Evaluation of new affinity chromatography resins for polyclonal,oligoclonal and monoclonal antibody pharmaceuticals

The performance of MabSelect SuRe and IgSelect affinity chromatography resins designed for process-scale purification of antibodies was investigated. Various antibodies (4 human monoclonal, 1 human polyclonal and 1 bovine polyclonal antibody and 1 Fc-fusion protein) were used to evaluate the elution pH and dynamic binding capacity of the resins. The elution pH for each human antibody was similar on MabSelect SuRe and IgSelect (pH 3.5–3.8). No significant differences in dynamic binding capacity were observed among human antibodies on MabSelect SuRe (∼20–40 mg/mL resin) and IgSelect (∼10–30 mg/mL resin). The binding capacity order for the human antibodies was the same on MabSelect SuRe and IgSelect. Using a linear pH gradient, both resins were able to partially separate monomeric and aggregated forms of the antibodies. The results indicate that these new affinity resins are powerful tools for the purification of human polyclonal antibodies from transgenic animals and oligoclonal antibodies from CHO cell cultures.     

Optimization of a calcium-dependent Protein A-derived domain for mild antibody purification

ABSTRACT

As reported here, we developed and optimized a purification matrix based on a Protein A-derived domain, Z_Ca, displaying calcium-dependent antibody binding. It provides an alternative to the acidic elution conditions of conventional Protein A affinity chromatography for purification of sensitive antibodies and other Fc-based molecules. We describe the multimerization of Z_Ca to generate a chromatography resin with higher binding capacity. The highest order multimeric variant, Z_CaTetraCys, demonstrated a considerably high dynamic binding capacity (35 mg IgG/ml resin) while preserving the specificity for IgG. High recovery was obtained and host cell protein and DNA content in purified fractions proved to be comparable to commercial MabSelect SuRe and MabSelect PrismA. Various elution conditions for use of this domain in antibody purification were investigated. The purification data presented here revealed variations in the interaction of different subclasses of human IgG with Z_CaTetraCys. This resulted in diverse elution properties for the different IgGs, where complete elution of all captured antibody for IgG2 and IgG4 was possible at neutral pH. This optimized protein ligand and the proposed purification method offer a unique strategy for effective and mild purification of antibodies and Fc-fusion proteins that cannot be purified under conventional acidic elution conditions due to aggregation formation or loss of function.     

Antibody Binding Heterogeneity of Protein A Resins

Protein A affinity chromatography is a core unit operation in antibody manufacturing. Nevertheless, there is not enough understanding of in‐column antibody adsorption in the Protein A capture step. This work aims to investigate in situ the establishment of an antibody (trastuzumab) layer during Protein A chromatography both in terms of energetic contributions and uptake kinetics. Flow microcalorimetry is employed as a technique with an in situ operating detector, which provides an understanding of the thermodynamics of the adsorption process. In addition, the antibody uptake rate is also investigated in order to establish a correlation between its diffusion on the stationary phase and the associated thermodynamics. Two resins with different particle size, intraparticle porosity, and a Protein A ligand structure are studied: the synthetically engineered B‐domain tetrameric MabSelect SuRe and the synthetically engineered C‐domain hexameric TOYOPEARL AF‐rProtein A HC. The uptake rate follows a pore diffusion model at low equilibrium time, showing a slower diffusivity after a certain time because of the heterogeneous binding nature of these two resins. In addition, the microcalorimetric studies show that adsorption enthalpy is highly favourable at low isotherm concentrations and evolves toward an equilibrium with increasing surface concentration. These data suggest that the relationship between adsorption enthalpy and the establishment of the antibody layer in the Protein A chain is consistent with heterogeneous adsorption.     

Maximizing the functional lifetime of Protein A resins

Protein A chromatography is currently the industry gold‐standard for monoclonal antibody and Fc‐fusion protein purification. The high cost of Protein A, however, makes resin lifetime and resin reuse an important factor for process economics. Typical resin lifetime studies performed in the industry usually examine the effect of resin re‐use on binding capacity, yield, and product quality without answering the fundamental question of what is causing the decrease in performance. A two part mechanistic study was conducted in an attempt to decouple the effect of the two possible factors (resin hydrolysis and/or degradation vs. resin fouling) on column performance over lifetime of the most commonly used alkali‐stable Protein A resins (MabSelect SuRe and MabSelect SuRe LX). The change in binding capacity as a function of sodium hydroxide concentration (rate of hydrolysis), temperature, and stabilizing additives was examined. Additionally, resin extraction studies and product cycling studies were conducted to determine cleaning effectiveness (resin fouling) of various cleaning strategies. Sodium hydroxide‐based cleaning solutions were shown to be more effective at preventing resin fouling. Conversely, cold temperature and the use of stabilizing additives in conjunction with sodium hydroxide were found to be beneficial in minimizing the rate of Protein A ligand hydrolysis. An effective and robust cleaning strategy is presented here to maximize resin lifetime and thereby the number of column cycles for future manufacturing processes. © 2017 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 33:708–715, 2017     

Single-chain Fv with Fc fragment of the human IgG1 tag: construction, Pichia pastoris expression and antigen binding characterization

We report two expression vectors in Pichia pastoris that direct the synthesis of recombinant single chain antibody variable region (scFv), derived from anti-Z-DNA monoclonal antibody Z22. The first vector codes for a scFv fused to the Ig binding domain of staphylococcal Protein A. The second vector codes for the scFv fused to the Fc fragment of the human IgG1. The fusion partner simplified the detection and purification of the secreted protein. These constructs yielded high level expression of an scFv with specific binding activity toward a Z form of DNA, with binding activity comparable to that of the scFv molecule produced in an Escherichia coli expression system and the original monoclonal antibody.     

PDBx/mmCIF Ecosystem: Foundational Semantic Tools for Structural Biology

PDBx/mmCIF, Protein Data Bank Exchange (PDBx) macromolecular Crystallographic Information Framework (mmCIF), has become the data standard for structural biology. With its early roots in the domain of small-molecule crystallography, PDBx/mmCIF provides an extensible data representation that is used for deposition, archiving, remediation, and public dissemination of experimentally determined three-dimensional (3D) structures of biological macromolecules by the Worldwide Protein Data Bank (wwPDB, wwpdb.org). Extensions of PDBx/mmCIF are similarly used for computed structure models by ModelArchive (modelarchive.org), integrative/hybrid structures by PDB-Dev (pdb-dev.wwpdb.org), small angle scattering data by Small Angle Scattering Biological Data Bank SASBDB (sasbdb.org), and for models computed generated with the AlphaFold 2.0 deep learning software suite (alphafold.ebi.ac.uk). Community-driven development of PDBx/mmCIF spans three decades, involving contributions from researchers, software and methods developers in structural sciences, data repository providers, scientific publishers, and professional societies. Having a semantically rich and extensible data framework for representing a wide range of structural biology experimental and computational results, combined with expertly curated 3D biostructure data sets in public repositories, accelerates the pace of scientific discovery. Herein, we describe the architecture of the PDBx/mmCIF data standard, tools used to maintain representations of the data standard, governance, and processes by which data content standards are extended, plus community tools/software libraries available for processing and checking the integrity of PDBx/mmCIF data. Use cases exemplify how the members of the Worldwide Protein Data Bank have used PDBx/mmCIF as the foundation for its pipeline for delivering Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable (FAIR) data to many millions of users worldwide.     

Structure of a functional IGF2R fragment determined from the anomalous scattering of sulfur

Insulin-like growth factor II receptor (IGF2R) is a multifunctional cell surface receptor implicated in tumour suppression. Its growth inhibitory activity has been associated with an ability to bind IGF-II. IGF2R contains 15 homologous extracellular domains, with domain 11 primarily responsible for IGF-II binding. We report a 1.4 A resolution crystal structure of domain 11, solved using the anomalous scattering signal of sulfur. The structure consists of two crossed beta-sheets forming a flattened beta-barrel. Structural analysis identifies the putative IGF-II binding site at one end of the beta-barrel whilst crystal lattice contacts suggest a model for the full-length IGF2R extracellular region. The structure factors and coordinates of IGF2R domain 11 have been deposited in the Protein Data Bank (accession codes 1GP0 and 1GP3).     

Automated high throughput microscale antibody purification workflows for accelerating antibody discovery

To rapidly find “best-in-class” antibody therapeutics, it has become essential to develop high throughput (HTP) processes that allow rapid assessment of antibodies for functional and molecular properties. Consequently, it is critical to have access to sufficient amounts of high quality antibody, to carry out accurate and quantitative characterization. We have developed automated workflows using liquid handling systems to conduct affinity-based purification either in batch or tip column mode. Here, we demonstrate the capability to purify >2000 antibodies per day from microscale (1 mL) cultures. Our optimized, automated process for human IgG1 purification using MabSelect SuRe resin achieves ～70% recovery over a wide range of antibody loads, up to 500 µg. This HTP process works well for hybridoma-derived antibodies that can be purified by MabSelect SuRe resin. For rat IgG2a, which is often encountered in hybridoma cultures and is challenging to purify via an HTP process, we established automated purification with GammaBind Plus resin. Using these HTP purification processes, we can efficiently recover sufficient amounts of antibodies from mammalian transient or hybridoma cultures with quality comparable to conventional column purification.     

A small bispecific protein selected for orthogonal affinity purification

A novel protein domain with dual affinity has been created by randomization and selection. The small alkali-stabilized albumin-binding domain (ABD*), used as scaffold to construct the library, has affinity to human serum albumin (HSA) and is constituted of 46 amino acids of which 11 were randomized. To achieve a dual binder, the binding site of the inherent HSA affinity was untouched and the randomization was made on the opposite side of the molecule. Despite its small size and randomization of almost a quarter of its amino acids, a bifunctional molecule, ABDz1, with ability to bind to both HSA and the Z2 domain/protein A was successfully selected using phage display. Moreover, the newly selected variant showed improved affinity for HSA compared to the parental molecule. This novel protein domain has been characterized regarding secondary structure and affinity to the two different ligands. The possibility for affinity purification on two different matrices has been investigated using the two ligands, the HSA matrix and the protein A-based, MabSelect SuRe matrix, and the new protein domain was purified to homogeneity. Furthermore, gene fusions between the new domain and three different target proteins with different characteristics were made. To take advantage of both affinities, a purification strategy referred to as orthogonal affinity purification using two different matrices was created. Successful purification of all three versions was efficiently carried out using this strategy.     

Structure and activity of exo-1,3/1,4-β-glucanase from marine bacterium Pseudoalteromonas sp. BB1 showing a novel C-terminal domain

Following the discovery of an exo-1,3/1,4-β-glucanase (glycoside hydrolase family 3) from a seaweed-associated bacterium Pseudoalteromonas sp. BB1, the recombinant three-domain protein (ExoP) was crystallized and its structure solved to 2.3 ? resolution. The first two domains of ExoP, both of which contribute to the architecture of the active site, are similar to those of the two-domain barley homologue β-d-glucan exohydrolase (ExoI) with a distinctive Trp-Trp clamp at the +1 subsite, although ExoI displays broader specificity towards β-glycosidic linkages. Notably, excision of the third domain of ExoP results in an inactive enzyme. Domain 3 has a β-sandwich structure and was shown by CD to be more temperature stable than the native enzyme. It makes relatively few contacts to domain 1 and none at all to domain 2. Two of the domain 3 residues involved at the interface, Q683 (forming one hydrogen bond) and Q676 (forming two hydrogen bonds) were mutated to alanine. Variant Q676A retained about half the activity of native ExoP, but the Q683A variant was severely attenuated. The crystal structure of Q683A-ExoP indicated that domain 3 was highly mobile and that Q683 is critical to the stabilization of ExoP by domain 3. Small-angle X-ray scattering data lent support to this proposal. Domain 3 does not appear to be an obvious carbohydrate-binding domain and is related neither in sequence nor structure to the additional domains characterized in other glycoside hydrolase 3 subgroups. Its major role appears to be for protein stability but it may also help orient substrate. DATABASE: Structural data are available in the Protein Data Bank under the accession numbers 3UT0, 3USZ, 3F95 and 3RRX.     

A tool for increasing the lifetime of chromatography resins

There is a steadily increasing demand for speed, cost efficiency and process understanding within biopharmaceutical process development. To match this, a high-throughput method for screening of cleaning-in-place (CIP) conditions for chromatography resins has been developed. The methodology includes fouling of MabSelect SuRe chromatography resin in 96-well filter plates, cleaning of the fouled resin by incubation in different CIP agents, and finally, analysis of the residual impurities on the resin after cleaning. This article describes the improvements that transformed the method from low throughput and significant manual interference to a totally automated method with high throughput and good reproducibility.Key words: bioprocess, cleaning-in-place, chromatography, high-throughput, monoclonal antibody, process development, protein A, screening     

Synthesis and characterization of CN-modified protein analogues as potential vibrational contrast agents

A recombinant VH single-domain antibody recognizing staphylococcal protein A was functionalized on reactive lysine residues with N-hydroxysuccimidyl-activated 4-cyanobenzoate. Surface plasmon resonance analysis of antibody-antigen binding revealed that modified and unmodified antibodies bound protein A with similar affinities. Raman imaging of the modified antibodies indicated that the benzonitrile group provides vibrational contrast enhancement in a region of the electromagnetic spectrum that is transparent to cellular materials. Thus, the modified single-domain antibody may be amenable to detecting protein A from samples of the human pathogen Staphylococcus aureus using vibronic detection schemes such as Raman and coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering. The generality of this labeling strategy should make it applicable to modifying an array of proteins with varied structure and function.     

Engineered high-affinity nanobodies recognizing staphylococcal Protein A and suitable for native isolation of protein complexes

In addition to its high affinity for antibody Fc domains, staphylococcal Protein A has been shown to bind certain Fab domains. We investigated this in order to develop a small, recombinant Protein A-binding alternative to immunoglobulin G (IgG) from nanobodies, single-domain antibodies derived from a camelid variant IgG’s variable region. We engineered a nanobody with affinity solely for Protein A as well as a dimerized version of higher affinity for typical multidomain Protein A constructs. Because this recombinant nanobody can be immobilized using a cleavable crosslinker, it has proven to be suitable for the isolation and mild elution of protein complexes in native conditions.     

InSite: a computational method for identifying protein-protein interaction binding sites on a proteome-wide scale

We propose InSite, a computational method that integrates high-throughput protein and sequence data to infer the specific binding regions of interacting protein pairs. We compared our predictions with binding sites in Protein Data Bank and found significantly more binding events occur at sites we predicted. Several regions containing disease-causing mutations or cancer polymorphisms in human are predicted to be binding for protein pairs related to the disease, which suggests novel mechanistic hypotheses for several diseases.     

Staphylococcus aureus protein A binding to von Willebrand factor A1 domain is mediated by conserved IgG binding regions

Protein A (Spa) is a surface-associated protein of Staphylococcus aureus best known for its ability to bind to the Fc region of IgG. Spa also binds strongly to the Fab region of the immunoglobulins bearing V(H)3 heavy chains and to von Willebrand factor (vWF). Previous studies have suggested that the protein A-vWF interaction is important in S. aureus adherence to platelets under conditions of shear stress. We demonstrate that Spa expression is sufficient for adherence of bacteria to immobilized vWF under low fluid shear. The full length recombinant Ig-binding region of protein A, Spa-EDABC, fused to glutathione-S-transferase (GST), bound recombinant vWF in a dose-dependent and saturable fashion with half maximal binding of about 30 nm in immunosorbent assays. Full length-Spa did not bind recombinant vWF A3 domain but displayed binding to recombinant vWF domains A1 and D'-D3 (half maximal binding at 100 nm and 250 nm, respectively). Each recombinant protein A Ig-binding domain bound to the A1 domain in a similar manner to the full length-Spa molecule (half maximal binding 100 nm). Amino acid substitutions were introduced in the GST-SpaD protein at sites known to be involved in IgG Fc or in V(H)3 Fab binding. Mutants altered in residues that recognized IgG Fc but not those that recognized V(H)3 Fab had reduced binding to vWF A1 and D'-D3. This indicated that both vWF regions recognized a region on helices I and II that overlapped the IgG Fc binding site.     

Structural motif of phosphate-binding site common to various protein superfamilies: all-against-all structural comparison of protein-mononucleotide complexes

In order to search for a common structural motif in the phosphate-binding sites of protein-mononucleotide complexes, we investigated the structural variety of phosphate-binding schemes by an all-against-all comparison of 491 binding sites found in the Protein Data Bank. We found four frequently occurring structural motifs composed of protein atoms interacting with phosphate groups, each of which appears in different protein superfamilies with different folds. The most frequently occurring motif, which we call the structural P-loop, is shared by 13 superfamilies and is characterized by a four-residue fragment, GXXX, interacting with a phosphate group through the backbone atoms. Various sequence motifs, including Walker's A motif or the P-loop, turn out to be a structural P-loop found in a few specific superfamilies. The other three motifs are found in pairs of superfamilies: protein kinase and glutathione synthetase ATPase domain like, actin-like ATPase domain and nucleotidyltransferase, and FMN-linked oxidoreductase and PRTase.     

Cluster and information entropy patterns in immunoglobulin complementarity determining regions

Previous studies of antibody binding domains have established many crucial features that include important structural positions, canonical formations, and the geometric correlations with the binding site nature and topography. In this work, position-specific frequency and hierarchical clustering analysis are used to explore the statistical pattern of the residues in the complementarity determining regions of human antibodies. In addition, Shannon's information entropy is computed for the entire heavy and light chains and compared with germline patterns to seek variability due to antibody clonal selection. Results are compared with reported analyses based on structural data and ligand-protein contact point computations based on Protein Data Bank records. Observations derived from the present sequence analysis are consistent with previous structural based methods. In the absence of structural data, methods used in this work can be effective and efficient computational tools used for identifying residues that are important for antigen targeting and predicting the probable amino acid distribution expected at these positions. The results in turn can be applied to help design or plan mutagenesis experiments to improve the binding properties of antibodies.     

Protein flexibility prediction by an all-atom mean-field statistical theory

We extended a mean-field model to proteins with all atomic detail. The all-atom mean-field model was used to calculate the dynamic and thermodynamic properties of a three-helix bundle fragment of Staphylococcal protein A (Protein Data Bank [PDB] ID 1BDD) and alpha-spectrin SH3 domain protein (PDB ID 1SHG). We show that a model with all-atomic detail provides a significantly more accurate prediction of flexibility of residues in proteins than does a coarse-grained residue-level model. The accuracy of flexibility prediction is further confirmed by application of the method to 18 additional proteins with the largest size of 224 residues.     

Visualization of the entire surface of a protein by cartographic projection

A minicomputer based system for the determination and schematicrepresentation of protein surfaces is described. The algorithmsare based on the atomic coordinates of globular protein moleculesof the Brookhaven Protein Data Bank. Using a cartographic projectiona normalized graphic representation is obtained of the aminoacid residues located on the surface of the considered protein.The programs are written in FORTRAN IV (surface determination)and BASIC (graphic representation). Received on April 28, 1986; accepted on July 17, 1986