Ricin A-chain substrate specificity in RNA, DNA, and hybrid stem-loop structures

Ricin toxin A-chain (RTA) is the catalytic subunit of ricin, a heterodimeric toxin from castor beans. Its ribosomal inactivating activity arises from depurination of a single adenine from position A(4324) in a GAGA tetraloop from 28S ribosomal RNA. Minimal substrate requirements are the GAGA tetraloop and stem of two or more base pairs. Depurination activity also occurs on stem-loop DNA with the same sequence, but with the k(cat) reduced 200-fold. Systematic variation of RNA 5'-G(1)C(2)G(3)C(4)[G(5)A(6)G(7)A(8)]G(9)C(10)G(11)C(12)-3' 12mers via replacement of each nucleotide in the tetraloop with a deoxynucleotide showed a 16-fold increase in k(cat) for A(6) --> dA(6) but reduced k(cat) up to 300-fold for the other sites. Methylation of individual 2'-hydroxyls in a similar experiment reduced k(cat) by as much as 3 x 10(-3)-fold. In stem-loop DNA, replacement of d[G(5)A(6)G(7)A(8)] with individual ribonucleotides resulted in small kinetic changes, except for the dA(6) --> A(6) replacement for which k(cat) decreased 6-fold. Insertion of d[G(5)A(6)G(7)A(8)] into an RNA stem-loop or G(5)A(6)G(7)A(8) into a DNA stem-loop reduced k(cat) by 30- and 5-fold, respectively. Multiple substitutions of deoxyribonucleotides into RNA stem-loops in one case (dG(5),dG(7)) decreased k(cat)/K(m) by 10(5)-fold, while a second change (dG(5),dA(8)) decreased k(cat) by 100-fold. Mapping these interactions on the structure of GAGA stem-loop RNA suggests that all the loop 2'-hydroxyl groups play a significant role in the action of ricin A-chain. Improved binding of RNA-DNA stem-loop hybrids provides a scaffold for inhibitor design. Replacing the adenosine of the RTA depurination site with deoxyadenosine in a small RNA stem-loop increased k(cat) 20-fold to 1660 min(-1), a value similar to RTA's k(cat) on intact ribosomes.     

Ricin A-chain inhibitors resembling the oxacarbenium ion transition state

Ricin toxin A-chain (RTA) is expressed by the castor bean plant and is among the most potent mammalian toxins. Upon activation in the cytosol, RTA depurinates a single adenine from position 4324 of rat 28S ribosomal RNA, causing inactivation of ribosomes by preventing the binding of elongation factors. Kinetic isotope effect studies have established that RTA operates via a D(N)*A(N) mechanism involving an oxacarbenium ion intermediate with bound adenine [Chen, X.-Y., Berti, P. J., and Schramm, V. L. (2000) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122, 1609-1617]. On the basis of this information, stem-loop RNA molecules were chemically synthesized, incorporating structural features of the oxacarbenium ion-like transition state. A 10-base RNA stem-loop incorporating (1S)-1-(9-deazaadenin-9-yl)-1,4-dideoxy-1,4-imino-D-ribitol at the depurination site binds four times better (0.57 microM) than the 10-base RNA stem-loop with adenosine at the depurination site (2.2 microM). A 10-base RNA stem-loop with 1,2-dideoxyribitol [(2R,3S)-2-(hydroxymethyl)-3-hydroxytetrahydrofuran] at the depurination site binds with a Kd of 3.2 microM and tightens to 0.75 microM in the presence of 9-deazaadenine. A similar RNA stem-loop with 1,4-dideoxy-1,4-imino-D-ribitol at the depurination site binds with a K(d) of 1.3 microM and improves to 0.65 micro;M with 9-deazaadenine added. When (3S,4R)-4-hydroxy-3-(hydroxymethyl)pyrrolidine was incorporated at the depurination site of a 14-base RNA stem-loop, the Kd was 0.48 microM. Addition of 9-deazaadenine tightens the binding to 0.10 microM whereas added adenine increases the affinity to 12 nM. The results of this study are consistent with the unusual dissociative D(N)*A(N) mechanism determined for RTA. Knowledge of this intermediate has led to the design and synthesis of the highest affinity inhibitor reported for the catalytic site of RTA.     

Vinyldeoxyadenosine in a sarcin-ricin RNA loop and its binding to ricin toxin a-chain

8-Vinyl-2'-deoxyadenosine (8vdA) is a fluorophore with a quantum yield comparable to that of 2-aminopurine nucleoside. 8vdA was incorporated into a 10-mer stem-tetraloop RNA (8vdA-10) structure for characterization of the properties of the base, 8-vinyladenine (8-vA), with respect to adenine as a substrate or inhibitor for ribosome-inactivating proteins. Ricin toxin A-chain (RTA) and pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) catalyze the release of adenine from a specific adenosine on a stem-tetraloop (GAGA) sequence at the elongation factor (eEF2) binding site of the 28S subunit of eukaryotic ribosomes, thereby arresting translation. RTA does not catalyze the release of 8-vinyladenine from 8vdA-10. Molecular dynamics simulations implicate a role for Arg180 in oxacarbenium ion destabilization and the lack of catalysis. However, 8vdA-10 is an active site analogue and inhibits RTA with a Ki value of 2.4 microM. Adenine is also released from the second adenosine in the modified tetraloop, demonstrating an alternative mode for the binding of this motif in the RTA active site. The 8vdA analogue defines the specificities of RTA for the two adenylate depurination sites in a RNA substrate with a GAGA tetraloop. The rate of nonenzymatic acid-catalyzed solvolysis of 8-vinyladenine from the stem-loop RNA is described. Unlike RTA, PAP catalyzes the slow release of 8-vinyladenine from 8vdA-10. The isolation of 8-vA and its physicochemical characterization is described.     

Self-catalyzed site-specific depurination of G residues mediated by cruciform extrusion in closed circular DNA plasmids

A major variety of "spontaneous" genomic damage is endogenous generation of apurinic sites. Depurination rates vary widely across genomes, occurring with higher frequency at "depurination hot spots." Recently, we discovered a site-specific self-catalyzed depurinating activity in short (14-18 nucleotides) DNA stem-loop-forming sequences with a 5'-G(T/A)GG-3' loop and T·A or G·C as the first base pair at the base of the loop; the 5'-G residue of the loop self-depurinates at least 10(5)-fold faster than random "spontaneous" depurination at pH 5. Formation of the catalytic intermediate for self-depurination in double-stranded DNA requires a stem-loop to extrude as part of a cruciform. In this study, evidence is presented for self-catalyzed depurination mediated by cruciform formation in plasmid DNA in vitro. Cruciform extrusion was confirmed, and its extent was quantitated by digestion of the plasmid with single strand-specific mung bean endonuclease, followed by restriction digestion and sequencing of resulting mung bean-generated fragments. Appearance of the apurinic site in the self-depurinating stem-loop was confirmed by digestion of plasmid DNA with apurinic endonuclease IV, followed by primer extension and/or PCR amplification to detect the endonuclease-generated strand break and identify its location. Self-catalyzed depurination was contingent on the plasmid being supercoiled and was not observed in linearized plasmids, consistent with the presence of the extruded cruciform in the supercoiled plasmid and not in the linear one. These results indicate that self-catalyzed depurination is not unique to single-stranded DNA; rather, it can occur in stem-loop structures extruding from double-stranded DNA and therefore could, in principle, occur in vivo.     

In vitro selection of RNA molecules that inhibit the activity of ricin A-chain

The cytotoxin ricin disables translation by depurinating a conserved site in eukaryotic rRNA. In vitro selection has been used to generate RNA ligands (aptamers) specific for the catalytic ricin A-chain (RTA). The anti-RTA aptamers bear no resemblance to the normal RTA substrate, the sarcin-ricin loop (SRL), and were not depurinated by RTA. An initial 80-nucleotide RNA ligand was minimized to a 31-nucleotide aptamer that contained all sequences and structures necessary for interacting with RTA. This minimal RNA formed high affinity complexes with RTA (K(d) = 7.3 nM) which could compete directly with the SRL for binding to RTA. The aptamer inhibited RTA depurination of the SRL and could partially protect translation from RTA inhibition. The IC(50) of the aptamer for RTA in an in vitro translation assay is 100 nM, roughly 3 orders of magnitude lower than a small molecule inhibitor of ricin, pteroic acid, and 2 orders of magnitude lower than the best known RNA inhibitor. The novel anti-RTA aptamers may find application as diagnostic reagents for a potential biological warfare agent and hold promise as scaffolds for the development of strong ricin inhibitors.     

DNA aptamers selected against the HIV-1 trans-activation-responsive RNA element form RNA-DNA kissing complexes

In vitro selection was performed in a DNA library, made of oligonucleotides with a 30-nucleotide random sequence, to identify ligands of the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 trans-activation-responsive (TAR) RNA element. Aptamers, extracted after 15 rounds of selection-amplification, either from a classical library of sequences or from virtual combinatorial libraries, displayed an imperfect stem-loop structure and presented a consensus motif 5'ACTCCCAT in the apical loop. The six central bases of the consensus were complementary to the TAR apical region, giving rise to the formation of RNA-DNA kissing complexes, without disrupting the secondary structure of TAR. The RNA-DNA kissing complex was a poor substrate for Escherichia coli RNase H, likely due to steric and conformational constraints of the DNA/RNA heteroduplex. 2'-O-Methyl derivatives of a selected aptamer were binders of lower efficiency than the parent aptamer in contrast to regular sense/antisense hybrids, indicating that the RNA/DNA loop-loop region adopted a non-canonical heteroduplex structure. These results, which allowed the identification of a new type of complex, DNA-RNA kissing complex, demonstrate the interest of in vitro selection for identifying non-antisense oligonucleotide ligands of RNA structures that are of potential value for artificially modulating gene expression.     

High-resolution NMR study of a synthetic oligoribonucleotide with a tetranucleotide GAGA loop that is a substrate for the cytotoxic protein, ricin.

Ricin is a cytotoxic protein that inactivates ribosomes by hydrolyzing the N-glycosidic bond at position A4324 in eukaryotic 28S rRNA. Its substrate domain forms a double helical stem and a 17-base loop that includes the sequence GAGA, the second adenosine of which corresponds to A4324. Recently, studies of mutant RNAs have shown that the four-nucleotide loop, GAGA, can function as a substrate for ricin. To investigate the structure that is recognized by ricin, we studied the properties of a short synthetic substrate, the dodecaribonucleotide r-CUCAGAGAUGAG, which forms a RNA hairpin structure with a GABA loop and a stem of four base pairs. The results of NMR spectroscopy allowed us to construct the solution structure of this oligonucleotide by restrained molecular-dynamic calculations. We found that the stem region exists as an A-form duplex. 5G and 8A in the loop region form an unusual G:A base pair, and the phosphodiester backbone has a turn between 5G and 6A. This turn seems to help ricin to gain access to 6A which is the only site of depurination in the entire structure. The overall structure of the GAGA loop is similar to those of the GAAA and GCAA loops that have been described but that are not recognized by ricin. Therefore, in addition to the adenosine at the depurination site, the neighboring guanosine on the 3' side (7G) may also play a role in the recognition mechanism together with 5G and 8A.     

Detection of an abasic site in RNA with stem-loop DNA beacons: application to an activity assay for Ricin Toxin A-Chain

The catalytic ability of Ricin Toxin A-Chain (RTA) to create an abasic site in a 14-mer stem-tetraloop RNA is exploited for its detection. RTA catalyzes the hydrolysis of the N-glycosidic bond of a specific adenosine in the GAGA tetraloop of stem-loop RNA. Thus, a 14-mer stem-loop RNA substrate containing an intact “GAGA” sequence can be discriminated from the product containing an abasic “GabGA” sequence by hybridization with a 14-mer DNA stem-loop probe sequence and following the fluorescent response of the heteroduplexes. Three DNA beacon probe designs are described. Beacon 1 probe is a stem-loop structure and has a fluorophore and a quencher covalently linked to the 5′- and 3′-ends. In this format the probe–substrate heteroduplex gives a fluorescent signal while the probe–product one remains quenched. Beacon 2 is a modified version of 1 and incorporates a pyrene deoxynucleoside for recognition of the abasic site. In this format both the substrate and product heteroduplexes give a fluorescent response. Beacon 3 utilizes a design where the fluorophore is on the substrate RNA sequence at its 5′-end while the quencher is on the probe DNA sequence at its 3′-end. In this format the fluorescence of the substrate–probe heteroduplex is quenched while that of the product–probe one is enhanced. The lower limit of detection with beacons is 14 ng/mL of RTA.     

Ribosomal RNA identity elements for ricin A-chain recognition and catalysis. Analysis with tetraloop mutants.

Ricin is a cytotoxic protein that inactivates ribosomes by hydrolyzing the N-glycosidic bond between the base and the ribose of the adenosine at position 4324 in eukaryotic 28 S rRNA. Ricin A-chain will also catalyze depurination in naked prokaryotic 16 S rRNA; the adenosine is at position 1014 in a GAGA tetraloop. The rRNA identity elements for recognition by ricin A-chain and for the catalysis of cleavage were examined using synthetic GAGA tetraloop oligoribonucleotides. The RNA designated wild-type, an oligoribonucleotide (19-mer) that approximates the structure of the ricin-sensitive site in 16 S rRNA, and a number of mutants were transcribed in vitro from synthetic DNA templates with phage T7 RNA polymerase. With the wild-type tetraloop oligoribonucleotide the ricin A-chain-catalyzed reaction has a Km of 5.7 microM and a Kcat of 0.01 min-1. The toxin alpha-sarcin, which cleaves the phosphodiester bond on the 3' side of G4325 in 28 S rRNA, does not recognize the tetraloop RNA, although alpha-sarcin does affect a larger synthetic oligoribonucleotide that has a 17-nucleotide loop with a GAGA sequence; thus, there is a clear divergence in the identity elements for the two toxins. Mutants were constructed with all of the possible transitions and transversions of each nucleotide in the GAGA tetraloop; none was recognized by ricin A-chain. Thus, there is an absolute requirement for the integrity of the GAGA sequence in the tetraloop. The helical stem of the tetraloop oligoribonucleotide can be reduced to three base-pairs, indeed, to two base-pairs if the temperature is decreased, without affecting recognition; the nature of these base-pairs does not influence recognition or catalysis by ricin A-chain. If the tetraloop is opened so as to form a GAGA-containing hexaloop, recognition by ricin A-chain is lost. This suggests that during the elongation cycle, a GAGA tetraloop either exists or is formed in the putative 17-member single-stranded region of the ricin domain in 28 S rRNA and this bears on the mechanism of protein synthesis.     

Crystal structures of RNase H2 in complex with nucleic acid reveal the mechanism of RNA-DNA junction recognition and cleavage

Two classes of RNase H hydrolyze RNA of RNA/DNA hybrids. In contrast to RNase H1 that requires four ribonucleotides for cleavage, RNase H2 can nick duplex DNAs containing a single ribonucleotide, suggesting different in vivo substrates. We report here the crystal structures of a type 2 RNase H in complex with substrates containing a (5')RNA-DNA(3') junction. They revealed a unique mechanism of recognition and substrate-assisted cleavage. A conserved tyrosine residue distorts the nucleic acid at the junction, allowing the substrate to function in catalysis by participating in coordination of the active site metal ion. The biochemical and structural properties of RNase H2 explain the preference of the enzyme for junction substrates and establish the structural and mechanistic differences with RNase H1. Junction recognition is important for the removal of RNA embedded in DNA and may play an important role in DNA replication and repair.     

The structural and biochemical characterization of human RNase H2 complex reveals the molecular basis for substrate recognition and Aicardi-Goutières syndrome defects

RNase H2 cleaves RNA sequences that are part of RNA/DNA hybrids or that are incorporated into DNA, thus, preventing genomic instability and the accumulation of aberrant nucleic acid, which in humans induces Aicardi-Goutières syndrome, a severe autoimmune disorder. The 3.1 Å crystal structure of human RNase H2 presented here allowed us to map the positions of all 29 mutations found in Aicardi-Goutières syndrome patients, several of which were not visible in the previously reported mouse RNase H2. We propose the possible effects of these mutations on the protein stability and function. Bacterial and eukaryotic RNases H2 differ in composition and substrate specificity. Bacterial RNases H2 are monomeric proteins and homologs of the eukaryotic RNases H2 catalytic subunit, which in addition possesses two accessory proteins. The eukaryotic RNase H2 heterotrimeric complex recognizes RNA/DNA hybrids and (5′)RNA-DNA(3′)/DNA junction hybrids as substrates with similar efficiency, whereas bacterial RNases H2 are highly specialized in the recognition of the (5′)RNA-DNA(3′) junction and very poorly cleave RNA/DNA hybrids in the presence of Mg²⁺ ions. Using the crystal structure of the Thermotoga maritima RNase H2-substrate complex, we modeled the human RNase H2-substrate complex and verified the model by mutational analysis. Our model indicates that the difference in substrate preference stems from the different position of the crucial tyrosine residue involved in substrate binding and recognition.     

Inhibition of ricin A-chain with pyrrolidine mimics of the oxacarbenium ion transition state

Ricin A-chain (RTA) catalyzes the hydrolytic depurination of a specific adenosine at position 4324 of 28S rRNA. Kinetic isotope effects on the hydrolysis of a small 10mer stem-tetraloop oligonucleotide substrate established the mechanism of the reaction as D(N)*A(N), involving an oxacarbenium ion intermediate in a highly dissociative transition state. An inhibitor with a protonated 1,4-dideoxy-1,4-imino-D-ribitol moiety, a 4-azasugar mimic, at the depurination site in the tetraloop of a 14mer oligonucleotide with a 5 bp duplex stem structure had previously been shown to bind to RTA with a K(d) of 480 nM, which improved to 12 nM upon addition of adenine. Second-generation stem-tetraloop inhibitors have been synthesized that incorporate a methylene bridge between the nitrogen of a 1-azasugar mimic, namely, (3S,4R)-3-hydroxy-4-(hydroxymethyl)pyrrolidine, and substituents, including phenyl, 8-aza-9-deazaadenyl, and 9-deazaadenyl groups, that mimic the activated leaving group at the transition state. The values for the dissociation constants (K(i)) for these were 99 nM for the phenyl 10mer, 163 and 94 nM for the 8-aza-9-deazaadenyl 10- and 14mers, respectively, and 280 nM for the 9-deazaadenyl 14mer. All of these compounds are among the tightest binding molecules known for RTA. A related phenyl-substituted inhibitor with a deoxyguanosine on the 5'-side of the depurination site was also synthesized on the basis of stem-loop substrate specificity studies. This molecule binds with a K(i) of 26 nM and is the tightest binding "one-piece" inhibitor. 8-Aza-9-deaza- and 9-deazaadenyl substituents provide an increased pK(a) at N7, a protonation site en route to the transition state. The binding of these inhibitors is not improved relative to the binding of their phenyl counterpart, however, suggesting that RTA might also employ protonation at N1 and N3 of the adenine moiety to activate the substrate during catalysis. Studies with methylated adenines support this argument. That the various stem-loop inhibitors have similar potencies suggests that an optimal one-piece inhibitor remains to be identified. The second-generation inhibitors described here incorporate ribose mimics missing the 2-hydroxy group. On the basis of inhibition data and substrate specificity studies, the 2'-hydroxyl group at the depurination site seems to be critical for recruitment as well as catalysis by RTA.     

HIV-1 TAR as anchoring site for optimized catalytic RNAs

Ribozymes have a great potential for developing specific gene silencing molecules. One of the main limitations to ensure the efficient application of ribozymes is to achieve effective binding to the target. Stem-loop domains support efficient formation of the kissing complex between natural antisense molecules and their target sequence. We have characterized catalytic antisense RNA hybrid molecules composed of a hammerhead ribozyme and a stem-loop antisense domain. A series of artificial RNA substrates containing the TAR-RNA stem-loop and a target for the hammerhead ribozyme were constructed and challenged with a catalytic antisense RNA carrying the TAR complementary stem-loop. The catalytic antisense RNA cleaves each of these substrates significantly more efficiently than the parental hammerhead ribozyme. Deletion of the TAR domain in the substrate abolishes the positive effect. These results suggest that the enhancement is due to the interaction of both complementary stem-loop motifs. A similar improvement was corroborated when targeting the LTR region of HIV-1 with either hammerhead- and hairpin-based catalytic antisense RNAs. Our results indicate that the TAR domain can be used as an anchoring site to facilitate the access of ribozymes to their specific target sequences within TAR-containing RNAs. Finally, we propose the addition of stable stem-loop motifs to the ribozyme domain as a rational way for constructing catalytic antisense RNAs.     

RNA-DNA hybrids containing damaged DNA are substrates for RNase H

During the replication of the lagging strand, RNA-DNA hybrids are formed and the RNA is subsequently degraded by the action of RNase H. Little is known about the effects of damaged DNA on lagging strand replication and subsequent RNA removal. The rates and sites of digestion by E. coli RNase H of RNA-DNA hybrids containing either a thymine glycol or urea site in the DNA strand have been examined. The cleavage patterns for duplexes containing thymine glycol or urea differ from that of a fully complementary duplex. There is one major product of the digestion of the fully complementary hybrid, but three products are formed in the reactions with the hybrids containing damaged DNAs. Cleavage is partially redirected to the position adjacent to the damaged sites. The overall rate of cleavage of these hybrids containing damaged DNA is comparable to that of the fully complementary duplex. These results indicate that the cleavage of RNA-DNA hybrids by RNase H is less selective when a damaged site is present in the DNA strand.     

Non-specific deadenylation and deguanylation of naked RNA catalyzed by ricin under acidic condition.

Ricin A-chain catalyzes the hydrolysis of the N-glycosidic bond of a conserved adenosine residue at position 4324 in the sarcin/ricin domain of 28S RNA of rat ribosome. The GAGA tetraloop closed by C-G pairs is required for recognition of the cleavage site on 28S ribosomal RNA by ricin A-chain. In this study, ricin A-chain (reduced ricin) exhibits specific depurination on a synthetic oligoribonucleotide (named SRD RNA) mimic of the sarcin/ricin domain of rat 28S ribosomal RNA under neutral and weak acidic conditions. Furthermore, the activity of intact ricin is also similar to that of ricin A-chain. However, under more acidic conditions, both enzymes lose their site specificity. The alteration in specificity of depurination is not dependent on the GAGA tetraloop of SRD RNA. A higher concentration of KCl inhibits the non-specific N-glycosidase activity much more than the specific activity of ricin A-chain. In addition, characterization of depurination sites by RNA sequencing reveals that under acidic conditions ricin A-chain can release not only adenines, but also guanines from SRD RNA or 5S ribosomal RNA. This is the first report of the non-specific deadenylation and deguanylation activity of ricin A-chain to the naked RNA under acidic conditions.     

Bacillus subtilis RNAase III cleavage sites in phage SP82 early mRNA

We have determined the DNA sequence encoding three sites in Bacillus subtilis phage SP82 early mRNA that are cleaved by a B. subtilis processing endonuclease. The products generated by cleavage of the RNA were sequenced to determine the exact points of RNA strand scission. We propose that the RNA surrounding each processing site forms a stable stem-loop structure and that cleavage occurs at the 5- side of specific adenosine residues located on the loop. The model is consistent with our previous observations that the active site of the enzyme recognizes double-stranded RNA. S1 mapping experiments with RNA-DNA hybrids established that the same cleavage sites are used both in vivo and in vitro. Examination of the B. subtilis processing sites on SP82 mRNA reveals distinctive features of primary and secondary structure that are not present in any of the E. coli RNAase III processing sites previously studied.