Limitation of usage of PicoGreen dye in quantitative assays of double-stranded DNA in the presence of intercalating compounds

PicoGreen is a very sensitive fluorescent dye for quantitative assays of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) in solution and is used in several analytical protocols in which sensitive and precise DNA detection is needed, also for examination of drug-DNA interactions. The data shown in this paper indicate that compounds intercalating to DNA influence the applicability of PicoGreen dye for quantitative measurements of dsDNA, and for this reason PicoGreen dye is not suitable for examination of drug-DNA interactions, especially interstrand DNA crosslinks.     

Comparison of three common DNA concentration measurement methods

Accurate measurement of DNA concentration is important for DNA-based biological applications. DNA concentration is usually determined by the ultraviolet (UV) absorption, fluorescence staining, and diphenylamine reaction methods. However, the best method for quality assurance of measurements is unknown. Here, we comprehensively compared these methods using different types of samples. We found that all three methods accurately determined the concentrations of high-purity DNA solutions. After digestion of DNA samples, concentration measurements revealed that the PicoGreen dye method was very sensitive to the degradation of DNA. The three methods displayed different anti-jamming ability when contaminants such as transfer RNA (tRNA), protein, and organic chemicals were included in DNA solutions. The diphenylamine reaction method gave the highest accuracy, with an average error of approximately 10% between measured and true values. The PicoGreen dye method was influenced by tRNA and protein, and the UV absorption method was susceptible to all kinds of impurities. Overall, the diphenylamine reaction method gave the most accurate results when DNA was mixed with contaminants, the PicoGreen dye method was most suitable for degraded DNA samples or DNA extracted from processed products, and the UV absorbance method was best for evaluating the impurities in DNA solutions.     

Characterization of PicoGreen interaction with dsDNA and the origin of its fluorescence enhancement upon binding

PicoGreen is a fluorescent probe that binds dsDNA and forms a highly luminescent complex when compared to the free dye in solution. This unique probe is widely used in DNA quantitation assays but has limited application in biophysical analysis of DNA and DNA-protein systems due to limited knowledge pertaining to its physical properties and characteristics of DNA binding. Here we have investigated PicoGreen binding to DNA to reveal the origin and mode of PicoGreen/DNA interactions, in particular the role of electrostatic and nonelectrostatic interactions in formation of the complex, as well as demonstrating minor groove binding specificity. Analysis of the fluorescence properties of free PicoGreen, the diffusion properties of PG/DNA complexes, and the excited-state lifetime changes upon DNA binding and change in solvent polarity, as well as the viscosity, reveal that quenching of PicoGreen in the free state results from its intramolecular dynamic fluctuations. On binding to DNA, intercalation and electrostatic interactions immobilize the dye molecule, resulting in a >1000-fold enhancement in its fluorescence. Based on the results of this study, a model of PicoGreen/DNA complex formation is proposed.     

Metal-enhanced PicoGreen fluorescence: Application for double-stranded DNA quantification

PicoGreen (PG) is a fluorescent probe for both double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) detection and quantification based on its ability to form a luminescent complex with dsDNA as compared with the free dye in solution. To expand the sensitivity of PG detection, we have studied the spectral properties of PG, both free and in complex with DNA in solution, when the fluorophore is in proximity to silver nanoparticles. We show that for a broad range of PG concentrations (20 pM-3.5 μM), it does not form dimers/oligomers and it exists in a monomeric state. On binding to DNA in the absence of silver, PG fluorescence increases approximately 1100-fold. Deposition of PG/DNA complex onto silver island films (SiFs) increases fluorescence approximately 7-fold due to the metal-enhanced fluorescence (MEF) effect, yielding fluorescence enhancement of 7700-fold as compared with the free dye on glass. In contrast to PG in complex with DNA, the free dye on SiFs demonstrates a decrease in brightness approximately 5-fold. Therefore, the total enhancement of PG on binding to DNA on silver reaches a value of approximately 38,000 as compared with free PG on SiFs. Consequently, the metal-enhanced detection of PG fluorescence is likely to find important utility for amplified dsDNA quantification.     

Assay for the quantification of intact/fragmented genomic DNA

This study shows that the accuracy of the quantification of genomic DNA by the commonly used Hoechst- and PicoGreen-based assays is drastically affected by its degree of fragmentation. Specifically, it was shown that these assays underestimate by 70% the concentration of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) with sizes less than 23 kb. On the other hand, DNA sizes greater and less than approximately 23 kb are commonly characterized as intact and fragmented genomic DNA, respectively, by the agarose electrophoresis DNA smearing assay and are evaluated only qualitatively by this assay. The need for accurate quantification of fragmented and total genomic DNA, combined with the lack of specific, reliable, and simple quantitative methods, prompted us to develop a Hoechst/PicoGreen-based fluorescent assay that quantifies both types of DNA. This assay addresses these problems, and in its Hoechst and PicoGreen version it accurately quantifies dsDNA as being either intact (>or=23 kb) or fragmented (<23 kb) in concentrations as low as 3 ng ml-1 or 5 pg ml-1 with Hoechst or PicoGreen, respectively, as well as the individual fractions of intact/fragmented DNA existing in any proportions in a total DNA sample in concentrations as low as 10 ng ml-1 or 15 pg ml-1 with Hoechst or PicoGreen, respectively. Because the assay discriminates total genomic DNA in the two size ranges (>or=23 and <23 kb) and quantitates them, it is proposed as the quantitative replacement of the agarose gel electrophoresis genomic DNA smearing assay.     

Effects of humic substances on fluorometric DNA quantification and DNA hybridization

DNA extracts from sediment and water samples are often contaminated with coextracted humic-like impurities. Estuarine humic substances and vascular plant extract were used to evaluate the effect of the presence of such impurities on DNA hybridization and quantification. The presence of humic substances and vascular plant extract interfered with the fluorometric measurement of DNA concentration using Hoechst dye H33258 and PicoGreen reagent. Quantification of DNA amended with humic substances (20-80 ng/microl) using the Hoechst dye assay was more reliable than with PicoGreen reagent. A simple procedure was developed to improve the accuracy for determining the DNA concentration in the presence of humic substances. In samples containing up to 80 ng/microl of humic acids, the fluorescence of the samples were measured twice: first without Hoechst dye to ascertain any fluorescence from impurities in the DNA sample, followed with Hoechst dye addition to obtain the total sample fluorescence. The fluorescence of the Hoechst dye-DNA complex was calculated by subtracting the fluorescence of the impurities from the fluorescence of the sample. Vascular plant extract and humic substances reduced the binding of DNA onto the nylon membrane. Low amounts (<2.0 microg) of humic substances derived from estuarine waters did not affect the binding of 100 ng of target DNA to nylon membranes. DNA samples containing 1.0 microg of humic substances performed well in DNA hybridizations with DIG-labeled oliogonucleotide and chromosomal probes. Therefore, we suggest that DNA samples containing low concentrations of humic substances (<20 ng/microl) could be used in quantitative membrane hybridization without further purification.     

Fluorescent cyanine dyes for the quantification of low amounts of dsDNA

In this research six cyanine fluorophores for the quantification of dsDNA in the pg-ng range, without amplification, are compared under exactly identical conditions: EvaGreen, SYBR Green, PicoGreen, AccuClear, AccuBlue NextGen and YOYO-1. The fluorescence intensity as a function of the amount of dsDNA is measured at the optimal wavelengths for excitation and emission and for each dye the limit of detection and the response linearity at low levels of dsDNA are determined. No linear range was found for SYBR Green and YOYO-1 for pg-ng quantities of dsDNA. EvaGreen, PicoGreen, AccuClear and AccuBlue NextGen show good linearity in the pg-ng range. AccuClear exhibits the widest linear range of 3 pg–200 ng, whereas AccuBlue NextGen turned out to have the highest sensitivity of the tested dyes with a limit of detection of 50 pg.     

Simple detection of point mutations in DNA oligonucleotides using SYBR Green I

A novel and simple method for detection of mutations in DNA oligonucleotides using a double-stranded DNA specific dye (SYBR Green I) is reported. The SYBR Green I is bound specifically with a duplex DNA oligonucleotide (intercalation). This intercalation induces fluorescent emission at 525 nm with excitation at 494 nm. The fluorescence intensity of mismatched oligonucleotides (40-mer) decreases (by more than 13%) in comparison with the perfectly matched oligonucleotides. Moreover, fluorescence measurement of the SYBR Green I can distinguish various types of single-base mismatches, except for the T-G terminal mismatch. The addition of 20% (v/v) formamide, however, to an oligonucleotide solution improved the sensitivity of detection and also enabled the detection of the T-G terminal-mismatch. This detection method requires only a normal fluorescence spectrophotometer, an inexpensive dye and just 50 pmol of sample DNA.     

A real-time DNase assay (ReDA) based on PicoGreen fluorescence

DNA nucleases (DNases) perform a wide variety of important cellular functions and are also very useful for research and in biotechnological applications. Due to the biological and technological importance of DNases and their use in a wide range of applications, DNase activity assays are essential. Traditional DNase assays employ radiolabeled DNA substrates and require separation of the products of the reaction from the unreacted substrate before quantification of enzyme activity. As a consequence, these methods are discontinuous. In this report, we describe a continuous DNase assay based on the differential fluorescence output of a DNA dye ligand called PicoGreen. The assay was developed to characterize a processive dsDNA exonuclease, lambda exonuclease. The assay appears to have general utility as it is also suitable for measuring the DNA digestion activities of a processive helicase/nuclease, RecBCD, a distributive exonuclease, T7 gene 6 exonuclease, and an endonuclease, DNaseI. The benefits of, and limitations to, the method are discussed.     

Fluorometric determination of deoxyribonuclease I activity with PicoGreen

A rapid and sensitive assay for the detection of deoxyribonuclease I (DNase I) activity is described. This method is based on the ability of PicoGreen dye to enhance its fluorescence when bound to double-stranded DNA. In the standard assay, reaction mixtures containing the DNase I sample and 0.2 microg of the substrate DNA were prepared in a fluorescence microtiter plate and incubated at 37 degrees C. At the end of the reaction, the diluted PicoGreen reagent was added to each well and fluorescence intensity was measured with a fluorescence plate reader. By this assay, it was possible to determine precisely as little as 5 pg of DNase I within an hour. Moreover, using a small amount of the substrate DNA, the method was shown to be suitable for the sensitive detection of DNase I inhibitor activity.     

Investigations on DNA intercalation and surface binding by SYBR Green I, its structure determination and methodological implications

The detection of double-stranded (ds) DNA by SYBR Green I (SG) is important in many molecular biology methods including gel electrophoresis, dsDNA quantification in solution and real-time PCR. Biophysical studies at defined dye/base pair ratios (dbprs) were used to determine the structure–property relationships that affect methods applying SG. These studies revealed the occurrence of intercalation, followed by surface binding at dbprs above ~0.15. Only the latter led to a significant increase in fluorescence. Studies with poly(dA) · poly(dT) and poly(dG) · poly(dC) homopolymers showed sequence-specific binding of SG. Also, salts had a marked impact on SG fluorescence. We also noted binding of SG to single-stranded (ss) DNA, although SG/ssDNA fluorescence was at least ~11-fold lower than with dsDNA. To perform these studies, we determined the structure of SG by mass spectrometry and NMR analysis to be [2-[N-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)-N-propylamino]-4-[2,3-dihydro-3-methyl-(benzo-1,3-thiazol-2-yl)-methylidene]-1-phenyl-quinolinium]. For comparison, the structure of PicoGreen (PG) was also determined and is [2-[N-bis-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)-amino]-4-[2,3-dihydro-3-methyl-(benzo-1,3-thiazol-2-yl)-methylidene]-1-phenyl-quinolinium]⁺. These structure–property relationships help in the design of methods that use SG, in particular dsDNA quantification in solution and real-time PCR.     

High-sensitivity two-color detection of double-stranded DNA with a confocal fluorescence gel scanner using ethidium homodimer and thiazole orange.

Ethidium homodimer (EthD; lambda Fmax 620 nm) at EthD:DNA ratios up to 1 dye:4-5 bp forms stable fluorescent complexes with double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) which can be detected with high sensitivity using a confocal fluorescence gel scanner (Glazer, A.N., Peck, K. & Mathies, R.A. (1990) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 87, 3851-3855). However, on incubation with unlabeled DNA partial migration of EthD takes place from its complex with dsDNA to the unlabeled DNA. It is shown here that this migration is dependent on the fractional occupancy of intercalating sites in the original dsDNA-EthD complex and that there is no detectable transfer from dsDNA-EthD complexes formed at 50 bp: 1 dye. The monointercalator thiazole orange (TO; lambda Fmax 530 nm) forms readily dissociable complexes with dsDNA with a large fluorescence enhancement on binding (Lee, L.G., Chen, C. & Liu, L.A. (1986) Cytometry 7, 508-517). However, a large molar excess of TO does not displace EthD from its complex with dsDNA. When TO and EthD are bound to the same dsDNA molecule, excitation of TO leads to efficient energy transfer from TO to EthD. This observation shows the practicability of 'sensitizing' EthD fluorescence with a second intercalating dye having a very high absorption coefficient and efficient energy transfer characteristics. Electrophoresis on agarose gels, with TO in the buffer, of preformed linearized M13mp18 DNA-EthD complex together with unlabeled linearized pBR322 permits sensitive fluorescence detection in the same lane of pBR322 DNA-TO complex at 530 nm and of M13mp18 DNA-EthD complex at 620 nm. These observations lay the groundwork for the use of stable DNA-dye intercalation complexes carrying hundreds of chromophores in two-color applications such as the physical mapping of chromosomes.     

Oriented and vectorial immobilization of linear M13 dsDNA between interdigitated electrodes--towards single molecule DNA nanostructures

The ability to control molecules at a resolution well below that offered by photolithography has gained much interest recently. DNA is a promising candidate for this task since it offers excellent specificity in base-pairing combined with addressability at the nanometer scale. New applications in biosensing, e.g. interaction analysis at the single molecule level, or nanobiotechnology, e.g. ultradense DNA microarrays, have been devised that rely on stretched DNA bridges. The basic technology required is the ability to deposit spatially defined, stretched DNA-bridges between anchoring structures on surfaces. In this paper we present two techniques for spanning 2 microm long dsDNA bridges between neighboring interdigitated electrodes (IDEs). The extended DNA used was linearized M13 dsDNA (M13mp18 7231 bp, ca. 2.5 microm length), either unmodified, or with chemical modifications at both ends. The first approach is based on the dielectrophoretic (DEP) concentration and alignment of linearized wild-type dsDNA. IDEs with 1.7 microm spacing are driven with an AC voltage around 1 MHz leading to field strengths in the order of 1 MV m(-1). The dsDNA is polarized and linearized by the force field and accumulates in the gap between two neighboring electrodes. This process is reversible and was visualized by fluorescence staining of M13 DNA using PicoGreen, as intercalating dye. The resulting dsDNA bridges and their orientation are discernible under the fluorescence microscope using fluorescent particles of different color. The particles are tagged with sequence specific peptide nucleic acid (PNA) probes that bind to the DNA double strand at specific sites. The second approach is based on asymmetric electrochemical modification of a gold IDE with 2.0 microm spacings followed by spontaneous or stimulated deposition of a chemically modified M13-DNA. One side of the IDE was selectively coated with streptavidin by electropolymerization of a novel hydrophilic conductive polymer in the presence of the binding protein. The second side was modified with gold nanoparticles by reductive plating from aqueous gold chloride solution. An asymmetric double stranded (ds) M13 DNA carrying a 5'-thiol group at one end and a 5'-biotin at the other end was obtained by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using two differently labeled primers. For DNA bridges to form spontaneously the modified IDE was incubated over night with a 50 nM solution of the modified M13 DNA. Potential applications of DNA-bridge formation in biosensing and biotechnology are discussed.     

Interaction of dimeric intercalating dyes with single-stranded DNA.

The unsymmetrical cyanine dye thiazole orange homodimer (TOTO) binds to single-stranded DNA (ssDNA, M13mp18 ssDNA) to form a fluorescent complex that is stable under the standard conditions of electrophoresis. The stability of this complex is indistinguishable from that of the corresponding complex of TOTO with double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). To examine if TOTO exhibits any binding preference for dsDNA or ssDNA, transfer of TOTO from pre-labeled complexes to excess unlabeled DNA was assayed by gel electrophoresis. Transfer of TOTO from M13 ssDNA to unlabeled dsDNA proceeds to the same extent as that from M13 dsDNA to unlabeled dsDNA. A substantial amount of the dye is retained by both the M13 ssDNA and M13 dsDNA even when the competing dsDNA is present at a 600-fold weight excess; for both dsDNA and ssDNA, the pre-labeled complex retains approximately one TOTO per 30 bp (dsDNA) or bases (ssDNA). Rapid transfer of dye from both dsDNA and ssDNA complexes is seen at Na+ concentrations > 50 mM. Interestingly, at higher Na+ or Mg2+ concentrations, the M13 ssDNA-TOTO complex appears to be more stable to intrinsic dissociation (dissociation in the absence of competing DNA) than the complex between TOTO and M13 dsDNA. Similar results were obtained with the structurally unrelated dye ethidium homodimer. The dsDNA- and ssDNA-TOTO complexes were further examined by absorption, fluorescence and circular dichroism spectroscopy. The surprising conclusion is that polycationic dyes, such as TOTO and EthD, capable of bis-intercalation, interact with dsDNA and ssDNA with very similar high affinity.     

Quantitation of supercoiled circular content in plasmid DNA solutions using a fluorescence-based method

A method for quantifying the proportion of supercoiled circular (SC) forms in DNA solutions is described. The method (SCFluo) takes advantage of the reversible denaturation property of SC forms and the high specificity of the PicoGreen fluorochrome for double-stranded (ds)DNA. Fluorescence values of forms capable of reversible denaturation after a 5 min heating, 2 min cooling step are normalised to fluorescence values of total dsDNA present in the preparation. For samples with a SC content >20–30%, good regression fits were obtained when values derived from densitometric scanning of an agarose gel and those derived from the SCFluo method were compared. The method represents an attractive alternative to currently established methods because it is simple, rapid and quantitative. During large-scale processing and long-term storage, enzymatic, chemical and shear degradation may substantially decrease the SC content of plasmid DNA preparations. Regulations for pharmaceutical grade products for use in gene therapy and DNA vaccination may require >90% of the plasmid to be in the SC form. In the present study the SC content of 6.9, 13 and 20 kb plasmid preparations that had been subjected to chemical and shear degradation was successfully quantified using the new method.     

DNA length evaluation using cyanine dye and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

To develop a high-performance method for measuring the length of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) fragments, the capability of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) was examined. To omit troublesome and time-consuming labeling operations such as PCR with fluorescently labeled mononucleotides or primers, intercalation of dimeric cyanine dye YOYO-1 iodide (YOYO) to dsDNA was utilized as a simple labeling method. Various lengths of dsDNA fragments were prepared and mixed with YOYO prior to FCS, and the dependence of the diffusion time of a dsDNA-YOYO complex on the length of dsDNA fragment and the dsDNA/YOYO ratio was investigated. It was successfully demonstrated that the dsDNA length can be measured using YOYO and FCS, and the calibration curve was developed taking into account the rewinding and expansion of the dsDNA fragment caused by YOYO intercalation.     

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) using ssDNA binding fluorescent dye

There is a need for simple and inexpensive methods for genotyping single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and short insertion/deletion variations (InDels). In this work, I demonstrate that a single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding dye can be used as a donor fluorophore for fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). The method presented is a homogenous assay in which detection is based on the FRET from the fluorescence of the ssDNA dye bound to the unmodified detection primer to the fluorescent nucleotide analog incorporated into this detection primer during cyclic template directed primer extension reaction. Collection of the FRET emission spectrum with a scanning fluorescence spectrophotometer allows powerful data analysis. The fluorescence emission signal is modified by the optical properties of the assay vessel. This seems to be a completely neglected parameter. By proper selection of the optical properties of the assay plate one can improve the detection of the fluorescence emission signal.     

Heterodimeric DNA-binding dyes designed for energy transfer: synthesis and spectroscopic properties.

Heterodimeric dyes are described which bind tightly to double-stranded (dsDNA) with large fluorescence enhancements. These dyes are designed to exploit energy transfer between donor and acceptor chromophores to tune the separation between excitation and emission wavelengths. The dyes described here absorb strongly at the 488 nm argon ion line, but emit at different wavelengths, and can be applied to multiplex detection of various targets. The chromophores in these dyes, a thiazole orange-thiazole blue heterodimer (TOTAB), two different thiazole orange-ethidium heterodimers (TOED1 and TOED2), and a fluorescein-ethidium heterodimer (FED), are in each case linked through polymethyleneamine linkers. The emission maxima of the DNA-bound dyes lie at 662 (TOTAB), 614 (TOED 2), and 610 nm (FED). The dyes showed a > 100 fold enhancement of the acceptor chromophore fluorescence on binding to dsDNA and no sequence selectivity. In comparison with direct 488 nm excitation of the constituent monomeric dyes, in the heterodimers the fluorescence of the acceptor chromophores was greatly enhanced and the emission of the donor chromophores quenched by over 90%. The acceptor emission per DNA-bound dye molecule was constant from 100 DNA bp:dye to 20 bp:dye and decreased sharply at higher dye:DNA ratios.     

基于SYBR Green I的双链DNA定量方法

摘要 基于SYBR Green I荧光染料与双链DNA（dsDNA）结合产生荧光的原理,建立一种高精度、高通量的双链DNA 定量方法。将梯度稀释后的基因组DNA及已知浓度的?DNA与等体积的SYBR Green I（4×）充分混合后,利用荧光定量PCR仪采集荧光信号,以ROX（1×）作为校正染料进行定量分析;同时利用紫外分光光度计对样品进行平行测定,比较该方法与紫外分光光度法的检测限与准确度。紫外分光光度法的检测限为2 ng/?l,而SYBR Green I荧光定量法的检测限可达到0.015 ng/?l,并且在0.015~2 ng/?l范围内,SYBR Green I荧光强度与?DNA浓度呈线性关系（R2=0.9999）,比紫外分光光度法灵敏100倍以上,并可准确定量低纯度的DNA样品。此方法具有重复性好、高通量的特点,仅需少量的生物样本即可满足定量要求,为分子生物学研究及临床检验等多个领域提供了一种可靠的dsDNA定量方法。     

Visualizing Single-molecule DNA Replication with Fluorescence Microscopy

We describe a simple fluorescence microscopy-based real-time method for observing DNA replication at the single-molecule level. A circular, forked DNA template is attached to a functionalized glass coverslip and replicated extensively after introduction of replication proteins and nucleotides (Figure 1). The growing product double-strand DNA (dsDNA) is extended with laminar flow and visualized by using an intercalating dye. Measuring the position of the growing DNA end in real time allows precise determination of replication rate (Figure 2). Furthermore, the length of completed DNA products reports on the processivity of replication. This experiment can be performed very easily and rapidly and requires only a fluorescence microscope with a reasonably sensitive camera.