Rp-phosphorothioate modifications in RNase P RNA that interfere with tRNA binding.

We have used Rp-phosphorothioate modifications and a binding interference assay to analyse the role of phosphate oxygens in tRNA recognition by Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (RNase P) RNA. Total (100%) Rp-phosphorothioate modification at A, C or G positions of RNase P RNA strongly impaired tRNA binding and pre-tRNA processing, while effects were less pronounced at U positions. Partially modified E. coli RNase P RNAs were separated into tRNA binding and non-binding fractions by gel retardation. Rp-phosphorothioate modifications that interfered with tRNA binding were found 5' of nucleotides A67, G68, U69, C70, C71, G72, A130, A132, A248, A249, G300, A317, A330, A352, C353 and C354. Manganese rescue at positions U69, C70, A130 and A132 identified, for the first time, sites of direct metal ion coordination in RNase P RNA. Most sites of interference are at strongly conserved nucleotides and nine reside within a long-range base-pairing interaction present in all known RNase P RNAs. In contrast to RNase P RNA, 100% Rp-phosphorothioate substitutions in tRNA showed only moderate effects on binding to RNase P RNAs from E. coli, Bacillus subtilis and Chromatium vinosum, suggesting that pro-Rp phosphate oxygens of mature tRNA contribute relatively little to the formation of the tRNA-RNase P RNA complex.     

Efficient cleavage of pre-tRNAs by E. coli RNAse P RNA requires the 2'-hydroxyl of the ribose at the cleavage site.

RNAse P cleaves pre-tRNAs to liberate 5'-flanks and 5'-matured, 5'-phosphorylated tRNAs. It is not evident if the 2'-hydroxyls of the ribose moieties in the substrate are involved in the reaction. To study their influence in two different pre-tRNAs, we have modified specifically the 2'-hydroxyl groups at the cleavage site and in neighbouring positions. We have shown that these hydroxyls are important but not essential for the processing of these substrates by E. coli RNase P RNA (M1 RNA). The reduction in the catalytic efficiency was moderate for 2'-deoxy and severe for 2'-methoxy substitutions at the cleavage site. Additional effects of modifications in neighbouring positions were smaller. Based on our data we suggest that the modifications do not interfere with binding of the substrate, whereas they prevent an optimal steric arrangement for the hydrolysis reaction.     

Recent approaches to probe functional groups in ribonuclease P RNA by modification interference

Modification interference is a powerful method to identify important functional groups in RNA molecules. We review here recent developments of techniques to screen for chemical modifications that interfere with (i) binding of(pre-)tRNA to bacterial RNase P RNA or (ii) pre-tRNA cleavage by this ribozyme. For example, two studies have analyzed positions at which a substitution of sulfur for thepro-Rp oxygen affects tRNA binding [1] or catalysis [2]. The results emphasize the functional key role of a central core element present in all known RNase P RNA subunits. The four sulfur substitutions identified in one study [2] to inhibit the catalytic step also interfered with binding of tRNA toE. coli RNase P RNA [1]. This suggests that losses in binding energy due to the modification at these positions affect the enzyme-substrate and the enzyme-transition state complex. In addition, the two studies have revealed, for the first time, sites of direct metal ion coordination in RNase P RNA. The potentials, limitations and interpretational ambiguities of modification interference experiments as well as factors influencing their outcome are discussed.Abbreviations nt nucleotide(s) - PAGE polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis     

Purine N7 groups that are crucial to the interaction of Escherichia coli rnase P RNA with tRNA.

We have detected by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) purine N7 functional groups in Escherichia coli RNase P RNA that are important for tRNA binding under moderate salt conditions (0.1 M Mg2+, 0.1 M NH4+). The majority of identified positions represent highly or universally conserved nucleotides. Our assay system allowed us, for the first time, to identify c7-deaza interference effects at two G residues (G292, G306). Several c7-deazaadenine interference effects (A62, A65, A136, A249, A334, A351) have also been identified in other studies performed at very different salt concentrations, either selecting for substrate binding in the presence of 0.025 M Ca2+ and 1 M NH4+ or self-cleavage of a ptRNA-RNase P RNA conjugate in the presence of 3 M NH4+ or Na+. This indicates that these N7 functional groups play a key role in the structural organization of ribozyme-substrate and -product complexes. We further observed that a c7-deaza modification at A76 of tRNA interferes with tRNA binding to and ptRNA processing by E. coli RNase P RNA. This finding combined with the strong c7-deaza interference at G292 of RNase P RNA supports a model in which substrate and product binding to E. coli RNase P RNA involves the formation of intermolecular base triples (A258-G292-C75 and G291-G259-A76).     

Distinct modes of mature and precursor tRNA binding to Escherichia coli RNase P RNA revealed by NAIM analyses

We have analyzed by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) pools of precursor or mature tRNA molecules, carrying a low level of Rp-RMPalphaS (R = A, G, I) or Rp-c7-deaza-RMPalphaS (R = A, G) modifications, to identify functional groups that contribute to the specific interaction with and processing efficiency by Escherichia coli RNase P RNA. The majority of interferences were found in the acceptor stem, T arm, and D arm, including the strongest effects observed at positions G19, G53, A58, and G71. In some cases (interferences at G5, G18, and G71), the affected functional groups are candidates for direct contacts with RNase P RNA. Several modifications disrupt intramolecular tertiary contacts known to stabilize the authentic tRNA fold. Such indirect interference effects were informative as well, because they allowed us to compare the structural constraints required for ptRNA processing versus product binding. Our ptRNA processing and mature tRNA binding NAIM analyses revealed overlapping but nonidentical patterns of interference effects, suggesting that substrate binding and cleavage involves binding modes or conformational states distinct from the binding mode of mature tRNA, the product of the reaction.     

Catalysis by RNase P RNA: unique features and unprecedented active site plasticity

Metal ions are essential cofactors for precursor tRNA (ptRNA) processing by bacterial RNase P. The ribose 2'-OH at nucleotide (nt) -1 of ptRNAs is known to contribute to positioning of catalytic Me2+. To investigate the catalytic process, we used ptRNAs with single 2'-deoxy (2'-H), 2'-amino (2'-N), or 2'-fluoro (2'-F) modifications at the cleavage site (nt -1). 2' modifications had small (2.4-7.7-fold) effects on ptRNA binding to E. coli RNase P RNA in the ground state, decreasing substrate affinity in the order 2'-OH > 2'-F > 2'-N > 2'-H. Effects on the rate of the chemical step (about 10-fold for 2'-F, almost 150-fold for 2'-H and 2'-N) were much stronger, and, except for the 2'-N modification, resembled strikingly those observed in the Tetrahymena ribozyme-catalyzed reaction at corresponding position. Mn2+ rescued cleavage of the 2'-N but also the 2'-H-modified ptRNA, arguing against a direct metal ion coordination at this location. Miscleavage between nt -1 and -2 was observed for the 2'-N-ptRNA at low pH (further influenced by the base identities at nt -1 and +73), suggesting repulsion of a catalytic metal ion due to protonation of the amino group. Effects caused by the 2'-N modification at nt -1 of the substrate allowed us to substantiate a mechanistic difference in phosphodiester hydrolysis catalyzed by Escherichia coli RNase P RNA and the Tetrahymena ribozyme: a metal ion binds next to the 2' substituent at nt -1 in the reaction catalyzed by RNase P RNA, but not at the corresponding location in the Tetrahymena ribozyme reaction.     

A 2'-methyl or 2'-methylene group at G+1 in precursor tRNA interferes with Mg2+ binding at the enzyme-substrate interface in E-S complexes of E. coli RNase P

We analyzed processing of precursor tRNAs carrying a single 2'-deoxy, 2'-OCH(3), or locked nucleic acid (LNA) modification at G+1 by Escherichia coli RNase P RNA in the absence and presence of its protein cofactor. The extra methyl or methylene group caused a substrate binding defect, which was rescued at higher divalent metal ion (M(2+)) concentrations (more efficiently with Mn(2+) than Mg(2+)), and had a minor effect on cleavage chemistry at saturating M(2+) concentrations. The 2'-OCH(3) and LNA modification at G+1 resulted in higher metal ion cooperativity for substrate binding to RNase P RNA without affecting cleavage site selection. This indicates disruption of an M(2+) binding site in enzyme-substrate complexes, which is compensated for by occupation of alternative M(2+) binding sites of lower affinity. The 2'-deoxy modification at G+1 caused at most a two-fold decrease in the cleavage rate; this mild defect relative to 2'-OCH(3) and LNA at G+1 indicates that the defect caused by the latter two is steric in nature. We propose that the 2'-hydroxyl at G+1 in the substrate is in the immediate vicinity of the M(2+) cluster at the phosphates of A67 to U69 in helix P4 of E. coli RNase P RNA.     

NAIM and site-specific functional group modification analysis of RNase P RNA: magnesium dependent structure within the conserved P1-P4 multihelix junction contributes to catalysis

The tRNA processing endonuclease ribonuclease P contains an essential and highly conserved RNA molecule (RNase P RNA) that is the catalytic subunit of the enzyme. To identify and characterize functional groups involved in RNase P RNA catalysis, we applied self-cleaving ribozyme-substrate conjugates, on the basis of the RNase P RNA from Escherichia coli, in nucleotide analogue interference mapping (NAIM) and site-specific modification experiments. At high monovalent ion concentrations (3 M) that facilitate protein-independent substrate binding, we find that the ribozyme is largely insensitive to analogue substitution and that concentrations of Mg2+ (1.25 mM) well below that necessary for optimal catalytic rate (>100 mM) are required to produce interference effects because of modification of nucleotide bases. An examination of the pH dependence of the reaction rate at 1.25 mM Mg2+ indicates that the increased sensitivity to analogue interference is not due to a change in the rate-limiting step. The nucleotide positions detected by NAIM under these conditions are located exclusively in the catalytic domain, consistent with the proposed global structure of the ribozyme, and predominantly occur within the highly conserved P1-P4 multihelix junction. Several sensitive positions in J3/4 and J2/4 are proximal to a previously identified site of divalent metal ion binding in the P1-P4 element. Kinetic analysis of ribozymes with site-specific N7-deazaadenosine and deazaguanosine modifications in J3/4 was, in general, consistent with the interference results and also permitted the analysis of sites not accessible by NAIM. These results show that, in this region only, modification of the N7 positions of A62, A65, and A66 resulted in measurable effects on reaction rate and modification at each position displayed distinct sensitivities to Mg2+ concentration. These results reveal a restricted subset of individual functional groups within the catalytic domain that are particularly important for substrate cleavage and demonstrate a close association between catalytic function and metal ion-dependent structure in the highly conserved P1-P4 multihelix junction.     

Guanosine 2-NH2 groups of Escherichia coli RNase P RNA involved in intramolecular tertiary contacts and direct interactions with tRNA.

We have identified by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) exocyclic NH2 groups of guanosines in RNase P RNA from Escherichia coli that are important for tRNA binding. The majority of affected guanosines represent phylogenetically conserved nucleotides. Several sites of interference could be assigned to direct contacts with the tRNA moiety, whereas others were interpreted as reflecting indirect effects on tRNA binding due to the disruption of tertiary contacts within the catalytic RNA. Our results support the involvement of the 2-NH2 groups of G292/G293 in pairing with C74 and C75 of tRNA CCA-termini, as well as formation of two consecutive base triples involving C75 and A76 of CCA-ends interacting with G292/A258 and G291/G259, respectively. Moreover, we present first biochemical evidence for two tertiary contacts (L18/P8 and L8/P4) within the catalytic RNA, whose formation has been postulated previously on the basis of phylogenetic comparative analyses. The tRNA binding interference data obtained in this and our previous studies are consistent with the formation of a consecutive nucleotide triple and quadruple between the tetraloop L18 and helix P8. Formation of the nucleotide triple (G316 and A94:U104 in wild-type E. coli RNase P RNA) is also supported by mutational analysis. For the mutant RNase P RNA carrying a G94:C104 double mutation, an additional G316-to-A mutation resulted in a restoration of binding affinity for mature and precursor tRNA.     

Chemical synthesis and biological investigation of a 77-mer oligoribonucleotide with a sequence corresponding to E. coli tRNA(Asp)

A 77-mer RNA with the sequence of Eschlerichia coli tRNA(Asp) has been chemically synthesised using standard automated phosphoramidite chemistry with the coupling reagent 4,5-dicyanoimidazole (DCI). The synthesis was carried out on a 1000 A CPG-column and. after deprotection and gel purification, a yield of about 7 mmol with a purity of > 95% was reproducibly obtained. By comparing automated synthesis of the 77-mer RNA using 1H-tetrazole and DCI as activator, DCI is advantageous in producing longer RNAs. However, for shorter RNAs ( <40 mer) no difference could be observed. In addition to the all-ribo tRNA(Asp) carrying the wild-type sequence, two variants were synthesised, one with a single C to G48 mutation and the second with a 2'-deoxy modification at C48. The three tRNAs were tested for their aminoacylation efficiency and high affinity binding to E. coli RNase P RNA. The results demonstrate that chemically synthesised 77-mer oligoribonucleotides can be successfully used for structure function studies.     

Identification by modification-interference of purine N-7 and ribose 2'-OH groups critical for catalysis by bacterial ribonuclease P.

The RNA subunit of bacterial ribonuclease P is a catalytic RNA that cleaves precursor tRNAs to generate mature tRNA 5' ends. A self-cleaving RNase P RNA-substrate conjugate was used in modification-interference analysis to identify purine N-7 and ribose 2'-hydroxyl functional groups that are critical to catalysis. We identify six adenine N-7 groups and only one 2'-hydroxyl that, when substituted with 7-deazaadenine or 2'-deoxy analogues, respectively, reduce the RNase P catalytic rate approximately 10-fold at pH 8 and limiting concentration of magnesium. Two sites of low-level interference by phosphorothioate modification were detected in addition to the four sites of strong interference documented previously. These modification-interference results, the absolute phylogenetic conservation of these functional groups in bacterial RNase P RNA, their proximity to the substrate-phosphate in the tertiary structure of the ribozyme-substrate complex, and the importance of some of the sites for binding of catalytic magnesium all implicate these functional groups as components of the RNase P active site. Five of the 7-deazaadenine interferences are suppressed at pH 6, where the hydrolytic step is rate-limiting, or at saturating concentrations of magnesium. We propose, therefore, that these base functional groups are specifically engaged in the catalytic center of RNase P RNA, possibly by involvement in magnesium-dependent folding. One 7-deazaadenine interference and one 2'-deoxy-interference, although partially suppressed at pH 6, are not suppressed at saturating magnesium concentrations. This implicates these groups in magnesium-independent folding of the catalytic substructure of the ribozyme.     

Metal ion and substrate structure dependence of the processing of tRNA precursors by RNase P and M1 RNA

A synthetic tRNA precursor analog containing the structural elements of Escherichia coli tRNA(Phe) was characterized as a substrate for E. coli ribonuclease P and for M1 RNA, the catalytic RNA subunit. Processing of the synthetic precursor exhibited a Mg2+ dependence quite similar to that of natural tRNA precursors such as E. coli tRNA(Tyr) precursor. It was found that Sr2+, Ca2+, and Ba2+ ions promoted processing of the dimeric precursor at Mg2+ concentrations otherwise insufficient to support processing; very similar behavior was noted for E. coli tRNA(Tyr). As noted previously for natural tRNA precursors, the absence of the 3'-terminal CA sequence in the synthetic precursor diminished the facility of processing of this substrate by RNase P and M1 RNA. A study of the Mg2+ dependence of processing of the synthetic tRNA dimeric substrate radiolabeled between C75 and A76 provided unequivocal evidence for an alteration in the actual site of processing by E. coli RNase P as a function of Mg2+ concentration. This property was subsequently demonstrated to obtain (Carter, B. J., Vold, B.S., and Hecht, S. M. (1990) J. Biol. Chem. 265, 7100-7103) for a mutant Bacillus subtilis tRNAHis precursor containing a potential A-C base pair at the end of the acceptor stem.     

Identification of amino acid residues in the catalytic domain of RNase E essential for survival of Escherichia coli: functional analysis of DNase I subdomain

RNase E is an essential Escherichia coli endoribonuclease that plays a major role in the decay and processing of a large fraction of RNAs in the cell. To better understand the molecular mechanisms of RNase E action, we performed a genetic screen for amino acid substitutions in the catalytic domain of the protein (N-Rne) that knock down the ability of RNase E to support survival of E. coli. Comparative phylogenetic analysis of RNase E homologs shows that wild-type residues at these mutated positions are nearly invariably conserved. Cells conditionally expressing these N-Rne mutants in the absence of wild-type RNase E show a decrease in copy number of plasmids regulated by the RNase E substrate RNA I, and accumulation of 5S ribosomal RNA, M1 RNA, and tRNA(Asn) precursors, as has been found in Rne-depleted cells, suggesting that the inability of these mutants to support cellular growth results from loss of ribonucleolytic activity. Purified mutant proteins containing an amino acid substitution in the DNase I subdomain, which is spatially distant from the catalytic site posited from crystallographic studies, showed defective binding to an RNase E substrate, p23 RNA, but still retained RNA cleavage activity-implicating a previously unidentified structural motif in the DNase I subdomain in the binding of RNase E to targeted RNA molecules, demonstrating the role of the DNase I domain in RNase E activity.     

Phylogenetic comparative chemical footprint analysis of the interaction between ribonuclease P RNA and tRNA.

Ribonuclease P RNA is the catalytic moiety of the ribonucleoprotein enzyme that endonucleolytically cleaves precursor sequences from the 5' ends of pre-tRNAs. The bacterial RNase P RNA-tRNA complex was examined with a footprinting approach, utilizing chemical modification to determine RNase P RNA nucleotides that potentially contact tRNA. RNase P RNA was modified with dimethylsulfate or kethoxal in the presence or absence of tRNA, and sites of modification were detected by primer extension. Comparison of the results reveals RNase P bases that are protected from modification upon binding tRNA. Analyses were carried out with RNase P RNAs from three different bacteria: Escherichia coli, Chromatium vinosum and Bacillus subtilis. Discrete bases of these RNAs that lie within conserved, homologous portions of the secondary structures are similarly protected. One protection among all three RNAs was attributed to the precursor segment of pre-tRNA. Experiments using pre-tRNAs containing precursor segments of variable length demonstrate that a precursor segment of only 2-4 nucleotides is sufficient to confer this protection. Deletion of the 3'-terminal CCA sequence of tRNA correlates with loss of protection of a particular loop in the RNase P RNA secondary structure. Analysis of mutant tRNAs containing sequential 3'-terminal deletions suggests a relative orientation of the bound tRNA CCA to that loop.     

The effect of tRNA binding on the structure of 5 S RNA in Escherichia coli. A chemical modification study

The structure of 5 S RNA within the 70 S ribosome from Escherichia coli was studied using the chemical reagent kethoxal (alpha-keto-beta-ethoxybutyraldehyde) to modify accessible guanosines. The modification pattern of 5 S RNA from free 70 S ribosomes was compared with that of poly(U) programmed ribosomes where tRNA had been bound to both the A- and P-sites. Binding to the ribosomal A-site was achieved enzymatically using the elongation factor Tu and GTP in the presence of deacylated tRNA which blocks the ribosomal P-site. Modified guanosines were identified after partial RNase T1 hydrolysis and separation of the hydrolysis products on sequencing gels. Binding of tRNA to the ribosome leads to a strong protection of 5 S RNA guanosine G-41 and to some degree G-44 from kethoxal modification. The limited RNase T1 hydrolysis pattern provides evidence for the existence of a 5 S RNA conformation different from the known 5 S RNA A- and B-forms which are characterized by their gel electrophoretic mobility. The importance of 5 S RNA for the binding of tRNA to the ribosome is discussed.     

Modification interference approach to detect ribose moieties important for the optimal activity of a ribozyme.

A new approach for modification interference studies is presented. It involves the use of phosphorothioates as a handle to analyze any desired base or sugar modification. This method was applied to identify ribose and phosphate moieties which could be important in the pre-tRNA recognition of E. coli RNase P RNA (M1 RNA). The utility of this technique was confirmed by detecting the inhibitory effect of a deoxyribose in the 5'-flank (position-1). This site was already known to interfere with RNase P cleavage, if modified. We have analyzed pre-tRNA(Tyr) and pre-tRNA(Phe) and found different interference patterns for both tRNAs. Two unpaired regions were involved in both pre-tRNAs. Phosphorothioates interfered at the transition between acceptor- and D-arms. The results with deoxythymidines in the T-loop indicated that deoxyribose moieties or the extra methyl group in thymidine could interfere with RNAse P cleavage. These data suggest that even in complete pre-tRNAs, only a few intact ribonucleotides are important in the substrate recognition by RNase P. We have demonstrated the potential of this new approach which offers many future applications in all fields involving nucleic acids, for example RNA processing, action of ribozymes, tRNA charging and studies related to DNA promoter recognition.     

Studies on Escherichia coli RNase P RNA with Zn2+ as the catalytic cofactor

We demonstrate, for the first time, catalysis by Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (RNase P) RNA with Zn2+ as the sole divalent metal ion cofactor in the presence of ammonium, but not sodium or potassium salts. Hill analysis suggests a role for two or more Zn2+ ions in catalysis. Whereas Zn2+ destabilizes substrate ground state binding to an extent that precludes reliable Kd determination, Co(NH3)6(3+) and Sr2+ in particular, both unable to support catalysis by themselves, promote high-substrate affinity. Zn2+ and Co(NH3)6(3+) substantially reduce the fraction of precursor tRNA molecules capable of binding to RNase P RNA. Stimulating and inhibitory effects of Sr2+ on the ribozyme reaction with Zn2+ as cofactor could be rationalized by a model involving two Sr2+ ions (or two classes of Sr2+ ions). Both ions improve substrate affinity in a cooperative manner, but one of the two inhibits substrate conversion in a non-competitive mode with respect to the substrate and the Zn2+. A single 2'-fluoro modification at nt -1 of the substrate substantially weakened the inhibitory effect of Sr2+. Our results demonstrate that the studies on RNase P RNA with metal cofactors other than Mg2+ entail complex effects on structural equilibria of ribozyme and substrate RNAs as well as E*S formation apart from the catalytic performance.     

The decoding region of 16S RNA; a cross-linking study of the ribosomal A, P and E sites using tRNA derivatized at position 32 in the anticodon loop.

A photo-reactive diazirine derivative was attached to the 2-thiocytidine residue at position 32 of tRNA(Arg)I from Escherichia coli. This modified tRNA was bound under suitable conditions to the A, P or E site of E.coli ribosomes. After photo-activation of the diazirine label, the sites of cross-linking to 16S rRNA were identified by our standard procedures. Each of the three tRNA binding sites showed a characteristic pattern of cross-linking. From tRNA at the A site, a major cross-link was observed to position 1378 of the 16S RNA, and a minor one to position 936. From the P site, there were major cross-links to positions 693 and to 957 and/or 966, as well as a minor cross-link to position 1338. The E site bound tRNA showed major cross-links to position 693 (identical to that from the P site) and to positions 1376/1378 (similar, but not identical, to the cross-link observed from the A site). Immunological analysis of the concomitantly cross-linked ribosomal proteins indicated that S7 was the major target of cross-linking from all three tRNA sites, with S11 as a minor product. The results are discussed in terms of the overall topography of the decoding region of the 30S ribosomal subunit.     

Topography of the E site on the Escherichia coli ribosome.

Three photoreactive tRNA probes have been utilized in order to identify ribosomal components that are in contact with the aminoacyl acceptor end and the anticodon loop of tRNA bound to the E site of Escherichia coli ribosomes. Two of the probes were derivatives of E. coli tRNA(Phe) in which adenosines at positions 73 and 76 were replaced by 2-azidoadenosine. The third probe was derived from yeast tRNA(Phe) by substituting wyosine at position 37 with 2-azidoadenosine. Despite the modifications, all of the photoreactive tRNA species were able to bind to the E site of E. coli ribosomes programmed with poly(A) and, upon irradiation, formed covalent adducts with the ribosomal subunits. The tRNA(Phe) probes modified at or near the 3' terminus exclusively labeled protein L33 in the 50S subunit. The tRNA(Phe) derivative containing 2-azidoadenosine within the anticodon loop became cross-linked to protein S11 as well as to a segment of the 16S rRNA encompassing the 3'-terminal 30 nucleotides. We have located the two extremities of the E site-bound tRNA on the ribosomal subunits according to the positions of L33, S11 and the 3' end of 16S rRNA defined by immune electron microscopy. Our results demonstrate conclusively that the E site is topographically distinct from either the P site or the A site, and that it is located alongside the P site as expected for the tRNA exit site.