Mediation of Herbicide Effects by Hormone Interactions

Chemical manipulation of the phytohormone system involves the use of herbicides for weed control in modern crop production. In the latter case, only compounds interacting with the auxin system have gained practical importance. Auxin herbicides mimic the overdose effects of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), the principal natural auxin in higher plants. With their ability to control, particularly, dicotyledonous weeds in cereal crops, the synthetic auxins have been among the most successful herbicides used in agriculture. A newly discovered sequential hormone interaction plays a decisive role in their mode of action. The induction of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase in ethylene biosynthesis is the primary target process, following auxin herbicide signalling. Although the exact molecular target site has yet to be identified, it appears likely to be at the level of auxin receptor(s) for perception or signalling, leading ultimately to species- and organ-specific de novo enzyme synthesis. In sensitive dicots, ethylene causes epinastic growth and tissue swelling. Ethylene also triggers the biosynthesis of abscisic acid (ABA), mainly through the stimulated cleavage of xanthophylls to xanthoxal, catalyzed by 9-cis-epoxycarotenoid dioxygenase (NCED). ABA mediates stomatal closure which limits photosynthetic activity and biomass production, accompanied by an overproduction of reactive oxygen species. Growth inhibition, senescence and tissue decay are the consequences. Recent results suggest that ethylene-triggered ABA is not restricted to the action of auxin herbicides. It may function as a module in the signalling of a variety of stimuli leading to plant growth regulation. An additional phenomenon is caused by the auxin herbicide quinclorac which also controls grass weeds. Here, quinclorac induces the accumulation of phytotoxic levels of cyanide, a co-product of ethylene, which ultimately derives from herbicide-induced ACC synthase activity in the tissue. Phytotropins are a further group of hormone-related compounds which are used as herbicides. They inhibit polar auxin transport by interacting with a regulatory protein, the NPA-binding protein, of the auxin efflux carrier. This causes an abnormal accumulation of IAA and applied synthetic auxins in plant meristems. Growth inhibition, loss of tropic responses and, in combination with auxin herbicides, synergistic effects are the consequences.     

Herbicidal activity of 4-chloroindoleacetic acid and other auxins on pea, barley and mustard

The natural auxins, 4-chloroindoleacetic acid and its methyl ester have strong herbicidal effects on pea, Pisum sativum , a plant in which they occur naturally. The standard herbicide, 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) is only 5 times more effective than 4-chloroindoleacetic acid. The I₅₀, the dose inhibiting yield by 50%, for 4-chloroindoleacetic acid and its methyl ester is 0.5 kg ha⁻¹ or 15 mg kg⁻¹ fresh weight, close to the concentration of 4-chloroindoleacetic acid methyl ester in maturing pea seeds. Naphthaleneacetic acid and indoleacetic acid are also inhibitory, but at much higher concentrations. In its inhibiting effect on white mustard, Sinapis alba , 4-chloroindoleacetic acid approximates that of 2,4-D, whereas in barley, Hordeum vulgare , it is a stronger herbicide than 2,4-D. All auxins tested killed white mustard at low doses, but none killed barley. Both 4-chloroindoleacetic acid and 2,4-D killed pea. The chloroindole auxins of pea may be the hypothetic death hormones or senescence factors that are secreted from the developing seeds into the parent plant which is strongly inhibited or killed and from which the nutrients are mobilized and translocated to the seeds. The action mechanism of auxin type herbicides may be to simulate the action of endogenous herbicides.     

Regulation of genes associated with auxin, ethylene and ABA pathways by 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid in Arabidopsis

The chemical 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) regulates plant growth and development and mimics auxins in exhibiting a biphasic mode of action. Although gene regulation in response to the natural auxin indole acetic acid (IAA) has been examined, the molecular mode of action of 2,4-D is poorly understood. Data from biochemical studies, (Grossmann (2000) Mode of action of auxin herbicides: a new ending to a long, drawn out story. Trends Plant Sci 5:506–508) proposed that at high concentrations, auxins and auxinic herbicides induced the plant hormones ethylene and abscisic acid (ABA), leading to inhibited plant growth and senescence. Further, in a recent gene expression study (Raghavan et al. (2005) Effect of herbicidal application of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid in Arabidopsis. Funct Integr Genomics 5:4–17), we have confirmed that at high concentrations, 2,4-D induced the expression of the gene NCED1, which encodes 9-cis-epoxycarotenoid dioxygenase, a key regulatory enzyme of ABA biosynthesis. To understand the concentration-dependent mode of action of 2,4-D, we further examined the regulation of whole genome of Arabidopsis in response to a range of 2,4-D concentrations from 0.001 to 1.0 mM, using the ATH1-121501 Arabidopsis whole genome microarray developed by Affymetrix. Results of this study indicated that 2,4-D induced the expression of auxin-response genes (IAA1, IAA13, IAA19) at both auxinic and herbicidal levels of application, whereas the TIR1 and ASK1 genes, which are associated with ubiquitin-mediated auxin signalling, were down-regulated in response to low concentrations of 2,4-D application. It was also observed that in response to low concentrations of 2,4-D, ethylene biosynthesis was induced, as suggested by the up-regulation of genes encoding 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase and ACC oxidase. Although genes involved in ethylene biosynthesis were not regulated in response to 0.1 and 1.0 mM 2,4-D, ethylene signalling was induced as indicated by the down-regulation of CTR1 and ERS, both of which play a key role in the ethylene signalling pathway. In response to 1.0 mM 2,4-D, both ABA biosynthesis and signalling were induced, in contrast to the response to lower concentrations of 2,4-D where ABA biosynthesis was suppressed. We present a comprehensive model indicating a molecular mode of action for 2,4-D in Arabidopsis and the effects of this growth regulator on the auxin, ethylene and abscisic acid pathways. Experiment station: Plant Biotechnology Centre, Primary Industries Research Victoria, Department of Primary Industries, La Trobe University, Bundoora, Victoria 3086, and the Victorian Microarray Technology Consortium (VMTC).     

Ethylene‐triggered abscisic acid: A principle in plant growth regulation?

The application of auxins to sensitive plant species or their overproduction in transgenic plants stimulates ethylene biosynthesis via induction of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase. Recent studies with auxin herbicides and indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) have revealed that auxin-stimulated ethylene triggers an increase in the biosynthesis of abscisic acid (ABA), which then functions as a second messenger, leading to growth inhibition and senescence. This raises the question of whether ethylene-triggered ABA is restricted to the action of auxin herbicides or whether it is a widespread phenomenon in the normal plant growth regulation. Our own results and a reappraisal of the literature indicate that ethylene-induced ABA may, indeed, play a role in natural physiological phenomena, such as root gravireaction and suppression of lateral bud growth in apical dominance. In addition, it would be worthwhile to investigate whether ethylene-triggered ABA is involved in other processes which coincide with a strong stimulation of ethylene biosynthesis, such as growth inhibition induced by cytokinins and senescence elicited under stress conditions.     

Evaluating the necessity of additional aquatic plant testing by comparing the sensitivities of different species

At present, at least three and up to five plant species are required to assess the potential risks of herbicides to non-target aquatic plants. Several regulatory authorities are considering whether there should be further requirements based on concerns about the possible selectivity of herbicides (e.g., specific modes of action against dicotyledonous plants). The relative sensitivity of a range of aquatic plants is assessed in our work in order to evaluate the implications of differences in species sensitivity for aquatic risk assessment of herbicides. We therefore present results from ecotoxicological tests performed at Syngenta Crop Protection AG on various aquatic plants and compare them to available studies and results in literature. The criterion used for sensitivity ranking is the EC50 (median effect concentration) value, which allows a better comparison of values from different testing methods and conditions. The overall results obtained in the present work show that the aquatic risk assessment procedure for herbicides based on Lemna sp. and algae is sufficiently protective while identifying potential toxicity to non-target plants. Only few exceptions concerning herbicides with selective modes of action (e.g., auxin simulators) may require additional species testing for proper risk assessment.     

Inhibition of auxin transport by isoquinolinedione herbicides

2-(p-carbethoxyphenyl)-1,3(2H,4H)-isoquinolinedione (CEPIQ), an experimental herbicide, caused effects on geotropism, which are often indicative of an effect on auxin transport, in a whole plant herbicidal screen. However, it showed little or no activity in an in vitro binding assay in corn coleoptiles for the auxin-transport inhibitor,N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA). Other active isoquinolinedione analogues of this compound did, however, exhibit significant in vitro activity. Direct measurements of auxin transport in corn coleoptiles were undertaken in an attempt to resolve the apparent discrepancy between herbicidal and binding activities. In all cases examined, compounds that were highly active on whole plants were good inhibitors of auxin transport, and compounds that were weak as herbicides showed little or no effect on auxin transport. Therefore, it is concluded that the mode of action of these isoquinolinedione herbicides is the inhibition of auxin transport. Ring-opened analogues of several isoquinolinediones were synthesized and assayed in both the transport and binding assays, in order to test whether compounds in this class express their herbicidal activity by undergoing ring-opening in vivo, yielding products that are more straightforward analogues of NPA with free carboxyl groups. The homophthalamic acids had little or no activity in both assays. On the other hand, thep-ethyl- andp-ethoxy-phenyl phthalamic acids showed auxin transport inhibition comparable to the parent isoquinolinediones, but with markedly increased binding activity. These results support the possible role of ring-opening in the generation of biological activity. However, thep-carbethoxyphenyl phthalamic acid, analogous to CEPIQ, was very weak in both assays. Thus, ring-opening in vivo cannot alone account for the biological activity of this class of compounds.     

Inhibition of auxin transport by isoquinolinedione herbicides

2-(p-carbethoxyphenyl)-1,3(2H,4H)-isoquinolinedione (CEPIQ), an experimental herbicide, caused effects on geotropism, which are often indicative of an effect on auxin transport, in a whole plant herbicidal screen. However, it showed little or no activity in an in vitro binding assay in corn coleoptiles for the auxin-transport inhibitor,N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA). Other active isoquinolinedione analogues of this compound did, however, exhibit significant in vitro activity. Direct measurements of auxin transport in corn coleoptiles were undertaken in an attempt to resolve the apparent discrepancy between herbicidal and binding activities. In all cases examined, compounds that were highly active on whole plants were good inhibitors of auxin transport, and compounds that were weak as herbicides showed little or no effect on auxin transport. Therefore, it is concluded that the mode of action of these isoquinolinedione herbicides is the inhibition of auxin transport. Ring-opened analogues of several isoquinolinediones were synthesized and assayed in both the transport and binding assays, in order to test whether compounds in this class express their herbicidal activity by undergoing ring-opening in vivo, yielding products that are more straightforward analogues of NPA with free carboxyl groups. The homophthalamic acids had little or no activity in both assays. On the other hand, thep-ethyl- andp-ethoxy-phenyl phthalamic acids showed auxin transport inhibition comparable to the parent isoquinolinediones, but with markedly increased binding activity. These results support the possible role of ring-opening in the generation of biological activity. However, thep-carbethoxyphenyl phthalamic acid, analogous to CEPIQ, was very weak in both assays. Thus, ring-opening in vivo cannot alone account for the biological activity of this class of compounds.     

Auxin herbicides induce H(2)O(2) overproduction and tissue damage in cleavers (Galium aparine L.)

The phytotoxic effects of auxin herbicides, including the quinoline carboxylic acids quinmerac and quinclorac, the benzoic acid dicamba and the pyridine carboxylic acid picloram, were studied in relation to changes in phytohormonal ethylene and abscisic acid (ABA) levels and the production of H(2)O(2) in cleavers (Galium aparine). When plants were root-treated with 10 microM quinmerac, ethylene synthesis was stimulated in the shoot tissue, accompanied by increases in immunoreactive levels of ABA and its precursor xanthoxal. It has been demonstrated that auxin herbicide-stimulated ethylene triggers ABA biosynthesis. The time-course and dose-response of ABA accumulation closely correlated with reductions in stomatal aperture and CO(2) assimilation and increased levels of hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2)), deoxyribonuclease (DNase) activity and chlorophyll loss. The latter parameters were used as sensitive indicators for the progression of tissue damage. On a shoot dry weight basis, DNase activity and H(2)O(2) levels increased up to 3-fold, relative to the control. Corresponding effects were obtained using auxin herbicides from the other chemical classes or when ABA was applied exogenously. It is hypothesized, that auxin herbicides stimulate H(2)O(2) generation which contributes to the induction of cell death in Galium leaves. This overproduction of H(2)O(2) could be triggered by the decline of photosynthetic activity, due to ABA-mediated stomatal closure.     

The hormonal regulation of axillary bud growth in Arabidopsis

Apically derived auxin has long been known to inhibit lateral bud growth, but since it appears not to enter the bud, it has been proposed that its inhibitory effect is mediated by a second messenger. Candidates include the plant hormones ethylene, cytokinin and abscisic acid. We have developed a new assay to study this phenomenon using the model plant Arabidopsis. The assay allows study of the effects of both apical and basal hormone applications on the growth of buds on excised nodal sections. We have shown that apical auxin can inhibit the growth of small buds, but larger buds were found to have lost competence to respond. We have used the assay with nodes from wild-type and hormone-signalling mutants to test the role of ethylene, cytokinin and abscisic acid in bud inhibition by apical auxin. Our data eliminate ethylene as a second messenger for auxin-mediated bud inhibition. Similarly, abscisic acid signalling is not to be required for auxin action, although basally applied abscisic can enhance inhibition by apical auxin and apically applied abscisic acid can reduce it. By contrast, basally applied cytokinin was found to release lateral buds from inhibition by apical auxin, while apically applied cytokinin dramatically increased the duration of inhibition. These results are consistent with cytokinin acting independently to regulate bud growth, rather than as a second messenger for auxin. However, in the absence of cytokinin-signalling mutants, a role for cytokinin as a second messenger for auxin cannot be ruled out.     

A role for IAA in the infection of Arabidopsis thaliana by Orobanche aegyptiaca

BACKGROUND: Vascular continuity is established between a host plant and the root parasite broomrape. It is generally accepted that the direction of vascular continuity results from polar flow of auxin. Our hypothesis was that chemical disruptions of auxin transport and activity could influence the infection of the host by the parasite. METHODS: A sterile system for the routine infection of Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings in Nunc cell culture plates by germinated seeds of Orobanche aegyptiaca was developed. This method permitted a quantitative assay of the rate of host infection. The three-dimensional structure of the vascular contacts was followed in cleared tissue. IAA (indole acetic acid) or substances that influence its activity and transport were applied locally to the host root. RESULTS: The orientation of the xylem contacts showed that broomrape grafts itself upon the host by acting hormonally as a root rather than a shoot. Local applications of IAA, PCIB (p-chlorophenoxyisobutyric acid) or NPA (naphthylphthalamic acid) all resulted in drastic reductions of Orobanche infection CONCLUSIONS: Broomrape manipulates the host by acting as a sink for auxin. Disruption of auxin action or auxin flow at the contact site could be a novel basis for controlling infection by Orobanche.     

Species differences in ligand specificity of auxin-controlled elongation and auxin transport: comparing Zea and Vigna

The plant hormone auxin affects cell elongation in both roots and shoots. In roots, the predominant action of auxin is to inhibit cell elongation while in shoots auxin, at normal physiological levels, stimulates elongation. The question of whether the primary receptor for auxin is the same in roots and shoots has not been resolved. In addition to its action on cell elongation in roots and shoots, auxin is transported in a polar fashion in both organs. Although auxin transport is well characterized in both roots and shoots, there is relatively little information on the connection, if any, between auxin transport and its action on elongation. In particular, it is not clear whether the protein mediating polar auxin movement is separate from the protein mediating auxin action on cell elongation or whether these two processes might be mediated by one and the same receptor. We examined the identity of the auxin growth receptor in roots and shoots by comparing the response of roots and shoots of the grass Zea mays L. and the legume Vigna mungo L. to indole-3-acetic acid, 2-naphthoxyacetic acid, 4,6-dichloroindoleacetic acid, and 4,7-dichloroindoleacetic acid. We also studied whether or not a single protein might mediate both auxin transport and auxin action by comparing the polar transport of indole-3-acetic acid and 2-naphthoxyacetic acid through segments from Vigna hypocotyls and maize coleoptiles. For all of the assays performed (root elongation, shoot elongation, and polar transport) the action and transport of the auxin derivatives was much greater in the dicots than in the grass species. The preservation of ligand specificity between roots and shoots and the parallels in ligand specificity between auxin transport and auxin action on growth are consistent with the hypothesis that the auxin receptor is the same in roots and shoots and that this protein may mediate auxin efflux as well as auxin action in both organ types.     

A role for cyanide, derived from ethylene biosynthesis, in the development of stress symptoms

Cyanide is formed as a co-product of ethylene during the oxidation of 1-aminocyclo-propane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) catalyzed by ACC oxidase. A toxic or regulatory function for cyanide in plant metabolism remains controversial. However, recent studies on the mode of action of auxin herbicides in sensitive plants suggest that the accumulation of tissue cyanide, derived ultimately from herbicide-stimulated ACC synthesis, is implicated in the induction of herbicide phytotoxicity. Furthermore, increases in cyanide levels have been observed during the formation of necrotic lesions in tobacco mosaic virus-infected tobacco leaves. It thus appears worthwhile to elucidate in more detail a possible role for cyanide in the induction of cell death under stress conditions which coincide with a strong stimulation of ethylene biosynthesis.     

Increases in jasmonic acid caused by indole-3-acetic acid and auxin herbicides in cleavers (Galium aparine)

The effects of indole-3-acetic acid and auxin herbicides on endogenous jasmonic acid (JA) concentrations were studied in relation to changes in ethylene and abscisic acid (ABA) levels in cleavers (Galium aparine). When plants were root-treated with increasing concentrations of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), ethylene biosynthesis was stimulated in response to the accumulation of endogenous IAA in the shoot tissue. Within 25h of treatment, stimulated ethylene formation was accompanied by increases in immunoreactive concentrations of JA and ABA, which reached maxima of 4.5-fold and 26-fold of the control, respectively, at 100 microM of applied IAA. Corresponding effects were obtained using synthetic auxins and when the ethylene-releasing compound ethephon was applied exogenously. This represents the first report, to our knowledge, of an auxin-mediated increase in JA levels. The increase in JA may be triggered by ethylene.     

Auxin action: the search for the receptor

Abstract. The molecular specificity of the substances which have auxin activity implies the existence of specific receptors. There have been many efforts to identify and isolate these receptors on the assumption that they should bind auxins with affinities coordinate to their activities in bioassays. However, the known complexity of auxin uptake and metabolism make this assumption seriously deficient. Although several such binding sites have, in fact, been identified, proof of a connection between these sites and auxin action has been lacking. Definite proof would include a requirement that the site be reconstituted, together with the appropriate macro-molecular machinery, to construct a model of an auxin response. At the moment, our ignorance of the biochemistry and molecular biology of auxin growth responses makes such a proof difficult. However, two avenues of research promise to accelerate the rate of progress. The increasingly potent tools of molecular biology should soon allow the dissection of auxin-regulated gene expression, while improved knowledge of plasma membrane proton pumps and the mechanism of cell wall biosynthesis should produce, in parallel, an understanding of the auxin regulation of acid growth.     

Specificity patterns indicate that auxin exporters and receptors are the same proteins

A study of transport and action of synthetic auxin analogues can help to identify transporters and receptors of this plant hormone. Both aspects--transportability and action on growth--were tested with 2-naphthoxyacetic acid (2-NOA) and compared across several plant species. 2-NOA stimulates elongation effectively at low concentrations in petioles of the gymnosperm Ginkgo biloba L., in hypocotyls or internodes of the dicot legumes, mung bean (Vigna mungo L.) and pea (Pisum sativum L.), in cotyledons of onion (Allium cepa L.) and in leaf bases of chive (Allium schoenoprasum L.), the latter two of the monocot order Asparagales. In contrast, elongation of coleoptile segments of maize (Zea mays L.) is poorly responsive to 2-NOA. Significant auxin-like transport of 2-NOA was observed in segments of mung bean hypocotyls, pea internodes, and chive leaf bases, but not in segments of the grass coleoptiles. Thus, for the two assays, elongation and polar transportability, the same difference in ligand specificity was observed between the grass and all other species assayed. This finding supports the hypothesis that a common protein mediates auxin efflux as well as auxin action on elongation.     

Auxin-resistant mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana with an altered morphology

Summary Mutant lines of Arabidopsis thaliana resistant to the artificial auxin 2,4-dichloro phenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) were isolated by screening for growth of seedlings in the presence of toxic levels of 2,4-D. Genetic analysis of these resistant lines indicated that 2,4-D resistance is due to a recessive mutation at a locus we have designated Axr-1. Mutant seedlings were resistant to approximately 50-fold higher concentrations of 2,4-D than wild-type and were also resistant to 8-fold higher concentrations of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) than wild-type. Labelling studies with (¹⁴C)2,4-D suggest that resistance was not due to changes in uptake or metabolism of 2,4-D. In addition to auxin resistance the mutants have a distinct morphological phenotype including alterations of the roots, leaves, and flowers. Genetic evidence indicates that both auxin resistance and the morphological changes are due to the same mutation. Because of the pleiotropic morphological effects of these mutations the Axr-1 gene may code for a function involved in auxin action in all tissues of the plant.     

Specifically deuterated and tritiated auxins

Regiospecific syntheses of monodeuterated and monotritiated natural auxin (indole- 3-acetic acid), a synthetic auxin (naphthalene-1-acetic acid) and a photoaffinity labeling auxin (5-azidoindole-3-acetic acid) are described. These syntheses provide benzene-ring tritiated auxins for use in reversible and covalent binding studies.