utero and drops to a trickle in adults. The physical and cell signaling advantages of elastin in a wound healing context creates a parallel with the innate features of fetal skin that can allow for scarless healing. Birth Defects Research (Part C) 96:248–257, 2012. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Scarless fetal wound healing: a basic science review

SUMMARY: Scar formation is a major medical problem that can have devastating consequences for patients. The adverse physiological and psychological effects of scars are broad, and there are currently no reliable treatments to prevent scarring. In contrast to adult wounds, early gestation fetal skin wounds repair rapidly and in the absence of scar formation. Despite extensive investigation, the exact mechanisms of scarless fetal wound healing remain largely unknown. For some time, it has been known that significant differences exist among the extracellular matrix, inflammatory response, cellular mediators, and gene expression profiles of fetal and postnatal wounds. These differences may have important implications in scarless wound repair.     

Confocal microscopic analysis of scarless repair in the fetal rat: defining the transition.

Fetal wounds pass from scarless repair to healing with scar formation during gestation. This transition depends on both the size of the wound and the gestational age of the fetus. This study defines the transition period in the fetal rat model and provides new insight into scarless collagen wound architecture by using confocal microscopy. A total of 16 pregnant Sprague-Dawley rats were operated on. Open full-thickness wounds, 2 mm in diameter, were created on fetal rats at gestational ages 14.5 days (E14; n = 10), 16.5 days (E16; n = 42), and 18.5 days (E18; n = 42) (term = 21.5 days). Wounds were harvested at 24 (n = 18 per gestational age) and 72 hours (n = 24 per gestational age). Skin at identical gestational ages to wound harvest was used for controls. The wounds were fixed and stained with hematoxylin and eosin, antibody to type I collagen, and Sirius red for confocal microscopic evaluation. No E14 rat fetuses survived to wound harvest. Wounds created on E16 fetal rats healed completely and without scarring. E16 fetal rat hair follicle formation and collagen architecture was similar to that of normal, nonwounded skin. Wounds created on E18 fetal rats demonstrated slower healing; only 50 percent were completely healed at 72 hours compared with 100 percent of the E16 fetal rat wounds at 72 hours. Furthermore, the E18 wounds healed with collagen scar formation and without hair follicle formation. Confocal microscopy demonstrated that the collagen fibers were thin and arranged in a wispy pattern in E16 fetal rat wounds and in nonwounded dermis. E18 fetal rat wounds had thickened collagen fibers with large interfiber distances. Two-millimeter excisional E16 fetal rat wounds heal without scar formation and with regeneration of normal dermal and epidermal appendage architecture. E18 fetal rat wounds heal in a pattern similar to that of adult cutaneous wounds, with scar formation and absence of epidermal appendages. Confocal microscopy more clearly defined the dermal architecture in normal skin, scarless wounds, and scars. These data further define the transition period in the fetal rat wound model, which promises to be an effective system for the study of in vivo scarless wound healing.     

Chaperonin Containing T-Complex Polypeptide Subunit Eta (CCT-eta) Is a Specific Regulator of Fibroblast Motility and Contractility

Integumentary wounds in mammalian fetuses heal without scar; this scarless wound healing is intrinsic to fetal tissues and is notable for absence of the contraction seen in postnatal (adult) wounds. The precise molecular signals determining the scarless phenotype remain unclear. We have previously reported that the eta subunit of the chaperonin containing T-complex polypeptide (CCT-eta) is specifically reduced in healing fetal wounds in a rabbit model. In this study, we examine the role of CCT-eta in fibroblast motility and contractility, properties essential to wound healing and scar formation. We demonstrate that CCT-eta (but not CCT-beta) is underexpressed in fetal fibroblasts compared to adult fibroblasts. An in vitro wound healing assay demonstrated that adult fibroblasts showed increased cell migration in response to epidermal growth factor (EGF) and platelet derived growth factor (PDGF) stimulation, whereas fetal fibroblasts were unresponsive. Downregulation of CCT-eta in adult fibroblasts with short inhibitory RNA (siRNA) reduced cellular motility, both basal and growth factor-induced; in contrast, siRNA against CCT-beta had no such effect. Adult fibroblasts were more inherently contractile than fetal fibroblasts by cellular traction force microscopy; this contractility was increased by treatment with EGF and PDGF. CCT-eta siRNA inhibited the PDGF-induction of adult fibroblast contractility, whereas CCT-beta siRNA had no such effect. In each of these instances, the effect of downregulating CCT-eta was to modulate the behavior of adult fibroblasts so as to more closely approximate the characteristics of fetal fibroblasts. We next examined the effect of CCT-eta modulation on alpha-smooth muscle actin (α-SMA) expression, a gene product well known to play a critical role in adult wound healing. Fetal fibroblasts were found to constitutively express less α-SMA than adult cells. Reduction of CCT-eta with siRNA had minimal effect on cellular beta-actin but markedly decreased α-SMA; in contrast, reduction of CCT-beta had minimal effect on either actin isoform. Direct inhibition of α-SMA with siRNA reduced both basal and growth factor-induced fibroblast motility. These results indicate that CCT-eta is a specific regulator of fibroblast motility and contractility and may be a key determinant of the scarless wound healing phenotype by means of its specific regulation of α-SMA expression.     

Skin Wound Healing and Scarring: Fetal Wounds and Regenerative Restitution

The adverse physiological and psychological effects of scars formation after healing of wounds are broad and a major medical problem for patients. In utero, fetal wounds heal in a regenerative manner, though the mechanisms are unknown. Differences in fetal scarless regeneration and adult repair can provide key insight into reduction of scarring therapy. Understanding the cellular and extracellular matrix alterations in excessive adult scarring in comparison to fetal scarless healing may have important implications. Herein, we propose that matrix can be controlled via cellular therapy to resemble a fetal‐like matrix that will result in reduced scarring. Birth Defects Research (Part C) 96:325–333, 2012. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Matrix metalloproteinases and the ontogeny of scarless repair: the other side of the wound healing balance

Early gestation mammalian fetuses possess the remarkable ability to heal cutaneous wounds in a scarless fashion. Over the past 20 years, scientists have been working to decipher the mechanisms underlying this phenomenon. Much of the research to date has focused on fetal correlates of adult wound healing that promote fibrosis and granulation tissue formation. It is important to remember, however, that wound repair consists of a balance between tissue synthesis, deposition, and degradation. Relatively little attention has been paid to this latter component of the fetal wound healing process.In this study, we examined the ontogeny of ten matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and their tissue inhibitors (TIMPs) in nonwounded fetal rat skin and fibroblasts as a function of gestational age. We used a semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction protocol to analyze these important enzymes at time points that represent both the scarless and scar-forming periods of rat gestation. The enzymes evaluated were collagenase-1 (MMP-1), stromelysin-1 (MMP-3), gelatinase A (MMP-2), gelatinase B (MMP-9), membrane-type matrix metalloproteinases (MT-MMPs) 1, 2, and 3, and TIMPs 1, 2, and 3.Results demonstrated marked increases in gene expression for MMP-1, MMP-3 and MMP-9 that correlated with the onset of scar formation in nonwounded fetal skin. Similar results were noted in terms of MMP-9 gene expression in fetal fibroblasts. These results suggest that differences in the expression of these matrix metalloproteinases may have a role in the scarless wound healing phenotype observed early in fetal rat gestation. Furthermore, our data suggest that the differential expression of gelatinase B (MMP-9) may be mediated by the fetal fibroblasts themselves.     

Blood-derived small Dot cells reduce scar in wound healing

Wounds in fetal skin heal without scar, however the mechanism is unknown. We identified a novel group of E-cadherin positive cells in the blood of fetal and adult mice and named them "Dot cells". The percentage of Dot cells in E16.5 fetal mice blood is more than twenty times higher compared to adult blood. Dot cells also express integrin beta1, CD184, CD34, CD13low and Sca1low, but not CD45, CD44, and CD117. Dot cells have a tiny dot shape between 1 and 7 microm diameters with fast proliferation in vitro. Most of the Dot cells remain positive for E-cadherin and integrin beta1 after one month in culture. Transplantation of Dot cells to adult mice heals skin wounds with less scar due to reduced smooth muscle actin and collagen expression in the repair tissue. Tracking GFP-positive Dot cells demonstrates that Dot cells migrate to wounds and differentiate into dermal cells, which also express strongly to FGF-2, and later lose their GFP expression. Our results indicate that Dot cells are a group of previously unidentified cells that have strong wound healing effect. The mechanism of scarless wound healing in fetal skin is due to the presence of a large number of Dot cells.     

Nerve dependency in scarless fetal wound healing

The human fetus is capable of healing cutaneous wounds without scar up to the third trimester of development This process of tissue repair is more akin to newt limb regeneration than classic adult scar forming wound repair. Regeneration of the newt limb is dependent on neural input in its early stages. This study was an attempt to determine whether a similar dependence on neural input exists for mammalian fetal wounds to heal without scar. The left hind limb of six fetal lambs was denervated during the early second trimester of development (day 55; term = 145 days). Two weeks after denervation, the animals were again exposed to create bilateral incisional and 6-mm-diameter excisional wounds on their innervated right and denervated left lower extremities. Five days after creation of these defects, the wounds were examined for alterations in repair. Four fetal lambs survived, and three were suitable for evaluation. There were marked alterations in wound healing seen after denervation. Excisional wounds on the innervated side contracted and decreased their surface area by 14 percent. In contrast, the denervated wounds not only failed to contract, but increased in size by 60 percent. Changes in the incisional wounds were equally distinctive. Innervated incisional wounds healed completely without scar and had a wound breaking strength comparable to that of normal skin (Table I). In contrast, two of the three denervated incisional wounds dehisced and failed to heal, even in the regions where the skin was approximated by suture. The third denervated incisional wound did heal but with a significant amount of scar. Electron microscopy confirmed this finding by clearly demonstrating thickened and irregular collagen deposition in the extracellular matrix of all the denervated incisional specimens. In summary, like the regenerating newt limb, scarless fetal skin wound repair requires neural stimulation for tissue regeneration to occur. Therefore, in the mammal, the primary regulator for this unique type of tissue repair may have a central neural, rather than a local, tissue origin.     

The extracellular matrix of lip wounds in fetal, neonatal and adult mice.

Wound healing in the fetus occurs rapidly, by a regenerative process and without an inflammatory response, resulting in complete restitution of normal tissue function. By contrast, in the adult, wounds heal with scar formation, which may impair function and inhibit further growth. The cellular mechanisms underlying these differing forms of wound healing are unknown but the extracellular matrix (ECM), through its effects on cell function, may play a key role. We have studied the ECM in upper lip wounds of adult, neonatal and fetal mice at days 14, 16 and 18 of gestation. The spatial and temporal distribution of collagen types I, III, IV, V and VI, fibronectin, tenascin, laminin, chondroitin and heparan sulphates were examined immunohistochemically. Results from the fetal groups were essentially similar whilst there were distinct differences between fetus, neonate and adult. Fibronectin was present at the surface of the wound in all groups at 1 h post-wounding. Tenascin was also present at the wound surface but the time at which it was first present differed between fetus (1 h), neonate (12 h) and adult (24 h). The time of first appearance paralleled the rate of wound healing which was most rapid in the fetus and slowest in the adult. Tenascin inhibits the cell adhesion effect of fibronectin and during development the appearance of tenascin correlates with the initiation of cell migration. During wound healing the appearance of tenascin preceded cell migration and the rapid closure of fetal wounds may be due to the early appearance of tenascin in the wound. Collagen types I, III, IV, V and VI were present in all three wound groups but the timing and pattern of collagen deposition differed, with restoration of the normal collagen pattern in the fetus and a scar pattern in the adult. This confirms that lack of scarring in fetal wounds is due to the organisation of collagen within the wound and not simply lack of collagen formation. The distribution of chondroitin sulphate differed between normal fetal and adult tissues and between fetal and adult wounds. Its presence in the fetal wound may alter collagen fibril formation. No inflammatory response was seen in the fetal wounds. The differences in the ECM of fetal and adult wounds suggests that it may be possible to alter the adult wound so that it heals by a fetal-like process without scar formation, loss of tissue function or restriction of growth.     

Tissue-engineered fetal dermal matrices

In the early to mid-gestation fetus, skin wounds heal with no scar formation and perfect restoration of dermal architecture. This phenomenon is intrinsic to fetal skin. The intrinsic phenotypic properties of the fetal fibroblast are believed to be ??the effector of scarless repair??. We sought to prepare dermal matrices with high similarity to the mid-gestation fetal dermis using the technology of ??self-assembly?? with fetal dermal cells of 18, 20, and 22?wk gestation. Comparison of these dermal constructs to those prepared with neonatal dermal cells, adult skin, neonatal foreskin, and mid-gestation fetal skin demonstrates that these fetal dermal matrices bear marked morphological and biochemical resemblance to the mid-gestation fetal dermis. In order to shed further light on the genes involved in scarless wound healing, we conducted a differential gene array analysis of the neonatal and fetal dermal matrices. Using a gene chip (GLYCOv4 gene chip) of approximately 1,260 human genes, we observed differential expression of 67 genes. A number of fibrotic genes were observed to be downregulated and anti-fibrotic genes upregulated.     

Discoidin domain receptors and their ligand, collagen, are temporally regulated in fetal rat fibroblasts in vitro

The biochemical regulation of collagen deposition during adult cutaneous wound repair is poorly understood. Likewise, how collagen is perceived and modulated in fetal scarless healing remains unknown. Recently, discoidin domain receptors-1 and 2 (DDR1 and DDR2) with tyrosine kinase activity have been identified as novel receptors for collagen. In light of these findings, it was speculated that the production of collagen receptors DDR1 and DDR2 by fetal fibroblasts may be temporally regulated to correlate with the ontogeny of embryonic scar formation. More specifically, because DDRs directly bind collagen and transmit the signals intracellularly, it was hypothesized that they may play an important role in fetal scarless healing by ultimately regulating and modulating collagen production and organization. As part of a fundamental assessment to elucidate the role of DDRs in scarless fetal wound repair, the endogenous expression of DDR1, DDR2, collagen I, and total collagen, as a function of fetal Sprague-Dawley rat skin fibroblasts of different gestational ages, representing scar-free (E16.5) periods was determined. Using explanted dermal fibroblasts of gestational days E13.5, E16.5, E18.5, and E21.5 (term gestation = 21.5 days) fetuses (n = 92), [3H]proline incorporation assay and Northern and Western blotting analysis were performed to compare the expressions of these molecules with scar-free and scar-forming stages of embryonic development. These results revealed a pattern of increasing collagen production with increasing gestational ages, whereas DDR1 expression decreased with increasing gestational age. This observation suggests that elevated levels of DDR1 may play an important role in scarless tissue regeneration by early gestation fetal fibroblasts. In contrast, DDR2 was expressed by fetal rat fibroblasts at a similar level throughout gestation. These data demonstrate for the first time the temporal expression of collagen and DDR tyrosine kinases in fetal rat fibroblasts as a function of gestational ages. Overall, these data suggest that differential temporal expression of the above-mentioned molecules during fetal skin development may play an important role in the ontogeny of scar formation. Future studies will involve the characterization of the biomolecular functions of these receptor kinases during fetal wound repair.