Functional Analysis of Two Matrix Attachment Region (MAR) Elements in Transgenic Maize Plants

Matrix attachment regions (MARs) are binding sites for nuclear scaffold proteins in vitro, and are proposed to mediate the attachment of chromatin to the nuclear scaffold in vivo. Previous reports suggest that MAR elements may stabilize transgene expression. Here, we tested the effects of two maize MAR elements (P-MAR from the P1-rr gene, and Adh1-MAR from the adh1 gene) on the expression of a gusA reporter gene driven by three different promoters: the maize p1 gene promoter, a wheat peroxidase (WP) gene promoter, or a synthetic promoter (Rsyn7). The inclusion of P-MAR or Adh1-MAR on P::GUS transgene constructs did not reduce variation in the levels of GUS activity among independent transformation events, nor among the progeny derived from each event. The Adh1-MAR element did not affect GUS expression driven by the WP promoter, but did modify the spatial pattern of expression of the Rsyn7::GUS transgene. These results indicate that, in transgenic maize plants, the effects of MAR elements can vary significantly depending upon the promoter used to drive the transgene.     

Enhancement of maize transformation efficiency by the use of maize matrix attachment regions

Improving genetic transformation efficiency is a major concern in plant genetic engineering. While various strategies have been investigated, the enhancement of selectable marker gene expression has not been tried extensively. We used maize matrix attachment regions (MARs) to bracket an herbicide resistance transgene, bar. MARs have been reported to enhance transgene expression level and stability. We show here that MARs not only enhance transformation efficiency by 50%, but are also able to increase or decrease relative efficiencies of each step of the regeneration process depending on MAR sequence combinations. Furthermore, we assessed the trans-effect of MARs in co-bombardment experiments with two independent plasmids, one including the MAR sequences and the other one the bar gene. As for simple bombardment, MARs enhanced transformation efficiency by having a positive influence on organogenesis step in the regeneration process.     

Use of matrix attachment regions (MARs) to minimize transgene silencing

Matrix attachment regions (MARs) are operationally defined as DNA elements that bind specifically to the nuclear matrix in vitro. It is possible, although unproven, that they also mediate binding of chromatin to the nuclear matrix in vivo and alter the topology of the genome in interphase nuclei. When MARs are positioned on either side of a transgene their presence usually results in higher and more stable expression in transgenic plants or cell lines, most likely by minimizing gene silencing. Our review explores current data and presents several plausible models to explain MAR effects on transgene expression.     

A matrix attachment region is located upstream from the high-molecular-weight glutenin gene Bx7 in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.).

A 2.2-kb nucleotide sequence rich in AT, located upstream from the Bx7 allele of the high-molecular-weight glutenin Glu-B1 locus in wheat (Triticum aestivum cv. Glenlea) was cloned following amplification by PCR. The 5' region of this sequence contains motifs typically found in matrix attachment regions (MARs) in other plants. We have shown that part of the 2.2-kb DNA binds to wheat nuclear matrix (NM) in vitro, at least as strongly as a known MAR (Adh1) from maize suggesting that there is a MAR upstream of Bx7. This MAR is approximately 800 bases in length running from -750 to -1560 bases, relative to the start codon. Although the MAR is associated with a tissue-specific gene and is beside a strong tissue-specific promoter, the MAR sequence did not lead to tissue-specific expression of the beta-glucuronidase marker gene under the control of the rice actin promoter in various tissues. Presence of the MAR was only slightly beneficial with respect to expression levels, which were not greatly altered in transient expression assays in various wheat tissues although a slight increase in the number of foci was observed in leaves, which have low transformation efficiencies.     

Matrix attachment regions increase transgene expression levels and stability in transgenic rice plants and their progeny

To investigate the effect of matrix attachment regions (MARs) on transgene expression levels and stability in cereal crops, we generated 83 independent transgenic rice callus lines containing a gusA expression cassette either as a simple expression unit, or flanked with MARs from tobacco (Rb7) or yeast (ARS1). Transgenic rice plants were regenerated from these callus lines and analysed at the structural and expression levels over two generations. In the first generation (T₀), both Rb7 and ARS1 MARs significantly increased transgene expression levels. In the populations of plants containing MARs, we observed a significant reduction in the number of non-expressing lines compared to the population of plants without MARs. However, variation in β-glucuronidase (GUS) expression levels between independent lines was similar both in the presence and absence of flanking MARs. In the presence of MARs, GUS activity increased in proportion to transgene copy number up to 20 copies, but was generally reduced in lines carrying a higher copy number. In the population of plants without MARs, there was no correlation between expression level and transgene copy number. In the second generation (T₁), transgene expression levels were significantly correlated with those of the T₀ parents. The Rb7 MARs significantly improved the stability of transgene expression levels over two generations, and therefore appear to offer protection against transgene silencing. Our study shows that the exploitation of MARs may be an important strategy for stabilising transgene expression levels in genetically engineered cereals.     

Heritable transgene expression pattern imposed onto maize ubiquitin promoter by maize <Emphasis Type="Italic">adh-1</Emphasis> matrix attachment regions: tissue and developmental specificity in maize transgenic plants

Matrix attachment regions (MARs) have been used to enhance transgene expression and to reduce transgene expression instability in various organisms. In plants, contradictory data question the role of MAR sequences. To assess the use of MAR sequences in maize, we have used two well-characterized MARs from the maize adh-1 region. The MARs have been cloned either 5 to or at both sides of a reporter gene expression cassette to reconstitute a MAR-based domain. Histochemical staining revealed a new transgene expression pattern in roots of regenerated plants and their progeny. Furthermore, MARs systematically induced variegation. We show here that maize adh-1 MARs are able to modify transgene expression patterns as a heritable trait, giving a new and complementary outcome following use of MARs in genetic transformation.Abbreviations adh-1 Alcohol dehydrogenase 1 - GUS -Glucuronidase - HSC80 Heat shock cognate 80 gene - MAR Matrix attachment regions - Rsyn-7 Root specific synthetic promoter     

Effect of nuclear matrix attachment regions on transgene expression in tobacco plants

Matrix attachment regions (MARs) are thought to participate in the organization and segregation of independent chromosomal loop domains. Although there are several reports on the action of natural MARs in the context of heterologous genes in transgenic plants, in our study we tested a synthetic MAR (sMAR) with the special property of unpairing when under superhelical strain, for its effect on reporter gene expression in tobacco plants. The synthetic MAR was a multimer of a short sequence from the MAR 3' end of the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) enhancer. This sMAR sequence was used to flank the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene within the T-DNA of the binary vector pBI121. Vectors with or without the sMARs were then used to transform tobacco plants by Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Transgenic plants containing the sMAR sequences flanking the GUS gene exhibited higher levels of transgene expression compared with transgenic plants which lacked the sMARs. This effect was observed independently of the position of the sMAR at the 5' side of the reporter gene. However, variation of the detected transgene expression was significant in all transformed plant populations, irrespective of the construct used.     

A short synthetic MAR positively affects transgene expression in rice and Arabidopsis

Matrix Attachment Regions (MARs) are DNA elements that are thought to influence gene expression by anchoring active chromatin domains to the nuclear matrix. When flanking a construct in transgenic plants, MARs could be useful for enhancing transgene expression. Naturally occurring MARs have a number of sequence features and DNA elements in common, and using different subsets of these sequence elements, three independent synthetic MARs were created. Although short, these MARs were able to bind nuclear scaffold preparations with an affinity equal to or greater than naturally occurring plant MARs. One synthetic MAR was extensively tested for its effect on transgene expression, using different MAR orientations, plant promoters, transformation methods and plant species. This MAR was able to increase average transgene expression and produced integration patterns of lower complexity. These data show the potential of making well defined synthetic MARs and using them to improve transgene expression.     

The function of the nuclear matrix attachment region of silkworm rDNA as an autonomously replicating sequence in plasmid and chromosomal replication origin in yeast

Nuclear matrix attachment regions (MARs) play a crucial role in chromatin architecture, gene expression, and DNA replication. Although it is well known that yeast autonomously replicating sequences (ARSs) bind nuclear matrix and MARs also function as ARS elements in yeast, whether a heterologous MAR or ARS element acts as a replication origin in the chromosome has not been elucidated. We previously identified a MAR (rMAR) located in the nontranscribed spacer (NTS) of silkworm Attacus ricini rDNA. We report here that this rMAR contains 10 copies of ARS consensus sequence (ACS) and several DNA unwinding regions. The rMAR employs ARS activity in yeast and a rARS element locates in the 3(') region of the rMAR. Furthermore, we have also revealed that either the rMAR or the rARS element functions as a replication origin in the chromosome. Our results provide the first direct evidence to demonstrate that heterologous rMAR and rARS display chromosomal origin activity, suggesting that the chromosome structure and replication origin of rDNA reserve some common features during evolution.     

TM2, a novel strong matrix attachment region isolated from tobacco, increases transgene expression in transgenic rice calli and plants

Nuclear matrix attachment regions (MARs) are thought to influence the expression of the flanking genes. TM2, a new DNA fragment isolated from tobacco, can bind with the rice nuclear matrix in vitro. In this study, we investigated the effect of TM2 on transgene expression under the control of three different promoters in stably transformed rice calli and plants. The presence of TM2 flanking the transgene increased the expression of constructs based on the constitutive CaMV 35S and maize ubiquitin gene promoters in both resistant calli and transformed plants. The GUS expression directed by the photosynthetic-tissue-specific PNZIP promoter was also increased in photosynthetic tissues of transformants. However, TM2 did not change the gene expression pattern controlled by the PNZIP promoter. The effect of TM2 in transgenic plants was stronger than that in transgenic calli based on all three promoters. Our results indicate that TM2, as a novel strong MAR, can be used to increase the transgene expression levels in the whole plant or in particular tissues of monocotyledons.     

A tobacco matrix attachment region reduces the loss of transgene expression in the progeny of transgenic tobacco plants

The RB7 matrix attachment region (MAR), when flanking a uidA (GUS) reporter gene, has been previously shown to increase uidA gene expression by 60-fold in stably transformed tobacco suspension cell lines. We have now used the same co-transformation procedure to determine the effect of flanking MARs on uidA gene expression in tobacco plants. The neomycin phosphotransferase selection gene and uidA reporter gene on separate plasmids were co-transformed into seedlings by microprojectile bombardment. In primary transgenic plants, the average uidA expression in plants with MARs was twofold greater than in control plants without MARs, but there was no effect on variation of expression. GUS activity was not proportional to the number of integrated uidA transgenes over the entire range of copy numbers. However, in the lower part of the copy number range, MAR lines show a tendency for expression to increase with copy number. Transgene expression in backcross progenies of the MAR-containing lines averaged threefold higher than in control progenies. MARs also reduced the loss of transgene expression in the BC₁ generation. Sixty-three per cent of the 21 MAR-containing primary transformants, but only 20% of the 14 control primary transformants, produced backcross progenies in which no loss of transgene expression was observed. These observations are discussed in the context of homology-dependent gene silencing.     

Positional effects of the matrix attachment region on transgene expression in stably transfected CHO cells

Previous work has shown that the MAR (matrix attachment region) could increase transgene expression in stably transfected CHO (Chinese‐hamster ovary) cells. To study the positional effect of MAR on transgene expression, three expression vectors were constructed which contained the human β‐globin MAR in different sites, including the vector with two MARs flanking the CAT (chloramphenicol acetyltransferase) expression cassette, one MAR at the 5′ or 3′ site. These vectors were transfected into CHO cells. The level of CAT gene expression was most effectively increased by two MARs flanking the CAT expression cassette. This increase was also seen when MAR was inserted at the 5′ site upstream of the expression cassette, whereas the transgene expression level decreased when MAR was inserted at the 3′ site downstream of the expression cassette. We have also shown that the transgene expression level is not directly proportional to the gene copy number, and gene copy number dependency does not exist.     

The role of cell differentiation state and HMG-I/Y in the expression of transgenes flanked by matrix attachment regions

The tobacco nuclear matrix attachment region (MAR), RB7, has been shown to have a much greater effect on transgene expression in cultured cells than in transgenic plants. This is comparable to work in mouse systems showing that MARs have a positive effect on transgene expression in embryonic tissues but not adult tissues. There are several possible explanations for these observations. One is that cell differentiation state and proliferation rate can affect MAR function. We tested this possibility by initiating suspension cell cultures from well-characterized transgenic plants transformed with 35S::GUS with and without flanking MARs and then comparing GUS specific activity in the cell lines to those of the transgenic plants from which the cell lines were derived. If cell differentiation state and proliferation rate do affect MAR function, we would expect the ratio of transgene expression (cell suspensions : plants) to be greater in MAR lines than in control lines. This turned out not to be the case. Thus, it appears that MAR function is not enhanced simply because cells in culture divide rapidly and are not differentiated. Because in animal systems the chromosomal protein HMG-I/Y has been shown to be upregulated in proliferating cells and may have a role in MAR function, we have also examined the levels of the tobacco HMG-I/Y homolog by immunoblotting. The level of this protein does not differ between primary transformant cultured cells (NT-1) and Nicotiana tabacum plants (SR-1). However, a higher molecular weight cross-reacting polypeptide was found in nuclei from the NT-1 cell suspensions but was not detected in SR-1 leaf nuclei or cell suspensions derived from the SR-1 plants.     

The Influences of Two Plant Nuclear Matrix Attachment Regions (MARs) on Gene Expression in Transgenic Plants

Nuclear matrix attachment regions (MARs) are thought to influencegene expression by anchoring active chromatin to the proteinaceousnuclear matrix. In this study, two plant DNA fragments withstrong MAR activity were selected and tested for their effectson expression of a linked reporter gene in transgenic tobacco.One MAR was isolated from the 5' flanking region of a pea vicilingene previously reported to be expressed in a copy number-dependentmanner in transgenic tobacco. A second MAR was isolated fromthe genome of Arabidopsis thaliana by preselection for autonomouslyreplicating sequence (ARS) activity in yeast. Flanking copiesof the A. thaliana MAR stimulated median reporter gene expressionin transgenic plants by five to ten fold. Neither MAR significantlyreduced the variation in transgene expression between individualtransformants, or conferred copy number-dependence in gene expression. (Received July 24, 1997; Accepted November 10, 1997)