Disruption of the Golgi apparatus by brefeldin A inhibits the cytotoxicity of ricin, modeccin, and Pseudomonas toxin

We have studied the cytotoxicity of ricin in cells treated with brefeldin A (BFA), which dramatically disrupts the structure of the Golgi apparatus causing Golgi content and membrane to redistribute to the ER. BFA inhibits the cytotoxicity of ricin in Chinese hamster ovary, normal rat kidney, and Vero cells and abolishes the enhancement of ricin cytotoxicity by NH4Cl, nigericin, swainsonine, and tunicamycin or by a mutation in endosomal acidification. BFA protects cells from the cytotoxicities of modeccin and Pseudomonas toxin, but has no effect on the intoxication by diphtheria toxin. Pretreatment of BFA does not protect cells from ricin treatment in the absence of BFA. Our results suggest that ricin, modeccin, and Pseudomonas toxin share a common pathway of intracellular transport from endosomes to the Golgi region where they are released into the cytosol. In contrast, the lack of protection of Vero cells from diphtheria toxin by BFA indicates that diphtheria toxin is released from acidified endosomes without involving the Golgi region.     

Properties and action mechanism of the toxic lectin modeccin: Interaction with cell lines resistant to modeccin,abrin, and ricin

The toxic lectin modeccin, which inhibits protein synthesis in eukaryotic cells, is cleaved upon treatment with 2-mercaptoethanol into two peptide chains which move in polyacrylamide gels at rates corresponding to molecular weights 28,000 and 38,000. After reduction, the toxin loses its effect on cells, while its ability to inhibit cell-free protein synthesis increases. Like abrin and ricin it inhibits protein synthesis by inactivating the 60S ribosomal subunits. Modeccin binds to surface receptors containing terminal galactose residues. Competition experiments with various glycoproteins indicate that the modeccin receptors are different from the abrin receptors. In addition, they were present on HeLa cells in much smaller numbers. Moreover, mutant lines resistant to abrin and ricin were not resistant to modeccin and vice-versa. The toxin resistance of various mutant cell lines could not be accounted for by a reduced number of binding sites on cells. The data are consistent with the view that the cells possesss different populations of binding sites with differences in ability to facilitate the uptake of the toxins and that in the resistant lines the most active receptors have been reduced or eliminated.     

The Different Behavior of Diphtheria Toxin, Modeccin and Ricin in HeLa Cells Infected with Trypanosoma cruzi

ABSTRACT. We have studied the action of diphtheria toxin, modeccin and ricin on HeLa cells infected by Trypanosoma cruzi . Parasitized HeLa cells were resistant to diphtheria toxin and modeccin, whereas non-parasitized cells from the same cultures and control cultures showed cytopathological alterations. Protein synthesis, assayed by the incorporation of labelled methionine, diminished in toxin-treated control cultures but remained unaltered in the infected ones, compared to synthesis by untreated infected cells. Ricin, on the other hand, is a toxin that enters the cytoplasm by endocytosis. It has greater cytopathological effects in parasitized cells than in non-parasitized ones from the same cultures or uninfected control cells. Protein synthesis was inhibited in infected cultures treated with ricin.     

Enhancement of cytotoxicities of ricin and Pseudomonas toxin in Chinese hamster ovary cells by nigericin.

Nigericin and monensin, ionophores for Na+ and K+, have been found to enhance the cytotoxicities of abrin, ricin, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa exotoxin A in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. They do not affect the cytotoxicity of diphtheria toxin in the same cell line. Maximal sensitization of the CHO cells toward ricin and Pseudomonas toxin requires preculture of CHO cells in the presence of nigericin. Inhibition of protein synthesis in CHO cells by ricin or Pseudomonas toxin is also enhanced by preculture of CHO cells in the presence of nigericin. These results suggest a common step in the intoxication process of ricin and Pseudomonas toxin, the rate of which is facilitated by pretreatment with nigericin. This step is, however, not shared by the intoxication of CHO cells with diphtheria toxin.     

Chinese hamster ovary cell mutants defective in the internalization of ricin.

Chinese hamster ovary mutants simultaneously resistant to ricin and Pseudomonas toxin have been isolated. Two mutant cell lines (4-10 and 11-2) were found to retain normal levels of binding of both ricin and Pseudomonas toxin. They were defective in the internalization of [125I]ricin into the mutant cells, as measured by both a biochemical assay for ricin internalization and electron microscopic autoradiographic studies. Although pretreatment of Chinese hamster ovary cells with a Na+/K+ ionophore, nigericin, resulted in an enhancement of the cytotoxicities of ricin and Pseudomonas toxin in the wild-type Chinese hamster ovary cells, preculture of the mutant cells did not alter the susceptibility of the mutant cells to either toxin. These results provide further evidence that there is a common step in the internalization process for ricin and Pseudomonas toxin.     

Enhanced internalization of ricin in nigericin-pretreated Chinese hamster ovary cells.

Biochemical and electron microscopic autoradiographic studies with [125I] ricin have revealed that nigericin-pretreated Chinese hamster ovary cells are more efficient than untreated cells in the internalization of the toxin into the cells. These results suggest that the enhanced rate of internalization of ricin in nigericin-pretreated cells may account for the enhancement of cytotoxicity of ricin in Chinese hamster ovary cells by nigericin.     

Inhibition of the cytotoxicity of protein toxins by a novel plant metabolite,Mansonone-D

We have studied the effect of several structurally related mansonones on the cytotoxicity of plant and bacterial toxins in Vero and BER-40, a brefeldin A-resistant mutant of Vero cells. Mansonone-D (MD), a sesquiterpenoid ortho-naphthoquinone, inhibited the cytotoxicity of ricin, modeccin, Pseudomonas toxin, and diphtheria toxin in Vero cells to different extents. The inhibition of ricin cytotoxicity was dose dependent and reversed upon removal of the drug. Protection of ricin cytotoxicity was also observed in the presence of cycloheximide, indicating that de novo protein synthesis is not required for the protective effect. Although MD inhibited the degradation and excretion of ricin, the binding and internalization of ricin was not affected. In contrast, MD strongly reduced the specific binding of diphtheria toxin in Vero cells. Fluorescence microscopic studies show that MD treatment dramatically alters the morphology of the Golgi apparatus in Vero cells. The kinetic studies reveal that the protection of ricin cytotoxicity is the consequence of decreased toxin translocation to the cytosol in MD-treated cells. The reactive ortho-quinone moiety of MD is important for the protective effect as thespesone, a para-naphthoquinone with a heterocyclic ring structure identical to that of MD, did not inhibit the cytotoxicity of toxins. Thespone, a dehydromansonone-D, lacking two hydrogens from the heterocyclic dihydrofuran ring of MD, inhibited the cytotoxicity of ricin, but was albeit less potent than MD. Neither mansonone-E nor mansonone-H with reactive ortho-quinone moiety, but with a different heterocyclic structure, had any effect on the cytotoxicity of ricin indicating that the protective effect of MD is specifically related to the overall structure of the metabolite. J. Cell. Physiol. 176:40–49, 1998. Published 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

1 This article was prepared by a group of United States government employees and non-United States government employees, and as such is subject to 17 U.S.C. Sec. 105.

     

Entry of lethal doses of abrin, ricin and modeccin into the cytosol of HeLa cells

In attempts to assess how many molecules of the toxic lectins abrin, ricin and modeccin are needed in the cytosol to kill HeLa cells the effect of these toxins on protein synthesis and plating efficiency was studied. The incubation time of the cells after a 1 h exposure to the toxins influenced strongly the extent of inhibition of protein synthesis. The full toxic effect was expressed about 20 h of incubation after the exposure. On further incubation, protein synthesis again increased at a rate comparable to that in the control cells. After exposure to increasing concentrations of toxins the inhibition of cellular protein synthesis measured after 20 h showed excellent agreement with the inhibition of plating efficiency, indicating that the inhibition of protein synthesis can be used as a measure of cell killing. The inhibition of protein synthesis by toxins was found to follow first order kinetics, indicating that the cells are killed by an all- or none-effect. Autoradiographic studies indicated that after exposure to intermediate toxin concentrations protein synthesis was completely abolished in some cells, whereas it appeared to proceed at a normal rate in the remaining cells. The results provide evidence that penetration of one molecule of abrin, ricin or modeccin into cytosol is lethal to HeLa cells and that the efficiency of toxin entry into the cytoplasm is very low compared to the rate of bulk toxin uptake.     

Resistance against ricin-induced apoptosis in a brefeldin A-resistant mutant cell line (BER-40) of Vero cells

We have found that a brefeldin A (BFA)-resistant mutant cell line derived from Vero cells (BER-40) is highly resistant to ricin-induced apoptosis as compared with parental Vero cells. In BER-40 cells, all apoptotic events caused by ricin including cytolysis, nuclear morphological changes, and DNA fragmentation occur to a lesser extent than in Vero cells, even though both cell lines show similar sensitivities to ricin-mediated inhibition of protein synthesis. Furthermore, no significant apoptotic signaling events, such as increases in caspase-3 and -9-like activities, release of cytochrome c from mitochondria, or the cleavage of PARP, were observed in BER-40 cells under the conditions at which these changes were evident in Vero cells. Intracellular biochemical changes associated with ricin-induced apoptosis, such as the depletion of glutathione and an increase in free Zn2+, were also less apparent in BER-40 cells than in Vero cells. BER-40 cells were also found to be highly resistant to apoptosis induced by other toxins with different intoxication mechanisms such as diphtheria toxin, modeccin, and anisomycin. These results suggest that the entire apoptotic signal transduction mechanism in BER-40 cells, which may be triggered after the inhibition of protein synthesis by toxins, becomes resistant. Since MDCK cells, a naturally BFA resistant cell line, are highly sensitive to ricin-induced apoptosis, it seems likely that the BFA resistance phenotype may not necessarily lead to resistance to apoptotic cell death. Probably the underlaying BFA-resistance mechanism in BER-40 cells is distinct from that in MDCK cells, and the resistance to ricin-induced apoptosis of BER-40 cells may be a unique phenotype acquired concomitantly with BFA-resistance.     

Effects of retinoids and phorbol esters on the sensitivity of different cell lines to the polypeptide toxins modeccin, abrin, ricin and diphtheria toxin.

The effects of retinoic acid and 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol 13-acetate on the sensitivities of a number of cell lines to the toxins modeccin, abrin, ricin and diphtheria toxin were studied. Retinoic acid and some other retinoids were found to protect a number of the cell lines against the toxins. HeLa cells that were protected bound much more retinoic acid than L-cells that were not protected. The tumour promoter 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol 13-acetate was found to increase the sensitivity of cells to abrin, ricin and modeccin in the absence as well as in the presence of retinoic acid. Neither retinoic acid nor 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol 13-acetate affected the extent of binding and pinocytotic uptake of toxins by the cells. Apparently retinoic acid and 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol 13-acetate interfere with the entry of the toxins through the cell membrane.     

Toxin resistance and reduced secretion in a mouse L-cell mutant defective in herpes virus propagation.

The mouse L-cell mutant gro29 was selected originally for its inability to propagate herpes simplex virus; it shows severe defects in virus egress and the transport and processing of viral glycoproteins after infection. In this report, we show that uninfected gro29 cells display pleiotropic changes in protein secretion, oligosaccharide processing, and sensitivity to the toxins ricin and modeccin. Specifically, the rate of secretion of a nonglycosylated protein, human growth hormone, was reduced 70% in gro29 cells compared with the parental L cells. A direct measurement of the transport capacity of Golgi membranes in a cell-free assay suggests that gro29 cells contain less functional Golgi than parental cells. Despite this deficiency, N-linked oligosaccharides were processed efficiently in mutant cells, although there were differences in the structure of the mature forms. Lectin intoxication assays revealed that gro29 cells were cross-resistant to killing by the cytotoxic lectins ricin and modeccin, but not to wheat germ agglutinin, Ricinus communis agglutinin RCA120, or leucoagglutinin. Fluorescence labeling using fluorescein-conjugated lectins showed that uninfected gro29 cells expressed relatively few ricin-binding molecules, suggesting a possible mechanism for toxin resistance. These studies provide evidence that the processes of protein secretion, lectin intoxication, and herpes virus maturation and egress may share a common cellular component.     

HeLa cell mutants resistant to epidermal growth factor ricin A-chain conjugate

Epidermal growth factor (EGF) was linked to the toxic A chain of ricin toxin (RTA) to produce an EGF-receptor-specific cytotoxic agent, EGF-RTA. Three EGF-RTA-resistant mutants of the human HeLa cell line were selected. These mutant cell lines are 10-fold to more than 100-fold more resistant to EGF-RTA when compared to HeLa cells. The EGF-RTA-resistant mutants have at least as many EGF receptors as parent cells; the basis for the EGF-RTA-resistant phenotype must be distal to EGF binding. The EGF-RTA-resistant cells are not cross-ressitant to ricin or to diphtheria toxin; their mutant phenotype appears to be EGF specific. The EGF-RTA-resistant mutants are able to internalize and degrade EGF. However, the mutants have altered EGF receptor down-regulation and phorbol 12-tetradecanoate 13-acetate modulation properties. EGF-RTA/ammonium chloride and EGF-RTA/adenovirus co-treatment data suggest that the mutant defect(s) which confers EGF-RTA resistance is either in the endosome or at a step(s) in the intracellular EGF processing pathway between the endosome and the lysosome.     

Isolation of Chinese hamster ovary ribosomal mutants differentially resistant to ricin, abrin, and modeccin

The molecular action of ricin A chain involves cleavage of the N-glycosidic bond between ribose and the adenine 4324 nucleotides from the 5' end of mammalian 28 S rRNA (Endo, Y., and Tsurugi, K. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 8128-8130). In this paper, four ricin- and abrin-resistant Chinese hamster ovary cell mutants that possess ribosomes resistant to this N-glycosidase action are described. Three of the mutant phenotypes, Lec26, Lec27, and Lec28, were recessive in somatic cell hybrids and define at least two new lectin-resistant complementation groups. The most extensively characterized mutant type, LEC17, was dominant in such hybrids. None of the mutants were cross-resistant to modeccin. Post-mitochondrial supernatants from each of the four mutants were resistant to inhibition of cell-free protein synthesis by ricin, ricin A chain, and abrin. In addition, polysomes isolated from mutant cells were resistant to cleavage of the adenine-ribose N-glycosidic bond by ricin A chain or abrin, as assayed by the release of an approximately 470-nucleotide fragment following aniline treatment of ribosomal RNA extracted from toxin-treated polysomes. The unique lectin-resistance properties of the different mutants suggests that the accessibility of adenine 4324 to each toxin differs. It seems likely that the recessive Chinese hamster ovary ribosomal mutants reflect structural changes in different ribosomal proteins while the dominant phenotype may be due to the modification of protein(s) or rRNA involved in toxin-ribosome interaction. Further analysis of these cell lines should provide new insights into the structure/function relationships of eukaryotic ribosomes.     

Osmotically induced microinjection of ricin bypasses a ricin internalization defect in a Chinese hamster ovary mutant cell line.

By osmotic lysis of pinocytic vesicles we were able to inject ricin or ricin A chain directly into the cytosol of Chinese hamster ovary cells. The lag time of 1 to 2 h before the onset of the inhibition of protein synthesis by ricin in intact cells was reduced to 15 to 30 min by this method. Preincubation of cells with a low concentration of nigericin, which was shown earlier to enhance the cytotoxicity of ricin, had no effect under this condition. Direct transfer of either intact ricin or the ricin A subunit by osmotic lysis of pinocytic vesicles into the cytosol of the ricin-resistant CHO mutant cell line 4-10 rendered the mutant 4-10 cells as sensitive to ricin as the CHO pro wild-type cells. Both the lag time and the rate of inhibition of protein synthesis in the wild-type and mutant cell lines after the introduction of ricin by osmotic lysis of pinocytic vesicles were the same. These results indicate that injection of ricin into the cytosol by osmotic lysis of pinosomes bypasses the internalization defect in the mutant cell line.     

Brefeldin-A enhancement of ricin A-chain immunotoxins and blockade of intact ricin, modeccin, and abrin

After binding, the protein toxins ricin, abrin, and modeccin are endocytosed and processed through the cell's vesicular system in a poorly understood fashion, prior to translocation to the cytosol. The role of the Golgi apparatus in toxin processing was studied using brefeldin-A (BFA), a fungal metabolite which blocks Golgi function. At concentrations that inhibit secretion of interleukin-2 (IL-2), BFA blocks ricin, modeccin, and abrin intoxication of a lymphocyte derived cell line (Jurkat). Paradoxically, BFA enhances the toxicity of two ricin A-chain immunotoxins targeted against distinct cell surface determinants. BFA concentrations which are optimal for immunotoxin enhancement are below those needed to affect ricin intoxication or IL-2 secretion. BFA blockade of ricin does not involve effects on ricin endocytosis, toxin translocation to the cytosol, or the enzymatic activity of toxin A-chain. In contrast, BFA has no effect on immunotoxin processing but does enhance the immunotoxin translocation step. It is concluded that: 1) intact Golgi function is required for holotoxin processing. 2) Intact Golgi function is not required for holotoxin translocation. 3) Golgi function is tightly linked to immunotoxin translocation. 4) BFA has effects on vesicular routing in addition to the block of Golgi function in secretion which has been reported.     

The diphthamide modification on elongation factor-2 renders mammalian cells resistant to ricin

Diphthamide is a post-translational derivative of histidine in protein synthesis elongation factor-2 (eEF-2) that is present in all eukaryotes with no known normal physiological role. Five proteins Dph1–Dph5 are required for the biosynthesis of diphthamide. Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells mutated in the biosynthetic genes lack diphthamide and are resistant to bacterial toxins such as diphtheria toxin. We found that diphthamide-deficient cultured cells were threefold more sensitive than their parental cells towards ricin, a r ibosome- i nactivating p rotein (RIP). RIPs bind to ribosomes at the same site as eEF-2 and cleave the large ribosomal RNA, inhibiting translation and causing cell death. We hypothesized that one role of diphthamide may be to protect ribosomes, and therefore all eukaryotic life forms, from RIPs, which are widely distributed in nature. A protective role of diphthamide against ricin was further demonstrated by complementation where dph mutant CHO cells transfected with the corresponding DPH gene acquired increased resistance to ricin in comparison with the control-transfected cells, and resembled the parental CHO cells in their response to the toxin. These data show that the presence of diphthamide in eEF-2 provides protection against ricin and suggest the hypothesis that diphthamide may have evolved to provide protection against RIPs.     

Preparation and properties of a hybrid toxin of modeccin A-chain and ricin B-chain

Hybrid molecules were prepared from the A- and B-chains of the two toxic lectins ricin and modeccin by dialyzing mixtures of isolated chains to allow a disulfide bridge to be formed between them. Whereas the hybrid consisting of ricin A-chain and modeccin B-chain was non-toxic, the converse hybrid, modeccin A-chain/ricin B-chain, was even more toxic to Vero cells than were the parent toxins, native ricin and modeccin. A number of drugs (NH₄Cl, monensin, trifluoperazine, verapamil, ionophore A23187) which protect cells against modeccin, but not against ricin, protected to some extent against the toxic hybrid, but less so than against native modeccin. The possibility is discussed that the modeccin A-chain of the hybrid may enter the cytosol by two routes, one which is highly efficient and identical to that used by native modeccin and another less efficient one which cannot be used by native modeccin.     

Somatic cell mutants resistant to ricin, diphtheria toxin, and to immunotoxins

The human B-cell line Namalwa expresses the common acute lymphoblastic leukemia antigen (CALLA). Frame-shift mutants in Namalwa cell cultures were generated with ICR-191, and mutants were then selected for resistance to ricin or resistance to a conjugate of ricin with the anti-CALLA antibody J5 in the presence of lactose. Three mutants were found that were resistant to ricin and were in addition shown to be resistant to diphtheria toxin, to a J5-ricin conjugate, and to a conjugate between ricin B-chain and gelonin. The mutants, however, were sensitive to a J5-gelonin conjugate. These mutants expressed high levels of CALLA and/or receptors for ricin, and their cell-free translation systems appeared to be as sensitive to the inhibitory action of ricin A-chain and of gelonin as the translation system of wild-type Namalwa cells. The behavior of these mutants was consistent with the hypothesis that these cells possess an alteration of their surface that impedes the passage of ricin and diphtheria toxin across the plasma membrane. A fourth mutant was found to bind reduced quantities of ricin and was resistant to ricin but was sensitive to J5-ricin. The properties of this cell line provide evidence that the binding of antibody-ricin conjugates to cells via the ricin moiety may be prevented without impeding the cytotoxicity of the conjugates.     

Genetic and biochemical analysis of mutation(s) affecting ricin internalization in Chinese hamster ovary cells

We have previously reported the isolation and characterization of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell mutants defective in the internalization of ricin (Ray, B., and Wu, H.C. (1982) Mol. Cell. Biol. 2, 535-544). These mutants also do not exhibit the enhancement of ricin internalization by nigericin pretreatment at a low concentration, which is observed in the wild-type CHO cells. An analysis of somatic cell hybrids between the mutant and the toxin-sensitive wild-type CHO cell line shows that all of the phenotypes associated with the toxin resistance mutation are dominant in the hybrid cell lines. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of [3H]palmitic acid-labeled cell extracts from the mutant and toxin-resistant hybrid cell lines has revealed an increased incorporation of [3H] palmitic acid into two proteins with apparent molecular weights near 30,000 in the mutant and hybrid cells as compared to that in the wild-type cell line. Our studies indicate that these two fatty acyl proteins might be related to a dominant mutation(s) which results in a decreased uptake of ricin.     

Endosome to Golgi Transport of Ricin Is Independent of Clathrin and of the Rab9- and Rab11-GTPases

The plant toxin ricin is transported to the Golgi and the endoplasmic reticulum before translocation to the cytosol where it inhibits protein synthesis. The toxin can therefore be used to investigate pathways leading to the Golgi apparatus. Except for the Rab9-mediated transport of mannose 6-phosphate receptors from endosomes to the trans-Golgi network (TGN), transport routes between endosomes and the Golgi apparatus are still poorly characterized. To investigate endosome to Golgi transport, we have used here a modified ricin molecule containing a tyrosine sulfation site and quantified incorporation of radioactive sulfate, a TGN modification. A tetracycline-inducible mutant Rab9S21N HeLa cell line was constructed and characterized to study whether Rab9 was involved in transport of ricin to the TGN and, if not, to further investigate the route used by ricin. Induced expression of Rab9S21N inhibited Golgi transport of mannose 6-phosphate receptors but did not affect the sulfation of ricin, suggesting that ricin is transported to the TGN via a Rab9-independent pathway. Moreover, because Rab11 is present in the endosomal recycling compartment and the TGN, studies of transient transfections with mutant Rab11 were performed. The results indicated that routing of ricin from endosomes to the TGN occurs by a Rab11-independent pathway. Finally, because clathrin has been implicated in early endosome to TGN transport, ricin transport was investigated in cells with inducible expression of antisense to clathrin heavy chain. Importantly, endosome to TGN transport (sulfation of endocytosed ricin) was unchanged when clathrin function was abolished. In conclusion, ricin is transported from endosomes to the Golgi apparatus by a Rab9-, Rab11-, and clathrin-independent pathway.