The inner ear of gymnophione amphibians and its nerve supply: A comparative study of regressive events in a complex sensory system (Amphibia,Gymnophiona)

Summary The inner ears of representatives of all six gymnophionan families, as well as an ontogenetic series of one species, were studied in order to understand the origin and changes of the amphibian and basilar papillae. The amphibian papilla is in close proximity to the papilla neglecta in some adult gymnophionans. During ontogeny, both epithelia are adherent before they are separated by the formation of the utriculosaccular foramen. The nerve fibers to both epithelia run together, and both epithelia show a comparable variation in size and position among amphibians (amphibian papilla) and among vertebrates (papilla neglecta). Based on these arguments we propose that the amphibian papilla is a translocation of a part of the papilla neglecta specific to amphibians. Present in all primitive gymnophionans, the basilar papilla is lost in all derived gymnophionans. In contrast to anurans, but similar to some urodeles, amniotes, and Latimeria, the basilar papilla rests partly on a basilar membrane. Because of similarities in structure, topology, and innervation, the basilar papilla is suggested to be homologous in Latimeria and tetrapods. The structural differences of most amphibian basilar papillae, compared to those of amniotes and Latimeria, may be due to the different course of the periotic system and the formation of a basilar papillar recess rather than to a separate evolution of this epithelium. In addition to loss of the basilar papilla, some derived gymnophionans have lost the lagena, presumably independently, and the amphibian papilla is extremely reduced in the only genus without a stapes (Scolecomorphus). The papilla neglecta is, for unknown functional reasons, relatively large in aquatic gymnophionans, whereas it is almost lost in some thoroughly terrestrial gymnophionans. The regressive changes in the inner ear are not reflected in obvious changes in the pattern of eighth nerve projection. However, there is a rearrangement of cell masses in the rhombencephalic alar plate of derived gymnophionans, which may be related to the partial or complete loss of lateral line afferents. We propose that the presence of a basilar papilla is a synapomorphy of tetrapods and Latimeria, that the translocation of the papilla neglecta is related to the unique course of the amphibian periotic canal, and that regressive changes in the inner ear are related to the primitive absence of a tympanic ear.     

The evolution of the amphibian lateral line system and its bearing on amphibian phylogeny

In modern amphibians that are aquatic the lateral line system is organized, by order, as follows: caecilians have electroreceptive ampullary organs and single rows of mechanoreceptive neuromast organs; generalized anurans have single rows of neuromasts that divide in a transverse plane to form secondary neuromasts or stitches, they do not have ampullary organs; generalized urodeles have ampullary organs, transverse stitches, and double or triple rows of neuromasts. Fossil evidence indicates that early amphibians had both ampullary organs and single rows of neuromasts embedded in bone. With time, receptors became epidermal in all three orders. Modern caecilians have retained the primitive receptor arrangement. I propose that the common ancestor of anurans and urodeles had transverse stitches, and that this character allies these two groups. Subsequent to the anuranurodele split, anurans lost their ampullary organs, perhaps concomitant with developing specializations for herbivory. Urodeles developed orthogonal neuromast couplets und triplets. In modern anurans und urodeles, transverse stitches are correlated with pond dwelling, while ampullary organs are correlated with carnivory, suggesting that the anuran-urodele ancestor(s) was a (were) pond-dwelling carnivore(s).     

Central Lateral Line and Auditory Pathways: A Phylogenetic Perspective

The phylogenetic origins of the lateral line electrosensory,lateral line mechanosensory, and auditory components of theoctavolateralis system are unknown but each of these sensorymodalities appears to have evolved early in vertebrate history.The octavolateralis terminal field occupies a large area ofthe dorsolateral wall of the medulla and among agnathids, cartilaginousfishes, non-teleost bony fishes and, with modifications, urodeles,consists of a dorsal electrosensory nucleus, a medial mechanosensorynucleus and a ventral octaval nuclear complex. This arrangementof medullary octavolateral nuclei, which differs from that ofnon-electroreceptive and electroreceptive teleosts, is consideredthe primitive plan and is retained in that phyletic line leadingto tetrapods. Separate and parallel pathways are known, in elasmobranchsand a few teleosts, to ascend from each medullary lateral linecenter to the midbrain and presumably from midbrain to telencephaliclevels via thalamic relays. There is no evidence, with the lossof lateral line senses among some amphibians and all amniotes,that the central neural pathways and nuclei are retained andused to process information from other sensory modalities. Theanatomy of the central auditory system of fishes is unknownbut is required for an understanding of whether auditory nucleiand pathways are retained during the fishamphibian transition,or whether new ones arise, to process information from independentlyevolved peripheral receptors.     

Structural characteristics of genome organization in amphibians: Differential staining of chromosomes and DNA structure

Summary Differential staining patterns on amphibian chromosomes are in some respects distinct from those on mammalian chromosomes; C-bands are best obtained, whereas G- and Q-bands are either unobtainable (on anuran chromosomes) or coincide with C-bands (chromosomes of urodeles). In amphibians, rRNA genes are located at secondary constrictions, but in urodeles they are also found at other chromosome sites, the positions of these sites being strictly heritable. DNA content in amphibian cells is tens and hundreds times higher than in mammals. DNA contents in anurans and urodeles differ within certain limits: from 2 to 25 pg/N and from 30 to over 160 pg/N respectively. Species characterized by slow morphogenesis have larger genomes. Genome growth is normally due to an increase in the amount of repetitive DNA (mostly intermediate repetitive sequences), the amount of unique sequences being almost constant (11 pg/genome in urodeles, and 1.5 pg/genome in anurans). In anurans in general no satellite DNA was found, whereas such fractions were found in manyUrodela species. Nucleosome chromatin structure in amphibians is identical to that of other eukariotes. It is postulated that differences in chromosome banding between amphibians and mammals are due to differences in chromatin packing which in turn is related to the distinct organization of DNA repetitive sequences. It is likely that fish chromosomes have a similiar structure. A comparison of such properties as the chromosome banding patterns, variations in nuclear DNA content and some genome characteristics enable us to group fishes and amphibians together as regards chromosome structure, as distinct from amniotes - reptiles, birds and mammals. It is probable that in the ancient amphibians - ancestors of reptiles - chromatin packing underwent a radical transformation, following changes in the organization of DNA repetitive sequences.     

Comparative view of the central organization of afferent and efferent circuitry for the inner ear

In all vertebrates, eighth nerve fibres from the inner ear distribute to target nuclei situated in the dorsolateral wall of the rhombencephalon. In amniotes, primary auditory and vestibular nuclei are readily delineated in that acoustic nuclei lie dorsal and sometimes rostral to vestibular nuclei. Fishes and aquatic amphibians have, in addition to labyrinthine organs, hair cell receptors in the lateral line system. Eighth nerve and lateral line fibres from these sense organs project to the octavolateralis region of the rhombencephalon. In this region, the primary nuclei cannot be easily divided into functionally distinct units. However, modality-specific zones seem to be present for auditory as well as lateral line projections lie dorsal and sometimes rostral to those from vestibular organs. Projections from the primary auditory and vestibular nuclei to higher order centres follow pathways which are conservative in their architecture among vertebrates. Ascending auditory fibres project either directly or via relay nuclei to a large midbrain center, the torus semicircularis (inferior colliculus) and hence to the forebrain. In fishes and aquatic amphibians, the lateral line system also sends a projection to the midbrain and information from this system may be integrated with auditory input at that level. The organization of vestibulospinal and vestibulo-ocular pathways shows little variation throughout vertebrate phylogeny. The sense organs of the inner ear of all vertebrates and of the lateral line system of anamniotes receive an efferent innervation. In anamniotes and some reptiles, the efferent supply originates from a single nucleus (Octavolateralis Efferent Nucleus) while that of "higher" vertebrates arises from separate auditory and vestibular efferent nuclei. The biological significance of this innervation for all vertebrates is not yet understood. However, an important feature common to all is the association of the efferent system with the motor centres of the hindbrain.     

The lateral line system in larvalIchthyophis (Amphibia: Gymnophiona)

Summary The lateral line systems of larval caecilians of the genusIchthyophis possess two types of elements, free neuromasts and ampullary organs. Free mechanoreceptive neuromasts are typical of those found in other vertebrates, and are arranged in series roughly homologous to neuromast groups in many other fishes and amphibians. In contrast to other amphibians,Ichthyophis larvae possess only one paired, dorsal body series of neuromasts. Regional specialization of neuromasts is evident inIchthyophis. Premaxillary and anterior head neuromasts are the largest in size and total cell number. Overall, size and total cell numbers are correlated with depth of epidermis. Neuromasts on the anterior sides of the head occur in slight grooves and have apical tips situated farther below the level of the epidermis and with greater apical indentation. These features probably provide increased protection against abrasion. Apparently abnormal neuromasts are frequently found among the neuromast series. Such neuromasts contain fewer cells that lack normal apical extension, producing a sunken effect similar to that of the ampullary organ elements. The ampullary organs ofIchthyophis are morphologically similar to those found in various freshwater fishes and known to function as electroreceptors. These organs are not observed in the lateral line systems of members of other amphibian orders (Urodela and Anura), and we suggest that they function as electroreceptors. The sunken neuromasts of theIchthyophis lateral line system may parallel the possible evolutionary development of pit organs from normal neuromasts.     

Evolution of the amphibian tympanic ear and the origin of frogs

Recent anurans plus all but the most primitive temnospondyl labyrinthodont amphibians are proposed as a monophyletic taxon, based on shared stapedial characters which are derived with respect to all other tetrapods. Within temnospondyls, the mostly Lower Permian dissorophoids are proposed as most closely related to Recent anurans, based on interpretation of the dissorophoid dorsal quadrate process and the anuran tympanic annulus as sequential steps in a character transformation series. The otic features described here reinforce the concept of the amphibian tympanic ear as a prior "invention" with no genealogical relationship to amniote tympanic ears.     

Development and evolution of lateral line placodes in amphibians. - II. Evolutionary diversification

The amphibian lateral line system develops from a series of lateral line placodes. The different phases of development from early induction, to pattern formation, differentiation, morphogenesis, and metamorphic fate were summarized in the first part of this review (Schlosser, 2002a). Here, a survey of the diversity of lateral line systems in amphibians is presented indicating that most phases of lateral line development have been subject to evolutionary changes. Several trends suggest important roles for both adaptive changes and internal constraints in amphibian lateral line evolution. Many of these trends involved the coordinated modification of different derivatives of lateral line placodes suggesting that these placodes are not only autonomous developmental modules, but also units of evolutionary variation that tend to be modified in a coherent and largely context-independent fashion.     

Neuromast topography in anuran amphibians

Generalized anuran tadpoles across families exhibit a similar neuromast morphology on their heads, as follows: (1) all neuromast lines known for anurans are present; (2) within these lines total neuromast number ranges from about 250 to 320; (3) neuromasts form linear stitches composed of two to three, but sometimes up to five, neuromasts; (4) neuromast linear dimensions are ? 10 μm; and (5) neuromasts contain ? 15 hair cells. Compared with generalized forms, stream, arboreal, carnivorous, and desert-pond forms have fewer neuromasts but they contain more hair cells. They do not, however, form stitches. Obligate midwater suspension-feeding forms, including Xenopus (Pipidae), Rhinophrynus (Rhinophyrnidae), and Phrynomerus (Microhylidae), form stitches that contain > six, but potentially up to 18 or more, loosely aggregated neuromasts. Xenopus and Rhinophrynus have large neuromasts (up to 40 μm across). Chiasmocleis (Microhylidae) tadpoles form stiches that are linearly arranged with up to ten neuromasts. Whereas urodeles can have more than one neuromast row per line and may form both linear and transverse stitches, anurans have only one row of neuromasts per line and form only transverse stitches. Neuromasts in anurans tend to be smaller and more circular than in urodeles and positioned flush with the epidermal surface. A greater percentage of anurans form stitches, and anurans have greater intrafamilial variation in stitch formation than do urodeles.     

Ganglioside variations in amphibian brain tissue

Variation in the content and pattern of brain gangliosides from three anurans and two urodeles was analysed by thin-layer chromatography. The pattern for all three anurans was basically similar, though quantitative differences among species were detected. Ganglioside patterns from the two salamanders were distinctively different from that of the anurans and from one another, and more closely resembled the patterns seen in other tetrapods. Ganglioside variations in amphibians appear to reflect phylogenetic relationships better than life history or ecological factors.     

Auditory processing in anurans.

Anurans (frogs and toads) represent an example of peripheral specialization of the auditory systems. Their inner ear contains two distinct auditory organs: the amphibian papilla and the basilar papilla. Each organ is tuned to different species-specific frequency ranges. Because of this peripheral specialization, anurans offer an excellent opportunity to explore neural decoding of complex sounds in the central auditory system.     

Of chicken wings and frog legs: a smorgasbord of evolutionary variation in mechanisms of tetrapod limb development

The tetrapod limb, which has served as a paradigm for the study of development and morphological evolution, is becoming a paradigm for developmental evolution as well. In its origin and diversification, the tetrapod limb has undergone a great deal of remodeling. These morphological changes and other evolutionary phenomena have produced variation in mechanisms of tetrapod limb development. Here, we review that variation in the four major clades of limbed tetrapods. Comparisons in a phylogenetic context reveal details of development and evolution that otherwise may have been unclear. Such details include apparent differences in the mechanisms of dorsal-ventral patterning and limb identity specification between mouse and chick and mechanistic novelties in amniotes, anurans, and urodeles. As we gain a better understanding of the details of limb development, further differences among taxa will be revealed. The use of appropriate comparative techniques in a phylogenetic context thus sheds light on evolutionary transitions in limb morphology and the generality of developmental models across species and is therefore important to both evolutionary and developmental biologists.     

Evidences for shared features in the organization of the basal ganglia in tetrapods: studies in amphibians.

In a series of recent studies, the organization of the basal ganglia of amphibians, more in particular their connectivity and chemoarchitecture, has been thoroughly analyzed. The pattern of organization found for the amphibian basal ganglia includes dorsal and ventral striatopallidal systems, reciprocal connections between the striatopallidal complex and structures derived from the diencephalic and mesencephalic parts of the basal plate (striatonigral and nigrostriatal projections), and descending pathways from the striatopallidal system to the midbrain tectum and the reticular formation of the brain stem. A comparative analysis of the organization of the basal ganglia in tetrapods strongly supports the notion that a primitive pattern was most likely present in ancestral tetrapods, and that many features can still be recognized in extant amphibians and amniotes.     

Comparative morphology of the amphibian opercularis system: I. General design features and functional interpretation

The morphology of the opercularis system of anuran and caudate amphibians suggests that it acts to produce motion of the operculum that in turn produces fluid motion within the inner ear. The operculum and opercularis muscle form a lever system, with a narrow connection between the operculum and otic capsule acting as a fulcrum about which the operculum moves in response to forces applied via the muscle. The opercula of many species possess a muscular process on which the muscle inserts, thereby increasing the moment arm through which the muscle acts. The tonicity of the opercularis muscle allows tensile forces produced by substrate vibration or other mechanical energy applied to the forelimb to be effectively transmitted to the operculum; the elasticity of the connective tissue holding the operculum in place should act to return the operculum to its original position. The opercularis systems of frogs and non-plethodontid salamanders are similar structurally and functionally; that of plethodontid salamanders is structurally distinct but also functions as a lever system. Fluid motion produced by opercular motion could stimulate various end organs of the inner ear; the saccule, lagena, and amphibian papilla are in close approximation and wave energy could directly affect their otoconial or tectorial structures. In those anurans with a tympanic ear, the stapedial footplate and operculum articulate, but this articulation allows both to move independently. The stapes-tympanum complex and opercularis system therefore appear to be independent functional systems, and it is unlikely that the opercularis system modulates middle ear responsiveness. The general design of the opercularis system is consistent with a function in reception of substrate vibrations.     

Hair Cell Polarization in the Inner Ear of a Caecilian,Ichthyophis glutinosus (Amphibia: Gymnophiona)

The inner ear of Ichthyophis glutinosus is described with emphasis on the position of the sensory organs and the polarization of the hair cells. The hair cell polarization patterns of the maculae, cristae and papilla basilaris is similar to previous observations in other tetrapods. The papilla amphibiorum shows a simpler bidirectional polarization than described in other amphibians. The papilla neglecta, a sensory organ in the utriculus shows a unidirectional posteriorly directed polarization. A neglecta has not been found in the utriculus of anurans and urodeles previously.     

The development of the hindbrain afferent projections in the axolotl: evidence for timing as a specific mechanism of afferent fiber sorting

The aim of this study is to reveal the timing and growth pattern of central octavolateral projection development in the Mexican axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum. In this amphibian species the development of the inner ear occurs first, followed by mechanosensory lateral line organs, and finally by ampullary electroreceptors. Several hypotheses have been proposed about how the development of peripheral organs, including differential projections of the ear, might relate to the development of central projections. Our data suggest that the sequence of maturation of the ear, mechanosensory lateral line, and ampullary electroreceptive organs is closely accompanied by the timed development of the trigeminal, inner ear, mechanosensory lateral line organs, and the ampullary electroreceptor afferent projections in the axolotl. Our data suggest that segregation of central termination within the alar plate is a function of time and space: later forming organs are likely innervated by later forming ganglia that project centrally later and to more dorsal areas of the alar plate that have not yet received any other afferents. Later forming ganglia of the same type may grow along existing pathways of earlier formed neurons.     

Hedgehog参与西伯利亚鲟侧线机械和电感受器分化的初始证据

为揭示Hedgehog（Hh）信号与神经丘和壶腹器官分化的关系,研究以西伯利亚鲟（Acipenser baerii Brandt）为模型,首先对再生过程中的神经丘和壶腹器官的转录组进行比较分析,发现Hh信号通路关键基因（Shh、Patched 1）在两类感受器中差异表达,且它们的表达在再生过程中呈现动态性。然后用环巴胺（Cyclopamine,Hh信号抑制剂）处理西伯利亚鲟胚胎（st29）,用扫描电镜和FM1-43荧光染色对西伯利亚鲟仔鱼（st43-st44）分析发现环巴胺显著抑制了壶腹器官的发育。整体原位杂交表明,Shh、Patched1、Smoothened、Gli2在腹面侧线区域的表达受到了环巴胺的抑制。以上结果暗示Hh信号通路与神经丘和壶腹器官的发育有关,推测Hh信号在神经丘和壶腹器官的分化过程中起到了重要作用。     

Sonic hedgehog antagonists reduce size and alter patterning of the frog inner ear

Sonic hedgehog (Shh) signaling plays a major role in vertebrate development, from regulation of proliferation to the patterning of various organs. In amniotes, Shh affects dorsoventral patterning in the inner ear but affects anteroposterior patterning in teleost ears. It remains unknown how altered function of Shh relates to morphogenetic changes that coincide with the evolution of limbs and novel auditory organs in the ear. In this study, we used the tetrapod, Xenopus laevis , to test how increasing concentrations of the Shh signal pathway antagonist, Vismodegib, affects ear development. Vismodegib treatment dose dependently alters the development of the ear, hypaxial muscle, and indirectly the Mauthner cell through its interaction with the inner ear afferents. Together, these phenotypes have an effect on escape response. The altered Mauthner cell likely contributes to the increased time to respond to a stimulus. In addition, the increased hypaxial muscle in the trunk likely contributes to the subtle change in animal C‐start flexion angle. In the ear, Vismodegib treatment results in decreasing segregation between the gravistatic sensory epithelia as the concentration of Vismodegib increases. Furthermore, at higher doses, there is a loss of the horizontal canal but no enantiomorphic transformation, as in bony fish lacking Shh. Like in amniotes, Shh signaling in frogs affects dorsoventral patterning in the ear, suggesting that auditory sensory evolution in sarcopterygians/tetrapods evolved with a shift of Shh function in axis specification. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Develop Neurobiol 77: 1385–1400, 2017     

Inner ear morphology of diadectomorphs and seymouriamorphs (Tetrapoda) uncovered by high-resolution x-ray microcomputed tomography,and the origin of the amniote crown group

The origin of amniotes was a key event in vertebrate evolution, enabling tetrapods to break their ties with water and invade terrestrial environments. Two pivotal clades of early tetrapods, the diadectomorphs and the seymouriamorphs, have played an unsurpassed role in debates about the ancestry of amniotes for over a century, but their skeletal morphology has provided conflicting evidence for their affinities. Using high-resolution X-ray microcomputed tomography, we reveal the three-dimensional architecture of the well preserved endosseous labyrinth of the inner ear in representative species belonging to both groups. Data from the inner ear are coded in a new cladistic matrix of stem and primitive crown amniotes. Both maximum parsimony and Bayesian inference analyses retrieve seymouriamorphs as derived non-crown amniotes and diadectomorphs as sister group to synapsids. If confirmed, this sister group relationship invites re-examination of character polarity near the roots of the crown amniote radiation. Major changes in the endosseous labyrinth and adjacent braincase regions are mapped across the transition from non-amniote to amniote tetrapods and include: a ventral shift of the cochlear recess relative to the vestibule and the semicircular canals; cochlear recess (primitively housed exclusively within the opisthotic) accommodated within both the prootic and the opisthotic; development of a distinct fossa subarcuata. The inner ear of seymouriamorphs foreshadows conditions of more derived groups, whereas that of diadectomorphs shows a mosaic of plesiomorphic and apomorphic traits, some of which are unambiguously amniote-like, including a distinct and pyramid-like cochlear recess.